Showing 1–17 of 17 results for author: Pestourie, R

Towards optimal spatiotemporal wavefront sha** for the cocktail party problem with inverse design of an acoustic reconfigurable metasurface in disordered media

Authors: Raphael Pestourie, Constant Bourdeloux, Fabrice Lemoult, Mathias Fink, Steven G. Johnson

Abstract: Multiple-user multiple-input multiple-output applications have recently gained a lot of attention. Here, we show an efficient optimization formulation for the design of all the temporal and spatial degrees of freedom of an acoustic reconfigurable metasurface for the cocktail party problem. In the frequency domain, the closed-form least square solution matches the optimal time reversal solution for… ▽ More Multiple-user multiple-input multiple-output applications have recently gained a lot of attention. Here, we show an efficient optimization formulation for the design of all the temporal and spatial degrees of freedom of an acoustic reconfigurable metasurface for the cocktail party problem. In the frequency domain, the closed-form least square solution matches the optimal time reversal solution for multiple emitter-receiver pairs, optimizing for each frequency independently. This is more efficient than solving in the time domain where the time convolution mixes all the degrees of freedom into a resource-intensive optimization. We illustrate this methodology by optimizing the frequency response of a design for two pairs of emitters-receivers using the Green's functions of disordered media that are measured experimentally. We report strong performance that will be put in perspective in future work, where we will analyze the robustness of the design to noise in the data and design the convolutional filters that match the optimal frequency response for experiment validation of the design. △ Less

Submitted 23 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 3 pages, 1 figure

A New Homogenization-Free Boundary Condition Towards Aperiodic Metasurface Design Using Full-Wave Surrogate Models of Printed Circuits

Authors: Jordan Budhu, Raphael Pestourie

Abstract: A new homogenization-free boundary condition is introduced for the design of metasurfaces. The boundary condition, linking the tangential electric field to the induced surface current density within a unit cell, is described as a matrix equation containing a surrogate model of a printed circuit. Full-wave simulations are performed to construct the data needed to capture the physics of a printed ci… ▽ More A new homogenization-free boundary condition is introduced for the design of metasurfaces. The boundary condition, linking the tangential electric field to the induced surface current density within a unit cell, is described as a matrix equation containing a surrogate model of a printed circuit. Full-wave simulations are performed to construct the data needed to capture the physics of a printed circuits response to exciting fields in terms of its induced current density. The matrix equation takes the form of a boundary condition which can be included in design and optimization algorithms incorporating mutual coupling in the form of an impedance matrix. Modelling the metasurface in this manner allows for direct design of the realizable model avoiding any homogenization or locally periodic approximations leading to a paradigm shift in metasurface design approaches. The surrogate models construction is described and its use in a 50 printed circuit example is provided. △ Less

Submitted 8 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Efficient inverse design of large-area metasurfaces for incoherent light

Authors: Raphaël Pestourie, Wenjie Yao, Boubacar Kanté, Steven G. Johnson

Abstract: Incoherent light is ubiquitous, yet designing optical devices that can handle its random nature is very challenging, since directly averaging over many incoherent incident beams can require a huge number of scattering calculations. We show how to instead solve this problem with a reciprocity technique which leads to three orders of magnitude speedup: one Maxwell solve (using any numerical techniqu… ▽ More Incoherent light is ubiquitous, yet designing optical devices that can handle its random nature is very challenging, since directly averaging over many incoherent incident beams can require a huge number of scattering calculations. We show how to instead solve this problem with a reciprocity technique which leads to three orders of magnitude speedup: one Maxwell solve (using any numerical technique) instead of thousands. This improvement enables us to perform efficient inverse design, large scale optimization of the metasurface for applications such as light collimators and concentrators. We show the impact of the angular distribution of incident light on the resulting performance, and show especially promising designs for the case of "annular" beams distributed only over nonzero angles. △ Less

Submitted 16 October, 2022; v1 submitted 21 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

Inverse-Designed Meta-Optics with Spectral-Spatial Engineered Response to Mimic Color Perception

Authors: Chris Munley, Wenchao Ma, Johannes E. Fröch, Quentin A. A. Tanguy, Elyas Bayati, Karl F. Böhringer, Zin Lin, Raphaël Pestourie, Steven G. Johnson, Arka Majumdar

Abstract: Meta-optics have rapidly become a major research field within the optics and photonics community, strongly driven by the seemingly limitless opportunities made possible by controlling optical wavefronts through interaction with arrays of sub-wavelength scatterers. As more and more modalities are explored, the design strategies to achieve desired functionalities become increasingly demanding, neces… ▽ More Meta-optics have rapidly become a major research field within the optics and photonics community, strongly driven by the seemingly limitless opportunities made possible by controlling optical wavefronts through interaction with arrays of sub-wavelength scatterers. As more and more modalities are explored, the design strategies to achieve desired functionalities become increasingly demanding, necessitating more advanced design techniques. Herein, the inverse-design approach is utilized to create a set of single-layer meta-optics that simultaneously focus light and shape the spectra of focused light without using any filters. Thus, both spatial and spectral properties of the meta-optics are optimized, resulting in spectra that mimic the color matching functions of the CIE 1931 XYZ color space, which links the distributions of wavelengths in light and the color perception of a human eye. Experimental demonstrations of these meta-optics show qualitative agreement with the theoretical predictions and help elucidate the focusing mechanism of these devices. △ Less

Submitted 28 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Multifidelity deep neural operators for efficient learning of partial differential equations with application to fast inverse design of nanoscale heat transport

Authors: Lu Lu, Raphael Pestourie, Steven G. Johnson, Giuseppe Romano

Abstract: Deep neural operators can learn operators map** between infinite-dimensional function spaces via deep neural networks and have become an emerging paradigm of scientific machine learning. However, training neural operators usually requires a large amount of high-fidelity data, which is often difficult to obtain in real engineering problems. Here, we address this challenge by using multifidelity l… ▽ More Deep neural operators can learn operators map** between infinite-dimensional function spaces via deep neural networks and have become an emerging paradigm of scientific machine learning. However, training neural operators usually requires a large amount of high-fidelity data, which is often difficult to obtain in real engineering problems. Here, we address this challenge by using multifidelity learning, i.e., learning from multifidelity datasets. We develop a multifidelity neural operator based on a deep operator network (DeepONet). A multifidelity DeepONet includes two standard DeepONets coupled by residual learning and input augmentation. Multifidelity DeepONet significantly reduces the required amount of high-fidelity data and achieves one order of magnitude smaller error when using the same amount of high-fidelity data. We apply a multifidelity DeepONet to learn the phonon Boltzmann transport equation (BTE), a framework to compute nanoscale heat transport. By combining a trained multifidelity DeepONet with genetic algorithm or topology optimization, we demonstrate a fast solver for the inverse design of BTE problems. △ Less

Submitted 13 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Efficient perturbative framework for coupling of radiative and guided modes in nearly periodic surfaces

Authors: Sophie Fisher, Raphaël Pestourie, Steven G. Johnson

Abstract: We present a semi-analytical framework for computing the coupling of radiative and guided waves in slowly varying (nearly uniform or nearly periodic) surfaces, which is especially relevant to the exploitation of nonlocal effects in large-area metasurfaces. Our framework bridges a gap in the theory of slowly varying surfaces: aside from brute-force numerical simulations, current approximate methods… ▽ More We present a semi-analytical framework for computing the coupling of radiative and guided waves in slowly varying (nearly uniform or nearly periodic) surfaces, which is especially relevant to the exploitation of nonlocal effects in large-area metasurfaces. Our framework bridges a gap in the theory of slowly varying surfaces: aside from brute-force numerical simulations, current approximate methods can model either guided or radiative waves, but cannot easily model their coupling. We solve this problem by combining two methods: the locally periodic approximation, which approximates radiative scattering by composing a set of periodic scattering problems, and spatial coupled-wave theory, which allows the perturbative modeling of guided waves using an eigenmode expansion. We derive our framework for both nearly uniform and nearly periodic surfaces, and we validate each case against brute-force finite-difference time-domain simulations, which show increasing agreement as the surface varies more slowly. △ Less

Submitted 10 May, 2023; v1 submitted 4 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: 14 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A, 106, 013507 (2022)

Physics-enhanced deep surrogates for partial differential equations

Authors: Raphaël Pestourie, Youssef Mroueh, Chris Rackauckas, Payel Das, Steven G. Johnson

Abstract: Many physics and engineering applications demand Partial Differential Equations (PDE) property evaluations that are traditionally computed with resource-intensive high-fidelity numerical solvers. Data-driven surrogate models provide an efficient alternative but come with a significant cost of training. Emerging applications would benefit from surrogates with an improved accuracy-cost tradeoff, whi… ▽ More Many physics and engineering applications demand Partial Differential Equations (PDE) property evaluations that are traditionally computed with resource-intensive high-fidelity numerical solvers. Data-driven surrogate models provide an efficient alternative but come with a significant cost of training. Emerging applications would benefit from surrogates with an improved accuracy-cost tradeoff, while studied at scale. Here we present a "physics-enhanced deep-surrogate" ("PEDS") approach towards develo** fast surrogate models for complex physical systems, which is described by PDEs. Specifically, a combination of a low-fidelity, explainable physics simulator and a neural network generator is proposed, which is trained end-to-end to globally match the output of an expensive high-fidelity numerical solver. Experiments on three exemplar testcases, diffusion, reaction-diffusion, and electromagnetic scattering models, show that a PEDS surrogate can be up to 3$\times$ more accurate than an ensemble of feedforward neural networks with limited data ($\approx 10^3$ training points), and reduces the training data need by at least a factor of 100 to achieve a target error of 5%. Experiments reveal that PEDS provides a general, data-driven strategy to bridge the gap between a vast array of simplified physical models with corresponding brute-force numerical solvers modeling complex systems, offering accuracy, speed, data efficiency, as well as physical insights into the process. △ Less

Submitted 14 December, 2023; v1 submitted 10 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

End-to-end metasurface inverse design for single-shot multi-channel imaging

Authors: Zin Lin, Raphaël Pestourie, Charles Roques-Carmes, Zhaoyi Li, Federico Capasso, Marin Soljačić, Steven G. Johnson

Abstract: We introduce end-to-end metaoptics inverse design for multi-channel imaging: reconstruction of depth, spectral and polarization channels from a single-shot monochrome image. The proposed technique integrates a single-layer metasurface frontend with an efficient Tikhonov reconstruction backend, without any additional optics except a grayscale sensor. Our method yields multi-channel imaging by spont… ▽ More We introduce end-to-end metaoptics inverse design for multi-channel imaging: reconstruction of depth, spectral and polarization channels from a single-shot monochrome image. The proposed technique integrates a single-layer metasurface frontend with an efficient Tikhonov reconstruction backend, without any additional optics except a grayscale sensor. Our method yields multi-channel imaging by spontaneous demultiplexing: the metaoptics front-end separates different channels into distinct spatial domains whose locations on the sensor are optimally discovered by the inverse-design algorithm. We present large-area metasurface designs, compatible with standard lithography, for multi-spectral imaging, depth-spectral imaging, and ``all-in-one'' spectro-polarimetric-depth imaging with robust reconstruction performance ($\lesssim 10\%$ error with 1\% detector noise). In contrast to neural networks, our framework is physically interpretable and does not require large training sets. It can be used to reconstruct arbitrary three-dimensional scenes with full multi-wavelength spectra and polarization textures. △ Less

Submitted 1 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Inverse Designed Extended Depth of Focus Meta-Optics for Broadband Imaging in the Visible

Authors: Elyas Bayati, Raphael Pestourie, Shane Colburn, Zin Lin, Steven G. Johnson, Arka Majumdar

Abstract: We report an inverse-designed, high numerical aperture (~0.44), extended depth of focus (EDOF) meta-optic, which exhibit a lens-like point spread function (PSF). The EDOF meta-optic maintains a focusing efficiency comparable to that of a hyperboloid metalens throughout its depth of focus. Exploiting the extended depth of focus and computational post-processing, we demonstrate broadband imaging acr… ▽ More We report an inverse-designed, high numerical aperture (~0.44), extended depth of focus (EDOF) meta-optic, which exhibit a lens-like point spread function (PSF). The EDOF meta-optic maintains a focusing efficiency comparable to that of a hyperboloid metalens throughout its depth of focus. Exploiting the extended depth of focus and computational post-processing, we demonstrate broadband imaging across the full visible spectrum using a 1 mm, f/1 meta-optic. Unlike other canonical EDOF meta-optics, characterized by phase masks such as a log-asphere or cubic function, our design exhibits a highly invariant PSF across ~290nm optical bandwidth, which leads to significantly improved image quality, as quantified by structural similarity metrics. △ Less

Submitted 30 September, 2021; v1 submitted 1 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Inverse design enables large-scale high-performance meta-optics resha** virtual reality

Authors: Zhaoyi Li, Raphaël Pestourie, Joon-Suh Park, Yao-Wei Huang, Steven G. Johnson, Federico Capasso

Abstract: Meta-optics has achieved major breakthroughs in the past decade; however, conventional forward design faces challenges as functionality complexity and device size scale up. Inverse design aims at optimizing meta-optics design but has been currently limited by expensive brute-force numerical solvers to small devices, which are also difficult to realize experimentally. Here, we present a general inv… ▽ More Meta-optics has achieved major breakthroughs in the past decade; however, conventional forward design faces challenges as functionality complexity and device size scale up. Inverse design aims at optimizing meta-optics design but has been currently limited by expensive brute-force numerical solvers to small devices, which are also difficult to realize experimentally. Here, we present a general inverse design framework for aperiodic large-scale complex meta-optics in three dimensions, which alleviates computational cost for both simulation and optimization via a fast-approximate solver and an adjoint method, respectively. Our framework naturally accounts for fabrication constraints via a surrogate model. In experiments, we demonstrate, for the first time, aberration-corrected metalenses working in the visible with high numerical aperture, poly-chromatic focusing, and large diameter up to centimeter scale. Such large-scale meta-optics opens a new paradigm for applications, and we demonstrate its potential for future virtual-reality platforms by using a meta-eyepiece and a laser back-illuminated micro-Liquid Crystal Display. △ Less

Submitted 19 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Physics-informed neural networks with hard constraints for inverse design

Authors: Lu Lu, Raphael Pestourie, Wenjie Yao, Zhicheng Wang, Francesc Verdugo, Steven G. Johnson

Abstract: Inverse design arises in a variety of areas in engineering such as acoustic, mechanics, thermal/electronic transport, electromagnetism, and optics. Topology optimization is a major form of inverse design, where we optimize a designed geometry to achieve targeted properties and the geometry is parameterized by a density function. This optimization is challenging, because it has a very high dimensio… ▽ More Inverse design arises in a variety of areas in engineering such as acoustic, mechanics, thermal/electronic transport, electromagnetism, and optics. Topology optimization is a major form of inverse design, where we optimize a designed geometry to achieve targeted properties and the geometry is parameterized by a density function. This optimization is challenging, because it has a very high dimensionality and is usually constrained by partial differential equations (PDEs) and additional inequalities. Here, we propose a new deep learning method -- physics-informed neural networks with hard constraints (hPINNs) -- for solving topology optimization. hPINN leverages the recent development of PINNs for solving PDEs, and thus does not rely on any numerical PDE solver. However, all the constraints in PINNs are soft constraints, and hence we impose hard constraints by using the penalty method and the augmented Lagrangian method. We demonstrate the effectiveness of hPINN for a holography problem in optics and a fluid problem of Stokes flow. We achieve the same objective as conventional PDE-constrained optimization methods based on adjoint methods and numerical PDE solvers, but find that the design obtained from hPINN is often simpler and smoother for problems whose solution is not unique. Moreover, the implementation of inverse design with hPINN can be easier than that of conventional methods. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Active learning of deep surrogates for PDEs: Application to metasurface design

Authors: Raphaël Pestourie, Youssef Mroueh, Thanh V. Nguyen, Payel Das, Steven G. Johnson

Abstract: Surrogate models for partial-differential equations are widely used in the design of meta-materials to rapidly evaluate the behavior of composable components. However, the training cost of accurate surrogates by machine learning can rapidly increase with the number of variables. For photonic-device models, we find that this training becomes especially challenging as design regions grow larger than… ▽ More Surrogate models for partial-differential equations are widely used in the design of meta-materials to rapidly evaluate the behavior of composable components. However, the training cost of accurate surrogates by machine learning can rapidly increase with the number of variables. For photonic-device models, we find that this training becomes especially challenging as design regions grow larger than the optical wavelength. We present an active learning algorithm that reduces the number of training points by more than an order of magnitude for a neural-network surrogate model of optical-surface components compared to random samples. Results show that the surrogate evaluation is over two orders of magnitude faster than a direct solve, and we demonstrate how this can be exploited to accelerate large-scale engineering optimization. △ Less

Submitted 24 August, 2020; originally announced August 2020.

Comments: submitted to npj

Journal ref: npj Computational Materials (2020)6:164

End-to-End Nanophotonic Inverse Design for Imaging and Polarimetry

Authors: Zin Lin, Charles Roques-Carmes, Raphaël Pestourie, Marin Soljačić, Arka Majumdar, Steven G. Johnson

Abstract: By co-designing a meta-optical front end in conjunction with an image-processing back end, we demonstrate noise sensitivity and compactness substantially superior to either an optics-only or a computation-only approach, illustrated by two examples: subwavelength imaging and reconstruction of the full polarization coherence matrices of multiple light sources. Our end-to-end inverse designs couple t… ▽ More By co-designing a meta-optical front end in conjunction with an image-processing back end, we demonstrate noise sensitivity and compactness substantially superior to either an optics-only or a computation-only approach, illustrated by two examples: subwavelength imaging and reconstruction of the full polarization coherence matrices of multiple light sources. Our end-to-end inverse designs couple the solution of the full Maxwell equations---exploiting all aspects of wave physics arising in subwavelength scatterers---with inverse-scattering algorithms in a single large-scale optimization involving $\gtrsim 10^4$ degrees of freedom. The resulting structures scatter light in a way that is radically different from either a conventional lens or a random microstructure, and suppress the noise sensitivity of the inverse-scattering computation by several orders of magnitude. Incorporating the full wave physics is especially crucial for detecting spectral and polarization information that is discarded by geometric optics and scalar diffraction theory. △ Less

Submitted 10 October, 2020; v1 submitted 16 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: 19 pages, 4 figures. Initially submitted on June 16, 2020. Expanded version submitted on October 10, 2020

Inverse designed metalenses with extended depth of focus

Authors: Elyas Bayati, Raphael Pestourie, Shane Colburn, Zin Lin, Steven G. Johnson, Arka Majumdar

Abstract: Extended depth of focus (EDOF) lenses are important for various applications in computational imaging and microscopy. In addition to enabling novel functionalities, EDOF lenses can alleviate the need for stringent alignment requirements for imaging systems. Existing EDOF lenses, however, are often inefficient or produce an asymmetric point spread function (PSF) that blurs images. Inverse design of… ▽ More Extended depth of focus (EDOF) lenses are important for various applications in computational imaging and microscopy. In addition to enabling novel functionalities, EDOF lenses can alleviate the need for stringent alignment requirements for imaging systems. Existing EDOF lenses, however, are often inefficient or produce an asymmetric point spread function (PSF) that blurs images. Inverse design of nanophotonics, including metasurfaces, has generated strong interest in recent years owing to its potential for generating exotic and innovative optical elements, which are generally difficult to model intuitively. Using adjoint optimization-based inverse electromagnetic design, in this paper, we designed a cylindrical metasurface lens operating at ~ 625nm with a depth of focus exceeding that of an ordinary lens. We validated our design by nanofabrication and optical characterization of silicon nitride metasurface lenses (with lateral dimension of 66.66 μm) with three different focal lengths (66.66 μm,100 μm,133.33 μm). The focusing efficiencies of the fabricated extended depth of focus metasurface lenses are similar to those of traditional metalenses. △ Less

Submitted 1 April, 2020; v1 submitted 15 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Comments: ACS Photonics, 2020

Topology optimization of freeform large-area metasurfaces

Authors: Zin Lin, Victor Liu, Raphaël Pestourie, Steven G. Johnson

Abstract: We demonstrate optimization of optical metasurfaces over $10^5$--$10^6$ degrees of freedom in two and three dimensions, 100--1000+ wavelengths ($λ$) in diameter, with 100+ parameters per $λ^2$. In particular, we show how topology optimization, with one degree of freedom per high-resolution "pixel," can be extended to large areas with the help of a locally periodic approximation that was previously… ▽ More We demonstrate optimization of optical metasurfaces over $10^5$--$10^6$ degrees of freedom in two and three dimensions, 100--1000+ wavelengths ($λ$) in diameter, with 100+ parameters per $λ^2$. In particular, we show how topology optimization, with one degree of freedom per high-resolution "pixel," can be extended to large areas with the help of a locally periodic approximation that was previously only used for a few parameters per $λ^2$. In this way, we can computationally discover completely unexpected metasurface designs for challenging multi-frequency, multi-angle problems, including designs for fully coupled multi-layer structures with arbitrary per-layer patterns. Unlike typical metasurface designs based on subwavelength unit cells, our approach can discover both sub- and supra-wavelength patterns and can obtain both the near and far fields. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Inverse design of large-area metasurfaces

Authors: Raphaël Pestourie, Carlos Pérez-Arancibia, Zin Lin, Wonseok Shin, Federico Capasso, Steven G. Johnson

Abstract: We present a computational framework for efficient optimization-based "inverse design" of large-area "metasurfaces" (subwavelength-patterned surfaces) for applications such as multi-wavelength and multi-angle optimizations, and demultiplexers. To optimize surfaces that can be thousands of wavelengths in diameter, with thousands (or millions) of parameters, the key is a fast approximate solver for… ▽ More We present a computational framework for efficient optimization-based "inverse design" of large-area "metasurfaces" (subwavelength-patterned surfaces) for applications such as multi-wavelength and multi-angle optimizations, and demultiplexers. To optimize surfaces that can be thousands of wavelengths in diameter, with thousands (or millions) of parameters, the key is a fast approximate solver for the scattered field. We employ a "locally periodic" approximation in which the scattering problem is approximated by a composition of periodic scattering problems from each unit cell of the surface, and validate it against brute-force Maxwell solutions. This is an extension of ideas in previous metasurface designs, but with greatly increased flexibility, e.g. to automatically balance tradeoffs between multiple frequencies, or to optimize a photonic device given only partial information about the desired field. Our approach even extends beyond the metasurface regime to non-subwavelength structures where additional diffracted orders must be included (but the period is not large enough to apply scalar diffraction theory). △ Less

Submitted 14 December, 2018; v1 submitted 13 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Comments: 18 pages, 8 figures

Journal ref: Optics Express 26(26) (2018) 33732-33747

Sideways adiabaticity: Beyond ray optics for slowly varying metasurfaces

Authors: Carlos Pérez-Arancibia, Raphaël Pestourie, Steven G. Johnson

Abstract: Optical metasurfaces (subwavelength-patterned surfaces typically described by variable effective surface impedances) are typically modeled by an approximation akin to ray optics: the reflection or transmission of an incident wave at each point of the surface is computed as if the surface were "locally uniform", and then the total field is obtained by summing all of these local scattered fields via… ▽ More Optical metasurfaces (subwavelength-patterned surfaces typically described by variable effective surface impedances) are typically modeled by an approximation akin to ray optics: the reflection or transmission of an incident wave at each point of the surface is computed as if the surface were "locally uniform", and then the total field is obtained by summing all of these local scattered fields via a Huygens principle. (Similar approximations are found in scalar diffraction theory and in ray optics for curved surfaces.) In this paper, we develop a precise theory of such approximations for variable-impedance surfaces. Not only do we obtain a type of adiabatic theorem showing that the "zeroth-order" locally uniform approximation converges in the limit as the surface varies more and more slowly, including a way to quantify the rate of convergence, but we also obtain an infinite series of higher-order corrections. These corrections, which can be computed to any desired order by performing integral operations on the surface fields, allow rapidly varying surfaces to be modeled with arbitrary accuracy, and also allow one to validate designs based on the zeroth-order approximation (which is often surprisingly accurate) without resorting to expensive brute-force Maxwell solvers. We show that our formulation works arbitrarily close to the surface, and can even compute coupling to guided modes, whereas in the far-field limit our zeroth-order result simplifies to an expression similar to what has been used by other authors. △ Less

Submitted 14 November, 2018; v1 submitted 13 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Journal ref: Optics Express, 26(23):335299, 2018