-
Simulations of Precessing Jets and the Formation of X-shaped Radio Galaxies
Authors:
Chris Nolting,
Jay Ball,
Tri M. Nguyen
Abstract:
Jet precession is sometimes invoked to explain asymmetries in radio galaxy (RG) jets and "X/S/Z-shape" radio galaxies, caused by the presence of a binary black hole companion to the source active galactic nucleus (AGN) or by accretion instabilities. We present a series of simulations of radio galaxy jet precession to examine how these sources would evolve over time, including a passive distributio…
▽ More
Jet precession is sometimes invoked to explain asymmetries in radio galaxy (RG) jets and "X/S/Z-shape" radio galaxies, caused by the presence of a binary black hole companion to the source active galactic nucleus (AGN) or by accretion instabilities. We present a series of simulations of radio galaxy jet precession to examine how these sources would evolve over time, including a passive distribution of cosmic ray electrons (CRe) so we can model radio synchrotron emissions and create synthetic radio maps of the sources. We find that a single source viewed from different angles can result in differing RG morphological classifications, confusing physical implications of these classifications. Additionally, the jet trajectories can become unstable due to their own self-interactions and lead to "reorientation events" that may look like the effects of external dynamics such as shocks, winds, or cold fronts in the medium. Finally, something akin to an "Odd Radio Circle" may be observed in the case of viewing the radio remnant of such a precessing source from a line of sight near the precession axis.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2023; v1 submitted 11 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Intracluster magnetic filaments and an encounter with a radio jet
Authors:
Lawrence Rudnick,
Marcus Bruggen,
Gianfranco Brunetti,
William Cotton,
William Forman,
Thomas W. Jones,
Chris Nolting,
Gerrit Schellenberger,
Reinout van Weeren
Abstract:
Thin synchrotron-emitting filaments are increasingly seen in the intracluster medium (ICM). We present the first example of a direct interaction between a magnetic filament, a radio jet, and a dense ICM clump in the poor cluster Abell 194. This enables the first exploration of the dynamics and possible histories of magnetic fields and cosmic rays in such filaments. Our observations are from the Me…
▽ More
Thin synchrotron-emitting filaments are increasingly seen in the intracluster medium (ICM). We present the first example of a direct interaction between a magnetic filament, a radio jet, and a dense ICM clump in the poor cluster Abell 194. This enables the first exploration of the dynamics and possible histories of magnetic fields and cosmic rays in such filaments. Our observations are from the MeerKAT Galaxy Cluster Legacy Survey and the LOFAR Two Metre Sky Survey. Prominent 220 kpc long filaments extend east of radio galaxy 3C40B, with very faint extensions to 300 kpc, and show signs of interaction with its northern jet. They curve around a bend in the jet and intersect the jet in Faraday depth space. The X-ray surface brightness drops across the filaments; this suggests that the relativistic particles and fields contribute significantly to the pressure balance and evacuate the thermal plasma in a $\sim$35 kpc cylinder. We explore whether the relativistic electrons could have streamed along the filaments from 3C40B, and present a plausible alternative whereby magnetized filaments are a) generated by shear motions in the large-scale, post-merger ICM flow, b) stretched by interactions with the jet and flows in the ICM, amplifying the embedded magnetic fields, and c) perfused by re-energized relativistic electrons through betatron-type acceleration or diffusion of turbulently accelerated ICM cosmic ray electrons. We use the Faraday depth measurements to reconstruct some of the 3D structures of the filaments and of 3C40A and B.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Observations and Simulations of Radio Emission and Magnetic Fields in Minkowski's Object
Authors:
C. Nolting,
M. Lacy,
S. Croft,
P. C. Fragile,
S. T. Linden,
K. Nyland,
P. Patil
Abstract:
We combine new data from the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array with previous radio observations to create a more complete picture of the ongoing interactions between the radio jet from galaxy NGC 541 and the star-forming system known as Minkowski's Object (MO). We then compare those observations with synthetic radio data generated from a new set of magnetohydrodynamic simulations of a jet-cloud inte…
▽ More
We combine new data from the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array with previous radio observations to create a more complete picture of the ongoing interactions between the radio jet from galaxy NGC 541 and the star-forming system known as Minkowski's Object (MO). We then compare those observations with synthetic radio data generated from a new set of magnetohydrodynamic simulations of a jet-cloud interaction specifically tailored to the parameters of MO. The combination of radio intensity, polarization, and spectral index measurements all convincingly support the interaction scenario and provide additional constraints on the local dynamical state of the intracluster medium and the time since the jet-cloud interaction first began. In particular, we show that only a simulation with a bent radio jet can reproduce the observations.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2022; v1 submitted 9 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Shocked Narrow-Angle Tail Radio Galaxies: Simulations and Emissions
Authors:
Brian J. O'Neill,
T. W. Jones,
Chris Nolting,
P. J. Mendygral
Abstract:
We present a numerical study of the interactions between the elongated AGN outflows representing an evolved, narrow-angle tail (NAT) radio galaxy and planar, transverse ICM shock fronts characteristic of those induced by galaxy cluster mergers (incident Mach numbers 2 - 4). The simulated NAT formation was reported previously in \cite{on19a}. Our simulations utilize a three-dimensional, Eulerian ma…
▽ More
We present a numerical study of the interactions between the elongated AGN outflows representing an evolved, narrow-angle tail (NAT) radio galaxy and planar, transverse ICM shock fronts characteristic of those induced by galaxy cluster mergers (incident Mach numbers 2 - 4). The simulated NAT formation was reported previously in \cite{on19a}. Our simulations utilize a three-dimensional, Eulerian magnetohydrodynamic code along with energy-dependent Eulerian transport of passive cosmic ray electrons. Our analysis of the shock/NAT interaction applies a Riemann problem-based theoretical model to interpret complex shock front behavior during passage through the highly heterogeneous structures of the simulated NAT tails. In addition to shock compression, shock-induced vortical motions are observed within the tails that contribute to coherent turbulent dynamo processes that continue to amplify the magnetic fields in the tails well after initial shock compression. We analyze synthetic radio observations spanning the NAT-shock interaction period, and examine the brightness, spectral and polarization properties of our shock-rejuvenated radio tails, as well as the extent to which the pre-shock states of the plasma and particle populations in our tails influence post-shock observations. Finally, we evaluate our findings in the possible context of a physical analogy to our simulated NAT providing the precursor to a cluster ``radio relic'' associated with an impacting ICM shock.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2019; v1 submitted 17 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Simulated Interactions Between Radio Galaxies and Cluster Shocks -- 2: Jet Axes Orthogonal to Shock Normals
Authors:
Chris Nolting,
T. W. Jones,
Brian O'Neill,
P. J. Mendygral
Abstract:
We report a 3D MHD simulation study of the interactions between radio galaxies and galaxy-cluster-media shocks in which the incident shock normals are orthogonal to the bipolar AGN jets. Before shock impact, light, supersonic jets inflate lobes (cavities) in a static, uniform ICM. We examine three AGN activity scenarios: 1) continued, steady jet activity; 2) jet source cycled off coincident with s…
▽ More
We report a 3D MHD simulation study of the interactions between radio galaxies and galaxy-cluster-media shocks in which the incident shock normals are orthogonal to the bipolar AGN jets. Before shock impact, light, supersonic jets inflate lobes (cavities) in a static, uniform ICM. We examine three AGN activity scenarios: 1) continued, steady jet activity; 2) jet source cycled off coincident with shock/radio lobe impact; 3) jet activity ceased well before shock arrival (a "radio phoenix" scenario). The simulations follow relativistic electrons (CRe) introduced by the jets, enabling synthetic radio synchrotron images and spectra. Such encounters can be decomposed into an abrupt shock transition and a subsequent long term post shock wind. Shock impact disrupts the pre-formed, low density RG cavities into two ring vortices embedded in the post shock wind. Dynamical processes cause the vortex pair to merge as they propagate downwind somewhat faster than the wind itself. When the AGN jets remain active ram pressure bends the jets downwind, generating a narrow angle tail morphology aligned with the axis of the vortex ring. The deflected jets do not significantly alter dynamical evolution of the vortex ring. However, active jets and their associated tails do dominate the synchrotron emission, compromising the observability of the vortex structures. Downwind-directed momentum concentrated by the jets impacts and alters the post-encounter shock. In the "radio phoenix" scenario, no DSA of the fossil electron population is required to account for the observed brightening and flattening of the spectra, adiabatic compression effects are sufficient.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
A Fresh Look at Narrow-Angle Tail Radio Galaxy Dynamics, Evolution and Emissions
Authors:
Brian J. O'Neill,
T. W. Jones,
Chris Nolting,
P. J. Mendygral
Abstract:
We present a 3D magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) study of narrow-angle tail (NAT) radio galaxy (RG) dynamics, including passive cosmic ray electrons. We follow evolution of a bipolar-jet RG in a persistent crosswind through hundreds of Myr. We confirm traditional jet-bending models, while noting that our NAT exhibits a transitional morphology reminiscent of wide-angle radio tails. Once deflected, jets re…
▽ More
We present a 3D magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) study of narrow-angle tail (NAT) radio galaxy (RG) dynamics, including passive cosmic ray electrons. We follow evolution of a bipolar-jet RG in a persistent crosswind through hundreds of Myr. We confirm traditional jet-bending models, while noting that our NAT exhibits a transitional morphology reminiscent of wide-angle radio tails. Once deflected, jets remain internally stable, but are intermittently disrupted by external disturbances induced by the NAT dynamics itself. The disruptions enhance jet and tail magnetic fields. Disrupted jet plasma is heterogeneously mixed with denser wind plasma, yielding patchy, filamentary tails that grow longer at a rate exceeding the wind speed. Such fast tail extension could, for example, allow NAT tails to overtake extraneous ICM features, such as shocks and shear layers downwind of where the tails first form. Those events, in turn, could generate enhanced radio emissions within the ICM features themselves that do not follow the geometrical extension of the tails past the encounter. Analysis of synthetic radio observations reveals an extended time period once the NAT has developed in which it displays a nearly steady-state morphology with integrated fluxes that are roughly constant, along with a self-similar, curved integrated spectrum. In an appendix, we outline a simple analytic jet trajectory formalism with one adjustable parameter, using it to illustrate explicit trajectories that extend the classic bending model to arbitrary jet-wind orientations.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Interactions Between Radio Galaxies and Cluster Shocks - 1: Jet Axes Aligned with Shock Normals
Authors:
Chris Nolting,
T. W. Jones,
Brian O'Neill,
P. J. Mendygral
Abstract:
We report from a study utilizing 3D MHD simulations, including cosmic-ray electrons, of the interactions between radio galaxies (RGs) and dynamically active ICMs. Here we consider interactions involving plane ICM shocks having Mach numbers 2--4 and their normals aligned with steady, active bipolar RG jets penetrating uniform, stationary ICMs. Shock impact disrupts the pre-formed RG jet cocoons int…
▽ More
We report from a study utilizing 3D MHD simulations, including cosmic-ray electrons, of the interactions between radio galaxies (RGs) and dynamically active ICMs. Here we consider interactions involving plane ICM shocks having Mach numbers 2--4 and their normals aligned with steady, active bipolar RG jets penetrating uniform, stationary ICMs. Shock impact disrupts the pre-formed RG jet cocoons into ring vortex structures. Sufficiently strong post-shock winds can stop and even reverse the upwind jet, and strip jets to virtually "naked" states, leaving them without a surrounding cocoon. Strong shock-induced vorticity can also disrupt the downwind jet, so that the ring vortex remnant of the cocoons appears ahead of that jet's visible terminus. Magnetic field amplification in the ring vortex can significantly enhance its synchrotron emissions well after the vortex becomes isolated from the RG and its fresh CRe supply. We examine these dynamics and their observable consequences in detail.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
WOMBAT: A Scalable and High Performance Astrophysical MHD Code
Authors:
Peter Mendygral,
Nick Radcliffe,
Krishna Kandalla,
David Porter,
Brian J. O'Neill,
Chris Nolting,
Paul Edmon,
Julius M. F. Donnert,
Thomas W. Jones
Abstract:
We present a new code for astrophysical magneto-hydrodynamics specifically designed and optimized for high performance and scaling on modern and future supercomputers. We describe a novel hybrid OpenMP/MPI programming model that emerged from a collaboration between Cray, Inc. and the University of Minnesota. This design utilizes MPI-RMA optimized for thread scaling, which allows the code to run ex…
▽ More
We present a new code for astrophysical magneto-hydrodynamics specifically designed and optimized for high performance and scaling on modern and future supercomputers. We describe a novel hybrid OpenMP/MPI programming model that emerged from a collaboration between Cray, Inc. and the University of Minnesota. This design utilizes MPI-RMA optimized for thread scaling, which allows the code to run extremely efficiently at very high thread counts ideal for the latest generation of the multi-core and many-core architectures. Such performance characteristics are needed in the era of "exascale" computing. We describe and demonstrate our high-performance design in detail with the intent that it may be used as a model for other, future astrophysical codes intended for applications demanding exceptional performance.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Using Collisions of AGN Outflows with ICM Shocks as Dynamical Probes
Authors:
T. W. Jones,
Chris Nolting,
B. J. O'Neill,
P. J. Mendygral
Abstract:
In this paper we lay out a simple set of relationships connecting the dynamics of fast plasma jets to the dynamical state of their ambient media. The objective is to provide a tool kit that can be used to connect the morphologies of radio AGNs in galaxy clusters to the dynamical state of the local ICM. The formalism is intended to apply to jets whether they are relativistic or non-relativistic. Sp…
▽ More
In this paper we lay out a simple set of relationships connecting the dynamics of fast plasma jets to the dynamical state of their ambient media. The objective is to provide a tool kit that can be used to connect the morphologies of radio AGNs in galaxy clusters to the dynamical state of the local ICM. The formalism is intended to apply to jets whether they are relativistic or non-relativistic. Special attention is paid to interactions involving ICM shocks, although the results can be applied more broadly. Our formalism emphasizes the importance of the relative Mach number of the impacting ICM flow and the internal Mach number of the AGN jet in determining how the AGN outflows evolve.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Testing DARKexp against energy and density distributions of Millennium-II halos
Authors:
Chris Nolting,
Liliya L. R. Williams,
Michael Boylan-Kolchin,
Jens Hjorth
Abstract:
We test the DARKexp model for relaxed, self-gravitating, collisionless systems against equilibrium dark matter halos from the Millennium-II simulation. While limited tests of DARKexp against simulations and observations have been carried out elsewhere, this is the first time the testing is done with a large sample of simulated halos spanning a factor of ~ 50 in mass, and using independent fits to…
▽ More
We test the DARKexp model for relaxed, self-gravitating, collisionless systems against equilibrium dark matter halos from the Millennium-II simulation. While limited tests of DARKexp against simulations and observations have been carried out elsewhere, this is the first time the testing is done with a large sample of simulated halos spanning a factor of ~ 50 in mass, and using independent fits to density and energy distributions. We show that DARKexp, a one shape parameter family, provides very good fits to the shapes of density profiles, ρ(r), and differential energy distributions, N(E), of individual simulated halos. The best fit shape parameter $φ_{0}$ obtained from the two types of fits are correlated, though with scatter. Our most important conclusions come from ρ(r) and N(E) that have been averaged over many halos. These show that the bulk of the deviations between DARKexp and individual Millennium-II halos come from halo-to-halo fluctuations, likely driven by substructure, and other density perturbations. The average ρ(r) and N(E) are quite smooth and follow DARKexp very closely. The only deviation that remains after averaging is small, and located at most bound energies for N(E) and smallest radii for ρ(r). Since the deviation is confined to 3-4 smoothing lengths, and is larger for low mass halos, it is likely due to numerical resolution effects.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2016; v1 submitted 23 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
QPot: An R Package for Stochastic Differential Equation Quasi-Potential Analysis
Authors:
Christopher M. Moore,
Christopher R. Stieha,
Ben C. Nolting,
Maria K. Cameron,
Karen C. Abbott
Abstract:
QPot is an R package for analyzing two-dimensional systems of stochastic differential equations. It provides users with a wide range of tools to simulate, analyze, and visualize the dynamics of these systems. One of QPot's key features is the computation of the quasi-potential, an important tool for studying stochastic systems. Quasi-potentials are particularly useful for comparing the relative st…
▽ More
QPot is an R package for analyzing two-dimensional systems of stochastic differential equations. It provides users with a wide range of tools to simulate, analyze, and visualize the dynamics of these systems. One of QPot's key features is the computation of the quasi-potential, an important tool for studying stochastic systems. Quasi-potentials are particularly useful for comparing the relative stabilities of equilibria in systems with alternative stable states. This paper describes QPot's primary functions, and explains how quasi-potentials can yield insights about the dynamics of stochastic systems. Three worked examples guide users through the application of QPot's functions.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Balls, cups, and quasi-potentials: quantifying stability in stochastic systems
Authors:
Ben C. Nolting,
Karen C. Abbott
Abstract:
When a system has more than one stable state, how can the stability of these states be compared? This deceptively simple question has important consequences for ecosystems, because systems with alternative stable states can undergo dramatic regime shifts. The probability, frequency, duration, and dynamics of these shifts will all depend on the relative stability of the stable states. Unfortunately…
▽ More
When a system has more than one stable state, how can the stability of these states be compared? This deceptively simple question has important consequences for ecosystems, because systems with alternative stable states can undergo dramatic regime shifts. The probability, frequency, duration, and dynamics of these shifts will all depend on the relative stability of the stable states. Unfortunately, the concept of stability in ecology has suffered from substantial confusion and this is particularly problematic for systems where stochastic perturbations can cause shifts between coexisting alternative stable states. A useful way to visualize stable states in stochastic systems is with a ball-in-cup diagram, in which the state of the system is represented as the position of a ball rolling on a surface, and the random perturbations can push the ball from one basin of attraction to another. The surface is determined by a potential function, which provides a natural stability metric. However, systems amenable to this representation, called gradient systems, are quite rare. As a result, the potential function is not widely used and other approaches based on linear stability analysis have become standard. Linear stability analysis is designed for local analysis of deterministic systems and, as we show, can produce a highly misleading picture of how the system will behave under continual, stochastic perturbations. In this paper, we show how the potential function can be generalized so that it can be applied broadly, employing a concept from stochastic analysis called the quasi-potential. Using three classic ecological models, we demonstrate that the quasi-potential provides a useful way to quantify stability in stochastic systems.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2015; v1 submitted 9 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Composite random search strategies based on non-directional sensory cues
Authors:
Ben C. Nolting,
Travis M. Hinkelman,
Chad E. Brassil,
Brigitte Tenhumberg
Abstract:
Many foraging animals find food using composite random search strategies, which consist of intensive and extensive search modes. Models of composite search can generate predictions about how optimal foragers should behave in each search mode, and how they should determine when to switch between search modes. Most of these models assume that foragers use resource encounters to decide when to switch…
▽ More
Many foraging animals find food using composite random search strategies, which consist of intensive and extensive search modes. Models of composite search can generate predictions about how optimal foragers should behave in each search mode, and how they should determine when to switch between search modes. Most of these models assume that foragers use resource encounters to decide when to switch between search modes. Empirical observations indicate that a variety of organisms use non-directional sensory cues to identify areas that warrant intensive search. These cues are not precise enough to allow a forager to directly orient itself to a resource, but can be used as a criterion to determine the appropriate search mode. As a potential example, a forager might use olfactory information, which could help it determine if an area is worth searching carefully. We developed a model of composite search based on non-directional sensory cues. With simulations, we compared the search efficiencies of composite foragers that use resource encounters as their mode-switching criterion with those that use non-directional sensory cues. We identified optimal search patterns and mode-switching criteria on a variety of resource distributions, characterized by different levels of resource aggregation and density. On all resource distributions, foraging strategies based on the non-directional sensory criterion were more efficient than those based on the resource encounter criterion. Strategies based on the non-directional sensory criterion were also more robust to changes in resource distribution. Our results suggest that current assumptions about the role of resource encounters in models of optimal composite search should be re-examined. The search strategies predicted by our model can help bridge the gap between random search theory and traditional patch-use foraging theory.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2015; v1 submitted 21 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.