-
Deep Learning for Causal Inference: A Comparison of Architectures for Heterogeneous Treatment Effect Estimation
Authors:
Demetrios Papakostas,
Andrew Herren,
P. Richard Hahn,
Francisco Castillo
Abstract:
Causal inference has gained much popularity in recent years, with interests ranging from academic, to industrial, to educational, and all in between. Concurrently, the study and usage of neural networks has also grown profoundly (albeit at a far faster rate). What we aim to do in this blog write-up is demonstrate a Neural Network causal inference architecture. We develop a fully connected neural n…
▽ More
Causal inference has gained much popularity in recent years, with interests ranging from academic, to industrial, to educational, and all in between. Concurrently, the study and usage of neural networks has also grown profoundly (albeit at a far faster rate). What we aim to do in this blog write-up is demonstrate a Neural Network causal inference architecture. We develop a fully connected neural network implementation of the popular Bayesian Causal Forest algorithm, a state of the art tree based method for estimating heterogeneous treatment effects. We compare our implementation to existing neural network causal inference methodologies, showing improvements in performance in simulation settings. We apply our method to a dataset examining the effect of stress on sleep.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Do forecasts of bankruptcy cause bankruptcy? A machine learning sensitivity analysis
Authors:
Demetrios Papakostas,
P. Richard Hahn,
Jared Murray,
Frank Zhou,
Joseph Gerakos
Abstract:
It is widely speculated that auditors' public forecasts of bankruptcy are, at least in part, self-fulfilling prophecies in the sense that they might actually cause bankruptcies that would not have otherwise occurred. This conjecture is hard to prove, however, because the strong association between bankruptcies and bankruptcy forecasts could simply indicate that auditors are skillful forecasters wi…
▽ More
It is widely speculated that auditors' public forecasts of bankruptcy are, at least in part, self-fulfilling prophecies in the sense that they might actually cause bankruptcies that would not have otherwise occurred. This conjecture is hard to prove, however, because the strong association between bankruptcies and bankruptcy forecasts could simply indicate that auditors are skillful forecasters with unique access to highly predictive covariates. In this paper, we investigate the causal effect of bankruptcy forecasts on bankruptcy using nonparametric sensitivity analysis. We contrast our analysis with two alternative approaches: a linear bivariate probit model with an endogenous regressor, and a recently developed bound on risk ratios called E-values. Additionally, our machine learning approach incorporates a monotonicity constraint corresponding to the assumption that bankruptcy forecasts do not make bankruptcies less likely. Finally, a tree-based posterior summary of the treatment effect estimates allows us to explore which observable firm characteristics moderate the inducement effect.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2022; v1 submitted 8 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Low-Temperature and Dynamic Magnetism of Highly Frustrated 5d2 Li4MgOsO6 Polymorphs in Comparison with 5d3 Li3Mg2OsO6
Authors:
Gia T. Tran,
Phuong-Hieu T. Nguyen,
Charles J. Bloed,
Michael E. Evans,
Jamie A. Anczarski,
William P. Martin,
Jefferson Toro,
Demetrios V. Papakostas,
James Beare,
Murray N. Wilson,
John E. Greedan,
Graeme M. Luke,
Thomas Gredig,
Jeremy P. Carlo,
Shahab Derakhshan
Abstract:
Geometric magnetic frustration (GMF) has attracted substantial interest due to the exotic physics and rich phase diagrams revealed by the cancellation of normally-dominant magnetic interactions, giving impetus for the search for novel frustrated systems, most often based on antiferromagnetic correlations between magnetic ions decorating triangular or tetrahedral lattices. We report here low-temper…
▽ More
Geometric magnetic frustration (GMF) has attracted substantial interest due to the exotic physics and rich phase diagrams revealed by the cancellation of normally-dominant magnetic interactions, giving impetus for the search for novel frustrated systems, most often based on antiferromagnetic correlations between magnetic ions decorating triangular or tetrahedral lattices. We report here low-temperature magnetic susceptibility and muon spin relaxation results on Li4MgOsO6 and Li3Mg2OsO6, members of the A5BO6 "rock salt ordered" family of frustrated materials. In Li3Mg2OsO6 we find spin freezing below 12K. In Li4MgOsO6, which can crystallize into either orthorhombic Fddd or monoclinic C2/m crystal symmetries depending on synthesis conditions, we find magnetism consistent with glassy-like behavior dominating below 2K, with partial ordering and evidence for dynamics at somewhat higher temperatures.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2018; v1 submitted 12 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
