Showing 1–14 of 14 results for author: Ortiz, E L

Physics, scientific investigation and society in Argentina, 1930-1940

Authors: Alejandro Gangui, Eduardo L. Ortiz

Abstract: In this paper we continue our study of the scientific research carried out at the Institute of Physics of the National University of La Plata during the first half of the 20th century, and of the important role played by the physicist Ramon G. Loyarte. Based on his studies, alone or in collaboration with members of the Institute, towards the end of the 1920s Loyarte proposed the possible existence… ▽ More In this paper we continue our study of the scientific research carried out at the Institute of Physics of the National University of La Plata during the first half of the 20th century, and of the important role played by the physicist Ramon G. Loyarte. Based on his studies, alone or in collaboration with members of the Institute, towards the end of the 1920s Loyarte proposed the possible existence of a new quantum of rotational energy in the mercury atom. This idea raised criticism and generated a fierce scientific controversy that reached the national and international academic media. We analyse this controversy by studying the comments that appeared in international review journals. We also study Loyarte's activities in politics and science policy in Argentina in the 1930s and 1940s, where he was responsible for interesting political and scientific initiatives. △ Less

Submitted 11 July, 2024; originally announced July 2024.

Comments: Article in Spanish, PDF document. Other related documents available at https://www.universoeinstein.com.ar/einsteinargentina.htm

Journal ref: Revista Brasileira de Historia da Ciencia 15:325-346, 2022

Physics, scientific investigation and society in Argentina, 1920-1930

Authors: Alejandro Gangui, Eduardo L. Ortiz

Abstract: We analyse the scientific research carried out at the Institute of Physics of the National University of La Plata in the first half of the 20th century, and the cultural and social context in which they were immersed. We focus especially on the activities carried out by the Argentine physicist Ramon G. Loyarte, who was an emblematic personality in the scientific, educational, cultural and politica… ▽ More We analyse the scientific research carried out at the Institute of Physics of the National University of La Plata in the first half of the 20th century, and the cultural and social context in which they were immersed. We focus especially on the activities carried out by the Argentine physicist Ramon G. Loyarte, who was an emblematic personality in the scientific, educational, cultural and political world of Argentina in those years. We discuss his most important works in experimental physics and quantum mechanics, his activities in the management and promotion of science and the international impact of his scientific proposals, as well as the origin of the controversies unleashed by his most daring ideas. For the latter topics we employ a novel tool: we examine the comments on his work published in prestigious international scientific review journals, which help to understand Loyarte's findings in a more comprehensive and contemporary way. △ Less

Submitted 14 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: Article in Spanish, PDF document. Other related documents available at https://www.universoeinstein.com.ar/einsteinargentina.htm

Journal ref: Revista Brasileira de Historia da Ciencia 15:299-324, 2022

The Institute of Physics of La Plata in the first post-war period: the qualified transmission of sciences to young people

Authors: Alejandro Gangui, Eduardo L. Ortiz

Abstract: In the first decade of the 20th century, the Universidad Nacional de La Plata, founded in 1905, created a modern and well-equipped Physics Institute. In this paper we study the impact that this initiative had on the modernisation of physics teaching at secondary and university level in Argentina. We focus on two of the most representative graduates of the Institute in those years, Ramon G. Loyarte… ▽ More In the first decade of the 20th century, the Universidad Nacional de La Plata, founded in 1905, created a modern and well-equipped Physics Institute. In this paper we study the impact that this initiative had on the modernisation of physics teaching at secondary and university level in Argentina. We focus on two of the most representative graduates of the Institute in those years, Ramon G. Loyarte and Enrique Loedel Palumbo, and analyse their most important pedagogical works and the public reception they received. These works are a sample of the contribution of the Institute of Physics to the raising of the level of national education in the field of physical sciences in the first half of the 20th century. △ Less

Submitted 17 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: Article in Spanish, PDF document. Other related documents available at https://www.universoeinstein.com.ar/einsteinargentina.htm

Journal ref: Asclepio. Revista de Historia de la Medicina y de la Ciencia 74:601, 2022

The physicist Enrique Loedel Palumbo in the Montevideo-Buenos Aires-La Plata scientific corridor: 1920-1930

Authors: Alejandro Gangui, Eduardo L. Ortiz

Abstract: In this paper we consider Montevideo's liberal progressive atmosphere towards the end of the nineteenth century and, within it, the trajectory of young science student Enrique Loedel Palumbo. We discuss some of his activities in Argentina, where he moved to study Physics at a new and well-equipped Physics Institute at the National University of La Plata, where he would later become a leading figur… ▽ More In this paper we consider Montevideo's liberal progressive atmosphere towards the end of the nineteenth century and, within it, the trajectory of young science student Enrique Loedel Palumbo. We discuss some of his activities in Argentina, where he moved to study Physics at a new and well-equipped Physics Institute at the National University of La Plata, where he would later become a leading figure. Initially Loedel Palumbo worked on the structure of complex molecules based on their magnetic, electric and optical properties. Later, when Einstein visited Argentina in 1925, he had chance to exchange ideas, which led to the publication of the first of a series of papers on the Theory of Relativity in some of Germany's leading scientific journals. Loedel Palumbo integrated fully with the intellectual life of his adopted country, becoming one of Argentina's top physicists and philosophers of science of his day. He is a valuable example of the deep intertwining of the intellectual life of Uruguay and Argentina in the first-half of the twentieth century. Like his Argentine colleagues, he also experienced the consequences of living through a complex historical period. △ Less

Submitted 7 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Comments: Article in Spanish, PDF document. Other related documents available at http://www.universoeinstein.com.ar/einsteinargentina.htm. arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:1909.02558

Journal ref: Revista de Indias 80:815-846, 2020

Scientific relations between Uruguay and Argentina in the 1920s: the exact sciences

Authors: Alejandro Gangui, Eduardo L. Ortiz

Abstract: The scientific career of Uruguayan theoretical physicist Enrique Loedel Palumbo in Argentina illustrates the intense intellectual exchange that existed between these neighboring countries in the first third of the twentieth century. In this paper we briefly discuss the scientific training of this scientist in Uruguay, his subsequent incorporation to the Institute of Physics of La Plata, in Buenos… ▽ More The scientific career of Uruguayan theoretical physicist Enrique Loedel Palumbo in Argentina illustrates the intense intellectual exchange that existed between these neighboring countries in the first third of the twentieth century. In this paper we briefly discuss the scientific training of this scientist in Uruguay, his subsequent incorporation to the Institute of Physics of La Plata, in Buenos Aires, and his first steps in research under the tutelage of German professor Richard Gans. △ Less

Submitted 5 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: Article in Spanish, PDF document. To be published in Filosofia e Historia de la Ciencia del Cono Sur. Seleccion de trabajos del XI Encuentro de Filosofia e Historia de la Ciencia. Other related documents available at http://www.universoeinstein.com.ar/einsteinargentina.htm

Relativity in Argentine culture in the early twentieth century

Authors: Alejandro Gangui, Eduardo L. Ortiz

Abstract: In previous works we have considered various aspects of the reception of the theories of Albert Einstein in our country. In particular, we discussed the impact of his visit to Argentina in 1925, and the precise content of the conferences and scientific publications that Einstein communicated while he was here. We have also discussed, critically, different documents on topics related to the theory… ▽ More In previous works we have considered various aspects of the reception of the theories of Albert Einstein in our country. In particular, we discussed the impact of his visit to Argentina in 1925, and the precise content of the conferences and scientific publications that Einstein communicated while he was here. We have also discussed, critically, different documents on topics related to the theory of relativity published in the country during the first decades of the last century, in which the technical level was extremely varied. Finally, we have dealt with a forgotten document, which Einstein prepared for his visit but, once in the country, thought it convenient not to communicate. In the present work, which is part of that same line of research, we propose to consider the scientific, cultural and pedagogical career of Enrique Loedel Palumbo (1901-1962), who was one of the main local actors during Einstein's visit to Argentina. He was also one of the founders of the research on relativity issues in the Rio de la Plata. In addition to his strictly scientific interests, Loedel Palumbo took seriously the pedagogy of science and became interested in philosophical, cultural and artistic problems of his time. △ Less

Submitted 8 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: Article in Spanish, PDF document. Published in Filosofia e Historia de la Ciencia en el Cono Sur. Seleccion de trabajos del IX Congreso y las XXV Jornadas de Epistemologia e Historia de la Ciencia, edited by J.Ahumada et al., Cordoba: Editorial de la UNC, pp. 279-287, 2015. Other related documents available at http://www.universoeinstein.com.ar/einsteinargentina.htm

Einstein en la Argentina: el impacto cientifico de su visita

Authors: Alejandro Gangui, Eduardo L. Ortiz

Abstract: We present a brief review of the impact that Albert Einstein's visit to Argentina had on the scientific community and on the general public. Among other particularities, his visit was, at a certain point, somewhat disconcerting: not only because of the complexity of his ideas, but also because of his appearance, which did not fit with the image of the wise visitor firmly seated in the minds of his… ▽ More We present a brief review of the impact that Albert Einstein's visit to Argentina had on the scientific community and on the general public. Among other particularities, his visit was, at a certain point, somewhat disconcerting: not only because of the complexity of his ideas, but also because of his appearance, which did not fit with the image of the wise visitor firmly seated in the minds of his interlocutors. His openness and tendency to ironize, especially in his first interviews with the press, first disorientated journalists and later also some members of his intellectual audience. Einstein, then, forced a revision of both the image of the wise man and that of spacetime. △ Less

Submitted 26 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Comments: Article in Spanish, PDF document, 19 pages. Published in Visitas culturales en la Argentina, 1898-1936, P. Bruno (ed.), Buenos Aires: Biblos, pp. 167-190, 2014. Other related documents available at http://www.universoeinstein.com.ar/einsteinargentina.htm . arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:physics/0506052

The scientific impact of Einstein's visit to Argentina, in 1925

Authors: Alejandro Gangui, Eduardo L. Ortiz

Abstract: The arrival of Albert Einstein in Argentina in 1925 had an impact, equally relevant, on the scientific community and on the general public. In this paper we discuss that visit from three different perspectives. Firstly, we consider the conditions that allowed for such visit to be possible. Then we focus on the institutional actors that facilitated it, as well as on the expertise and written refere… ▽ More The arrival of Albert Einstein in Argentina in 1925 had an impact, equally relevant, on the scientific community and on the general public. In this paper we discuss that visit from three different perspectives. Firstly, we consider the conditions that allowed for such visit to be possible. Then we focus on the institutional actors that facilitated it, as well as on the expertise and written references on topics related to relativity theory circulating at the time in the local community. In the last section we consider the implications of that visit for the local scientific environment. △ Less

Submitted 11 March, 2016; originally announced March 2016.

Comments: PDF document, 11 pages; Other related documents available at http://www.universoeinstein.com.ar/einsteinargentina.htm

Journal ref: Asian Journal of Physics 23:81-90, 2014

Anti-positivism, theoretical sciences and relativity in the Argentina of the 1920s

Authors: Alejandro Gangui, Eduardo L. Ortiz

Abstract: Observing the early years of the 1920's, it is possible to detect a fracture in the perception of relativity theory in Argentina, characterized by the publication of a series of strictly scientific studies on this theory, in parallel with presentations aimed at the general culture. In this work, we attempt to relate this fracture with the advances made by Anti-Positivist ideas in the higher echelo… ▽ More Observing the early years of the 1920's, it is possible to detect a fracture in the perception of relativity theory in Argentina, characterized by the publication of a series of strictly scientific studies on this theory, in parallel with presentations aimed at the general culture. In this work, we attempt to relate this fracture with the advances made by Anti-Positivist ideas in the higher echelons of Argentine culture. The new philosophical approach configured a new vision of science that questioned the traditional methodology of the experimental sciences and attributed to the theoretical sciences a more prominent role than they had in the past. In this work, we present a detailed account of a 1923 paper by José B. Collo and Teófilo Isnardi, two young Argentine physicists trained in Germany, which is a representative contribution to this new trend. △ Less

Submitted 20 March, 2012; originally announced March 2012.

Comments: Article in Spanish, PDF document; Published version available at http://www.universoeinstein.com.ar/einsteinargentina.htm

Journal ref: Revista Brasileira de Historia da Ciencia, Vol. 4, issue 2, pp. 201-218 (2011)

Unpublished opening lecture for the course on the theory of relativity in Argentina, 1925

Authors: Albert Einstein, Alejandro Gangui, Eduardo L. Ortiz

Abstract: Honorable Rector, Honorable Professors, and Students of this University: In these times of political and economic struggle and nationalistic fragmentation, it is a particular joy for me to see people assembling here to give their attention exclusively to the highest values that are common to us all. I am glad to be in this blessed land before a small circle of people who are interested in topics… ▽ More Honorable Rector, Honorable Professors, and Students of this University: In these times of political and economic struggle and nationalistic fragmentation, it is a particular joy for me to see people assembling here to give their attention exclusively to the highest values that are common to us all. I am glad to be in this blessed land before a small circle of people who are interested in topics of science to speak on those issues that, in essence, are the subject of my own meditations.. [abridged]. △ Less

Submitted 13 March, 2009; originally announced March 2009.

Comments: Companion paper to arXiv:0903.2064 . Published version available at (http://www.universoeinstein.com.ar/einsteinargentina.htm) Translated by Alejandro Gangui and Eduardo L. Ortiz

Journal ref: Sci.Context 21:451-459,2008

Einstein's unpublished opening lecture for his course on relativity theory in Argentina, 1925

Authors: Alejandro Gangui, Eduardo L. Ortiz

Abstract: In 1922 the University of Buenos Aires (UBA) Council approved a motion to send an invitation to Albert Einstein to visit Argentina and give a course of lectures on his theory of relativity. The motion was proposed by Jorge Duclout (1856-1927), who had been educated at the Eidgenossische Technische Hochschule, Zurich (ETH). This proposal was the culmination of a series of initiatives of various A… ▽ More In 1922 the University of Buenos Aires (UBA) Council approved a motion to send an invitation to Albert Einstein to visit Argentina and give a course of lectures on his theory of relativity. The motion was proposed by Jorge Duclout (1856-1927), who had been educated at the Eidgenossische Technische Hochschule, Zurich (ETH). This proposal was the culmination of a series of initiatives of various Argentine intellectuals interested in the theory of relativity. In a very short time Dr. Mauricio Nirenstein (1877-1935), then the university's administrative secretary, fulfilled all the requirements for the university's invitation to be endorsed and delivered to the sage in Berlin. The visit took place three years later, in March-April 1925. The Argentine press received Einstein with great interest and respect; his early exchanges covered a wide range of topics, including international politics and Jewish matters. Naturally, the journalists were more eager to hear from the eminent pacifist than from the incomprehensible physicist. However, after his initial openness with the press, the situation changed and Einstein restricted his public discourse to topics on theoretical physics, avoiding some controversial political, religious, or philosophical matters that he had freely touched upon in earlier interviews.. [abridged]. △ Less

Submitted 11 March, 2009; originally announced March 2009.

Comments: Published version available at http://www.universoeinstein.com.ar/einsteinargentina.htm

Journal ref: Sci.Context 21:435-450,2008

First echoes of relativity in Argentine astronomy

Authors: Alejandro Gangui, Eduardo L. Ortiz

Abstract: We consider the attitude of astronomers in Argentina in connection with the new problems posed by relativity theory, before and after GR was presented. We begin considering the sequence of "technical" publications that appeared and use it to attempt to identify who were the relativity leaders and authors in the Argentina scientific community of the 1910-1920s. Among them there are natives of Arg… ▽ More We consider the attitude of astronomers in Argentina in connection with the new problems posed by relativity theory, before and after GR was presented. We begin considering the sequence of "technical" publications that appeared and use it to attempt to identify who were the relativity leaders and authors in the Argentina scientific community of the 1910-1920s. Among them there are natives of Argentina, permanent resident scientists, and occasional foreign visitors. They are either academic scientists, or high school teachers; we leave aside the {\it philosophers} and the {\it aficionados}. We discuss the scientific facts and publications they handled, the modernity of their information and the "language" they use to transmit their ideas. Finally, we consider astronomers proper; first Charles Perrine, an astronomer interested in astrophysics, contracted by the government of Argentina in the USA as director of its main observatory. He became interested in testing the possible deflection of light rays by the Sun towards 1912; his Argentine expedition was the first to attempt that test. Perhaps Perrine was not so much interested in relativity as in testing the particular astronomical effects it predicted. In any case, he attempted the test with the acquiescence and financial support of the Argentine state, and as a leading member of its official scientific elite. We contrast his very specific and strictly scientific efforts with those of our second astronomer, José Ubach, SJ, a secondary school teacher of science at a leading Buenos Aires Catholic school who reported in response to Eddington's expedition. Finally, our third astronomer is Félix Aguilar, who made an effort to contribute to the public understanding of Einstein's theories in 1924, when Einstein's visit to Argentina had become a certainty. [abridged] △ Less

Submitted 17 September, 2008; originally announced September 2008.

Comments: Proceedings of the Workshop on the History of Argentine Astronomy. G.Romero, S.Cora and S.Cellone, eds. To be published by the Argentinean Astronomical Association, 2008. Additional material available at http://www.universoeinstein.com.ar/einsteinargentina.htm

The "inedito" of Einstein and his 1925 visit to Buenos Aires

Authors: Alejandro Gangui, Eduardo L. Ortiz

Abstract: In an article published by Mauricio Nirenstein in 1925, a few months after the visit of Albert Einstein to Argentina, the author wrote various comments and references relative to the scientist's visit. In particular, Nirenstein mentioned a personal conversation he had with Einstein in which the sage expressed many interesting ideas on the epistemology of physical sciences. In a note to that arti… ▽ More In an article published by Mauricio Nirenstein in 1925, a few months after the visit of Albert Einstein to Argentina, the author wrote various comments and references relative to the scientist's visit. In particular, Nirenstein mentioned a personal conversation he had with Einstein in which the sage expressed many interesting ideas on the epistemology of physical sciences. In a note to that article, it was indicated that Einstein would have left in the hands of Nirenstein some notes of a speech he wanted to deliver at the University of Buenos Aires. From 1931 onwards there appeared in a few journals of this city, different versions of what became known as the "inedito" of Einstein. In this paper we discuss both the facts and the individuals. We analyse briefly the "inedito" and we compare it with the two introductory lectures Einstein delivered at the University of Buenos Aires and at the Faculty of Science. △ Less

Submitted 30 June, 2008; originally announced July 2008.

Comments: Article in Spanish, PDF document. Full-fledged article will soon appear in Science in Context (CUP)

Journal ref: Epistemologia e Historia de la Ciencia, Vol 12, pp. 240-247, 2006

Albert Einstein visits Argentina

Authors: Alejandro Gangui, Eduardo L. Ortiz

Abstract: This is a detailed, day by day, account of Albert Einstein's activities, both social and scientific, during his 30-day stay in Argentina in 1925, including his lectures on relativity at the various local universities and his visit to the National Academy of Sciences, as follows from his personal Diary of the trip to South-America and other contemporary documents. This is a detailed, day by day, account of Albert Einstein's activities, both social and scientific, during his 30-day stay in Argentina in 1925, including his lectures on relativity at the various local universities and his visit to the National Academy of Sciences, as follows from his personal Diary of the trip to South-America and other contemporary documents. △ Less

Submitted 6 June, 2005; originally announced June 2005.

Comments: Article in Spanish, PDF document

Journal ref: Todo es Historia 454 (May 2005), pp. 22-30