-
Atmospheric cooling of freshwater near the temperature of maximum density
Authors:
Jason Olsthoorn
Abstract:
We perform three-dimensional direct numerical simulations of surface-driven convection near the temperature of maximum density $\tilde T_{md}$. A dynamic surface boundary condition couples heat flux through the surface to the induced convection, creating a dynamic equilibrium between the surface water temperature and the convection below. In this system, we identified three convective regimes: (1)…
▽ More
We perform three-dimensional direct numerical simulations of surface-driven convection near the temperature of maximum density $\tilde T_{md}$. A dynamic surface boundary condition couples heat flux through the surface to the induced convection, creating a dynamic equilibrium between the surface water temperature and the convection below. In this system, we identified three convective regimes: (1) free convection when the surface water temperature is above $\tilde T_{md}$, (2) penetrative convection when the surface water temperature is below $\tilde T_{md}$ and the convection is actively mixing the fluid layer, and (3) decaying convection when the convection weakens. We then predict the transitions between these regimes. Understanding these transitions is essential for the predicting timing of ice formation in natural systems.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Boundary layer instability beneath periodic internal solitary waves
Authors:
Andres Posada-Bedoya,
Jason Olsthoorn,
Leon Boegman
Abstract:
We investigated the stability of the bottom boundary layer (BBL) beneath periodic internal solitary waves (ISWs) of depression over a flat bottom through two-dimensional direct numerical simulations. We explored the effects of variation in wave Reynolds number $Re_{ISW}$ and wave period on the nature of the instability, and energy production in the separated BBL. The instability characteristics an…
▽ More
We investigated the stability of the bottom boundary layer (BBL) beneath periodic internal solitary waves (ISWs) of depression over a flat bottom through two-dimensional direct numerical simulations. We explored the effects of variation in wave Reynolds number $Re_{ISW}$ and wave period on the nature of the instability, and energy production in the separated BBL. The instability characteristics and rate of vortex shedding of the BBL were strongly dependent on $Re_{ISW}$. The BBL was laminar and convectively unstable at $Re_{ISW}$ 90 and 300, respectively. At $Re_{ISW}=300$, the convective wave packet was periodically amplified by each successive ISW, until vortex-shedding occurred. This implies noise-amplification behavior and suggests that the discrepancies in the critical $Re_{ISW}$, for vortex shedding between lab and different numerical simulations, are due to differences in background seed noise. Instability energy decreased under the front shoulder of the ISW, analogous to flow relaminarization under a favourable pressure gradient. At larger $Re_{ISW}=900$, the BBL was initially convectively unstable, and then the instability tracked with the ISW, characteristic of global instability, regardless of the ISW periodicity. The simulated initial convective instability at both $Re_{ISW}$ 300 and 900 is in agreement with local linear stability analysis which predicts that the instability group speed is always lower than the ISW celerity. Increased free-stream perturbations and larger $Re_{ISW}$ shift the location of vortex shedding (and enhanced bed shear stress) closer to the ISW trough, thereby potentially changing the location of maximum sediment resuspension from the ISW, in agreement with field observations at higher $Re_{ISW}$.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Accounting for surface temperature variations in Rayleigh-Bénard convection
Authors:
Jason Olsthoorn
Abstract:
Turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection is often modelled with a constant surface temperature. However, the surface temperature of many geophysical systems, such as lakes, is coupled to the atmospheric forcing. In this paper, we account for this dynamic surface temperature through an additional parameter $β$. Using an appropriately defined dynamical Rayleigh number $\RaD$, we recover many of the resu…
▽ More
Turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection is often modelled with a constant surface temperature. However, the surface temperature of many geophysical systems, such as lakes, is coupled to the atmospheric forcing. In this paper, we account for this dynamic surface temperature through an additional parameter $β$. Using an appropriately defined dynamical Rayleigh number $\RaD$, we recover many of the results from the standard Rayleigh-Bénard model. We hope that this work will simplify the application of Rayleigh-Bénard theory in geophysical contexts, such as lakes.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2023; v1 submitted 19 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
The Dynamics of Asymmetric Stratified Shear Instabilities
Authors:
Jason Olsthoorn,
Alexis K. Kaminski,
Daniel M. Robb
Abstract:
Most idealized studies of stratified shear instabilities assume that the shear interface and the buoyancy interface are coincident. We discuss the role of asymmetry on the evolution of shear instabilities. Using linear stability theory and direct numerical simulations, we show that asymmetric shear instabilities exhibit features of both Holmboe and Kelvin-Helmholtz (KH) instabilities, and develop…
▽ More
Most idealized studies of stratified shear instabilities assume that the shear interface and the buoyancy interface are coincident. We discuss the role of asymmetry on the evolution of shear instabilities. Using linear stability theory and direct numerical simulations, we show that asymmetric shear instabilities exhibit features of both Holmboe and Kelvin-Helmholtz (KH) instabilities, and develop a framework to determine whether the instabilities are more Holmboe-like or more KH-like. Further, the asymmetric instabilities produce asymmetric mixing that exhibits features of both overturning and scouring flows and that tends to realign the shear and buoyancy interfaces. In all but the symmetric KH simulations, we observe a collapse in the distribution of gradient Richardson number ($Ri_g$), suggesting that asymmetry reduces the parameter dependence of KH-driven mixing events. The observed dependence of the turbulent dynamics on small-scale details of the shear and stratification has important implications for the interpretation of oceanographic data.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2022; v1 submitted 2 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Salt-fingering in seasonally ice-covered lakes
Authors:
Jason Olsthoorn,
Edmund W. Tedford,
Gregory A. Lawrence
Abstract:
When ice forms on lakes, dissolved salts are rejected, which can lead to under-ice salt-finger formation. We performed a series of laboratory experiments to visualize these fingers. While we detected salt-fingers in our camera recordings, the signal of these fingers is nearly absent in the temperature record. We quantify the velocity of the salt plumes and measure the bottom salinity increase from…
▽ More
When ice forms on lakes, dissolved salts are rejected, which can lead to under-ice salt-finger formation. We performed a series of laboratory experiments to visualize these fingers. While we detected salt-fingers in our camera recordings, the signal of these fingers is nearly absent in the temperature record. We quantify the velocity of the salt plumes and measure the bottom salinity increase from these fingers. Further, we estimate that the salinity is often distributed evenly with depth. Comparing the salt fluxes in our experiments with a typical salt flux in lakes, we suggest that conditions are favorable for salt-fingering in most seasonally ice-covered lakes.
△ Less
Submitted 2 September, 2022; v1 submitted 10 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Reynolds stresses in Holmboe instabilities: from linear growth to saturation
Authors:
Adam J. K. Yang,
E. W. Tedford,
J. Olsthoorn,
A. Lefauve,
G. A. Lawrence
Abstract:
The Reynolds stress in Holmboe instabilities at moderate Reynolds numbers is investigated using single wavelength simulations (SWS), multiple wavelength simulations (MWS), and laboratory experiments. The rightward and leftward propagating instabilities are separated with the two-dimensional discrete Fourier transform, enabling a direct comparison of the perturbation fields between the numerical si…
▽ More
The Reynolds stress in Holmboe instabilities at moderate Reynolds numbers is investigated using single wavelength simulations (SWS), multiple wavelength simulations (MWS), and laboratory experiments. The rightward and leftward propagating instabilities are separated with the two-dimensional discrete Fourier transform, enabling a direct comparison of the perturbation fields between the numerical simulations and linear stability analysis. The decomposition and superposition of the perturbation fields provide a new insight into the origin of Reynolds stresses. Conventionally, only the statistics of horizontal and vertical velocity perturbation pairs, ($u',w'$), are presented to show the degree of anisotropy in turbulent fields. Here, we present these ($u',w'$)-pairs using both theory-based and statistical approaches to reveal the mechanism of the anisotropy of perturbation field. For an individual Holmboe mode, both the simulations and linear theory show that ($u',w'$)-pairs tilt towards the 2nd and 4th quadrants ($u'w'<0$) within upper and lower vorticity interfaces, indicating an anisotropic perturbation field. As a result, a negative correlation between the horizontal and vertical velocity perturbation is produced, $i.e.$ negative Reynolds stresses on average. Combining the leftward and rightward Holmboe modes, ($u',w'$)-pairs are also ellipses whose orientation and aspect ratio are phase dependent. The joint probability density functions of ($u',w'$) in the linear theory and SWS show `steering wheel' structures, while in MWS and laboratory experiments the presence of waves of varying wavelength smears out the `steering wheel' structure leaving an elliptical cloud with similar orientation to the corresponding linear prediction. The vertical structure of the Reynolds stresses in the simulations and the laboratory experiment agree with the linear stability predictions.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
The Cooling Box Problem: Convection with a quadratic equation of state
Authors:
Jason Olsthoorn,
Edmund W. Tedford,
Gregory A. Lawrence
Abstract:
We investigate the convective cooling of a fluid with a quadratic equation of state by performing three-dimensional direct numerical simulations of a flow with a fixed top-boundary temperature, which is lower than the initial fluid temperature. We consider fluid temperatures near the density maximum, where the nonlinearity is expected to be important. When the equation of state is nonlinear, the r…
▽ More
We investigate the convective cooling of a fluid with a quadratic equation of state by performing three-dimensional direct numerical simulations of a flow with a fixed top-boundary temperature, which is lower than the initial fluid temperature. We consider fluid temperatures near the density maximum, where the nonlinearity is expected to be important. When the equation of state is nonlinear, the resultant vertical transport of heat is fundamentally different and significantly lower than the predictions derived for a linear equation of state. Further, three dimensionless groups parameterize the convective system: the Rayleigh number ($\hbox{Ra}_0$), the Prandtl number (Pr), and the dimensionless bottom water temperature $(T_B)$. We further define an effective Rayleigh number ($\hbox{Ra}_{eff} = Ra_0 \ T_B^2$), which is equivalent to the traditional Rayleigh number used with a linear equation of state. We present a predictive model for the vertical heat flux, the top boundary-layer thickness, and the turbulent kinetic energy of the system. We show that this model agrees well with the direct numerical simulations. This model could be used to understand how quickly freshwater lakes cool in high latitude environments.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2020; v1 submitted 3 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
