-
CCD $UBV(RI)_{KC}$ photometry and dynamics of the open cluster NGC 1513
Authors:
İnci Akkaya Oralhan,
Hikmet Çakmak,
Yüksel Karataş,
Raúl Michel,
Charles Bonatto
Abstract:
We derive astrophysical parameters of the open cluster NGC 1513 by means of colour indices built with new $CCD\,UBV(RI)_{KC}$ photometry. Based on early-type members, the mean foreground reddening and total to selective extinction ratio are E(B-V)=0.79$\pm$0.09 mag and $R_{V}$=2.85$\pm$0.05. Through the differential grid method, we derive the metal abundance [Fe/H]=-0.06 dex (Z=+0.013), which is c…
▽ More
We derive astrophysical parameters of the open cluster NGC 1513 by means of colour indices built with new $CCD\,UBV(RI)_{KC}$ photometry. Based on early-type members, the mean foreground reddening and total to selective extinction ratio are E(B-V)=0.79$\pm$0.09 mag and $R_{V}$=2.85$\pm$0.05. Through the differential grid method, we derive the metal abundance [Fe/H]=-0.06 dex (Z=+0.013), which is consistent with the value [Fe/H]=-0.088 of the bright giant member-LAMOST-695710060. The Z=+0.013 isochrone fit to the V x (B-V) colour-magnitude diagram leads to a turn-off age of 224$\pm$27 Myr (thus an intermediate-age cluster), and a distance modulus of ($V_{0}$ - $M_{\rm V}$)=10.90$\pm$0.15 mag, thus implying a distance from the Sun d=1514$\pm$105 pc. Within the uncertainties, our photometric distance is consistent with the value d=1435$\pm$14 pc from the Gaia DR3 parallax. We find signs of small mass segregation through a minimum spanning tree analysis for the 190 most massive stars, together with the rather steep mass function ($χ$=+2.39) slope. The high core to half-light radius ratio $R_{core}$/$R_{h}$=0.82, together with the compact half-light to tidal radius ratio $R_{h}$/$R_{t}$=0.22, suggest that it is probably related to cluster-formation effects, due to little dynamical evolution, instead of driving its dynamical evolution by internal relaxation. Indeed, NGC 1513 is located in the second quadrant ($\ell$=152.59$^{\circ}$ and Galactocentric distance $R_{GC}$=9.57 kpc), which tends to minimize tidal effects by external processes and tidal disruption. Therefore, internal mass segregation effects in NGC 1513 seem to be more efficient than cluster evaporation processes. We find that NGC 1513 migrated about 0.50 kpc from its birth place.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Study of the Open Clusters in Kepler Prime Field
Authors:
Yüksel Karataş,
Hikmet Çakmak,
İnci Akkaya Oralhan,
Charles Bonatto,
Raúl Michel,
Martin Netopil
Abstract:
We present a detailed study of NGC 6791, NGC 6811, NGC 6819 and NGC 6866, the four open clusters that are located in the Kepler prime field. We use new CCD UBV(RI)KC photometry, which was combined with Gaia EDR3 photometric/astrometric data, to derive the astrophysical parameters with two independent methods - one of them the fitCMD algorithm. Furthermore, we provide among others estimates of the…
▽ More
We present a detailed study of NGC 6791, NGC 6811, NGC 6819 and NGC 6866, the four open clusters that are located in the Kepler prime field. We use new CCD UBV(RI)KC photometry, which was combined with Gaia EDR3 photometric/astrometric data, to derive the astrophysical parameters with two independent methods - one of them the fitCMD algorithm. Furthermore, we provide among others estimates of the mass and mass function, the cluster structure, derive the cluster orbits, and discuss the cluster dynamics. All objects belong to the older open cluster population (1-7Gyr), are in an advanced dynamical stage with signs of mass segregation, and are located close to the solar circle, but show a large range in respect of radii, member stars or observed cluster mass (100-2000 Msolar). For the three younger objects we were also able to provide photometric metallicity estimates, which confirms their status as clusters with a roughly solar metallicity. The most outstanding object is clearly NGC 6791, a very old cluster with a high metallicity at a distance of about 4.5 kpc from the Sun. We estimate a probable radial migration by about 7 kpc, resulting in a birth position close to the Galactic center.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Investigation of the Connection Between X-ray Binaries and Compact Star Clusters in NGC 628
Authors:
Senay Avdan,
Aysun Akyuz,
Seda Acar,
Inci Akkaya Oralhan,
Sinan Allak,
Nazim Aksaker
Abstract:
We investigated for a possible connection between the types of X-ray binaries (XRBs) and the properties of compact star clusters in the nearby galaxy NGC 628. Using {\it Chandra} archival data covering the years 2001-2018, 75 X-ray sources were detected within the field of view of observations. A total of 69 XRBs, one of which is an ultraluminous X-ray source (ULX), were found to be in the luminos…
▽ More
We investigated for a possible connection between the types of X-ray binaries (XRBs) and the properties of compact star clusters in the nearby galaxy NGC 628. Using {\it Chandra} archival data covering the years 2001-2018, 75 X-ray sources were detected within the field of view of observations. A total of 69 XRBs, one of which is an ultraluminous X-ray source (ULX), were found to be in the luminosity range of 3$\times10^{36}\leq L_{X}$ $\leq $ 2$\times10^{39}$ erg s$^{-1}$. We identified the optical counterpart(s) of 15 of the 42 XRBs that coincide with the {\it HST} field of view via improved astrometry. We classified 15 of them as HMXBs based on the presence of the optical counterparts. The remaining sources with no optical counterparts were classified as LMXBs. We also search compact star clusters in this galaxy using the multi-band optical images drawn from {\it HST} archives. 864 compact star clusters were identified and their ages and masses were determined by applying the best-fit SSP (Simple Stellar Population) model to their color-color diagram. We found that in NGC 628, HMXBs are associated with younger star clusters and LMXBs with older ones. Our findings support a connection between different types of XRBs and cluster ages, already known to exist for other galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2023; v1 submitted 23 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
The Galactic metallicity gradient shown by open clusters in the light of radial migration
Authors:
Martin Netopil,
İnci Akkaya Oralhan,
Hikmet Çakmak,
Raúl Michel,
Yüksel Karataş
Abstract:
During the last years and decades several individual studies and large-scale spectroscopic surveys significantly improved our knowledge of the Galactic metallicity distribution based on open clusters. The availability of Gaia data provided a further step forward in our knowledge. However, still some open issues remain, for example the influence of radial migration on the interpretation of the obse…
▽ More
During the last years and decades several individual studies and large-scale spectroscopic surveys significantly improved our knowledge of the Galactic metallicity distribution based on open clusters. The availability of Gaia data provided a further step forward in our knowledge. However, still some open issues remain, for example the influence of radial migration on the interpretation of the observed gradients. We used spectroscopic metallicities from individual studies and from the APOGEE survey to compile a sample of 136 open clusters, with a membership verification based on Gaia DR2. Additionally, we present photometric metallicity estimates of 14 open clusters in a somewhat outer Galactic region. Eight age groups allow us to study the evolution of the metallicity gradient in detail, showing within the errors an almost constant gradient of about $-$0.06 dex kpc$^{-1}$. Furthermore, using the derived gradients and an analysis of the individual objects, we estimate a mean migration rate of 1 kpc Gyr$^{-1}$ for objects up to about 2 Gyr. Here, the change of the guiding radius is clearly the main contributor. For older and dynamically hotter objects up to 6 Gyr we infer a lower migration rate of up to 0.5 kpc Gyr$^{-1}$. The influence of epicyclic excursions increases with age and contributes already about 1 kpc to the total migration distance after 6 Gyr. A comparison of our results with available models shows good agreement. However, there is still a lack of a suitable coverage of older objects, future studies are still needed to provide a better sampling in this respect.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2021; v1 submitted 22 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
The Transient Ultra-luminous X-ray Source, ULX-4, in M51
Authors:
S. Allak,
A. Akyuz,
İ. Akkaya Oralhan,
S. Avdan,
N. Aksaker,
A. Vinokurov,
F. Soydugan,
E. Sonbas,
K. S. Dhuga
Abstract:
We present the results of a temporal and spectral analysis of the transient source ULX-4 in the galaxy M51. The data used were drawn from Chandra, XMM-Newton and Swift-XRT archives, spanning the years 2000-2019. The X-ray flux of the source is seen to vary by two orders of magnitudes within a month but a short-term variability was not observed over the time intervals of 100-2000 second in the 0.3-…
▽ More
We present the results of a temporal and spectral analysis of the transient source ULX-4 in the galaxy M51. The data used were drawn from Chandra, XMM-Newton and Swift-XRT archives, spanning the years 2000-2019. The X-ray flux of the source is seen to vary by two orders of magnitudes within a month but a short-term variability was not observed over the time intervals of 100-2000 second in the 0.3-10 keV energy band. We find some evidence for the existence of bi-modality feature in the flux distribution of ULX-4. We identified two optical sources as possible counterparts within an error radius of 0."18 at 95% confidence level for ULX-4 based on the archival HST/ACS and HST/WFC3 data. Blackbody fits of the spectral energy distributions (SEDs) indicate the spectral type to be B-type stars. One of these counterparts exhibits a low-amplitude optical periodicity of 264 days in the F606W filter; if we assume this apparent periodicity is associated with the orbital motion of the donor, then it is more likely that the donor is a red supergiant satisfying the long periodicity and accretion via Roche-lobe overflow. Consequently, the SED would then have to be interpreted as a superposition of emissions from a cold donor and a hot flow component, most likely from an accretion disk. If, on the other hand, the periodicity is super orbital in nature i.e., due to possible interactions of the compact object with a circumstellar disk, the donor could then be a Be/X star hosting a neutron star.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2021; v1 submitted 27 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Optical Counterparts of ULXs in Two Dwarf Galaxies: NGC 4861 and NGC 4449
Authors:
M. Ozdogan Ela,
A. Akyuz,
N. Aksaker,
S. Avdan,
İ. Akkaya Oralhan,
A. Vinokurov,
S. Allak,
Y. Solovyeva,
K. Atapin,
D. Bizyaev
Abstract:
We present the results of a search for optical candidates of Ultraluminous X-ray sources (ULXs) in two dwarf galaxies: NGC 4861 and NGC 4449 using Hubble Space Telescope {\it HST} archival data. With a precise astrometry, we confirm that NGC 4861 X1 associated with an HII complex as reported by \cite{2014MNRAS.441.1841T} and we conclude that NGC 4861 X2 resides in a young star group with 400$\pm$8…
▽ More
We present the results of a search for optical candidates of Ultraluminous X-ray sources (ULXs) in two dwarf galaxies: NGC 4861 and NGC 4449 using Hubble Space Telescope {\it HST} archival data. With a precise astrometry, we confirm that NGC 4861 X1 associated with an HII complex as reported by \cite{2014MNRAS.441.1841T} and we conclude that NGC 4861 X2 resides in a young star group with 400$\pm$80 M$\odot$. We also find that NGC 4449 X7 is associated with three optical candidates within an error radius of 0$\farcs$2 at the 90$\%$ confidence level. Absolute magnitudes (M$_{v}$) of these candidates are determined as $-$5.0 and $-$4.1. The age and mass values for the three candidates by using stellar evolutionary tracks are estimated as 40-50 Myr and $\sim$8 M$\odot$, respectively. The locations of optical candidates suggest possible association with a nearby group of stars. In addition, we analyzed the previously unused archival data of {\it XMM-Newton}, {\it Chandra} and {\it Swift} where the sources detected. Although the X-ray spectral data do not allow us to discriminate between physical models, long-term data at hand are consistent with the sources being in luminous hard states.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
UBVI CCD Photometry of Berkeley 55 Open Cluster
Authors:
İnci Akkaya Oralhan
Abstract:
Fundamental astrophysical parameters have been derived for Be 55 open cluster based on UBVI CCD photometric data, observed with the AZT-22 1.5m telescope at Maidanak Astronomical Observatory in Uzbekistan. The mean reddening is obtained as E(B-V)=1.77+-0.10 mag from early type members. The zero age main sequence fitting in the Q(VA)- Q0 diagrams indicates the distance modulus, (V0 - MV)=12.4+-0.20…
▽ More
Fundamental astrophysical parameters have been derived for Be 55 open cluster based on UBVI CCD photometric data, observed with the AZT-22 1.5m telescope at Maidanak Astronomical Observatory in Uzbekistan. The mean reddening is obtained as E(B-V)=1.77+-0.10 mag from early type members. The zero age main sequence fitting in the Q(VA)- Q0 diagrams indicates the distance modulus, (V0 - MV)=12.4+-0.20 mag (d=3.02+-0.28 kpc). This photometric distance is consistent with the distances of Gaia EDR3 (d=3.09+-0.16 kpc) and period-luminosity relation (d=2.78+-0.32 kpc) of its Cepheid S5 within the uncertainties. This distance also locates the cluster near the Perseus spiral arm. The Geneva isochrone fittings to the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram and observational colourmagnitude diagrams derive turn-off age, 85+-13 Myr, by taking care five red supergiants/bright giants. The possible inconsistences on the locations of the bright giants with the rotating/non-rotating isochrones may be due to both the age spread of stars in young open clusters and the diversity in rotational velocities.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2021; v1 submitted 3 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
The ULX Source X-3 in NGC 4258: A Search for Its X-ray and Optical Properties
Authors:
A. Akyuz,
S. Avdan,
S. Allak,
N. Aksaker,
İ. Akkaya Oralhan,
Ş. Balman
Abstract:
We present the results of a search for the nature of ultraluminous X-ray source (ULX) X-3 in the nearby galaxy NGC 4258. We use archival data from {\it XMM-Newton}, {\it Chandra}, {\it NuSTAR} and {\it HST} observations. Total X-ray data analysed to find the model parameters of the system is indicative of a stellar mass black hole, $\sim$ 10 M$_{\sun}$, as the central compact object. Furthermore,…
▽ More
We present the results of a search for the nature of ultraluminous X-ray source (ULX) X-3 in the nearby galaxy NGC 4258. We use archival data from {\it XMM-Newton}, {\it Chandra}, {\it NuSTAR} and {\it HST} observations. Total X-ray data analysed to find the model parameters of the system is indicative of a stellar mass black hole, $\sim$ 10 M$_{\sun}$, as the central compact object. Furthermore, analyses of the optical data from {\it HST} reveal two optical candidates with the 90 per cent confidence level of error radius of 0$\farcs$28. Assuming the optical emission is dominated by the donor star, both of these candidates are found to have spectral types that lie between B3$-$F1 with absolute magnitudes of $M_{\rm V}$ $\approx$ -6.4. Moreover, the age and mass estimates for the candidates are found to be of 10 and 18 Myr and of 13 and 20 M$_{\sun}$, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
CCD UBV(RI)KC Photometry of the Open Clusters Juchert 9 and Berkeley 97
Authors:
İnci Akkaya Oralhan,
Raúl Michel,
Yonca Karslı,
Hikmet Çakmak,
Hwankyung Sung,
Yüksel Karataş
Abstract:
The CCD UBV(RI)KC photometry of the poorly studied open clusters Juchert 9 (Juc 9) and Berkeley 97 (Be 97), which are observed with the 0.84 m telescope at the San Pedro Mártir National Observatory, México has been analysed. For the likely cluster members, we determined the reddenings, E(B-V)=0.82 +- 0.04 (Juc 9) and E(B-V)=0.87 +- 0.05 (Be 97), from the early type stars. Our distance moduli/dista…
▽ More
The CCD UBV(RI)KC photometry of the poorly studied open clusters Juchert 9 (Juc 9) and Berkeley 97 (Be 97), which are observed with the 0.84 m telescope at the San Pedro Mártir National Observatory, México has been analysed. For the likely cluster members, we determined the reddenings, E(B-V)=0.82 +- 0.04 (Juc 9) and E(B-V)=0.87 +- 0.05 (Be 97), from the early type stars. Our distance moduli/distances for only (B - V) colour are (Vo-Mv , d(kpc)) = (13.40 +- 0.10, 4.8 +- 0.2 kpc) (Juc 9) and (12.40 +- 0.12, 3.0 +- 0.2 kpc) (Be 97), respectively. The Gaia DR2 distances are d = 4.5 +- 1.2 kpc (Juc 9) and d = 3.1 +- 0.7 kpc (Be 97) from the median parallaxes with relative parallaxes < 0.20, which are in good agreement with the photometric distances within the uncertainties. The solar abundance PARSEC isochrones give us the intermediate ages, 30 +- 10 Myr for Juc 9 and 100 +- 30 Myr for Be 97.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
UBVRI-KC Photometry of NGC~2323 and NGC~2539 Open Clusters
Authors:
Inci Akkaya Oralhan,
Raul Michel,
William J. Schuster,
Yüksel Karatas,
Yonca Karsli,
Carlos Chavarria
Abstract:
The open clusters NGC 2323 and NGC 2539 have been analysed using CCD UBV(RI)KC photometric data, observed at the San Pedro Martir Observatory. Cluster memberships have been determined with the proper motion and parallax measures from the GaiaDR2 astrometric data release. Photometric metal and heavy element abundances have been obtained as (M/H, Z) = (-0.10, 0.012) (NGC 2323) and (-0.31, 0.007) (NG…
▽ More
The open clusters NGC 2323 and NGC 2539 have been analysed using CCD UBV(RI)KC photometric data, observed at the San Pedro Martir Observatory. Cluster memberships have been determined with the proper motion and parallax measures from the GaiaDR2 astrometric data release. Photometric metal and heavy element abundances have been obtained as (M/H, Z) = (-0.10, 0.012) (NGC 2323) and (-0.31, 0.007) (NGC 2539), from the delta(U-B) technique in the two colour diagrams, which are used to select the appropriate PARSEC isochrones.
The estimated reddening of NGC 2323 is E(B-V) = 0.23+-0.04 using 11 early type stars. For NGC 2539, we find E(B-V)= 0.02+-0.06. For (B-V) colour, distance moduli and distances for NGC 2323 and NGC 2539 are derived as (V0-MV, d (pc)) = (10.00+-0.10, 1000+-50) and (V0-MV, d (pc)) = (10.00+-0.04,1000+-20), respectively.The median GaiaDR2 distance d=1000+-140 pc (plx=0.998+-0.136 mas) for the likely members of NGC 2323 is in concordance with its four colour photometric distances 910-1000 pc. For NGC 2539, its GaiaDR2 distance d=1330+-250 pc (plx=0.751+-0.139 mas) is close to its four colour photometric distances, 1000 pc.
Fitting the PARSEC isochrones to the colour magnitude diagrams (CMDs) gives an old age, 890+-110 Myr, for NGC 2539. Whereas NGC 2323 has an intermediate age, 200+-50 Myr. One Red Clump Red Giant candidate (BD 12 2380) in the CMDs of NGC 2539 has been confirmed as a member in terms of the distances dI = 950+-50 pc and dV =910+-90 pc of VI filters within the uncertainties, as compared to the distance, 1000+-20 pc of NGC 2539. This giant's GaiaDR2 distance (d=1200+-70 pc) is not close to these photometric distances.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
X-ray spectral and optical properties of a ULX in NGC 4258 (M106)
Authors:
Hasan Avdan,
Senay Avdan,
Aysun Akyuz,
Solen Balman,
Nazim Aksaker,
Inci Akkaya Oralhan
Abstract:
We study the X-ray and optical properties of the ultraluminous X-ray source (ULX) X-6 in the nearby galaxy NGC 4258 (M106) based on the archival {\it XMM-Newton}, {\it Chandra}, {\it Swift}, and {\it Hubble Space Telescope} ({\it HST}) observations. The source has a peak luminosity of $L_{\mathrm{X}} \sim 2 \times 10^{39}$ erg s$^{-1}$ in the {\it XMM-Newton} observation of 2004 June. Consideratio…
▽ More
We study the X-ray and optical properties of the ultraluminous X-ray source (ULX) X-6 in the nearby galaxy NGC 4258 (M106) based on the archival {\it XMM-Newton}, {\it Chandra}, {\it Swift}, and {\it Hubble Space Telescope} ({\it HST}) observations. The source has a peak luminosity of $L_{\mathrm{X}} \sim 2 \times 10^{39}$ erg s$^{-1}$ in the {\it XMM-Newton} observation of 2004 June. Consideration of the hardness ratios and spectral model parameters shows that the source seems to exhibit possible spectral variations throughout the X-ray observations. In the images from the {\it HST}/Advanced Camera for Surveys (ACS), three optical sources have been identified as counterpart candidates within the 1$σ$ error radius of 0$\arcsec$.3. The brightest one has an absolute magnitude of $M_{V} \approx$ $-$7.0 and shows extended structure. The remaining two sources have absolute magnitudes of $M_{V} \approx$ $-$5.8 and $-$5.3 mag. The possible spectral types of the candidates from brightest to dimmest were determined as B6$-$A5, B0$-$A7, and B2$-$A3, respectively. The counterparts of the X-ray source possibly belong to a young star cluster. Neither the standard disk model nor the slim disk model provides firm evidence to determine the spectral characteristics of ULX X-6. We argue that the mass of the compact object lies in the range $10-15M_{\sun}$ indicating that the compact source is most likely a stellar-mass black hole.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2016; v1 submitted 11 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Analytical Studies of NGC 2571, NGC 6802, Koposov 53 and Be 89
Authors:
Ferhat F. Özeren,
Özgün Arslan,
İbrahim Küçük,
İnci Akkaya Oralhan
Abstract:
Astrophysical parameters (age, reddening, distance, radius, luminosity function, mass function, total mass, relaxation time and mass segregation) have been estimated for open clusters NGC 2571, NGC 6802, Koposov 53 and Be 89 by using the Two Micron All Sky Survey (2MASS) photometry. We analyse the color-magnitude diagrams and stellar radial density profiles. We have found that NGC 2571 is the youn…
▽ More
Astrophysical parameters (age, reddening, distance, radius, luminosity function, mass function, total mass, relaxation time and mass segregation) have been estimated for open clusters NGC 2571, NGC 6802, Koposov 53 and Be 89 by using the Two Micron All Sky Survey (2MASS) photometry. We analyse the color-magnitude diagrams and stellar radial density profiles. We have found that NGC 2571 is the youngest one having young main sequence stars while Be 89 is the oldest cluster.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
CCD $UBV(RI)_{C}$ Photometry of Twenty Open Clusters
Authors:
Inci Akkaya Oralhan,
Yüksel Karataş,
William J. Schuster,
Raúl Michel,
Carlos Chavarría
Abstract:
Fundamental astrophysical parameters have been derived for 20 open clusters (O\!Cs) using CCD~$U\!BV\!(RI)_C$ photometric data observed with the 84~cm telescope at the San Pedro Mártir National Astronomical Observatory, México.
The interstellar reddenings, metallicities, distances, and ages have been compared to the literature values. Significant differences are usually due to the usage of diver…
▽ More
Fundamental astrophysical parameters have been derived for 20 open clusters (O\!Cs) using CCD~$U\!BV\!(RI)_C$ photometric data observed with the 84~cm telescope at the San Pedro Mártir National Astronomical Observatory, México.
The interstellar reddenings, metallicities, distances, and ages have been compared to the literature values. Significant differences are usually due to the usage of diverse empirical calibrations and differing assumptions, such as concerning cluster metallicity, as well as distinct isochrones which correspond to differing element-abundance ratios, internal stellar physics, and photometric systems. Different interstellar reddenings, as well as varying reduction and cluster-membership techniques, are also responsible for these kinds of systematic differences and errors.
The morphological ages, which are derived from the morphological indices ($δV$ and $δ1$) in the CM diagrams, are in good agreement with the isochrone ages of 12 O\!Cs, those with good red clump (RC) and red giant (RG) star candidates. No metal abundance gradient is detected for the range $6.82 \leq R_{GC} \leq 15.37$ kpc, nor any correlation between the cluster ages and metal abundances for these 20 O\!Cs.
Young, metal-poor O\!Cs, observed here in the third Galactic quadrant, may be associated with stellar over-densities, such as that in Canis Major (Martin et al.) and the Monoceros Ring (Newberg et al.), or signatures of past accretion events, as discussed by Yong et al. and Carraro et al.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
