Monte Carlo calculation of organ and effective dose rates from ground contaminated by Am 241: Results of an international intercomparison exercise
Authors:
J Eakins,
C Huet,
H Brkić,
K Capello,
L Desorgher,
L Epstein,
J G Hunt,
H S Kim,
D Krstic,
Y-K Lee,
M Manohari,
D Nikezic,
R H Shukrun,
D. Souza-Santos,
K. Tymińska
Abstract:
An intercomparison exercise is described that examines Monte Carlo modelling of anthropomorphic voxel phantoms in an idealized ground-contamination photon exposure scenario. Thirteen participants calculated and submitted organ and effective dose rates for comparison against a set of verified reference solutions. The effective dose rates are shown to agree with the reference value to within reasona…
▽ More
An intercomparison exercise is described that examines Monte Carlo modelling of anthropomorphic voxel phantoms in an idealized ground-contamination photon exposure scenario. Thirteen participants calculated and submitted organ and effective dose rates for comparison against a set of verified reference solutions. The effective dose rates are shown to agree with the reference value to within reasonable statistical uncertainties in five of the cases, though in only one of those was similar agreement also demonstrated in the evaluation of all requested organ dose rates. Orders-of-magnitude differences in doses are seen for some of the other participants, both internally within their own dataset and also relative to the reference solutions. Following limited feedback and suggestions from the organizer, up to two sets of revised solutions were resubmitted by some of the participants; these generally exhibited improved agreement, though not always. The overall observations and conclusions from this intercomparison exercise are summarized and discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
Monte Carlo calculation of the organ equivalent dose and effective dose due to immersion in a 16N beta source in air using the ICRP Reference Phantoms
Authors:
Jose M. Gomez-Ros,
Montserrat Moraleda,
Pedro Arce,
Duc-Ky Bui,
Thi-My-Linh Dang,
Laurent Desorgher,
Han Sung Kim,
Dragana Krstic,
Michal Kuc,
Ngoc-Thiem Le,
Yi-Kang Lee,
Ngoc-Quynh Nguyen,
Dragoslav Nikezic,
Katarzyna Tyminska,
Tomas Vrba
Abstract:
This work summarises the results of a comparison organized by EURADOS focused on the usage of the ICRP Reference Computational Phantoms. This activity aimed to provide training for the implementation of voxel phantoms in Monte Carlo radiation transport codes and the calculation of the dose equivalent in organs and the effective dose. This particular case describes a scenario of immersion in a 16N…
▽ More
This work summarises the results of a comparison organized by EURADOS focused on the usage of the ICRP Reference Computational Phantoms. This activity aimed to provide training for the implementation of voxel phantoms in Monte Carlo radiation transport codes and the calculation of the dose equivalent in organs and the effective dose. This particular case describes a scenario of immersion in a 16N beta source distributed in the air of a room with concrete walls where the phantom is located. Seven participants took part in the comparison of results using GEANT4, TRIPOLI-4 and MCNP family codes, and there was detected a general problem when calculating the dose to skeletal tissue and the remainder tissue. After a process of feedback with the participants the errors were corrected and the final results reached an agreement of +/-5%.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
