-
A real-time digital twin of azimuthal thermoacoustic instabilities
Authors:
Andrea Nóvoa,
Nicolas Noiray,
James R. Dawson,
Luca Magri
Abstract:
When they occur, azimuthal thermoacoustic oscillations can detrimentally affect the safe operation of gas turbines and aeroengines. We develop a real-time digital twin of azimuthal thermoacoustics of a hydrogen-based annular combustor. The digital twin seamlessly combines two sources of information about the system (i) a physics-based low-order model; and (ii) raw and sparse experimental data from…
▽ More
When they occur, azimuthal thermoacoustic oscillations can detrimentally affect the safe operation of gas turbines and aeroengines. We develop a real-time digital twin of azimuthal thermoacoustics of a hydrogen-based annular combustor. The digital twin seamlessly combines two sources of information about the system (i) a physics-based low-order model; and (ii) raw and sparse experimental data from microphones, which contain both aleatoric noise and turbulent fluctuations. First, we derive a low-order thermoacoustic model for azimuthal instabilities, which is deterministic. Second, we propose a real-time data assimilation framework to infer the acoustic pressure, the physical parameters, and the model and measurement biases simultaneously. This is the bias-regularized ensemble Kalman filter (r-EnKF), for which we find an analytical solution that solves the optimization problem. Third, we propose a reservoir computer, which infers both the model bias and measurement bias to close the assimilation equations. Fourth, we propose a real-time digital twin of the azimuthal thermoacoustic dynamics of a laboratory hydrogen-based annular combustor for a variety of equivalence ratios. We find that the real-time digital twin (i) autonomously predicts azimuthal dynamics, in contrast to bias-unregularized methods; (ii) uncovers the physical acoustic pressure from the raw data, i.e., it acts as a physics-based filter; (iii) is a time-varying parameter system, which generalizes existing models that have constant parameters, and capture only slow-varying variables. The digital twin generalizes to all equivalence ratios, which bridges the gap of existing models. This work opens new opportunities for real-time digital twinning of multi-physics problems.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Synchronization-based lossless non-reciprocal scattering
Authors:
Tiemo Pedergnana,
Abel Faure-Beaulieu,
Romain Fleury,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
Breaking the reciprocity of wave propagation is a problem of fundamental interest, and a mucht-sought functionality in practical applications, both in photonics and phononics. Although it has been achieved using resonant linear scattering from cavities with broken time-reversal symmetry, such realizations have remained inescapably plagued by inherent passivity constraints, which make absorption lo…
▽ More
Breaking the reciprocity of wave propagation is a problem of fundamental interest, and a mucht-sought functionality in practical applications, both in photonics and phononics. Although it has been achieved using resonant linear scattering from cavities with broken time-reversal symmetry, such realizations have remained inescapably plagued by inherent passivity constraints, which make absorption losses unavoidable, leading to stringent limitations in transmitted power. In this work, we solve this problem by converting the cavity resonance into a limit cycle, exploiting the uncharted interplay between non-linearity, gain, and non-reciprocity. Remarkably, strong enough incident waves can synchronize with these self-sustained oscillations and use their energy for amplification. We theoretically and experimentally demonstrate that this mechanism can simultaneously enhance non-reciprocity and compensate absorption. Real-world acoustic scattering experiments allow us to observe perfect non-reciprocal transmission of audible sound in a synchronisation-based 3-port circulator with full immunity against losses.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
BOATS: Bayesian Optimization for Active Control of ThermoacousticS
Authors:
Bayu Dharmaputra,
Pit Reckinger,
Bruno Schuermans,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
This investigation presents novel adaptive control algorithms specifically designed to address and mitigate thermoacoustic instabilities. Two control strategies are available to alleviate this issue: active and passive. Active control strategies have a wider flexibility than passive control strategies because they can adapt to the operating conditions of the gas turbine. However, optimizing the co…
▽ More
This investigation presents novel adaptive control algorithms specifically designed to address and mitigate thermoacoustic instabilities. Two control strategies are available to alleviate this issue: active and passive. Active control strategies have a wider flexibility than passive control strategies because they can adapt to the operating conditions of the gas turbine. However, optimizing the control parameters remains a challenge, especially if additional constraints have to be fulfilled, such as e.g. pollutant emission levels. To address this issue, we propose three adaptive control strategies based on Bayesian optimization. The first and foundational algorithm is the safeOpt algorithm, and the two adaptations that have been made are stageOpt and shrinkAlgo. The Gaussian Process Regressor (GPR) is employed to approximate both the objective and constraint functions, with continuous updates occurring during iterations. The algorithms also enable the transfer of knowledge obtained from one operating point to another, thereby reducing the number of iterations needed to reach the optimal point. We demonstrate the effectiveness of the algorithms both numerically and through two distinct experimental validations. In the numerical demonstration, we employ a low-order thermoacoustic network model to simulate a single-stage combustor setup equipped with loudspeaker actuation and a gain-delay ($n-τ$) controller for active stabilization. The first experimental demonstration has the same structure as the numerical case. For the second experimental validation, we apply the framework to a sequential combustor configuration utilizing nanosecond repetitively pulsed discharges (NRPD) as the control actuator. This demonstrates the framework's adaptability to various control actuation methods in turbulent combustors where control parameter optimization is required.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Smooth transformations and ruling out closed orbits in planar systems
Authors:
Tiemo Pedergnana,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
This work deals with planar dynamical systems with and without noise. In the first part, we seek to gain a refined understanding of such systems by studying their differential-geometric transformation properties under an arbitrary smooth map**. Using elementary techniques, we obtain a unified picture of different classes of dynamical systems, some of which are classically viewed as distinct. We…
▽ More
This work deals with planar dynamical systems with and without noise. In the first part, we seek to gain a refined understanding of such systems by studying their differential-geometric transformation properties under an arbitrary smooth map**. Using elementary techniques, we obtain a unified picture of different classes of dynamical systems, some of which are classically viewed as distinct. We specifically give two examples of Hamiltonian systems with first integrals, which are simultaneously gradient systems. Potential applications of this apparent duality are discussed. The second part of this study is concerned with ruling out closed orbits in steady planar systems. We reformulate Bendixson's criterion using the coordinate-independent Helmholtz decomposition derived in the first part, and we derive another, similar criterion. Our results allow for automated ruling out of closed orbits in certain regions of phase space, and could be used in the future for efficient seeding of initial conditions in numerical algorithms to detect periodic solutions.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2023; v1 submitted 5 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Thermoacoustic Stabilization of a Sequential Combustor with Ultra-low-power Nanosecond Repetitively Pulsed Discharges
Authors:
Bayu Dharmaputra,
Sergey Shcherbanev,
Bruno Schuermans,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
This study demonstrates the stabilization of a sequential combustor with Nanosecond Repetitively Pulsed Discharges (NRPD). A constant pressure sequential combustor offers key advantages compared to a conventional combustor, in particular, a higher fuel flexibility and a wider operational range. However, thermoacoustic instabilities remain a barrier to further widen the operational range of these c…
▽ More
This study demonstrates the stabilization of a sequential combustor with Nanosecond Repetitively Pulsed Discharges (NRPD). A constant pressure sequential combustor offers key advantages compared to a conventional combustor, in particular, a higher fuel flexibility and a wider operational range. However, thermoacoustic instabilities remain a barrier to further widen the operational range of these combustors. Passive control strategies to suppress these instabilities, such as Helmholtz dampers, have been used in some industrial systems thanks to their simplicity in terms of implementation. Active control strategies are however not found in practical combustors, mainly due to the lack of robust actuators able to operate in harsh conditions with sufficient control authority. In this study, we demonstrate that thermoacoustic instabilities can be suppressed by using a non-equilibrium plasma produced with NRPD in a lab-scale atmospheric sequential combustor operated at 73.4 kW of thermal power. We employ continuous NRPD forcing to influence the combustion process in the sequential combustor. The two governing parameters are the pulse repetition frequency (PRF) and the plasma generator voltage. We examine the effect of both parameters on the acoustic amplitude, the NO emissions, and the flame centre of mass. We observe that for some operating conditions, with plasma power of 1.1 W, which is about 1.5$\times$ $10^{-3}$ percent of the thermal power of the flames, the combustor can be thermoacoustically stabilized. This finding motivates further research on the optimization of the plasma parameters as a function of the thermoacoustic properties of the combustor where it is applied. This study is a pioneering effort in controlling the thermoacoustic stability of turbulent flames with plasma discharges at such low power compared to the thermal power of the sequential combustor.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Numerical study of nitrogen oxides chemistry during plasma assisted combustion in a sequential combustor
Authors:
Quentin Malé,
Nicolas Barléon,
Sergey Shcherbanev,
Bayu Dharmaputra,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
Plasma Assisted Combustion (PAC) is a promising technology to enhance the combustion of lean mixtures prone to instabilities and flame blow-off. Although many PAC experiments demonstrated combustion enhancement, several studies report an increase in NOx emissions. The aim of this study is to determine the kinetic pathways leading to NOx formation in the second stage of a sequential combustor assis…
▽ More
Plasma Assisted Combustion (PAC) is a promising technology to enhance the combustion of lean mixtures prone to instabilities and flame blow-off. Although many PAC experiments demonstrated combustion enhancement, several studies report an increase in NOx emissions. The aim of this study is to determine the kinetic pathways leading to NOx formation in the second stage of a sequential combustor assisted by Nanosecond Repetitively Pulsed Discharges (NRPDs). For this purpose, Large Eddy Simulation (LES) associated with an accurate description of the combustion/NOx chemistry and a phenomenological model of the plasma kinetics is used. Detailed kinetics 0-Dimensional reactors complement the study. First, the LES setup is validated by comparison with experiments. Then, the NOx chemistry is analyzed. For the conditions of operation studied, it is shown that the production of atomic nitrogen in the plasma by direct electron impact on nitrogen molecules increases the formation of NO. Then, the NO molecules are transported through the turbulent flame without being strongly affected. This study illustrates the need to limit the diatomic nitrogen dissociation process in order to mitigate harmful emissions. More generally, the very good agreement with experimental measurements demonstrates the capability of LES combined with accurate models to predict the NRPD effects on both turbulent combustion and NOx emissions.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Numerical study of ignition and combustion of hydrogen-enriched methane in a sequential combustor
Authors:
Matteo Impagnatiello,
Quentin Malé,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
Ignition and combustion behavior in the second stage of a sequential combustor are investigated numerically at atmospheric pressure for pure CH4 fueling and for a CH4/H2 fuel blend in 24:1 mass ratio using Large Eddy Simulation (LES). Pure CH4 fueling results in a turbulent propagating flame anchored by the hot gas recirculation zone developed near the inlet of the sequential combustion chamber. C…
▽ More
Ignition and combustion behavior in the second stage of a sequential combustor are investigated numerically at atmospheric pressure for pure CH4 fueling and for a CH4/H2 fuel blend in 24:1 mass ratio using Large Eddy Simulation (LES). Pure CH4 fueling results in a turbulent propagating flame anchored by the hot gas recirculation zone developed near the inlet of the sequential combustion chamber. Conversely, CH4/H2 fueling results in a drastic change of the combustion process, with multiple auto-ignition kernels produced upstream of the main flame brush. Chemical Explosive Mode Analysis indicates that, when H2 is added, flame stabilization in the combustion chamber is strongly supported by auto-ignition chemistry. The analysis of fuel decomposition pathways highlights that radicals advected from the first stage flame, in particular OH, induce a rapid fuel decomposition and cause the reactivity enhancement that leads to auto-ignition upstream of the sequential flame. This behavior is promoted by the relatively large mass fraction of OH radicals found in the flow reaching the second stage, which is approximately one order of magnitude greater than it would be at chemical equilibrium. The importance of the out-of-equilibrium vitiated air on the ignition behavior is proven via an additional LES that features weak auto-ignition kernel formation when equilibrium is artificially imposed. It is concluded, therefore, that parameters affecting the relaxation towards chemical equilibrium of the vitiated flow can have an important influence on the operability of sequential combustors fueled with varying fractions of H2 blending.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Exact potentials in multivariate Langevin equations
Authors:
Tiemo Pedergnana,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
Systems governed by a multivariate Langevin equation featuring an exact potential exhibit straightforward dynamics but are often difficult to recognize because, after a general coordinate change, the gradient flow becomes obscured by the Jacobian matrix of the map**. In this work, a detailed analysis of the transformation properties of Langevin equations under general nonlinear map**s is prese…
▽ More
Systems governed by a multivariate Langevin equation featuring an exact potential exhibit straightforward dynamics but are often difficult to recognize because, after a general coordinate change, the gradient flow becomes obscured by the Jacobian matrix of the map**. In this work, a detailed analysis of the transformation properties of Langevin equations under general nonlinear map**s is presented. We show how to identify systems with exact potentials by understanding their differential-geometric properties. To demonstrate the power of our method, we use it to derive exact potentials for broadly studied models of nonlinear deterministic and stochastic oscillations. In selected examples, we visualize the identified potentials. Our results imply a broad class of exactly solvable stochastic models which can be self-consistently defined from given deterministic gradient systems.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2022; v1 submitted 4 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Superradiant Scattering from Nonlinear Wave-Mode Coupling
Authors:
Tiemo Pedergnana,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
Waves scattered at a self-oscillating mode can exhibit superradiance, or net amplification of an external harmonic excitation. This exotic behavior, arising from the nonlinear coupling between the mode and the incident wave, is theoretically predicted and experimentally confirmed for the first time in this work. We propose a generic theory of nonlinear wave-mode coupling, which is derived in analo…
▽ More
Waves scattered at a self-oscillating mode can exhibit superradiance, or net amplification of an external harmonic excitation. This exotic behavior, arising from the nonlinear coupling between the mode and the incident wave, is theoretically predicted and experimentally confirmed for the first time in this work. We propose a generic theory of nonlinear wave-mode coupling, which is derived in analogy to the temporal coupled-mode theory of [Fan et al., J. Opt. Soc. Am. A 20, 569 (2003)]. A well-reproducible aeroacoustic realization of a superradiant scatterer was used to test the theory's predictions. It is shown that the nonlinear wave-mode coupling can be exploited to quasi-passively tune the reflection and transmission coefficients of a side cavity in a waveguide. The theoretical framework used to describe this type of superradiance is applicable to non-acoustic systems and may be used to design lossless scattering devices.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2023; v1 submitted 21 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Steady State Statistics of Emergent Patterns in a Ring of Oscillators
Authors:
Tiemo Pedergnana,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
Networks of coupled nonlinear oscillators model a broad class of physical, chemical and biological systems. Understanding emergent patterns in such networks is an ongoing effort with profound implications for different fields. In this work, we analytically and numerically study a symmetric ring of N coupled self-oscillators of Van der Pol type under external stochastic forcing. The system is propo…
▽ More
Networks of coupled nonlinear oscillators model a broad class of physical, chemical and biological systems. Understanding emergent patterns in such networks is an ongoing effort with profound implications for different fields. In this work, we analytically and numerically study a symmetric ring of N coupled self-oscillators of Van der Pol type under external stochastic forcing. The system is proposed as a model of the thermo- and aeroacoustic interactions of sound fields in rigid enclosures with compact source regions in a can-annular combustor. The oscillators are connected via linear resistive coupling with nonlinear saturation. After transforming the system to amplitude-phase coordinates, deterministic and stochastic averaging is performed to eliminate the fast oscillating terms. By projecting the potential of the slow-flow dynamics onto the phase-locked quasi-limit cycle solutions, we obtain a compact, low-order description of the (de-)synchronization transition for an arbitrary number of oscillators. The stationary probability density function of the state variables is derived from the Fokker--Planck equation, studied for varying parameter values and compared to time series simulations. We leverage our analysis to offer explanations for features of acoustic pressure spectrograms observed in real-world gas turbines.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Dynamics of azimuthal thermoacoustic modes in imperfectly symmetric annular geometries
Authors:
Thomas Indlekofer,
Abel Faure-Beaulieu,
James R. Dawson,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
Using a nominally symmetric annular combustor, we present experimental evidence of a predicted spontaneous symmetry breaking and an unexpected explicit symmetry breaking in the neighborhood of the Hopf bifurcation, which separates linearly-stable azimuthal thermoacoustic modes from self-oscillating modes. We derive and solve a multidimensional Fokker-Planck equation to unravel a unified picture of…
▽ More
Using a nominally symmetric annular combustor, we present experimental evidence of a predicted spontaneous symmetry breaking and an unexpected explicit symmetry breaking in the neighborhood of the Hopf bifurcation, which separates linearly-stable azimuthal thermoacoustic modes from self-oscillating modes. We derive and solve a multidimensional Fokker-Planck equation to unravel a unified picture of the phase space topology. We demonstrate that symmetric probability density functions of the thermoacoustic state vector are elusive, because the effect of asymmetries, even imperceptible ones, is magnified close to the bifurcation.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Coupling-Induced Instability in a Ring of Thermoacoustic Oscillators
Authors:
Tiemo Pedergnana,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
Thermoacoustic instabilities in can-annular combustors of stationary gas turbines lead to unstable Bloch modes which appear as rotating acoustic pressure waves along the turbine annulus. The multi-scale, multiphysical nature of the full problem makes a detailed analysis challenging. In this work, we derive a low-order, coupled oscillator model of an idealized can-annular combustor. The unimodal pr…
▽ More
Thermoacoustic instabilities in can-annular combustors of stationary gas turbines lead to unstable Bloch modes which appear as rotating acoustic pressure waves along the turbine annulus. The multi-scale, multiphysical nature of the full problem makes a detailed analysis challenging. In this work, we derive a low-order, coupled oscillator model of an idealized can-annular combustor. The unimodal projection of the Helmholtz equation for the can acoustics is combined with the Rayleigh conductivity, which describes the aeroacoustic coupling between neighboring cans. Using a Bloch-wave ansatz, the resulting system is reduced to a single equation for the frequency spectrum. A linear stability analysis is then performed to study the perturbation of the spectrum by the can-to-can interaction. It is observed that the acoustic coupling can suppress or amplify thermoacoustic instabilities, raising the potential for instabilities in nominally stable systems.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2021; v1 submitted 16 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Modeling the nonlinear aeroacoustic response of a harmonically forced side branch aperture under turbulent grazing flow
Authors:
Tiemo Pedergnana,
Claire Bourquard,
Abel Faure-Beaulieu,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
Hydrodynamic modes in the turbulent mixing layer over a cavity can constructively interact with the acoustic modes of that cavity and lead to aeroacoustic instabilities. The resulting limit cycles can cause undesired structural vibrations or noise pollution in many industrial applications. To further the predictive understanding of this phenomenon, we propose two physics-based models which describ…
▽ More
Hydrodynamic modes in the turbulent mixing layer over a cavity can constructively interact with the acoustic modes of that cavity and lead to aeroacoustic instabilities. The resulting limit cycles can cause undesired structural vibrations or noise pollution in many industrial applications. To further the predictive understanding of this phenomenon, we propose two physics-based models which describe the nonlinear aeroacoustic response of a side branch aperture under harmonic forcing with variable acoustic pressure forcing amplitude pa. One model is based on Howe's classic vortex sheet formulation, and the other on an assumed vertical velocity profile in the side branch aperture. These models are validated against experimental data. Particle image velocimetry (PIV) was performed to quantify the turbulent and coherent fluctuations of the shear layer under increasing pa. The specific acoustic impedance Z of the aperture was acquired over a range of frequencies f for different bulk flow velocities U and acoustic pressure forcing amplitudes pa. We show that, once the handful of parameters in the two models for Z have been calibrated using experimental data at a given condition, it is possible to make robust analytical predictions of this impedance over a broad range of f, U and pa. In particular, the models allow prediction of a necessary condition for instability, implied by negative values of the acoustic resistance Re(Z). Furthermore, we demonstrate that the models are able to describe the nonlinear saturation of the aeroacoustic response caused by alteration of the mean flow at large forcing amplitudes, which was recently reported in literature. This effect stabilizes the coupling between the side branch opening and the acoustic field in the cavity, and its quantitative description may be of value for control of aeroacoustic instabilities.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2021; v1 submitted 11 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Symmetry breaking of azimuthal waves: Slow-flow dynamics on the Bloch Sphere
Authors:
Abel Faure Beaulieu,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
Depending on the reflectional and rotational symmetries of annular combustors for aeroengines and gas turbines, self-sustained azimuthal thermoacoustic eigenmodes can be standing, spinning or mix of these two types of waves. These thermoacoustic limit cycles are unwanted because the resulting intense acoustic fields induce high-cycle fatigue of the combustor components. This paper presents a new t…
▽ More
Depending on the reflectional and rotational symmetries of annular combustors for aeroengines and gas turbines, self-sustained azimuthal thermoacoustic eigenmodes can be standing, spinning or mix of these two types of waves. These thermoacoustic limit cycles are unwanted because the resulting intense acoustic fields induce high-cycle fatigue of the combustor components. This paper presents a new theoretical framework for describing, in an idealized annular combustor, the dynamics of the slow-flow variables, which define the state of an eigenmode, i.e. if the latter is standing, spinning or mixed. The acoustic pressure is expressed as a hypercomplex field and this ansatz is inserted into a one dimensional wave equation that describes the thermoacoustics of a thin annulus. Slow-flow averaging of this wave equation is performed by adapting the classic Krylov-Bogoliubov method to the quaternion field in order to derive a system of coupled first order differential equations for the four slow-flow variables, i.e. the amplitude, the nature angle, the preferential direction and the temporal phase of the azimuthal thermoacoustic mode. The state of the mode can be conveniently depicted by using the first three slow-flow variables as spherical coordinates for a Bloch sphere representation. Stochastic forcing from the turbulence in annular combustors is also accounted for. This new analytical model describes both rotational and reflectional symmetry breaking bifurcations induced by the non-uniform distribution of thermoacoustic sources along the annulus circumference and by the presence of a mean swirl.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2020; v1 submitted 7 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Bifurcation Dodge: Avoidance of a Thermoacoustic Instability under Transient Operation
Authors:
Giacomo Bonciolini,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
Varying one of the governing parameters of a dynamical system may lead to a critical transition, where the new stable state is undesirable. In some cases, there is only a limited range of the bifurcation parameter that corresponds to that unwanted attractor, while the system runs problem-less otherwise. In this study, we present experimental results regarding a thermoacoustic system subject to two…
▽ More
Varying one of the governing parameters of a dynamical system may lead to a critical transition, where the new stable state is undesirable. In some cases, there is only a limited range of the bifurcation parameter that corresponds to that unwanted attractor, while the system runs problem-less otherwise. In this study, we present experimental results regarding a thermoacoustic system subject to two consecutive and mirrored supercritical Hopf bifurcations: the system exhibits high amplitude thermoacoustic limit cycles for intermediate values of the bifurcation parameter. Changing quickly enough the bifurcation parameter, it was possible to dodge the unwanted limit cycles. A low-order model of the complex thermoacoustic system was developed, in order to describe this interesting transient dynamics. It was afterward used to assess the risk of exceeding an oscillation amplitude threshold as a function of the rate of change of the bifurcation parameter.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Combustion regimes in sequential combustors: Flame propagation and autoignition at elevated temperature and pressure
Authors:
Oliver Schulz,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
This numerical study investigates the combustion modes in the second stage of a sequential combustor at atmospheric and high pressure. The sequential burner (SB) features a mixing section with fuel injection into a hot vitiated crossflow. Depending on the dominant combustion mode, a recirculation zone assists flame anchoring in the combustion chamber. The flame is located sufficiently downstream o…
▽ More
This numerical study investigates the combustion modes in the second stage of a sequential combustor at atmospheric and high pressure. The sequential burner (SB) features a mixing section with fuel injection into a hot vitiated crossflow. Depending on the dominant combustion mode, a recirculation zone assists flame anchoring in the combustion chamber. The flame is located sufficiently downstream of the injector resulting in partially premixed conditions. First, combustion regime maps are obtained from 0-D and 1-D simulations showing the co-existence of three combustion modes: autoignition, flame propagation and flame propagation assisted by autoignition. These regime maps can be used to understand the combustion modes at play in turbulent sequential combustors, as shown with 3-D large eddy simulations (LES) with semi-detailed chemistry. In addition to the simulation of steady-state combustion at three different operating conditions, transient simulations are performed: (i) ignition of the combustor with autoignition as the dominant mode, (ii) ignition that is initiated by autoignition and that is followed by a transition to a propagation stabilized flame, and (iii) a transient change of the inlet temperature (decrease by 150 K) resulting into a change of the combustion regime. These results show the importance of the recirculation zone for the ignition and the anchoring of a propagating type flame. On the contrary, the autoignition flame stabilizes due to continuous self-ignition of the mixture and the recirculation zone does not play an important role for the flame anchoring.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Stabilization of acoustic modes using Helmholtz and Quarter-Wave resonators tuned at exceptional points
Authors:
Claire Bourquard,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
Acoustic dampers are efficient and cost-effective means for suppressing thermoacoustic instabilities in combustion chambers. However, their design and the choice of their purging air mass flow is a challenging task, when one aims at ensuring thermoacoustic stability after their implementation. In the present experimental and theoretical study, Helmholtz (HH) and Quarter-Wave (QW) dampers are consi…
▽ More
Acoustic dampers are efficient and cost-effective means for suppressing thermoacoustic instabilities in combustion chambers. However, their design and the choice of their purging air mass flow is a challenging task, when one aims at ensuring thermoacoustic stability after their implementation. In the present experimental and theoretical study, Helmholtz (HH) and Quarter-Wave (QW) dampers are considered. A model for their acoustic impedance is derived and experimentally validated. In a second part, a thermoacoustic instability is mimicked by an electro-acoustic feedback loop in a rectangular cavity, to which the dampers are added. The length of the dampers can be adjusted, so that the system can be studied for tuned and detuned conditions. The stability of the coupled system is investigated experimentally and then analytically, which shows that for tuned dampers, the best stabilization is achieved at the exceptional point. The stabilization capabilities of HH and QW dampers are compared for given damper volume and purge mass flow.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2018; v1 submitted 23 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Processing time-series of randomly forced self-oscillators: the example of beer bottle whistling
Authors:
E. Boujo,
C. Bourquard,
Y. Xiong,
N. Noiray
Abstract:
We present a model-based, output-only parameter identification method for self-sustained oscillators forced by dynamic noise, which we illustrate experimentally with an aeroacoustic setup: a turbulent jet im**ing a beer bottle and producing a whistling tone in a finite range of jet angles and velocities. Given a low-order model of the system, the identification analyzes stationary time series of…
▽ More
We present a model-based, output-only parameter identification method for self-sustained oscillators forced by dynamic noise, which we illustrate experimentally with an aeroacoustic setup: a turbulent jet im**ing a beer bottle and producing a whistling tone in a finite range of jet angles and velocities. Given a low-order model of the system, the identification analyzes stationary time series of a single observable: acoustic pressure fluctuations in the bottle. As this observable exhibits the characteristics of weakly non-linear self-oscillations, we choose as a minimal model the Van der Pol (VdP) oscillator: a linear acoustic oscillator (bottle) subject to stochastic forcing and non-linear deterministic forcing (turbulent jet). Although very simple, the VdP oscillator driven by random noise proves to be a sufficient phenomenological description of the aeroacoustic limit cycle for model-based linear growth rate identification. The associated stochastic amplitude equation allows us to describe the stochastic fluctuations of the acoustic amplitude resulting from a competition between (i) linear growth rate from the coherent unsteady vortex force, (ii) random forcing from the turbulence, (iii) non-linear saturation of the coherent flap** of the jet. Finally, the associated adjoint Fokker-Planck equation reveals the deterministic potential well and the stochastic forcing intensity governing these random fluctuations. Additional experiments with an external control validate the identification results. We observe that different operating conditions can yield similar statistics but different dynamics, showing that the identification method can disentangle deterministic and stochastic effects in systems forced stochastically. This output-only identification approach can be used in a wide range of phenomena exhibiting stationary self-sustained oscillations in the presence of random forcing.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2019; v1 submitted 8 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Effect of wall thermal inertia upon transient thermoacoustic dynamics of a swirl-stabilized flame
Authors:
Giacomo Bonciolini,
Dominik Ebi,
Ulrich Doll,
Markus Weilenmann,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
This paper shows the importance of considering the thermal state of a combustor to investigate or predict its thermoacoustic stability. This aspect is often neglected or regarded as less important than the effect of the operating parameters, such as thermal power or equivalence ratio, but under certain circumstances it can have a dramatic influence on the development of the instabilities. The pape…
▽ More
This paper shows the importance of considering the thermal state of a combustor to investigate or predict its thermoacoustic stability. This aspect is often neglected or regarded as less important than the effect of the operating parameters, such as thermal power or equivalence ratio, but under certain circumstances it can have a dramatic influence on the development of the instabilities. The paper presents experimental results collected from a combustor featuring a lean swirl-stabilized flame exhibiting thermoacoustic instability at some operating conditions. It is shown that this instability is caused by a change of the flame topology that is induced by the progressive increase of the wall temperature with the thermal power. This dependence of the instability on wall temperature leads to inertial effects and hysteresis when the operating condition is changed dynamically. A low-order model of the system reproducing this remarkable dynamics is proposed and validated against the experimental data.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Experiments and modelling of rate-dependent transition delay in a stochastic subcritical bifurcation
Authors:
Giacomo Bonciolini,
Dominik Ebi,
Edouard Boujo,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
Complex systems exhibiting critical transitions when one of their governing parameters varies are ubiquitous in nature and in engineering applications. Despite a vast literature focusing on this topic, there are few studies dealing with the effect of the rate of change of the bifurcation parameter on the tip** points. In this work, we consider a subcritical stochastic Hopf bifurcation under two…
▽ More
Complex systems exhibiting critical transitions when one of their governing parameters varies are ubiquitous in nature and in engineering applications. Despite a vast literature focusing on this topic, there are few studies dealing with the effect of the rate of change of the bifurcation parameter on the tip** points. In this work, we consider a subcritical stochastic Hopf bifurcation under two scenarios: the bifurcation parameter is first changed in a quasi-steady manner and then, with a finite ram** rate. In the latter case, a rate-dependent bifurcation delay is observed and exemplified experimentally using a thermoacoustic instability in a combustion chamber. This delay increases with the rate of change. This leads to a state transition of larger amplitude compared to the one that would be experienced by the system with a quasi-steady change of the parameter. We also bring experimental evidence of a dynamic hysteresis caused by the bifurcation delay when the parameter is ramped back. A surrogate model is derived in order to predict the statistic of these delays and to scrutinise the underlying stochastic dynamics. Our study highlights the dramatic influence of a finite rate of change of bifurcation parameters upon tip** points and it pinpoints the crucial need of considering this effect when investigating critical transitions.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Saturation of a turbulent mixing layer over a cavity: response to harmonic forcing around mean flows
Authors:
Edouard Boujo,
Michael Bauerheim,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
Turbulent mixing layers over cavities can couple with acoustic waves and lead to undesired oscillations. To understand the nonlinear aspects of this phenomenon, a turbulent mixing layer over a deep cavity at Reynolds number 150 000 is considered and its response to harmonic forcing is analysed with large-eddy simulations (LES) and linearised Navier-Stokes equations (LNSE). As a model of incoming a…
▽ More
Turbulent mixing layers over cavities can couple with acoustic waves and lead to undesired oscillations. To understand the nonlinear aspects of this phenomenon, a turbulent mixing layer over a deep cavity at Reynolds number 150 000 is considered and its response to harmonic forcing is analysed with large-eddy simulations (LES) and linearised Navier-Stokes equations (LNSE). As a model of incoming acoustic perturbations, spatially uniform time-harmonic forcing is applied at the cavity end, with amplitudes in the wide range 0.045-8.9% of the bulk velocity. Compressible LES provide reference nonlinear responses of the shear layer, and the associated mean flows. Linear responses are calculated with the incompressible LNSE around the LES mean flows; they predict well the amplification (both measured with kinetic energy and with a proxy for vortex sound production) and capture the nonlinear saturation observed as the forcing amplitude increases and the mixing layer thickens. Perhaps surprisingly, LNSE calculations based on a monochromatic (single frequency) assumption yield a good agreement even though higher harmonics and their nonlinear interaction (Reynolds stresses) are not negligible. However, the leading Reynolds stresses do not force the mixing layer efficiently, as shown by a comparison with the optimal volume forcing obtained in a resolvent analysis. Thus, they cannot fully benefit from the potential for amplification available in the flow. Finally, the sensitivity of the optimal harmonic forcing at the cavity end is computed with an adjoint method. The sensitivities to mean flow modification and to a localised feedback (structural sensitivity) both identify the upstream cavity corner as the region where a small-amplitude modification has the strongest effect. This can guide in a systematic way the design of strategies for the control of amplification and saturation mechanisms.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Output-only parameter identification of a colored-noise-driven Van der Pol oscillator -- Thermoacoustic instabilities as an example
Authors:
Giacomo Bonciolini,
Edouard Boujo,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
The problem of output-only parameter identification for nonlinear oscillators forced by colored noise is considered. In this context, it is often assumed that the forcing noise is white, since its actual spectral content is unknown. The impact of this white noise forcing assumption upon parameter identification is quantitatively analyzed. First, a Van der Pol oscillator forced by an Ornstein-Uhlen…
▽ More
The problem of output-only parameter identification for nonlinear oscillators forced by colored noise is considered. In this context, it is often assumed that the forcing noise is white, since its actual spectral content is unknown. The impact of this white noise forcing assumption upon parameter identification is quantitatively analyzed. First, a Van der Pol oscillator forced by an Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process is considered. Second, the practical case of thermoacoustic limit cycles in combustion chambers with turbulence-induced forcing is investigated. It is shown that in both cases, the system parameters are accurately identified if time signals are appropriately band-pass filtered around the oscillator eigenfrequency.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Quantifying acoustic dam** using flame chemiluminescence
Authors:
Edouard Boujo,
Alexey Denisov,
Bruno Schuermans,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
Thermoacoustic instabilities in gas turbines and aeroengine combustors falls within the category of complex systems. They can be described phenomenologically using nonlinear stochastic differential equations, which constitute the grounds for output-only model-based system identification. It has been shown recently that one can extract the governing parameters of the instabilities, namely the linea…
▽ More
Thermoacoustic instabilities in gas turbines and aeroengine combustors falls within the category of complex systems. They can be described phenomenologically using nonlinear stochastic differential equations, which constitute the grounds for output-only model-based system identification. It has been shown recently that one can extract the governing parameters of the instabilities, namely the linear growth rate and the nonlinear component of the thermoacoustic feedback, using dynamic pressure time series only. This is highly relevant for practical systems, which cannot be actively controlled due to a lack of cost-effective actuators. The thermoacoustic stability is given by the linear growth rate, which results from the combination of the acoustic dam** and the coherent feedback from the flame. In this paper, it is shown that it is possible to quantify the acoustic dam** of the system, and thus to separate its contribution to the linear growth rate from the one of the flame. This is achieved by post-processing in a simple way simultaneously acquired chemiluminescence and acoustic pressure data. It provides an additional approach to further unravel from observed time series the key mechanisms governing the system dynamics. This straightforward method is illustrated here using experimental data from a combustion chamber operated at several linearly stable and unstable operating conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Robust identification of harmonic oscillator parameters using the adjoint Fokker-Planck equation
Authors:
Edouard Boujo,
Nicolas Noiray
Abstract:
We present a model-based output-only method for identifying from time series the parameters governing the dynamics of stochastically forced oscillators. In this context, suitable models of the oscillator's dam** and stiffness properties are postulated, guided by physical understanding of the oscillatory phenomena. The temporal dynamics and the probability density function of the oscillation ampl…
▽ More
We present a model-based output-only method for identifying from time series the parameters governing the dynamics of stochastically forced oscillators. In this context, suitable models of the oscillator's dam** and stiffness properties are postulated, guided by physical understanding of the oscillatory phenomena. The temporal dynamics and the probability density function of the oscillation amplitude are described by a Langevin equation and its associated Fokker-Planck equation, respectively. One method consists in fitting the postulated analytical drift and diffusion coefficients with their estimated values, obtained from data processing by taking the short-time limit of the first two transition moments. However, this limit estimation loses robustness in some situations - for instance when the data is band-pass filtered to isolate the spectral contents of the oscillatory phenomena of interest. In this paper, we use a robust alternative where the adjoint Fokker-Planck equation is solved to compute Kramers-Moyal coefficients exactly, and an iterative optimisation yields the parameters that best fit the observed statistics simultaneously in a wide range of amplitudes and time scales. The method is illustrated with a stochastic Van der Pol oscillator serving as a prototypical model of thermoacoustic instabilities in practical combustors, where system identification is highly relevant to control.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
