-
Social Optima of a Linear Quadratic Collective Choice Model under Congestion
Authors:
Noureddine Toumi,
Roland Malhamé,
Jérôme Le Ny
Abstract:
This paper investigates the social optimum for a dynamic linear quadratic collective choice problem where a group of agents choose among multiple alternatives or destinations. The agents' common objective is to minimize the average cost of the entire population. A naive approach to finding a social optimum for this problem involves solving a number of linear quadratic regulator (LQR) problems that…
▽ More
This paper investigates the social optimum for a dynamic linear quadratic collective choice problem where a group of agents choose among multiple alternatives or destinations. The agents' common objective is to minimize the average cost of the entire population. A naive approach to finding a social optimum for this problem involves solving a number of linear quadratic regulator (LQR) problems that increases exponentially with the population size. By exploiting the problem's symmetries, we first show that one can equivalently solve a number of LQR problems equal to the number of destinations, followed by an optimal transport problem parameterized by the fraction of agents choosing each destination. Then, we further reduce the complexity of the solution search by defining an appropriate system of limiting equations, whose solution is used to obtain a strategy shown to be asymptotically optimal as the number of agents becomes large. The model includes a congestion effect captured by a negative quadratic term in the social cost function, which may cause agents to escape to infinity in finite time. Hence, we identify sufficient conditions, independent of the population size, for the existence of the social optimum. Lastly, we investigate the behavior of the model through numerical simulations in different scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Optimal Robot Formations: Balancing Range-Based Observability and User-Defined Configurations
Authors:
Syed Shabbir Ahmed,
Mohammed Ayman Shalaby,
Jerome Le Ny,
James Richard Forbes
Abstract:
This paper introduces a set of customizable and novel cost functions that enable the user to easily specify desirable robot formations, such as a ``high-coverage'' infrastructure-inspection formation, while maintaining high relative pose estimation accuracy. The overall cost function balances the need for the robots to be close together for good ranging-based relative localization accuracy and the…
▽ More
This paper introduces a set of customizable and novel cost functions that enable the user to easily specify desirable robot formations, such as a ``high-coverage'' infrastructure-inspection formation, while maintaining high relative pose estimation accuracy. The overall cost function balances the need for the robots to be close together for good ranging-based relative localization accuracy and the need for the robots to achieve specific tasks, such as minimizing the time taken to inspect a given area. The formations found by minimizing the aggregated cost function are evaluated in a coverage path planning task in simulation and experiment, where the robots localize themselves and unknown landmarks using a simultaneous localization and map** algorithm based on the extended Kalman filter. Compared to an optimal formation that maximizes ranging-based relative localization accuracy, these formations significantly reduce the time to cover a given area with minimal impact on relative pose estimation accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Gaussian-Sum Filter for Range-based 3D Relative Pose Estimation in the Presence of Ambiguities
Authors:
Syed S. Ahmed,
Mohammed A. Shalaby,
Charles C. Cossette,
Jerome Le Ny,
James R. Forbes
Abstract:
Multi-robot systems must have the ability to accurately estimate relative states between robots in order to perform collaborative tasks, possibly with no external aiding. Three-dimensional relative pose estimation using range measurements oftentimes suffers from a finite number of non-unique solutions, or ambiguities. This paper: 1) identifies and accurately estimates all possible ambiguities in 2…
▽ More
Multi-robot systems must have the ability to accurately estimate relative states between robots in order to perform collaborative tasks, possibly with no external aiding. Three-dimensional relative pose estimation using range measurements oftentimes suffers from a finite number of non-unique solutions, or ambiguities. This paper: 1) identifies and accurately estimates all possible ambiguities in 2D; 2) treats them as components of a Gaussian mixture model; and 3) presents a computationally-efficient estimator, in the form of a Gaussian-sum filter (GSF), to realize range-based relative pose estimation in an infrastructure-free, 3D, setup. This estimator is evaluated in simulation and experiment and is shown to avoid divergence to local minima induced by the ambiguous poses. Furthermore, the proposed GSF outperforms an extended Kalman filter, demonstrates similar performance to the computationally-demanding particle filter, and is shown to be consistent.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
IMU Preintegration for Multi-Robot Systems in the Presence of Bias and Communication Constraints
Authors:
Mohammed Ayman Shalaby,
Charles Champagne Cossette,
Jerome Le Ny,
James Richard Forbes
Abstract:
This document is in supplement to the paper titled "Multi-Robot Relative Pose Estimation and IMU Preintegration Using Passive UWB Transceivers", available at [1]. The purpose of this document is to show how IMU biases can be incorporated into the framework presented in [1], while maintaining the differential Sylvester equation form of the process model.
This document is in supplement to the paper titled "Multi-Robot Relative Pose Estimation and IMU Preintegration Using Passive UWB Transceivers", available at [1]. The purpose of this document is to show how IMU biases can be incorporated into the framework presented in [1], while maintaining the differential Sylvester equation form of the process model.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2023; v1 submitted 12 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
STAR-loc: Dataset for STereo And Range-based localization
Authors:
Frederike Dümbgen,
Mohammed A. Shalaby,
Connor Holmes,
Charles C. Cossette,
James R. Forbes,
Jerome Le Ny,
Timothy D. Barfoot
Abstract:
This document contains a detailed description of the STAR-loc dataset. For a quick starting guide please refer to the associated Github repository (https://github.com/utiasASRL/starloc). The dataset consists of stereo camera data (rectified/raw images and inertial measurement unit measurements) and ultra-wideband (UWB) data (range measurements) collected on a sensor rig in a Vicon motion capture a…
▽ More
This document contains a detailed description of the STAR-loc dataset. For a quick starting guide please refer to the associated Github repository (https://github.com/utiasASRL/starloc). The dataset consists of stereo camera data (rectified/raw images and inertial measurement unit measurements) and ultra-wideband (UWB) data (range measurements) collected on a sensor rig in a Vicon motion capture arena. The UWB anchors and visual landmarks (Apriltags) are of known position, so the dataset can be used for both localization and Simultaneous Localization and Map** (SLAM).
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Multi-Robot Relative Pose Estimation and IMU Preintegration Using Passive UWB Transceivers
Authors:
Mohammed Ayman Shalaby,
Charles Champagne Cossette,
Jerome Le Ny,
James Richard Forbes
Abstract:
Ultra-wideband (UWB) systems are becoming increasingly popular as a means of inter-robot ranging and communication. A major constraint associated with UWB is that only one pair of UWB transceivers can range at a time to avoid interference, hence hindering the scalability of UWB-based localization. In this paper, a ranging protocol is proposed that allows all robots to passively listen on neighbour…
▽ More
Ultra-wideband (UWB) systems are becoming increasingly popular as a means of inter-robot ranging and communication. A major constraint associated with UWB is that only one pair of UWB transceivers can range at a time to avoid interference, hence hindering the scalability of UWB-based localization. In this paper, a ranging protocol is proposed that allows all robots to passively listen on neighbouring communicating robots without any hierarchical restrictions on the role of the robots. This is utilized to allow each robot to obtain more range measurements and to broadcast preintegrated inertial measurement unit (IMU) measurements for relative extended pose state estimation directly on SE_2(3). Consequently, a simultaneous clock-synchronization and relative-pose estimator (CSRPE) is formulated using an on-manifold extended Kalman filter (EKF) and is evaluated in simulation using Monte-Carlo runs for up to 7 robots. The ranging protocol is implemented in C on custom-made UWB boards fitted to 3 quadcopters, and the proposed filter is evaluated over multiple experimental trials, yielding up to 56% improvement in localization accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2023; v1 submitted 7 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Reducing Two-Way Ranging Variance by Signal-Timing Optimization
Authors:
Mohammed Ayman Shalaby,
Charles Champagne Cossette,
James Richard Forbes,
Jerome Le Ny
Abstract:
Time-of-flight-based ranging among transceivers with different clocks requires protocols that accommodate varying rates of the clocks. Double-sided two-way ranging (DS-TWR) is widely adopted as a standard protocol due to its accuracy; however, the precision of DS-TWR has not been clearly addressed. In this paper, an analytical model of the variance of DS-TWR is derived as a function of the user-pr…
▽ More
Time-of-flight-based ranging among transceivers with different clocks requires protocols that accommodate varying rates of the clocks. Double-sided two-way ranging (DS-TWR) is widely adopted as a standard protocol due to its accuracy; however, the precision of DS-TWR has not been clearly addressed. In this paper, an analytical model of the variance of DS-TWR is derived as a function of the user-programmed response delays, which is then compared to the Cramer-Rao Lower Bound (CRLB). This is then used to formulate an optimization problem over the response delays in order to maximize the information gained from range measurements. The derived analytical variance model and optimized protocol are validated experimentally with 2 ranging UWB transceivers, where 29 million range measurements are collected.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2024; v1 submitted 1 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Calibration and Uncertainty Characterization for Ultra-Wideband Two-Way-Ranging Measurements
Authors:
Mohammed Ayman Shalaby,
Charles Champagne Cossette,
James Richard Forbes,
Jerome Le Ny
Abstract:
Ultra-Wideband (UWB) systems are becoming increasingly popular for indoor localization, where range measurements are obtained by measuring the time-of-flight of radio signals. However, the range measurements typically suffer from a systematic error or bias that must be corrected for high-accuracy localization. In this paper, a ranging protocol is proposed alongside a robust and scalable antenna-de…
▽ More
Ultra-Wideband (UWB) systems are becoming increasingly popular for indoor localization, where range measurements are obtained by measuring the time-of-flight of radio signals. However, the range measurements typically suffer from a systematic error or bias that must be corrected for high-accuracy localization. In this paper, a ranging protocol is proposed alongside a robust and scalable antenna-delay calibration procedure to accurately and efficiently calibrate antenna delays for many UWB tags. Additionally, the bias and uncertainty of the measurements are modelled as a function of the received-signal power. The full calibration procedure is presented using experimental training data of 3 aerial robots fitted with 2 UWB tags each, and then evaluated on 2 test experiments. A localization problem is then formulated on the experimental test data, and the calibrated measurements and their modelled uncertainty are fed into an extended Kalman filter (EKF). The proposed calibration is shown to yield an average of 46% improvement in localization accuracy. Lastly, the paper is accompanied by an open-source UWB-calibration Python library, which can be found at https://github.com/decargroup/uwb_calibration.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2023; v1 submitted 11 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Relative Position Estimation in Multi-Agent Systems Using Attitude-Coupled Range Measurements
Authors:
Mohammed Shalaby,
Charles Champagne Cossette,
James Richard Forbes,
Jerome Le Ny
Abstract:
The ability to accurately estimate the position of robotic agents relative to one another, in possibly GPS-denied environments, is crucial to execute collaborative tasks. Inter-agent range measurements are available at a low cost, due to technologies such as ultra-wideband radio. However, the task of three-dimensional relative position estimation using range measurements in multi-agent systems suf…
▽ More
The ability to accurately estimate the position of robotic agents relative to one another, in possibly GPS-denied environments, is crucial to execute collaborative tasks. Inter-agent range measurements are available at a low cost, due to technologies such as ultra-wideband radio. However, the task of three-dimensional relative position estimation using range measurements in multi-agent systems suffers from unobservabilities. This letter presents a sufficient condition for the observability of the relative positions, and satisfies the condition using a simple framework with only range measurements, an accelerometer, a rate gyro, and a magnetometer. The framework has been tested in simulation and in experiments, where 40-50 cm positioning accuracy is achieved using inexpensive off-the-shelf hardware.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Optimal Multi-robot Formations for Relative Pose Estimation Using Range Measurements
Authors:
Charles Champagne Cossette,
Mohammed Ayman Shalaby,
David Saussie,
Jerome Le Ny,
James Richard Forbes
Abstract:
In multi-robot missions, relative position and attitude information between agents is valuable for a variety of tasks such as map**, planning, and formation control. In this paper, the problem of estimating relative poses from a set of inter-agent range measurements is investigated. Specifically, it is shown that the estimation accuracy is highly dependent on the true relative poses themselves,…
▽ More
In multi-robot missions, relative position and attitude information between agents is valuable for a variety of tasks such as map**, planning, and formation control. In this paper, the problem of estimating relative poses from a set of inter-agent range measurements is investigated. Specifically, it is shown that the estimation accuracy is highly dependent on the true relative poses themselves, which prompts the desire to find multi-agent formations that provide the best estimation performance. By direct maximization of Fischer information, it is shown in simulation and experiment that large improvements in estimation accuracy can be obtained by optimizing the formation geometry of a team of robots.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Ultra-Wideband Teach and Repeat
Authors:
Mohammed Ayman Shalaby,
Charles Champagne Cossette,
Jerome Le Ny,
James Richard Forbes
Abstract:
Autonomously retracing a manually-taught path is desirable for many applications, and Teach and Repeat (T&R) algorithms present an approach that is suitable for long-range autonomy. In this paper, ultra-wideband (UWB) ranging-based T&R is proposed for vehicles with limited resources. By fixing single UWB transceivers at far-apart unknown locations in an indoor environment, a robot with 3 UWB trans…
▽ More
Autonomously retracing a manually-taught path is desirable for many applications, and Teach and Repeat (T&R) algorithms present an approach that is suitable for long-range autonomy. In this paper, ultra-wideband (UWB) ranging-based T&R is proposed for vehicles with limited resources. By fixing single UWB transceivers at far-apart unknown locations in an indoor environment, a robot with 3 UWB transceivers builds a locally consistent map during the teach pass by fusing the range measurements under a custom ranging protocol with an on-board IMU and height measurements. The robot then uses information from the teach pass to retrace the same trajectory autonomously. The proposed ranging protocol and T&R algorithm are validated in simulation, where it is shown that the robot can successfully retrace the taught trajectory with sub-metre tracking error.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Ranging-Based Localizability Optimization for Mobile Robotic Networks
Authors:
Justin Cano,
Jerome Le Ny
Abstract:
In robotic networks relying on noisy range measurements between agents for cooperative localization, the achievable positioning accuracy strongly strongly depends on the network geometry. This motivates the problem of planning robot trajectories in such multi-robot systems in a way that maintains high localization accuracy. We present potential-based planning methods, where localizability potentia…
▽ More
In robotic networks relying on noisy range measurements between agents for cooperative localization, the achievable positioning accuracy strongly strongly depends on the network geometry. This motivates the problem of planning robot trajectories in such multi-robot systems in a way that maintains high localization accuracy. We present potential-based planning methods, where localizability potentials are introduced to characterize the quality of the network geometry for cooperative position estimation. These potentials are based on Cramer Rao Lower Bounds (CRLB) and provide a theoretical lower bound on the error covariance achievable by any unbiased position estimator. In the process, we establish connections between CRLBs and the theory of graph rigidity, which has been previously used to plan the motion of robotic networks. We develop decentralized deployment algorithms appropriate for large networks, and we use equality-constrained CRLBs to extend the concept of localizability to scenarios where additional information about the relative positions of the ranging sensors is known. We illustrate the resulting robot deployment methodology through simulated examples and an experiment.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2022; v1 submitted 1 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Relative Position Estimation Between Two UWB Devices with IMUs
Authors:
Charles C. Cossette,
Mohammed Shalaby,
David Saussié,
James R. Forbes,
Jérôme Le Ny
Abstract:
For a team of robots to work collaboratively, it is crucial that each robot have the ability to determine the position of their neighbors, relative to themselves, in order to execute tasks autonomously. This letter presents an algorithm for determining the three-dimensional relative position between two mobile robots, each using nothing more than a single ultra-wideband transceiver, an acceleromet…
▽ More
For a team of robots to work collaboratively, it is crucial that each robot have the ability to determine the position of their neighbors, relative to themselves, in order to execute tasks autonomously. This letter presents an algorithm for determining the three-dimensional relative position between two mobile robots, each using nothing more than a single ultra-wideband transceiver, an accelerometer, a rate gyro, and a magnetometer. A sliding window filter estimates the relative position at selected keypoints by combining the distance measurements with acceleration estimates, which each agent computes using an on-board attitude estimator. The algorithm is appropriate for real-time implementation, and has been tested in simulation and experiment, where it comfortably outperforms standard estimators. A positioning accuracy of less than 1 meter is achieved with inexpensive sensors.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Cascaded Filtering Using the Sigma Point Transformation (Extended Version)
Authors:
Mohammed Shalaby,
Charles Champagne Cossette,
Jerome Le Ny,
James Richard Forbes
Abstract:
It is often convenient to separate a state estimation task into smaller "local" tasks, where each local estimator estimates a subset of the overall system state. However, neglecting cross-covariance terms between state estimates can result in overconfident estimates, which can ultimately degrade the accuracy of the estimator. Common cascaded filtering techniques focus on the problem of modelling c…
▽ More
It is often convenient to separate a state estimation task into smaller "local" tasks, where each local estimator estimates a subset of the overall system state. However, neglecting cross-covariance terms between state estimates can result in overconfident estimates, which can ultimately degrade the accuracy of the estimator. Common cascaded filtering techniques focus on the problem of modelling cross-covariances when the local estimators share a common state vector. This letter introduces a novel cascaded and decentralized filtering approach that approximates the cross-covariances when the local estimators consider distinct state vectors. The proposed estimator is validated in simulations and in experiments on a three-dimensional attitude and position estimation problem. The proposed approach is compared to a naive cascaded filtering approach that neglects cross-covariance terms, a sigma point-based Covariance Intersection filter, and a full-state filter. In both simulations and experiments, the proposed filter outperforms the naive and the Covariance Intersection filters, while performing comparatively to the full-state filter.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Localizability-Constrained Deployment of Mobile Robotic Networks with Noisy Range Measurements
Authors:
Jerome Le Ny,
Simon Chauvière
Abstract:
When nodes in a mobile network use relative noisy measurements with respect to their neighbors to estimate their positions, the overall connectivity and geometry of the measurement network has a critical influence on the achievable localization accuracy. This paper considers the problem of deploying a mobile robotic network implementing a cooperative localization scheme based on range measurements…
▽ More
When nodes in a mobile network use relative noisy measurements with respect to their neighbors to estimate their positions, the overall connectivity and geometry of the measurement network has a critical influence on the achievable localization accuracy. This paper considers the problem of deploying a mobile robotic network implementing a cooperative localization scheme based on range measurements only, while attempting to maintain a network geometry that is favorable to estimating the robots' positions with high accuracy. The quality of the network geometry is measured by a "localizability" function serving as potential field for robot motion planning. This function is built from the Cramér-Rao bound, which provides for a given geometry a lower bound on the covariance matrix achievable by any unbiased position estimator that the robots might implement using their relative measurements. We describe gradient descent-based motion planners for the robots that attempt to optimize or constrain different variations of the network's localizability function, and discuss ways of implementing these controllers in a distributed manner. Finally, the paper also establishes formal connections between our statistical point of view and maintaining a form of weighted rigidity for the graph capturing the relative range measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
A Two-Stage Architecture for Differentially Private Kalman Filtering and LQG Control
Authors:
Kwassi H. Degue,
Jerome Le Ny
Abstract:
Large-scale monitoring and control systems enabling a more intelligent infrastructure increasingly rely on sensitive data obtained from private agents, e.g., location traces collected from the users of an intelligent transportation system. In order to encourage the participation of these agents, it becomes then critical to design algorithms that process information in a privacy-preserving way. Thi…
▽ More
Large-scale monitoring and control systems enabling a more intelligent infrastructure increasingly rely on sensitive data obtained from private agents, e.g., location traces collected from the users of an intelligent transportation system. In order to encourage the participation of these agents, it becomes then critical to design algorithms that process information in a privacy-preserving way. This article revisits the Kalman filtering and Linear Quadratic Gaussian (LQG) control problems, subject to privacy constraints. We aim to enforce differential privacy, a formal, state-of-the-art definition of privacy ensuring that the output of an algorithm is not too sensitive to the data collected from any single participating agent. A two-stage architecture is proposed that first aggregates and combines the individual agent signals before adding privacy-preserving noise and post-filtering the result to be published. We show a significant performance improvement offered by this architecture over input perturbation schemes as the number of input signals increases and that an optimal static aggregation stage can be computed by solving a semidefinite program. The two-stage architecture, which we develop first for Kalman filtering, is then adapted to the LQG control problem by leveraging the separation principle. Numerical simulations illustrate the performance improvements over differentially private algorithms without first-stage signal aggregation.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2020; v1 submitted 27 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Autonomous Landing of a Multirotor Micro Air Vehicle on a High Velocity Ground Vehicle
Authors:
Alexandre Borowczyk,
Duc-Tien Nguyen,
André Phu-Van Nguyen,
Dang Quang Nguyen,
David Saussié,
Jerome Le Ny
Abstract:
While autonomous multirotor micro aerial vehicles (MAVs) are uniquely well suited for certain types of missions benefiting from stationary flight capabilities, their more widespread usage still faces many hurdles, due in particular to their limited range and the difficulty of fully automating their deployment and retrieval. In this paper we address these issues by solving the problem of the automa…
▽ More
While autonomous multirotor micro aerial vehicles (MAVs) are uniquely well suited for certain types of missions benefiting from stationary flight capabilities, their more widespread usage still faces many hurdles, due in particular to their limited range and the difficulty of fully automating their deployment and retrieval. In this paper we address these issues by solving the problem of the automated landing of a quadcopter on a ground vehicle moving at relatively high speed. We present our system architecture, including the structure of our Kalman filter for the estimation of the relative position and velocity between the quadcopter and the landing pad, as well as our controller design for the full rendezvous and landing maneuvers. The system is experimentally validated by successfully landing in multiple trials a commercial quadcopter on the roof of a car moving at speeds of up to 50 km/h.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Design of a Trajectory Tracking Controller for a Nanoquadcopter
Authors:
Carlos Luis,
Jérôme Le Ny
Abstract:
The primary purpose of this study is to investigate the system modeling of a nanoquadcopter as well as designing position and trajectory control algorithms, with the ultimate goal of testing the system both in simulation and on a real platform.
The open source nanoquadcopter platform named Crazyflie 2.0 was chosen for the project. The first phase consisted in the development of a mathematical mo…
▽ More
The primary purpose of this study is to investigate the system modeling of a nanoquadcopter as well as designing position and trajectory control algorithms, with the ultimate goal of testing the system both in simulation and on a real platform.
The open source nanoquadcopter platform named Crazyflie 2.0 was chosen for the project. The first phase consisted in the development of a mathematical model that describes the dynamics of the quadcopter. Secondly, a simulation environment was created to design two different control architectures: cascaded PID position tracker and LQT trajectory tracker. Finally, the implementation phase consisted in testing the controllers on the chosen platform and comparing their performance in trajectory tracking.
Our simulations agreed with the experimental results, and further refinement of the model is proposed as future work through closed-loop model identification techniques. The results show that the LQT controller performed better at tracking trajectories, with RMS errors in position up to four times smaller than those obtained with the PID. LQT control effort was greater, but eliminated the high control peaks that induced motor saturation in the PID controller. The LQT controller was also tested using an ultra-wide band two-way ranging system, and comparisons with the more precise VICON system indicate that the controller could track a trajectory in both cases despise the difference in noise levels between the two systems.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
Dynamic Collective Choice: Social Optima
Authors:
Rabih Salhab,
Jerome Le Ny,
Roland P. Malhamé
Abstract:
We consider a dynamic collective choice problem where a large number of players are cooperatively choosing between multiple destinations while being influenced by the behavior of the group. For example, in a robotic swarm exploring a new environment, a robot might have to choose between multiple sites to visit, but at the same time it should remain close to the group to achieve some coordinated ta…
▽ More
We consider a dynamic collective choice problem where a large number of players are cooperatively choosing between multiple destinations while being influenced by the behavior of the group. For example, in a robotic swarm exploring a new environment, a robot might have to choose between multiple sites to visit, but at the same time it should remain close to the group to achieve some coordinated tasks. We show that to find a social optimum for our problem, one needs to solve a set of Linear Quadratic Regulator problems, whose number increases exponentially with the size of the population. Alternatively, we develop via the Mean Field Games methodology a set of decentralized strategies that are independent of the size of the population. When the number of agents is sufficiently large, these strategies qualify as approximately socially optimal. To compute the approximate social optimum, each player needs to know its own state and the statistical distributions of the players' initial states and problem parameters. Finally, we give a numerical example where the cooperative and noncooperative cases have opposite behaviors. Whereas in the former the size of the majority increases with the social effect, in the latter, the existence of a majority is disadvantaged.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
Collective Stochastic Discrete Choice Problems: A Min-LQG Game Formulation
Authors:
Rabih Salhab,
Roland P. Malhamé,
Jerome Le Ny
Abstract:
We consider a class of dynamic collective choice models with social interactions, whereby a large number of non-uniform agents have to individually settle on one of multiple discrete alternative choices, with the relevance of their would-be choices continuously impacted by noise and the unfolding group behavior. This class of problems is modeled here as a so-called Min-LQG game, i.e., a linear qua…
▽ More
We consider a class of dynamic collective choice models with social interactions, whereby a large number of non-uniform agents have to individually settle on one of multiple discrete alternative choices, with the relevance of their would-be choices continuously impacted by noise and the unfolding group behavior. This class of problems is modeled here as a so-called Min-LQG game, i.e., a linear quadratic Gaussian dynamic and non-cooperative game, with an additional combinatorial aspect in that it includes a final choice-related minimization in its terminal cost. The presence of this minimization term is key to enforcing some specific discrete choice by each individual agent. The theory of mean field games is invoked to generate a class of decentralized agent feedback control strategies which are then shown to converge to an exact Nash equilibrium of the game as the number of players increases to infinity. A key building block in our approach is an explicit solution to the problem of computing the best response of a generic agent to some arbitrarily posited smooth mean field trajectory. Ultimately, an agent is shown to face a continuously revised discrete choice problem, where greedy choices dictated by current conditions must be constantly balanced against the risk of the future process noise upsetting the wisdom of such decisions.Even though an agent's ultimately chosen alternative is random and dictated by its entire noise history and initial state, the limiting infinite population macroscopic behavior can still be predicted. It is shown that any Nash equilibrium of the game is defined by an a priori computable probability matrix characterizing the manner in which the agent population ultimately splits among the available alternatives.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2017; v1 submitted 27 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
A Motion Planning Strategy for the Active Vision-Based Map** of Ground-Level Structures
Authors:
Manikandasriram Srinivasan Ramanagopal,
André Phu-Van Nguyen,
Jerome Le Ny
Abstract:
This paper presents a strategy to guide a mobile ground robot equipped with a camera or depth sensor, in order to autonomously map the visible part of a bounded three-dimensional structure. We describe motion planning algorithms that determine appropriate successive viewpoints and attempt to fill holes automatically in a point cloud produced by the sensing and perception layer. The emphasis is on…
▽ More
This paper presents a strategy to guide a mobile ground robot equipped with a camera or depth sensor, in order to autonomously map the visible part of a bounded three-dimensional structure. We describe motion planning algorithms that determine appropriate successive viewpoints and attempt to fill holes automatically in a point cloud produced by the sensing and perception layer. The emphasis is on accurately reconstructing a 3D model of a structure of moderate size rather than map** large open environments, with applications for example in architecture, construction and inspection. The proposed algorithms do not require any initialization in the form of a mesh model or a bounding box, and the paths generated are well adapted to situations where the vision sensor is used simultaneously for map** and for localizing the robot, in the absence of additional absolute positioning system. We analyze the coverage properties of our policy, and compare its performance to the classic frontier based exploration algorithm. We illustrate its efficacy for different structure sizes, levels of localization accuracy and range of the depth sensor, and validate our design on a real-world experiment.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2017; v1 submitted 22 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Privacy-Preserving Nonlinear Observer Design Using Contraction Analysis
Authors:
Jerome Le Ny
Abstract:
Real-time information processing applications such as those enabling a more intelligent infrastructure are increasingly focused on analyzing privacy-sensitive data obtained from individuals. To produce accurate statistics about the habits of a population of users of a system, this data might need to be processed through model-based estimators. Moreover, models of population dynamics, originating f…
▽ More
Real-time information processing applications such as those enabling a more intelligent infrastructure are increasingly focused on analyzing privacy-sensitive data obtained from individuals. To produce accurate statistics about the habits of a population of users of a system, this data might need to be processed through model-based estimators. Moreover, models of population dynamics, originating for example from epidemiology or the social sciences, are often necessarily nonlinear. Motivated by these trends, this paper presents an approach to design nonlinear privacy-preserving model-based observers, relying on additive input or output noise to give differential privacy guarantees to the individuals providing the input data. For the case of output perturbation, contraction analysis allows us to design convergent observers as well as set the level of privacy-preserving noise appropriately. Two examples illustrate the approach: estimating the edge formation probabilities in a dynamic social network, and syndromic surveillance relying on an epidemiological model.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2018; v1 submitted 8 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
A Dynamic Game Model of Collective Choice in Multi-Agent Systems
Authors:
Rabih Salhab,
Roland P. Malhamé,
Jerome Le Ny
Abstract:
Inspired by successful biological collective decision mechanisms such as honey bees searching for a new colony or the collective navigation of fish schools, we consider a mean field games (MFG)-like scenario where a large number of agents have to make a choice among a set of different potential target destinations. Each individual both influences and is influenced by the group's decision, as well…
▽ More
Inspired by successful biological collective decision mechanisms such as honey bees searching for a new colony or the collective navigation of fish schools, we consider a mean field games (MFG)-like scenario where a large number of agents have to make a choice among a set of different potential target destinations. Each individual both influences and is influenced by the group's decision, as well as the mean trajectory of all the agents. The model can be interpreted as a stylized version of opinion crystallization in an election for example. The agents' biases are dictated first by their initial spatial position and, in a subsequent generalization of the model, by a combination of initial position and a priori individual preference. The agents have linear dynamics and are coupled through a modified form of quadratic cost. Fixed point based finite population equilibrium conditions are identified and associated existence conditions are established. In general multiple equilibria may exist and the agents need to know all initial conditions to compute them precisely. However, as the number of agents increases sufficiently, we show that 1) the computed fixed point equilibria qualify as epsilon Nash equilibria, 2) agents no longer require all initial conditions to compute the equilibria but rather can do so based on a representative probability distribution of these conditions now viewed as random variables. Numerical results are reported.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2016; v1 submitted 30 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Privacy-Preserving Filtering for Event Streams
Authors:
Jerome Le Ny
Abstract:
Many large-scale information systems such as intelligent transportation systems, smart grids or smart buildings collect data about the activities of their users to optimize their operations. To encourage participation and adoption of these systems, it is becoming increasingly important that the design process take privacy issues into consideration. In a typical scenario, signals originate from man…
▽ More
Many large-scale information systems such as intelligent transportation systems, smart grids or smart buildings collect data about the activities of their users to optimize their operations. To encourage participation and adoption of these systems, it is becoming increasingly important that the design process take privacy issues into consideration. In a typical scenario, signals originate from many sensors capturing events involving the users, and several statistics of interest need to be continuously published in real-time. This paper considers the problem of providing differential privacy guarantees for such multi-input multi-output systems processing event streams. We show how to construct and optimize various extensions of the zero-forcing equalization mechanism, which we previously proposed for single-input single-output systems. Some of these extensions can take a model of the input signals into account. We illustrate our privacy-preserving filter design methodology through the problem of privately monitoring and forecasting occupancy in a building equipped with multiple motion detection sensors.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2015; v1 submitted 21 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Distributed Algorithms for Stochastic Source Seeking with Mobile Robot Networks: Technical Report
Authors:
Nikolay A. Atanasov,
Jerome Le Ny,
George J. Pappas
Abstract:
Autonomous robot networks are an effective tool for monitoring large-scale environmental fields. This paper proposes distributed control strategies for localizing the source of a noisy signal, which could represent a physical quantity of interest such as magnetic force, heat, radio signal, or chemical concentration. We develop algorithms specific to two scenarios: one in which the sensors have a p…
▽ More
Autonomous robot networks are an effective tool for monitoring large-scale environmental fields. This paper proposes distributed control strategies for localizing the source of a noisy signal, which could represent a physical quantity of interest such as magnetic force, heat, radio signal, or chemical concentration. We develop algorithms specific to two scenarios: one in which the sensors have a precise model of the signal formation process and one in which a signal model is not available. In the model-free scenario, a team of sensors is used to follow a stochastic gradient of the signal field. Our approach is distributed, robust to deformations in the group geometry, does not necessitate global localization, and is guaranteed to lead the sensors to a neighborhood of a local maximum of the field. In the model-based scenario, the sensors follow the stochastic gradient of the mutual information between their expected measurements and the location of the source in a distributed manner. The performance is demonstrated in simulation using a robot sensor network to localize the source of a wireless radio signal.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2014; v1 submitted 31 January, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
Nonmyopic View Planning for Active Object Detection
Authors:
Nikolay Atanasov,
Bharath Sankaran,
Jerome Le Ny,
George J. Pappas,
Kostas Daniilidis
Abstract:
One of the central problems in computer vision is the detection of semantically important objects and the estimation of their pose. Most of the work in object detection has been based on single image processing and its performance is limited by occlusions and ambiguity in appearance and geometry. This paper proposes an active approach to object detection by controlling the point of view of a mobil…
▽ More
One of the central problems in computer vision is the detection of semantically important objects and the estimation of their pose. Most of the work in object detection has been based on single image processing and its performance is limited by occlusions and ambiguity in appearance and geometry. This paper proposes an active approach to object detection by controlling the point of view of a mobile depth camera. When an initial static detection phase identifies an object of interest, several hypotheses are made about its class and orientation. The sensor then plans a sequence of views, which balances the amount of energy used to move with the chance of identifying the correct hypothesis. We formulate an active hypothesis testing problem, which includes sensor mobility, and solve it using a point-based approximate POMDP algorithm. The validity of our approach is verified through simulation and real-world experiments with the PR2 robot. The results suggest that our approach outperforms the widely-used greedy view point selection and provides a significant improvement over static object detection.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Information Acquisition with Sensing Robots: Algorithms and Error Bounds
Authors:
Nikolay Atanasov,
Jerome Le Ny,
Kostas Daniilidis,
George J. Pappas
Abstract:
Utilizing the capabilities of configurable sensing systems requires addressing difficult information gathering problems. Near-optimal approaches exist for sensing systems without internal states. However, when it comes to optimizing the trajectories of mobile sensors the solutions are often greedy and rarely provide performance guarantees. Notably, under linear Gaussian assumptions, the problem be…
▽ More
Utilizing the capabilities of configurable sensing systems requires addressing difficult information gathering problems. Near-optimal approaches exist for sensing systems without internal states. However, when it comes to optimizing the trajectories of mobile sensors the solutions are often greedy and rarely provide performance guarantees. Notably, under linear Gaussian assumptions, the problem becomes deterministic and can be solved off-line. Approaches based on submodularity have been applied by ignoring the sensor dynamics and greedily selecting informative locations in the environment. This paper presents a non-greedy algorithm with suboptimality guarantees, which does not rely on submodularity and takes the sensor dynamics into account. Our method performs provably better than the widely used greedy one. Coupled with linearization and model predictive control, it can be used to generate adaptive policies for mobile sensors with non-linear sensing models. Applications in gas concentration map** and target tracking are presented.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
On Differentially Private Filtering for Event Streams
Authors:
Jerome Le Ny
Abstract:
Rigorous privacy mechanisms that can cope with dynamic data are required to encourage a wider adoption of large-scale monitoring and decision systems relying on end-user information. A promising approach to develop these mechanisms is to specify quantitative privacy requirements at design time rather than as an afterthought, and to rely on signal processing techniques to achieve satisfying trade-o…
▽ More
Rigorous privacy mechanisms that can cope with dynamic data are required to encourage a wider adoption of large-scale monitoring and decision systems relying on end-user information. A promising approach to develop these mechanisms is to specify quantitative privacy requirements at design time rather than as an afterthought, and to rely on signal processing techniques to achieve satisfying trade-offs between privacy and performance specifications. This paper discusses, from the signal processing point of view, an event stream analysis problem introduced in the database and cryptography literature. A discrete-valued input signal describes the occurrence of events contributed by end-users, and a system is supposed to provide some output signal based on this information, while preserving the privacy of the participants. The notion of privacy adopted here is that of event-level differential privacy, which provides strong privacy guarantees and has important operational advantages. Several mechanisms are described to provide differentially private output signals while minimizing the impact on performance. These mechanisms demonstrate the benefits of leveraging system theoretic techniques to provide privacy guarantees for dynamic systems.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Differentially Private Kalman Filtering
Authors:
Jerome Le Ny,
George J. Pappas
Abstract:
This paper studies the H2 (Kalman) filtering problem in the situation where a signal estimate must be constructed based on inputs from individual participants, whose data must remain private. This problem arises in emerging applications such as smart grids or intelligent transportation systems, where users continuously send data to third-party aggregators performing global monitoring or control ta…
▽ More
This paper studies the H2 (Kalman) filtering problem in the situation where a signal estimate must be constructed based on inputs from individual participants, whose data must remain private. This problem arises in emerging applications such as smart grids or intelligent transportation systems, where users continuously send data to third-party aggregators performing global monitoring or control tasks, and require guarantees that this data cannot be used to infer additional personal information. To provide strong formal privacy guarantees against adversaries with arbitrary side information, we rely on the notion of differential privacy introduced relatively recently in the database literature. This notion is extended to dynamic systems with many participants contributing independent input signals, and mechanisms are then proposed to solve the H2 filtering problem with a differential privacy constraint. A method for mitigating the impact of the privacy-inducing mechanism on the estimation performance is described, which relies on controlling the Hinfinity norm of the filter. Finally, we discuss an application to a privacy-preserving traffic monitoring system.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2012;
originally announced July 2012.
-
Differentially Private Filtering
Authors:
Jerome Le Ny,
George J. Pappas
Abstract:
Emerging systems such as smart grids or intelligent transportation systems often require end-user applications to continuously send information to external data aggregators performing monitoring or control tasks. This can result in an undesirable loss of privacy for the users in exchange of the benefits provided by the application. Motivated by this trend, this paper introduces privacy concerns in…
▽ More
Emerging systems such as smart grids or intelligent transportation systems often require end-user applications to continuously send information to external data aggregators performing monitoring or control tasks. This can result in an undesirable loss of privacy for the users in exchange of the benefits provided by the application. Motivated by this trend, this paper introduces privacy concerns in a system theoretic context, and addresses the problem of releasing filtered signals that respect the privacy of the user data streams. Our approach relies on a formal notion of privacy from the database literature, called differential privacy, which provides strong privacy guarantees against adversaries with arbitrary side information. Methods are developed to approximate a given filter by a differentially private version, so that the distortion introduced by the privacy mechanism is minimized. Two specific scenarios are considered. First, the notion of differential privacy is extended to dynamic systems with many participants contributing independent input signals. Kalman filtering is also discussed in this context, when a released output signal must preserve differential privacy for the measured signals or state trajectories of the individual participants. Second, differentially private mechanisms are described to approximate stable filters when participants contribute to a single event stream, extending previous work on differential privacy under continual observation.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2012; v1 submitted 18 July, 2012;
originally announced July 2012.
-
Adaptive Algorithms for Coverage Control and Space Partitioning in Mobile Robotic Networks
Authors:
Jerome Le Ny,
George J. Pappas
Abstract:
This paper considers deployment problems where a mobile robotic network must optimize its configuration in a distributed way in order to minimize a steady-state cost function that depends on the spatial distribution of certain probabilistic events of interest. Moreover, it is assumed that the event location distribution is a priori unknown, and can only be progressively inferred from the observati…
▽ More
This paper considers deployment problems where a mobile robotic network must optimize its configuration in a distributed way in order to minimize a steady-state cost function that depends on the spatial distribution of certain probabilistic events of interest. Moreover, it is assumed that the event location distribution is a priori unknown, and can only be progressively inferred from the observation of the actual event occurrences. Three classes of problems are discussed in detail: coverage control problems, spatial partitioning problems, and dynamic vehicle routing problems. In each case, distributed stochastic gradient algorithms optimizing the performance objective are presented. The stochastic gradient view simplifies and generalizes previously proposed solutions, and is applicable to new complex scenarios, such as adaptive coverage involving heterogeneous agents. Remarkably, these algorithms often take the form of simple distributed rules that could be implemented on resource-limited platforms.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2012; v1 submitted 2 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
-
Scheduling Kalman Filters in Continuous Time
Authors:
Jerome Le Ny,
Eric Feron,
Munther A. Dahleh
Abstract:
A set of N independent Gaussian linear time invariant systems is observed by M sensors whose task is to provide the best possible steady-state causal minimum mean square estimate of the state of the systems, in addition to minimizing a steady-state measurement cost. The sensors can switch between systems instantaneously, and there are additional resource constraints, for example on the number of…
▽ More
A set of N independent Gaussian linear time invariant systems is observed by M sensors whose task is to provide the best possible steady-state causal minimum mean square estimate of the state of the systems, in addition to minimizing a steady-state measurement cost. The sensors can switch between systems instantaneously, and there are additional resource constraints, for example on the number of sensors which can observe a given system simultaneously. We first derive a tractable relaxation of the problem, which provides a bound on the achievable performance. This bound can be computed by solving a convex program involving linear matrix inequalities. Exploiting the additional structure of the sites evolving independently, we can decompose this program into coupled smaller dimensional problems. In the scalar case with identical sensors, we give an analytical expression of an index policy proposed in a more general context by Whittle. In the general case, we develop open-loop periodic switching policies whose performance matches the bound arbitrarily closely.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2008;
originally announced October 2008.
-
A Linear Programming Relaxation and a Heuristic for the Restless Bandit Problem with General Switching Costs
Authors:
Jerome Le Ny,
Munther Dahleh,
Eric Feron
Abstract:
We extend a relaxation technique due to Bertsimas and Nino-Mora for the restless bandit problem to the case where arbitrary costs penalize switching between the bandits. We also construct a one-step lookahead policy using the solution of the relaxation. Computational experiments and a bound for approximate dynamic programming provide some empirical support for the heuristic.
We extend a relaxation technique due to Bertsimas and Nino-Mora for the restless bandit problem to the case where arbitrary costs penalize switching between the bandits. We also construct a one-step lookahead policy using the solution of the relaxation. Computational experiments and a bound for approximate dynamic programming provide some empirical support for the heuristic.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2008;
originally announced May 2008.
-
Performance Evaluation of a Multi-Agent Risk-Sensitive Tracking System
Authors:
Jerome Le Ny,
Eric Feron
Abstract:
In this paper, we consider a simple linear exponential quadratic Gaussian (LEQG) tracking problem for a multi-agent system. We study the dynamical behaviors of the group as we vary the risk-sensitivity parameter, comparing in particular the risk averse case to the LQG case. Then we consider the evolution of the performance per agent as the number of agents in the system increases. We provide som…
▽ More
In this paper, we consider a simple linear exponential quadratic Gaussian (LEQG) tracking problem for a multi-agent system. We study the dynamical behaviors of the group as we vary the risk-sensitivity parameter, comparing in particular the risk averse case to the LQG case. Then we consider the evolution of the performance per agent as the number of agents in the system increases. We provide some analytical as well as simulation results. In general, more agents are beneficial only if noisy agent dynamics and/or imperfect measurements are considered. The critical value of the risk sensitivity parameter above which the cost becomes infinite increases with the number of agents. In other words, for a fixed positive value of this parameter, there is a minimum number of agents above which the cost remains finite.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2007;
originally announced July 2007.
