-
Slow rates of approximation of U-statistics and V-statistics by quadratic forms of Gaussians
Authors:
Kevin Han Huang,
Peter Orbanz
Abstract:
We construct examples of degree-two U- and V-statistics of $n$ i.i.d.~heavy-tailed random vectors in $\mathbb{R}^{d(n)}$, whose $ν$-th moments exist for ${ν> 2}$, and provide tight bounds on the error of approximating both statistics by a quadratic form of Gaussians. In the case ${ν=3}$, the error of approximation is $Θ(n^{-1/12})$. The proof adapts a result of Huang, Austern and Orbanz [12] to U-…
▽ More
We construct examples of degree-two U- and V-statistics of $n$ i.i.d.~heavy-tailed random vectors in $\mathbb{R}^{d(n)}$, whose $ν$-th moments exist for ${ν> 2}$, and provide tight bounds on the error of approximating both statistics by a quadratic form of Gaussians. In the case ${ν=3}$, the error of approximation is $Θ(n^{-1/12})$. The proof adapts a result of Huang, Austern and Orbanz [12] to U- and V-statistics. The lower bound for U-statistics is a simple example of the concept of variance domination used in [12].
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Gaussian universality for approximately polynomial functions of high-dimensional data
Authors:
Kevin Han Huang,
Morgane Austern,
Peter Orbanz
Abstract:
We establish an invariance principle for polynomial functions of $n$ independent high-dimensional random vectors, and also show that the obtained rates are nearly optimal. Both the dimension of the vectors and the degree of the polynomial are permitted to grow with $n$. Specifically, we obtain a finite sample upper bound for the error of approximation by a polynomial of Gaussians, measured in Kolm…
▽ More
We establish an invariance principle for polynomial functions of $n$ independent high-dimensional random vectors, and also show that the obtained rates are nearly optimal. Both the dimension of the vectors and the degree of the polynomial are permitted to grow with $n$. Specifically, we obtain a finite sample upper bound for the error of approximation by a polynomial of Gaussians, measured in Kolmogorov distance, and extend it to functions that are approximately polynomial in a mean squared error sense. We give a corresponding lower bound that shows the invariance principle holds up to polynomial degree $o(\log n)$. The proof is constructive and adapts an asymmetrisation argument due to V. V. Senatov. As applications, we obtain a higher-order delta method with possibly non-Gaussian limits, and generalise a number of known results on high-dimensional and infinite-order U-statistics, and on fluctuations of subgraph counts.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Global optimality under amenable symmetry constraints
Authors:
Peter Orbanz
Abstract:
We ask whether there exists a function or measure that (1) minimizes a given convex functional or risk and (2) satisfies a symmetry property specified by an amenable group of transformations. Examples of such symmetry properties are invariance, equivariance, or quasi-invariance. Our results draw on old ideas of Stein and Le Cam and on approximate group averages that appear in ergodic theorems for…
▽ More
We ask whether there exists a function or measure that (1) minimizes a given convex functional or risk and (2) satisfies a symmetry property specified by an amenable group of transformations. Examples of such symmetry properties are invariance, equivariance, or quasi-invariance. Our results draw on old ideas of Stein and Le Cam and on approximate group averages that appear in ergodic theorems for amenable groups. A class of convex sets known as orbitopes in convex analysis emerges as crucial, and we establish properties of such orbitopes in nonparametric settings. We also show how a simple device called a cocycle can be used to reduce different forms of symmetry to a single problem. As applications, we obtain results on invariant kernel mean embeddings and a Monge-Kantorovich theorem on optimality of transport plans under symmetry constraints. We also explain connections to the Hunt-Stein theorem on invariant tests.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
The Graph Pencil Method: Map** Subgraph Densities to Stochastic Block Models
Authors:
Lee M Gunderson,
Gecia Bravo-Hermsdorff,
Peter Orbanz
Abstract:
In this work, we describe a method that determines an exact map from a finite set of subgraph densities to the parameters of a stochastic block model (SBM) matching these densities. Given a number $K$ of blocks, the subgraph densities of a finite number of stars and bistars uniquely determines a single element of the class of all degree-separated stochastic block models with $K$ blocks. Our method…
▽ More
In this work, we describe a method that determines an exact map from a finite set of subgraph densities to the parameters of a stochastic block model (SBM) matching these densities. Given a number $K$ of blocks, the subgraph densities of a finite number of stars and bistars uniquely determines a single element of the class of all degree-separated stochastic block models with $K$ blocks. Our method makes it possible to translate estimates of these subgraph densities into model parameters, and hence to use subgraph densities directly for inference. The computational overhead is negligible; computing the translation map is polynomial in $K$, but independent of the graph size once the subgraph densities are given.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Poisson approximation for stochastic processes summed over amenable groups
Authors:
Haoyu Ye,
Peter Orbanz,
Morgane Austern
Abstract:
We generalize the Poisson limit theorem to binary functions of random objects whose law is invariant under the action of an amenable group. Examples include stationary random fields, exchangeable sequences, and exchangeable graphs. A celebrated result of E. Lindenstrauss shows that normalized sums over certain increasing subsets of such groups approximate expectations. Our results clarify that the…
▽ More
We generalize the Poisson limit theorem to binary functions of random objects whose law is invariant under the action of an amenable group. Examples include stationary random fields, exchangeable sequences, and exchangeable graphs. A celebrated result of E. Lindenstrauss shows that normalized sums over certain increasing subsets of such groups approximate expectations. Our results clarify that the corresponding unnormalized sums of binary statistics are asymptotically Poisson, provided suitable mixing conditions hold. They extend further to randomly subsampled sums and also show that strict invariance of the distribution is not needed if the requisite mixing condition defined by the group holds. We illustrate the results with applications to random fields, Cayley graphs, and Poisson processes on groups.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Representing and Learning Functions Invariant Under Crystallographic Groups
Authors:
Ryan P. Adams,
Peter Orbanz
Abstract:
Crystallographic groups describe the symmetries of crystals and other repetitive structures encountered in nature and the sciences. These groups include the wallpaper and space groups. We derive linear and nonlinear representations of functions that are (1) smooth and (2) invariant under such a group. The linear representation generalizes the Fourier basis to crystallographically invariant basis f…
▽ More
Crystallographic groups describe the symmetries of crystals and other repetitive structures encountered in nature and the sciences. These groups include the wallpaper and space groups. We derive linear and nonlinear representations of functions that are (1) smooth and (2) invariant under such a group. The linear representation generalizes the Fourier basis to crystallographically invariant basis functions. We show that such a basis exists for each crystallographic group, that it is orthonormal in the relevant $L_2$ space, and recover the standard Fourier basis as a special case for pure shift groups. The nonlinear representation embeds the orbit space of the group into a finite-dimensional Euclidean space. We show that such an embedding exists for every crystallographic group, and that it factors functions through a generalization of a manifold called an orbifold. We describe algorithms that, given a standardized description of the group, compute the Fourier basis and an embedding map. As examples, we construct crystallographically invariant neural networks, kernel machines, and Gaussian processes.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Data Augmentation in the Underparameterized and Overparameterized Regimes
Authors:
Kevin Han Huang,
Peter Orbanz,
Morgane Austern
Abstract:
We provide results that exactly quantify how data augmentation affects the variance and limiting distribution of estimates, and analyze several specific models in detail. The results confirm some observations made in machine learning practice, but also lead to unexpected findings: Data augmentation may increase rather than decrease the uncertainty of estimates, such as the empirical prediction ris…
▽ More
We provide results that exactly quantify how data augmentation affects the variance and limiting distribution of estimates, and analyze several specific models in detail. The results confirm some observations made in machine learning practice, but also lead to unexpected findings: Data augmentation may increase rather than decrease the uncertainty of estimates, such as the empirical prediction risk. It can act as a regularizer, but fails to do so in certain high-dimensional problems, and it may shift the double-descent peak of an empirical risk. Overall, the analysis shows that several properties data augmentation has been attributed with are not either true or false, but rather depend on a combination of factors -- notably the data distribution, the properties of the estimator, and the interplay of sample size, number of augmentations, and dimension. Our main theoretical tool is a limit theorem for functions of randomly transformed, high-dimensional random vectors. The proof draws on work in probability on noise stability of functions of many variables.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2023; v1 submitted 18 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Empirical Risk Minimization and Stochastic Gradient Descent for Relational Data
Authors:
Victor Veitch,
Morgane Austern,
Wenda Zhou,
David M. Blei,
Peter Orbanz
Abstract:
Empirical risk minimization is the main tool for prediction problems, but its extension to relational data remains unsolved. We solve this problem using recent ideas from graph sampling theory to (i) define an empirical risk for relational data and (ii) obtain stochastic gradients for this empirical risk that are automatically unbiased. This is achieved by considering the method by which data is s…
▽ More
Empirical risk minimization is the main tool for prediction problems, but its extension to relational data remains unsolved. We solve this problem using recent ideas from graph sampling theory to (i) define an empirical risk for relational data and (ii) obtain stochastic gradients for this empirical risk that are automatically unbiased. This is achieved by considering the method by which data is sampled from a graph as an explicit component of model design. By integrating fast implementations of graph sampling schemes with standard automatic differentiation tools, we provide an efficient turnkey solver for the risk minimization problem. We establish basic theoretical properties of the procedure. Finally, we demonstrate relational ERM with application to two non-standard problems: one-stage training for semi-supervised node classification, and learning embedding vectors for vertex attributes. Experiments confirm that the turnkey inference procedure is effective in practice, and that the sampling scheme used for model specification has a strong effect on model performance. Code is available at https://github.com/wooden-spoon/relational-ERM.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2019; v1 submitted 27 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Limit theorems for invariant distributions
Authors:
Morgane Austern,
Peter Orbanz
Abstract:
A distributional symmetry is invariance of a distribution under a group of transformations. Exchangeability and stationarity are examples. We explain that a result of ergodic theory provides a law of large numbers: If the group satisfies suitable conditions, expectations can be estimated by averaging over subsets of transformations, and these estimators are strongly consistent. We show that, if a…
▽ More
A distributional symmetry is invariance of a distribution under a group of transformations. Exchangeability and stationarity are examples. We explain that a result of ergodic theory provides a law of large numbers: If the group satisfies suitable conditions, expectations can be estimated by averaging over subsets of transformations, and these estimators are strongly consistent. We show that, if a mixing condition holds, the averages also satisfy a central limit theorem, a Berry-Esseen bound, and concentration. These are extended further to apply to triangular arrays, to randomly subsampled averages, and to a generalization of U-statistics. As applications, we obtain new results on exchangeability, random fields, network models, and a class of marked point processes. We also establish asymptotic normality of the empirical entropy for a large class of processes. Some known results are recovered as special cases, and can hence be interpreted as an outcome of symmetry. The proofs adapt Stein's method.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2021; v1 submitted 27 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Non-Vacuous Generalization Bounds at the ImageNet Scale: A PAC-Bayesian Compression Approach
Authors:
Wenda Zhou,
Victor Veitch,
Morgane Austern,
Ryan P. Adams,
Peter Orbanz
Abstract:
Modern neural networks are highly overparameterized, with capacity to substantially overfit to training data. Nevertheless, these networks often generalize well in practice. It has also been observed that trained networks can often be "compressed" to much smaller representations. The purpose of this paper is to connect these two empirical observations. Our main technical result is a generalization…
▽ More
Modern neural networks are highly overparameterized, with capacity to substantially overfit to training data. Nevertheless, these networks often generalize well in practice. It has also been observed that trained networks can often be "compressed" to much smaller representations. The purpose of this paper is to connect these two empirical observations. Our main technical result is a generalization bound for compressed networks based on the compressed size. Combined with off-the-shelf compression algorithms, the bound leads to state of the art generalization guarantees; in particular, we provide the first non-vacuous generalization guarantees for realistic architectures applied to the ImageNet classification problem. As additional evidence connecting compression and generalization, we show that compressibility of models that tend to overfit is limited: We establish an absolute limit on expected compressibility as a function of expected generalization error, where the expectations are over the random choice of training examples. The bounds are complemented by empirical results that show an increase in overfitting implies an increase in the number of bits required to describe a trained network.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2019; v1 submitted 16 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Subsampling large graphs and invariance in networks
Authors:
Peter Orbanz
Abstract:
Specify a randomized algorithm that, given a very large graph or network, extracts a random subgraph. What can we learn about the input graph from a single subsample? We derive laws of large numbers for the sampler output, by relating randomized subsampling to distributional invariance: Assuming an invariance holds is tantamount to assuming the sample has been generated by a specific algorithm. Th…
▽ More
Specify a randomized algorithm that, given a very large graph or network, extracts a random subgraph. What can we learn about the input graph from a single subsample? We derive laws of large numbers for the sampler output, by relating randomized subsampling to distributional invariance: Assuming an invariance holds is tantamount to assuming the sample has been generated by a specific algorithm. That in turn yields a notion of ergodicity. Sampling algorithms induce model classes---graphon models, sparse generalizations of exchangeable graphs, and random multigraphs with exchangeable edges can all be obtained in this manner, and we specialize our results to a number of examples. One class of sampling algorithms emerges as special: Roughly speaking, those defined as limits of random transformations drawn uniformly from certain sequences of groups. Some known pathologies of network models based on graphons are explained as a form of selection bias.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Preferential Attachment and Vertex Arrival Times
Authors:
Benjamin Bloem-Reddy,
Peter Orbanz
Abstract:
We study preferential attachment mechanisms in random graphs that are parameterized by (i) a constant bias affecting the degree-biased distribution on the vertex set and (ii) the distribution of times at which new vertices are created by the model. The class of random graphs so defined admits a representation theorem reminiscent of residual allocation, or "stick-breaking" schemes. We characterize…
▽ More
We study preferential attachment mechanisms in random graphs that are parameterized by (i) a constant bias affecting the degree-biased distribution on the vertex set and (ii) the distribution of times at which new vertices are created by the model. The class of random graphs so defined admits a representation theorem reminiscent of residual allocation, or "stick-breaking" schemes. We characterize how the vertex arrival times affect the asymptotic degree distribution, and relate the latter to neutral-to-the-left processes. Our random graphs generate edges "one end at a time", which sets up a one-to-one correspondence between random graphs and random partitions of natural numbers; via this map, our representation induces a result on (not necessarily exchangeable) random partitions that generalizes a theorem of Griffiths and Spanó. A number of examples clarify how the class intersects with several known random graph models.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Uniform estimation in stochastic block models is slow
Authors:
Ismaël Castillo,
Peter Orbanz
Abstract:
We explicitly quantify the empirically observed phenomenon that estimation under a stochastic block model (SBM) is hard if the model contains classes that are similar. More precisely, we consider estimation of certain functionals of random graphs generated by a SBM. The SBM may or may not be sparse, and the number of classes may be fixed or grow with the number of vertices. Minimax lower and upper…
▽ More
We explicitly quantify the empirically observed phenomenon that estimation under a stochastic block model (SBM) is hard if the model contains classes that are similar. More precisely, we consider estimation of certain functionals of random graphs generated by a SBM. The SBM may or may not be sparse, and the number of classes may be fixed or grow with the number of vertices. Minimax lower and upper bounds of estimation along specific submodels are derived. The results are nonasymptotic and imply that uniform estimation of a single connectivity parameter is much slower than the expected asymptotic pointwise rate. Specifically, the uniform quadratic rate does not scale as the number of edges, but only as the number of vertices. The lower bounds are local around any possible SBM. An analogous result is derived for functionals of a class of smooth graphons.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2022; v1 submitted 9 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Independence by Random Scaling
Authors:
Lancelot F. James,
Peter Orbanz
Abstract:
We give conditions under which a scalar random variable T can be coupled to a random scaling factor $ξ$ such that T and $ξ$T are rendered stochastically independent. A similar result is obtained for random measures. One consequence is a generalization of a result by Pitman and Yor on the Poisson-Dirichlet distribution to its negative parameter range. Another application are diffusion excursions st…
▽ More
We give conditions under which a scalar random variable T can be coupled to a random scaling factor $ξ$ such that T and $ξ$T are rendered stochastically independent. A similar result is obtained for random measures. One consequence is a generalization of a result by Pitman and Yor on the Poisson-Dirichlet distribution to its negative parameter range. Another application are diffusion excursions straddling an exponential random time.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Random Walk Models of Network Formation and Sequential Monte Carlo Methods for Graphs
Authors:
Benjamin Bloem-Reddy,
Peter Orbanz
Abstract:
We introduce a class of generative network models that insert edges by connecting the starting and terminal vertices of a random walk on the network graph. Within the taxonomy of statistical network models, this class is distinguished by permitting the location of a new edge to explicitly depend on the structure of the graph, but being nonetheless statistically and computationally tractable. In th…
▽ More
We introduce a class of generative network models that insert edges by connecting the starting and terminal vertices of a random walk on the network graph. Within the taxonomy of statistical network models, this class is distinguished by permitting the location of a new edge to explicitly depend on the structure of the graph, but being nonetheless statistically and computationally tractable. In the limit of infinite walk length, the model converges to an extension of the preferential attachment model---in this sense, it can be motivated alternatively by asking what preferential attachment is an approximation to. Theoretical properties, including the limiting degree sequence, are studied analytically. If the entire history of the graph is observed, parameters can be estimated by maximum likelihood. If only the final graph is available, its history can be imputed using MCMC. We develop a class of sequential Monte Carlo algorithms that are more generally applicable to sequential network models, and may be of interest in their own right. The model parameters can be recovered from a single graph generated by the model. Applications to data clarify the role of the random walk length as a length scale of interactions within the graph.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2018; v1 submitted 19 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Scaled subordinators and generalizations of the Indian buffet process
Authors:
Lancelot F. James,
Peter Orbanz,
Yee Whye Teh
Abstract:
We study random families of subsets of $\mathbb{N}$ that are similar to exchangeable random partitions, but do not require constituent sets to be disjoint: Each element of ${\mathbb{N}}$ may be contained in multiple subsets. One class of such objects, known as Indian buffet processes, has become a popular tool in machine learning. Based on an equivalence between Indian buffet and scale-invariant P…
▽ More
We study random families of subsets of $\mathbb{N}$ that are similar to exchangeable random partitions, but do not require constituent sets to be disjoint: Each element of ${\mathbb{N}}$ may be contained in multiple subsets. One class of such objects, known as Indian buffet processes, has become a popular tool in machine learning. Based on an equivalence between Indian buffet and scale-invariant Poisson processes, we identify a random scaling variable whose role is similar to that played in exchangeable partition models by the total mass of a random measure. Analogous to the construction of exchangeable partitions from normalized subordinators, random families of sets can be constructed from randomly scaled subordinators. Coupling to a heavy-tailed scaling variable induces a power law on the number of sets containing the first $n$ elements. Several examples, with properties desirable in applications, are derived explicitly. A relationship to exchangeable partitions is made precise as a correspondence between scaled subordinators and Poisson-Kingman measures, generalizing a result of Arratia, Barbour and Tavare on scale-invariant processes.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Bayesian Models of Graphs, Arrays and Other Exchangeable Random Structures
Authors:
Peter Orbanz,
Daniel M. Roy
Abstract:
The natural habitat of most Bayesian methods is data represented by exchangeable sequences of observations, for which de Finetti's theorem provides the theoretical foundation. Dirichlet process clustering, Gaussian process regression, and many other parametric and nonparametric Bayesian models fall within the remit of this framework; many problems arising in modern data analysis do not. This artic…
▽ More
The natural habitat of most Bayesian methods is data represented by exchangeable sequences of observations, for which de Finetti's theorem provides the theoretical foundation. Dirichlet process clustering, Gaussian process regression, and many other parametric and nonparametric Bayesian models fall within the remit of this framework; many problems arising in modern data analysis do not. This article provides an introduction to Bayesian models of graphs, matrices, and other data that can be modeled by random structures. We describe results in probability theory that generalize de Finetti's theorem to such data and discuss their relevance to nonparametric Bayesian modeling. With the basic ideas in place, we survey example models available in the literature; applications of such models include collaborative filtering, link prediction, and graph and network analysis. We also highlight connections to recent developments in graph theory and probability, and sketch the more general mathematical foundation of Bayesian methods for other types of data beyond sequences and arrays.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2015; v1 submitted 30 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
Borel Liftings of Graph Limits
Authors:
Peter Orbanz,
Balazs Szegedy
Abstract:
The cut pseudo-metric on the space of graph limits induces an equivalence relation. The quotient space obtained by collapsing each equivalence class to a point is a metric space with appealing analytic properties. We show that the equivalence relation admits a Borel lifting: There exists a Borel-measurable map** which maps each equivalence class to one of its elements.
The cut pseudo-metric on the space of graph limits induces an equivalence relation. The quotient space obtained by collapsing each equivalence class to a point is a metric space with appealing analytic properties. We show that the equivalence relation admits a Borel lifting: There exists a Borel-measurable map** which maps each equivalence class to one of its elements.
△ Less
Submitted 27 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
Projective Limit Random Probabilities on Polish Spaces
Authors:
Peter Orbanz
Abstract:
A pivotal problem in Bayesian nonparametrics is the construction of prior distributions on the space M(V) of probability measures on a given domain V. In principle, such distributions on the infinite-dimensional space M(V) can be constructed from their finite-dimensional marginals---the most prominent example being the construction of the Dirichlet process from finite-dimensional Dirichlet distrib…
▽ More
A pivotal problem in Bayesian nonparametrics is the construction of prior distributions on the space M(V) of probability measures on a given domain V. In principle, such distributions on the infinite-dimensional space M(V) can be constructed from their finite-dimensional marginals---the most prominent example being the construction of the Dirichlet process from finite-dimensional Dirichlet distributions. This approach is both intuitive and applicable to the construction of arbitrary distributions on M(V), but also hamstrung by a number of technical difficulties. We show how these difficulties can be resolved if the domain V is a Polish topological space, and give a representation theorem directly applicable to the construction of any probability distribution on M(V) whose first moment measure is well-defined. The proof draws on a projective limit theorem of Bochner, and on properties of set functions on Polish spaces to establish countable additivity of the resulting random probabilities.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2011; v1 submitted 24 January, 2011;
originally announced January 2011.
-
Conjugate Projective Limits
Authors:
Peter Orbanz
Abstract:
We characterize conjugate nonparametric Bayesian models as projective limits of conjugate, finite-dimensional Bayesian models. In particular, we identify a large class of nonparametric models representable as infinite-dimensional analogues of exponential family distributions and their canonical conjugate priors. This class contains most models studied in the literature, including Dirichlet process…
▽ More
We characterize conjugate nonparametric Bayesian models as projective limits of conjugate, finite-dimensional Bayesian models. In particular, we identify a large class of nonparametric models representable as infinite-dimensional analogues of exponential family distributions and their canonical conjugate priors. This class contains most models studied in the literature, including Dirichlet processes and Gaussian process regression models. To derive these results, we introduce a representation of infinite-dimensional Bayesian models by projective limits of regular conditional probabilities. We show under which conditions the nonparametric model itself, its sufficient statistics, and -- if they exist -- conjugate updates of the posterior are projective limits of their respective finite-dimensional counterparts. We illustrate our results both by application to existing nonparametric models and by construction of a model on infinite permutations.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2011; v1 submitted 1 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.