Showing 1–50 of 97 results for author: Oppenheim, J

A quantum oscillator interacting with a classical oscillator

Authors: Muhammad Sajjad, Andrea Russo, Maite Arcos, Andrzej Grudka, Jonathan Oppenheim

Abstract: We study a quantum oscillator interacting and back-reacting on a classical oscillator. This can be done consistently provided the quantum system decoheres, while the backreaction has a stochastic component which causes the classical system to undergo diffusion. Nonetheless the state of the quantum oscillator can remain pure conditioned on the trajectory of the classical oscillator. We solve the sy… ▽ More We study a quantum oscillator interacting and back-reacting on a classical oscillator. This can be done consistently provided the quantum system decoheres, while the backreaction has a stochastic component which causes the classical system to undergo diffusion. Nonetheless the state of the quantum oscillator can remain pure conditioned on the trajectory of the classical oscillator. We solve the system using the classical-quantum path integral formulation, and investigate slow moving regimes of either the classical or quantum oscillator. Lastly, we study the correlators of this classicalquantum setup. We are able to identify the free correlators of the theory and compute the full partition function perturbatively up to second order. This serves as a toy model for a number of other systems in which one system can be treated as effectively classical, such as a scalar quantum field interacting with another field undergoing decoherence, or a system emitting radiation, one of which is treated classically. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Anomalous contribution to galactic rotation curves due to stochastic spacetime

Authors: Jonathan Oppenheim, Andrea Russo

Abstract: We consider a proposed alternative to quantum gravity, in which the spacetime metric is treated as classical, even while matter fields remain quantum. Consistency of the theory necessarily requires that the metric evolve stochastically. Here, we show that this stochastic behaviour leads to a modification of general relativity at low accelerations. In the low acceleration regime, the variance in th… ▽ More We consider a proposed alternative to quantum gravity, in which the spacetime metric is treated as classical, even while matter fields remain quantum. Consistency of the theory necessarily requires that the metric evolve stochastically. Here, we show that this stochastic behaviour leads to a modification of general relativity at low accelerations. In the low acceleration regime, the variance in the acceleration produced by the gravitational field is high in comparison to that produced by the Newtonian potential, and acts as an entropic force, causing a deviation from Einstein's theory of general relativity. We show that in this "diffusion regime", the entropic force acts from a gravitational point of view, as if it were a contribution to the matter distribution. We compute modifications to the expectation value of the metric via the path integral formalism, and find a stochastic contribution which corresponds to a cosmological constant, anti-correlated with a contribution which has been used to fit galactic rotation curves without dark matter. We caution that a greater understanding of this effect is needed before conclusions can be drawn, most likely through numerical simulations, and provide a template for computing the deviation from general relativity which serves as an experimental signature of the Brownian motion of spacetime. △ Less

Submitted 1 May, 2024; v1 submitted 29 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: v2 : a comment added, and more critical discussion extended

Renormalisation of postquantum-classical gravity

Authors: Andrzej Grudka, Jonathan Oppenheim, Andrea Russo, Muhammad Sajjad

Abstract: One of the obstacles to reconciling quantum theory with general relativity, is constructing a theory which is both consistent with observation, and and gives finite answers at high energy, so that the theory holds at arbitrarily short distances. Quantum field theory achieves this through the process of renormalisation, but famously, perturbative quantum gravity fails to be renormalisable. Recently… ▽ More One of the obstacles to reconciling quantum theory with general relativity, is constructing a theory which is both consistent with observation, and and gives finite answers at high energy, so that the theory holds at arbitrarily short distances. Quantum field theory achieves this through the process of renormalisation, but famously, perturbative quantum gravity fails to be renormalisable. Recently, an alternative to quantum gravity has been proposed, in which the geometry of spacetime is taken to be classical rather than quantum, while still being coupled to quantum matter fields. This can be done consistently, provided that the dynamics is fundamentally stochastic. Here, we show that this theory is renormalisable in the gravitational degrees of freedom. We do so via the path integral formulation by relating the classical-quantum action to that of quadratic gravity. Because the action induces stochastic dynamics of spacetime, rather than deterministic evolution of a quantum field, the theory is able to remain renormalisable, while being free of tachyons and negative norm ghosts. The scale invariant and asymptotically free theory appears to be favoured through considerations of complete positivity. The results presented here have a number of implications for inflation, CMB data, and experiments to test the quantum nature of spacetime. They also point to a possible resolution of the black hole singularity. △ Less

Submitted 27 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Diffeomorphism invariant classical-quantum path integrals for Nordstrom gravity

Authors: Jonathan Oppenheim, Andrea Russo, Zachary Weller-Davies

Abstract: When classical degrees of freedom and quantum degrees of freedom are consistently coupled, the former diffuse, while the latter undergo decoherence. Here, we construct a theory of quantum matter fields and Nordstrom gravity in which the space-time metric is treated classically. The dynamics is constructed via the classical-quantum path integral and is completely positive, trace preserving (CPTP),… ▽ More When classical degrees of freedom and quantum degrees of freedom are consistently coupled, the former diffuse, while the latter undergo decoherence. Here, we construct a theory of quantum matter fields and Nordstrom gravity in which the space-time metric is treated classically. The dynamics is constructed via the classical-quantum path integral and is completely positive, trace preserving (CPTP), and respects the classical-quantum split. The weak field limit of the model matches the Newtonian limit of the full covariant path integral but it is easier to show that the theory is both diffeomorphism invariant, CPTP, and has the appropriate classical limit. △ Less

Submitted 10 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

The classical-quantum limit

Authors: Isaac Layton, Jonathan Oppenheim

Abstract: The standard notion of a classical limit, represented schematically by $\hbar\rightarrow 0$, provides a method for approximating a quantum system by a classical one. In this work we explain why the standard classical limit fails when applied to subsystems, and show how one may resolve this by explicitly modelling the decoherence of a subsystem by its environment. Denoting the decoherence time $τ$,… ▽ More The standard notion of a classical limit, represented schematically by $\hbar\rightarrow 0$, provides a method for approximating a quantum system by a classical one. In this work we explain why the standard classical limit fails when applied to subsystems, and show how one may resolve this by explicitly modelling the decoherence of a subsystem by its environment. Denoting the decoherence time $τ$, we demonstrate that a double scaling limit in which $\hbar \rightarrow 0$ and $τ\rightarrow 0$ such that the ratio $E_f =\hbar /τ$ remains fixed leads to an irreversible open-system evolution with well-defined classical and quantum subsystems. The main technical result is showing that, for arbitrary Hamiltonians, the generators of partial versions of the Wigner, Husimi and Glauber-Sudarshan quasiprobability distributions may all be mapped in the above double scaling limit to the same completely-positive classical-quantum generator. This provides a regime in which one can study effective and consistent classical-quantum dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 27 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 27 pages, 19 main

Is it time to rethink quantum gravity?

Authors: Jonathan Oppenheim

Abstract: Although it's widely believed that gravity should have a quantum nature like every other force, the conceptual obstacles to constructing a quantum theory of gravity compel us to explore other perspectives. Gravity is not like any other force. It alone defines a universal space-time geometry, upon which quantum fields evolve. We feel gravity because matter causes space-time to bend. Time flows at u… ▽ More Although it's widely believed that gravity should have a quantum nature like every other force, the conceptual obstacles to constructing a quantum theory of gravity compel us to explore other perspectives. Gravity is not like any other force. It alone defines a universal space-time geometry, upon which quantum fields evolve. We feel gravity because matter causes space-time to bend. Time flows at unequal rates at different locations. The rate at which time flows, and the causal structure it provides, may be required to have a classical description in order for quantum theory to be well-formulated. I discuss arguments for this proposition, but ultimately conclude that we must turn to experiment to guide us. △ Less

Submitted 18 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: Honourable Mention in the Gravity Research Foundation 2023 Awards for Essays on Gravitation

The weak field limit of quantum matter back-reacting on classical spacetime

Authors: Isaac Layton, Jonathan Oppenheim, Andrea Russo, Zachary Weller-Davies

Abstract: Consistent coupling of quantum and classical degrees of freedom exists so long as there is both diffusion of the classical degrees of freedom and decoherence of the quantum system. In this paper, we derive the Newtonian limit of such classical-quantum (CQ) theories of gravity. Our results are obtained both via the gauge fixing of the recently proposed path integral theory of CQ general relativity… ▽ More Consistent coupling of quantum and classical degrees of freedom exists so long as there is both diffusion of the classical degrees of freedom and decoherence of the quantum system. In this paper, we derive the Newtonian limit of such classical-quantum (CQ) theories of gravity. Our results are obtained both via the gauge fixing of the recently proposed path integral theory of CQ general relativity and via the CQ master equation approach. In each case, we find the same weak field dynamics. We find that the Newtonian potential diffuses by an amount lower bounded by the decoherence rate into mass eigenstates. We also present our results as an unravelled system of stochastic differential equations for the trajectory of the hybrid classical-quantum state and provide a series of kernels for constructing figures of merit, which can be used to rule out part of the parameter space of classical-quantum theories of gravity by experimentally testing it via the decoherence-diffusion trade-off. We compare and contrast the weak field limit to previous models of classical Newtonian gravity coupled to quantum systems. Here, we find that the Newtonian potential and quantum state change in lock-step, with the flow of time being stochastic. △ Less

Submitted 5 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 42 pages, 1 table, comments welcomed

Covariant path integrals for quantum fields back-reacting on classical space-time

Authors: Jonathan Oppenheim, Zachary Weller-Davies

Abstract: We introduce configuration space path integrals for quantum fields interacting with classical fields. We show that this can be done consistently by proving that the dynamics are completely positive directly, without resorting to master equation methods. These path integrals allow one to readily impose space-time symmetries, including Lorentz invariance or diffeomorphism invariance. They generalize… ▽ More We introduce configuration space path integrals for quantum fields interacting with classical fields. We show that this can be done consistently by proving that the dynamics are completely positive directly, without resorting to master equation methods. These path integrals allow one to readily impose space-time symmetries, including Lorentz invariance or diffeomorphism invariance. They generalize and combine the Feynman-Vernon path integral of open quantum systems and the stochastic path integral of classical stochastic dynamics while respecting symmetry principles. We introduce a path integral formulation of general relativity where the space-time metric is treated classically, as well as a diffeomorphism invariant theory based on the trace of Einstein's equations. The theory is a candidate for a fundamental theory that reconciles general relativity with quantum mechanics. △ Less

Submitted 14 November, 2023; v1 submitted 14 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Comments: 8 pages plus 4 appendices

Path integrals for classical-quantum dynamics

Authors: Jonathan Oppenheim, Zachary Weller-Davies

Abstract: Consistent dynamics which couples classical and quantum degrees of freedom exists. This dynamics is linear in the hybrid state, completely positive and trace preserving. Starting from completely positive classical-quantum master equations, we derive a general path integral representation for such dynamics in terms of a classical-quantum action, which includes the necessary and sufficient condition… ▽ More Consistent dynamics which couples classical and quantum degrees of freedom exists. This dynamics is linear in the hybrid state, completely positive and trace preserving. Starting from completely positive classical-quantum master equations, we derive a general path integral representation for such dynamics in terms of a classical-quantum action, which includes the necessary and sufficient conditions for complete positivity and trace preservation. The path integral we study is a generalization of the Feynman path integral for quantum systems, and the stochastic path integral used to study classical stochastic processes, allowing for interaction between the classical and quantum systems. When the classical-quantum Hamiltonian is at most quadratic in the momenta we are able to derive a configuration space path integral, providing a map between master equations and covariant classical-quantum path integrals. △ Less

Submitted 11 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Comments: 18 main. 25 total

Semantic Decomposition Improves Learning of Large Language Models on EHR Data

Authors: David A. Bloore, Romane Gauriau, Anna L. Decker, Jacob Oppenheim

Abstract: Electronic health records (EHR) are widely believed to hold a profusion of actionable insights, encrypted in an irregular, semi-structured format, amidst a loud noise background. To simplify learning patterns of health and disease, medical codes in EHR can be decomposed into semantic units connected by hierarchical graphs. Building on earlier synergy between Bidirectional Encoder Representations f… ▽ More Electronic health records (EHR) are widely believed to hold a profusion of actionable insights, encrypted in an irregular, semi-structured format, amidst a loud noise background. To simplify learning patterns of health and disease, medical codes in EHR can be decomposed into semantic units connected by hierarchical graphs. Building on earlier synergy between Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers (BERT) and Graph Attention Networks (GAT), we present H-BERT, which ingests complete graph tree expansions of hierarchical medical codes as opposed to only ingesting the leaves and pushes patient-level labels down to each visit. This methodology significantly improves prediction of patient membership in over 500 medical diagnosis classes as measured by aggregated AUC and APS, and creates distinct representations of patients in closely related but clinically distinct phenotypes. △ Less

Submitted 14 November, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Comments: Extended Abstract presented at Machine Learning for Health (ML4H) symposium 2022, November 28th, 2022, New Orleans, United States & Virtual, http://www.ml4h.cc, 9 pages

Molecular Fingerprints for Robust and Efficient ML-Driven Molecular Generation

Authors: Ruslan N. Tazhigulov, Joshua Schiller, Jacob Oppenheim, Max Winston

Abstract: We propose a novel molecular fingerprint-based variational autoencoder applied for molecular generation on real-world drug molecules. We define more suitable and pharma-relevant baseline metrics and tests, focusing on the generation of diverse, drug-like, novel small molecules and scaffolds. When we apply these molecular generation metrics to our novel model, we observe a substantial improvement i… ▽ More We propose a novel molecular fingerprint-based variational autoencoder applied for molecular generation on real-world drug molecules. We define more suitable and pharma-relevant baseline metrics and tests, focusing on the generation of diverse, drug-like, novel small molecules and scaffolds. When we apply these molecular generation metrics to our novel model, we observe a substantial improvement in chemical synthetic accessibility ($Δ\bar{SAS}$ = -0.83) and in computational efficiency up to 5.9x in comparison to an existing state-of-the-art SMILES-based architecture. △ Less

Submitted 16 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: 7 pages, 5 figures. To be presented in the Machine Learning and the Physical Sciences workshop, NeurIPS 2022, New Orleans, United States, December 3, 2022, https://ml4physicalsciences.github.io/2022/

Phenotype Detection in Real World Data via Online MixEHR Algorithm

Authors: Ying Xu, Romane Gauriau, Anna Decker, Jacob Oppenheim

Abstract: Understanding patterns of diagnoses, medications, procedures, and laboratory tests from electronic health records (EHRs) and health insurer claims is important for understanding disease risk and for efficient clinical development, which often require rules-based curation in collaboration with clinicians. We extended an unsupervised phenoty** algorithm, mixEHR, to an online version allowing us to… ▽ More Understanding patterns of diagnoses, medications, procedures, and laboratory tests from electronic health records (EHRs) and health insurer claims is important for understanding disease risk and for efficient clinical development, which often require rules-based curation in collaboration with clinicians. We extended an unsupervised phenoty** algorithm, mixEHR, to an online version allowing us to use it on order of magnitude larger datasets including a large, US-based claims dataset and a rich regional EHR dataset. In addition to recapitulating previously observed disease groups, we discovered clinically meaningful disease subtypes and comorbidities. This work scaled up an effective unsupervised learning method, reinforced existing clinical knowledge, and is a promising approach for efficient collaboration with clinicians. △ Less

Submitted 15 November, 2022; v1 submitted 14 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Comments: Extended Abstract presented at Machine Learning for Health (ML4H) symposium 2022, November 28th, 2022, New Orleans, United States & Virtual, http://www.ml4h.cc, 6 pages

A healthier semi-classical dynamics

Authors: Isaac Layton, Jonathan Oppenheim, Zachary Weller-Davies

Abstract: We study the back-reaction of quantum systems onto classical ones. Taking the starting point that semi-classical physics should be described at all times by a point in classical phase space and a quantum state in Hilbert space, we consider an unravelling approach, describing the system in terms of a classical-quantum trajectory. We derive the general form of the dynamics under the assumptions that… ▽ More We study the back-reaction of quantum systems onto classical ones. Taking the starting point that semi-classical physics should be described at all times by a point in classical phase space and a quantum state in Hilbert space, we consider an unravelling approach, describing the system in terms of a classical-quantum trajectory. We derive the general form of the dynamics under the assumptions that the classical trajectories are continuous and the evolution is autonomous, and the requirement that the dynamics is linear and completely positive in the combined classical-quantum state. This requirement is necessary in order to consistently describe probabilities, and forces the dynamics to be stochastic when the back-reaction is non-zero. The resulting equations of motion are natural generalisations of the standard semi-classical equations of motion, but since the resulting dynamics is linear in the combined classical-quantum state, it does not lead to the pathologies which usually follow from evolution laws based on expectation values. In particular, the evolution laws we present account for correlations between the classical and quantum system, which resolves issues associated with other semi-classical approaches. In addition, despite a breakdown of predictability in the classical degrees of freedom, the quantum state evolves deterministically conditioned on the classical trajectory, provided a trade-off between decoherence and diffusion is saturated. As a result, the quantum state remains pure when conditioned on the classical trajectory. To illustrate these points, we numerically simulate a number of semi-classical toy models, including one of vacuum fluctuations as a source driving the expansion of the universe. Finally, we discuss the application of these results to semi-classical gravity, and the black-hole information problem. △ Less

Submitted 9 February, 2023; v1 submitted 24 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Comments: 12 main, 31 total, 8 figures V2: fixed typos; improved presentation in main results section; alternate notation and proof details for main results added to appendices A and C

Gravitationally induced decoherence vs space-time diffusion: testing the quantum nature of gravity

Authors: Jonathan Oppenheim, Carlo Sparaciari, Barbara Šoda, Zachary Weller-Davies

Abstract: We consider two interacting systems when one is treated classically while the other system remains quantum. Consistent dynamics of this coupling has been shown to exist, and explored in the context of treating space-time classically. Here, we prove that such hybrid dynamics necessarily results in decoherence of the quantum system, and a breakdown in predictability in the classical phase space. We… ▽ More We consider two interacting systems when one is treated classically while the other system remains quantum. Consistent dynamics of this coupling has been shown to exist, and explored in the context of treating space-time classically. Here, we prove that such hybrid dynamics necessarily results in decoherence of the quantum system, and a breakdown in predictability in the classical phase space. We further prove that a trade-off between the rate of this decoherence and the degree of diffusion induced in the classical system is a general feature of all classical quantum dynamics; long coherence times require strong diffusion in phase-space relative to the strength of the coupling. Applying the trade-off relation to gravity, we find a relationship between the strength of gravitationally-induced decoherence versus diffusion of the metric and its conjugate momenta. This provides an experimental signature of theories in which gravity is fundamentally classical. Bounds on decoherence rates arising from current interferometry experiments, combined with precision measurements of mass, place significant restrictions on theories where Einstein's classical theory of gravity interacts with quantum matter. We find that part of the parameter space of such theories are already squeezed out, and provide figures of merit which can be used in future mass measurements and interference experiments. △ Less

Submitted 3 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: 16 pages main + 21 pages appendices

Journal ref: Nat Commun 14, 7910 (2023)

The two classes of hybrid classical-quantum dynamics

Authors: Jonathan Oppenheim, Carlo Sparaciari, Barbara Šoda, Zachary Weller-Davies

Abstract: Coupling between quantum and classical systems is consistent, provided the evolution is linear in the state space, preserves the split of systems into quantum and classical degrees of freedom, and preserves probabilities. The evolution law must be a completely positive and norm preserving map. We prove that if the dynamics is memoryless, there are two classes of these dynamics, one which features… ▽ More Coupling between quantum and classical systems is consistent, provided the evolution is linear in the state space, preserves the split of systems into quantum and classical degrees of freedom, and preserves probabilities. The evolution law must be a completely positive and norm preserving map. We prove that if the dynamics is memoryless, there are two classes of these dynamics, one which features finite sized jumps in the classical phase space and one which is continuous. We find the most general form of each class of classical-quantum master equation. This is achieved by applying the complete positivity conditions using a generalized Cauchy-Schwartz inequality applicable to classical-quantum systems. The key technical result is a generalisation of the Pawula theorem. △ Less

Submitted 2 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: 8 pages + appendicies

The constraints of post-quantum classical gravity

Authors: Jonathan Oppenheim, Zachary Weller-Davies

Abstract: We study a class of theories in which space-time is treated classically, while interacting with quantum fields. These circumvent various no-go theorems and the pathologies of semi-classical gravity, by being linear in the density matrix and phase-space density. The theory can either be considered fundamental or as an effective theory where the classical limit is taken of space-time. The theories h… ▽ More We study a class of theories in which space-time is treated classically, while interacting with quantum fields. These circumvent various no-go theorems and the pathologies of semi-classical gravity, by being linear in the density matrix and phase-space density. The theory can either be considered fundamental or as an effective theory where the classical limit is taken of space-time. The theories have the dynamics of general relativity as their classical limit and provide a way to study the back-action of quantum fields on the space-time metric. The theory is invariant under spatial diffeomorphisms, and here, we provide a methodology to derive the constraint equations of such a theory by imposing invariance of the dynamics under time-reparametrization invariance. This leads to generalisations of the Hamiltonian and momentum constraints. We compute the constraint algebra for a wide class of realisations of the theory (the "discrete class") in the case of a quantum scalar field interacting with gravity. We find that the algebra doesn't close without additional constraints, although these do not necessarily reduce the number of local degrees of freedom. △ Less

Submitted 7 February, 2022; v1 submitted 30 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: 32 +4 pages, V2 added background material and general improvements. Accepted in JHEP

Journal ref: JHEP 02 (2022) 080

Objective trajectories in hybrid classical-quantum dynamics

Authors: Jonathan Oppenheim, Carlo Sparaciari, Barbara Šoda, Zachary Weller-Davies

Abstract: Consistent dynamics which couples classical and quantum degrees of freedom exists, provided it is stochastic. This dynamics is linear in the hybrid state, completely positive and trace preserving. One application of this is to study the back-reaction of quantum fields on space-time which does not suffer from the pathologies of the semi-classical equations. Here we introduce several toy models in w… ▽ More Consistent dynamics which couples classical and quantum degrees of freedom exists, provided it is stochastic. This dynamics is linear in the hybrid state, completely positive and trace preserving. One application of this is to study the back-reaction of quantum fields on space-time which does not suffer from the pathologies of the semi-classical equations. Here we introduce several toy models in which to study hybrid classical-quantum evolution, including a qubit coupled to a particle in a potential, and a quantum harmonic oscillator coupled to a classical one. We present an unravelling approach to calculate the dynamics, and provide code to numerically simulate it. Unlike the purely quantum case, the trajectories (or histories) of this unravelling can be unique, conditioned on the classical degrees of freedom for discrete realisations of the dynamics, when different jumps in the classical degrees of freedom are accompanied by the action of unique operators on the quantum system. As a result, the ``measurement postulate'' of quantum theory is not needed; quantum systems become classical because they interact with a fundamentally classical field. △ Less

Submitted 2 January, 2023; v1 submitted 11 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: 35 pages (Quantum format), 8 figures; appendix 6 pages. Accepted for publication in Quantum

Journal ref: Quantum 7, 891 (2023)

A postquantum theory of classical gravity?

Authors: Jonathan Oppenheim

Abstract: The effort to discover a quantum theory of gravity is motivated by the need to reconcile the incompatibility between quantum theory and general relativity. Here, we present an alternative approach by constructing a consistent theory of classical gravity coupled to quantum field theory. The dynamics is linear in the density matrix, completely positive and trace preserving, and reduces to Einstein's… ▽ More The effort to discover a quantum theory of gravity is motivated by the need to reconcile the incompatibility between quantum theory and general relativity. Here, we present an alternative approach by constructing a consistent theory of classical gravity coupled to quantum field theory. The dynamics is linear in the density matrix, completely positive and trace preserving, and reduces to Einstein's theory of general relativity in the classical limit. Consequently, the dynamics doesn't suffer from the pathologies of the semiclassical theory based on expectation values. The assumption that general relativity is classical necessarily modifies the dynamical laws of quantum mechanics -- the theory must be fundamentally stochastic in both the metric degrees of freedom and in the quantum matter fields. This allows it to evade several no-go theorems purporting to forbid classical-quantum interactions. The measurement postulate of quantum mechanics is not needed -- the interaction of the quantum degrees of freedom with classical space-time necessarily causes decoherence in the quantum system. We first derive the general form of classical-quantum dynamics and consider realisations which have as its limit deterministic classical Hamiltonian evolution. The formalism is then applied to quantum field theory interacting with the classical space-time metric. One can view the classical-quantum theory as fundamental or as an effective theory useful for computing the back-reaction of quantum fields on geometry. We discuss a number of open questions from the perspective of both viewpoints. △ Less

Submitted 27 November, 2023; v1 submitted 7 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Comments: "It's very difficult to find a black cat in a dark room, especially if there is no cat."

The first law of general quantum resource theories

Authors: Carlo Sparaciari, Lidia del Rio, Carlo Maria Scandolo, Philippe Faist, Jonathan Oppenheim

Abstract: We extend the tools of quantum resource theories to scenarios in which multiple quantities (or resources) are present, and their interplay governs the evolution of physical systems. We derive conditions for the interconversion of these resources, which generalise the first law of thermodynamics. We study reversibility conditions for multi-resource theories, and find that the relative entropy dista… ▽ More We extend the tools of quantum resource theories to scenarios in which multiple quantities (or resources) are present, and their interplay governs the evolution of physical systems. We derive conditions for the interconversion of these resources, which generalise the first law of thermodynamics. We study reversibility conditions for multi-resource theories, and find that the relative entropy distances from the invariant sets of the theory play a fundamental role in the quantification of the resources. The first law for general multi-resource theories is a single relation which links the change in the properties of the system during a state transformation and the weighted sum of the resources exchanged. In fact, this law can be seen as relating the change in the relative entropy from different sets of states. In contrast to typical single-resource theories, the notion of free states and invariant sets of states become distinct in light of multiple constraints. Additionally, generalisations of the Helmholtz free energy, and of adiabatic and isothermal transformations, emerge. We thus have a set of laws for general quantum resource theories, which generalise the laws of thermodynamics. We first test this approach on thermodynamics with multiple conservation laws, and then apply it to the theory of local operations under energetic restrictions. △ Less

Submitted 20 April, 2020; v1 submitted 13 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Comments: 33 pages main text, 25 pages appendix, 9 figure, 1 flowchart. Accepted in Quantum

Journal ref: Quantum 4, 259 (2020)

Holographic second laws of black hole thermodynamics

Authors: Alice Bernamonti, Federico Galli, Robert C. Myers, Jonathan Oppenheim

Abstract: Recently, it has been shown that for out-of-equilibrium systems, there are additional constraints on thermodynamical evolution besides the ordinary second law. These form a new family of second laws of thermodynamics, which are equivalent to the monotonicity of quantum Rényi divergences. In black hole thermodynamics, the usual second law is manifest as the area increase theorem. Hence one may ask… ▽ More Recently, it has been shown that for out-of-equilibrium systems, there are additional constraints on thermodynamical evolution besides the ordinary second law. These form a new family of second laws of thermodynamics, which are equivalent to the monotonicity of quantum Rényi divergences. In black hole thermodynamics, the usual second law is manifest as the area increase theorem. Hence one may ask if these additional laws imply new restrictions for gravitational dynamics, such as for out-of-equilibrium black holes? Inspired by this question, we study these constraints within the AdS/CFT correspondence. First, we show that the Rényi divergence can be computed via a Euclidean path integral for a certain class of excited CFT states. Applying this construction to the boundary CFT, the Rényi divergence is evaluated as the renormalized action for a particular bulk solution of a minimally coupled gravity-scalar system. Further, within this framework, we show that there exist transitions which are allowed by the traditional second law, but forbidden by the additional thermodynamical constraints. We speculate on the implications of our findings. △ Less

Submitted 9 October, 2018; v1 submitted 9 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: 81 pages, 19 figures; v2: clarifications and reference added, minor typos corrected, published version

Entanglement fluctuation theorems

Authors: Álvaro M. Alhambra, Lluis Masanes, Jonathan Oppenheim, Christopher Perry

Abstract: Pure state entanglement transformations have been thought of as irreversible, with reversible transformations generally only possible in the limit of many copies. Here, we show that reversible entanglement transformations do not require processing on the many copy level, but can instead be undertaken on individual systems, provided the amount of entanglement which is produced or consumed is allowe… ▽ More Pure state entanglement transformations have been thought of as irreversible, with reversible transformations generally only possible in the limit of many copies. Here, we show that reversible entanglement transformations do not require processing on the many copy level, but can instead be undertaken on individual systems, provided the amount of entanglement which is produced or consumed is allowed to fluctuate. We derive necessary and sufficient conditions for entanglement manipulations in this case. As a corollary, we derive an equation which quantifies the fluctuations of entanglement, which is formally identical to the Jarzynski fluctuation equality found in thermodynamics. One can also relate a forward entanglement transformation to its reverse process in terms of the entanglement cost of such a transformation, in a manner equivalent to the Crooks relation. We show that a strong converse theorem for entanglement transformations is formally related to the second law of thermodynamics, while the fact that the Schmidt rank of an entangled state cannot increase is related to the third law of thermodynamics. Achievability of the protocols is done by introducing an entanglement battery, a device which stores entanglement and uses an amount of entanglement that is allowed to fluctuate but with an average cost which is still optimal. This allows us to also solve the problem of partial entanglement recovery, and in fact, we show that entanglement is fully recovered. Allowing the amount of consumed entanglement to fluctuate also leads to improved and optimal entanglement dilution protocols. △ Less

Submitted 19 July, 2019; v1 submitted 18 September, 2017; originally announced September 2017.

Comments: comments welcome, v2 published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 100, 012317 (2019)

Approximate Majorization

Authors: Michał Horodecki, Jonathan Oppenheim, Carlo Sparaciari

Abstract: Although an input distribution may not majorize a target distribution, it may majorize a distribution which is close to the target. Here we introduce a notion of approximate majorization. For any distribution, and given a distance $δ$, we find the approximate distributions which majorize (are majorized by) all other distributions within the distance $δ$. We call these the steepest and flattest app… ▽ More Although an input distribution may not majorize a target distribution, it may majorize a distribution which is close to the target. Here we introduce a notion of approximate majorization. For any distribution, and given a distance $δ$, we find the approximate distributions which majorize (are majorized by) all other distributions within the distance $δ$. We call these the steepest and flattest approximation. This enables one to compute how close one can get to a given target distribution under a process governed by majorization. We show that the flattest and steepest approximations preserve ordering under majorization. Furthermore, we give a notion of majorization distance. This has applications ranging from thermodynamics, entanglement theory, and economics. △ Less

Submitted 16 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Comments: 4 pages main text + 6 pages appendix. 2 figure

Journal ref: J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 51 305301 (2018)

Energetic instability of passive states in thermodynamics

Authors: Carlo Sparaciari, David Jennings, Jonathan Oppenheim

Abstract: Passivity is a fundamental concept in thermodynamics that demands a quantum system's energy cannot be lowered by any reversible, unitary process acting on the system. In the limit of many such systems, passivity leads in turn to the concept of complete passivity, thermal states, and the emergence of a thermodynamic temperature. In contrast, here we need only consider a single system and show that… ▽ More Passivity is a fundamental concept in thermodynamics that demands a quantum system's energy cannot be lowered by any reversible, unitary process acting on the system. In the limit of many such systems, passivity leads in turn to the concept of complete passivity, thermal states, and the emergence of a thermodynamic temperature. In contrast, here we need only consider a single system and show that every passive state except the thermal state is unstable under a weaker form of reversibility. More precisely, we show that given a single copy of any athermal quantum state we may extract a maximal amount of energy from the state when we can use a machine that operates in a reversible cycle and whose state is left unchanged. This means that for individual systems the only form of passivity that is stable under general reversible processes is complete passivity, and thus provides a single-shot and more physically motivated identification of thermal states and the emergence of temperature. The machine which extracts work from passive states exploits the fact that one can find a subspace which acts as a virtual hot reservoir, and a subspace which acts as a virtual cold reservoir. We show that an optimal amount of work can be extracted, and that the machine operates at the Carnot efficiency between pairs of virtual reservoirs. △ Less

Submitted 6 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Comments: Main text: 11 pages, 5 figures. Supplemental material: 12 pages, 1 figure

Journal ref: Nat. Commun 8, 1895 (2017)

Autonomous quantum machines and the finite sized Quasi-Ideal clock

Authors: Mischa P. Woods, Ralph Silva, Jonathan Oppenheim

Abstract: Processes such as quantum computation, or the evolution of quantum cellular automata are typically described by a unitary operation implemented by an external observer. In particular, an interaction is generally turned on for a precise amount of time, using a classical clock. A fully quantum mechanical description of such a device would include a quantum description of the clock whose state is gen… ▽ More Processes such as quantum computation, or the evolution of quantum cellular automata are typically described by a unitary operation implemented by an external observer. In particular, an interaction is generally turned on for a precise amount of time, using a classical clock. A fully quantum mechanical description of such a device would include a quantum description of the clock whose state is generally disturbed because of the back-reaction on it. Such a description is needed if we wish to consider finite sized autonomous quantum machines requiring no external control. The extent of the back-reaction has implications on how small the device can be, on the length of time the device can run, and is required if we want to understand what a fully quantum mechanical treatment of an observer would look like. Here, we consider the implementation of a unitary by a finite sized device which we call the "Quasi-Ideal clock", and show that the back-reaction on it can be made exponentially small in the device's dimension with only a linear increase in energy. As a result, an autonomous quantum machine need only be of modest size and or energy. We are also able to solve a long-standing open problem by using a finite sized quantum clock to approximate the continuous evolution of an Idealised clock. The result has implications on the equivalence of different paradigms of quantum thermodynamics, some which allow external control and some which only allow autonomous thermal machines. △ Less

Submitted 4 November, 2018; v1 submitted 15 July, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

Comments: Main text: 9 + 53 pages. V4: Close to the published version, J. Annales Henri Poincaré (2018) [Communicated by David Pérez-García]

A Resource Theory for Work and Heat

Authors: Carlo Sparaciari, Jonathan Oppenheim, Tobias Fritz

Abstract: Several recent results on thermodynamics have been obtained using the tools of quantum information theory and resource theories. So far, the resource theories utilised to describe thermodynamics have assumed the existence of an infinite thermal reservoir, by declaring that thermal states at some background temperature come for free. Here, we propose a resource theory of quantum thermodynamics with… ▽ More Several recent results on thermodynamics have been obtained using the tools of quantum information theory and resource theories. So far, the resource theories utilised to describe thermodynamics have assumed the existence of an infinite thermal reservoir, by declaring that thermal states at some background temperature come for free. Here, we propose a resource theory of quantum thermodynamics without a background temperature, so that no states at all come for free. We apply this resource theory to the case of many non-interacting systems, and show that all quantum states are classified by their entropy and average energy, even arbitrarily far away from equilibrium. This implies that thermodynamics takes place in a two-dimensional convex set that we call the energy-entropy diagram. The answers to many resource-theoretic questions about thermodynamics can be read off from this diagram, such as the efficiency of a heat engine consisting of finite reservoirs, or the rate of conversion between two states. This allows us to consider a resource theory which puts work and heat on an equal footing, and serves as a model for other resource theories. △ Less

Submitted 19 October, 2017; v1 submitted 5 July, 2016; originally announced July 2016.

Comments: main text: 12 pages, 5 figure; appendix: 7 pages

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 96, 052112 (2017)

The second law of quantum thermodynamics as an equality

Authors: Álvaro M. Alhambra, Lluis Masanes, Jonathan Oppenheim, Christopher Perry

Abstract: We investigate the connection between recent results in quantum thermodynamics and fluctuation relations by adopting a fully quantum mechanical description of thermodynamics. By including a work system whose energy is allowed to fluctuate, we derive a set of equalities which all thermodynamical transitions have to satisfy. This extends the condition for maps to be Gibbs-preserving to the case of f… ▽ More We investigate the connection between recent results in quantum thermodynamics and fluctuation relations by adopting a fully quantum mechanical description of thermodynamics. By including a work system whose energy is allowed to fluctuate, we derive a set of equalities which all thermodynamical transitions have to satisfy. This extends the condition for maps to be Gibbs-preserving to the case of fluctuating work, providing a more general characterisation of maps commonly used in the information theoretic approach to thermodynamics. For final states, block diagonal in the energy basis, this set of equalities are necessary and sufficient conditions for a thermodynamical state transition to be possible. The conditions serves as a parent equation which can be used to derive a number of results. These include writing the second law of thermodynamics as an equality featuring a fine-grained notion of the free energy. It also yields a generalisation of the Jarzynski fluctuation theorem which holds for arbitrary initial states, and under the most general manipulations allowed by the laws of quantum mechanics. Furthermore, we show that each of these relations can be seen as the quasi-classical limit of three fully quantum identities. This allows us to consider the free energy as an operator, and allows one to obtain more general and fully quantum fluctuation relations from the information theoretic approach to quantum thermodynamics. △ Less

Submitted 24 March, 2017; v1 submitted 21 January, 2016; originally announced January 2016.

Comments: 11+3 pages. V4: Updated to match published version. Discussion of thermo-majorization and implementing arbitary unitaries added. V3: Added funding information. V2: Expanded discussion on relation to fluctuation theorems

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. X 6, 041017 (2016)

Microcanonical and resource-theoretic derivations of the thermal state of a quantum system with noncommuting charges

Authors: Nicole Yunger Halpern, Philippe Faist, Jonathan Oppenheim, Andreas Winter

Abstract: The grand canonical ensemble lies at the core of quantum and classical statistical mechanics. A small system thermalizes to this ensemble while exchanging heat and particles with a bath. A quantum system may exchange quantities represented by operators that fail to commute. Whether such a system thermalizes and what form the thermal state has are questions about truly quantum thermodynamics. Here… ▽ More The grand canonical ensemble lies at the core of quantum and classical statistical mechanics. A small system thermalizes to this ensemble while exchanging heat and particles with a bath. A quantum system may exchange quantities represented by operators that fail to commute. Whether such a system thermalizes and what form the thermal state has are questions about truly quantum thermodynamics. Here we investigate this thermal state from three perspectives. First, we introduce an approximate microcanonical ensemble. If this ensemble characterizes the system-and-bath composite, tracing out the bath yields the system's thermal state. This state is expected to be the equilibrium point, we argue, of typical dynamics. Finally, we define a resource-theory model for thermodynamic exchanges of noncommuting observables. Complete passivity---the inability to extract work from equilibrium states---implies the thermal state's form, too. Our work opens new avenues into equilibrium in the presence of quantum noncommutation. △ Less

Submitted 21 July, 2016; v1 submitted 3 December, 2015; originally announced December 2015.

Comments: Published version. 7 pages (2 figures) + appendices. The leading author's surname is "Yunger Halpern."

Journal ref: Nature Communications 7, 12051 (2016)

A sufficient set of experimentally implementable thermal operations

Authors: Chris Perry, Piotr Ćwikliński, Janet Anders, Michał Horodecki, Jonathan Oppenheim

Abstract: Recent work using tools from quantum information theory has shown that at the nanoscale where quantum effects become prevalent, there is not one thermodynamical second law but many. Derivations of these laws assume that an experimenter has very precise control of the system and heat bath. Here we show that these multitude of laws can be saturated using two very simple operations: changing the ener… ▽ More Recent work using tools from quantum information theory has shown that at the nanoscale where quantum effects become prevalent, there is not one thermodynamical second law but many. Derivations of these laws assume that an experimenter has very precise control of the system and heat bath. Here we show that these multitude of laws can be saturated using two very simple operations: changing the energy levels of the system and thermalizing over any two system energy levels. Using these two operations, one can distill the optimal amount of work from a system, as well as perform the reverse formation process. Even more surprisingly, using only these two operations and one ancilla qubit in a thermal state, one can transform any state into any other state allowable by the second laws. We thus have the remarkable result that the second laws hold for fine-grained manipulation of system and bath, but can be achieved using very coarse control. This brings the full array of thermal operations into a regime accessible by experiment, and establishes the physical relevance of these second laws. △ Less

Submitted 10 October, 2016; v1 submitted 20 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Comments: 7+28 pages, 25 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. X 8, 041049 (2018)

The extraction of work from quantum coherence

Authors: Kamil Korzekwa, Matteo Lostaglio, Jonathan Oppenheim, David Jennings

Abstract: The interplay between quantum-mechanical properties, such as coherence, and classical notions, such as energy, is a subtle topic at the forefront of quantum thermodynamics. The traditional Carnot argument limits the conversion of heat to work; here we critically assess the problem of converting coherence to work. Through a careful account of all resources involved in the thermodynamic transformati… ▽ More The interplay between quantum-mechanical properties, such as coherence, and classical notions, such as energy, is a subtle topic at the forefront of quantum thermodynamics. The traditional Carnot argument limits the conversion of heat to work; here we critically assess the problem of converting coherence to work. Through a careful account of all resources involved in the thermodynamic transformations within a fully quantum-mechanical treatment, we show that there exist thermal machines extracting work from coherence arbitrarily well. Such machines only need to act on individual copies of a state and can be reused. On the other hand, we show that for any thermal machine with finite resources not all the coherence of a state can be extracted as work. However, even bounded thermal machines can be reused infinitely many times in the process of work extraction from coherence. △ Less

Submitted 22 February, 2016; v1 submitted 25 June, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Comments: 15 pages, 4 figures. Published version. Improved and expanded discussion

Journal ref: New J. Phys. 18, 023045 (2016)

Do black holes create polyamory?

Authors: Andrzej Grudka, Michael J. W. Hall, Michal Horodecki, Ryszard Horodecki, Jonathan Oppenheim, John A. Smolin

Abstract: Of course not, but if one believes that information cannot be destroyed in a theory of quantum gravity, then we run into apparent contradictions with quantum theory when we consider evaporating black holes. Namely that the no-cloning theorem or the principle of entanglement monogamy is violated. Here, we show that neither violation need hold, since, in arguing that black holes lead to cloning or n… ▽ More Of course not, but if one believes that information cannot be destroyed in a theory of quantum gravity, then we run into apparent contradictions with quantum theory when we consider evaporating black holes. Namely that the no-cloning theorem or the principle of entanglement monogamy is violated. Here, we show that neither violation need hold, since, in arguing that black holes lead to cloning or non-monogamy, one needs to assume a tensor product structure between two points in space-time that could instead be viewed as causally connected. In the latter case, one is violating the semi-classical causal structure of space, which is a strictly weaker implication than cloning or non-monogamy. We show that the lack of monogamy that can emerge in evaporating space times is one that is allowed in quantum mechanics, and is very naturally related to a lack of monogamy of correlations of outputs of measurements performed at subsequent instances of time of a single system. A particular example of this is the Horowitz-Maldacena proposal, and we argue that it needn't lead to cloning or violations of entanglement monogamy. For measurements on systems which appear to be leaving a black hole, we introduce the notion of the temporal product, and argue that it is just as natural a choice for measurements as the tensor product. For black holes, the tensor and temporal products have the same measurement statistics, but result in different type of non-monogamy of correlations, with the former being forbidden in quantum theory while the latter is allowed. In the case of the AMPS firewall experiment we find that the entanglement structure is modified, and one must have entanglement between the infalling Hawking partners and early time outgoing Hawking radiation which surprisingly tame violation of entanglement monogamy. △ Less

Submitted 27 February, 2017; v1 submitted 23 June, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Comments: 20 pages, comments welcome, grants added to acknowledgements

Journal ref: J. High Energ. Phys. 45 (2018)

What is the probability of a thermodynamical transition?

Authors: Álvaro M. Alhambra, Jonathan Oppenheim, Christopher Perry

Abstract: If the second law of thermodynamics forbids a transition from one state to another, then it is still possible to make the transition happen by using a sufficient amount of work. But if we do not have access to this amount of work, can the transition happen probabilistically? In the thermodynamic limit, this probability tends to zero, but here we find that for finite-sized systems, it can be finite… ▽ More If the second law of thermodynamics forbids a transition from one state to another, then it is still possible to make the transition happen by using a sufficient amount of work. But if we do not have access to this amount of work, can the transition happen probabilistically? In the thermodynamic limit, this probability tends to zero, but here we find that for finite-sized systems, it can be finite. We compute the maximum probability of a transition or a thermodynamical fluctuation from any initial state to any final state, and show that this maximum can be achieved for any final state which is block-diagonal in the energy eigenbasis. We also find upper and lower bounds on this transition probability, in terms of the work of transition. As a bi-product, we introduce a finite set of thermodynamical monotones related to the thermo-majorization criteria which governs state transitions, and compute the work of transition in terms of them. The trade-off between the probability of a transition, and any partial work added to aid in that transition is also considered. Our results have applications in entanglement theory, and we find the amount of entanglement required (or gained) when transforming one pure entangled state into any other. △ Less

Submitted 16 February, 2016; v1 submitted 31 March, 2015; originally announced April 2015.

Comments: 15+6 pages, 7+1 figures V3: Added discussion on heralded probability and relation to fluctuation theorems. V2: Emphasized that X can be any state and that the achievability of our result in the full thermodynamics case, holds only when the target state is block-diagonal in the energy eigenbasis

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. X 6, 041016 (2016)

A derivation (and quantification) of the third law of thermodynamics

Authors: Lluis Masanes, Jonathan Oppenheim

Abstract: The third law of thermodynamics has a controversial past and a number of formulations due to Planck, Einstein, and Nernst. It's most accepted version, the unattainability principle, states that "any thermodynamic process cannot reach the temperature of absolute zero by a finite number of steps and within a finite time." Although formulated in 1912, there has been no general proof of the principle,… ▽ More The third law of thermodynamics has a controversial past and a number of formulations due to Planck, Einstein, and Nernst. It's most accepted version, the unattainability principle, states that "any thermodynamic process cannot reach the temperature of absolute zero by a finite number of steps and within a finite time." Although formulated in 1912, there has been no general proof of the principle, and the only evidence we have for it is that particular cooling methods become less efficient as the temperature decreases. Here we provide the first derivation of a general unattainability principle, which applies to arbitrary cooling processes, even those exploiting the laws of quantum mechanics or involving an infinite-dimensional reservoir. We quantify the resources needed to cool a system to any particular temperature, and translate these resources into a minimal time or number of steps by considering the notion of a Thermal Machine which obeys similar restrictions to universal computers. We generally find that the obtainable temperature can scale as an inverse power of the cooling time. Our argument relies on the heat capacity of the bath being positive, and we show that if this is not the case then perfect cooling in finite time is in principle possible. Our results also clarify the connection between two versions of the third law (the Unattainability Principle and the Heat Theorem), and place ultimate bounds on the speed at which information can be erased. △ Less

Submitted 7 April, 2016; v1 submitted 11 December, 2014; originally announced December 2014.

Comments: Substantial improvement of the third law derivation, which now only relies on a single assumption: the positivity of the heat capacity. 7 pages+appendix, 2 figures

Journal ref: Nature Communications volume 8, Article number: 14538 (2017)

Quantum Conditional Mutual Information, Reconstructed States, and State Redistribution

Authors: Fernando G. S. L. Brandao, Aram W. Harrow, Jonathan Oppenheim, Sergii Strelchuk

Abstract: We give two strengthenings of an inequality for the quantum conditional mutual information of a tripartite quantum state recently proved by Fawzi and Renner, connecting it with the ability to reconstruct the state from its bipartite reductions. Namely we show that the conditional mutual information is an upper bound on the regularised relative entropy distance between the quantum state and its rec… ▽ More We give two strengthenings of an inequality for the quantum conditional mutual information of a tripartite quantum state recently proved by Fawzi and Renner, connecting it with the ability to reconstruct the state from its bipartite reductions. Namely we show that the conditional mutual information is an upper bound on the regularised relative entropy distance between the quantum state and its reconstructed version. It is also an upper bound for the measured relative entropy distance of the state to its reconstructed version. The main ingredient of the proof is the fact that the conditional mutual information is the optimal quantum communication rate in the task of state redistribution. △ Less

Submitted 2 June, 2016; v1 submitted 18 November, 2014; originally announced November 2014.

Comments: 6 pages, 1 figure. v3 minor fixes and some added explanation. v4. minor fixes. Published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 050501 (2015)

An upper bound on the second order asymptotic expansion for the quantum communication cost of state redistribution

Authors: Nilanjana Datta, Min-Hsiu Hsieh, Jonathan Oppenheim

Abstract: State redistribution is the protocol in which, given an arbitrary tripartite quantum state, with two of the subsystems initially being with Alice and one being with Bob, the goal is for Alice to send one of her subsystems to Bob, possibly with the help of prior shared entanglement. We derive an upper bound on the second order asymptotic expansion for the quantum communication cost of achieving sta… ▽ More State redistribution is the protocol in which, given an arbitrary tripartite quantum state, with two of the subsystems initially being with Alice and one being with Bob, the goal is for Alice to send one of her subsystems to Bob, possibly with the help of prior shared entanglement. We derive an upper bound on the second order asymptotic expansion for the quantum communication cost of achieving state redistribution with a given finite accuracy. In proving our result, we also obtain an upper bound on the quantum communication cost of this protocol in the one-shot setting, by using the protocol of coherent state merging as a primitive. △ Less

Submitted 15 September, 2014; originally announced September 2014.

Comments: 11 pages, 1 figure

Journal ref: Journal of Mathematical Physics 57, 052203 (2016)

Communication tasks with infinite quantum-classical separation

Authors: Christopher Perry, Rahul Jain, Jonathan Oppenheim

Abstract: Quantum resources can be more powerful than classical resources - a quantum computer can solve certain problems exponentially faster than a classical computer, and computing a function of two people's inputs can be done with exponentially less communication with quantum messages than with classical ones. Here we consider a task between two players, Alice and Bob where quantum resources are infinit… ▽ More Quantum resources can be more powerful than classical resources - a quantum computer can solve certain problems exponentially faster than a classical computer, and computing a function of two people's inputs can be done with exponentially less communication with quantum messages than with classical ones. Here we consider a task between two players, Alice and Bob where quantum resources are infinitely more powerful than classical ones. Alice is given a string of length n, and Bob's task is to exclude certain combinations of bits that Alice might have. If Alice must send classical messages, then she must reveal nearly n bits of information to Bob, but if she is allowed to send quantum bits, the amount of information she must reveal goes to zero with increasing n. Next, we consider a version of the task where the parties can only send classical messages but may have access to entanglement. When assisted by entanglement, Alice only needs to send a constant number of bits, while without entanglement, the number of bits Alice must send grows linearly with n. The task is related to the PBR theorem which arises in the context of the foundations of quantum theory. △ Less

Submitted 2 October, 2015; v1 submitted 30 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Comments: V4: Added affiliation V3: Slight changes to match journal version. V2: Slight modification in entanglement assisted setting - Alice must now abort rather than Bob. Improved proofs in appendices

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 030504 (2015)

Gibbs-Preserving Maps outperform Thermal Operations in the quantum regime

Authors: Philippe Faist, Jonathan Oppenheim, Renato Renner

Abstract: In this brief note, we compare two frameworks for characterizing possible operations in quantum thermodynamics. One framework considers Thermal Operations---unitaries which conserve energy. The other framework considers all maps which preserve the Gibbs state at a given temperature. Thermal Operations preserve the Gibbs state; hence a natural question which arises is whether the two frameworks are… ▽ More In this brief note, we compare two frameworks for characterizing possible operations in quantum thermodynamics. One framework considers Thermal Operations---unitaries which conserve energy. The other framework considers all maps which preserve the Gibbs state at a given temperature. Thermal Operations preserve the Gibbs state; hence a natural question which arises is whether the two frameworks are equivalent. Classically, this is true---Gibbs-Preserving Maps are no more powerful than Thermal Operations. Here, we show that this no longer holds in the quantum regime: a Gibbs-Preserving Map can generate coherent superpositions of energy levels while Thermal Operations cannot. This gap has an impact on clarifying a mathematical framework for quantum thermodynamics. △ Less

Submitted 10 April, 2015; v1 submitted 13 June, 2014; originally announced June 2014.

Comments: 4 pages, 1 figure

Journal ref: New J. Phys. 17 043003 (2015)

Towards fully quantum second laws of thermodynamics: limitations on the evolution of quantum coherences

Authors: Piotr Ćwikliński, Michał Studziński, Michał Horodecki, Jonathan Oppenheim

Abstract: The second law of thermodynamics places a limitation into which states a system can evolve into. For systems in contact with a heat bath, it can be combined with the law of energy conservation, and it says that a system can only evolve into another if the free energy goes down. Recently, it's been shown that there are actually many second laws, and that it is only for large macroscopic systems tha… ▽ More The second law of thermodynamics places a limitation into which states a system can evolve into. For systems in contact with a heat bath, it can be combined with the law of energy conservation, and it says that a system can only evolve into another if the free energy goes down. Recently, it's been shown that there are actually many second laws, and that it is only for large macroscopic systems that they all become equivalent to the ordinary one. These additional second laws also hold for quantum systems, and are, in fact, often more relevant in this regime. They place a restriction on how the probabilities of energy levels can evolve. Here, we consider additional restrictions on how the coherences between energy levels can evolve. Coherences can only go down, and we provide a set of restrictions which limit the extent to which they can be maintained. We find that coherences over energy levels must decay at rates that are suitably adapted to the transition rates between energy levels. We show that the limitations are matched in the case of a single qubit, in which case we obtain the full characterization of state-to-state transformations. For higher dimensions, we conjecture that more severe constraints exist. We also introduce a new class of thermodynamical operations which allow for greater manipulation of coherences and study its power with respect to a class of operations known as thermal operations. △ Less

Submitted 19 November, 2015; v1 submitted 20 May, 2014; originally announced May 2014.

Comments: New title, new results, greatly rewritten version, closed to the published version

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 210403 (2015)

Firewalls and flat mirrors: An alternative to the AMPS experiment which evades the Harlow-Hayden obstacle

Authors: Jonathan Oppenheim, William G. Unruh

Abstract: If quantum gravity does not lead to a breakdown of predictability, then Almheiri, Marolf, Polchinski and Sully (AMPS) have argued that an observer falling into a black hole can perform an experiment which verifies a violation of entanglement monogamy - that late time Hawking radiation is maximally entangled with early time Hawking radiation and also with infalling radiation - something impossible… ▽ More If quantum gravity does not lead to a breakdown of predictability, then Almheiri, Marolf, Polchinski and Sully (AMPS) have argued that an observer falling into a black hole can perform an experiment which verifies a violation of entanglement monogamy - that late time Hawking radiation is maximally entangled with early time Hawking radiation and also with infalling radiation - something impossible in quantum field theory. However, as pointed out by Hayden and Harlow, this experiment is infeasible, as the time required to perform the experiment is almost certainly longer than the lifetime of the black hole. Here we propose an alternative firewall experiment which could actually be performed within the black hole's lifetime. The alternative experiment involves forming an entangled black hole in which the unscrambling of information is precomputed on a quantum memory prior to the creation of the black hole and without acting on the matter which forms the black hole or emerges from it. This would allow an observer near a black hole to signal faster than light. As another application of our precomputing strategy, we show how one can produce entangled black holes which acts like ``flat mirrors'', in the sense that information comes out almost instantly (as in the Hayden-Preskill scenario), but also emerge unscrambled, so that it can actually be observed instantly as well. Finally, we prove that a black hole in thermal equilibrium with its own radiation, is uncorrelated with this radiation. △ Less

Submitted 7 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

Conclusive Exclusion of Quantum States

Authors: Somshubhro Bandyopadhyay, Rahul Jain, Jonathan Oppenheim, Christopher Perry

Abstract: In the task of quantum state exclusion we consider a quantum system, prepared in a state chosen from a known set. The aim is to perform a measurement on the system which can conclusively rule that a subset of the possible preparation procedures can not have taken place. We ask what conditions the set of states must obey in order for this to be possible and how well we can complete the task when it… ▽ More In the task of quantum state exclusion we consider a quantum system, prepared in a state chosen from a known set. The aim is to perform a measurement on the system which can conclusively rule that a subset of the possible preparation procedures can not have taken place. We ask what conditions the set of states must obey in order for this to be possible and how well we can complete the task when it is not. The task of quantum state discrimination forms a subclass of this set of problems. Within this paper we formulate the general problem as a Semidefinite Program (SDP), enabling us to derive sufficient and necessary conditions for a measurement to be optimal. Furthermore, we obtain a necessary condition on the set of states for exclusion to be achievable with certainty and give a construction for a lower bound on the probability of error. This task of conclusively excluding states has gained importance in the context of the foundations of quantum mechanics due to a result of Pusey, Barrett and Rudolph (PBR). Motivated by this, we use our SDP to derive a bound on how well a class of hidden variable models can perform at a particular task, proving an analogue of Tsirelson's bound for the PBR experiment and the optimality of a measurement given by PBR in the process. We also introduce variations of conclusive exclusion, including unambiguous state exclusion, and state exclusion with worst case error. △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2014; v1 submitted 19 June, 2013; originally announced June 2013.

Comments: 8+11 pages. Version 2 includes a new result in Section V providing a lower bound on the probability of error in an exclusion task. Additional references and clarifications based on referee comments have also been incorporated. Version 3 acknowledges funding sources

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 89, 022336 (2014)

The second laws of quantum thermodynamics

Authors: Fernando G. S. L. Brandao, Michał Horodecki, Nelly Huei Ying Ng, Jonathan Oppenheim, Stephanie Wehner

Abstract: The second law of thermodynamics tells us which state transformations are so statistically unlikely that they are effectively forbidden. Its original formulation, due to Clausius, states that "Heat can never pass from a colder to a warmer body without some other change, connected therewith, occurring at the same time". The second law applies to systems composed of many particles interacting; howev… ▽ More The second law of thermodynamics tells us which state transformations are so statistically unlikely that they are effectively forbidden. Its original formulation, due to Clausius, states that "Heat can never pass from a colder to a warmer body without some other change, connected therewith, occurring at the same time". The second law applies to systems composed of many particles interacting; however, we are seeing that one can make sense of thermodynamics in the regime where we only have a small number of particles interacting with a heat bath. Is there a second law of thermodynamics in this regime? Here, we find that for processes which are cyclic or very close to cyclic, the second law for microscopic systems takes on a very different form than it does at the macroscopic scale, imposing not just one constraint on what state transformations are possible, but an entire family of constraints. In particular, we find a family of free energies which generalise the traditional one, and show that they can never increase. We further find that there are three regimes which determine which family of second laws govern state transitions, depending on how cyclic the process is. In one regime one can cause an apparent violation of the usual second law, through a process of embezzling work from a large system which remains arbitrarily close to its original state. These second laws are not only relevant for small systems, but also apply to individual macroscopic systems interacting via long-range interactions, which only satisfy the ordinary second law on average. By making precise the definition of thermal operations, the laws of thermodynamics take on a simple form with the first law defining the class of thermal operations, the zeroeth law emerging as a unique condition ensuring the theory is nontrivial, and the remaining laws being a monotonicity property of our generalised free energies. △ Less

Submitted 25 September, 2014; v1 submitted 22 May, 2013; originally announced May 2013.

Comments: v3: 39 pages, 2 figures. Substantial expansion of the previous text, conditions in terms of generalised alpha free energies, addition on discussion about the role of zeroeth and first laws of thermodynamics, addition of two new figures

Journal ref: PNAS 112, 3275 (2015)

Minimal Bounds on Nonlinearity in Auditory Processing

Authors: Jacob N. Oppenheim, Pavel Isakov, Marcelo O. Magnasco

Abstract: Time-reversal symmetry breaking is a key feature of nearly all natural sounds, caused by the physics of sound production. While attention has been paid to the response of the auditory system to "natural stimuli," very few psychophysical tests have been performed. We conduct psychophysical measurements of time-frequency acuity for both "natural" notes (sharp attack, long decay) and time-reversed on… ▽ More Time-reversal symmetry breaking is a key feature of nearly all natural sounds, caused by the physics of sound production. While attention has been paid to the response of the auditory system to "natural stimuli," very few psychophysical tests have been performed. We conduct psychophysical measurements of time-frequency acuity for both "natural" notes (sharp attack, long decay) and time-reversed ones. Our results demonstrate significantly greater precision, arising from enhanced temporal acuity, for such "natural" sounds over both their time-reversed versions and theoretically optimal gaussian pulses, without a corresponding decrease in frequency acuity. These data rule out models of auditory processing that obey a modified "uncertainty principle" between temporal and frequency acuity and suggest the existence of statistical priors for naturalistic stimuli, in the form of sharp-attack, long-decay notes. We are additionally able to calculate a minimal theoretical bound on the order of the nonlinearity present in auditory processing. We find that only matching pursuit, spectral derivatives, and reassigned spectrograms are able to satisfy this criterion. △ Less

Submitted 3 January, 2013; originally announced January 2013.

Comments: 9 pages, 3 figures

The Minimal Work Cost of Information Processing

Authors: Philippe Faist, Frédéric Dupuis, Jonathan Oppenheim, Renato Renner

Abstract: Irreversible information processing cannot be carried out without some inevitable thermodynamical work cost. This fundamental restriction, known as Landauer's principle, is increasingly relevant today, as the energy dissipation of computing devices impedes the development of their performance. Here we determine the minimal work required to carry out any logical process, for instance a computation.… ▽ More Irreversible information processing cannot be carried out without some inevitable thermodynamical work cost. This fundamental restriction, known as Landauer's principle, is increasingly relevant today, as the energy dissipation of computing devices impedes the development of their performance. Here we determine the minimal work required to carry out any logical process, for instance a computation. It is given by the entropy of the discarded information conditional to the output of the computation. Our formula takes precisely into account the statistically fluctuating work requirement of the logical process. It enables the explicit calculation of practical scenarios, such as computational circuits or quantum measurements. On the conceptual level, our result gives a precise and operationally justified connection between thermodynamic and information entropy, and explains the emergence of the entropy state function in macroscopic thermodynamics. △ Less

Submitted 7 July, 2015; v1 submitted 5 November, 2012; originally announced November 2012.

Comments: Journal version; 6+3+25 pages, 4+3 figures; previously "A Quantitative Landauer's Principle"

Journal ref: Nat. Commun. 6:7669 (2015)

Generalized teleportation and entanglement recycling

Authors: Sergii Strelchuk, Michał Horodecki, Jonathan Oppenheim

Abstract: We introduce new teleportation protocols which are generalizations of the original teleportation protocols that use the Pauli group [Bennett, et al. Physical Review Letters, 70(13) 1895-1899] and the port-based teleportation protocols, introduced by Hiroshima and Ishizaka [Physical Review Letters, 101(24) 240501], that use the symmetric permutation group. We derive sufficient condition for a set o… ▽ More We introduce new teleportation protocols which are generalizations of the original teleportation protocols that use the Pauli group [Bennett, et al. Physical Review Letters, 70(13) 1895-1899] and the port-based teleportation protocols, introduced by Hiroshima and Ishizaka [Physical Review Letters, 101(24) 240501], that use the symmetric permutation group. We derive sufficient condition for a set of operations, which in general need not form a group, to give rise to a teleportation protocol and provide examples of such schemes. This generalization leads to protocols with novel properties and is needed to push forward new schemes of computation based on them. Port-based teleportation protocols and our generalizations use a large resource state consisting of N singlets to teleport only a single qubit state reliably. We provide two distinct protocols which recycle the resource state to teleport multiple states with error linearly increasing with their number. The first protocol consists of sequentially teleporting qubit states, and the second teleports them in a bulk. △ Less

Submitted 13 December, 2012; v1 submitted 12 September, 2012; originally announced September 2012.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 069902 (2013)

(Quantumness in the context of) Resource Theories

Authors: Michał Horodecki, Jonathan Oppenheim

Abstract: We review the basic idea behind resource theories, where we quantify quantum resources by specifying a restricted class of operations. This divides the state space into various sets, including states which are free (because they can be created under the class of operations), and those which are a resource (because they cannot be). One can quantify the worth of the resource by the relative entropy… ▽ More We review the basic idea behind resource theories, where we quantify quantum resources by specifying a restricted class of operations. This divides the state space into various sets, including states which are free (because they can be created under the class of operations), and those which are a resource (because they cannot be). One can quantify the worth of the resource by the relative entropy distance to the set of free states, and under certain conditions, this is a unique measure which quantifies the rate of state to state transitions. The framework includes entanglement, asymmetry and purity theory. It also includes thermodynamics, which is a hybrid resource theory combining purity theory and asymmetry. Another hybrid resource theory which merges purity theory and entanglement can be used to study quantumness of correlations and discord, and we present quantumness in this more general framework of resource theories. △ Less

Submitted 10 September, 2012; originally announced September 2012.

Comments: review article

Journal ref: Int. J. Mod. Phys. B 27, 1345019 (2013)

Human Time-Frequency Acuity Beats the Fourier Uncertainty Principle

Authors: Jacob N. Oppenheim, Marcelo O. Magnasco

Abstract: The time-frequency uncertainty principle states that the product of the temporal and frequency extents of a signal cannot be smaller than $1/(4π)$. We study human ability to simultaneously judge the frequency and the timing of a sound. Our subjects often exceeded the uncertainty limit, sometimes by more than tenfold, mostly through remarkable timing acuity. Our results establish a lower bound for… ▽ More The time-frequency uncertainty principle states that the product of the temporal and frequency extents of a signal cannot be smaller than $1/(4π)$. We study human ability to simultaneously judge the frequency and the timing of a sound. Our subjects often exceeded the uncertainty limit, sometimes by more than tenfold, mostly through remarkable timing acuity. Our results establish a lower bound for the nonlinearity and complexity of the algorithms employed by our brains in parsing transient sounds, rule out simple "linear filter" models of early auditory processing, and highlight timing acuity as a central feature in auditory object processing. △ Less

Submitted 3 January, 2013; v1 submitted 22 August, 2012; originally announced August 2012.

Comments: 4 pages, 2 figures; Accepted at PRL

Hybrid Zero-capacity Channels

Authors: Sergii Strelchuk, Jonathan Oppenheim

Abstract: There are only two known kinds of zero-capacity channels. The first kind produces entangled states that have positive partial transpose, and the second one - states that are cloneable. We consider the family of 'hybrid' quantum channels, which lies in the intersection of the above classes of channels and investigate its properties. It gives rise to the first explicit examples of the channels, whic… ▽ More There are only two known kinds of zero-capacity channels. The first kind produces entangled states that have positive partial transpose, and the second one - states that are cloneable. We consider the family of 'hybrid' quantum channels, which lies in the intersection of the above classes of channels and investigate its properties. It gives rise to the first explicit examples of the channels, which create bound entangled states that have the property of being cloneable to the arbitrary finite number of parties. Hybrid channels provide the first example of highly cloneable binding entanglement channels, for which known superactivation protocols must fail - superactivation is the effect where two channels each with zero quantum capacity having positive capacity when used together. We give two methods to construct a hybrid channel from any binding entanglement channel. We also find the low-dimensional counterparts of hybrid states - bipartite qubit states which are extendible and possess two-way key. △ Less

Submitted 4 July, 2012; originally announced July 2012.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. A 86, 022328 (2012)

The black hole information problem beyond quantum theory

Authors: Markus P. Mueller, Jonathan Oppenheim, Oscar C. O. Dahlsten

Abstract: The origin of black hole entropy and the black hole information problem provide important clues for trying to piece together a quantum theory of gravity. Thus far, discussions on this topic have mostly assumed that in a consistent theory of gravity and quantum mechanics, quantum theory will be unmodified. Here, we examine the black hole information problem in the context of generalisations of quan… ▽ More The origin of black hole entropy and the black hole information problem provide important clues for trying to piece together a quantum theory of gravity. Thus far, discussions on this topic have mostly assumed that in a consistent theory of gravity and quantum mechanics, quantum theory will be unmodified. Here, we examine the black hole information problem in the context of generalisations of quantum theory. In particular, we examine black holes in the setting of generalised probabilistic theories, in which quantum theory and classical probability theory are special cases. We compute the time it takes information to escape a black hole, assuming that information is preserved. We find that under some very general assumptions, the arguments of Page (that information should escape the black hole after half the Hawking photons have been emitted), and the black-hole mirror result of Hayden and Preskill (that information can escape quickly) need to be modified. The modification is determined entirely by what we call the Wootters-Hardy parameter associated with a theory. We find that although the information leaves the black hole after enough photons have been emitted, it is fairly generic that it fails to appear outside the black hole at this point -- something impossible in quantum theory due to the no-hiding theorem. The information is neither inside the black hole, nor outside it, but is delocalised. Our central technical result is an information decoupling theorem which holds in the generalised probabilistic framework. △ Less

Submitted 1 October, 2012; v1 submitted 21 June, 2012; originally announced June 2012.

Comments: 12 pages + appendix, 5 figures. Comments welcome. v2: typos corrected, published version

Journal ref: Journal of High Energy Physics, Volume 2012, Issue 9, 116 (2012)

A Topological Phase Transition in the Scheidegger Model of River Networks

Authors: Jacob N. Oppenheim, Marcelo O. Magnasco

Abstract: We investigate the canonical Scheidegger Model of river network morphology for the case of convergent and divergent underlying topography, by embedding it on a cone. We find two distinct phases corresponding to few, long basins and many, short basins, respectively, separated by a singularity in number of basins, indicating a phase transition. Quantifying basin shape through Hack's Law $l\sim a^h$… ▽ More We investigate the canonical Scheidegger Model of river network morphology for the case of convergent and divergent underlying topography, by embedding it on a cone. We find two distinct phases corresponding to few, long basins and many, short basins, respectively, separated by a singularity in number of basins, indicating a phase transition. Quantifying basin shape through Hack's Law $l\sim a^h$ gives distinct values for the exponent $h$, providing a method of testing our hypotheses. The generality of our model suggests implications for vascular morphology, in particular differing number and shapes of arterial and venous trees. △ Less

Submitted 22 August, 2012; v1 submitted 22 May, 2012; originally announced May 2012.

Comments: 6 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Physical Review E, August 2012

The Resource Theory of Quantum States Out of Thermal Equilibrium

Authors: Fernando G. S. L. Brandão, Michał Horodecki, Jonathan Oppenheim, Joseph M. Renes, Robert W. Spekkens

Abstract: The ideas of thermodynamics have proved fruitful in the setting of quantum information theory, in particular the notion that when the allowed transformations of a system are restricted, certain states of the system become useful resources with which one can prepare previously inaccessible states. The theory of entanglement is perhaps the best-known and most well-understood resource theory in this… ▽ More The ideas of thermodynamics have proved fruitful in the setting of quantum information theory, in particular the notion that when the allowed transformations of a system are restricted, certain states of the system become useful resources with which one can prepare previously inaccessible states. The theory of entanglement is perhaps the best-known and most well-understood resource theory in this sense. Here we return to the basic questions of thermodynamics using the formalism of resource theories developed in quantum information theory and show that the free energy of thermodynamics emerges naturally from the resource theory of energy-preserving transformations. Specifically, the free energy quantifies the amount of useful work which can be extracted from asymptotically-many copies of a quantum system when using only reversible energy-preserving transformations and a thermal bath at fixed temperature. The free energy also quantifies the rate at which resource states can be reversibly interconverted asymptotically, provided that a sublinear amount of coherent superposition over energy levels is available, a situation analogous to the sublinear amount of classical communication required for entanglement dilution. △ Less

Submitted 6 October, 2013; v1 submitted 16 November, 2011; originally announced November 2011.

Comments: 4.5 pages main text, 12 pages appendix; v3: improvements to presentation of the main result

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 250404 (2013)

Fundamental limitations for quantum and nano thermodynamics

Authors: Michał Horodecki, Jonathan Oppenheim

Abstract: The relationship between thermodynamics and statistical physics is valid in the thermodynamic limit - when the number of particles becomes very large. Here, we study thermodynamics in the opposite regime - at both the nano scale, and when quantum effects become important. Applying results from quantum information theory we construct a theory of thermodynamics in these limits. We derive general cri… ▽ More The relationship between thermodynamics and statistical physics is valid in the thermodynamic limit - when the number of particles becomes very large. Here, we study thermodynamics in the opposite regime - at both the nano scale, and when quantum effects become important. Applying results from quantum information theory we construct a theory of thermodynamics in these limits. We derive general criteria for thermodynamical state transformations, and as special cases, find two free energies: one that quantifies the deterministically extractable work from a small system in contact with a heat bath, and the other that quantifies the reverse process. We find that there are fundamental limitations on work extraction from nonequilibrium states, owing to finite size effects and quantum coherences. This implies that thermodynamical transitions are generically irreversible at this scale. As one application of these methods, we analyse the efficiency of small heat engines and find that they are irreversible during the adiabatic stages of the cycle. △ Less

Submitted 25 October, 2014; v1 submitted 16 November, 2011; originally announced November 2011.

Comments: Final, published version

Journal ref: Nature Communications 4, 2059 (2013)