-
Children's Overtrust and Shifting Perspectives of Generative AI
Authors:
Jaemarie Solyst,
Ellia Yang,
Shixian Xie,
Jessica Hammer,
Amy Ogan,
Motahhare Eslami
Abstract:
The capabilities of generative AI (genAI) have dramatically increased in recent times, and there are opportunities for children to leverage new features for personal and school-related endeavors. However, while the future of genAI is taking form, there remain potentially harmful limitations, such as generation of outputs with misinformation and bias. We ran a workshop study focused on ChatGPT to e…
▽ More
The capabilities of generative AI (genAI) have dramatically increased in recent times, and there are opportunities for children to leverage new features for personal and school-related endeavors. However, while the future of genAI is taking form, there remain potentially harmful limitations, such as generation of outputs with misinformation and bias. We ran a workshop study focused on ChatGPT to explore middle school girls' (N = 26) attitudes and reasoning about how genAI works. We focused on girls who are often disproportionately impacted by algorithmic bias. We found that: (1) middle school girls were initially overtrusting of genAI, (2) deliberate exposure to the limitations and mistakes of generative AI shifted this overtrust to disillusionment about genAI capabilities, though they were still optimistic for future possibilities of genAI, and (3) their ideas about school policy were nuanced. This work informs how children think about genAI like ChatGPT and its integration in learning settings.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2024; v1 submitted 22 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
ClassInSight: Designing Conversation Support Tools to Visualize Classroom Discussion for Personalized Teacher Professional Development
Authors:
Tricia J. Ngoon,
S Sushil,
Angela Stewart,
Ung-Sang Lee,
Saranya Venkatraman,
Neil Thawani,
Prasenjit Mitra,
Sherice Clarke,
John Zimmerman,
Amy Ogan
Abstract:
Teaching is one of many professions for which personalized feedback and reflection can help improve dialogue and discussion between the professional and those they serve. However, professional development (PD) is often impersonal as human observation is labor-intensive. Data-driven PD tools in teaching are of growing interest, but open questions about how professionals engage with their data in pr…
▽ More
Teaching is one of many professions for which personalized feedback and reflection can help improve dialogue and discussion between the professional and those they serve. However, professional development (PD) is often impersonal as human observation is labor-intensive. Data-driven PD tools in teaching are of growing interest, but open questions about how professionals engage with their data in practice remain. In this paper, we present ClassInSight, a tool that visualizes three levels of teachers' discussion data and structures reflection. Through 22 reflection sessions and interviews with 5 high school science teachers, we found themes related to dissonance, contextualization, and sustainability in how teachers engaged with their data in the tool and in how their professional vision, the use of professional expertise to interpret events, shifted over time. We discuss guidelines for these conversational support tools to support personalized PD in professions beyond teaching where conversation and interaction are important.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Making Sense of Machine Learning: Integrating Youth's Conceptual, Creative, and Critical Understandings of AI
Authors:
Luis Morales-Navarro,
Yasmin B. Kafai,
Francisco Castro,
William Payne,
Kayla DesPortes,
Daniella DiPaola,
Randi Williams,
Safinah Ali,
Cynthia Breazeal,
Clifford Lee,
Elisabeth Soep,
Duri Long,
Brian Magerko,
Jaemarie Solyst,
Amy Ogan,
Cansu Tatar,
Shiyan Jiang,
Jie Chao,
Carolyn P. Rosé,
Sepehr Vakil
Abstract:
Understanding how youth make sense of machine learning and how learning about machine learning can be supported in and out of school is more relevant than ever before as young people interact with machine learning powered applications everyday; while connecting with friends, listening to music, playing games, or attending school. In this symposium, we present different perspectives on understandin…
▽ More
Understanding how youth make sense of machine learning and how learning about machine learning can be supported in and out of school is more relevant than ever before as young people interact with machine learning powered applications everyday; while connecting with friends, listening to music, playing games, or attending school. In this symposium, we present different perspectives on understanding how learners make sense of machine learning in their everyday lives, how sensemaking of machine learning can be supported in and out of school through the construction of applications, and how youth critically evaluate machine learning powered systems. We discuss how sensemaking of machine learning applications involves the development and integration of conceptual, creative, and critical understandings that are increasingly important to prepare youth to participate in the world.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Investigating Girls' Perspectives and Knowledge Gaps on Ethics and Fairness in Artificial Intelligence in a Lightweight Workshop
Authors:
Jaemarie Solyst,
Alexis Axon,
Angela E. B. Stewart,
Motahhare Eslami,
Amy Ogan
Abstract:
Artificial intelligence (AI) is everywhere, with many children having increased exposure to AI technologies in daily life. We aimed to understand middle school girls' (a group often excluded group in tech) perceptions and knowledge gaps about AI. We created and explored the feasibility of a lightweight (less than 3 hours) educational workshop in which learners considered challenges in their lives…
▽ More
Artificial intelligence (AI) is everywhere, with many children having increased exposure to AI technologies in daily life. We aimed to understand middle school girls' (a group often excluded group in tech) perceptions and knowledge gaps about AI. We created and explored the feasibility of a lightweight (less than 3 hours) educational workshop in which learners considered challenges in their lives and communities and critically considered how existing and future AI could have an impact. After the workshop, learners had nuanced perceptions of AI, understanding AI can both help and harm. We discuss design implications for creating educational experiences in AI and fairness that embolden learners.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
