-
Local minima in Newton's aerodynamical problem and inequalities between norms of partial derivatives
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov,
Vladimir Protasov
Abstract:
The problem considered first by I. Newton (1687) consists in finding a surface of the minimal frontal resistance in a parallel flow of non-interacting point particles. The standard formulation assumes that the surface is convex with a given convex base $Ω$ and a bounded altitude. Newton found the solution for surfaces of revolution. Without this assumption the problem is still unsolved, although m…
▽ More
The problem considered first by I. Newton (1687) consists in finding a surface of the minimal frontal resistance in a parallel flow of non-interacting point particles. The standard formulation assumes that the surface is convex with a given convex base $Ω$ and a bounded altitude. Newton found the solution for surfaces of revolution. Without this assumption the problem is still unsolved, although many important results have been obtained in the last decades. We consider the problem to characterize the domains $Ω$ for which the flat surface gives a local minimum. We show that this problem can be reduced to an inequality between $L_2$-norms of partial derivatives for bivariate concave functions on a convex domain that vanish on the boundary. Can the ratio between those norms be arbitrarily large? The answer depends on the geometry of the domain. A complete criterion is derived, which also solves the local minimality problem.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
The problem of optimal camouflaging
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov,
Vera Roshchina
Abstract:
We consider the problem of camouflaging for bodies with specular surface in the framework of geometric optics. The index of visibility introduced in [Plakhov 2017] measures the mean deviation of light rays incident on the body's surface. We study the problem of minimal visibility index for bodies with fixed volume contained in the unit sphere. This problem is reduced to a special vector-valued pro…
▽ More
We consider the problem of camouflaging for bodies with specular surface in the framework of geometric optics. The index of visibility introduced in [Plakhov 2017] measures the mean deviation of light rays incident on the body's surface. We study the problem of minimal visibility index for bodies with fixed volume contained in the unit sphere. This problem is reduced to a special vector-valued problem of optimal mass transfer, which is solved partly analytically and partly numerically. This paper is a continuation of the study started in [Plakhov 2009], [Plakhov 2017], and [Plakhov and Roshchina 2011].
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Rotating rod and ball
Authors:
Sergey Kryzhevich,
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
We consider a mechanical system consisting of an infinite rod (a straight line) and a ball (a massless point) on the plane. The rod rotates uniformly around one of its points. The ball is reflected elastically when colliding with the rod and moves freely between consecutive hits. A sliding motion along the rod is also allowed. We prove the existence and uniqueness of the motion with a given positi…
▽ More
We consider a mechanical system consisting of an infinite rod (a straight line) and a ball (a massless point) on the plane. The rod rotates uniformly around one of its points. The ball is reflected elastically when colliding with the rod and moves freely between consecutive hits. A sliding motion along the rod is also allowed. We prove the existence and uniqueness of the motion with a given position and velocity at a certain time instant. We prove that only 5 kinds of motion are possible: a billiard motion; a sliding motion; a billiard motion followed by sliding; a sliding motion followed by a billiard one; and a constant motion when the ball is at the center of rotation. The asymptotic behaviors of time intervals between consecutive hits and of distances between the points of hits on the rod are determined.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2023; v1 submitted 19 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Local structure of convex surfaces near regular and conical points
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
Consider a point on a convex surface in $\mathbb{R}^d$, $d \ge 2$ and a plane of support $Π$ to the surface at this point. Draw a plane parallel to $Π$ cutting a part of the surface. We study the limiting behavior of this part of surface when the plane approaches the point, being always parallel to $Π$. More precisely, we study the limiting behavior of the normalized surface area measure in…
▽ More
Consider a point on a convex surface in $\mathbb{R}^d$, $d \ge 2$ and a plane of support $Π$ to the surface at this point. Draw a plane parallel to $Π$ cutting a part of the surface. We study the limiting behavior of this part of surface when the plane approaches the point, being always parallel to $Π$. More precisely, we study the limiting behavior of the normalized surface area measure in $S^{d-1}$ induced by this part of surface. In this paper we consider two cases: (a) when the point is regular and (b) when it is singular conical, that is, the tangent cone at the point does not contain straight lines. In the case (a) the limit is the atom located at the outward normal vector to $Π$, and in the case (b) the limit is equal to the measure induced by the part of the tangent cone cut off by a plane.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
On the structure of singular points of a solution to Newton's least resistance problem
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
We consider the following problem stated in 1993 by Buttazzo and Kawohl: minimize the functional $\int\!\!\int_Ω(1 + |\nabla u(x,y)|^2)^{-1} dx\, dy$ in the class of concave functions $u: Ω\to [0,M]$, where $Ω\subset \mathbb{R}^2$ is a convex domain and $M > 0$. It generalizes the classical minimization problem, which was initially stated by I. Newton in 1687 in the more restricted class of radial…
▽ More
We consider the following problem stated in 1993 by Buttazzo and Kawohl: minimize the functional $\int\!\!\int_Ω(1 + |\nabla u(x,y)|^2)^{-1} dx\, dy$ in the class of concave functions $u: Ω\to [0,M]$, where $Ω\subset \mathbb{R}^2$ is a convex domain and $M > 0$. It generalizes the classical minimization problem, which was initially stated by I. Newton in 1687 in the more restricted class of radial functions. The problem is not solved until now; there is even nothing known about the structure of singular points of a solution.
In this paper we, first, solve a family of auxiliary 2D least resistance problems and, second, apply the obtained results to study singular points of a solution to our original problem. More precisely, we derive a necessary condition for a point being a ridge singular point of a solution and prove, in particular, that all ridge singular points with horizontal edge lie on the top level and zero level sets.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Open problems on billiards and geometric optics
Authors:
M. Bialy,
C. Fierobe,
A. Glutsyuk,
M. Levi,
A. Plakhov,
S. Tabachnikov
Abstract:
This is a collection of open problems from workshop "Differential Geometry, Billiards, and Geometric Optics" at CIRM on October 4-8, 2021.
This is a collection of open problems from workshop "Differential Geometry, Billiards, and Geometric Optics" at CIRM on October 4-8, 2021.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2021; v1 submitted 20 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
A solution to Newton's least resistance problem is uniquely defined by its singular set
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
Let $u$ minimize the functional $F(u) = \int_Ωf(\nabla u(x))\, dx$ in the class of convex functions $u : Ω\to {\mathbb R}$ satisfying $0 \le u \le M$, where $Ω\subset {\mathbb R}^2$ is a compact convex domain with nonempty interior and $M > 0$, and $f : {\mathbb R}^2 \to {\mathbb R}$ is a $C^2$ function, with $\{ ξ: \, \text{the smallest eigenvalue of} \, f"(ξ) \, \text{is zero} \}$ being a closed…
▽ More
Let $u$ minimize the functional $F(u) = \int_Ωf(\nabla u(x))\, dx$ in the class of convex functions $u : Ω\to {\mathbb R}$ satisfying $0 \le u \le M$, where $Ω\subset {\mathbb R}^2$ is a compact convex domain with nonempty interior and $M > 0$, and $f : {\mathbb R}^2 \to {\mathbb R}$ is a $C^2$ function, with $\{ ξ: \, \text{the smallest eigenvalue of} \, f"(ξ) \, \text{is zero} \}$ being a closed nowhere dense set in ${\mathbb R}^2$. Let epi$(u)$ denote the epigraph of $u$. Then any extremal point $(x, u(x))$ of epi$(u)$ is contained in the closure of the set of singular points of epi$(u)$. As a consequence, an optimal function $u$ is uniquely defined by the set of singular points of epi$(u)$. This result is applicable to the classical Newton's problem, where $F(u) = \int_Ω(1 + |\nabla u(x)|^2)^{-1}\, dx$.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2022; v1 submitted 29 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Method of nose stretching in Newton's problem of minimal resistance
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
We consider the problem $\inf\big\{ \int\!\!\int_Ω(1 + |\nabla u(x,y)|^2)^{-1} dx dy : \text{ the function } u : Ω\to \mathbb{R} \text{ is concave and } 0 \le u(x,y) \le M \text{ for all } (x,y) \in Ω=\{ (x,y): x^2 + y^2 \le 1 \} \, \big\}$ (Newton's problem) and its generalizations. In the paper \cite{BrFK} it is proved that if a solution $u$ is $C^2$ in an open set $\mathcal{U} \subset Ω$ then…
▽ More
We consider the problem $\inf\big\{ \int\!\!\int_Ω(1 + |\nabla u(x,y)|^2)^{-1} dx dy : \text{ the function } u : Ω\to \mathbb{R} \text{ is concave and } 0 \le u(x,y) \le M \text{ for all } (x,y) \in Ω=\{ (x,y): x^2 + y^2 \le 1 \} \, \big\}$ (Newton's problem) and its generalizations. In the paper \cite{BrFK} it is proved that if a solution $u$ is $C^2$ in an open set $\mathcal{U} \subset Ω$ then $\det D^2u = 0$ in $\mathcal{U}$. It follows that graph$(u)\rfloor_\mathcal{U}$ does not contain extreme points of the subgraph of $u$.
In this paper we prove a somewhat stronger result. Namely, there exists a solution $u$ possessing the following property. If $u$ is $C^1$ in an open set $\mathcal{U} \subset Ω$ then graph$(u\rfloor_\mathcal{U})$ does not contain extreme points of the convex body $C_u = \{ (x,y,z) :\, (x,y) \in Ω,\ 0 \le z \le u(x,y) \}$. As a consequence, we have $C_u = \text{\rm Conv} (\overline{\text{\rm Sing$C_u$}})$, where Sing$C_u$ denotes the set of singular points of $\partial C_u$. We prove a similar result for a generalized Newton's problem.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2020; v1 submitted 14 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
A note on Newton's problem of minimal resistance for convex bodies
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
We consider the following problem: minimize the functional $\int_Ωf(\nabla u(x))\, dx$ in the class of concave functions $u: Ω\to [0,M]$, where $Ω\subset \mathbb{R}^2$ is a convex body and $M > 0$. If $f(x) = 1/(1 + |x|^2)$ and $Ω$ is a circle, the problem is called Newton's problem of least resistance. It is known that the problem admits at least one solution. We prove that if all points of…
▽ More
We consider the following problem: minimize the functional $\int_Ωf(\nabla u(x))\, dx$ in the class of concave functions $u: Ω\to [0,M]$, where $Ω\subset \mathbb{R}^2$ is a convex body and $M > 0$. If $f(x) = 1/(1 + |x|^2)$ and $Ω$ is a circle, the problem is called Newton's problem of least resistance. It is known that the problem admits at least one solution. We prove that if all points of $\partialΩ$ are regular and ${|x|f(x)}/(|y|f(y)) \to +\infty$ as $|x|/|y| \to 0$ then a solution $u$ to the problem satisfies $u\rfloor_{\partialΩ} = 0$. This result proves the conjecture stated in 1993 for Newton's problem.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2019; v1 submitted 2 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Behavior of convex surfaces near ridge points
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
The aim of this paper is twofold. First, we cut off a part of a convex surface by a plane near a ridge point and characterize the limiting behavior of the surface measure in $S^2$ induced by this part of surface when the plane approaches the point. Second, this characterization is applied to Newton's least resistance problem for convex bodies: minimize the functional…
▽ More
The aim of this paper is twofold. First, we cut off a part of a convex surface by a plane near a ridge point and characterize the limiting behavior of the surface measure in $S^2$ induced by this part of surface when the plane approaches the point. Second, this characterization is applied to Newton's least resistance problem for convex bodies: minimize the functional $\int\int_Ω(1 + |\nabla u(x,y)|^2)^{-1} dx dy$ in the class of convex functions $u: Ω\to [0,M]$, where $Ω\subset R^2$ is a convex body and $M > 0$. It has been known that if $u_*$ solves the problem then $|\nabla u_*(x,y)| \ge 1$ at all regular points $(x,y)$ such that $u_*(x,y) > 0$. We prove that if the lower level set $L_0 = \{ (x,y): u_*(x,y) = 0 \}$ has nonempty interior, then for almost all points of its boundary $(\bar x, \bar y) \in \partial L_0$ one has $\lim_{\stackrel{(x,y)\to(\bar x,\bar y)}{u_*(x,y)>0}}|\nabla u_*(x,y)| = 1$.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2019; v1 submitted 5 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Local properties of the surface measure of convex bodies
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
It is well known that any measure in S^2 satisfying certain simple conditions is the surface measure of a bounded convex body in R^3. It is also known that a local perturbation of the surface measure may lead to a nonlocal perturbation of the corresponding convex body. We prove that, under mild conditions on a convex body, there are families of perturbations of its surface measure forming line seg…
▽ More
It is well known that any measure in S^2 satisfying certain simple conditions is the surface measure of a bounded convex body in R^3. It is also known that a local perturbation of the surface measure may lead to a nonlocal perturbation of the corresponding convex body. We prove that, under mild conditions on a convex body, there are families of perturbations of its surface measure forming line segments, with the original measure at the midpoint, leading to local perturbations of the body. Moreover, there is, in a sense, a huge amount of such families. We apply this result to Newton's problem of minimal resistance for convex bodies.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2018; v1 submitted 28 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Optimal Impulse Control of Dynamical Systems
Authors:
Alexey Piunovskiy,
Alexander Plakhov,
Delfim F. M. Torres,
Yi Zhang
Abstract:
Using the tools of the Markov Decision Processes, we justify the dynamic programming approach to the optimal impulse control of deterministic dynamical systems. We prove the equivalence of the integral and differential forms of the optimality equation. The theory is illustrated by an example from mathematical epidemiology. The developed methods can be also useful for the study of piecewise determi…
▽ More
Using the tools of the Markov Decision Processes, we justify the dynamic programming approach to the optimal impulse control of deterministic dynamical systems. We prove the equivalence of the integral and differential forms of the optimality equation. The theory is illustrated by an example from mathematical epidemiology. The developed methods can be also useful for the study of piecewise deterministic Markov processes.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Recent Photometric Monitoring of KIC 8462852, the Detection of a Potential Repeat of the Kepler Day 1540 Dip and a Plausible Model
Authors:
R. Bourne,
B. L. Gary,
A. Plakhov
Abstract:
This paper presents V- and g'-band observations of the F2V star KIC 8462852, which exhibited enigmatic fade patterns in Kepler mission data. We introduce a transit simulation model for interpretation of these fades, and use it to interpret an August 2017 dip as a repeat of the Kepler day 1540 dip (D1540). We suggest the August 2017 and D1540 dips may be caused by a brown dwarf and an associated ri…
▽ More
This paper presents V- and g'-band observations of the F2V star KIC 8462852, which exhibited enigmatic fade patterns in Kepler mission data. We introduce a transit simulation model for interpretation of these fades, and use it to interpret an August 2017 dip as a repeat of the Kepler day 1540 dip (D1540). We suggest the August 2017 and D1540 dips may be caused by a brown dwarf and an associated ring system in a 1601-day elliptical orbit. Transiting icy moons of the proposed brown dwarf, sublimating near periapsis like comets, could provide an explanation for the significant dips observed by Kepler, as well as the recent May to October 2017 dips and the long term variation in flux detected by Simon et al. (2017). Whereas the presence of such a ring structure is attractive for its ability to explain short term fade events, we do not address how such a ring system can be created and maintained. If our speculation is correct, a brightening of about 1-2 percent should occur during October to November 2017. In addition, this scenario predicts that a set of dimming events, similar to those in 2013 (Kepler) and in 2017 (reported here), can be expected to repeat during October 2021 to January 2022 and a repeat of D1540 should occur on 27 December 2021.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2018; v1 submitted 28 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
The problem of camouflaging via mirror reflections
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
This work is related to billiards and their applications in geometric optics. It is known that perfectly invisible bodies with mirror surface do not exist. It is natural to search for bodies that are, in a sense, close to invisible. We introduce a {\it visibility index} of a body measuring the mean angle of deviation of incident light rays, and derive a lower estimate to this index. This estimate…
▽ More
This work is related to billiards and their applications in geometric optics. It is known that perfectly invisible bodies with mirror surface do not exist. It is natural to search for bodies that are, in a sense, close to invisible. We introduce a {\it visibility index} of a body measuring the mean angle of deviation of incident light rays, and derive a lower estimate to this index. This estimate is a function of the body's volume and of the minimal radius of a ball containing the body. This result is far from being final and opens a possibility for further research.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Billiard transformations of parallel flows: a periscope theorem
Authors:
A. Plakhov,
S. Tabachnikov,
D. Treschev
Abstract:
We consider the following problem: given two parallel and identically oriented bundles of light rays in n-dimensional Euclidean space and given a diffeomorphism between the rays of the former bundle and the rays of the latter one, is it possible to realize this diffeomorphism by means of several mirror reflections? We prove that a 2-mirror realization is possible if and only if the diffeomorphism…
▽ More
We consider the following problem: given two parallel and identically oriented bundles of light rays in n-dimensional Euclidean space and given a diffeomorphism between the rays of the former bundle and the rays of the latter one, is it possible to realize this diffeomorphism by means of several mirror reflections? We prove that a 2-mirror realization is possible if and only if the diffeomorphism is the gradient of a function. We further prove that any orientation reversing diffeomorphism of domains in the plane is locally the composition of two gradient diffeomorphisms, and therefore can be realized by 4 mirror reflections of light rays in 3-space, while an orientation preserving diffeomorphism can be realized by 6 reflections. In general, we prove that an (orientation reversing or preserving) diffeomorphism of wave fronts of two normal families of light rays in 3-space can be realized by 6 or 7 reflections.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Plane sets invisible in finitely many directions
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
We consider the problem of mirror invisibility for plane sets. Given a circle and a finite number of unit vectors (defining the directions of invisibility) such that the angles between them are commensurable with $π$, for any $\varepsilon > 0$ there exists a set invisible in the chosen directions that contains the circle and is contained in its $\varepsilon$-neighborhood. This set is the disjoint…
▽ More
We consider the problem of mirror invisibility for plane sets. Given a circle and a finite number of unit vectors (defining the directions of invisibility) such that the angles between them are commensurable with $π$, for any $\varepsilon > 0$ there exists a set invisible in the chosen directions that contains the circle and is contained in its $\varepsilon$-neighborhood. This set is the disjoint union of infinitely many domains with piecewise smooth boundary.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Minimal resistance of curves under the single impact assumption
Authors:
Arseniy Akopyan,
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
We consider the hollow on the half-plane $\{(x,y) : y \le 0\} \subset \mathbb{R}^2$ defined by a function $u : (-1, 1) \to \mathbb{R}$, $u(x) < 0$ and a vertical flow of point particles incident on the hollow. It is assumed that $u$ satisfies the so-called single impact condition (SIC): each incident particle is elastically reflected by graph$(u)$ and goes away without hitting the graph of $u$ any…
▽ More
We consider the hollow on the half-plane $\{(x,y) : y \le 0\} \subset \mathbb{R}^2$ defined by a function $u : (-1, 1) \to \mathbb{R}$, $u(x) < 0$ and a vertical flow of point particles incident on the hollow. It is assumed that $u$ satisfies the so-called single impact condition (SIC): each incident particle is elastically reflected by graph$(u)$ and goes away without hitting the graph of $u$ anymore. We solve the problem: find the function $u$ minimizing the force of resistance created by the flow. We show that the graph of the minimizer is formed by two arcs of parabolas symmetric to each other with respect to the $y$-axis. Assuming that the resistance of $u \equiv 0$ equals 1, we show that the minimal resistance equals $π/2 - 2\arctan(1/2) \approx 0.6435$. This result completes the previously obtained result stating in particular that the minimal resistance of a hollow in higher dimensions equals 0.5.
We additionally consider a similar problem of minimal resistance, where the hollow in the half-space $\{(x_1,\ldots,x_d, y) : y \le 0 \} \subset \mathbb{R}^{d+1}$ is defined by a radial function $U$ satisfying SIC, $U(x) = u(|x|)$, with $x = (x_1,\ldots,x_d), u(ξ) < 0$ for $0 \le ξ< 1$ and $u(ξ) = 0$ for $ξ\ge 1$, and the flow is parallel to the $y$-axis. The minimal resistance is greater than $0.5$ (and coincides with $0.6435$ when $d = 1$) and converges to $0.5$ as $d \to \infty$.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Newton's problem of minimal resistance under the single-impact assumption
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
A parallel flow of non-interacting point particles is incident on a body at rest. When hitting the body's surface, the particles are reflected elastically. Assume that each particle hits the body at most once (SIC condition); then the force of resistance of the body along the flow direction can be written down in a simple analytical form.
The problem of minimal resistance within this model was f…
▽ More
A parallel flow of non-interacting point particles is incident on a body at rest. When hitting the body's surface, the particles are reflected elastically. Assume that each particle hits the body at most once (SIC condition); then the force of resistance of the body along the flow direction can be written down in a simple analytical form.
The problem of minimal resistance within this model was first considered by Newton (1687) in the class of bodies with a fixed length M along the flow direction and with a fixed maximum orthogonal cross section, under the additional conditions that the body is convex and rotationally symmetric. Here we solve the problem (first stated by Ferone, Buttazzo, and Kawohl in 1995) for the wider class of bodies satisfying SIC and with the additional conditions removed. The scheme of solution is inspired by Besicovitch's method of solving the Kakeya problem. If the maximum cross section is a disc, the decrease of resistance as compared with the original Newton problem is more than twofold; the ratio tends to 2 as M goes to 0 and to 81/4 as M goes to infinity. We also prove that the infimum of resistance is 0 for a wider class of bodies with both single and double impacts allowed.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
The problem of minimal resistance for functions and domains
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
Here we solve the problem posed by Comte and Lachand-Robert in (2001). Take a bounded domain Ωin R^2 and a piecewise smooth non-positive function u : \barΩ \to R vanishing on the boundary of Ω. Consider a flow of point particles falling vertically down and reflected elastically from the graph of u. It is assumed that each particle is reflected no more than once (no multiple reflections are allowed…
▽ More
Here we solve the problem posed by Comte and Lachand-Robert in (2001). Take a bounded domain Ωin R^2 and a piecewise smooth non-positive function u : \barΩ \to R vanishing on the boundary of Ω. Consider a flow of point particles falling vertically down and reflected elastically from the graph of u. It is assumed that each particle is reflected no more than once (no multiple reflections are allowed); then the resistance of the graph to the flow is expressed as F(u;Ω) = \frac{1}{|Ω|} \int_Ω(1 + |\nabla u(x)|^2)^{-1} dx. It is required to find \inf_{Ω,u} F(u;Ω). One can easily see that |\nabla u(x)| < 1 for all regular x \in Ω, and therefore one always has F(u;Ω) > 1/2.
We prove that the infimum of F is exactly 1/2. This result is somewhat paradoxical, and the proof is inspired by, and is partly similar to, the paradoxical solution given by Besicovitch to the Kakeya problem.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Bodies with mirror surface invisible from two points
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov,
Vera Roshchina
Abstract:
Here we are concerned with a special issue of billiard invisibility, where a bounded set with a piecewise smooth boundary in Euclidean space is identified with a body with mirror surface, and the billiard in the complement of the set is identified with the dynamics of light rays outside the body in the framework of geometric optics. We show that in this setting it is possible to construct a body i…
▽ More
Here we are concerned with a special issue of billiard invisibility, where a bounded set with a piecewise smooth boundary in Euclidean space is identified with a body with mirror surface, and the billiard in the complement of the set is identified with the dynamics of light rays outside the body in the framework of geometric optics. We show that in this setting it is possible to construct a body invisible from two points.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Invisibility in billiards is impossible in an infinite number of directions
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov,
Vera Roshchina
Abstract:
We consider the billiard in the exterior of a piecewise smooth body in two-dimensional Euclidean space and show that the maximum number of directions of invisibility in such billiard is at most finite.
We consider the billiard in the exterior of a piecewise smooth body in two-dimensional Euclidean space and show that the maximum number of directions of invisibility in such billiard is at most finite.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2012; v1 submitted 29 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
Bodies invisible from one point
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov,
Vera Roshchina
Abstract:
We show that there exist bodies with mirror surface invisible from a point in the framework of geometrical optics. In particular, we provide an example of a connected three-dimensional body invisible from one point.
We show that there exist bodies with mirror surface invisible from a point in the framework of geometrical optics. In particular, we provide an example of a connected three-dimensional body invisible from one point.
△ Less
Submitted 28 December, 2011;
originally announced December 2011.
-
Fractal bodies invisible in 2 and 3 directions
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov,
Vera Roshchina
Abstract:
We study the problem of invisibility for bodies with a mirror surface in the framework of geometrical optics. We show that for any two given directions it is possible to construct a two-dimensional fractal body invisible in these directions. Moreover, there exists a three-dimensional fractal body invisible in three orthogonal directions. The work continues the previous study in [A. Aleksenko and A…
▽ More
We study the problem of invisibility for bodies with a mirror surface in the framework of geometrical optics. We show that for any two given directions it is possible to construct a two-dimensional fractal body invisible in these directions. Moreover, there exists a three-dimensional fractal body invisible in three orthogonal directions. The work continues the previous study in [A. Aleksenko and A. Plakhov. Bodies of zero resistance and bodies invisible in one direction. Nonlinearity 22, 1247-1258 (2009)], [A Plakhov and V Roshchina. Invisibility in billiards. Nonlinearity 24, 847-854 (2011)], where two-dimensional bodies invisible in one direction and three-dimensional bodies invisible in one and two orthogonal directions were constructed.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2011;
originally announced July 2011.
-
Invisibility in billiards
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov,
Vera Roshchina
Abstract:
The question of invisibility for bodies with mirror surface is studied in the framework of geometrical optics. We construct bodies that are invisible/have zero resistance in two mutually orthogonal directions, and prove that there do not exist bodies which are invisible/have zero resistance in all possible directions of incidence.
The question of invisibility for bodies with mirror surface is studied in the framework of geometrical optics. We construct bodies that are invisible/have zero resistance in two mutually orthogonal directions, and prove that there do not exist bodies which are invisible/have zero resistance in all possible directions of incidence.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
-
Mathematical retroreflectors
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
Retroreflectors are optical devices that reverse the direction of incident beams of light. Here we present a collection of billiard type retroreflectors consisting of four objects; three of them are asymptotically perfect retroreflectors, and the fourth one is a retroreflector which is very close to perfect. Three objects of the collection have recently been discovered and published or submitted f…
▽ More
Retroreflectors are optical devices that reverse the direction of incident beams of light. Here we present a collection of billiard type retroreflectors consisting of four objects; three of them are asymptotically perfect retroreflectors, and the fourth one is a retroreflector which is very close to perfect. Three objects of the collection have recently been discovered and published or submitted for publication. The fourth object - notched angle - is a new one; a proof of its retroreflectivity is given.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2010;
originally announced May 2010.
-
Perfect Retroreflectors and Billiard Dynamics
Authors:
Pavel Bachurin,
Konstantin Khanin,
Jens Marklof,
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
We construct semi-infinite billiard domains which reverse the direction of most incoming particles. We prove that almost all particles will leave the open billiard domain after a finite number of reflections. Moreover, with high probability the exit velocity is exactly opposite to the entrance velocity, and the particle's exit point is arbitrarily close to its initial position. The method is bas…
▽ More
We construct semi-infinite billiard domains which reverse the direction of most incoming particles. We prove that almost all particles will leave the open billiard domain after a finite number of reflections. Moreover, with high probability the exit velocity is exactly opposite to the entrance velocity, and the particle's exit point is arbitrarily close to its initial position. The method is based on asymptotic analysis of statistics of entrance times to a small interval for irrational circle rotations. The rescaled entrance times have a limiting distribution in a limit when the number of iterates tends to infinity and the length of the interval vanishes. The proof of the main results follows from the study of related limiting distributions and their regularity properties.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2009;
originally announced November 2009.
-
On the two-dimensional rotational body of maximal Newtonian resistance
Authors:
Paulo D. F. Gouveia,
Alexander Plakhov,
Delfim F. M. Torres
Abstract:
We investigate, by means of computer simulations, shapes of nonconvex bodies that maximize resistance to their motion through a rarefied medium, considering that bodies are moving forward and at the same time slowly rotating. A two-dimensional geometric shape that confers to the body a resistance very close to the theoretical supremum value is obtained, improving previous results.
We investigate, by means of computer simulations, shapes of nonconvex bodies that maximize resistance to their motion through a rarefied medium, considering that bodies are moving forward and at the same time slowly rotating. A two-dimensional geometric shape that confers to the body a resistance very close to the theoretical supremum value is obtained, improving previous results.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
Two-dimensional body of maximum mean resistance
Authors:
Paulo D. F. Gouveia,
Alexander Plakhov,
Delfim F. M. Torres
Abstract:
A two-dimensional body, exhibiting a slight rotational movement, moves in a rarefied medium of particles which collide with it in a perfectly elastic way. In previously realized investigations by the first two authors, Plakhov & Gouveia (2007, Nonlinearity, 20), shapes of nonconvex bodies were sought which would maximize the braking force of the medium on their movement. Giving continuity to thi…
▽ More
A two-dimensional body, exhibiting a slight rotational movement, moves in a rarefied medium of particles which collide with it in a perfectly elastic way. In previously realized investigations by the first two authors, Plakhov & Gouveia (2007, Nonlinearity, 20), shapes of nonconvex bodies were sought which would maximize the braking force of the medium on their movement. Giving continuity to this study, new investigations have been undertaken which culminate in an outcome which represents a large qualitative advance relative to that which was achieved earlier. This result, now presented, consists of a two-dimensional shape which confers on the body a resistance which is very close to its theoretical supremum value. But its interest does not lie solely in the maximization of Newtonian resistance; on regarding its characteristics, other areas of application are seen to begin to appear which are thought to be capable of having great utility. The optimal shape which has been encountered resulted from numerical studies, thus it is the object of additional study of an analytical nature, where it proves some important properties which explain in great part its effectiveness.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2009;
originally announced April 2009.
-
Bodies invisible in one direction and bodies of zero total cross section
Authors:
Alena Aleksenko,
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
We consider a body in a parallel flow of non-interacting particles. One can imagine that the flow is highly rarefied or consists of light rays. The interaction of particles with the body is perfectly elastic. We introduce the notions of a body of zero resistance and an invisible body and prove that all such bodies do exist.
We consider a body in a parallel flow of non-interacting particles. One can imagine that the flow is highly rarefied or consists of light rays. The interaction of particles with the body is perfectly elastic. We introduce the notions of a body of zero resistance and an invisible body and prove that all such bodies do exist.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2009;
originally announced January 2009.
-
Bodies of zero resistance and bodies invisible in one direction
Authors:
Alena Aleksenko,
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
We consider a body in a parallel flow of non-interacting particles. The interaction of particles with the body is perfectly elastic. We introduce the notions of a body of zero resistance, a body that leaves no trace, and an invisible body, and prove that all such bodies do exist.
We consider a body in a parallel flow of non-interacting particles. The interaction of particles with the body is perfectly elastic. We introduce the notions of a body of zero resistance, a body that leaves no trace, and an invisible body, and prove that all such bodies do exist.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2008; v1 submitted 31 August, 2008;
originally announced September 2008.
-
The problem of the body of revolution of minimal resistance
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov,
Alena Aleksenko
Abstract:
Newton's problem of the body of minimal aerodynamic resistance is traditionally stated in the class of {\it convex} axially symmetric bodies with fixed length and width. We state and solve the minimal resistance problem in the wider class of axially symmetric but {\it generally nonconvex} bodies. The infimum in this problem is not attained. We construct a sequence of bodies minimizing the resist…
▽ More
Newton's problem of the body of minimal aerodynamic resistance is traditionally stated in the class of {\it convex} axially symmetric bodies with fixed length and width. We state and solve the minimal resistance problem in the wider class of axially symmetric but {\it generally nonconvex} bodies. The infimum in this problem is not attained. We construct a sequence of bodies minimizing the resistance. This sequence approximates a convex body with smooth front surface, while the surface of approximating bodies becomes more and more complicated. The shape of the resulting convex body and the value of minimal resistance are compared with the corresponding results for Newton's problem and for the problem in the intermediate class of axisymmetric bodies satisfying the {\it single impact} assumption \cite{CL1}. In particular, the minimal resistance in our class is smaller than in Newton's problem; the ratio goes to 1/2 as (length)/(width of the body) $\to 0$, and to 1/4 as (length)/(width) $\to +\infty$.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2008;
originally announced April 2008.
-
Spinning rough disk moving in a rarefied medium
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov,
Tatiana Tchemisova
Abstract:
A spinning rough disk moves through a rarefied medium on the plane. The roughness is formed by small cavities on the disk boundary. The medium is so rare that mutual interaction of particles can be neglected. All collisions of particles with the disk are perfectly elastic; there may happen multiple collisions in the cavities. We calculate the force of resistance acting on the body and examine ho…
▽ More
A spinning rough disk moves through a rarefied medium on the plane. The roughness is formed by small cavities on the disk boundary. The medium is so rare that mutual interaction of particles can be neglected. All collisions of particles with the disk are perfectly elastic; there may happen multiple collisions in the cavities. We calculate the force of resistance acting on the body and examine how it depends on the kind of roughness (shape of the cavities). We show that the nonzero transversal component of the force generally appears, resulting in deflection of the disk trajectory. In several simple cases the trajectory is determined. We compare our results with the ones known in the literature. It is known that there is a transversal force acting on a spinning body (most often a sphere or a cylinder) moving in a rarefied gas, due to nonelastic interaction of gas particles with the body. We propose another mechanism of creating the transversal force, resulting from multiple reflections of particles from the body.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2009; v1 submitted 17 April, 2008;
originally announced April 2008.
-
Billiard scattering on rough sets: two-dimensional case
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
The notion of a rough two-dimensional (convex) body is introduced, and to each rough body there is assigned a measure on $\TTT^3$ describing billiard scattering on the body. The main result is characterization of the set of measures generated by rough bodies. This result can be used to solve various problems of least aerodynamical resistance.
The notion of a rough two-dimensional (convex) body is introduced, and to each rough body there is assigned a measure on $\TTT^3$ describing billiard scattering on the body. The main result is characterization of the set of measures generated by rough bodies. This result can be used to solve various problems of least aerodynamical resistance.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2007;
originally announced November 2007.
-
Uma forma bidimensional que maximiza a resistência aerodinâmica newtoniana
Authors:
Paulo D. F. Gouveia,
Alexander Plakhov,
Delfim F. M. Torres
Abstract:
(English)
In a previous work [Nonlinearity, 20:2271-2287, 2007; arXiv:math/0703895] it is investigated, by means of computational simulations, shapes of nonconvex bodies that maximize resistance to its motion on a rarefied medium, considering that bodies are moving forward and at the same time slowly rotating. Here the previous results are improved: we obtain a two-dimensional geometric shape…
▽ More
(English)
In a previous work [Nonlinearity, 20:2271-2287, 2007; arXiv:math/0703895] it is investigated, by means of computational simulations, shapes of nonconvex bodies that maximize resistance to its motion on a rarefied medium, considering that bodies are moving forward and at the same time slowly rotating. Here the previous results are improved: we obtain a two-dimensional geometric shape that confers to the body a resistance very close to the supremum value (R=1.4965<1.5).
-----
Resumo (Portuguese)
Um corpo bidimensional, apresentando um ligeiro movimento rotacional, desloca-se num meio rarefeito de partículas que colidem com ele de uma forma perfeitamente elástica. Em investigações que os dois primeiros autores realizaram anteriormente [Nonlinearity, 20:2271-2287, 2007; arXiv:math/0703895], procuraram-se formas de corpos que maximizassem a força de travagem do meio ao seu movimento. Dando continuidade a esse estudo, encetam-se agora novas investigações que culminam num resultado que representa um grande avanço qualitativo relativamente aos previamente alcançados. Esse resultado, que agora se apresenta, consiste numa forma bidimensional que confere ao corpo uma resistência muito próxima do seu limite teórico.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2007;
originally announced September 2007.
-
Problems of maximal mean resistance on the plane
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov,
Paulo D. F. Gouveia
Abstract:
A two-dimensional body moves through a rarefied medium; the collisions of the medium particles with the body are absolutely elastic. The body performs both translational and slow rotational motion. It is required to select the body, from a given class of bodies, such that the average force of resistance of the medium to its motion is maximal.
There are presented numerical and analytical result…
▽ More
A two-dimensional body moves through a rarefied medium; the collisions of the medium particles with the body are absolutely elastic. The body performs both translational and slow rotational motion. It is required to select the body, from a given class of bodies, such that the average force of resistance of the medium to its motion is maximal.
There are presented numerical and analytical results concerning this problem. In particular, the maximum resistance in the class of bodies contained in a convex body K is proved to be 1.5 times resistance of K. The maximum is attained on a sequence of bodies with very complicated boundary. The numerical study was made for somewhat more restricted classes of bodies. The obtained values of resistance are slightly lower, but the boundary of obtained bodies is much simpler, as compared to the analytical solutions.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2007; v1 submitted 29 March, 2007;
originally announced March 2007.
-
Billiards and two-dimensional problems of optimal resistance
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov
Abstract:
A body moves in a medium composed of noninteracting point particles; interaction of particles with the body is absolutely elastic. It is required to find the body's shape minimizing or maximizing resistance of the medium to its motion. This is the general setting of optimal resistance problem going back to Newton.
Here, we restrict ourselves to the two-dimensional problems for rotating (genera…
▽ More
A body moves in a medium composed of noninteracting point particles; interaction of particles with the body is absolutely elastic. It is required to find the body's shape minimizing or maximizing resistance of the medium to its motion. This is the general setting of optimal resistance problem going back to Newton.
Here, we restrict ourselves to the two-dimensional problems for rotating (generally non-convex) bodies. The main results of the paper are the following. First, to any compact connected set with piecewise smooth boundary $B \subset \mathbb{R}^2$ we assign a measure $ν_B$ on $\partial(\text{conv}B) \times [-π/2, π/2]$ generated by the billiard in $\mathbb{R}^2 \setminus B$ and characterize the set of measures $\{ν_B \}$. Second, using this characterization, we solve various problems of minimal and maximal resistance of rotating bodies by reducing them to special Monge-Kantorovich problems.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2006;
originally announced July 2006.
-
A stochastic approximation algorithm with multiplicative step size adaptation
Authors:
Alexander Plakhov,
Pedro Cruz
Abstract:
An algorithm of searching a zero of an unknown undimensional function is considered, measured at a point x with some error. The step sizes are random positive values and are calculated according to the rule: if two consecutive iterations are in same direction step is multiplied by u>1, otherwise, it is multiplied by 0<d<1. The function may have one or more zeros; the random values are independen…
▽ More
An algorithm of searching a zero of an unknown undimensional function is considered, measured at a point x with some error. The step sizes are random positive values and are calculated according to the rule: if two consecutive iterations are in same direction step is multiplied by u>1, otherwise, it is multiplied by 0<d<1. The function may have one or more zeros; the random values are independent and identically distributed, with zero mean and finite variance. Under some additional assumptions on the conditions on the two parameters u and d almost sure convergence of the sequence as well as under some conditions is guaranteed almost sure divergence. In particular, if the error distribuition as median 0 and zero probability for particular poinst then it is established that for ud<1, convergence takes place, and for ud>1, divergence. Due to the multiplicative rule of updating of the step, it is natural to expect that the sequence converges rapidly: like a geometric progression (if convergence takes place), but the limit value may not coincide with, but instead, approximates one of zeros of the function. By adjusting the parameters u and d, one can reach necessary precision of approximation; higher precision is obtained at the expense of lower convergence rate.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2005;
originally announced March 2005.
-
Newton's aerodynamic problem in media of chaotically moving particles
Authors:
Alexander Yu. Plakhov,
Delfim F. M. Torres
Abstract:
We study the problem of minimal resistance for a body moving with constant velocity in a rarefied medium of chaotically moving point particles, in Euclidean space R^d. The particles distribution over velocities is radially symmetric. Under some additional assumptions on the distribution function, the complete classification of bodies of least resistance is made. In the case of three and more dim…
▽ More
We study the problem of minimal resistance for a body moving with constant velocity in a rarefied medium of chaotically moving point particles, in Euclidean space R^d. The particles distribution over velocities is radially symmetric. Under some additional assumptions on the distribution function, the complete classification of bodies of least resistance is made. In the case of three and more dimensions there are two kinds of solutions: a body similar to the solution of classical Newton's problem and a union of two such bodies ``glued together'' by rear parts of their surfaces. In the two-dimensional case there are solutions of five different types: (a) a trapezium; (b) an isosceles triangle; (c) the union of a triangle and a trapezium with common base; (d) the union of two isosceles triangles with common base; (e) the union of two triangles and a trapezium. The cases (a)--(d) are realized for any distribution of particles over velocities, and the case (e) is only realized for some distributions. Two limit cases are considered, where the average velocity of particles is big and where it is small as compared to the body's velocity. Finally, using the obtained analytical results, we study numerically a particular case: the problem of body's motion in a rarefied homogeneous monatomic ideal gas of positive temperature in R^2 and in R^3.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2005; v1 submitted 23 July, 2004;
originally announced July 2004.
-
Optimal Control of Newton-Type Problems of Minimal Resistance
Authors:
Delfim F. M. Torres,
Alexander Yu. Plakhov
Abstract:
We address Newton-type problems of minimal resistance from an optimal control perspective. It is proven that for Newton-type problems the Pontryagin maximum principle is a necessary and sufficient condition. Solutions are then computed for concrete situations, including the new case when the flux of particles is non-parallel.
We address Newton-type problems of minimal resistance from an optimal control perspective. It is proven that for Newton-type problems the Pontryagin maximum principle is a necessary and sufficient condition. Solutions are then computed for concrete situations, including the new case when the flux of particles is non-parallel.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2004;
originally announced April 2004.
-
Two-Dimensional Problems of Minimal Resistance in a Medium of Positive Temperature
Authors:
Alexander Yu. Plakhov,
Delfim F. M. Torres
Abstract:
We study the Newton-like problem of minimal resistance for a two-dimensional body moving with constant velocity in a homogeneous rarefied medium of moving particles. The distribution of the particles over velocities is centrally symmetric. The problem is solved analytically; the minimizers are shown to be of four different types. Numerical results are obtained for the physically significant case…
▽ More
We study the Newton-like problem of minimal resistance for a two-dimensional body moving with constant velocity in a homogeneous rarefied medium of moving particles. The distribution of the particles over velocities is centrally symmetric. The problem is solved analytically; the minimizers are shown to be of four different types. Numerical results are obtained for the physically significant case of gaussian circular distribution of velocities, which corresponds to a homogeneous ideal gas of positive temperature.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2004;
originally announced April 2004.
