-
An H-alpha survey of the host environments of 77 type IIn supernovae within z<0.02
Authors:
C. L. Ransome,
S. M. Habergham Mawson,
M. J. Darnley,
P. A. James,
S. M. Percival
Abstract:
Type IIn supernovae (SNe\,IIn) are an uncommon and highly heterogeneous class of SN where the SN ejecta interact with pre-existing circumstellar media (CSM). Previous studies have found a mass ladder in terms of the association of the SN location with H$α$ emission and the progenitor masses of SN classes. In this paper, we present the largest environmental study of SNe\,IIn. We analyse the H$α$ en…
▽ More
Type IIn supernovae (SNe\,IIn) are an uncommon and highly heterogeneous class of SN where the SN ejecta interact with pre-existing circumstellar media (CSM). Previous studies have found a mass ladder in terms of the association of the SN location with H$α$ emission and the progenitor masses of SN classes. In this paper, we present the largest environmental study of SNe\,IIn. We analyse the H$α$ environments of 77 type IIn supernovae using continuum subtracted H$α$ images. We use the pixel statistics technique, normalised cumulative ranking (NCR), to associate SN pixels with H$α$ emission. We find that our 77 SNe\,IIn do not follow the H$α$ emission. This is not consistent with the proposed progenitors of SNe\,IIn, luminous blue variables (LBVs) as LBVs are high mass stars that undergo dramatic episodic mass loss. However, a subset of the NCR values follow the H$α$ emission, suggesting a population of high mass progenitors. This suggests there may be multiple progenitor paths with $\sim$60\% having non-zero NCR values with a distribution consistent with high mass progenitors such as LBVs and $\sim$40\% of these SNe not being associated with H$α$ emission. We discuss the possible progenitor routes of SNe\,IIn, especially for the zero NCR value population. We also investigate the radial distribution of the SNe in their hosts in terms of H$α$ and $r'$-band flux.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2022; v1 submitted 20 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Diffuse LINER-type emission from extended disc regions of barred galaxies
Authors:
S. M. Percival,
P. A. James
Abstract:
We present a spectroscopic analysis of the central disc regions of barred spiral galaxies, concentrating on the region that is swept by the bar but not including the bar itself (the `Star Formation Desert' or SFD region). New spectroscopy is presented for 34 galaxies, and the full sample analysed comprises 48 SBa - SBcd galaxies. These data confirm the full suppression of star formation within the…
▽ More
We present a spectroscopic analysis of the central disc regions of barred spiral galaxies, concentrating on the region that is swept by the bar but not including the bar itself (the `Star Formation Desert' or SFD region). New spectroscopy is presented for 34 galaxies, and the full sample analysed comprises 48 SBa - SBcd galaxies. These data confirm the full suppression of star formation within the SFD regions of all but the latest type (SBcd) galaxies. However, diffuse [NII] and H alpha line emission is detected in all galaxies. The ubiquity and homogeneous properties of this emission from SBa - SBc galaxies favour post-Asymptotic Giant Branch (p-AGB) stars as the source of this line excitation, rather than extreme Blue Horizontal Branch stars. The emission-line ratios strongly exclude any contribution from recent star formation, but are fully consistent with recent population synthesis modelling of p-AGB emission by other authors, and favour excitation dominated by ambient gas of approximately solar abundance, rather than ejecta from the AGB stars themselves. The line equivalent widths are also larger than those observed in many fully passive (e.g. elliptical) galaxies, which may also be a consequence of a greater ambient gas density in the SFD regions.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2020; v1 submitted 18 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Galaxy and Mass Assembly (GAMA): Variation in Galaxy Structure Across the Green Valley
Authors:
Lee S. Kelvin,
Malcolm N. Bremer,
Steven Phillipps,
Philip A. James,
Luke J. M. Davies,
Roberto De Propris,
Amanda J. Moffett,
Susan M. Percival,
Ivan K. Baldry,
Chris A. Collins,
Mehmet Alpaslan,
Joss Bland-Hawthorn,
Sarah Brough,
Michelle Cluver,
Simon P. Driver,
Abdolhosein Hashemizadeh,
Benne W. Holwerda,
Jarkko Laine,
Maritza A. Lara-Lopez,
Jochen Liske,
Witold Maciejewski,
Nicola R. Napolitano,
Samantha J. Penny,
Cristina C. Popescu,
Anne E. Sansom
, et al. (4 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Using a sample of 472 local Universe (z<0.06) galaxies in the stellar mass range 10.25 < log M*/M_sun < 10.75, we explore the variation in galaxy structure as a function of morphology and galaxy colour. Our sample of galaxies is sub-divided into red, green and blue colour groups and into elliptical and non-elliptical (disk-type) morphologies. Using KiDS and VIKING derived postage stamp images, a g…
▽ More
Using a sample of 472 local Universe (z<0.06) galaxies in the stellar mass range 10.25 < log M*/M_sun < 10.75, we explore the variation in galaxy structure as a function of morphology and galaxy colour. Our sample of galaxies is sub-divided into red, green and blue colour groups and into elliptical and non-elliptical (disk-type) morphologies. Using KiDS and VIKING derived postage stamp images, a group of eight volunteers visually classified bars, rings, morphological lenses, tidal streams, shells and signs of merger activity for all systems. We find a significant surplus of rings ($2.3σ$) and lenses ($2.9σ$) in disk-type galaxies as they transition across the green valley. Combined, this implies a joint ring/lens green valley surplus significance of $3.3σ$ relative to equivalent disk-types within either the blue cloud or the red sequence. We recover a bar fraction of ~44% which remains flat with colour, however, we find that the presence of a bar acts to modulate the incidence of rings and (to a lesser extent) lenses, with rings in barred disk-type galaxies more common by ~20-30 percentage points relative to their unbarred counterparts, regardless of colour. Additionally, green valley disk-type galaxies with a bar exhibit a significant $3.0σ$ surplus of lenses relative to their blue/red analogues. The existence of such structures rules out violent transformative events as the primary end-of-life evolutionary mechanism, with a more passive scenario the favoured candidate for the majority of galaxies rapidly transitioning across the green valley.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Star formation suppression and bar ages in nearby barred galaxies
Authors:
P. A. James,
S. M. Percival
Abstract:
We present new spectroscopic data for 21 barred spiral galaxies, which we use to explore the effect of bars on disk star formation, and to place constraints on the characteristic lifetimes of bar episodes. The analysis centres on regions of heavily suppressed star formation activity, which we term 'star formation deserts'. Long-slit optical spectroscopy is used to determine H beta absorption stren…
▽ More
We present new spectroscopic data for 21 barred spiral galaxies, which we use to explore the effect of bars on disk star formation, and to place constraints on the characteristic lifetimes of bar episodes. The analysis centres on regions of heavily suppressed star formation activity, which we term 'star formation deserts'. Long-slit optical spectroscopy is used to determine H beta absorption strengths in these desert regions, and comparisons with theoretical stellar population models are used to determine the time since the last significant star formation activity, and hence the ages of the bars. We find typical ages of approx. 1 Gyr, but with a broad range, much larger than would be expected from measurement errors alone, extending from about 0.25 Gyr to more than 4 Gyr. Low-level residual star formation, or mixing of stars from outside the 'desert' regions, could result in a doubling of these age estimates. The relatively young ages of the underlying populations coupled with the strong limits on the current star formation rule out a gradual exponential decline in activity, and hence support our assumption of an abrupt truncation event.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Stellar population constraints on the ages of galactic bars
Authors:
Phil A. James,
Susan M. Percival
Abstract:
We present a study of the stellar populations within the central regions of four nearby barred galaxies, and use a novel technique to constrain the duration of bar activity. We focus on the star formation 'desert', a region within each of these galaxies where star formation appears to have been suppressed by the bar. New H beta spectroscopic data are presented, and used to produce spectroscopic li…
▽ More
We present a study of the stellar populations within the central regions of four nearby barred galaxies, and use a novel technique to constrain the duration of bar activity. We focus on the star formation 'desert', a region within each of these galaxies where star formation appears to have been suppressed by the bar. New H beta spectroscopic data are presented, and used to produce spectroscopic line indices which are compared with theoretical predictions from population synthesis models for simple stellar populations and temporally truncated star formation histories. This analysis shows that the dearth of star formation activity in these regions appears to have been continuing for at least 1 Gyr, with timescales of several Gyr indicated for two of the galaxies. This favours models in which strong bars can be long-lived features of galaxies, but our results also indicate a significant diversity in stellar population ages, and hence in the implied histories of bar activity in these four galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Discovery of kpc-scale line emission in barred galaxies, not linked to AGN or star formation
Authors:
Phil A. James,
Susan M. Percival
Abstract:
We present an analysis of the optical line emission from nearby barred galaxies, and in particular look at the radial range occupied by the bar. In many cases this region is marked by what we term a 'star formation desert', with a marked deficit of HII regions in optical narrow-band H-alpha imaging. Here we present long-slit spectroscopy revealing that such regions do have line emission, but that…
▽ More
We present an analysis of the optical line emission from nearby barred galaxies, and in particular look at the radial range occupied by the bar. In many cases this region is marked by what we term a 'star formation desert', with a marked deficit of HII regions in optical narrow-band H-alpha imaging. Here we present long-slit spectroscopy revealing that such regions do have line emission, but that it is low-level, spatially smooth and almost ubiquitous. The relative strengths of the H-alpha and the spectrally adjacent [NII] lines in the regions are completely discrepant from those associated with star formation regions, and more closely match expectations for 'LINER' regions. We quantify the total line emission from these extended, kpc-scale regions, and determine the spurious contribution it would make to the determined star formation rate of these galaxies if interpreted as normal H-alpha emission. We concur with previous studies that link this LINER emission to old stellar populations, e.g. post-asymptotic giant branch stars, and propose these strongly-barred early-type spirals as a prime location for further tests of such emission.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Modelling realistic horizontal branch morphologies and their impact on spectroscopic ages of unresolved stellar systems
Authors:
Susan M. Percival,
Maurizio Salaris
Abstract:
The presence of an extended blue horizontal branch (HB) in a stellar population is known to affect the age inferred from spectral fitting to stellar population synthesis models. However, most population synthesis models still rely on theoretical isochrones which do not include realistic modelling of extended HBs. In this work, we create detailed models for a range of old simple stellar populations…
▽ More
The presence of an extended blue horizontal branch (HB) in a stellar population is known to affect the age inferred from spectral fitting to stellar population synthesis models. However, most population synthesis models still rely on theoretical isochrones which do not include realistic modelling of extended HBs. In this work, we create detailed models for a range of old simple stellar populations (SSPs), to create a variety of realistic HB morphologies, from extended red clumps, to extreme blue HBs. We achieve this by utilising stellar tracks from the BaSTI database and implementing a different mass loss prescription for each SSP created, resulting in different HB morphologies. We find that, for each metallicity, there is some HB morphology which maximises Hbeta, making an underlying 14Gyr population look ~5-6Gyr old for the low and intermediate metallicity cases, and as young as 2Gyr for a solar metallicity SSP. We explore whether there are any spectral indices capable of breaking the degeneracy between an old SSP with extended blue HB and a truly young or intermediate age SSP, and find that the CaII index of Rose(1984) and the strength of the MgII doublet at 2800A are promising candidates, in combination with Hbeta and other metallicity indicators such as Mgb and Fe5406. We also run Monte Carlo simulations to investigate the level of statistical fluctuations in the spectra of typical stellar clusters. We find that fluctuations in spectral indices are significant even for average to large globular clusters, and that various spectral indices are affected in different ways, which has implications for full-spectrum fitting methods. Hence we urge caution if these types of stellar clusters are to be used as empirical calibrating objects for various aspects of SPS models. (Abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
The impact of systematic uncertainties in stellar parameters on integrated spectra of stellar populations
Authors:
Susan M. Percival,
Maurizio Salaris
Abstract:
In this paper we investigate a hitherto unexplored source of potentially significant error in stellar population synthesis (SPS) models, caused by systematic uncertainties associated with the three fundamental stellar atmospheric parameters; effective temperature T_eff, surface gravity g, and iron abundance [Fe/H]. All SPS models rely on calibrations of T_eff, logg and [Fe/H] scales, which are i…
▽ More
In this paper we investigate a hitherto unexplored source of potentially significant error in stellar population synthesis (SPS) models, caused by systematic uncertainties associated with the three fundamental stellar atmospheric parameters; effective temperature T_eff, surface gravity g, and iron abundance [Fe/H]. All SPS models rely on calibrations of T_eff, logg and [Fe/H] scales, which are implicit in stellar models, isochrones and synthetic spectra, and are explicitly adopted for empirical spectral libraries. We assess the effect of a mismatch in scales between isochrones and spectral libraries (the two key components of SPS models) and quantify the effects on 23 commonly used diagnostic line indices. We find that typical systematic offsets of 100K in T_eff, 0.15 dex in [Fe/H] and/or 0.25 dex in logg significantly alter inferred absolute ages of simple stellar populations (SSPs) and that in some circumstances, relative ages also change. Offsets in T_eff, logg and [Fe/H] scales for a scaled-solar SSP produce deviations from the model which can mimic the effects of altering abundance ratios to non-scaled-solar chemical compositions, and could also be spuriously interpreted as evidence for a more complex population, especially when multiple-index or full-SED fitting methods are used. We stress that the behavior we find can potentially affect any SPS models, whether using full integrated spectra or fitting functions to determine line strengths. We present measured offsets in 23 diagnostic line indices and urge caution in the over-interpretation of line-index data for stellar populations.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2009;
originally announced August 2009.
-
Optical and near infra-red colours as a discriminant of the age and metallicity of stellar populations
Authors:
David Carter,
Daniel J. B. Smith,
Susan M. Percival,
Ivan K. Baldry,
Christopher A. Collins,
Philip A. James,
Maurizio Salaris,
Chris Simpson,
John P. Stott,
Bahram Mobasher
Abstract:
We present a comprehensive analysis of the ability of current stellar population models to reproduce the optical (ugriz) and near infra-red (JHK) colours of a small sample of well-studied nearby elliptical and S0 galaxies. We find broad agreement between the ages and metallicities derived using different population models, although different models show different systematic deviations from the m…
▽ More
We present a comprehensive analysis of the ability of current stellar population models to reproduce the optical (ugriz) and near infra-red (JHK) colours of a small sample of well-studied nearby elliptical and S0 galaxies. We find broad agreement between the ages and metallicities derived using different population models, although different models show different systematic deviations from the measured broad-band fluxes. Although it is possible to constrain Simple Stellar Population models to a well defined area in age-metallicity space, there is a clear degeneracy between these parameters even with such a full range of precise colours. The precision to which age and metallicity can be determined independently, using only broad band photometry with realistic errors, is Delta{[Fe/H]} ~ 0.18 and Delta{log(Age)} ~ 0.25. To constrain the populations and therefore the star formation history further it will be necessary to combine broad-band optical-IR photometry with either spectral line indices, or else photometry at wavelengths outside of this range.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2009;
originally announced May 2009.
-
A large stellar evolution database for population synthesis studies. IV. Integrated properties and spectra
Authors:
Susan M. Percival,
Maurizio Salaris,
Santi Cassisi,
Adriano Pietrinferni
Abstract:
This paper is the 4th in a series describing the latest additions to the BaSTI stellar evolution database, which consists of a large set of homogeneous models and tools for population synthesis studies. Here we present a new set of low and high resolution synthetic spectra based on the BaSTI stellar models, covering a large range of simple stellar populations (SSPs) for both scaled solar and alp…
▽ More
This paper is the 4th in a series describing the latest additions to the BaSTI stellar evolution database, which consists of a large set of homogeneous models and tools for population synthesis studies. Here we present a new set of low and high resolution synthetic spectra based on the BaSTI stellar models, covering a large range of simple stellar populations (SSPs) for both scaled solar and alpha-enhanced metal mixtures. This enables a completely consistent study of the photometric and spectroscopic properties of both resolved and unresolved stellar populations, and allows us to make detailed tests on their integrated properties. Our low resolution spectra are suitable for deriving broadband magnitudes and colors in any photometric system. These spectra cover the full wavelength range (9-160000nm) and include all evolutionary stages up to the end of AGB evolution. Our high resolution spectra are suitable for studying the behaviour of line indices and we have tested them against a large sample of Galactic globular clusters. We find that the range of ages, iron abundances [Fe/H], and degree of alpha-enhancement predicted by the models matches observed values very well. We have also tested the global consistency of the BaSTI models by making detailed comparisons between ages and metallicities derived from isochrone fitting to observed CMDs, and from line index strengths, for the Galactic globular cluster 47Tuc and the open cluster M67. For 47Tuc we find reasonable agreement between the 2 methods, within the estimated errors. From the comparison with M67 we find non-negligible effects on derived line indices caused by statistical fluctuations, which are a result of the specific method used to populate an isochrone and assign appropriate spectra to individual stars. (abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2008;
originally announced September 2008.
-
Constraints on supernova progenitors from spatial correlations with H-alpha emission
Authors:
J. P. Anderson,
P. A. James,
M. Salaris,
S. M. Percival
Abstract:
We have attempted to constrain the progenitors of all supernova types, through correlations of the positions of historical supernovae with recent star formation, as traced by H-alpha emission. Through pixel statistics we have found that a large fraction of the SNII population do not show any association with current star formation, which we put down to a 'runaway' fraction of these progenitors.…
▽ More
We have attempted to constrain the progenitors of all supernova types, through correlations of the positions of historical supernovae with recent star formation, as traced by H-alpha emission. Through pixel statistics we have found that a large fraction of the SNII population do not show any association with current star formation, which we put down to a 'runaway' fraction of these progenitors. The SNIb/c population accurately traces the H-alpha emission, with some suggestion that the SNIc progenitors show a higher degree of correlation than the SNIb, suggesting higher mass progenitors for the former. Overall the SNIa population only show a weak correlation to the positions of HII regions, but as many as a half may be associated with a young stellar population.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2007;
originally announced April 2007.
-
The H-alpha Galaxy Survey II. Extinction and NII corrections to H-alpha fluxes
Authors:
P. A. James,
N. S. Shane,
J. H. Knapen,
J. Etherton,
S. M. Percival
Abstract:
We study the two main corrections generally applied to narrow-band H-alpha fluxes from galaxies in order to convert them to star formation rates, namely for NII contamination and for extinction internal to the galaxy. From an imaging study using narrow-band filters, we find the NII and H-alpha emission to be differently distributed. In most disk star formation regions the NII fraction is small,…
▽ More
We study the two main corrections generally applied to narrow-band H-alpha fluxes from galaxies in order to convert them to star formation rates, namely for NII contamination and for extinction internal to the galaxy. From an imaging study using narrow-band filters, we find the NII and H-alpha emission to be differently distributed. In most disk star formation regions the NII fraction is small, whereas some galaxies display a diffuse central component which can be dominated by NII emission. We consider explanations for variations in the NII/H-alpha ratio, including metallicity variations and different excitation mechanisms. We then estimate the extinction towards star formation regions in spiral galaxies, firstly using Br-gamma/H-alpha line ratios. We find that extinction values are larger in galaxy nuclei than in disks, and that there is no evidence for heavily dust-embedded regions emerging in the near-IR. We use optical emission line data from the literature to show only a moderate dependence of extinction on inclination, consistent with broad-band photometric studies; typical extinctions are smaller for late-type dwarfs than for spiral types. Finally, we show that the application of type-dependent extinction corrections significantly improves the agreement between star formation rates from H-alpha and IRAS fluxes. This agreement argues against star formation in normal galaxies being dominated by heavily dust-embedded components.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2004;
originally announced October 2004.
-
The distance to the Pleiades: Main sequence fitting in the near infrared
Authors:
S. M. Percival,
M. Salaris,
M. A. T. Groenewegen
Abstract:
Hipparcos parallax measurements of stars in the Pleiades notoriously result in a cluster distance of 118 pc; ~10% shorter than the `classical' results of MS-fitting. In an earlier paper we developed a purely empirical MS-fitting method to address this problem, which produced conflicting results between the (B-V) and (V-I) colour indices, indicating that the cluster's photometric metallicity is s…
▽ More
Hipparcos parallax measurements of stars in the Pleiades notoriously result in a cluster distance of 118 pc; ~10% shorter than the `classical' results of MS-fitting. In an earlier paper we developed a purely empirical MS-fitting method to address this problem, which produced conflicting results between the (B-V) and (V-I) colour indices, indicating that the cluster's photometric metallicity is substantially lower than its (~solar) spectroscopic metallicity. We were able to reconcile the discrepancy by assuming [Fe/H]=-0.4 (as indicated from (B-V)/(V-I) colour-colour plots), and the distance moduli obtained from the 2 indices were in agreement with the Hipparcos result, within the 1sig errors. With the release of the 2MASS All Sky Catalogue, we now apply our MS-fitting method to the Pleiades using the infrared colours, in order to test the plausibility of our earlier result. Fitting in the V/(V-K) and K/(J-K) colour planes, we find that assuming a subsolar metallicity does not produce distances in agreement with the (B-V) and (V-I) results. However the infrared plus (V-I) distances are in mutual agreement when adopting the spectroscopic metallicity. By considering only stars with Mv<=6, the infrared and optical colour indices all yield consistent distances using the spectroscopic [Fe/H]. The concordant distances thus obtained from the (B-V), (V-I), (V-K) and (J-K) indices yield a mean of 133.8+/-3 pc, in excellent agreement with the pre-Hipparcos MS-fitting results, and the most recent determinations from other methods. We conclude that there are two distinct issues affecting the Pleiades: the Hipparcos parallax is in error by ~10%, as previously claimed; the (B-V) colours of the lower MS are anomalous, and we caution against their use for MS-fitting to the Pleiades and similarly young open clusters. (Abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2004;
originally announced September 2004.
-
The H alpha Galaxy Survey I. The galaxy sample, H alpha narrow-band observations and star formation parameters for 334 galaxies
Authors:
P. A. James,
N. S. Shane,
J. E. Beckman,
A. Cardwell,
C. A. Collins,
J. Etherton,
R. S. de Jong,
K. Fathi,
J. H. Knapen,
R. F. Peletier,
S. M. Percival,
D. L. Pollacco,
M. S. Seigar,
S. Stedman,
I. A. Steele
Abstract:
We discuss the selection and observations of a large sample of nearby galaxies, which we are using to quantify the star formation activity in the local Universe. The sample consists of 334 galaxies across all Hubble types from S0/a to Im and with recession velocities of between 0 and 3000 km/s. The basic data for each galaxy are narrow band H alpha plus [NII] and R-band imaging, from which we de…
▽ More
We discuss the selection and observations of a large sample of nearby galaxies, which we are using to quantify the star formation activity in the local Universe. The sample consists of 334 galaxies across all Hubble types from S0/a to Im and with recession velocities of between 0 and 3000 km/s. The basic data for each galaxy are narrow band H alpha plus [NII] and R-band imaging, from which we derive star formation rates, H alpha plus [NII] equivalent widths and surface brightnesses, and R-band total magnitudes. A strong correlation is found between total star formation rate and Hubble type, with the strongest star formation in isolated galaxies occurring in Sc and Sbc types. More surprisingly, no significant trend is found between H alpha plus [NII] equivalent width and galaxy R-band luminosity. More detailed analyses of the data set presented here will be described in subsequent papers.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2003;
originally announced November 2003.
-
The age of the oldest Open Clusters
Authors:
Maurizio Salaris,
Achim Weiss,
Susan M. Percival
Abstract:
We determine ages of 71 old Open Clusters by a two-step method: we use main-squence fitting to 10 selected clusters, in order to obtain their distances, and derive their ages from comparison with our own isochrones used before for Globular Clusters. We then calibrate the morphological age indicator delta(V), which can be obtained for all remaining clusters, in terms of age and metallicity. Parti…
▽ More
We determine ages of 71 old Open Clusters by a two-step method: we use main-squence fitting to 10 selected clusters, in order to obtain their distances, and derive their ages from comparison with our own isochrones used before for Globular Clusters. We then calibrate the morphological age indicator delta(V), which can be obtained for all remaining clusters, in terms of age and metallicity. Particular care is taken to ensure consistency in the whole procedure. The resulting Open Cluster ages connect well to our previous Globular Cluster results. From the Open Cluster sample, as well as from the combined sample, questions regarding the formation process of Galactic components are addressed. The age of the oldest open clusters (NGC6791 and Be17) is of the order of 10 Gyr. We determine a delay by 2.0+-1.5 Gyr between the start of the halo and thin disk formation, whereas thin and thick disk started to form approximately at the same time. We do not find any significant age-metallicity relationship for the open cluster sample. The cumulative age distribution of the whole open cluster sample shows a moderately significant (~2sigma level) departure from the predictions for an exponentially declining dissolution rate with timescale of 2.5 Gyr. The cumulative age distribution does not show any trend with galactocentric distance, but the clusters with larger height to the Galactic plane have an excess of objects between 2-4 and 6 Gyr with respect to their counterpart closer to the plane of the Galaxy.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2003;
originally announced October 2003.
-
An empirical test of the theoretical population corrections to the Red Clump absolute magnitude
Authors:
Susan M. Percival,
Maurizio Salaris
Abstract:
The mean absolute magnitude of the local red clump (RC) is a very well determined quantity due to the availability of accurate HIPPARCOS parallaxes for several hundred RC stars, potentially allowing it to be used as an accurate extra-galactic distance indicator. Theoretical models predict that the RC mean magnitude has non-linear dependencies on both age and metallicity. This suggests that a pop…
▽ More
The mean absolute magnitude of the local red clump (RC) is a very well determined quantity due to the availability of accurate HIPPARCOS parallaxes for several hundred RC stars, potentially allowing it to be used as an accurate extra-galactic distance indicator. Theoretical models predict that the RC mean magnitude has non-linear dependencies on both age and metallicity. This suggests that a population correction, based on the star formation rate (SFR) and age-metallicity relation (AMR) of a particular system, should be applied to the local RC magnitude before it can be compared to the RC in that system in order to make a meaningful distance determination. Using a sample of 8 Galactic open clusters and the GC 47 Tuc, we determine the cluster distances, and hence the RC absolute magnitude in V, I and K, by applying our empirical main sequence fitting method, which utilizes a large sample of local field dwarfs with accurate HIPPARCOS parallaxes. The age and metallicity range of these 9 clusters enable us to make a quantitative assessment of the age and metallicity dependencies of the population corrections predicted by the theoretical models of Girardi & Salaris (2001). We find excellent agreement between the empirical data and the models in all 3 pass-bands, with no statistically significant trends or offsets, thus fully confirming the applicability of the models to single-age, single-metallicity stellar populations. Since, from the models, the population correction is a complicated function of both metallicity and age, if this method is used to derive distances to composite populations, it is essential to have an accurate assessment of the SFR and AMR of the system in question, if errors of several tenths of a magnitude are to be avoided.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2003;
originally announced April 2003.
-
The Open Cluster Distance Scale: A New Empirical Approach
Authors:
Susan M. Percival,
Maurizio Salaris,
David Kilkenny
Abstract:
We present new BVRI photometry for a sample of 54 local G and K stars with accurate Hipparcos parallaxes in the metallicity range -0.4 < [Fe/H] < +0.3. We use this sample to develop a completely model-independent main sequence (MS) fitting method which we apply to 4 open clusters - the Hyades, Praesepe, the Pleiades and NGC 2516 - which all have direct Hipparcos parallax distance determinations.…
▽ More
We present new BVRI photometry for a sample of 54 local G and K stars with accurate Hipparcos parallaxes in the metallicity range -0.4 < [Fe/H] < +0.3. We use this sample to develop a completely model-independent main sequence (MS) fitting method which we apply to 4 open clusters - the Hyades, Praesepe, the Pleiades and NGC 2516 - which all have direct Hipparcos parallax distance determinations. Comparison of our MS-fitting results with distances derived from Hipparcos parallaxes enables us to explore whether the discrepancy between the Hipparcos distance scale and other MS-fitting methods found for some clusters is a consequence of model assumptions. We find good agreement between our results and the Hipparcos ones for the Hyades and Praesepe. For the Pleiades and NGC 2516, when adopting the solar abundance determined from spectroscopy, we find significant disagreement at a level similar to that found by other MS-fitting studies. However, the colour-colour relationship for both these clusters suggests that their metallicity is significantly subsolar. Since the MS-fitting method relies on matching the cluster colours to a template MS, we argue that, when applying this method, the appropriate metallicity to adopt is the photometric subsolar one, not the solar abundance indicated by spectroscopy. Adopting photometric metallicities for all 4 clusters, we find complete agreement with the Hipparcos results and hence we conclude that the mismatch between the spectroscopic and photometric abundances for the Pleiades and NGC 2516 is responsible for the discrepancies in distance estimates found by previous studies. The origin of this mismatch in abundance scales remains an unsolved problem and some possible causes are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2003;
originally announced January 2003.
-
Resolving the 47 Tucanae Distance Problem
Authors:
Susan M. Percival,
Maurizio Salaris,
Francois van Wyk,
David Kilkenny
Abstract:
Using a sample of 43 suitable local subdwarfs with newly acquired BVI photometry, we apply our main sequence fitting method to the metal rich Globular Cluster 47 Tucanae. Fitting in 2 colour planes, we find an apparent distance modulus of (m-M)v = 13.37 (+0.10/-0.11), leading to a dereddened distance modulus of (m-M)o = 13.25 (+0.06/-0.07). Consideration of the Red Clump in the cluster produces…
▽ More
Using a sample of 43 suitable local subdwarfs with newly acquired BVI photometry, we apply our main sequence fitting method to the metal rich Globular Cluster 47 Tucanae. Fitting in 2 colour planes, we find an apparent distance modulus of (m-M)v = 13.37 (+0.10/-0.11), leading to a dereddened distance modulus of (m-M)o = 13.25 (+0.06/-0.07). Consideration of the Red Clump in the cluster produces a distance modulus fully consistent with this result. The implied cluster age is 11 (+/-1.4) Gyr.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2002;
originally announced September 2002.
-
Resolving the 47 Tucanae Distance Problem
Authors:
Susan M. Percival,
Maurizio Salaris,
Francois van Wyk,
David Kilkenny
Abstract:
We present new B, V and I-band photometry for a sample of 43 local subdwarfs with HIPPARCOS parallax errors < 13%, in the metallicity range -1.0 < [Fe/H] < -0.3, which we use to perform main sequence (MS) fitting to the Galactic globular cluster 47 Tuc. This sample is many times larger than those used in previous MS-fitting studies and also enables us to fit in two colour planes, V/(B-V) and V/(…
▽ More
We present new B, V and I-band photometry for a sample of 43 local subdwarfs with HIPPARCOS parallax errors < 13%, in the metallicity range -1.0 < [Fe/H] < -0.3, which we use to perform main sequence (MS) fitting to the Galactic globular cluster 47 Tuc. This sample is many times larger than those used in previous MS-fitting studies and also enables us to fit in two colour planes, V/(B-V) and V/(V-I). With this enlarged subdwarf sample we investigate whether the current discrepancy in empirical distance estimates for 47 Tuc, arising from recent MS-fitting and white dwarf fitting results, is due to inaccuracies in the MS-fitting method. Comparison of published photometries for 47 Tuc has revealed systematic offsets which mean that the $(B-V)$ main-line used in previous studies may be too blue by ~ 0.02 mag. We have derived main-lines in V/(B-V) and V/(V-I) from the data of Kaluzny et al. (1998), which we have recalibrated from the `secondary' standards in 47 Tuc of Stetson (2000). Using an assumed cluster reddening of E(B-V)=0.04, our best-fit apparent distance modulus is (m-M)V=13.37 (+0.10)(-0.11) in both colour planes, which implies a cluster age of 11.0 +/-1.4 Gyr and leads to a dereddened distance modulus of (m-M)0=13.25 (+0.06)(-0.07). Comparison with previous work shows that our apparent distance modulus is ~0.2 mag smaller than those derived in previous MS-fitting studies. The difference is accounted for by our preferred cluster reddening and the recalibration of the cluster photometry, which has made the main-line redder by an average of 0.02 mag in (B-V). Independent support for our MS-fitting distance comes from consideration of the Red Clump in the cluster, from which we derive a dereddened distance modulus of (m-M)0=13.31 +/-0.05, which is in agreement with the MS-fitting result. (Abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2002;
originally announced March 2002.
