-
Generalized Entropy Implies Varying-G: Horizon Area Dependent Field Equations and Black Hole-Cosmology Coupling
Authors:
Hengxin Lu,
Sofia Di Gennaro,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
When the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy is modified, ambiguity often arises concerning whether the Hawking temperature or the thermodynamic mass should be modified. The common practice, however, is to keep the black hole solution the same as that in general relativity. On the other hand, if Jacobson's method of deriving Einstein equations from thermodynamic is valid in the general settings, then given…
▽ More
When the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy is modified, ambiguity often arises concerning whether the Hawking temperature or the thermodynamic mass should be modified. The common practice, however, is to keep the black hole solution the same as that in general relativity. On the other hand, if Jacobson's method of deriving Einstein equations from thermodynamic is valid in the general settings, then given a generalized entropy one should first derive the corresponding modified gravity, and then look for the compatible black hole solution before investigating its thermodynamics. We comment on some properties and subtleties in this approach. In particular, we point out that generically generalized entropy would lead to a varying effective gravitational "constant" theory, where $G_\text{eff}$ depends on the horizon area. We discuss in what ways such theories are discernible from general relativity despite its seemingly jarring differences, and how to make sense of area-dependent field equations. As a consequence we show that in the Jacobson's approach, the standard quantum gravitational logarithmic correction to Bekenstein-Hawking entropy is equivalent to a running gravitational "constant". A horizon area dependent $G_\text{eff}$ could also lead to a coupling between black hole masses and cosmological expansion, a scenario that has been studied recently in the literature, but so far lacks strong theoretical motivation. In the Tsallis case, we show that the thermodynamic mass for a Schwarzschild black hole is just a constant multiple of its ADM mass, which is considerably simpler than the approach not utilizing the Jacobson's method.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Testing Cotton gravity as dark matter substitute with weak lensing
Authors:
Geyu Mo,
Qingqing Wang,
Xin Ren,
Weitong Yan,
Yen Chin Ong,
Wentao Luo
Abstract:
Harada proposed a modified theory of gravity called Cotton gravity, and argued that it successfully explains the rotation curves of $84$ galaxies without the need of dark matter. In this work we use galaxy-galaxy lensing technique to test whether the modification effect of Cotton gravity can indeed be a viable substitute for dark matter. Using the spherically symmetric solution of Cotton gravity,…
▽ More
Harada proposed a modified theory of gravity called Cotton gravity, and argued that it successfully explains the rotation curves of $84$ galaxies without the need of dark matter. In this work we use galaxy-galaxy lensing technique to test whether the modification effect of Cotton gravity can indeed be a viable substitute for dark matter. Using the spherically symmetric solution of Cotton gravity, we obtain the deflection angle via Gauss-Bonnet theorem and the weak lensing shear. We use five galaxy catalogs divided in 5 stellar mass bins from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 7 (SDSS DR7), each of which is further divided into blue star forming galaxy and red passive galaxy sub-catalogs. We find that Cotton gravity on its own has significant deviation from the measured galaxy-galaxy lensing signals, thus it cannot replace the role of dark matter. If we consider the combination of dark matter and Cotton gravity, the modification is tightly constrained. Our analysis also applies to other modified gravity theories whose an additional linear term appears in the Schwarzschild solution.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Constrain the linear scalar perturbation theory of Cotton gravity
Authors:
Pengbo Xia,
Dongdong Zhang,
Xin Ren,
Bo Wang,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
We perform a cosmological test of Cotton gravity, which describes gravity by cotton tensor. The model we consider allows for the same background evolution as the $Λ$CDM model. We derive the cosmological perturbation theory of the scalar mode at the linear level, where the difference from the $Λ$CDM model is characterized by the parameter $β$. We incorporate Cotton gravity with a neutrino model and…
▽ More
We perform a cosmological test of Cotton gravity, which describes gravity by cotton tensor. The model we consider allows for the same background evolution as the $Λ$CDM model. We derive the cosmological perturbation theory of the scalar mode at the linear level, where the difference from the $Λ$CDM model is characterized by the parameter $β$. We incorporate Cotton gravity with a neutrino model and perform a Monte Carlo Markov Chain (MCMC) analysis using data from the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS). The analysis constrains parameter $β=-0.00008^{+0.00080}_{-0.00104}$ at the 1-$σ$ confidence level. We conclude that currently, there is no obvious deviation between Cotton gravity and the $Λ$CDM model in the linear cosmological perturbation level for observations.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Classical Acceleration Temperature (CAT) in a Box
Authors:
Ahsan Mujtaba,
Maksat Temirkhan,
Yen Chin Ong,
Michael R. R. Good
Abstract:
A confined, slow-moving, accelerating electron is shown to emit thermal radiation. Since laboratories face spatial constraints when dealing with rectilinear motion, focusing on a finite total travel distance combines the benefits of simple theoretical analysis with prospects for table-top experimentation. We demonstrate an accelerated moving charge along an asymptotically static worldline with fix…
▽ More
A confined, slow-moving, accelerating electron is shown to emit thermal radiation. Since laboratories face spatial constraints when dealing with rectilinear motion, focusing on a finite total travel distance combines the benefits of simple theoretical analysis with prospects for table-top experimentation. We demonstrate an accelerated moving charge along an asymptotically static worldline with fixed transit distance and slow maximum speed, emitting self-consistent analytic power, spectra, and energy. The classical radiation is Planck distributed with an associated acceleration temperature. This is the first fully parametrized, spectrum-solved, finite-distance worldline.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Upper Bound of Barrow Entropy Index from Black Hole Fragmentation
Authors:
Jiayi Xia,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
Both classical and quantum arguments suggest that if Barrow entropy is correct, its index $δ$ must be energy dependent, which would affect the very early universe. Based on thermodynamic stability that sufficiently large black holes should not fragment, we argue that Barrow entropy correction must be small except possibly at the Planckian regime. Furthermore, the fact that a solar mass black hole…
▽ More
Both classical and quantum arguments suggest that if Barrow entropy is correct, its index $δ$ must be energy dependent, which would affect the very early universe. Based on thermodynamic stability that sufficiently large black holes should not fragment, we argue that Barrow entropy correction must be small except possibly at the Planckian regime. Furthermore, the fact that a solar mass black hole does not fragment implies an upper bound $δ\lesssim O(10^{-3})$, which surprisingly lies in the same range as the bound obtained from some cosmological considerations assuming fixed $δ$. This indicates that allowing $δ$ to run does not raise its allowed value. We briefly comment on the case of Kaniadakis entropy.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
A Maximum Force Perspective on Black Hole Thermodynamics, Quantum Pressure, and Near-Extremality
Authors:
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
I re-examined the notion of the thermodynamic force constructed from the first law of black hole thermodynamics. In general relativity, the value of the charge (or angular momentum) at which the thermodynamic force equals the conjectured maximum force $F=1/4$ is found to correspond to $Q^2/M^2=8/9$ (respectively, $a^2/M^2=8/9$), which is known in the literature to exhibit some special properties.…
▽ More
I re-examined the notion of the thermodynamic force constructed from the first law of black hole thermodynamics. In general relativity, the value of the charge (or angular momentum) at which the thermodynamic force equals the conjectured maximum force $F=1/4$ is found to correspond to $Q^2/M^2=8/9$ (respectively, $a^2/M^2=8/9$), which is known in the literature to exhibit some special properties. This provides a possible characterization of near-extremality. In addition, taking the maximum force conjecture seriously amounts to introducing a pressure term in the first law of black hole thermodynamics. This resolves the factor of two problem between the proposed maximum value $F=1/4$ and the thermodynamic force of Schwarzschild spacetime $F=1/2$. Surprisingly it also provides another indication for the instability of the inner horizon. For a Schwarzschild black hole, under some reasonable assumptions, this pressure can be interpreted as being induced by the quantum fluctuation of the horizon position, effectively giving rise to a diffused "shell" of characteristic width $\sqrt{M}$. The maximum force can therefore, in some contexts, be associated with inherently quantum phenomena. Some implications are discussed as more questions are raised.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2023; v1 submitted 8 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
A Critique on Some Aspects of GUP Effective Metric
Authors:
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
The generalized uncertainty principle (GUP) is a gravitational correction of Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, which allows us to probe some features of quantum gravity even without the full theory. We are used to working with metric tensors in general relativity; they are convenient to have available when we wish to calculate physical quantities like Hawking temperature and black hole shadow. V…
▽ More
The generalized uncertainty principle (GUP) is a gravitational correction of Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, which allows us to probe some features of quantum gravity even without the full theory. We are used to working with metric tensors in general relativity; they are convenient to have available when we wish to calculate physical quantities like Hawking temperature and black hole shadow. Various authors have tried to incorporate GUP into an effective metric that allows such calculations. In this note, I point out that some of these results are not correct due to working with series truncation rather than the full GUP-corrected expressions. Perhaps more importantly, we rely too much on heuristic arguments and lack a guiding principle in constructing the correct effective metric.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Electron as a Tiny Mirror: Radiation From a Worldline With Asymptotic Inertia
Authors:
Michael R. R. Good,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
We present a moving mirror analog of the electron, whose worldline possesses asymptotic constant velocity with corresponding beta Bogolubov coefficients that are consistent with finite total emitted energy. Furthermore, the quantum analog model is in agreement with the total energy obtained by integrating the classical Larmor power.
We present a moving mirror analog of the electron, whose worldline possesses asymptotic constant velocity with corresponding beta Bogolubov coefficients that are consistent with finite total emitted energy. Furthermore, the quantum analog model is in agreement with the total energy obtained by integrating the classical Larmor power.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
An Effective Sign Switching Dark Energy: Lotka-Volterra Model of Two Interacting Fluids
Authors:
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
One of the recent attempts to address the Hubble and $S_8$ tensions is to consider the Universe started out not as a de Sitter-like spacetime, but rather anti-de Sitter-like. That is, the Universe underwent an "AdS-to-dS" transition at some point. We study the possibility that there are two dark energy fluids, one of which gave rise to the anti-de Sitter-like early Universe. The interaction is mod…
▽ More
One of the recent attempts to address the Hubble and $S_8$ tensions is to consider the Universe started out not as a de Sitter-like spacetime, but rather anti-de Sitter-like. That is, the Universe underwent an "AdS-to-dS" transition at some point. We study the possibility that there are two dark energy fluids, one of which gave rise to the anti-de Sitter-like early Universe. The interaction is modeled by the Lotka-Volterra equations, commonly used in population biology. We consider "competition" models that are further classified as "unfair competition" and "fair competition". The former involves a quintessence in competition with a phantom, and the second involves two phantom fluids. Surprisingly, even in the latter scenario it is possible for the overall dark energy to cross the phantom divide. The latter model also allows a constant $w$ "AdS-to-dS" transition, thus evading the theorem that such a dark energy must possess a singular equation of state. We also consider a "conversion" model in which a phantom fluid still manages to achieve "AdS-to-dS" transition even if it is being converted into a negative energy density quintessence. In these models, the energy density of the late time effective dark energy is related to the coefficient of the quadratic self-interaction term of the fluids, which is analogous to the resource capacity in population biology.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2023; v1 submitted 8 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
On Black Hole Thermodynamics, Singularity, and Gravitational Entropy
Authors:
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
Many fundamental issues remain for black hole thermodynamics after almost half a century of its conception. For example, what are the underlying degrees of freedom of a black hole horizon that give rise to said thermodynamical properties? Furthermore, classical black holes also harbor a spacetime singularity. Although it is often believed that quantum gravity would "cure" the singularity, as empha…
▽ More
Many fundamental issues remain for black hole thermodynamics after almost half a century of its conception. For example, what are the underlying degrees of freedom of a black hole horizon that give rise to said thermodynamical properties? Furthermore, classical black holes also harbor a spacetime singularity. Although it is often believed that quantum gravity would "cure" the singularity, as emphasized by Penrose, this viewpoint requires a deeper examination. In this review, I will examine the possibility that singularities remain in quantum gravity, the roles they may play, and the possible links between singularity and black hole thermodynamics. I will also discuss how -- inspired by Penrose's Weyl curvature hypothesis -- gravitational entropy for a black hole can be defined using curvature invariants, and the surprising implication that the entropy of black holes in different theories of gravity are different manifestations of spacetime curvature, i.e., their underlying microstructures could be different. Finally, I review the "Hookean law" recently established for singly rotating Myers-Perry black holes (including Kerr black holes) that connect black hole fragmentation -- a consequence of the second law of black hole thermodynamics -- with the maximum "Hookean force", as well as with the thermodynamic geometry of Ruppeiner. This also suggests a new way to study black hole microstructures, and hints at the possibility that some black holes are beyond the Hookean regime (and thus have different microstructures). While examining the remarkable connections between black hole thermodynamics, spacetime singularities and cosmic censorship, as well as gravitational entropy, I shall point out some subtleties, provide some new thoughts, and raise some hard but fundamental questions, including whether black hole thermodynamics is really just "ordinary thermodynamics" or something quite different.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Lotka-Volterra Models for Extraterrestrial Self-Replicating Probes
Authors:
Yifan Chen,
Jiayi Ni,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
A sufficiently advanced extraterrestrial civilization can send out a swarm of self-replicating probes for space exploration. Given the fast-growing number of such a probe, even if there is only one extraterrestrial civilization sending out such probes in the Milky Way galaxy, we should still expect to see them. The fact that we do not consists part of the Fermi paradox. The suggestion that self-re…
▽ More
A sufficiently advanced extraterrestrial civilization can send out a swarm of self-replicating probes for space exploration. Given the fast-growing number of such a probe, even if there is only one extraterrestrial civilization sending out such probes in the Milky Way galaxy, we should still expect to see them. The fact that we do not consists part of the Fermi paradox. The suggestion that self-replicating probes will eventually mutate to consume their progenitors and therefore significantly reduce the number of total probes has been investigated and dismissed in the literature. In this work, we re-visit this question with a more realistic Lotka-Volterra model, and show that mutated probes would drive the progenitor probes into "extinction", thereby replacing them to spread throughout the galaxy. Thus, the efficiency of mutated probes in reducing the total number of self-replicating probes is even less than previously thought. As part of the analysis, we also suggest that, somewhat counter-intuitively, in designing self-replicating probes, one should not program them to stop replicating when sufficient mutation causes the probes to fail to recognize the progenitor probes as "self".
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2022; v1 submitted 8 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Holographic Consistency and the Sign of the Gauss-Bonnet Parameter
Authors:
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
If Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet gravity is obtained as a low energy limit of string theory, then the Gauss-Bonnet parameter $α$ is essentially the inverse string tension and thus necessarily positive. If one treats Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet gravity as a modified theory of gravity in the anti-de Sitter bulk in the bottom-up approach of holography, then there is no obvious restriction on the sign of the parame…
▽ More
If Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet gravity is obtained as a low energy limit of string theory, then the Gauss-Bonnet parameter $α$ is essentially the inverse string tension and thus necessarily positive. If one treats Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet gravity as a modified theory of gravity in the anti-de Sitter bulk in the bottom-up approach of holography, then there is no obvious restriction on the sign of the parameter a priori, though various studies involving boundary causality have restricted the possible range of $α$. In this short note, we argue that if holographic descriptions are to be consistent, then the Gauss-Bonnet parameter has to be positive. This follows from a geometric consistency condition in the Euclidean picture. From the Lorentzian signature perspective, black holes with a negative $α$ lead to uncontrolled brane nucleation in the bulk and so the supposedly static geometry is untenable. In fact, even the ground state without a black hole is problematic. In other words, the bottom-up approach agrees with the top-down approach on the sign of the parameter. Some possible loopholes of the conclusion are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
How Barrow Entropy Modifies Gravity: With Comments on Tsallis Entropy
Authors:
Sofia Di Gennaro,
Hao Xu,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
Barrow proposed that the area law of the horizon entropy might receive a "fractal correction" $S\propto A^{1+Δ/2}$ due to quantum gravitational effects, with $0\leqslant Δ\leqslant 1$ measures the deviation from the standard area law. While such a modification has been widely studied in the literature, its corresponding theory of gravity has not been discussed. We follow Jacobson's approach to der…
▽ More
Barrow proposed that the area law of the horizon entropy might receive a "fractal correction" $S\propto A^{1+Δ/2}$ due to quantum gravitational effects, with $0\leqslant Δ\leqslant 1$ measures the deviation from the standard area law. While such a modification has been widely studied in the literature, its corresponding theory of gravity has not been discussed. We follow Jacobson's approach to derive the modified gravity theory (interpreted as an effective theory), and find that in the stationary case the resulting theory only differs from general relativity by a re-scaled cosmological constant. Consequently in asymptotically flat stationary spacetimes the theory is identical to general relativity. The theory is not applicable when there is no horizon; the multi-horizon case is complicated. We emphasize on the importance of identifying the correct thermodynamic mass in a theory with modified thermodynamics to avoid inconsistencies. We also comment on the Hawking evaporation rate beyond the effective theory. In addition, we show that the Bekenstein bound is satisfied if the thermodynamic mass is used as the energy, up to a constant prefactor. We briefly comment on the Tsallis entropy case as well. Interestingly, for the latter, the requirement that Bekenstein bound holds imposes a lower bound on the non-extensive parameter: $δ> 1/2$, which unfortunately rules out the previously suggested possibility that the expansion of the universe can accelerate with normal matter field alone.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2022; v1 submitted 19 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Decoherence and Landauer's Principle in Qubit-Cavity Quantum-Field-Theory Interaction
Authors:
Hao Xu,
Si Yu Chen,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
We consider quantum decoherence and Landauer's principle in qubit-cavity quantum field theory (QFT) interaction, treating the qubit as the system and cavity QFT as the environment. In particular, we investigate the changes that occur in the system with a pure initial state and environment during the decoherence process, with or without energy dissipation, and compare the results with the case in w…
▽ More
We consider quantum decoherence and Landauer's principle in qubit-cavity quantum field theory (QFT) interaction, treating the qubit as the system and cavity QFT as the environment. In particular, we investigate the changes that occur in the system with a pure initial state and environment during the decoherence process, with or without energy dissipation, and compare the results with the case in which the initial state of the system is a mixed state and thus decoherence is absent. When we choose an interaction Hamiltonian such that the energy and coherence of the system change simultaneously, the population change of the system and the energy change are the same when the initial state is mixed. However, the decoherence terms increase the von Neumann entropy of the system. In this case the energy change and decoherence of the system are not independent physical processes. The decoherence process maintains unitarity. On the other hand, if the interaction Hamiltonian does not change the energy of the system, there is only the decoherence effect. The environment will be a distribution in the basis of the displaced number state and always increases the energy. Landauer's principle is satisfied in both cases.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2023; v1 submitted 14 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Sign Switching Dark Energy from a Running Barrow Entropy
Authors:
Sofia Di Gennaro,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
Barrow proposed that the area law of the entropy associated with a horizon might receive a "fractal correction" due to quantum gravitational effects -- in place of $S\propto A$, we have instead $S\propto A^{1+δ/2}$, where $0\leqslant δ\leqslant 1$ measures the deviation from the standard area law ($δ=0$). Based on black hole thermodynamics, we argue that the Barrow entropy should run (i.e., energy…
▽ More
Barrow proposed that the area law of the entropy associated with a horizon might receive a "fractal correction" due to quantum gravitational effects -- in place of $S\propto A$, we have instead $S\propto A^{1+δ/2}$, where $0\leqslant δ\leqslant 1$ measures the deviation from the standard area law ($δ=0$). Based on black hole thermodynamics, we argue that the Barrow entropy should run (i.e., energy scale dependent), which is reasonable given that quantum gravitational corrections are expected to be important only in high energy regime. When applied to the Friedmann equation, we demonstrate the possibility that such a running Barrow entropy index could give rise to a dynamical effective dark energy, which is asymptotically positive and vanishing, but negative at the Big Bang. Such a sign switching dark energy could help to alleviate the Hubble tension. Other cosmological implications are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2022; v1 submitted 18 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
On the Chandrasekhar Limit in Generalized Uncertainty Principles
Authors:
Daniele Gregoris,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
The Chandrasekhar limit for white dwarfs has been confirmed by many astrophysical observations. However, how to obtain it theoretically in models which rely on other-than-Heisenberg's uncertainty principles, which are predicted by some quantum gravity theories, is not a trivial task. In this manuscript, we will derive the Chandrasekhar mass assuming an uncertainty relation proposed in the framewor…
▽ More
The Chandrasekhar limit for white dwarfs has been confirmed by many astrophysical observations. However, how to obtain it theoretically in models which rely on other-than-Heisenberg's uncertainty principles, which are predicted by some quantum gravity theories, is not a trivial task. In this manuscript, we will derive the Chandrasekhar mass assuming an uncertainty relation proposed in the framework of Doubly Special Relativity, exhibiting both a minimal length and a maximum momentum. We will show how to re-obtain an asymptotically vanishing radius for the star in the limiting subcase of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle: this is the same behavior as in the original Chandrasekhar's derivation, but not when the more popular Generalized Uncertainty Principle is assumed. We will argue that this is related to the difference in the classical limit of these two different generalized uncertainty principles, enlightening that the modified uncertainty parameter considered here behaves like a finite temperature. The role of a maximum momentum in guaranteeing the stability of the configuration, and in providing a finite pressure for the degenerate electrons' gas, is also analyzed.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2023; v1 submitted 28 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Understanding Gravitational Entropy of Black Holes: A New Proposal via Curvature Invariants
Authors:
Daniele Gregoris,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
Partly motivated by the arrow of time problem in cosmology and the Weyl curvature hypothesis formulated by Roger Penrose, previous works in the literature have proposed - among other possibilities - the square of the Weyl curvature, as being the underlying entropy density function of black hole entropy, but the proposal suffers from a few drawbacks. In this work, we propose a new entropy density f…
▽ More
Partly motivated by the arrow of time problem in cosmology and the Weyl curvature hypothesis formulated by Roger Penrose, previous works in the literature have proposed - among other possibilities - the square of the Weyl curvature, as being the underlying entropy density function of black hole entropy, but the proposal suffers from a few drawbacks. In this work, we propose a new entropy density function also based solely on the Weyl curvature, but adopting some other combinations of curvature invariants. As an improvement we find that our method works for all static black hole solutions in four and five dimensional general relativity regardless of whether they are empty space solutions or not. It should also be possible to generalize our method to higher dimensions. This allows us to discuss the physical interpretation of black hole entropy, which remains somewhat mysterious. Extending to modified theories of gravity, our work also suggests that gravitational entropy in some theories is a manifestation of different physical effects since we need to choose different combinations of curvature quantities
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2022; v1 submitted 24 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Landauer's principle in Qubit-Cavity quantum field theory Interaction in Vacuum and Thermal States
Authors:
Hao Xu,
Yen Chin Ong,
Man-Hong Yung
Abstract:
Landauer's principle has seen a boom of interest in the last few years due to the growing interest in quantum information sciences. However, its relevance and validity in the contexts of quantum field theory (QFT) remain surprisingly unexplored. In the present paper, we consider Landauer's principle in qubit-cavity QFT interaction perturbatively, in which the initial state of the cavity QFT is cho…
▽ More
Landauer's principle has seen a boom of interest in the last few years due to the growing interest in quantum information sciences. However, its relevance and validity in the contexts of quantum field theory (QFT) remain surprisingly unexplored. In the present paper, we consider Landauer's principle in qubit-cavity QFT interaction perturbatively, in which the initial state of the cavity QFT is chosen to be a vacuum or thermal state. In the vacuum case, the QFT always absorbs heat and jumps to excited states. For the qubit at rest, its entropy decreases, whereas if the qubit accelerates, it may also gain energy and it increases its entropy due to the Unruh effect. For the thermal state, the QFT can both absorb and release heat, depending on its temperature and the initial state of the qubit, and the higher-order perturbations can excite or deexcite the initial state to a higher or lower state. Landauer's principle is valid in all the cases we consider. We hope that this paper will pave the way for future explorations of Landauer's principle in QFT and gravity theories.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2022; v1 submitted 17 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
The Hookean Law of Black Holes and Fragmentation: Insights from Maximum Force Conjecture and Ruppeiner Geometry
Authors:
Sofia Di Gennaro,
Michael R. R. Good,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
We show that the notion of "Hookean law" $F=kx$, suitably defined in asymptotically flat singly spinning Myers-Perry black hole spacetimes in dimensions $d\geqslant 5$, is related to the Emparan-Myers fragmentation (splitting of a black hole into two becomes thermodynamically preferable). Specifically, the values of black hole parameters when fragmentation occurs correspond to the maximal value of…
▽ More
We show that the notion of "Hookean law" $F=kx$, suitably defined in asymptotically flat singly spinning Myers-Perry black hole spacetimes in dimensions $d\geqslant 5$, is related to the Emparan-Myers fragmentation (splitting of a black hole into two becomes thermodynamically preferable). Specifically, the values of black hole parameters when fragmentation occurs correspond to the maximal value of $F$. Furthermore this always happens before $F$ reaches $1/4$ in Planck units. These results suggest that a version of "maximum force conjecture" may be relevant for black hole thermodynamics. We also relate these findings to the Ruppeiner thermodynamic geometry of these black holes and speculate on the implications for the underlying microstructures of black hole horizons.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2022; v1 submitted 30 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Traversable Wormhole in Einstein 3-Form Theory With Self-Interacting Potential
Authors:
Mariam Bouhmadi-López,
Che-Yu Chen,
Xiao Yan Chew,
Yen Chin Ong,
Dong-han Yeom
Abstract:
We numerically construct a symmetric wormhole solution in pure Einstein gravity supported by a massive $3$-form field with a potential that contains a quartic self-interaction term. The wormhole spacetimes have only a single throat and they are everywhere regular and asymptotically flat. Furthermore, their mass and throat circumference increase almost linearly as the coefficient of the quartic sel…
▽ More
We numerically construct a symmetric wormhole solution in pure Einstein gravity supported by a massive $3$-form field with a potential that contains a quartic self-interaction term. The wormhole spacetimes have only a single throat and they are everywhere regular and asymptotically flat. Furthermore, their mass and throat circumference increase almost linearly as the coefficient of the quartic self-interaction term $Λ$ increases. The amount of violation of the null energy condition (NEC) is proportional to the magnitude of $3$-form, thus the NEC is less violated as $Λ$ increases, since the magnitude of $3$-form decreases with $Λ$. In addition, we investigate the geodesics of particles moving around the wormhole. The unstable photon orbit is located at the throat. We also find that the wormhole can cast a shadow whose apparent size is smaller than that cast by the Schwarzschild black hole, but reduces to it when $Λ$ acquires a large value. The behavior of the innermost stable circular orbit around this wormhole is also discussed. The results of this paper hint toward the possibility that the 3-form wormholes could be potential black hole mimickers, as long as $Λ$ is sufficiently large, precisely when NEC is weakly violated.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2021; v1 submitted 16 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
On the Counter-Rotation of Closed Timelike Curves
Authors:
Yuanyuan Duan,
Fangxun Liu,
Yu Wang,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
While it is tempting to think of closed timelike curves (CTCs) around rotating bodies such as a black hole as being "caused" by the rotation of the source, Andréka et al. pointed out that the underlying physics is not as straightforward since such CTCs are "counter-rotating", i.e., the time orientation (the opening of the local light cones) of the CTCs is opposite to the direction in which the sin…
▽ More
While it is tempting to think of closed timelike curves (CTCs) around rotating bodies such as a black hole as being "caused" by the rotation of the source, Andréka et al. pointed out that the underlying physics is not as straightforward since such CTCs are "counter-rotating", i.e., the time orientation (the opening of the local light cones) of the CTCs is opposite to the direction in which the singularity or the ergosphere rotates. It was also suggested that this is a generic phenomenon that calls for a deeper intuitive physical understanding. In this short note we point out -- with Kerr-Taub-NUT as an example -- that CTCs are counter-rotating with respect to the local angular velocity of the spacetime, which makes a physical interpretation of CTCs being "caused" by a rotating source even more problematic.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
How Anti-de Sitter Black Holes Reach Thermal Equilibrium
Authors:
Ru Ling,
Hao Xu,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
It is commonly known in the literature that large black holes in anti-de Sitter spacetimes (with reflective boundary condition) are in thermal equilibrium with their Hawking radiation. Focusing on black holes with event horizon of toroidal topology, we study a simple model to understand explicitly how this thermal equilibrium is reached under Hawking evaporation. It is shown that it is possible fo…
▽ More
It is commonly known in the literature that large black holes in anti-de Sitter spacetimes (with reflective boundary condition) are in thermal equilibrium with their Hawking radiation. Focusing on black holes with event horizon of toroidal topology, we study a simple model to understand explicitly how this thermal equilibrium is reached under Hawking evaporation. It is shown that it is possible for a large toroidal black hole to evolve into a small (but stable) one.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2022; v1 submitted 4 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
A Critical Assessment of Black Hole Solutions With a Linear Term in Their Redshift Function
Authors:
Daniele Gregoris,
Yen Chin Ong,
Bin Wang
Abstract:
Different theories of gravity can admit the same black hole solution, but the parameters usually have different physical interpretations. In this work we study in depth the linear term $βr$ in the redshift function of black holes, which arises in conformal gravity, de Rham-Gabadadze-Tolley (dRGT) massive gravity, $f(R)$ gravity (as approximate solution) and general relativity. Geometrically we qua…
▽ More
Different theories of gravity can admit the same black hole solution, but the parameters usually have different physical interpretations. In this work we study in depth the linear term $βr$ in the redshift function of black holes, which arises in conformal gravity, de Rham-Gabadadze-Tolley (dRGT) massive gravity, $f(R)$ gravity (as approximate solution) and general relativity. Geometrically we quantify the parameter $β$ in terms of the curvature invariants. Astrophysically we found that $β$ can be expressed in terms of the cosmological constant, the photon orbit radius and the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO) radius. The metric degeneracy can be broken once black hole thermodynamics is taken into account. Notably, we show that under Hawking evaporation, different physical theories with the same black hole solution (at the level of the metric) can lead to black hole remnants with different values of their physical masses with direct consequences on their viability as dark matter candidates. In particular, the mass of the graviton in massive gravity can be expressed in terms of the cosmological constant and of the formation epoch of the remnant. Furthermore the upper bound of remnant mass can be estimated to be around $0.5 \times 10^{27}$ kg.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2021; v1 submitted 9 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Feasibility of Primordial Black Hole Remnants as Dark Matter in View of Hawking Radiation Recoil
Authors:
Sofia Di Gennaro,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
It has recently been suggested that black hole remnants of primordial origin are not a viable dark matter candidate since they would have far too large a velocity due to the recoil of Hawking radiation. We re-examined this interesting claim in more details and found that it does not rule out such a possibility. On the contrary, for models based on non-commutativity of spacetime near the Planck sca…
▽ More
It has recently been suggested that black hole remnants of primordial origin are not a viable dark matter candidate since they would have far too large a velocity due to the recoil of Hawking radiation. We re-examined this interesting claim in more details and found that it does not rule out such a possibility. On the contrary, for models based on non-commutativity of spacetime near the Planck scale, essentially the same argument can be used to estimate the scale at which non-commutativity effect becomes important. If dark matter "particles" are non-commutative black holes that have passed the maximum temperature, this implies that the non-commutative scale is about 100 times the Planck length. The same analysis applies to other black hole remnants whose temperature reaches a maximum before cooling off, for example, black holes in asymptotically safe gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2021; v1 submitted 18 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
How Not to Extract Information From Black Holes: Cosmic Censorship as a Guiding Principle
Authors:
Sofia Di Gennaro,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
Black holes in general relativity are commonly believed to evolve towards a Schwarzschild state as they gradually lose angular momentum and electrical charge under Hawking evaporation. However, when Kim and Wen applied quantum information theory to Hawking evaporation and argued that Hawking particles with maximum mutual information could dominate the emission process, they found that charged blac…
▽ More
Black holes in general relativity are commonly believed to evolve towards a Schwarzschild state as they gradually lose angular momentum and electrical charge under Hawking evaporation. However, when Kim and Wen applied quantum information theory to Hawking evaporation and argued that Hawking particles with maximum mutual information could dominate the emission process, they found that charged black holes tend towards extremality. In view of some evidence pointing towards extremal black holes being effectively singular, this would violate the cosmic censorship conjecture. Nevertheless, since the Kim-Wen model is too simplistic (e.g. it assumes a continuous spectrum of particles with arbitrary charge-to-mass ratio), one might hope that a more realistic model could avoid this problem. In this work, we show that having only a finite species of charged particles would actually worsen the situation, with some end states becoming a naked singularity. With this model as an example, we emphasize the need to study whether charged black holes can violate cosmic censorship under a given model of Hawking evaporation.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2022; v1 submitted 9 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Null Hypersurface Caustics, Closed Null Curves, and Super-Entropy
Authors:
Sousuke Noda,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
Recently it was discovered that null hypersurfaces can develop caustics outside the event horizon of super-entropic Kerr-AdS black holes, in contrast to the usual Kerr-AdS case. In this work we explore a few more examples of black hole spacetimes in which such exterior caustics can develop. If a closed null curve is present, e.g., in the case of Taub-NUT and the "transunital" Kerr-AdS spacetimes,…
▽ More
Recently it was discovered that null hypersurfaces can develop caustics outside the event horizon of super-entropic Kerr-AdS black holes, in contrast to the usual Kerr-AdS case. In this work we explore a few more examples of black hole spacetimes in which such exterior caustics can develop. If a closed null curve is present, e.g., in the case of Taub-NUT and the "transunital" Kerr-AdS spacetimes, then it coincides with a null hypersurface caustic (NHC) of a minimal separation parameter. Thus a spacetime on the verge of forming closed timelike curves could develop a caustic. Known examples of super-entropic black holes also have exterior NHC, although such spacetimes are free of closed null/timelike curves. Nevertheless the relationship between closed causal curves, NHC, and super-entropy is not straightforward. This is best illustrated with the BTZ black string, which for some choices of the warp factor in the extra dimension and the value of the charge, can be super-entropic. However, even those that are not super-entropic can admit NHC outside the horizon.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2020; v1 submitted 28 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Hawking Evaporation of Black Holes in Massive Gravity
Authors:
Meng-Shi Hou,
Hao Xu,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
We study the Hawking evaporation of a class of black hole solutions in dRGT massive gravity, in which the graviton mass gives rise to an effective negative cosmological constant. We found that the effective emission surface can be either proportional to the square of the effective AdS length scale, or corresponds to the square of the impact parameter of the null geodesic that falls onto the photon…
▽ More
We study the Hawking evaporation of a class of black hole solutions in dRGT massive gravity, in which the graviton mass gives rise to an effective negative cosmological constant. We found that the effective emission surface can be either proportional to the square of the effective AdS length scale, or corresponds to the square of the impact parameter of the null geodesic that falls onto the photon orbit of the black hole. Furthermore, depending on the black hole parameters, the emission surface could switch from one to another as the black hole loses mass during the evaporation process. Furthermore, the black holes can either evaporate completely or become a remnant at late time. Our result is more generally applicable to any asymptotically anti-de Sitter-like black hole solution in any theory whose metric function has a term linear in the coordinate radius, with massive gravity being only a concrete example.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Event Horizon Wrinklification
Authors:
Brett McInnes,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
The possible existence of stable black holes with entropies larger than the corresponding Schwarzschild black hole has been discussed extensively. The recently proposed "rough" black holes provide a concrete example of this. The fear is that, in accordance with the Second Law of thermodynamics, the familiar smooth-skinned black holes might spontaneously "wrinklify" into such an object. We show tha…
▽ More
The possible existence of stable black holes with entropies larger than the corresponding Schwarzschild black hole has been discussed extensively. The recently proposed "rough" black holes provide a concrete example of this. The fear is that, in accordance with the Second Law of thermodynamics, the familiar smooth-skinned black holes might spontaneously "wrinklify" into such an object. We show that this fear is to some extent justified, in the sense that AdS black holes with more entropy than the AdS-Schwarzschild black hole of the same mass do exist.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Regular Black Hole Interior Spacetime Supported by Three-Form Field
Authors:
Mariam Bouhmadi-López,
Che-Yu Chen,
Xiao Yan Chew,
Yen Chin Ong,
Dong-han Yeom
Abstract:
In this paper, we show that a minimally coupled 3-form endowed with a proper potential can support a regular black hole interior. By choosing an appropriate form for the metric function representing the radius of the 2-sphere, we solve for the 3-form field and its potential. Using the obtained solution, we construct an interior black hole spacetime which is everywhere regular. The singularity is r…
▽ More
In this paper, we show that a minimally coupled 3-form endowed with a proper potential can support a regular black hole interior. By choosing an appropriate form for the metric function representing the radius of the 2-sphere, we solve for the 3-form field and its potential. Using the obtained solution, we construct an interior black hole spacetime which is everywhere regular. The singularity is replaced with a Nariai-type spacetime, whose topology is $\text{dS}_2 \times \text{S}^2$, in which the radius of the 2-sphere is constant. So long as the interior continues to expand indefinitely, the geometry becomes essentially compactified. The 2-dimensional de Sitter geometry appears despite the negative potential of the 3-form field. Such a dynamical compactification could shed some light on the origin of de Sitter geometry of our Universe, exacerbated by the Swampland conjecture. In addition, we show that the spacetime is geodesically complete. The geometry is singularity-free due to the violation of the null energy condition.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2021; v1 submitted 27 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Schwinger Pair Production and the Extended Uncertainty Principle: Can Heuristic Derivations Be Trusted?
Authors:
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
The rate of Schwinger pair production due to an external electric field can be derived heuristically from the uncertainty principle. In the presence of a cosmological constant, it has been argued in the literature that the uncertainty principle receives a correction due to the background curvature, which is known as the "extended uncertainty principle" (EUP). We show that EUP does indeed lead to t…
▽ More
The rate of Schwinger pair production due to an external electric field can be derived heuristically from the uncertainty principle. In the presence of a cosmological constant, it has been argued in the literature that the uncertainty principle receives a correction due to the background curvature, which is known as the "extended uncertainty principle" (EUP). We show that EUP does indeed lead to the correct result for Schwinger pair production rate in anti-de Sitter spacetime (the case for de Sitter spacetime is similar), provided that the EUP correction term is negative (positive for the de Sitter case). We compare the results with previous works in the EUP literature, which are not all consistent. Our result further highlights an important issue in the literature of generalizations of the uncertainty principle: how much can heuristic derivations be trusted?
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2020; v1 submitted 25 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Spacetime Singularities and Cosmic Censorship Conjecture: A Review with Some Thoughts
Authors:
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
The singularity theorems of Hawking and Penrose tell us that singularities are common place in general relativity. Singularities not only occur at the beginning of the Universe at the Big Bang, but also in complete gravitational collapses that result in the formation of black holes. If singularities - except the one at the Big Bang - ever become "naked", i.e., not shrouded by black hole horizons,…
▽ More
The singularity theorems of Hawking and Penrose tell us that singularities are common place in general relativity. Singularities not only occur at the beginning of the Universe at the Big Bang, but also in complete gravitational collapses that result in the formation of black holes. If singularities - except the one at the Big Bang - ever become "naked", i.e., not shrouded by black hole horizons, then it is expected that problems would arise and render general relativity indeterministic. For this reason, Penrose proposed the cosmic censorship conjecture, which states that singularities should never be naked. Various counterexamples to the conjecture have since been discovered, but it is still not clear under which kind of physical processes one can expect violation of the conjecture. In this short review, I briefly examine some progresses in spacetime singularities and cosmic censorship conjecture. In particular, I shall discuss why we should still care about the conjecture, and whether we should be worried about some of the counterexamples. This is not meant to be a comprehensive review, but rather to give an introduction to the subject, which has recently seen an increase of interest.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2020; v1 submitted 14 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Black Hole Evaporation in Hořava-Lifshitz Gravity
Authors:
Hao Xu,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
Hořava-Lifshitz (HL) gravity was formulated in hope of solving the non-renormalization problem in Einstein gravity and the ghost problem in higher derivative gravity theories by violating Lorentz invariance. In this work we consider the spherically symmetric neutral AdS black hole evaporation process in HL gravity in various spacetime dimensions $d$, and with detailed balance violation parameter…
▽ More
Hořava-Lifshitz (HL) gravity was formulated in hope of solving the non-renormalization problem in Einstein gravity and the ghost problem in higher derivative gravity theories by violating Lorentz invariance. In this work we consider the spherically symmetric neutral AdS black hole evaporation process in HL gravity in various spacetime dimensions $d$, and with detailed balance violation parameter $0\leqslant ε^2\leqslant 1$. We find that the lifetime of the black holes under Hawking evaporation is dimensional dependent, with $d=4,5$ behave differently from $d\geqslant 6$. For the case of $ε=0$, in $d=4,5$, the black hole admits zero temperature state, and the lifetime of the black hole is always infinite. This phenomenon obeys the third law of black hole thermodynamics, and implies that the black holes become an effective remnant towards the end of the evaporation. As $d\geqslant 6$, however, the lifetime of black hole does not diverge with any initial black hole mass, and it is bounded by a time of the order of $\ell^{d-1}$, similar to the case of Schwarzschild-AdS in Einstein gravity (which corresponds to $ε^2=1$), though for the latter this holds for all $d\geqslant 4$. The case of $0<ε^2<1$ is also qualitatively similar with $ε=0$.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2020; v1 submitted 5 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
The Interior Volume of Kerr-AdS Black Holes
Authors:
Xiao Yan Chew,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
The interior volume of black holes as defined by Christodoulou and Rovelli exhibits many surprising features. For example, it increases with time, even under Hawking evaporation. For some black holes, the interior volume is not even a monotonic increasing function of its area, which means one cannot infer how large a black hole is by just looking from the outside. Such a notion of volume, however,…
▽ More
The interior volume of black holes as defined by Christodoulou and Rovelli exhibits many surprising features. For example, it increases with time, even under Hawking evaporation. For some black holes, the interior volume is not even a monotonic increasing function of its area, which means one cannot infer how large a black hole is by just looking from the outside. Such a notion of volume, however, turns out to be useful in the context of holography, as it seems to be dual to the complexity of the boundary field theory. In this study, we investigate the properties of the interior volume of 4-dimensional Kerr-AdS black holes, fixing either the mass parameter $M$ or the physical mass $E$, whilst varying the values of the cosmological constant. We found that the volume as a function of the radial coordinate features a "double lobe" while fixing $M$, whereas fixing $E$ yields behaviors that are qualitatively similar to the asymptotically flat case. We briefly comment on the holographic complexity of Kerr-AdS black holes.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2020; v1 submitted 4 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Thermodynamics of Shearing Massless Scalar Field Spacetimes is Inconsistent With the Weyl Curvature Hypothesis
Authors:
Daniele Gregoris,
Yen Chin Ong,
Bin Wang
Abstract:
Our Universe has an arrow of time. In accordance with the second law of thermodynamics, entropy has been increasing ever since the Big Bang. The fact that matter is in thermal equilibrium in the very early Universe, as indicated by the cosmic microwave background, has led to the idea that gravitational entropy must be very low in the beginning. Penrose proposed that gravitational entropy can be qu…
▽ More
Our Universe has an arrow of time. In accordance with the second law of thermodynamics, entropy has been increasing ever since the Big Bang. The fact that matter is in thermal equilibrium in the very early Universe, as indicated by the cosmic microwave background, has led to the idea that gravitational entropy must be very low in the beginning. Penrose proposed that gravitational entropy can be quantified by the Weyl curvature, which increases as structures formed. A concrete realization of such a measure is the Clifton-Ellis-Tavakol gravitational entropy, which has been shown to be increasing in quite a number of cosmological models. In this work, we show a counter-example involving a class of inhomogeneous universes that are supported by a chameleon massless scalar field and exhibit anisotropic spacetime shearing effects. In fact, in our model the Clifton-Ellis-Tavakol gravitational entropy is increasing although the magnitude of the Weyl curvature is decreasing; this is due to the growth of the spacetime shear. The topology and the values of the three free parameters of the model are constrained by imposing a positive energy density for the cosmic fluid, and the thermodynamical requirements which follow from the cosmological holographic principle and the second law. It is shown that a negative deceleration parameter and a time decreasing Weyl curvature automatically follow from those conditions. Thus, we argue that our model can account for the formation of some primordial structures, like the Large Quasar Groups, which has required a non-standard evolution of the spatial anisotropies.
△ Less
Submitted 29 July, 2020; v1 submitted 21 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Particle spectrum of the Reissner-Nordström black hole
Authors:
Michael R. R. Good,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
The Reissner-Nordström black hole - moving mirror correspondence is solved. The beta coefficients reveal that charge makes a black hole radiate fewer particles (neutral massless scalars) per frequency. An old Reissner-Nordström black hole emits particles in an explicit Planck distribution with temperature corresponding to the surface gravity of its outer horizon.
The Reissner-Nordström black hole - moving mirror correspondence is solved. The beta coefficients reveal that charge makes a black hole radiate fewer particles (neutral massless scalars) per frequency. An old Reissner-Nordström black hole emits particles in an explicit Planck distribution with temperature corresponding to the surface gravity of its outer horizon.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
The Quantum Atmosphere of Reissner-Nordström Black Holes
Authors:
Yen Chin Ong,
Michael R. R. Good
Abstract:
Hawking radiation originates from a "quantum atmosphere" around black holes, not necessarily from the vicinity of the horizon. We examine and discuss the properties of quantum atmospheres of asymptotically flat Reissner-Nordström black holes, which extends further and further away from the black hole as extremality is approached, though arguably it becomes indistinguishable from normal vacuum fluc…
▽ More
Hawking radiation originates from a "quantum atmosphere" around black holes, not necessarily from the vicinity of the horizon. We examine and discuss the properties of quantum atmospheres of asymptotically flat Reissner-Nordström black holes, which extends further and further away from the black hole as extremality is approached, though arguably it becomes indistinguishable from normal vacuum fluctuation at spatial infinity. In addition, following our previous findings on re-writing the Hawking temperature of a Kerr black hole in terms of a "spring constant", we generalize the same notion to the Reissner-Nordström case, which allows us to put a minimum size on the location where Hawking particles can be emitted near a black hole, which agrees with the stretched horizon.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Cosmic Censorship and the Evolution of d-Dimensional Charged Evaporating Black Holes
Authors:
Hao Xu,
Yen Chin Ong,
Man-Hong Yung
Abstract:
The cosmic censorship conjecture essentially states that naked singularities should not form from generic initial conditions. Since black hole parameters can change their values under Hawking evaporation, one has to ask whether it is possible to reach extremality by simply waiting for the black hole to evaporate. If so a slight perturbation would likely render the singularity naked. Fortunately, a…
▽ More
The cosmic censorship conjecture essentially states that naked singularities should not form from generic initial conditions. Since black hole parameters can change their values under Hawking evaporation, one has to ask whether it is possible to reach extremality by simply waiting for the black hole to evaporate. If so a slight perturbation would likely render the singularity naked. Fortunately, at least for the case of asymptotically flat 4-dimensional Reissner-Nordström black hole, Hiscock and Weems showed that it can never reach extremality despite the fact that for a sufficiently massive black hole, its charge-to-mass ratio can increase during Hawking evaporation. Hence cosmic censorship is never violated by Hawking emission. However, we know that under some processes, it is easier to violate cosmic censorship in higher dimensions, therefore it is crucial to generalize Hiscock and Weems model to dimensions above four to check cosmic censorship. We found that Hawking evaporation cannot lead to violation of cosmic censorship even in higher dimensional Reissner-Nordström spacetimes. Morerover, it seems to be more difficult to reach extremality as number of dimension increases.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2020; v1 submitted 27 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
The Horizon of the McVittie Black Hole: On the Role of the Cosmic Fluid Modeling
Authors:
Daniele Gregoris,
Yen Chin Ong,
Bin Wang
Abstract:
In this paper, we investigate the existence and time evolution of the cosmological and event horizons in a McVittie universe whose expansion is driven by the Redlich-Kwong, (Modified) Berthelot, Dieterici, and Peng-Robinson fluids, respectively. The equations of state of these fluids are rich enough to account for both exotic and regular, as well as ideal and non-ideal matter contents of the unive…
▽ More
In this paper, we investigate the existence and time evolution of the cosmological and event horizons in a McVittie universe whose expansion is driven by the Redlich-Kwong, (Modified) Berthelot, Dieterici, and Peng-Robinson fluids, respectively. The equations of state of these fluids are rich enough to account for both exotic and regular, as well as ideal and non-ideal matter contents of the universe. We show that the cosmological horizon is expanding, while the event horizon is shrinking along the cosmic time evolution. The former achieves larger size for regular types of matter, contrary to the latter. The strength of interactions within the cosmic fluid are shown to play a more important role in affecting the evolution of the event horizon, rather than of the cosmological horizon in the case of a singularity-free universe. While the cosmological horizon always exists during the time evolution, the event horizon can exist only when a certain relationship between the Hawking-Hayward quasi-local mass and the Hubble function is fulfilled. In this manner, we can study the role played by the large-scale physics (cosmic evolution) on the local scale physics (evolution of a black hole).
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2020; v1 submitted 5 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
The Attractor of Evaporating Reissner-Nordström Black Holes
Authors:
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
Hiscock and Weems showed that there is an attractor behavior in the evolution of asymptotically flat Reissner-Nordström black hole under Hawking evaporation. If the initial charge-to-mass ratio $Q/M$ of the black hole is relatively small, then the ratio first increases until the black hole hits the attractor, and then starts to discharge towards the Schwarzschild limit. Sufficiently charged black…
▽ More
Hiscock and Weems showed that there is an attractor behavior in the evolution of asymptotically flat Reissner-Nordström black hole under Hawking evaporation. If the initial charge-to-mass ratio $Q/M$ of the black hole is relatively small, then the ratio first increases until the black hole hits the attractor, and then starts to discharge towards the Schwarzschild limit. Sufficiently charged black holes, on the other hand, simply discharge steadily towards the Schwarzschild limit. In this work we further investigate the nature of the attractor, and found that it is characterized by the mass loss rate being equal to the charge loss rate. The attractor is not necessarily related to the specific heat in a general evaporating black hole spacetime, but for the Reissner-Nordström case part of the attractor lies very close to the boundary of the region where specific heat changes sign.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
The Charge of Electron, Weak Gravity Conjecture and Black Hole Evolution
Authors:
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
The charge of an electron is vastly larger than its mass. We found that black hole evolution under Hawking evaporation is very sensitive to the value of electron charge. If the electron charge is weakened by a mere one order of magnitude, then the evolutionary paths of Reissner-Nordström black holes under Hawking evaporation change substantially. In particular, weakening the electron charge causes…
▽ More
The charge of an electron is vastly larger than its mass. We found that black hole evolution under Hawking evaporation is very sensitive to the value of electron charge. If the electron charge is weakened by a mere one order of magnitude, then the evolutionary paths of Reissner-Nordström black holes under Hawking evaporation change substantially. In particular, weakening the electron charge causes some black holes that would otherwise immediately discharge towards Schwarzschild limit to first evolve towards extremality before turning around. We discuss the possible connections between the weak gravity conjecture, the cosmic censorship conjecture, and black hole evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Charged Particle Production Rate from Cosmic Censorship in Dilaton Black Hole Spacetimes
Authors:
Yen Chin Ong,
Yuan Yao
Abstract:
Hiscock and Weems showed that under Hawking evaporation, an isolated asymptotically flat Reissner-Nordstrom (RN) black hole evolves in a surprising manner: if it starts with a relatively small value of charge-to-mass ratio Q/M, then said value will temporarily increase along its evolutionary path, before finally decreases towards zero. This contrasts with highly charged ones that simply radiate aw…
▽ More
Hiscock and Weems showed that under Hawking evaporation, an isolated asymptotically flat Reissner-Nordstrom (RN) black hole evolves in a surprising manner: if it starts with a relatively small value of charge-to-mass ratio Q/M, then said value will temporarily increase along its evolutionary path, before finally decreases towards zero. This contrasts with highly charged ones that simply radiate away its charge steadily. The combination of these two effects is the cosmic censor at work: there exists an attractor that flows towards the Schwazschild limit, which ensures that extremality -- and hence naked singularity -- can never be reached under Hawking evaporation. We apply the scheme of Hiscock and Weems to model the evaporation of an asymptotically flat dilatonic charge black hole known as the Garfinkle-Horowitz-Strominger (GHS) black hole. We found that upholding the cosmic censorship requires us to modify the charged particle production rate, which remarkably agrees with the expression obtained independently via direct computation of charged particle production rate on curved spacetime background. This not only strengthens the case for cosmic censorship, but also provides an example in which cosmic censorship can be a useful principle to deduce other physics. We also found that the attractor behavior is not necessarily related to the specific heat, contrary to the claim by Hiscock and Weems.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2019; v1 submitted 17 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
No Violation of the Second Law in Extended Black Hole Thermodynamics
Authors:
Shi-Qian Hu,
Yen Chin Ong,
Don N. Page
Abstract:
Recently a number of papers have claimed that the horizon area - and thus the entropy - of near extremal black holes in anti-de Sitter spacetimes can be reduced by drop** particles into them. In this note we point out that this is a consequence of an underlying assumption that the energy of an infalling particle changes only the internal energy of the black hole, whereas a more physical assumpti…
▽ More
Recently a number of papers have claimed that the horizon area - and thus the entropy - of near extremal black holes in anti-de Sitter spacetimes can be reduced by drop** particles into them. In this note we point out that this is a consequence of an underlying assumption that the energy of an infalling particle changes only the internal energy of the black hole, whereas a more physical assumption would be that it changes the enthalpy (mass). In fact, under the latter choice, the second law of extended black hole thermodynamics is no longer violated.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Holographic Principle and the Second Law in Stephani Cosmology Revisited
Authors:
Daniele Gregoris,
Yen Chin Ong,
Bin Wang
Abstract:
We show in a model-independent way that the inhomogeneous cosmological class II Stephani model fulfills both the the cosmological holographic principle, and that the entropy is increasing with time. By this we mean the result does not depend on any assumption on the time evolution of the scale factor, or on the matter content of the Universe, we also do not need to use the numerical values of the…
▽ More
We show in a model-independent way that the inhomogeneous cosmological class II Stephani model fulfills both the the cosmological holographic principle, and that the entropy is increasing with time. By this we mean the result does not depend on any assumption on the time evolution of the scale factor, or on the matter content of the Universe, we also do not need to use the numerical values of the cosmological parameters, which are inferred in the framework of the usual homogeneous Friedmann model. Therefore our analysis is not affected by the tension of the current estimates of the Hubble parameter, and does not rely on any model-dependent assumption of the entropy amount at the present epoch. Our analysis allows us to set an upper limit for the inhomogeneity parameter of the model, an upper bound for the size that this type of universe can reach during the time evolution, a lower bound for the entropy abundance, and an estimate of the present day value of the deceleration parameter.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2020; v1 submitted 6 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Curvature Invariants and Lower Dimensional Black Hole Horizons
Authors:
Daniele Gregoris,
Yen Chin Ong,
Bin Wang
Abstract:
It is known that the event horizon of a black hole can often be identified from the zeroes of some curvature invariants. The situation in lower dimensions has not been thoroughly clarified. In this work we investigate both (2+1)- and (1+1)-dimensional black hole horizons of static, stationary and dynamical black holes, identified with the zeroes of scalar polynomial and Cartan curvature invariants…
▽ More
It is known that the event horizon of a black hole can often be identified from the zeroes of some curvature invariants. The situation in lower dimensions has not been thoroughly clarified. In this work we investigate both (2+1)- and (1+1)-dimensional black hole horizons of static, stationary and dynamical black holes, identified with the zeroes of scalar polynomial and Cartan curvature invariants, with the purpose of discriminating the different roles played by the Weyl and Riemann curvature tensors. The situations and applicability of the methods are found to be quite different from that in 4-dimensional spacetime. The suitable Cartan invariants employed for detecting the horizon can be interpreted as a local extremum of the tidal force suggesting that the horizon of a black hole is a genuine special hypersurface within the full manifold, contrary to the usual claim that there is nothing special at the horizon, which is said to be a consequence of the equivalence principle.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2019; v1 submitted 14 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
General Black Hole Solutions in (2+1)-dimensions with a Scalar Field Non-Minimally Coupled to Gravity
Authors:
Zi-Yu Tang,
Yen Chin Ong,
Bin Wang,
Eleftherios Papantonopoulos
Abstract:
We discuss black hole solutions in (2+1)-dimensions with a scalar field non-minimally coupled to Einstein's gravity in the presence of a cosmological constant and a self-interacting scalar potential. Without specifying the form of the potential, we find a general solution of the field equations, which includes all the known asymptotically anti-de Sitter (AdS) black hole solutions in (2+1)-dimensio…
▽ More
We discuss black hole solutions in (2+1)-dimensions with a scalar field non-minimally coupled to Einstein's gravity in the presence of a cosmological constant and a self-interacting scalar potential. Without specifying the form of the potential, we find a general solution of the field equations, which includes all the known asymptotically anti-de Sitter (AdS) black hole solutions in (2+1)-dimensions as special cases once values of the coupling constants are chosen appropriately. In addition, we obtain numerically new black hole solutions and for some specific choices of the coupling constants we derive new exact AdS black hole solutions. We also discuss the possibility of obtaining asymptotically de Sitter black hole solutions with or without an electromagnetic field.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2019; v1 submitted 22 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
A Complementary Third Law for Black Hole Thermodynamics
Authors:
Yuan Yao,
Meng-Shi Hou,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
There are some examples in the literature, in which despite the fact that the underlying theory or model does not impose a lower bound on the size of black holes, the final temperature under Hawking evaporation is nevertheless finite and nonzero. We show that under some loose conditions, the black hole is necessarily an effective remnant, in the sense that its evaporation time is infinite. That is…
▽ More
There are some examples in the literature, in which despite the fact that the underlying theory or model does not impose a lower bound on the size of black holes, the final temperature under Hawking evaporation is nevertheless finite and nonzero. We show that under some loose conditions, the black hole is necessarily an effective remnant, in the sense that its evaporation time is infinite. That is, the final state that there is nonzero finite temperature despite having no black hole remaining cannot be realized. We discuss the limitations, subtleties, and the implications of this result, which is reminiscent of the third law of black hole thermodynamics, but with the roles of temperature and size interchanged. We therefore refer to our result as the "complementary third law" for black hole thermodynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2019; v1 submitted 7 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
A Note on Smarr Relation and Coupling Constants
Authors:
Shi-Qian Hu,
Xiao-Mei Kuang,
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
The Smarr relation plays an important role in black hole thermodynamics. It is often claimed that the Smarr relation can be written down simply by observing the scaling behavior of the various thermodynamical quantities. We point out that this is not necessarily so in the presence of dimensionful coupling constants, and discuss the issues involving the identification of thermodynamical variables.
The Smarr relation plays an important role in black hole thermodynamics. It is often claimed that the Smarr relation can be written down simply by observing the scaling behavior of the various thermodynamical quantities. We point out that this is not necessarily so in the presence of dimensionful coupling constants, and discuss the issues involving the identification of thermodynamical variables.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2019; v1 submitted 14 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Generalized Uncertainty Principle and White Dwarfs Redux: How Cosmological Constant Protects Chandrasekhar Limit
Authors:
Yen Chin Ong,
Yuan Yao
Abstract:
It was previously argued that generalized uncertainty principle (GUP) with a positive parameter removes the Chandrasekhar limit. One way to restore the limit is by taking the GUP parameter to be negative. In this work we discuss an alternative method that achieves the same effect: by including a cosmological constant term in the GUP (known as "extended GUP" in the literature). We show that an arbi…
▽ More
It was previously argued that generalized uncertainty principle (GUP) with a positive parameter removes the Chandrasekhar limit. One way to restore the limit is by taking the GUP parameter to be negative. In this work we discuss an alternative method that achieves the same effect: by including a cosmological constant term in the GUP (known as "extended GUP" in the literature). We show that an arbitrarily small but nonzero cosmological constant can restore the Chandrasekhar limit. We also remark that if the extended GUP is correct, then the existence of white dwarfs gives an upper bound for the cosmological constant, which -- while still large compared to observation -- is approximately 86 orders of magnitude smaller than the natural scale.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2018; v1 submitted 17 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
GUP-Corrected Black Hole Thermodynamics and the Maximum Force Conjecture
Authors:
Yen Chin Ong
Abstract:
We show that thermodynamics for an asymptotically flat Schwarzschild black hole leads to a force of magnitude $c^4/(2G)$. This remains true if one considers the simplest form of correction due to the generalized uncertainty principle. We comment on the maximum force conjecture, the subtleties involved, as well as the discrepancies with previous results in the literature.
We show that thermodynamics for an asymptotically flat Schwarzschild black hole leads to a force of magnitude $c^4/(2G)$. This remains true if one considers the simplest form of correction due to the generalized uncertainty principle. We comment on the maximum force conjecture, the subtleties involved, as well as the discrepancies with previous results in the literature.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2018; v1 submitted 2 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Black Hole Remnant in Massive Gravity
Authors:
B. Eslam Panah,
S. H. Hendi,
Y. C. Ong
Abstract:
The possibility of a nonzero graviton mass has been widely pursued in the literature. In this work we investigate a black hole solution in massive gravity with a degenerate fiducial metric often used in the literature. We find that the end state of Hawking evaporation leads to black hole remnant, which could help to ameliorate the information paradox. We prove that these remnants only exist in ant…
▽ More
The possibility of a nonzero graviton mass has been widely pursued in the literature. In this work we investigate a black hole solution in massive gravity with a degenerate fiducial metric often used in the literature. We find that the end state of Hawking evaporation leads to black hole remnant, which could help to ameliorate the information paradox. We prove that these remnants only exist in anti-de Sitter spacetime. Nevertheless, we speculate on their possible relevance to our Universe as dark matter candidate, in view of the possibility that our Universe could be inherently anti-de Sitter-like, with a transient accelerated expansion phase.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2020; v1 submitted 23 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
