-
Thermal conductivity with bells and whistlers: suppression of the magnetothermal instability in galaxy clusters
Authors:
Lorenzo Maria Perrone,
Thomas Berlok,
Christoph Pfrommer
Abstract:
In the hot intracluster medium (ICM) in galaxy clusters, plasma microinstabilities may play an important role in the transport of heat and momentum on the large scales. In this paper, we continue our investigation of the effect of whistler suppression of thermal conductivity on the magneto-thermal instability (MTI), which may be active in the periphery of galaxy clusters and contribute to the obse…
▽ More
In the hot intracluster medium (ICM) in galaxy clusters, plasma microinstabilities may play an important role in the transport of heat and momentum on the large scales. In this paper, we continue our investigation of the effect of whistler suppression of thermal conductivity on the magneto-thermal instability (MTI), which may be active in the periphery of galaxy clusters and contribute to the observed turbulence. We use a closure for the heat flux inspired by kinetic simulations and show that MTI turbulence with whistler suppression exhibits a critical transition: for modest suppression of the conductivity, the MTI turbulent velocities decrease in agreement with previous MTI scaling laws. However, for suppression above a critical threshold, the MTI loses its ability to maintain equipartition-level magnetic fields through a small-scale dynamo, and the system enters a ``death-spiral''. We propose a model to explain this critical transition, and speculate that conditions in the hot ICM are favourable to the upkeep of the dynamo. Additionaly, with whistler suppression high-$β$ regions are brought out of thermal equilibrium while the efficiency of MTI turbulent driving is reduced. Finally, we show that external turbulence interferes with the MTI and leads to lower levels of turbulence. While individually both external turbulence and whistler suppression weaken the MTI, we find that they can exhibit a complex interplay when acting in conjunction, with external turbulence boosting the whistler-suppressed thermal conductivity and even reviving a ``dead'' MTI. Our study illustrates how extending magnetohydrodynamics with a simple prescription for microscale plasma physics can lead to the formation of a complicated dynamical system and demonstrates that further work is needed in order to bridge the gap between micro- and macro scales in galaxy clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Does the magneto-thermal instability survive whistler-suppression of thermal conductivity in galaxy clusters?
Authors:
Lorenzo Maria Perrone,
Thomas Berlok,
Christoph Pfrommer
Abstract:
The hot and dilute intracluster medium (ICM) plays a central role in many key processes that shape galaxy clusters. Nevertheless, the nature of plasma turbulence and particle transport in the ICM remain poorly understood and quantifying the effect of kinetic plasma instabilities on the macroscopic dynamics represents an outstanding problem. Here we focus on the impact of whistler-wave suppression…
▽ More
The hot and dilute intracluster medium (ICM) plays a central role in many key processes that shape galaxy clusters. Nevertheless, the nature of plasma turbulence and particle transport in the ICM remain poorly understood and quantifying the effect of kinetic plasma instabilities on the macroscopic dynamics represents an outstanding problem. Here we focus on the impact of whistler-wave suppression of the heat flux on the magneto-thermal instability (MTI), which is expected to drive significant turbulent motions in the periphery of galaxy clusters. We perform small-scale Boussinesq simulations with a sub-grid closure for the thermal diffusivity in the regime of whistler-wave suppression. Our model is characterized by a single parameter that quantifies the collisionality of the ICM on the astrophysical scales of interest that we tune to explore a range appropriate for the periphery of galaxy clusters. We find that the MTI is qualitatively unchanged for weak whistler-suppression. Conversely, with strong suppression the magnetic dynamo is interrupted and MTI-turbulence dies out. In the astrophysically relevant limit, however, the MTI is likely to be supplemented by additional sources of turbulence. Investigating this scenario, we show that the inclusion of external forcing has a beneficial impact and revives even MTI simulations with strong whistler-suppression. As a result, the plasma remains buoyantly unstable, with important consequences for turbulent mixing in the ICM.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Magneto-Thermal Instability In Galaxy Clusters II: Three-Dimensional Simulations
Authors:
Lorenzo M. Perrone,
Henrik Latter
Abstract:
In the intracluster medium (ICM) of galaxies, exchanges of heat across magnetic field lines are strongly suppressed. This anisotropic heat conduction, in the presence of a large-scale temperature gradient, destabilizes the outskirts of galaxy clusters via the magneto-thermal instability (MTI), and thus supplies a source of observed ICM turbulence. In this paper we continue our investigation of the…
▽ More
In the intracluster medium (ICM) of galaxies, exchanges of heat across magnetic field lines are strongly suppressed. This anisotropic heat conduction, in the presence of a large-scale temperature gradient, destabilizes the outskirts of galaxy clusters via the magneto-thermal instability (MTI), and thus supplies a source of observed ICM turbulence. In this paper we continue our investigation of the MTI with 3D simulations using the Boussinesq code SNOOPY. We redress two issues intrinsic to our previous 2D study: an inverse energy cascade and the impossibility of dynamo action. Contrary to 2D simulations, we find inconsequential transport of energy across scales (most energy is dissipated at the same scale as its injection), and that turbulent eddies are vertically elongated at or below the thermal conduction length, but relatively isotropic on larger scales. Similar to 2D, however, the saturated turbulent energy levels and the integral scale follow clear power-laws that depend on the thermal diffusivity, temperature gradient, and buoyancy frequency. We also show that the MTI amplifies magnetic fields, through a fluctuation dynamo, to equipartition strengths provided that the integral scale of MTI turbulence is larger than the viscous dissipation scale. Finally, we show that our scaling laws are consistent with extant observations of ICM turbulence if the thermal conductivity is reduced by a factor of $\sim 10$ from its Spitzer value, and that on global cluster scales the stable stratification significantly reduces the vertical elongation of MTI motions.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Magneto-Thermal Instability In Galaxy Clusters I: Theory and Two-Dimensional Simulations
Authors:
Lorenzo M. Perrone,
Henrik Latter
Abstract:
Determining the origin of turbulence in galaxy clusters, and quantifying its transport of heat, is an outstanding problem, with implications for our understanding of their thermodynamic history and structure. As the dilute plasma of the intracluster medium (ICM) is magnetized, heat and momentum travel preferentially along magnetic field lines. This anisotropy triggers a class of buoyancy instabili…
▽ More
Determining the origin of turbulence in galaxy clusters, and quantifying its transport of heat, is an outstanding problem, with implications for our understanding of their thermodynamic history and structure. As the dilute plasma of the intracluster medium (ICM) is magnetized, heat and momentum travel preferentially along magnetic field lines. This anisotropy triggers a class of buoyancy instabilities that destabilize the ICM, and whose turbulent motions can augment or impede heat transport. We focus on the magneto-thermal instability (MTI), which may be active in the periphery of galaxy clusters. We aim to take a fresh look at the problem and construct a general theory that explains the MTI saturation mechanism and provides scalings and estimates for the turbulent kinetic energy, magnetic energy, and heat flux. We simulate MTI turbulence with a Boussinesq code, SNOOPY, which, in contrast to previous work, allows us to perform an extensive sampling of the parameter space. In two dimensions the saturation mechanism involves an inverse cascade carrying kinetic energy from the short MTI injection scales to larger scales, where it is arrested by the stable entropy stratification; at a characteristic "buoyancy scale", the energy is dumped into large-scale g-modes, which subsequently dissipate. Consequently, the entropy stratification sets an upper limit on the size and strength of turbulent eddies. Meanwhile, the MTI conveys a substantial fraction of heat, despite the tangled geometry of the magnetic field. In a companion paper, these results are extended to three-dimensional flows, and compared to real cluster observations.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Neutrino-electron magnetohydrodynamics in an expanding Universe
Authors:
L. M. Perrone,
G. Gregori,
B. Reville,
L. O. Silva,
R. Bingham
Abstract:
We derive a new model for neutrino-plasma interactions in an expanding universe that incorporates the collective effects of the neutrinos on the plasma constituents. We start from the kinetic description of a multi-species plasma in the flat Friedmann-Robertson-Walker metric, where the particles are coupled to neutrinos through the charged- and neutral-current forms of the weak interaction. We the…
▽ More
We derive a new model for neutrino-plasma interactions in an expanding universe that incorporates the collective effects of the neutrinos on the plasma constituents. We start from the kinetic description of a multi-species plasma in the flat Friedmann-Robertson-Walker metric, where the particles are coupled to neutrinos through the charged- and neutral-current forms of the weak interaction. We then derive the fluid equations and specialize our model to (a) the lepton epoch, where we consider a pair electron-positron plasma interacting with electron (anti-)neutrinos, and (b) after the electron-positron annihilation, where we model an electron-proton plasma and take the limit of slow ions and inertia-less electrons to obtain a set of neutrino-electron magnetohydrodynamics (NEMHD) equations. In both models, the dynamics of the plasma is affected by the neutrino motion through a ponderomotive force and, as a result, new terms appear in the induction equation that can act as a source for magnetic field generation in the early universe. A brief discussion on the possible applications of our model is proposed.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2021; v1 submitted 28 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Four-dimensional drift-kinetic model for scrape-off layer plasmas
Authors:
L. M. Perrone,
R. Jorge,
P. Ricci
Abstract:
A four-dimensional plasma model able to describe the scrape-off layer region of tokamak devices at arbitrary collisionality is derived in the drift-reduced limit. The basis of the model is provided by a drift-kinetic equation that retains the full non-linear Coulomb collision operator and describes arbitrarily far from equilibrium distribution functions. By expanding the dependence of distribution…
▽ More
A four-dimensional plasma model able to describe the scrape-off layer region of tokamak devices at arbitrary collisionality is derived in the drift-reduced limit. The basis of the model is provided by a drift-kinetic equation that retains the full non-linear Coulomb collision operator and describes arbitrarily far from equilibrium distribution functions. By expanding the dependence of distribution function over the perpendicular velocity in a Laguerre polynomial basis and integrating over the perpendicular velocity, a set of four-dimensional moment equations for the expansion coefficients of the distribution function is obtained. The Coulomb collision operator, as well as Poisson's equation, are evaluated explicitly in terms of perpendicular velocity moments of the distribution function.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Linear Theory of Electron-Plasma Waves at Arbitrary Collisionality
Authors:
R. Jorge,
P. Ricci,
S. Brunner,
S. Gamba,
V. Konovets,
N. F. Loureiro,
L. M. Perrone,
N. Teixeira
Abstract:
The dynamics of electron-plasma waves are described at arbitrary collisionality by considering the full Coulomb collision operator. The description is based on a Hermite-Laguerre decomposition of the velocity dependence of the electron distribution function. The dam** rate, frequency, and eigenmode spectrum of electron-plasma waves are found as functions of the collision frequency and wavelength…
▽ More
The dynamics of electron-plasma waves are described at arbitrary collisionality by considering the full Coulomb collision operator. The description is based on a Hermite-Laguerre decomposition of the velocity dependence of the electron distribution function. The dam** rate, frequency, and eigenmode spectrum of electron-plasma waves are found as functions of the collision frequency and wavelength. A comparison is made between the collisionless Landau dam** limit, the Lenard-Bernstein and Dougherty collision operators, and the electron-ion collision operator, finding large deviations in the dam** rates and eigenmode spectra. A purely damped entropy mode, characteristic of a plasma where pitch-angle scattering effects are dominant with respect to collisionless effects, is shown to emerge numerically, and its dispersion relation is analytically derived. It is shown that such a mode is absent when simplified collision operators are used, and that like-particle collisions strongly influence the dam** rate of the entropy mode.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2019; v1 submitted 26 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
