Showing 1–50 of 66 results for author: Ormel, C W

How planets form by pebble accretion V. Silicate rainout delays contraction of sub-Neptunes

Authors: A. Vazan, C. W. Ormel, M. G. Brouwers

Abstract: The characterization of Super-Earth-to-Neptune sized exoplanets relies heavily on our understanding of their formation and evolution. In this study, we link a model of planet formation by pebble accretion to the planets' long-term observational properties by calculating the interior evolution, starting from the dissipation of the protoplanetary disk. We investigate the evolution of the interior st… ▽ More The characterization of Super-Earth-to-Neptune sized exoplanets relies heavily on our understanding of their formation and evolution. In this study, we link a model of planet formation by pebble accretion to the planets' long-term observational properties by calculating the interior evolution, starting from the dissipation of the protoplanetary disk. We investigate the evolution of the interior structure in 5-20 Earth masses planets, accounting for silicate redistribution caused by convective mixing, rainout (condensation and settling), and mass loss. Specifically, we have followed the fate of the hot silicate vapor that remained in the planet's envelope after planet formation, as the planet cools. We find that disk dissipation is followed by a rapid contraction of the envelope within 10 Myr. Subsequent cooling leads to substantial growth of the planetary core through silicate rainout, accompanied by inflated radii, in comparison to the standard models of planets that formed with core-envelope structure. We examine the dependence of rainout on the planet's envelope mass, distance from its host star, its silicate mass, and the atmospheric opacity. We find that the population of planets formed with polluted envelopes can be roughly divided in three groups, based on the mass of their gas envelopes: bare rocky cores that have shed their envelopes, super-Earth planets with a core-envelope structure, and Neptune-like planets with diluted cores that undergo gradual rainout. For polluted planets formed with envelope masses below 0.4 Earth mass, we anticipate that the inflation of the planet's radius caused by rainout will enhance mass loss by a factor of 2-8 compared to planets with non-polluted envelopes. Our model provides an explanation for bridging the gap between the predicted composition gradients in massive planets and the core-envelope structure in smaller planets. △ Less

Submitted 16 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: Accepted for publication in A&A

Rocky sub-Neptunes formed by pebble accretion: Rain of rocks from polluted envelopes

Authors: Allona Vazan, Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: Sub-Neptune planets formed in the protoplanetary disk accreted hydrogen-helium (H,He) envelopes. Planet formation models of sub-Neptunes formed by pebble accretion result in small rocky cores surrounded by polluted H,He envelopes where most of the rock (silicate) is in vapor form at the end of the formation phase. This vapor is expected to condense and rain-out as the planet cools. In this Letter… ▽ More Sub-Neptune planets formed in the protoplanetary disk accreted hydrogen-helium (H,He) envelopes. Planet formation models of sub-Neptunes formed by pebble accretion result in small rocky cores surrounded by polluted H,He envelopes where most of the rock (silicate) is in vapor form at the end of the formation phase. This vapor is expected to condense and rain-out as the planet cools. In this Letter we examine the timescale for the rainout and its effect on the thermal evolution. We calculate the thermal and structural evolution of a 10 Earth masses planet formed by pebble accretion, taking into account material redistribution from silicate rainout (condensation and settling) and from convective mixing. We find that the duration of the rainout in sub-Neptunes is on Gyr timescale and varies with envelope mass: planets with envelopes below 0.75 Earth mass rainout into a core-envelope structure in less than 1 Gyr, while planets in excess of 0.75 Earth mass of H,He preserve some of their envelope pollution for billions of years. The energy released by the rainout inflates the radius with respect to planets that start out from a plain core-envelope structure. This inflation would result in estimates of the H,He contents of observed exoplanets based on the standard core-envelope structure to be too high.We identify a number of planets in the exoplanet census where rainout may operate, which would result in their H,He contents to be overestimated by up to a factor two. Future accurate age measurements by the PLATO mission may allow the identification of planets formed with polluted envelopes. △ Less

Submitted 27 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: accepted to A&A Letters

Journal ref: A&A 676, L8 (2023)

Chemical footprints of giant planet formation. Role of planet accretion in sha** the C/O ratio of protoplanetary disks

Authors: Haochang Jiang, Yu Wang, Chris W. Ormel, Sebastiaan Krijt, Ruobing Dong

Abstract: Protoplanetary disks, the birthplaces of planets, commonly feature bright rings and dark gaps in both continuum and line emission maps. Accreting planets are interacting with the disk, not only through gravity, but also by changing the local irradiation and elemental abundances, which are essential ingredients for disk chemistry. We propose that giant planet accretion can leave chemical footprints… ▽ More Protoplanetary disks, the birthplaces of planets, commonly feature bright rings and dark gaps in both continuum and line emission maps. Accreting planets are interacting with the disk, not only through gravity, but also by changing the local irradiation and elemental abundances, which are essential ingredients for disk chemistry. We propose that giant planet accretion can leave chemical footprints in the gas local to the planet, which potentially leads to the spatial coincidence of molecular emissions with the planet in ALMA observation. Through 2D multi-fluid hydrodynamical simulations in Athena++ with built-in sublimation, we simulate the process of an accreting planet locally heating up its vicinity, opening a gas gap in the disk, and creating the conditions for C-photochemistry. An accreting planet located outside the methane snowline can render the surrounding gas hot enough to sublimate the C-rich organics off pebbles before they are accreted by the planet. This locally elevates the disk gas-phase C/O ratio, providing a potential explanation for the C$_2$H line-emission rings observed with ALMA. In particular, our findings provide an explanation for the MWC480 disk, where previous work has identified a statistically significant spatial coincidence of line-emission rings inside a continuum gap. Our findings present a novel view of linking the gas accretion of giant planets and their natal disks through the chemistry signals. This model demonstrates that giant planets can actively shape their forming chemical environment, moving beyond the traditional understanding of the direct map** of primordial disk chemistry onto planets. △ Less

Submitted 17 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 18 pages, 13 figures, Accepted for publication in A&A

Journal ref: A&A 678, A33 (2023)

A massive hot Jupiter orbiting a metal-rich early-M star discovered in the TESS full frame images

Authors: Tianjun Gan, Charles Cadieux, Farbod Jahandar, Allona Vazan, Sharon X. Wang, Shude Mao, Jaime A. Alvarado-Montes, D. N. C. Lin, Étienne Artigau, Neil J. Cook, René Doyon, Andrew W. Mann, Keivan G. Stassun, Adam J. Burgasser, Benjamin V. Rackham, Steve B. Howell, Karen A. Collins, Khalid Barkaoui, Avi Shporer, Jerome de Leon, Luc Arnold, George R. Ricker, Roland Vanderspek, David W. Latham, Sara Seager , et al. (19 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: Observations and statistical studies have shown that giant planets are rare around M dwarfs compared with Sun-like stars. The formation mechanism of these extreme systems remains under debate for decades. With the help of the TESS mission and ground based follow-up observations, we report the discovery of TOI-4201b, the most massive and densest hot Jupiter around an M dwarf known so far with a rad… ▽ More Observations and statistical studies have shown that giant planets are rare around M dwarfs compared with Sun-like stars. The formation mechanism of these extreme systems remains under debate for decades. With the help of the TESS mission and ground based follow-up observations, we report the discovery of TOI-4201b, the most massive and densest hot Jupiter around an M dwarf known so far with a radius of $1.22\pm 0.04\ R_J$ and a mass of $2.48\pm0.09\ M_J$, about 5 times heavier than most other giant planets around M dwarfs. It also has the highest planet-to-star mass ratio ($q\sim 4\times 10^{-3}$) among such systems. The host star is an early-M dwarf with a mass of $0.61\pm0.02\ M_{\odot}$ and a radius of $0.63\pm0.02\ R_{\odot}$. It has significant super-solar iron abundance ([Fe/H]=$0.52\pm 0.08$ dex). However, interior structure modeling suggests that its planet TOI-4201b is metal-poor, which challenges the classical core-accretion correlation of stellar-planet metallicity, unless the planet is inflated by additional energy sources. Building on the detection of this planet, we compare the stellar metallicity distribution of four planetary groups: hot/warm Jupiters around G/M dwarfs. We find that hot/warm Jupiters show a similar metallicity dependence around G-type stars. For M dwarf host stars, the occurrence of hot Jupiters shows a much stronger correlation with iron abundance, while warm Jupiters display a weaker preference, indicating possible different formation histories. △ Less

Submitted 13 September, 2023; v1 submitted 13 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 24 pages, 14 figures, 4 tables, accepted to AJ

Atmospheric Recyling of Volatiles by Pebble-Accreting Planets

Authors: Yu Wang, Chris W. Ormel, **hui Huang, Rolf Kuiper

Abstract: Planets, embedded in their natal discs, harbour hot envelopes. When pebbles are accreted by these planets, the contained volatile components may sublimate, enriching the envelope and potentially changing its thermodynamical properties. However, the envelopes of embedded planets actively exchange material with the disc, which would limit the buildup of a vapour-rich atmosphere. To properly investig… ▽ More Planets, embedded in their natal discs, harbour hot envelopes. When pebbles are accreted by these planets, the contained volatile components may sublimate, enriching the envelope and potentially changing its thermodynamical properties. However, the envelopes of embedded planets actively exchange material with the disc, which would limit the buildup of a vapour-rich atmosphere. To properly investigate these processes, we have developed a new phase change module to treat the sublimation process with hydrodynamical simultions. Combined with the recently developed multi-dust fluid approach, we conduct 2D self-consistent hydrodynamic simulations to study how pebble sublimation influences the water content of super-Earths and sub-Neptunes. We find the extent and the amount of vapour that a planet is able to hold on to is determined by the relative size of the sublimation front and the atmosphere. When the sublimation front lies far inside the atmosphere, vapour tends to be locked deep in the atmosphere and keeps accumulating through a positive feedback mechanism. On the other hand, when the sublimation front exceeds the (bound) atmosphere, the ice component of incoming pebbles can be fully recycled and the vapour content reaches a low, steady value. Low disc temperature, small planet mass and high pebble flux (omitting accretion heating by pebbles) render the planet atmosphere vapour-rich while the reverse changes render it vapour-poor. The phase change module introduced here can in future studies also be employed to model the chemical composition of the gas in the vicinity of accreting planets and around snowlines. △ Less

Submitted 9 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 21 pages, 16 figures. Accepted for publication in MNRAS on June 5th 2023

Accretion of aerodynamically large pebbles

Authors: Helong Huang, Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: Due to their aerodynamical coupling with gas, pebbles in protoplanetary discs can drift over large distances to support planet growth in the inner disc. In the past decade, this pebble accretion has been studied extensively for aerodynamically small pebbles (Stokes number St < 1). However, accretion can also operate in the St > 1 mode, e.g., when planetesimals collisionally fragment to smaller bod… ▽ More Due to their aerodynamical coupling with gas, pebbles in protoplanetary discs can drift over large distances to support planet growth in the inner disc. In the past decade, this pebble accretion has been studied extensively for aerodynamically small pebbles (Stokes number St < 1). However, accretion can also operate in the St > 1 mode, e.g., when planetesimals collisionally fragment to smaller bodies or when the primordial gas disc disperses. This work aims to extend the study of pebble accretion to these aerodynamically loosely coupled particles. We integrate the pebble's equation of motion, accounting for gas drag, stellar and planetary gravity, in the midplane of a laminar disc. The accretion probability ($ε$) is calculated as function of Stokes number, disc pressure gradient index, planet mass and eccentricity. We find that for Stokes number above unity $ε$(St) first rises, due to lower drift and aided by a large atmospheric capture radius, until it reaches a plateau where the efficiency approaches 100 per cent. At high St the plateau region terminates as particles become trapped in resonance. These results are well described by a semi-analytical "kick-and-drift" model and we also provide fully analytical prescriptions for $ε$. We apply our model to the accretion of $\sim 30 μ$m dust particles in a dispersing protoplanetary and secondary (CO-rich) debris disc. It shows that physically small particles are mainly accreted as aerodynamically large Stokes number pebbles during the debris disc phase. Earth-mass planets may obtain $\sim 25$ per cent of their heavy elements through this late accretion phase. △ Less

Submitted 4 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Comments: 19 pages, 16 figures, 5 tables. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

Forming equal mass planetary binaries via pebble accretion

Authors: T. J. Konijn, R. G. Visser, C. Dominik, C. W. Ormel

Abstract: Binary solar system objects are common and range from satellite systems with very large mass ratios $M_1/M_2$ to mass ratios very close to unity. A well-known example of a binary is the Pluto-Charon system. With Charon only eight times less massive than Pluto the question arises as for many other systems, why the mass-ratio is still close to unity. There is much evidence that (binary) planet(esima… ▽ More Binary solar system objects are common and range from satellite systems with very large mass ratios $M_1/M_2$ to mass ratios very close to unity. A well-known example of a binary is the Pluto-Charon system. With Charon only eight times less massive than Pluto the question arises as for many other systems, why the mass-ratio is still close to unity. There is much evidence that (binary) planet(esimal) formation happened early, when the protoplanetary gas disk was still around. It is likely that (some of) these binaries grew up together subject to pebble accretion. Here we focus on the question of how the mass arriving in the gravitational influence zone of the binary during pebble accretion, is distributed over the binary components. Does the accretion through time lead to a converging mass ratio, or to a diverging mass ratio? We numerically integrate pebble paths in the same well-known fashion as for a single mass subject to pebble accretion and track what the efficiency of accretion is for the two separate binary components, compared to a single body with the same mass. These numerical simulations are done for a range of binary mass-ratios, mutual separations, Stokes numbers and two orbital distances, 2.5 and 39 au. We find that in the limit where pebbles start to spiral around the primary (this holds for relatively large pebbles), the pebble preferentially collides with the secondary, causing the mass ratio to converge towards unity on Myr timescales. In this regime the total sweep-up efficiency can lower to half that of a pebble-accreting single body because pebbles that are thrown out of the system, after close encounters with the system. The results show that systems such as Pluto-Charon and other larger equal mass binaries could well have co-accreted by means of pebble accretion in the disk phase without producing binaries with highly diverging mass-ratios. △ Less

Submitted 17 February, 2023; v1 submitted 29 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 10 pages, 8 figures, submitted to Astronomy and Astrophysics

Journal ref: A&A 670, A116 (2023)

Efficient planet formation by pebble accretion in ALMA rings

Authors: Haochang Jiang, Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: In the past decade, ALMA observations have revealed that a large fraction of protoplanetary discs contains rings in the dust continuum. These rings are the locations where pebbles accumulate, which is beneficial for planetesimal formation and subsequent planet assembly. We investigate the viability of planet formation inside ALMA rings in which pebbles are trapped by either a Gaussian-shape pressu… ▽ More In the past decade, ALMA observations have revealed that a large fraction of protoplanetary discs contains rings in the dust continuum. These rings are the locations where pebbles accumulate, which is beneficial for planetesimal formation and subsequent planet assembly. We investigate the viability of planet formation inside ALMA rings in which pebbles are trapped by either a Gaussian-shape pressure bump or by the strong dust backreaction. Planetesimals form at the midplane of the ring via streaming instability. By conducting N-body simulations, we study the growth of these planetesimals by collisional mergers and pebble accretion. Thanks to the high concentration of pebbles in the ring, the growth of planetesimals by pebble accretion becomes efficient as soon as they are born. We find that planet migration plays a decisive role in the evolution of rings and planets. For discs where planets can migrate inward from the ring, a steady state is reached where the ring spawns ${\sim}20 M_\oplus$ planetary cores as long as rings are fed with materials from the outer disc. The ring acts as a long-lived planet factory and it can explain the 'fine-tuned' optical depths of the observed dust rings in the DSHARP large program. In contrast, in the absence of a planet removal mechanism (migration), a single massive planet will form and destroy the ring. A wide and massive planetesimals belt will be left at the location of the planet-forming ring. Planet formation in rings may explain the mature planetary systems observed inside debris discs. △ Less

Submitted 8 November, 2022; v1 submitted 26 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

Comments: 24 pages, 18 figures, 3 tables, Accepted for publication in MNRAS

Planet Formation Theory in the Era of ALMA and Kepler: from Pebbles to Exoplanets

Authors: Joanna Drazkowska, Bertram Bitsch, Michiel Lambrechts, Gijs D. Mulders, Daniel Harsono, Allona Vazan, Beibei Liu, Chris W. Ormel, Katherine Kretke, Alessandro Morbidelli

Abstract: Our understanding of planet formation has been rapidly evolving in recent years. The classical planet formation theory, developed when the only known planetary system was our own Solar System, has been revised to account for the observed diversity of the exoplanetary systems. At the same time, the increasing observational capabilities of the young stars and their surrounding disks bring new constr… ▽ More Our understanding of planet formation has been rapidly evolving in recent years. The classical planet formation theory, developed when the only known planetary system was our own Solar System, has been revised to account for the observed diversity of the exoplanetary systems. At the same time, the increasing observational capabilities of the young stars and their surrounding disks bring new constraints on the planet formation process. In this chapter, we summarize the new information derived from the exoplanets population and the circumstellar disks observations. We present the new developments in planet formation theory, from dust evolution to the growth of planetary cores by accretion of planetesimals, pebbles, and gas. We review the state-of-the-art models for the formation of diverse planetary systems, including the population synthesis approach which is necessary to compare theoretical model outcomes to the exoplanet population. We emphasize that the planet formation process may not be spatially uniform in the disk and there are preferential locations for the formation of planetesimals and planets. Outside of these locations, a significant fraction of solids is not growing past the pebble-sizes. The reservoir of pebbles plays an important role in the growth of planetary cores in the pebble accretion process. The timescale of the emergence of massive planetary cores is an important aspect of the present models and it is likely that the cores within one disk form at different times. In addition, there is growing evidence that the first planetary cores start forming early, during the circumstellar disk buildup process. △ Less

Submitted 24 May, 2023; v1 submitted 18 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: 38 pages, 13 figures, review chapter accepted to Protostars and Planets VII, editors: Shu-ichiro Inutsuka, Yuri Aikawa, Takayuki Muto, Kengo Tomida, and Motohide Tamura, corrected label in Fig. 1

Recycling of the first atmospheres of embedded planets: Dependence on core mass and optical depth

Authors: T. W. Moldenhauer, R. Kuiper, W. Kley, C. W. Ormel

Abstract: Recent observations found close-in planets with significant atmospheres of hydrogen and helium in great abundance. These are the so-called super-Earths and mini-Neptunes. Their atmospheric composition suggests that they formed early during the gas-rich phase of the circumstellar disk and were able to avoid becoming hot Jupiters. As a possible explanation, recent studies explored the recycling hypo… ▽ More Recent observations found close-in planets with significant atmospheres of hydrogen and helium in great abundance. These are the so-called super-Earths and mini-Neptunes. Their atmospheric composition suggests that they formed early during the gas-rich phase of the circumstellar disk and were able to avoid becoming hot Jupiters. As a possible explanation, recent studies explored the recycling hypothesis and showed that atmosphere-disk recycling is able to fully compensate for radiative cooling and thereby halt Kelvin-Helmholtz contraction to prevent runaway gas accretion. To understand the parameters that determine the efficiency of atmospheric recycling, we extend our earlier studies by exploring the effects of the core mass, the effect of circumstellar gas on sub-Keplerian orbits (headwind), and the optical depth of the surrounding gas on the recycling timescale. Additionally, we analyze their effects on the size and mass of the forming atmosphere. For the explored parameter space, all simulations eventually reach an equilibrium where heating due to hydrodynamic recycling fully compensates radiative cooling. In this equilibrium, the atmosphere-to-core mass ratio stays well below $10 \, \%$, preventing the atmosphere from becoming self-gravitating and entering runaway gas accretion. Higher core masses cause the atmosphere to become turbulent, which further enhances recycling. Even for our highest core mass of $10 \, M_\mathrm{Earth}$, atmosphere-disk recycling is efficient enough to fully compensate for radiative cooling and prevent the atmosphere from becoming self-gravitating. Hence, in-situ formation of hot Jupiters is very unlikely, and migration of gas giants is a key process required to explain their existence. Our findings imply that atmosphere-disk recycling is the most natural explanation for the prevalence of close-in super-Earths and mini-Neptunes. △ Less

Submitted 24 February, 2022; v1 submitted 23 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Comments: 18 pages, 13 figures, Accepted for publication by A&A on 2/7/2022

No Significant Correlation between Line-emission and Continuum Substructures in the Molecules with ALMA at Planet-forming Scales Program

Authors: Haochang Jiang, Wei Zhu, Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: Recently, the Molecules with ALMA at Planet-forming Scales (MAPS) ALMA Large Program reported a high number of line emission substructures coincident with dust rings and gaps in the continuum emission, suggesting a causal link between these axisymmetric line emission and dust continuum substructures. To test the robustness of the claimed correlation, we compare the observed spatial overlap fractio… ▽ More Recently, the Molecules with ALMA at Planet-forming Scales (MAPS) ALMA Large Program reported a high number of line emission substructures coincident with dust rings and gaps in the continuum emission, suggesting a causal link between these axisymmetric line emission and dust continuum substructures. To test the robustness of the claimed correlation, we compare the observed spatial overlap fraction in substructures with that from the null hypothesis, in which the overlap is assumed to arise from the random placement of line emission substructures. Our results reveal that there is no statistically significant evidence for a universal correlation between line emission and continuum substructures, questioning the frequently-made link between continuum rings and pressure bumps. The analysis also clearly identifies outliers. The chemical rings and the dust gaps in MWC 480 appear to be strongly correlated (${>}4σ$), and the gaps in the CO isotopologues tend to moderately (${\sim}3σ$) correlate with dust rings. △ Less

Submitted 2 February, 2022; v1 submitted 27 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: 8 pages, 3 figures, 2 tables, Accepted for publication in ApJL

The dynamics of the TRAPPIST-1 system in the context of its formation

Authors: Shuo Huang, Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: TRAPPIST-1 is an 0.09 $M_{\odot}$ star, which harbours a system of seven Earth-sized planets. Two main features stand out: (i) all planets have similar radii, masses, and compositions; and (ii) all planets are in resonance. Previous works have outlined a pebble-driven formation scenario where planets of similar composition form sequentially at the H$_2$O snowline (${\sim}0.1$ au for this low-mass… ▽ More TRAPPIST-1 is an 0.09 $M_{\odot}$ star, which harbours a system of seven Earth-sized planets. Two main features stand out: (i) all planets have similar radii, masses, and compositions; and (ii) all planets are in resonance. Previous works have outlined a pebble-driven formation scenario where planets of similar composition form sequentially at the H$_2$O snowline (${\sim}0.1$ au for this low-mass star). It was hypothesized that the subsequent formation and migration led to the current resonant configuration. Here, we investigate whether the sequential planet formation model is indeed capable to produce the present-day resonant configuration, characterized by its two-body and three-body mean motion resonances structure. We carry out N-body simulations, accounting for type-I migration, stellar tidal dam**, disc eccentricity-dam**, and featuring a migration barrier located at the disc's inner edge. Due to the sequential migration, planets naturally form a chain of first-order resonances. But to explain the period ratios of the b/c/d-system, which are presently in higher-order resonances, we find that planets b and c must have marched across the migration barrier, into the gas-free cavity, before the disc has dispersed. We investigate both an early and late cavity infall scenario and find that the early infall model best matches the constraints, as well as being more probable. After the dispersal of the gaseous disc, stellar tidal torque also contributes towards a modest separation of the inner system. We outline how the insights obtained in this work can be applied to aid the understanding of other compact resonant planet systems. △ Less

Submitted 25 January, 2022; v1 submitted 22 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: 18 pages, 14 figures; accepted for publication in MNRAS

How planets grow by pebble accretion IV: Envelope opacity trends from sedimenting dust and pebbles

Authors: M. G. Brouwers, C. W. Ormel, A. Bonsor, A. Vazan

Abstract: The amount of nebular gas that a planet can bind is limited by its cooling rate, which is set by the opacity of its envelope. Accreting dust and pebbles contribute to the envelope opacity and, thus, influence the outcome of planet formation. Our aim is to model the size evolution and opacity contribution of solids inside planetary envelopes. We then use the resultant opacity relations to study eme… ▽ More The amount of nebular gas that a planet can bind is limited by its cooling rate, which is set by the opacity of its envelope. Accreting dust and pebbles contribute to the envelope opacity and, thus, influence the outcome of planet formation. Our aim is to model the size evolution and opacity contribution of solids inside planetary envelopes. We then use the resultant opacity relations to study emergent trends in planet formation. We design a model for the opacity of solids in planetary envelopes that accounts for the growth, fragmentation and erosion of pebbles during their sedimentation. We formulate analytical expressions for the opacity of pebbles and dust and map out their trends as a function of depth, planet mass, distance and accretion rate. We find that the accretion of pebbles rather than planetesimals can produce fully convective envelopes, but only in lower-mass planets that reside in the outer disk or in those that are accreting pebbles at a high rate. In these conditions, pebble sizes are limited by fragmentation and erosion, allowing them to pile up in the envelope. At higher planetary masses or reduced accretion rates, a different regime applies where the sizes of sedimenting pebbles are only limited by their rate of growth. The opacity in this growth-limited regime is much lower, steeply declines with depth and planet mass but is invariant with the pebble mass flux. Our results imply that the opacity of a forming planetary envelope can not be approximated by a value that is constant with either depth or planet mass. When applied to the Solar System, we argue that Uranus and Neptune could not have maintained a sufficiently high opacity to avoid runaway gas accretion unless they both experienced sufficiently rapid accretion of solids and formed late. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: Accepted to A&A. Comments are welcome

Journal ref: A&A 653, A103 (2021)

Survival of ALMA Rings in the Absence of Pressure Maxima

Authors: Haochang Jiang, Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: Recent ALMA observations have revealed that a large fraction of protoplanetary discs contain bright rings at (sub)millimeter wavelengths. Dust trap** induced by pressure maxima in the gas disc is a popular explanation for these rings. However, it is unclear whether such pressure bumps can survive for evolutionary time-scales of the disc. In this work, we investigate an alternative scenario, whic… ▽ More Recent ALMA observations have revealed that a large fraction of protoplanetary discs contain bright rings at (sub)millimeter wavelengths. Dust trap** induced by pressure maxima in the gas disc is a popular explanation for these rings. However, it is unclear whether such pressure bumps can survive for evolutionary time-scales of the disc. In this work, we investigate an alternative scenario, which involves only dust-gas interactions in a smooth gas disc. We postulate that ALMA rings are a manifestation of a dense, clumpy mid-plane that is actively forming planetesimals. The clumpy medium itself hardly experiences radial drift, but clumps lose mass by disintegration and vertical transport and planetesimal formation. Starting from a seed ring, we numerically solve the transport equations to investigate the ring's survival. In general, rings move outward, due to diffusion of the clump component. Without pressure support, rings leak material at rates $\sim$40 $M_\oplus\,\mathrm{Myr}^{-1}$ and in order for rings to survive, they must feed from an external mass reservoir of pebbles. In the case where the pebble size is constant in the disk, a cycle between ring formation and dispersion emerges. Rings produce large quantities of planetesimals, which could be material for planet formation and explain the massive budget inferred debris disc. Mock images of ALMA observations compare well to the rings of Elias 24 and AS 209 from DSHARP's sample. △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2021; v1 submitted 1 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: 18 pages, 15 figures, Accepted for publication in MNRAS

Steady State by Recycling prevents Premature Collapse of Protoplanetary Atmospheres

Authors: T. W. Moldenhauer, R. Kuiper, W. Kley, C. W. Ormel

Abstract: In recent years, space missions such as Kepler and TESS have discovered many close-in planets with significant atmospheres consisting of hydrogen and helium: mini-Neptunes. This indicates that these planets formed early in gas-rich disks while avoiding the runaway gas accretion that would otherwise have turned them into hot-Jupiters. A solution is to invoke a long Kelvin-Helmholtz contraction (or… ▽ More In recent years, space missions such as Kepler and TESS have discovered many close-in planets with significant atmospheres consisting of hydrogen and helium: mini-Neptunes. This indicates that these planets formed early in gas-rich disks while avoiding the runaway gas accretion that would otherwise have turned them into hot-Jupiters. A solution is to invoke a long Kelvin-Helmholtz contraction (or cooling) timescale, but it has also been suggested that thermodynamical cooling can be prevented by hydrodynamical planet atmosphere-disk recycling. We investigate the efficacy of the recycling hypothesis in preventing the collapse of the atmosphere, check for the existence of a steady state configuration, and determine the final atmospheric mass to core mass ratio. We use three-dimensional radiation-hydrodynamic simulations to model the formation of planetary proto-atmospheres. Equations are solved in a local frame centered on the planet. Ignoring small oscillations that average to zero over time, the simulations converge to a steady state where the velocity field of the gas becomes constant in time. In a steady state, the energy loss by radiative cooling is fully compensated by the recycling of the low entropy gas in the planetary atmosphere with high entropy gas from the circumstellar disk. For close-in planets, recycling naturally halts the cooling of planetary proto-atmospheres, preventing them from contracting toward the runaway regime and collapsing into gas giants. △ Less

Submitted 1 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures, accepted to A&A

Journal ref: A&A 646, L11 (2021)

The ARCiS framework for Exoplanet Atmospheres: Modelling Philosophy and Retrieval

Authors: Michiel Min, Chris W. Ormel, Katy Chubb, Christiane Helling, Yui Kawashima

Abstract: Aims: ARCiS, a novel code for the analysis of exoplanet transmission and emission spectra is presented. The aim of the modelling framework is to provide a tool able to link observations to physical models of exoplanet atmospheres. Methods: The modelling philosophy chosen in this paper is to use physical and chemical models to constrain certain parameters while kee** free the parts where our phys… ▽ More Aims: ARCiS, a novel code for the analysis of exoplanet transmission and emission spectra is presented. The aim of the modelling framework is to provide a tool able to link observations to physical models of exoplanet atmospheres. Methods: The modelling philosophy chosen in this paper is to use physical and chemical models to constrain certain parameters while kee** free the parts where our physical understanding is still more limited. This approach, in between full physical modelling and full parameterisation, allows us to use the processes we understand well and parameterise those less understood. A Bayesian retrieval framework is implemented and applied to the transit spectra of a set of 10 hot Jupiters. The code contains chemistry and cloud formation and has the option for self consistent temperature structure computations. Results: The code presented is fast and flexible enough to be used for retrieval and for target list simulations for e.g. JWST or the ESA Ariel missions. We present results for the retrieval of elemental abundance ratios using the physical retrieval framework and compare this to results obtained using a parameterised retrieval setup. Conclusions: We conclude that for most of the targets considered the current dataset is not constraining enough to reliably pin down the elemental abundance ratios. We find no significant correlations between different physical parameters. We confirm that planets in our sample with a strong slope in the optical transmission spectrum are the planets where we find cloud formation to be most active. Finally, we conclude that with ARCiS we have a computationally efficient tool to analyse exoplanet observations in the context of physical and chemical models. △ Less

Submitted 28 July, 2020; v1 submitted 23 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: Accepted for publication in A&A

Journal ref: A&A 642, A28 (2020)

Diverse outcomes of planet formation and composition around low-mass stars and brown dwarfs

Authors: Y. Miguel, A. Cridland, C. W. Ormel, J. J. Fortney, S. Ida

Abstract: The detection of Earth-size exoplanets around low-mass stars -- in stars such as Proxima Centauri and TRAPPIST-1 -- provide an exceptional chance to improve our understanding of the formation of planets around M stars and brown dwarfs. We explore the formation of such planets with a population synthesis code based on a planetesimal-driven model previously used to study the formation of the Jovian… ▽ More The detection of Earth-size exoplanets around low-mass stars -- in stars such as Proxima Centauri and TRAPPIST-1 -- provide an exceptional chance to improve our understanding of the formation of planets around M stars and brown dwarfs. We explore the formation of such planets with a population synthesis code based on a planetesimal-driven model previously used to study the formation of the Jovian satellites. Because the discs have low mass and the stars are cool, the formation is an inefficient process that happens at short periods, generating compact planetary systems. Planets can be trapped in resonances and we follow the evolution of the planets after the gas has dissipated and they undergo orbit crossings and possible mergers. We find that formation of planets above Mars mass and in the planetesimal accretion scenario, is only possible around stars with masses $M_{\star} \ge 0.07 M_{sun}$ and discs of $M_{disc} \ge 10^{-2}~M_{sun} $. We find that planets above Earth-mass form around stars with masses larger than $0.15 M_{\oplus}$ while planets larger than $5 M_{\oplus}$do not form in our model, even not under the most optimal conditions (massive disc), showing that planets such as GJ 3512b form with another, more efficient mechanism. Our results show that the majority of planets form with a significant water fraction; that most of our synthetic planetary systems have 1, 2, or 3 planets, but those with 4, 5, 6, and 7 planets are also common, confirming that compact planetary systems with many planets should be a relatively common outcome of planet formation around small stars. △ Less

Submitted 18 December, 2019; v1 submitted 26 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: published in MNRAS

Journal ref: MNRAS 491, 1998-2009

The Galilean Satellites Formed Slowly from Pebbles

Authors: Yuhito Shibaike, Chris W. Ormel, Shigeru Ida, Satoshi Okuzumi, Takanori Sasaki

Abstract: It is generally accepted that the four major (Galilean) satellites formed out of the gas disk that accompanied Jupiter's formation. However, understanding the specifics of the formation process is challenging as both small particles (pebbles) as well as the satellites are subject to fast migration processes. Here, we hypothesize a new scenario for the origin of the Galilean system, based on the ca… ▽ More It is generally accepted that the four major (Galilean) satellites formed out of the gas disk that accompanied Jupiter's formation. However, understanding the specifics of the formation process is challenging as both small particles (pebbles) as well as the satellites are subject to fast migration processes. Here, we hypothesize a new scenario for the origin of the Galilean system, based on the capture of several planetesimal seeds and subsequent slow accretion of pebbles. To halt migration, we invoke an inner disk truncation radius, and other parameters are tuned for the model to match physical, dynamical, compositional, and structural constraints. In our scenario it is natural that Ganymede's mass is determined by pebble isolation. Our slow-pebble-accretion scenario then reproduces the following characteristics: (1) the mass of all the Galilean satellites; (2) the orbits of Io, Europa, and Ganymede captured in mutual 2:1 mean motion resonances; (3) the ice mass fractions of all the Galilean satellites; (4) the unique ice-rock partially differentiated Callisto and the complete differentiation of the other satellites. Our scenario is unique to simultaneously reproduce these disparate properties. △ Less

Submitted 28 October, 2019; v1 submitted 31 August, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: 25 pages, 11 figures, 6 tables, accepted for publication in ApJ

How planets grow by pebble accretion II: Analytical calculations on the evolution of polluted envelopes

Authors: M. G. Brouwers, C. W. Ormel

Abstract: Proto-planets embedded in their natal disks acquire hot envelopes as they grow and accrete solids. This ensures that the material they accrete - pebbles, as well as (small) planetesimals - will vaporize to enrich their atmospheres. Enrichment modifies an envelope's structure and significantly alters its further evolution. Our aim is to describe the formation of planets with polluted envelopes from… ▽ More Proto-planets embedded in their natal disks acquire hot envelopes as they grow and accrete solids. This ensures that the material they accrete - pebbles, as well as (small) planetesimals - will vaporize to enrich their atmospheres. Enrichment modifies an envelope's structure and significantly alters its further evolution. Our aim is to describe the formation of planets with polluted envelopes from the moment that impactors begin to sublimate to beyond the disk's eventual dissipation. We constructed an analytical interior structure model, characterized by a hot and uniformly mixed high-Z vapor layer surrounding the core, located below the usual unpolluted radiative-convective regions. The evolution of planets with uniformly mixed polluted envelopes follows four potential phases. Initially, the central core grows directly through impacts and rainout until the envelope becomes hot enough to vaporize and absorb all incoming solids. We find that a planet reaches runaway accretion when the sum of its core and vapor mass exceeds a value that we refer to as the critical metal mass - a criterion that supersedes the traditional critical core mass. It scales positively with both the pollutant's evaporation temperature and with the planet's core mass. Hence, planets at shorter orbital separations require the accretion of more solids to reach runaway as they accrete less volatile materials. If the solids accretion rate dries up, we identify the decline of the mean molecular weight - dilution - as a mechanism to limit gas accretion during a polluted planet's embedded cooling phase. When the disk ultimately dissipates, the envelope's inner temperature declines and its vapor eventually rains out, augmenting the mass of the core. The energy release that accompanies this does not result in significant mass-loss, as it only occurs after the planet has substantially contracted. △ Less

Submitted 2 January, 2020; v1 submitted 7 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: 18 pages, 11 figures. Published in A&A

Journal ref: A&A 634, A15 (2020)

Spinning up planetary bodies by pebble accretion

Authors: R. G. Visser, C. W. Ormel, C. Dominik, S. Ida

Abstract: Most major planetary bodies in the solar system rotate in the same direction as their orbital motion: their spin is prograde. Theoretical studies to explain the direction as well as the magnitude of the spin vector have had mixed success. When the accreting building blocks are $\sim$ km-size planetesimals -- as predicted by the classical model -- the accretion process is so symmetric that it cance… ▽ More Most major planetary bodies in the solar system rotate in the same direction as their orbital motion: their spin is prograde. Theoretical studies to explain the direction as well as the magnitude of the spin vector have had mixed success. When the accreting building blocks are $\sim$ km-size planetesimals -- as predicted by the classical model -- the accretion process is so symmetric that it cancels out prograde with retrograde spin contributions, rendering the net spin minute. For this reason, the currently-favored model for the origin of planetary rotation is the giant impact model, in which a single collision suffices to deliver a spin, which magnitude is close to the breakup rotation rate. However, the giant impact model does not naturally explain the preference for prograde spin. Similarly, an increasing number of spin-vector measurement of asteroids also shows that the spin vector of large (primordial) asteroids is not isotropic. Here, we re-assess the viability of smaller particles to bestow planetary bodies with a net spin, focusing on the pebble accretion model in which gas drag and gravity join forces to accrete small particles at a large cross section. Similar to the classical calculation for planetesimals, we integrate the pebble equation of motion and measure the angular momentum transfer at impact. We consider a variety of disk conditions and pebble properties and conduct our calculations in the limits of 2D (planar) and 3D (homogeneous) pebble distributions. We find that in certain regions of the parameter space the angular momentum transfer is significant, much larger than with planetesimals and on par with or exceeding the current spin of planetary bodies. △ Less

Submitted 16 July, 2019; v1 submitted 9 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: Accepted for publication in Icarus

Pebble-driven planet formation for TRAPPIST-1 and other compact systems

Authors: Djoeke Schoonenberg, Beibei Liu, Chris W. Ormel, Caroline Dorn

Abstract: Recently, seven Earth-sized planets were discovered around the M-dwarf star TRAPPIST-1. Thanks to transit-timing variations, the masses and therefore the bulk densities of the planets have been constrained, suggesting that all TRAPPIST-1 planets are consistent with water mass fractions on the order of 10%. These water fractions, as well as the similar planet masses within the system, constitute st… ▽ More Recently, seven Earth-sized planets were discovered around the M-dwarf star TRAPPIST-1. Thanks to transit-timing variations, the masses and therefore the bulk densities of the planets have been constrained, suggesting that all TRAPPIST-1 planets are consistent with water mass fractions on the order of 10%. These water fractions, as well as the similar planet masses within the system, constitute strong constraints on the origins of the TRAPPIST-1 system. In a previous work, we outlined a pebble-driven formation scenario. In this paper we investigate this formation scenario in more detail. We used a Lagrangian smooth-particle method to model the growth and drift of pebbles and the conversion of pebbles to planetesimals through the streaming instability. We used the N-body code \texttt{MERCURY} to follow the composition of planetesimals as they grow into protoplanets by merging and accreting pebbles. This code is adapted to account for pebble accretion, type-I migration, and gas drag. In this way, we modelled the entire planet formation process (pertaining to planet masses and compositions, not dynamical configuration). We find that planetesimals form in a single, early phase of streaming instability. The initially narrow annulus of planetesimals outside the snowline quickly broadens due to scattering. Our simulation results confirm that this formation pathway indeed leads to similarly-sized planets and is highly efficient in turning pebbles into planets ($\sim$50% solids-to-planets conversion efficiency). [...] The water content of planets resulting from our simulations is on the order of 10%, and our results predict a `V-shaped' trend in the planet water fraction with orbital distance: from relatively high (innermost planets) to relatively low (intermediate planets) to relatively high (outermost planets). △ Less

Submitted 15 June, 2019; v1 submitted 3 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Comments: 16 pages, accepted for publication in A&A, abstract abridged

Journal ref: A&A 627, A149 (2019)

Growth after the streaming instability: from planetesimal accretion to pebble accretion

Authors: Beibei Liu, Chris W. Ormel, Anders Johansen

Abstract: Streaming instability is a key mechanism in planet formation, clustering pebbles into planetesimals. It is triggered at a particular disk location where the local volume density of solids exceeds that of the gas. After their formation, planetesimals can grow by feeding from other planetesimals in the birth ring as well as by accreting inwardly drifting pebbles from the outer disk. To investigate… ▽ More Streaming instability is a key mechanism in planet formation, clustering pebbles into planetesimals. It is triggered at a particular disk location where the local volume density of solids exceeds that of the gas. After their formation, planetesimals can grow by feeding from other planetesimals in the birth ring as well as by accreting inwardly drifting pebbles from the outer disk. To investigate the growth of planetesimals at a single location by the streaming instability, we test the conditions under which super-Earths are able to form within the lifetime of the gaseous disk. We modify the \texttt{Mercury} N-body code to trace the growth and dynamical evolution of a swarm of planetesimals at the ice line for a solar-mass star. Three distributions of planetesimal sizes are investigated: (i) a mono-dispersed population of 400 km radius planetesimals, (ii) a poly-dispersed populations of planetesimals from 200 km up to 1000 km, (iii) a bimodal distribution with a single runaway body and a swarm of smaller, 100 km size planetesimals. The mono-disperse population of 400 km size planetesimals cannot form $\gtrsim$ Earth mass protoplanets. Their velocity dispersions are quickly excited, which suppresses both planetesimal and pebble accretion. Planets can form from the poly-dispersed and bimodal distributions. In these circumstances, the two-component nature damps the random velocity of the large embryo by small planetesimals' dynamical friction, allowing the embryo to accrete pebbles efficiently when it approaches $10^{-2}$ Earth mass. We find that super-Earth planets are preferred to form when the pebble mass flux is higher, the disk turbulence is lower, or the Stokes number of the pebbles is higher. △ Less

Submitted 26 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: 13 pages, 9 pages, accepted in A&A

Journal ref: A&A 624, A114 (2019)

The ARCiS framework for Exoplanet Atmospheres: The Cloud Transport Model

Authors: Chris W. Ormel, Michiel Min

Abstract: Understanding of clouds is instrumental in interpreting current and future spectroscopic observations of exoplanets. Modelling clouds consistently is complex, since it involves many facets of chemistry, nucleation theory, condensation physics, coagulation, and particle transport. We develop a simple physical model for cloud formation and transport, efficient and versatile enough that it can be use… ▽ More Understanding of clouds is instrumental in interpreting current and future spectroscopic observations of exoplanets. Modelling clouds consistently is complex, since it involves many facets of chemistry, nucleation theory, condensation physics, coagulation, and particle transport. We develop a simple physical model for cloud formation and transport, efficient and versatile enough that it can be used in modular fashion for parameter optimization searches of exoplanet atmosphere spectra. The transport equations are formulated in 1D, accounting for sedimentation and diffusion. The grain size is obtained through a moment method. For simplicity, only one cloud species is considered and the nucleation rate is parametrized. From the resulting physical profiles we simulate transmission spectra covering the visual to mid-IR wavelength range. We apply our models towards KCl clouds in the atmosphere of GJ1214 b and towards MgSiO3 clouds of a canonical hot-Jupiter. We find that larger cloud diffusivity $K_{zz}$ increases the thickness of the cloud, pushing the $τ=1$ surface to a lower pressure layer higher in the atmosphere. A larger nucleation rate also increases the cloud thickness while it suppresses the grain size. Coagulation is most important at high nuclei injection rates ($\dotΣ_n$) and low $K_{zz}$. We find that the investigated combinations of $K_{zz}$ and $\dotΣ_n$ greatly affect the transmission spectra in terms of the slope at near-IR wavelength (a proxy for grain size), the molecular features seen at ~1\micr (which disappear for thick clouds, high in the atmosphere), and the 10\micr silicate feature, which becomes prominent for small grains high in the atmosphere. The result of our hybrid approach -- aimed to provide a good balance between physical consistency and computational efficiency -- is ideal towards interpreting (future) spectroscopic observations of exoplanets. △ Less

Submitted 23 January, 2019; v1 submitted 12 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Comments: language and other tiny corrections

Journal ref: A&A 622, A121 (2019)

Contribution of the core to the thermal evolution of sub-Neptunes

Authors: A. Vazan, C. W. Ormel, L. Noack, C. Dominik

Abstract: Sub-Neptune planets are a very common type of planets. They are inferred to harbour a primordial (H/He) envelope, on top of a (rocky) core, which dominates the mass. Here, we investigate the long-term consequences of the core properties on the planet mass-radius relation. We consider the role of various core energy sources resulting from core formation, its differentiation, its solidification (lat… ▽ More Sub-Neptune planets are a very common type of planets. They are inferred to harbour a primordial (H/He) envelope, on top of a (rocky) core, which dominates the mass. Here, we investigate the long-term consequences of the core properties on the planet mass-radius relation. We consider the role of various core energy sources resulting from core formation, its differentiation, its solidification (latent heat), core contraction and radioactive decay. We divide the evolution of the rocky core into three phases: the formation phase, which sets the initial conditions, the magma ocean phase, characterized by rapid heat transport, and the solid state phase, where cooling is inefficient. We find that for typical sub-Neptune planets of ~2-10 Earth masses and envelope mass fractions of 0.5-10% the magma ocean phase lasts several Gyrs, much longer than for terrestrial planets. The magma ocean phase effectively erases any signs of the initial core thermodynamic state. After solidification, the reduced heat flux from the rocky core causes a significant drop in the rocky core surface temperature, but its effect on the planet radius is limited. In the long run, radioactive heating is the most significant core energy source in our model. Overall, the long term radius uncertainty by core thermal effects is up to 15%. △ Less

Submitted 13 January, 2019; v1 submitted 6 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Comments: ApJ Published

Journal ref: The Astrophysical Journal, Volume 869, Issue 2, article id. 163, 11 pp. (2018)

A Lagrangian Model for Dust Evolution in Protoplanetary Disks: Formation of Wet and Dry Planetesimals at Different Stellar Masses

Authors: Djoeke Schoonenberg, Chris W. Ormel, Sebastiaan Krijt

Abstract: We introduce a new Lagrangian smooth-particle method to model the growth and drift of pebbles in protoplanetary disks. The Lagrangian nature of the model makes it especially suited to follow characteristics of individual (groups of) particles, such as their composition. In this work we focus on the water content of solid particles. Planetesimal formation via streaming instability is taken into acc… ▽ More We introduce a new Lagrangian smooth-particle method to model the growth and drift of pebbles in protoplanetary disks. The Lagrangian nature of the model makes it especially suited to follow characteristics of individual (groups of) particles, such as their composition. In this work we focus on the water content of solid particles. Planetesimal formation via streaming instability is taken into account, partly based on previous results on streaming instability outside the water snowline that were presented in Schoonenberg & Ormel (2017). We validate our model by reproducing earlier results from the literature and apply our model to steady-state viscous gas disks (with constant gas accretion rate) around stars with different masses. We also present various other models where we explore the effects of pebble accretion, the fragmentation velocity threshold, the global metallicity of the disk, and a time-dependent gas accretion rate. We find that planetesimals preferentially form in a local annulus outside the water snowline, at early times in the lifetime of the disk ($\lesssim$$10^{5} \: \rm{yr}$), when the pebble mass fluxes are high enough to trigger the streaming instability. During this first phase in the planet formation process, the snowline location hardly changes due to slow viscous evolution, and we conclude that assuming a constant gas accretion rate is justified in this first stage. The efficiency of converting the solids reservoir of the disk to planetesimals depends on the location of the water snowline. Cooler disks with a closer-in water snowline are more efficient at producing planetesimals than hotter disks where the water snowline is located further away from the star. Therefore, low-mass stars tend to form planetesimals more efficiently, but any correlation may be overshadowed by the spread in disk properties. △ Less

Submitted 4 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 18 pages, 15 figures, accepted for publication in A&A

Journal ref: A&A 620, A134 (2018)

Radial and vertical dust transport inhibit refractory carbon depletion in protoplanetary disks

Authors: L. Klarmann, C. W. Ormel, C. Dominik

Abstract: The Earth is strongly depleted in carbon compared to the dust in the ISM, implying efficient removal of refractory carbon before parent body formation. It has been argued that grains get rid of their carbon through oxidation and photolysis in the exposed upper disk layers. We assess the efficacy of these C-removal mechanisms accounting for the vertical and radial transport of grains. We obtain the… ▽ More The Earth is strongly depleted in carbon compared to the dust in the ISM, implying efficient removal of refractory carbon before parent body formation. It has been argued that grains get rid of their carbon through oxidation and photolysis in the exposed upper disk layers. We assess the efficacy of these C-removal mechanisms accounting for the vertical and radial transport of grains. We obtain the carbon and carbon free mass budget of solids by solving two 1D advection-diffusion equations, accounting for the dust grain size distribution and radial transport. The carbon removal acts on the fraction of the grains that are in the exposed layer and requires efficient vertical transport. In models without radial transport, oxidation and photolysis can destroy most of the refractory carbon in terrestrial planet formation region. But it only reaches the observed depletion levels for extreme parameter combinations and requires that parent body formation was delayed by 1 Myr. Adding radial transport of solids prevents the depletion entirely, leaving refractory carbon equally distributed throughout the disk. It is unlikely that the observed carbon depletion can ultimately be attributed to mechanisms operating on small grains in the disk surface layers. Other mechanisms need to be studied, for example flash heating events or FU Ori outbursts in order to remove carbon quickly and deeply. However, a sustained drift barrier or strongly reduced radial grain mobility are necessary to prevent replenishment of carbon from the outer disk. △ Less

Submitted 5 September, 2018; originally announced September 2018.

Comments: 8 pages, 3 figures, 2 tables, accepted for publication at A&A

Journal ref: A&A 618, L1 (2018)

Catching drifting pebbles II. A stochastic equation of motions for pebbles

Authors: Chris W. Ormel, Beibei Liu

Abstract: Turbulence plays a key role in the transport of pebble-sized particles. It also affects the ability of pebbles to be accreted by protoplanets, because it stirs pebbles out of the disk midplane. In addition, turbulence can suppress pebble accretion once the relative velocities become too large for the settling mechanism to be viable. Following Paper I, we aim to quantify these effects by calculatin… ▽ More Turbulence plays a key role in the transport of pebble-sized particles. It also affects the ability of pebbles to be accreted by protoplanets, because it stirs pebbles out of the disk midplane. In addition, turbulence can suppress pebble accretion once the relative velocities become too large for the settling mechanism to be viable. Following Paper I, we aim to quantify these effects by calculating the pebble accretion efficiency $\varepsilon$ using three-body simulations. To model the effect of turbulence on the pebbles, we derive a stochastic equation of motion (SEOM) applicable to stratified disk configurations. In the strong coupling limit (ignoring particle inertia) the limiting form of this equation agrees with previous works. We conduct a parameter study and calculate $\varepsilon$ in 3D, varying pebble and gas (turbulence) properties and accounting for the planet inclination. We find that strong turbulence suppresses pebble accretion through turbulent diffusion, agreeing within factors of order unity with previous works. Another reduction of $\varepsilon$ occurs when the turbulent rms motions are large and the settling mechanism fails. Efficiency-wise, the outer disk regions are more affected by turbulence than the inner regions. At the location of the H$_2$O iceline, planets around low-mass stars achieve much higher efficiencies. Including the results from Paper I, we present a framework to obtain $\varepsilon$ under general circumstances. △ Less

Submitted 9 April, 2018; v1 submitted 16 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: accepted version

Journal ref: A&A 615, A178 (2018)

Catching drifting pebbles I. Enhanced pebble accretion efficiencies for eccentric planets

Authors: Beibei Liu, Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: Coagulation theory predicts that micron-sized dust grains grow into pebbles which drift inward towards the star, when they reach sizes of mm-cm. When they cross the orbit of a planet, a fraction of these drifting pebbles will be accreted. In the pebble accretion mechanism, the combined effects of the planet's gravitational attraction and gas drag greatly increase the accretion rate. We calculate t… ▽ More Coagulation theory predicts that micron-sized dust grains grow into pebbles which drift inward towards the star, when they reach sizes of mm-cm. When they cross the orbit of a planet, a fraction of these drifting pebbles will be accreted. In the pebble accretion mechanism, the combined effects of the planet's gravitational attraction and gas drag greatly increase the accretion rate. We calculate the pebble accretion efficiency $\varepsilon_{2D}$ -- the probability a pebble is accreted by the planet -- in the 2D limit (pebbles reside in the midplane). In particular, we investigate the dependence of $\varepsilon_{2D}$ on the planet eccentricity and its implications for planet formation models. We conduct N-body simulations to calculate the pebble accretion efficiency in both the local frame and the global frame. With the global method we investigate the pebble accretion efficiency when the planet is on an eccentric orbit. We find that the local and the global methods generally give consistent results. The efficiency increases with the planet's eccentricity once the relative velocity between the pebble and the planet is determined by the planet's eccentric velocity. At large eccentricities, however, the relative velocity becomes too large for pebble accretion. The efficiency then drops significantly and the accretion enters the ballistic regime. We present general expressions for $\varepsilon_{2D}$. Applying the obtained formula to the formation of a secondary planet, in resonance with an already-formed giant planet, we find that the embryo grows quickly due to its larger eccentricity. The maximum $\varepsilon_{2D}$ for a planet on an eccentric orbit is several times higher than for a planet on a circular orbit, but this increase gives the planet an important headstart and boosts its following mass growth. △ Less

Submitted 17 April, 2018; v1 submitted 16 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: 12 pages, 6 figures, A&A in press

Journal ref: A&A 615, A138 (2018)

Pebble dynamics and accretion onto rocky planets. I. Adiabatic and convective models

Authors: A. Popovas, Å. Nordlund, Jon P. Ramsey, Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: We present nested-grid, high-resolution hydrodynamic simulations of gas and particle dynamics in the vicinity of Mars- to Earth-mass planetary embryos. The simulations extend from the surface of the embryos to a few vertical disk scale heights, with \rev{a spatial} dynamic range \rev{of} $\sim\! 1.4\times 10^5$. Our results confirm that "pebble"-sized particles are readily accreted, with accretion… ▽ More We present nested-grid, high-resolution hydrodynamic simulations of gas and particle dynamics in the vicinity of Mars- to Earth-mass planetary embryos. The simulations extend from the surface of the embryos to a few vertical disk scale heights, with \rev{a spatial} dynamic range \rev{of} $\sim\! 1.4\times 10^5$. Our results confirm that "pebble"-sized particles are readily accreted, with accretion rates continuing to increase up to metre-size "boulders" for a 10\% MMSN surface density model. The gas mass flux in and out of the Hill sphere is consistent with the Hill rate, $ΣΩR_\mathrm{H}^2 = 4\, 10^{-3}$ M$_\oplus$ yr$^{-1}$. While smaller size particles mainly track the gas, a net accretion rate of $\approx 2\,10^{-5}$ M$_\oplus$ yr$^{-1}$ is reached for 0.3--1 cm particles, even though a significant fraction leaves the Hill sphere again. Effectively all pebble-sized particles that cross the Bondi sphere are accreted. The resolution of these simulations is sufficient to resolve accretion-driven convection. Convection driven by a nominal accretion rate of $10^{-6}$ M$_\oplus$ yr$^{-1}$ does not significantly alter the pebble accretion rate. We find that, due to cancellation effects, accretion rates of pebble-sized particles are nearly independent of disk surface density. As a result, we can estimate accurate growth times for specified particle sizes. For 0.3--1 cm size particles, the growth time from a small seed is $\sim$0.15 million years for an Earth mass planet at 1 AU and $\sim$0.1 million years for a Mars mass planet at 1.5 AU. △ Less

Submitted 30 July, 2018; v1 submitted 23 January, 2018; originally announced January 2018.

Comments: 19 pages, 21 figures, update includes accepted version, MNRAS 479, 5136--5156 (2018)

Effect of Core Cooling on the Radius of Sub-Neptune Planets

Authors: A. Vazan, C. W. Ormel, C. Dominik

Abstract: Sub-Neptune planets are very common in our galaxy and show a large diversity in their mass-radius relation. In sub-Neptunes most of the planet mass is in the rocky part (hereafter core) which is surrounded by a modest hydrogen-helium envelope. As a result, the total initial heat content of such a planet is dominated by that of the core. Nonetheless, most studies contend that the core cooling will… ▽ More Sub-Neptune planets are very common in our galaxy and show a large diversity in their mass-radius relation. In sub-Neptunes most of the planet mass is in the rocky part (hereafter core) which is surrounded by a modest hydrogen-helium envelope. As a result, the total initial heat content of such a planet is dominated by that of the core. Nonetheless, most studies contend that the core cooling will only have a minor effect on the radius evolution of the gaseous envelope, because the core's cooling is in sync with the envelope, i.e., most of the initial heat is released early on timescales of about 10-100 Myr. In this Letter we examine the importance of the core cooling rate for the thermal evolution of the envelope. Thus, we relax the early core cooling assumption and present a model where the core is characterized by two parameters: the initial temperature and the cooling time. We find that core cooling can significantly enhance the radius of the planet when it operates on a timescale similar to the observed age, i.e. several Gyr. Consequently, the interpretation of sub-Neptunes' mass-radius observations depends on the assumed core thermal properties and the uncertainty therein. The degeneracy of composition and core thermal properties can be reduced by obtaining better estimates of the planet ages (in addition to their radii and masses) as envisioned by future observations. △ Less

Submitted 17 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Comments: Accepted for publication in A&A Letters

Journal ref: A&A 610, L1 (2018)

How cores grow by pebble accretion I. Direct core growth

Authors: M. G. Brouwers, A. Vazan, C. W. Ormel

Abstract: Context: Planet formation by pebble accretion is an alternative to planetesimal-driven core accretion. In this scenario, planets grow by accreting cm-to-m-sized pebbles instead of km-sized planetesimals. One of the main differences with planetesimal-driven core accretion is the increased thermal ablation experienced by pebbles. This provides early enrichment to the planet's envelope, which changes… ▽ More Context: Planet formation by pebble accretion is an alternative to planetesimal-driven core accretion. In this scenario, planets grow by accreting cm-to-m-sized pebbles instead of km-sized planetesimals. One of the main differences with planetesimal-driven core accretion is the increased thermal ablation experienced by pebbles. This provides early enrichment to the planet's envelope, which changes the process of core growth. Aims: We aim to predict core masses and envelope compositions of planets that form by pebble accretion and compare mass deposition of pebbles to planetesimals. Methods: We model the early growth of a proto-planet by calculating the structure of its envelope, taking into account the fate of impacting pebbles or planetesimals. The region where high-Z material can exist in vapor form is determined by the vapor pressure. We include enrichment effects by locally modifying the mean molecular weight. Results: In the pebble case, three phases of core growth can be identified. In the first phase, pebbles impact the core without significant ablation. During the second phase, ablation becomes increasingly severe. A layer of high-Z vapor starts to form around the core that absorbs a small fraction of the ablated mass. The rest either rains out to the core or mixes outwards instead, slowing core growth. In the third phase, the vapor inner region expands outwards, absorbing an increasing fraction of the ablated material as vapor. Rainout ends before the core mass reaches 0.6 M_Earth, terminating direct core growth. In the case of icy H2O pebbles, this happens before 0.1 M_Earth. Conclusions: Our results indicate that pebble accretion can directly form rocky cores up to only 0.6 M_Earth, and is unable to form similarly sized icy cores. Subsequent core growth can proceed indirectly when the planet cools, provided it is able to retain its high-Z material. △ Less

Submitted 7 August, 2019; v1 submitted 17 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Comments: 12 pages, 6 figures. Published in A&A. Includes corrigendum to Sect. 4.2

Journal ref: A&A, 611, A65 (2018)

What pebbles are made of: Interpretation of the V883 Ori disk

Authors: Djoeke Schoonenberg, Satoshi Okuzumi, Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: Recently, an Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) observation of the water snow line in the protoplanetary disk around the FU Orionis star V883 Ori was reported. The radial variation of the spectral index at mm-wavelengths around the snow line was interpreted as being due to a pileup of particles interior to the snow line. However, radial transport of solids in the outer disk operat… ▽ More Recently, an Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) observation of the water snow line in the protoplanetary disk around the FU Orionis star V883 Ori was reported. The radial variation of the spectral index at mm-wavelengths around the snow line was interpreted as being due to a pileup of particles interior to the snow line. However, radial transport of solids in the outer disk operates on timescales much longer than the typical timescale of an FU Ori outburst ($10^{1}$--$10^{2}$ yr). Consequently, a steady-state pileup is unlikely. We argue that it is only necessary to consider water evaporation and re-coagulation of silicates to explain the recent ALMA observation of V883 Ori because these processes are short enough to have had their impact since the outburst. Our model requires the inner disk to have already been optically thick before the outburst, and our results suggest that the carbon content of pebbles is low. △ Less

Submitted 10 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Comments: Accepted to A&A Letters

Dynamical rearrangement of super-Earths during disk dispersal II. Assessment of the magnetospheric rebound model for planet formation scenarios

Authors: Beibei Liu, Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: Context.The Kepler mission has provided a large sample to statistically analyze the orbital properties of the super-Earth planets. We hypothesize that these planets formed early and consider the problem of matching planet formation theory to the current observations. Two scenarios, disk migration and in-situ formation, have been proposed to explain their origin. In the migration scenario planets m… ▽ More Context.The Kepler mission has provided a large sample to statistically analyze the orbital properties of the super-Earth planets. We hypothesize that these planets formed early and consider the problem of matching planet formation theory to the current observations. Two scenarios, disk migration and in-situ formation, have been proposed to explain their origin. In the migration scenario planets migrate inward due to planet-disk interaction, whereas in the in-situ scenario planets assemble locally. Therefore, planets formed by migration are expected to end up in resonances, whereas those formed in-situ are expected to stay in short period ratios and in non-resonant orbits. Both predictions are at odds with observations. Aims. We investigate whether a preferred formation scenario can be identified through a comparison between the magnetospheric rebound model and the Kepler data. Methods. We conduct N-body simulations of two-planet systems during the disk dispersal phase, and make a statistical comparison between the simulations and the Kepler observations. Results. Comparing the two scenarios, we find that magnetospheric rebound tends to erase the difference in the orbital configuration that was initially presented. After disk dispersal, not all planets are in resonance in the migration scenario, whereas planets do not remain in compact configurations in the in-situ scenario. In both scenarios, the orbits of planets increase with the cavity expansion, and their period ratios have a wider distribution. Conclusions. From a statistical perspective, the magnetospheric rebound model reproduces several observed properties of Kepler planets, such as the significant number of planets are not in resonances and planet pairs can end up at large period ratios. The disparity in orbital configuration between the two formation scenarios is substantially reduced after disk dispersal. △ Less

Submitted 3 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Comments: 8 pages, 4 figures, accepted for publication in A&A

Journal ref: A&A 606, A66 (2017)

Hydrodynamics of embedded planets' first atmospheres - III. The role of radiation transport for super-Earth planets

Authors: Nicolas P. Cimerman, Rolf Kuiper, Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: The population of close-in super-Earths, with gas mass fractions of up to 10% represents a challenge for planet formation theory: how did they avoid runaway gas accretion and collapsing to hot Jupiters despite their core masses being in the critical range of $M_\mathrm{c} \simeq 10 M_\mathrm{\oplus}$? Previous three-dimensional (3D) hydrodynamical simulations indicate that atmospheres of low-mass… ▽ More The population of close-in super-Earths, with gas mass fractions of up to 10% represents a challenge for planet formation theory: how did they avoid runaway gas accretion and collapsing to hot Jupiters despite their core masses being in the critical range of $M_\mathrm{c} \simeq 10 M_\mathrm{\oplus}$? Previous three-dimensional (3D) hydrodynamical simulations indicate that atmospheres of low-mass planets cannot be considered isolated from the protoplanetary disc, contrary to what is assumed in 1D-evolutionary calculations. This finding is referred to as the recycling hypothesis. In this Paper we investigate the recycling hypothesis for super-Earth planets, accounting for realistic 3D radiation hydrodynamics. Also, we conduct a direct comparison in terms of the evolution of the entropy between 1D and 3D geometries. We clearly see that 3D atmospheres maintain higher entropy: although gas in the atmosphere loses entropy through radiative cooling, the advection of high entropy gas from the disc into the Bondi/Hill sphere slows down Kelvin-Helmholtz contraction, potentially arresting envelope growth at a sub-critical gas mass fraction. Recycling, therefore, operates vigorously, in line with results by previous studies. However, we also identify an "inner core" -- in size $\approx$ 25% of the Bondi radius -- where streamlines are more circular and entropies are much lower than in the outer atmosphere. Future studies at higher resolutions are needed to assess whether this region can become hydrodynamically-isolated on long time-scales. △ Less

Submitted 25 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: 16 pages, 12 figures, accepted for publication at MNRAS

Planetesimal formation near the snowline: in or out?

Authors: Djoeke Schoonenberg, Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: The formation of planetesimals in protoplanetary disks is not well-understood. Streaming instability is a promising mechanism to directly form planetesimals from pebble-sized particles, provided a high enough solids-to-gas ratio. However, local enhancements of the solids-to-gas ratio are difficult to realize in a smooth disk, which motivates the consideration of special disk locations such as the… ▽ More The formation of planetesimals in protoplanetary disks is not well-understood. Streaming instability is a promising mechanism to directly form planetesimals from pebble-sized particles, provided a high enough solids-to-gas ratio. However, local enhancements of the solids-to-gas ratio are difficult to realize in a smooth disk, which motivates the consideration of special disk locations such as the snowline. In this article we investigate the viability of planetesimal formation by streaming instability near the snowline due to water diffusion and condensation. We adopt a viscous disk model, and numerically solve the transport equations for vapor and solids on a cylindrical, 1D grid. We take into account radial drift of solids, gas accretion on to the central star, and turbulent diffusion. We study the importance of the back-reaction of solids on the gas and of the radial variation of the mean molecular weight of the gas. We find that water diffusion and condensation can locally enhance the ice surface density by a factor 3--5 outside the snowline. Assuming that icy pebbles contain many micron-sized silicate grains that are released during evaporation, the enhancement is increased by another factor $\sim$$2$. In this `many-seeds' model, the solids-to-gas ratio interior to the snowline is enhanced as well, but not as much as just outside the snowline. In the context of a viscous disk, the diffusion-condensation mechanism is most effective for high values of the turbulence parameter $α$ ($10^{-3}$--$10^{-2}$). Therefore, assuming young disks are more vigorously turbulent than older disks, planetesimals near the snowline can form in an early stage of the disk. In highly turbulent disks, tens of Earth masses can be stored in an annulus outside the snowline, which can be identified with recent ALMA observations. △ Less

Submitted 7 February, 2017; originally announced February 2017.

Comments: 19 pages, 11 figures; abstract abridged to meet arXiv requirements. Accepted for publication in A&A

Journal ref: A&A 602, A21 (2017)

Dynamical rearrangement of super-Earths during disk dispersal I. Outline of the magnetospheric rebound model

Authors: Beibei Liu, Chris W. Ormel, Douglas N. C. Lin

Abstract: The Kepler mission has discovered that multiple close-in super-Earth planets are common around solar-type stars, but their period ratios do not show strong pile-ups near mean motion resonances (MMRs). One scenario is that super-Earths form in a gas-rich disk, and they interact gravitationally with the surrounding gas, inducing their orbital migration. Disk migration theory predicts, however, that… ▽ More The Kepler mission has discovered that multiple close-in super-Earth planets are common around solar-type stars, but their period ratios do not show strong pile-ups near mean motion resonances (MMRs). One scenario is that super-Earths form in a gas-rich disk, and they interact gravitationally with the surrounding gas, inducing their orbital migration. Disk migration theory predicts, however, that planets would end up at resonant orbits due to their differential migration speed. Motivated by the discrepancy between observation and theory, we seek for a mechanism that moves planets out of resonances. We examine the orbital evolution of planet pairs near the magnetospheric cavity during the gas disk dispersal phase. Our study determines the conditions under which planets can escape resonances. We perform two-planet N-body simulations, varying the planet masses, stellar magnetic field strengths, disk accretion rates and gas disk depletion timescales. As planets migrate outward with the expanding magnetospheric cavity, their dynamical configurations can be rearranged. Migration of planets is substantial (minor) in a massive (light) disk. When the outer planet is more massive than the inner planet, the period ratio of two planets increases through outward migration. On the other hand, when the inner planet is more massive, the final period ratio tends to remain similar to the initial one. Larger stellar magnetic field strengths result in planets stop** their migration at longer periods. We highlight \textit{magnetospheric rebound} as an important ingredient able to reconcile disk migration theory with observations. Even when planets are trapped into MMR during the early gas-rich stage, subsequent cavity expansion would induce substantial changes to their orbits, moving them out of resonance. △ Less

Submitted 7 February, 2017; originally announced February 2017.

Comments: 10 pages, 5 figures, accepted for publication in A&A

Journal ref: A&A 601, A15 (2017)

Effect of turbulence on collisions of dust particles with planetesimals in protoplanetary disks

Authors: H. Homann, T. Guillot, J. Bec, C. W. Ormel, S. Ida, P. Tanga

Abstract: Planetesimals in gaseous protoplanetary disks may grow by collecting dust particles. Hydrodynamical studies show that small particles generally avoid collisions with the planetesimals because they are entrained by the flow around them. This occurs when $St$, the Stokes number, defined as the ratio of the dust stop** time to the planetesimal crossing time, becomes much smaller than unity. However… ▽ More Planetesimals in gaseous protoplanetary disks may grow by collecting dust particles. Hydrodynamical studies show that small particles generally avoid collisions with the planetesimals because they are entrained by the flow around them. This occurs when $St$, the Stokes number, defined as the ratio of the dust stop** time to the planetesimal crossing time, becomes much smaller than unity. However, these studies have been limited to the laminar case, whereas these disks are believed to be turbulent. We want to estimate the influence of gas turbulence on the dust-planetesimal collision rate and on the impact speeds. We used three-dimensional direct numerical simulations of a fixed sphere (planetesimal) facing a laminar and turbulent flow seeded with small inertial particles (dust) subject to a Stokes drag. A no-slip boundary condition on the planetesimal surface is modeled via a penalty method. We find that turbulence can significantly increase the collision rate of dust particles with planetesimals. For a high turbulence case (when the amplitude of turbulent fluctuations is similar to the headwind velocity), we find that the collision probability remains equal to the geometrical rate or even higher for $St\geq 0.1$, i.e., for dust sizes an order of magnitude smaller than in the laminar case. We derive expressions to calculate impact probabilities as a function of dust and planetesimal size and turbulent intensity. △ Less

Submitted 9 February, 2016; originally announced February 2016.

Journal ref: A&A 589, A129 (2016)

A panoptic model for planetesimal formation and pebble delivery

Authors: Sebastiaan Krijt, Chris W. Ormel, Carsten Dominik, Alexander G. G. M. Tielens

Abstract: The journey from dust particle to planetesimal involves physical processes acting on scales ranging from micrometers (the sticking and restructuring of aggregates) to hundreds of astronomical units (the size of the turbulent protoplanetary nebula). Considering these processes simultaneously is essential when studying planetesimal formation. We develop a novel, global, semi-analytical model for the… ▽ More The journey from dust particle to planetesimal involves physical processes acting on scales ranging from micrometers (the sticking and restructuring of aggregates) to hundreds of astronomical units (the size of the turbulent protoplanetary nebula). Considering these processes simultaneously is essential when studying planetesimal formation. We develop a novel, global, semi-analytical model for the evolution of the mass-dominating dust particles in a turbulent protoplanetary disk that takes into account the evolution of the dust surface density while preserving the essential characteristics of the porous coagulation process. This panoptic model is used to study the growth from submicron to planetesimal sizes in disks around Sun-like stars. For highly porous ices, unaffected by collisional fragmentation and erosion, rapid growth to planetesimal sizes is possible in a zone stretching out to ${\sim}10\mathrm{~AU}$ for massive disks. When porous coagulation is limited by erosive collisions, the formation of planetesimals through direct coagulation is not possible, but the creation of a large population of aggregates with Stokes numbers close to unity might trigger the streaming instability (SI). However, we find that reaching conditions necessary for SI is difficult and limited to dust-rich disks, (very) cold disks, or disks with weak turbulence. Behind the snow-line, porosity-driven aggregation of icy grains results in rapid (${\sim}10^{4}\mathrm{~yr}$) formation of planetesimals. If erosive collisions prevent this, SI might be triggered for specific disk conditions. The numerical approach introduced in this work is ideally suited for studying planetesimal formation and pebble delivery simultaneously and will help build a coherent picture of the start of the planet formation process. △ Less

Submitted 24 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Comments: 13 pages, 7 figures. Accepted for publication in Astronomy & Astrophysics

Journal ref: A&A 586, A20 (2016)

On the growth of pebble-accreting planetesimals

Authors: Rico G. Visser, Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: Pebble accretion is a new mechanism to quickly grow the cores of planets. In pebble accretion, gravity and gas drag conspire to yield large collisional cross sections for small particles in protoplanetary disks. However, before pebble accretion commences, aerodynamical deflection may act to prevent planetesimals from becoming large, because particles tend to follow gas streamlines. We derive the p… ▽ More Pebble accretion is a new mechanism to quickly grow the cores of planets. In pebble accretion, gravity and gas drag conspire to yield large collisional cross sections for small particles in protoplanetary disks. However, before pebble accretion commences, aerodynamical deflection may act to prevent planetesimals from becoming large, because particles tend to follow gas streamlines. We derive the planetesimal radius where pebble accretion is initiated and determine the growth timescales of planetesimals by sweepup of small particles. We obtain the collision efficiency factor as the ratio of the numerically-obtained collisional cross section to the planetesimal surface area, from which we obtain the growth timescales. Integrations are conducted in the potential flow limit (steady, inviscid) and in the Stokes flow regime (steady, viscid). Only particles of stop** time $t_s \ll t_X$ where $t_X\approx10^3$ s experience aerodynamic deflection. Even in that case, the planetesimal's gravity always ensures positive collision factors. The maximum growth timescale occurs typically at around $R\approx100 \ \mathrm{km}$, but is less for colder disks, corresponding to interactions shifting to the Safronov focusing regime. For particles $t_s \gg t_X$ pebble accretion commences only after this phase and is characterized by a steep drop in growth timescales. Consequently, at distances beyond ~10 AU sweepup growth timescales are always longer than $10$ Myr, while in the inner disk (~<3 AU) the viability of the sweepup scenario is determined by the outcome of pebble-planetesimal collisions in the geometric regime. We present analytical fits for the collision efficiency factors and the minimum planetesimal size needed for pebble accretion. (Abridged) △ Less

Submitted 12 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Comments: Accepted for publication in Astronomy & Astrophysics

Erosion and the limits to planetesimal growth

Authors: Sebastiaan Krijt, Chris W. Ormel, Carsten Dominik, Alexander G. G. M. Tielens

Abstract: The coagulation of microscopic dust into planetesimals is the first step towards planet formation. The size and shape of the growing aggregates determine the efficiency of this early growth. It has been proposed that fluffy ice aggregates can grow very efficiently, suffering less from the bouncing and radial drift barriers. While the collision velocity between icy aggregates of similar size is tho… ▽ More The coagulation of microscopic dust into planetesimals is the first step towards planet formation. The size and shape of the growing aggregates determine the efficiency of this early growth. It has been proposed that fluffy ice aggregates can grow very efficiently, suffering less from the bouncing and radial drift barriers. While the collision velocity between icy aggregates of similar size is thought to stay below the fragmentation threshold, they may nonetheless lose mass from collisions with much smaller projectiles. We investigate the effect of these erosive collisions on the ability of porous ice aggregates to cross the radial drift barrier. We develop a Monte Carlo code that calculates the evolution of the growing aggregates, while resolving the entire mass distribution at all times. The aggregate's porosity is treated independently of its mass, and is determined by collisions, gas compaction, and eventually self-gravity compaction. For erosion threshold velocities of 20-40 m/s, high-velocity collisions with small projectiles prevent the largest aggregates from growing when they start to drift. In these cases, our local simulations result in a steady-state distribution, with the majority of the dust mass in particles with Stokes numbers close to unity. Only for the highest erosion threshold considered (60 m/s), do porous aggregates manage to cross the radial drift barrier in the inner 10 AU of MMSN-like disks. Erosive collisions are more effective in limiting the growth than fragmentary collisions between similar-size particles. Conceivably, erosion limits the growth before the radial drift barrier, although the robustness of this statement depends on (uncertain) material properties of icy aggregates. If erosion inhibits planetesimal formation through direct sticking, the sea of ${\sim}10^9$ g, highly porous particles appears well-suited for triggering streaming instability. △ Less

Submitted 11 December, 2014; originally announced December 2014.

Comments: 16 pages, 14 figures, accepted for publication in A&A

Journal ref: A&A 574, A83 (2015)

Hydrodynamics of Embedded Planets' First Atmospheres. II. A Rapid Recycling of Atmospheric Gas

Authors: Chris W. Ormel, Ji-Ming Shi, Rolf Kuiper

Abstract: Following Paper I we investigate the properties of atmospheres that form around small protoplanets embedded in a protoplanetary disc by conducting hydrodynamical simulations. These are now extended to three dimensions, employing a spherical grid centred on the planet. Compression of gas is shown to reduce rotational motions. Contrasting the 2D case, no clear boundary demarcates bound atmospheric g… ▽ More Following Paper I we investigate the properties of atmospheres that form around small protoplanets embedded in a protoplanetary disc by conducting hydrodynamical simulations. These are now extended to three dimensions, employing a spherical grid centred on the planet. Compression of gas is shown to reduce rotational motions. Contrasting the 2D case, no clear boundary demarcates bound atmospheric gas from disc material; instead, we find an open system where gas enters the Bondi sphere at high latitudes and leaves through the midplane regions, or, vice versa, when the disc gas rotates sub-Keplerian. The simulations do not converge to a time-independent solution; instead, the atmosphere is characterized by a time-varying velocity field. Of particular interest is the timescale to replenish the atmosphere by nebular gas, $t_\mathrm{replenish}$. It is shown that the replenishment rate, $M_\mathrm{atm}/t_\mathrm{replenish}$, can be understood in terms of a modified Bondi accretion rate, $\sim$$R_\mathrm{Bondi}^2ρ_\mathrm{gas}v_\mathrm{Bondi}$, where $v_\mathrm{Bondi}$ is set by the Keplerian shear or the magnitude of the sub-Keplerian motion of the gas, whichever is larger. In the inner disk, the atmosphere of embedded protoplanets replenishes on a timescale that is shorter than the Kelvin-Helmholtz contraction (or cooling) timescale. As a result, atmospheric gas can no longer contract and the growth of these atmospheres terminates. Future work must confirm whether these findings continue to apply when the (thermodynamical) idealizations employed in this study are relaxed. But if shown to be broadly applicable, replenishment of atmospheric gas provides a natural explanation for the preponderance of gas-rich but rock-dominant planets like super-Earths and mini-Neptunes. △ Less

Submitted 17 October, 2014; originally announced October 2014.

Comments: 15 pages, 13 figures, submitted to MNRAS. Comments welcome

Hydrodynamics of Embedded Planets' First Atmospheres. I. A Centrifugal Growth Barrier for 2D Flows

Authors: Chris W. Ormel, Rolf Kuiper, Ji-Ming Shi

Abstract: In the core accretion paradigm of planet formation, gas giants only form a massive atmosphere after their progenitors exceeded a threshold mass: the critical core mass. Most (exo)planets, being smaller and rock/ice-dominated, never crossed this line. Nevertheless, they were massive enough to attract substantial amounts of gas from the disc, while their atmospheres remained in pressure-equilibrium… ▽ More In the core accretion paradigm of planet formation, gas giants only form a massive atmosphere after their progenitors exceeded a threshold mass: the critical core mass. Most (exo)planets, being smaller and rock/ice-dominated, never crossed this line. Nevertheless, they were massive enough to attract substantial amounts of gas from the disc, while their atmospheres remained in pressure-equilibrium with the disc. Our goal is to characterise the hydrodynamical properties of the atmospheres of such embedded planets and their implication for their (long-term) evolution. In this paper -- the first in series -- we start to investigate the properties of an isothermal and inviscid flow past a small, embedded planet by conducting local, 2D hydrodynamical simulations. Using the PLUTO code we confirm that the flow is steady and bound. This steady outcome is most apparent for the log-polar grid (with the grid spacing proportional to the distance from the planet). For low-mass planets, Cartesian grids are somewhat less efficient as they have difficulty to follow the circular, large speeds in the deep atmosphere. Relating the amount of rotation to the gas fraction of the atmosphere, we find that more massive atmospheres rotate faster -- a finding consistent with Kelvin's circulation theorem. Rotation therefore limits the amount of gas that planets can acquire from the nebula. Dependent on the Toomre-Q parameter of the circumstellar disc, the planet's atmosphere will reach Keplerian rotation before self-gravity starts to become important. △ Less

Submitted 17 October, 2014; originally announced October 2014.

Comments: 16 pages, 12 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

On the filtering and processing of dust by planetesimals 1. Derivation of collision probabilities for non-drifting planetesimals

Authors: Tristan Guillot, Shigeru Ida, Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: Context. Circumstellar disks are known to contain a significant mass in dust ranging from micron to centimeter size. Meteorites are evidence that individual grains of those sizes were collected and assembled into planetesimals in the young solar system. Aims. We assess the efficiency of dust collection of a swarm of non-drifting planetesimals {\rev with radii ranging from 1 to $10^3$\,km and beyon… ▽ More Context. Circumstellar disks are known to contain a significant mass in dust ranging from micron to centimeter size. Meteorites are evidence that individual grains of those sizes were collected and assembled into planetesimals in the young solar system. Aims. We assess the efficiency of dust collection of a swarm of non-drifting planetesimals {\rev with radii ranging from 1 to $10^3$\,km and beyond. Methods. We calculate the collision probability of dust drifting in the disk due to gas drag by planetesimal accounting for several regimes depending on the size of the planetesimal, dust, and orbital distance: the geometric, Safronov, settling, and three-body regimes. We also include a hydrodynamical regime to account for the fact that small grains tend to be carried by the gas flow around planetesimals. Results. We provide expressions for the collision probability of dust by planetesimals and for the filtering efficiency by a swarm of planetesimals. For standard turbulence conditions (i.e., a turbulence parameter $α=10^{-2}$), filtering is found to be inefficient, meaning that when crossing a minimum-mass solar nebula (MMSN) belt of planetesimals extending between 0.1 AU and 35 AU most dust particles are eventually accreted by the central star rather than colliding with planetesimals. However, if the disk is weakly turbulent ($α=10^{-4}$) filtering becomes efficient in two regimes: (i) when planetesimals are all smaller than about 10 km in size, in which case collisions mostly take place in the geometric regime; and (ii) when planetary embryos larger than about 1000 km in size dominate the distribution, have a scale height smaller than one tenth of the gas scale height, and dust is of millimeter size or larger in which case most collisions take place in the settling regime. These two regimes have very different properties: we find that the local filtering efficiency $x_{filter,MMSN}$ scales with $r^{-7/4}$ (where $r$ is the orbital distance) in the geometric regime, but with $r^{-1/4}$ to $r^{1/4}$ in the settling regime. This implies that the filtering of dust by small planetesimals should occur close to the central star and with a short spread in orbital distances. On the other hand, the filtering by embryos in the settling regime is expected to be more gradual and determined by the extent of the disk of embryos. Dust particles much smaller than millimeter size tend only to be captured by the smallest planetesimals because they otherwise move on gas streamlines and their collisions take place in the hydrodynamical regime. Conclusions. Our results hint at an inside-out formation of planetesimals in the infant solar system because small planetesimals in the geometrical limit can filter dust much more efficiently close to the central star. However, even a fully-formed belt of planetesimals such as the MMSN only marginally captures inward-drifting dust and this seems to imply that dust in the protosolar disk has been filtered by planetesimals even smaller than 1 km (not included in this study) or that it has been assembled into planetesimals by other mechanisms (e.g., orderly growth, capture into vortexes). Further refinement of our work concerns, among other things: a quantitative description of the transition region between the hydro and settling regimes; an assessment of the role of disk turbulence for collisions, in particular in the hydro regime; and the coupling of our model to a planetesimal formation model. △ Less

Submitted 26 September, 2014; v1 submitted 25 September, 2014; originally announced September 2014.

Comments: Accepted for publication in A\&A. 31 pages, 29 figures. (Version corrected by the A\&A Language Editor)

Journal ref: A&A 572, A72 (2014)

Make Super-Earths, Not Jupiters: Accreting Nebular Gas onto Solid Cores at 0.1 AU and Beyond

Authors: Eve J. Lee, Eugene Chiang, Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: Close-in super-Earths having radii 1--4 $R_\oplus$ may possess hydrogen atmospheres comprising a few percent by mass of their rocky cores. We determine the conditions under which such atmospheres can be accreted by cores from their parent circumstellar disks. Accretion from the nebula is problematic because it is too efficient: we find that 10-$M_\oplus$ cores embedded in solar metallicity disks t… ▽ More Close-in super-Earths having radii 1--4 $R_\oplus$ may possess hydrogen atmospheres comprising a few percent by mass of their rocky cores. We determine the conditions under which such atmospheres can be accreted by cores from their parent circumstellar disks. Accretion from the nebula is problematic because it is too efficient: we find that 10-$M_\oplus$ cores embedded in solar metallicity disks tend to undergo runaway gas accretion and explode into Jupiters, irrespective of orbital location. The threat of runaway is especially dire at $\sim$0.1 AU, where solids may coagulate on timescales orders of magnitude shorter than gas clearing times; thus nascent atmospheres on close-in orbits are unlikely to be supported against collapse by planetesimal accretion. The time to runaway accretion is well approximated by the cooling time of the atmosphere's innermost convective zone, whose extent is controlled by where H$_2$ dissociates. Insofar as the temperatures characterizing H$_2$ dissociation are universal, timescales for core instability tend not to vary with orbital distance --- and to be alarmingly short for 10-$M_\oplus$ cores. Nevertheless, in the thicket of parameter space, we identify two scenarios, not mutually exclusive, that can reproduce the preponderance of percent-by-mass atmospheres for super-Earths at $\sim$0.1 AU, while still ensuring the formation of Jupiters at $\gtrsim 1$ AU. Scenario (a): planets form in disks with dust-to-gas ratios that range from $\sim$20$\times$ solar at 0.1 AU to $\sim$2$\times$ solar at 5 AU. Scenario (b): the final assembly of super-Earth cores from mergers of proto-cores --- a process that completes quickly at $\sim$0.1 AU once begun --- is delayed by gas dynamical friction until just before disk gas dissipates completely. △ Less

Submitted 8 December, 2014; v1 submitted 11 September, 2014; originally announced September 2014.

Comments: 18 pages, 10 figures, Final proofed version, 2014 ApJ, 797, 95. Includes conceptual corrections to Section 4.2 on the amount of nebular depletion required for scenario (b)

An Atmospheric Structure Equation for Grain Growth

Authors: Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: We present a method to include the evolution of the grain size and grain opacity $κ_\mathrm{gr}$ in the equations describing the structure of protoplanetary atmospheres. The key assumption of this method is that a single grain size dominates the grain size distribution at any height $r$. In addition to following grain growth, the method accounts for mass deposition by planetesimals and grain poros… ▽ More We present a method to include the evolution of the grain size and grain opacity $κ_\mathrm{gr}$ in the equations describing the structure of protoplanetary atmospheres. The key assumption of this method is that a single grain size dominates the grain size distribution at any height $r$. In addition to following grain growth, the method accounts for mass deposition by planetesimals and grain porosity. We illustrate this method by computation of a simplified atmosphere structure model. In agreement with previous works, grain coagulation is seen to be very efficient. The opacity drops to values much below the often-used `ISM-opacities' ($\sim$$1\ \mathrm{cm^2\ g}^{-1}$) and the atmosphere structure profiles for temperature and density resemble that of the grain-free case. Deposition of planetesimals in the radiative part of the atmosphere hardly influences this outcome as the added surface is quickly coagulated away. We observe a modest dependence on the internal structure (porosity), but show that filling factors cannot become too large because of compression by gas drag. △ Less

Submitted 16 June, 2014; originally announced June 2014.

Comments: 6 pages; accepted for publication in APJ Letters

Planetesimal driven migration as an explanation for observations of high levels of warm, exozodiacal dust

Authors: Amy Bonsor, Sean N. Raymond, Jean-Charles Augereau, Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: High levels of exozodiacal dust have been observed in the inner regions of a large fraction of main sequence stars. Given the short lifetime of the observed small dust grains, these 'exozodis' are difficult to explain, especially for old (>100 Myr) stars. The exozodiacal dust may be observed as excess emission in the mid-infrared, or using interferometry. We hypothesise that exozodi are sustained… ▽ More High levels of exozodiacal dust have been observed in the inner regions of a large fraction of main sequence stars. Given the short lifetime of the observed small dust grains, these 'exozodis' are difficult to explain, especially for old (>100 Myr) stars. The exozodiacal dust may be observed as excess emission in the mid-infrared, or using interferometry. We hypothesise that exozodi are sustained by planetesimals scattered by planets inwards from an outer planetesimal belt, where collision timescales are long. In this work, we use N-body simulations to show that the outwards migration of a planet into a belt, driven by the scattering of planetesimals, can increase, or sustain, the rate at which planetesimals are scattered from the outer belt to the exozodi region. We hypothesise that this increase is sufficient to sustain the observed exozodi on Gyr timescales. No correlation between observations of an outer belt and an exozodi is required for this scenario to work, as the outer belt may be too faint to detect. If planetesimal driven migration does explain the observed exozodi, this work suggests that the presence of an exozodi indicates the presence of outer planets and a planetesimal belt. △ Less

Submitted 9 April, 2014; originally announced April 2014.

Comments: 13 pages, MNRAS, accepted

Coreshine in L1506C - Evidence for a primitive big-grain component or indication for a turbulent core history?

Authors: J. Steinacker, C. W. Ormel, M. Andersen, A. Bacmann

Abstract: The recently discovered coreshine effect can aid in exploring the core properties and in probing the large grain population of the ISM. We discuss the implications of the coreshine detected from the molecular cloud core L1506C in the Taurus filament for the history of the core and the existence of a primitive ISM component of large grains becoming visible in cores. The coreshine surface brightness… ▽ More The recently discovered coreshine effect can aid in exploring the core properties and in probing the large grain population of the ISM. We discuss the implications of the coreshine detected from the molecular cloud core L1506C in the Taurus filament for the history of the core and the existence of a primitive ISM component of large grains becoming visible in cores. The coreshine surface brightness of L1506C is determined from IRAC Spitzer images at 3.6 micron. We perform grain growth calculations to estimate the grain size distribution in model cores similar in gas density, radius, and turbulent velocity to L1506C. Scattered light intensities at 3.6 micron are calculated for a variety of MRN and grain growth distributions to compare with the observed coreshine. For a core with the overall physical properties of L1506C, no detectable coreshine is predicted for an MRN size distribution. Extending the distribution to grain radii of about 0.65 $μ$m allows to reproduce the observed surface brightness level in scattered light. Assuming the properties of L1506C to be preserved, models for the growth of grains in cores do not yield sufficient scattered light to account for the coreshine within the lifetime of the Taurus complex. Only increasing the core density and the turbulence amplifies the scattered light intensity to a level consistent with the observed coreshine brightness. The grains could be part of primitive omni-present large grain population becoming visible in the densest part of the ISM, could grow under the turbulent dense conditions of former cores, or in L1506C itself. In the later case, L1506C must have passed through a period of larger density and stronger turbulence. This would be consistent with the surprisingly strong depletion usually attributed to high column densities, and with the large-scale outward motion of the core envelope observed today. △ Less

Submitted 14 March, 2014; originally announced March 2014.

Comments: 6 pages, 6 figures, accepted for publication in Astronomy & Astrophysics

The Fate of Planetesimals in Turbulent Disks with Dead Zones. I. The Turbulent Stirring Recipe

Authors: Satoshi Okuzumi, Chris W. Ormel

Abstract: Turbulence in protoplanetary disks affects planet formation in many ways. While small dust particles are mainly affected by the aerodynamical coupling with turbulent gas velocity fields, planetesimals and larger bodies are more affected by gravitational interaction with gas density fluctuations. For the latter process, a number of numerical simulations have been performed in recent years, but a fu… ▽ More Turbulence in protoplanetary disks affects planet formation in many ways. While small dust particles are mainly affected by the aerodynamical coupling with turbulent gas velocity fields, planetesimals and larger bodies are more affected by gravitational interaction with gas density fluctuations. For the latter process, a number of numerical simulations have been performed in recent years, but a fully parameter-independent understanding has not been yet established. In this study, we present simple scaling relations for the planetesimal stirring rate in turbulence driven by magnetorotational instability (MRI), taking into account the stabilization of MRI due to Ohmic resistivity. We begin with order-of-magnitude estimates of the turbulence-induced gravitational force acting on solid bodies and associated diffusion coefficients for their orbital elements. We then test the predicted scaling relations using the results of recent Ohmic-resistive MHD simulations by Gressel et al. We find that these relations successfully explain the simulation results if we properly fix order-of-unity uncertainties within the estimates. We also update the saturation predictor for the density fluctuation amplitude in MRI-driven turbulence originally proposed by Okuzumi & Hirose. Combination of the scaling relations and saturation predictor allows to know how the turbulent stirring rate of planetesimals depends on disk parameters such as the gas column density, distance from the central star, vertical resistivity distribution, and net vertical magnetic flux. In Paper II, we apply our recipe to planetesimal accretion to discuss its viability in turbulent disks. △ Less

Submitted 8 May, 2013; originally announced May 2013.

Comments: 14 pages, 10 figures, accepted for publication in ApJ

The steady-state flow pattern past gravitating bodies

Authors: C. W. Ormel

Abstract: Gravitating bodies significantly alter the flow pattern (density and velocity) of the gas that attempts to stream past. Still, small protoplanets in the Mars--super-Earth range can only bind limited amounts of nebular gas; until the so-called critical core mass has been reached (~1-10 Earth masses) this gas is in near hydrostatic equilibrium with the nebula. Here we aim for a general description o… ▽ More Gravitating bodies significantly alter the flow pattern (density and velocity) of the gas that attempts to stream past. Still, small protoplanets in the Mars--super-Earth range can only bind limited amounts of nebular gas; until the so-called critical core mass has been reached (~1-10 Earth masses) this gas is in near hydrostatic equilibrium with the nebula. Here we aim for a general description of the flow pattern surrounding these low-mass, embedded planets. Using various simplifying assumptions (subsonic, 2D, inviscid flow, etc), we reduce the problem to a partial differential equation that we solve numerically as well as approximate analytically. It is found that the boundary between the atmosphere and the nebula gas strongly depends on the value of the disc headwind (deviation from Keplerian rotation). With increasing headwind the atmosphere decreases in size and also becomes more asymmetrical. Using the derived flow pattern for the gas, trajectories of small solid particles, which experience both gas drag and gravitational forces, are integrated numerically. Accretion rates for small particles (dust) are found to be low, as they closely follow the streamlines, which curl away from the planet. However, pebble-size particles achieve large accretion rates, in agreement with previous numerical and analytical works. △ Less

Submitted 28 October, 2012; originally announced October 2012.

Comments: 19 pages, 12 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

Rapid Formation of Saturn after Jupiter Completion

Authors: Hiroshi Kobayashi, Chris W. Ormel, Shigeru Ida

Abstract: We have investigated Saturn's core formation at a radial pressure maximum in a protoplanetary disk, which is created by gap opening by Jupiter. A core formed via planetesimal accretion induces the fragmentation of surrounding planetesimals, which generally inhibits further growth of the core by removal of the resulting fragments due to radial drift caused by gas drag. However, the emergence of the… ▽ More We have investigated Saturn's core formation at a radial pressure maximum in a protoplanetary disk, which is created by gap opening by Jupiter. A core formed via planetesimal accretion induces the fragmentation of surrounding planetesimals, which generally inhibits further growth of the core by removal of the resulting fragments due to radial drift caused by gas drag. However, the emergence of the pressure maximum halts the drift of the fragments, while their orbital eccentricities and inclinations are efficiently damped by gas drag. As a result, the core of Saturn rapidly grows via accretion of the fragments near the pressure maximum. We have found that in the minimum-mass solar nebula, kilometer sized planetesimals can produce a core exceeding 10 Earth masses within two million years. Since Jupiter may not have undergone significant type II inward migration, it is likely that Jupiter's formation was completed when the local disk mass has already decayed to a value comparable to or less than Jovian mass. The expected rapid growth of Saturn's core on a timescale comparable to or shorter than observationally inferred disk lifetime enables Saturn to acquire the current amount of envelope gas before the disk gas is completely depleted. The high heat energy release rate onto the core surface due to the rapid accretion of the fragments delays onset of runaway gas accretion until the core mass becomes somewhat larger than that of Jupiter, which is consistent with the estimate based on interior modeling. Therefore, the rapid formation of Saturn induced by gap opening of Jupiter can account for the formation of multiple gas giants (Jupiter and Saturn) without significant inward migration and larger core mass of Saturn than that of Jupiter. △ Less

Submitted 9 July, 2012; v1 submitted 8 July, 2012; originally announced July 2012.

Comments: Accepted for publication in ApJ