-
Bulk and fracture process zone contribution to the rate-dependent adhesion amplification in viscoelastic broad-band materials
Authors:
Ali Maghami,
Qingao Wang,
Michele Tricarico,
Michele Ciavarella,
Qunyang Li,
Antonio Papangelo
Abstract:
The contact between a rigid Hertzian indenter and an adhesive broad-band viscoelastic substrate is considered. The material behaviour is described by a modified power law model, which is characterized by only four parameters, the glassy and rubbery elastic moduli, a characteristic exponent n and a timescale $τ_0$. The maximum adherence force that can be reached while unloading the rigid indenter f…
▽ More
The contact between a rigid Hertzian indenter and an adhesive broad-band viscoelastic substrate is considered. The material behaviour is described by a modified power law model, which is characterized by only four parameters, the glassy and rubbery elastic moduli, a characteristic exponent n and a timescale $τ_0$. The maximum adherence force that can be reached while unloading the rigid indenter from a relaxed viscoelastic half-space is studied by means of a numerical implementation based on the boundary element method, as a function of the unloading velocity, preload and by varying the broadness of the viscoelastic material spectrum. Through a comprehensive numerical analysis we have determined the minimum contact radius that is needed to achieve the maximum amplification of the pull-off force at a specified unloading rate and for different material exponents n. The numerical results are then compared with the prediction of Persson and Brener viscoelastic crack propagation theory, providing excellent agreement. However, comparison against experimental tests for a glass lens indenting a PDMS substrate show data can be fitted with the linear theory only up to an unloading rate of about $100 \textrm{ $μ$}$m/s showing the fracture process zone rate-dependent contribution to the energy enhancement is of the same order of the bulk dissipation contribution. Hence, the limitations of the current numerical and theoretical models for viscoelastic adhesion are discussed in light of the most recent literature results.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Viscoelastic amplification of the pull-off stress in the detachment of a rigid flat punch from an adhesive soft viscoelastic layer
Authors:
Ali Maghami,
Michele Ciavarella,
Antonio Papangelo
Abstract:
The problem of the detachment of a sufficiently large flat indenter from a plane adhesive viscoelastic strip of thickness "b" is studied. For any given retraction speed, three different detachment regimes are found: (i) for very small "b" the detachment stress is constant and equal to the theoretical strength of the interface, (ii) for intermediate values of "b" the detachment stress decays approx…
▽ More
The problem of the detachment of a sufficiently large flat indenter from a plane adhesive viscoelastic strip of thickness "b" is studied. For any given retraction speed, three different detachment regimes are found: (i) for very small "b" the detachment stress is constant and equal to the theoretical strength of the interface, (ii) for intermediate values of "b" the detachment stress decays approximately as b^(-1/2), (iii) for thick layers a constant detachment stress is obtained corresponding to case the punch is detaching from a halfplane. By using the boundary element method a comprehensive numerical study is performed which assumes a linear viscoelastic material with a single relaxation time and a Lennard-Jones force-separation law. Pull-off stress is found to consistently and monotonically increase with unloading rate, but to be almost insensitive to the history of the contact. Due to viscoelasticity, unloading at high enough retraction velocity may allow punches of macroscopic size to reach the theoretical strength of the interface. Finally, a corrective term in Greenwood or Persson theories considering finite size effects is proposed. Theoretical and numerical results are found in very good agreement.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2024; v1 submitted 11 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
A two-scale FEM-BAM approach for fingerpad friction under electroadhesion
Authors:
Fabian Forsbach,
Markus Heß,
Antonio Papangelo
Abstract:
The complex physics behind electroadhesion-based tactile displays poses an enormous modeling challenge since not only the fingerpad structure with multiple nonlinear layers, but also the roughness at the microscopic scale play a decisive role. To investigate tactile perception, a potential model should also offer the possibility to extract mechanical stimuli at the sites of the relevant mechanorec…
▽ More
The complex physics behind electroadhesion-based tactile displays poses an enormous modeling challenge since not only the fingerpad structure with multiple nonlinear layers, but also the roughness at the microscopic scale play a decisive role. To investigate tactile perception, a potential model should also offer the possibility to extract mechanical stimuli at the sites of the relevant mechanoreceptors. In this paper, we present a two-scale approach that involves a finite element model (FEM) at the macroscopic scale and a simple bearing area model (BAM) that accounts for the measured roughness on the papillary ridges. Both separate scales couple in an iterative way using the concept of an equivalent air gap. We show that the electroadhesion-induced changes in friction and contact area predicted by the proposed model are in qualitative agreement with recent experimental studies. In a simple example, we demonstrate that the model can readily be extended by a neural dynamics model to investigate the tactile perception of electroadhesion.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Detachment of a rigid flat punch from a viscoelastic material
Authors:
Antonio Papangelo,
Michele Ciavarella
Abstract:
We show that the detachment of a flat punch from a viscoelastic substrate has a relatively simple behavior, framed between the Kendall's elastic solution at the relaxed modulus and at the instantaneous modulus, and the cohesive strength limit. We find hardly any dependence of the pull-off force on the details of the loading process, including maximum indentation at preload and loading rate, result…
▽ More
We show that the detachment of a flat punch from a viscoelastic substrate has a relatively simple behavior, framed between the Kendall's elastic solution at the relaxed modulus and at the instantaneous modulus, and the cohesive strength limit. We find hardly any dependence of the pull-off force on the details of the loading process, including maximum indentation at preload and loading rate, resulting much simpler than the case of a spherical punch. Pull-off force peaks at the highest speeds of unloading, when energy dissipation is negligible, which seems to be in contrast with what suggested by the theories originated by de Gennes of viscoelastic semi-infinite crack propagation which associated enhanced work of adhesion to dissipation. Further qualitative differences with the dissipation-based model occur to explain the finite size effect.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2023; v1 submitted 24 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Stickiness of randomly rough surfaces with high fractal dimension: is there a fractal limit?
Authors:
G. Violano,
A. Papangelo,
M. Ciavarella
Abstract:
Two surfaces are "sticky" if breaking their mutual contact requires a finite tensile force. At low fractal dimensions D, there is consensus stickiness does not depend on the upper truncation frequency of roughness spectrum (or "magnification"). As debate is still open for the case at high D, we exploit BAM theory of Ciavarella and Persson-Tosatti theory, to derive criteria for all fractal dimensio…
▽ More
Two surfaces are "sticky" if breaking their mutual contact requires a finite tensile force. At low fractal dimensions D, there is consensus stickiness does not depend on the upper truncation frequency of roughness spectrum (or "magnification"). As debate is still open for the case at high D, we exploit BAM theory of Ciavarella and Persson-Tosatti theory, to derive criteria for all fractal dimensions. For high D, we show that stickiness is more influenced by short wavelength roughness with respect to the low D case. BAM converges at high magnifications to a simple criterion which depends only on D, in agreement with theories that includes Lennard-Jones traction-gap law, while Persson-Tosatti disagrees because of its simplifying approximations.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
A comment on "Discussion on the use of the strain energy release rate for fatigue delamination characterization"
Authors:
M. Ciavarella,
A. Papangelo,
G. Cricri
Abstract:
In a recent very interesting and illuminating proposal, Yao et al. (2014) have discussed the use of the strain energy release rate (SERR) as a parameter to characterize fatigue delamination growth in composite materials. They consider fatigue delamination data strongly affected by R-curve behaviour due to fibres bridging and argue that a better approach is to correlate the crack advance with the t…
▽ More
In a recent very interesting and illuminating proposal, Yao et al. (2014) have discussed the use of the strain energy release rate (SERR) as a parameter to characterize fatigue delamination growth in composite materials. They consider fatigue delamination data strongly affected by R-curve behaviour due to fibres bridging and argue that a better approach is to correlate the crack advance with the total work per cycle measured in the testing machine. This seems to work better than estimating the compliance as a linear fit of experimental curves from Modified Compliance Calibration ASTM standards equations for the SERR in the classical Linear Elastic Fracture Mechanics framework. We show however that if we assume indeed linear behaviour (i.e. LEFM), the approach they introduce is perfectly equivalent to the SERR one, i.e. Paris type of laws. As well known form Barenblatt and Botvina, fatigue crack growth is a weak form of scaling, and it gives Paris classical dependence only when the crack is much longer than any other characteristic sizes. Paris' law is not a fundamental law of physics, is not an energy balance equation like Griffith, and strong size effects due to cohesive zones have been found already in concrete by Bazant. The proposal is very simple, and interesting as it would seem to suggest that a proper scaling with a cohesive model at crack tip could be predicted, although this doesn't seem to have been attempted in the Literature. The main drawback of the present proposal is that it is not predictive, but purely observational, as it requires the actual measurement of work input during the fatigue process.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Shear-induced contact area anisotropy explained by a fracture mechanics model
Authors:
A. Papangelo,
J. Scheibert,
R. Sahli,
G. Pallares,
M. Ciavarella
Abstract:
This paper gives a theoretical analysis for the fundamental problem of anisotropy induced by shear forces onan adhesive contact, discussing the experimental data of the companion Letter. We present a fracture mechanicsmodel where two phenomenological mode-mixity functions are introduced to describe the weak couplingbetween modes I and II or I and III, which changes the effective toughness of the i…
▽ More
This paper gives a theoretical analysis for the fundamental problem of anisotropy induced by shear forces onan adhesive contact, discussing the experimental data of the companion Letter. We present a fracture mechanicsmodel where two phenomenological mode-mixity functions are introduced to describe the weak couplingbetween modes I and II or I and III, which changes the effective toughness of the interface. The mode-mixityfunctions have been interpolated using the data of a single experiment and then used to predict the behavior of thewhole set of experimental observations. The model extends an idea by Johnson and Greenwood, to solve purelymode I problems of adhesion in the presence of a nonaxisymmetric Hertzian geometry, to the case of ellipticalcontacts sheared along their major or minor axis. Equality between the stress intensity factors and their criticalvalues is imposed solely at the major and minor axes. We successfully validate our model against experimentaldata. The model predicts that the punch geometry will affect both the shape and the overall decay of the shearedcontact area.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Shear-Induced Anisotropy in Rough Elastomer Contact
Authors:
R. Sahli,
G. Pallares,
A. Papangelo,
M. Ciavarella,
C. Ducottet,
N. Ponthus,
J. Scheibert
Abstract:
True contact between randomly rough solids consists of myriad individual micro-junctions. While their total area controls the adhesive friction force of the interface, other macroscopic features, including viscoelastic friction, wear, stiffness and electric resistance, also strongly depend on the size and shape of individual micro-junctions. Here we show that, in rough elastomer contacts, the shap…
▽ More
True contact between randomly rough solids consists of myriad individual micro-junctions. While their total area controls the adhesive friction force of the interface, other macroscopic features, including viscoelastic friction, wear, stiffness and electric resistance, also strongly depend on the size and shape of individual micro-junctions. Here we show that, in rough elastomer contacts, the shape of micro-junctions significantly varies as a function of the shear force applied to the interface. This process leads to a growth of anisotropy of the overall contact interface, which saturates in macroscopic sliding regime. We show that smooth sphere/plane contacts have the same shear-induced anisotropic behaviour as individual micro-junctions, with a common scaling law over four orders of magnitude in initial area. We discuss the physical origin of the observations in the light of a fracture-based adhesive contact mechanics model, described in the companion article, which captures the smooth sphere/plane measurements. Our results shed light on a generic, overlooked source of anisotropy in rough elastic contacts, not taken into account in current rough contact mechanics models.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Nucleation and propagation of excitation fronts in self-excited systems
Authors:
I. B. Shiroky,
A. Papangelo,
N. Hoffmann,
O. V. Gendelman
Abstract:
Frictional interfaces exhibits a very rich dynamical behavior due to frictional interactions. This work focuses on the transition between spatially localized and propagating stick-slip motion. To overcome the difficulties related to the non-smoothness of the friction law we have studied two models: (model I) a friction-excited chain of weakly coupled oscillators excited by a frictional moving belt…
▽ More
Frictional interfaces exhibits a very rich dynamical behavior due to frictional interactions. This work focuses on the transition between spatially localized and propagating stick-slip motion. To overcome the difficulties related to the non-smoothness of the friction law we have studied two models: (model I) a friction-excited chain of weakly coupled oscillators excited by a frictional moving belt and (model II) a chain of Van der Pol oscillators. The two models show very similar dynamical features. Both exhibit discrete breathers (i.e. spatially localized periodic solutions) solutions for low coupling and show propagation along the chain of high amplitude limit cycles for stronger elastic coupling between the unit cells. In both models the transition from discrete breathers to propagating limit cycles happens through a nucleation process and, above a certain critical coupling, the velocity of propagation scales linearly with the elastic coupling coefficient. We suggest that dynamical features similar to what was demonstrated in this work are expected for models that are different quantitatively but preserve the same single-unit topology.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
On stickiness of multiscale randomly rough surfaces
Authors:
G. Violano,
L. Afferrante,
A. Papangelo,
M. Ciavarella
Abstract:
We derive a very simple and effective stickiness criterion for solids having random roughness using a new asymptotic theory, which we validate with that of Persson and Scaraggi and independent numerical experiments. Previous claims that stickiness may depend on small scale quantities such as rms slopes and/or curvatures, obtained by making oversimplified assumptions on the contact area geometry, a…
▽ More
We derive a very simple and effective stickiness criterion for solids having random roughness using a new asymptotic theory, which we validate with that of Persson and Scaraggi and independent numerical experiments. Previous claims that stickiness may depend on small scale quantities such as rms slopes and/or curvatures, obtained by making oversimplified assumptions on the contact area geometry, are largely incorrect, as the truncation of the PSD spectrum of roughness at short wavelengths is irrelevant. We find stickiness is destroyed typically at roughness amplitudes up to three orders of magnitude larger than the range of attractive forces. With typical nanometer values of the latter, the criterion gives justification to the qualitative well known empirical Dalhquist criterion for stickiness which demands adhesives to have elastic modulus lower than about 1MPa. The results clarifies a much debated question in both the scientific and technological world of adhesion, and may serve as benchmark for better comprehension of the role of roughness.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Multistability and localization in forced cyclic symmetric structures modelled by weakly-coupled Duffing oscillators
Authors:
A. Papangelo,
F. Fontanela,
A. Grolet,
M. Ciavarella,
N. Hoffmann
Abstract:
Many engineering structures are composed of weakly coupled sectors assembled in a cyclic and ideally symmetric configuration, which can be simplified as forced Duffing oscillators. In this paper, we study the emergence of localized states in the weakly nonlinear regime. We show that multiple spatially localized solutions may exist, and the resulting bifurcation diagram strongly resembles the snaki…
▽ More
Many engineering structures are composed of weakly coupled sectors assembled in a cyclic and ideally symmetric configuration, which can be simplified as forced Duffing oscillators. In this paper, we study the emergence of localized states in the weakly nonlinear regime. We show that multiple spatially localized solutions may exist, and the resulting bifurcation diagram strongly resembles the snaking pattern observed in a variety of fields in physics, such as optics and fluid dynamics. Moreover, in the transition from the linear to the nonlinear behaviour isolated branches of solutions are identified. Localization is caused by the hardening effect introduced by the nonlinear stiffness, and occurs at large excitation levels. Contrary to the case of mistuning, the presented localization mechanism is triggered by the nonlinearities and arises in perfectly homogeneous systems.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
The role of adhesion in contact mechanics
Authors:
M. Ciavarella,
J. Joe,
A. Papangelo,
JR Barber
Abstract:
Adhesive [e.g. van der Waals] forces were not generally taken into account in contact mechanics until 1971, when Johnson, Kendall and Roberts (JKR) generalized Hertz' solution for an elastic sphere using an energetic argument which we now recognize to be analogous to that used in linear elastic fracture mechanics. A significant result is that the load-displacement relation exhibits instabilities i…
▽ More
Adhesive [e.g. van der Waals] forces were not generally taken into account in contact mechanics until 1971, when Johnson, Kendall and Roberts (JKR) generalized Hertz' solution for an elastic sphere using an energetic argument which we now recognize to be analogous to that used in linear elastic fracture mechanics. A significant result is that the load-displacement relation exhibits instabilities in which approaching bodies `jump in' to contact, whereas separated bodies `jump out' at a tensile `pull-off force'. The JKR approach has since been widely used in other geometries, but at small length scales or for stiffer materials it is found to be less accurate. In conformal contact problems, other instabilities can occur, characterized by the development of regular patterns of regions of large and small traction. All these instabilities result in differences between loading and unloading curves and consequent hysteretic energy losses. Adhesive contact mechanics has become increasingly important in recent years with the focus on soft materials [which generally permit larger areas of the interacting surfaces to come within the range of adhesive forces], nano-devices and the analysis of bio-systems. Applications are found in nature, such as insect attachment forces, in nano-manufacturing, and more generally in industrial systems involving rubber or polymer contacts. In this paper, we review the strengths and limitations of various methods for analyzing contact problems involving adhesive tractions, with particular reference to the effect of the inevitable roughness of the contacting surfaces.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
On mixed-mode fracture mechanics models for contact area reduction under shear load in soft materials
Authors:
A. Papangelo,
M. Ciavarella
Abstract:
The fundamental problem of friction in the presence of macroscopic adhesion, as in soft bodies, is receiving interest from many experimentalists. Since the first fracture mechanics `purely brittle' model of Savkoor and Briggs, models have been proposed where the mixed mode toughness is interpreted with phenomenological fitting coefficients introducing weaker coupling between modes than expected by…
▽ More
The fundamental problem of friction in the presence of macroscopic adhesion, as in soft bodies, is receiving interest from many experimentalists. Since the first fracture mechanics `purely brittle' model of Savkoor and Briggs, models have been proposed where the mixed mode toughness is interpreted with phenomenological fitting coefficients introducing weaker coupling between modes than expected by the "purely brittle" model. We compare here two such previously proposed models and introduce a third one to show that the transition to sliding is very sensitive to the form of the mixed-mode model. In particular, after a quadratic decay of the contact area with load for modest tangential loads, there could be an inflexion point and an asymptotic limit, or a jump to the Hertzian contact area. We find also that the unstable points are different under load or displacement control. The idea that the mixed mode function and parameter should be an interface property may be erroneous.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Ultrastrong adhesion in the contact with thin elastic layers on a rigid foundation
Authors:
M. Ciavarella,
A. Papangelo
Abstract:
In the present short note, we generalize simple approximate Johnson-Jaffar-Barber solutions for the indentation by a rigid punch of a thin elastic layer on a rigid foundation to the case of adhesion. This could be an interesting geometry for an adhesive system, a limit case of the more general class of layered systems, or FGMs (Functionally Graded Materials). We show that ultrastrong adhesion (up…
▽ More
In the present short note, we generalize simple approximate Johnson-Jaffar-Barber solutions for the indentation by a rigid punch of a thin elastic layer on a rigid foundation to the case of adhesion. This could be an interesting geometry for an adhesive system, a limit case of the more general class of layered systems, or FGMs (Functionally Graded Materials). We show that ultrastrong adhesion (up to theoretical strength) can be reached both in line contact or in axisymmetric contact for thin layers (typically of nanoscale size), which suggests a new possible strategy for "optimal adhesion". In particular, in line contact adhesion enhancement occurs as an increase of the actual pull-off force, while in axisymmetric case the latter is apparently very close to the classical JKR case. However, it appears in closer examination that also for axisymmetric case, the enhancement occurs by reducing the size of contact needed to sustain the pull-off force. These effects are further enhanced by Poisson's ratio effects in the case of nearly incompressible layer.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Adhesion of surfaces with wavy roughness and a shallow depression
Authors:
Michele Ciavarella,
Antonio Papangelo
Abstract:
Recently, a simple and elegant "dimple" model was introduced by McMeeking et al. (Adv Eng Mat 12(5), 389-397, 2010) to show a mechanism for a bistable adhesive system involving a surface with a shallow depression. The system shows, at least for intermediate levels of stickiness, that external pressure can switch the system into a "strong adhesive" regime of full contact, or into weak adhesion and…
▽ More
Recently, a simple and elegant "dimple" model was introduced by McMeeking et al. (Adv Eng Mat 12(5), 389-397, 2010) to show a mechanism for a bistable adhesive system involving a surface with a shallow depression. The system shows, at least for intermediate levels of stickiness, that external pressure can switch the system into a "strong adhesive" regime of full contact, or into weak adhesion and complete pull-off, similarly to the contact of surfaces with a single scale of periodical waviness. We add to this model the effect of roughness, in the simple form of axisymmetric single scale of waviness, permitting a very detailed study, and we show that this induces a resistance to jum** into full contact on one hand (limiting the "strong adhesion" regime), and an enhancement of pull-off and of hysteresis starting from the partial contact state on the other (enhancing the "weak adhesion" regime). We show the system depends only on two dimensionless parameters, depending on the ratio of work of adhesion to the energy to flatten the dimple or waviness, respectively. The system becomes pressure-sensitive also in the intermediate states, as it is observed in real adhesive rough systems. The model obviously is specular to the Guduru model of rough spheres (Guduru, JMPS, 55, 473--488, 2007), with which it shares the limitations of the analysis assuming a connected contact (crack) area, and serves also the purpose of showing the effect of a depression into an otherwise periodic rough contact, towards the understanding of adhesion with multiple scales of roughness.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Fracture Mechanics implications for apparent static friction coefficient in contact problems involving slip-weakening laws
Authors:
A. Papangelo,
M. Ciavarella,
J. R. Barber
Abstract:
We consider the effect of differing coefficients of static and dynamic friction coefficients on the behaviour of contacts involving microslip. The classic solutions of Cattaneo and Mindlin are unchanged if the transition in coefficients is abrupt, but if it occurs over some small slip distance, the solution has some mathematical similarities with those governing the normal tractions in adhesive co…
▽ More
We consider the effect of differing coefficients of static and dynamic friction coefficients on the behaviour of contacts involving microslip. The classic solutions of Cattaneo and Mindlin are unchanged if the transition in coefficients is abrupt, but if it occurs over some small slip distance, the solution has some mathematical similarities with those governing the normal tractions in adhesive contact problems. In particular, if the transition to dynamic slip occurs over a sufficiently small area, we can identify a `JKR' approximation, where the transition region is condensed to a line. A local singularity in shear traction is then predicted, with a stress-intensity factor that is proportional to the the square root of the local contact pressure and to a certain integral of the friction coefficient-slip distance relation. We can also define an equivalent of the `small-scale yielding' criterion, which enables us to assess when the singular solution provides a good approximation. One consequence of the results is that the static coefficient of friction determined from force measurements in experiments is significantly smaller than the value that holds at the microscale.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
