-
Sails and Anchors: The Complementarity of Exploratory and Exploitative Scientists in Knowledge Creation
Authors:
Pierre Pelletier,
Kevin Wirtz
Abstract:
This paper investigates the relationship between scientists' cognitive profile and their ability to generate innovative ideas and gain scientific recognition. We propose a novel author-level metric based on the semantic representation of researchers' past publications to measure cognitive diversity both at individual and team levels. Using PubMed Knowledge Graph (PKG), we analyze the impact of cog…
▽ More
This paper investigates the relationship between scientists' cognitive profile and their ability to generate innovative ideas and gain scientific recognition. We propose a novel author-level metric based on the semantic representation of researchers' past publications to measure cognitive diversity both at individual and team levels. Using PubMed Knowledge Graph (PKG), we analyze the impact of cognitive diversity on novelty, as measured by combinatorial novelty indicators and peer labels on Faculty Opinion. We assessed scientific impact through citations and disruption indicators. We show that the presence of exploratory individuals (i.e., cognitively diverse) is beneficial in generating distant knowledge combinations, but only when balanced by a significant proportion of exploitative individuals (i.e., cognitively specialized). Furthermore, teams with a high proportion of exploitative profiles tend to consolidate science, whereas those with a significant share of both profiles tend to disrupt it. Cognitive diversity between team members appears to be always beneficial to combining more distant knowledge. However, to maximize the relevance of these distant combinations of knowledge, maintaining a limited number of exploratory individuals is essential, as exploitative individuals must question and debate their novel perspectives. These specialized individuals are the most qualified to extract the full potential of novel ideas and integrate them within the existing scientific paradigm.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Drivers and Barriers of AI Adoption and Use in Scientific Research
Authors:
Stefano Bianchini,
Moritz Müller,
Pierre Pelletier
Abstract:
New technologies have the power to revolutionize science. It has happened in the past and is happening again with the emergence of new computational tools, such as artificial intelligence and machine learning. Despite the documented impact of these technologies, there remains a significant gap in understanding the process of their adoption within the scientific community. In this paper, we draw on…
▽ More
New technologies have the power to revolutionize science. It has happened in the past and is happening again with the emergence of new computational tools, such as artificial intelligence and machine learning. Despite the documented impact of these technologies, there remains a significant gap in understanding the process of their adoption within the scientific community. In this paper, we draw on theories of scientific and technical human capital to study the integration of AI in scientific research, focusing on the human capital of scientists and the external resources available within their network of collaborators and institutions. We validate our hypotheses on a large sample of publications from OpenAlex, covering all sciences from 1980 to 2020, and identify a set key drivers and inhibitors of AI adoption and use in science. Our results suggest that AI is pioneered by domain scientists with a `taste for exploration' and who are embedded in a network rich of computer scientists, experienced AI scientists and early-career researchers; they come from institutions with high citation impact and a relatively strong publication history on AI. The access to computing resources only matters for a few scientific disciplines, such as chemistry and medical sciences. Once AI is integrated into research, most adoption factors continue to influence its subsequent reuse. Implications for the organization and management of science in the evolving era of AI-driven discovery are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2024; v1 submitted 15 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Anderson mobility edge as a percolation transition
Authors:
Marcel Filoche,
Pierre Pelletier,
Dominique Delande,
Svitlana Mayboroda
Abstract:
The location of the mobility edge is a long standing problem in Anderson localization. In this paper, we show that the effective confining potential introduced in the localization landscape (LL) theory predicts the onset of delocalization in 3D tight-binding models, in a large part of the energy-disorder diagram. Near the edge of the spectrum, the eigenstates are confined inside the basins of the…
▽ More
The location of the mobility edge is a long standing problem in Anderson localization. In this paper, we show that the effective confining potential introduced in the localization landscape (LL) theory predicts the onset of delocalization in 3D tight-binding models, in a large part of the energy-disorder diagram. Near the edge of the spectrum, the eigenstates are confined inside the basins of the LL-based potential. The delocalization transition corresponds to the progressive merging of these basins resulting in the percolation of this classically-allowed region throughout the system. This approach, shown to be valid both in the cases of uniform and binary disorders despite their very different phase diagrams, allows us to reinterpret the Anderson transition in the tight-binding model: the mobility edge appears to be composed of two parts, one being understood as a percolation transition.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2024; v1 submitted 7 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Novelpy: A Python package to measure novelty and disruptiveness of bibliometric and patent data
Authors:
Pierre Pelletier,
Kevin Wirtz
Abstract:
Novelpy (v1.2) is an open-source Python package designed to compute bibliometrics indicators. The package aims to provide a tool to the scientometrics community that centralizes different measures of novelty and disruptiveness, enables their comparison and fosters reproducibility. This paper offers a comprehensive review of the different indicators available in Novelpy by formally describing these…
▽ More
Novelpy (v1.2) is an open-source Python package designed to compute bibliometrics indicators. The package aims to provide a tool to the scientometrics community that centralizes different measures of novelty and disruptiveness, enables their comparison and fosters reproducibility. This paper offers a comprehensive review of the different indicators available in Novelpy by formally describing these measures (both mathematically and graphically) and presenting their benefits and limitations. We then compare the different measures on a random sample of 1.5M articles drawn from Pubmed Knowledge Graph to demonstrate the module's capabilities. We encourage anyone interested to participate in the development of future versions.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Wigner-Weyl description of light absorption in disordered semiconductor alloys using the localization landscape theory
Authors:
Jean-Philippe Banon,
Pierre Pelletier,
Claude Weisbuch,
Svitlana Mayboroda,
Marcel Filoche
Abstract:
The presence of disorder in semiconductors can dramatically change their physical properties. Yet, models faithfully accounting for it are still scarce and computationally inefficient. We present a mathematical and computational model able to simulate the optoelectronic response of semiconductor alloys of several tens of nanometer sidelength, while at the same time accounting for the quantum local…
▽ More
The presence of disorder in semiconductors can dramatically change their physical properties. Yet, models faithfully accounting for it are still scarce and computationally inefficient. We present a mathematical and computational model able to simulate the optoelectronic response of semiconductor alloys of several tens of nanometer sidelength, while at the same time accounting for the quantum localization effects induced by the compositional disorder at the nano-scale. The model is based on a Wigner-Weyl analysis of the structure of electron and hole eigenstates in phase space made possible by the localization landscape theory. After validation against eigenstates-based computations in 1D and 2D, our model is applied to the computation of light absorption in 3D InGaN alloys of different compositions. We obtain the detailed structures of the absorption tail below the average bandgap and the Urbach energies of all simulated compositions. Moreover, the Wigner-Weyl formalism allows us to define and compute 3D maps of the effective locally absorbed power at all frequencies. Finally the proposed approach opens the way to generalize this method to all energy-exchange processes such as radiative and non-radiative recombination in realistic devices.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2022; v1 submitted 13 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Spectral functions and localization landscape theory in speckle potentials
Authors:
Pierre Pelletier,
Dominique Delande,
Vincent Josse,
Alain Aspect,
Svitlana Mayboroda,
Douglas Arnold,
Marcel Filoche
Abstract:
Spectral function is a key tool for understanding the behavior of Bose-Einstein condensates of cold atoms in random potentials generated by a laser speckle. In this paper we introduce a new method for computing the spectral functions in disordered potentials. Using a combination of the Wigner-Weyl approach with the landscape theory, we build an approximation for the Wigner distributions of the eig…
▽ More
Spectral function is a key tool for understanding the behavior of Bose-Einstein condensates of cold atoms in random potentials generated by a laser speckle. In this paper we introduce a new method for computing the spectral functions in disordered potentials. Using a combination of the Wigner-Weyl approach with the landscape theory, we build an approximation for the Wigner distributions of the eigenstates in the phase space and show its accuracy in all regimes, from the deep quantum regime to the intermediate and semiclassical. Based on this approximation, we devise a method to compute the spectral functions using only the landscape-based effective potential. The paper demonstrates the efficiency of the proposed approach for disordered potentials with various statistical properties without requiring any adjustable parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Global health science leverages established collaboration network to fight COVID-19
Authors:
Stefano Bianchini,
Moritz Müller,
Pierre Pelletier,
Kevin Wirtz
Abstract:
How has the science system reacted to the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic? Here we compare the (growing) international network for coronavirus research with the broader international health science network. Our findings show that, before the outbreak, coronavirus research realized a relatively small and rather peculiar niche within the global health sciences. As a response to the pandemic, t…
▽ More
How has the science system reacted to the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic? Here we compare the (growing) international network for coronavirus research with the broader international health science network. Our findings show that, before the outbreak, coronavirus research realized a relatively small and rather peculiar niche within the global health sciences. As a response to the pandemic, the international network for coronavirus research expanded rapidly along the hierarchical structure laid out by the global health science network. Thus, in face of the crisis, the global health science system proved to be structurally stable yet versatile in research. The observed versatility supports optimistic views on the role of science in meeting future challenges. However, the stability of the global core-periphery structure may be worrying, because it reduces learning opportunities and social capital of scientifically peripheral countries -- not only during this pandemic but also in its "normal" mode of operation.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Deep Learning in Science
Authors:
Stefano Bianchini,
Moritz Müller,
Pierre Pelletier
Abstract:
Much of the recent success of Artificial Intelligence (AI) has been spurred on by impressive achievements within a broader family of machine learning methods, commonly referred to as Deep Learning (DL). This paper provides insights on the diffusion and impact of DL in science. Through a Natural Language Processing (NLP) approach on the arXiv.org publication corpus, we delineate the emerging DL tec…
▽ More
Much of the recent success of Artificial Intelligence (AI) has been spurred on by impressive achievements within a broader family of machine learning methods, commonly referred to as Deep Learning (DL). This paper provides insights on the diffusion and impact of DL in science. Through a Natural Language Processing (NLP) approach on the arXiv.org publication corpus, we delineate the emerging DL technology and identify a list of relevant search terms. These search terms allow us to retrieve DL-related publications from Web of Science across all sciences. Based on that sample, we document the DL diffusion process in the scientific system. We find i) an exponential growth in the adoption of DL as a research tool across all sciences and all over the world, ii) regional differentiation in DL application domains, and iii) a transition from interdisciplinary DL applications to disciplinary research within application domains. In a second step, we investigate how the adoption of DL methods affects scientific development. Therefore, we empirically assess how DL adoption relates to re-combinatorial novelty and scientific impact in the health sciences. We find that DL adoption is negatively correlated with re-combinatorial novelty, but positively correlated with expectation as well as variance of citation performance. Our findings suggest that DL does not (yet?) work as an autopilot to navigate complex knowledge landscapes and overthrow their structure. However, the 'DL principle' qualifies for its versatility as the nucleus of a general scientific method that advances science in a measurable way.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2020; v1 submitted 3 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.