-
Normative brain map** of 3-dimensional morphometry imaging data using skewed functional data analysis
Authors:
Marco Palma,
Shahin Tavakoli,
Julia Brettschneider,
Ana-Maria Staicu,
Thomas E. Nichols
Abstract:
Tensor-based morphometry (TBM) aims at showing local differences in brain volumes with respect to a common template. TBM images are smooth but they exhibit (especially in diseased groups) higher values in some brain regions called lateral ventricles. More specifically, our voxelwise analysis shows both a mean-variance relationship in these areas and evidence of spatially dependent skewness. We pro…
▽ More
Tensor-based morphometry (TBM) aims at showing local differences in brain volumes with respect to a common template. TBM images are smooth but they exhibit (especially in diseased groups) higher values in some brain regions called lateral ventricles. More specifically, our voxelwise analysis shows both a mean-variance relationship in these areas and evidence of spatially dependent skewness. We propose a model for 3-dimensional functional data where mean, variance, and skewness functions vary smoothly across brain locations. We model the voxelwise distributions as skew-normal. The smooth effects of age and sex are estimated on a reference population of cognitively normal subjects from the Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI) dataset and mapped across the whole brain. The three parameter functions allow to transform each TBM image (in the reference population as well as in a test set) into a Gaussian process. These subject-specific normative maps are used to derive indices of deviation from a healthy condition to assess the individual risk of pathological degeneration.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Scalable Bayesian Image-on-Scalar Regression for Population-Scale Neuroimaging Data Analysis
Authors:
Yuliang Xu,
Timothy D. Johnson,
Thomas E. Nichols,
Jian Kang
Abstract:
Bayesian Image-on-Scalar Regression (ISR) offers significant advantages for neuroimaging data analysis, including flexibility and the ability to quantify uncertainty. However, its application to large-scale imaging datasets, such as found in the UK Biobank, is hindered by the computational demands of traditional posterior computation methods, as well as the challenge of individual-specific brain m…
▽ More
Bayesian Image-on-Scalar Regression (ISR) offers significant advantages for neuroimaging data analysis, including flexibility and the ability to quantify uncertainty. However, its application to large-scale imaging datasets, such as found in the UK Biobank, is hindered by the computational demands of traditional posterior computation methods, as well as the challenge of individual-specific brain masks that deviate from the common mask typically used in standard ISR approaches. To address these challenges, we introduce a novel Bayesian ISR model that is scalable and accommodates inconsistent brain masks across subjects in large-scale imaging studies. Our model leverages Gaussian process priors and integrates salience area indicators to facilitate ISR. We develop a cutting-edge scalable posterior computation algorithm that employs stochastic gradient Langevin dynamics coupled with memory map** techniques, ensuring that computation time scales linearly with subsample size and memory usage is constrained only by the batch size. Our approach uniquely enables direct spatial posterior inferences on brain activation regions. The efficacy of our method is demonstrated through simulations and analysis of the UK Biobank task fMRI data, encompassing 38,639 subjects and over 120,000 voxels per image, showing that it can achieve a speed increase of 4 to 11 times and enhance statistical power by 8% to 18% compared to traditional Gibbs sampling with zero-imputation in various simulation scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2024; v1 submitted 19 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Scalable Scalar-on-Image Cortical Surface Regression with a Relaxed-Thresholded Gaussian Process Prior
Authors:
Anna Menacher,
Thomas E. Nichols,
Timothy D. Johnson,
Jian Kang
Abstract:
In addressing the challenge of analysing the large-scale Adolescent Brain Cognition Development (ABCD) fMRI dataset, involving over 5,000 subjects and extensive neuroimaging data, we propose a scalable Bayesian scalar-on-image regression model for computational feasibility and efficiency. Our model employs a relaxed-thresholded Gaussian process (RTGP), integrating piecewise-smooth, sparse, and con…
▽ More
In addressing the challenge of analysing the large-scale Adolescent Brain Cognition Development (ABCD) fMRI dataset, involving over 5,000 subjects and extensive neuroimaging data, we propose a scalable Bayesian scalar-on-image regression model for computational feasibility and efficiency. Our model employs a relaxed-thresholded Gaussian process (RTGP), integrating piecewise-smooth, sparse, and continuous functions capable of both hard- and soft-thresholding. This approach introduces additional flexibility in feature selection in scalar-on-image regression and leads to scalable posterior computation by adopting a variational approximation and utilising the Karhunen-Loève expansion for Gaussian processes. This advancement substantially reduces the computational costs in vertex-wise analysis of cortical surface data in large-scale Bayesian spatial models. The model's parameter estimation and prediction accuracy and feature selection performance are validated through extensive simulation studies and an application to the ABCD study. Here, we perform regression analysis correlating intelligence scores with task-based functional MRI data, taking into account confounding factors including age, sex, and parental education level. This validation highlights our model's capability to handle large-scale neuroimaging data while maintaining computational feasibility and accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
False Discovery Rate and Localizing Power
Authors:
Anderson M. Winkler,
Paul A. Taylor,
Thomas E. Nichols,
Chris Rorden
Abstract:
False discovery rate (FDR) is commonly used for correction for multiple testing in neuroimaging studies. However, when using two-tailed tests, making directional inferences about the results can lead to vastly inflated error rate, even approaching 100\% in some cases. This happens because FDR only provides weak control over the error rate, meaning that the proportion of error is guaranteed only gl…
▽ More
False discovery rate (FDR) is commonly used for correction for multiple testing in neuroimaging studies. However, when using two-tailed tests, making directional inferences about the results can lead to vastly inflated error rate, even approaching 100\% in some cases. This happens because FDR only provides weak control over the error rate, meaning that the proportion of error is guaranteed only globally over all tests, not within subsets, such as among those in only one or another direction. Here we consider and evaluate different strategies for FDR control with two-tailed tests, using both synthetic and real imaging data. Approaches that separate the tests by direction of the hypothesis test, or by the direction of the resulting test statistic, more properly control the directional error rate and preserve FDR benefits, albeit with a doubled risk of errors under complete absence of signal. Strategies that combine tests in both directions, or that use simple two-tailed p-values, can lead to invalid directional conclusions, even if these tests remain globally valid. To enable valid thresholding for directional inference, we suggest that imaging software should allow the possibility that the user sets asymmetrical thresholds for the two sides of the statistical map. While FDR continues to be a valid, powerful procedure for multiple testing correction, care is needed when making directional inferences for two-tailed tests, or more broadly, when making any localized inference.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Robust FWER control in Neuroimaging using Random Field Theory: Riding the SuRF to Continuous Land Part 2
Authors:
Samuel Davenport,
Armin Schwartzman,
Thomas E. Nichols,
Fabian J. E. Telschow
Abstract:
Historically, applications of RFT in fMRI have relied on assumptions of smoothness, stationarity and Gaussianity. The first two assumptions have been addressed in Part 1 of this article series. Here we address the severe non-Gaussianity of (real) fMRI data to greatly improve the performance of voxelwise RFT in fMRI group analysis. In particular, we introduce a transformation which accelerates the…
▽ More
Historically, applications of RFT in fMRI have relied on assumptions of smoothness, stationarity and Gaussianity. The first two assumptions have been addressed in Part 1 of this article series. Here we address the severe non-Gaussianity of (real) fMRI data to greatly improve the performance of voxelwise RFT in fMRI group analysis. In particular, we introduce a transformation which accelerates the convergence of the Central Limit Theorem allowing us to rely on limiting Gaussianity of the test-statistic. We shall show that, when the GKF is combined with the Gaussianization transformation, we are able to accurately estimate the EEC of the excursion set of the transformed test-statistic even when the data is non-Gaussian. This allows us to drop the key assumptions of RFT inference and enables us to provide a fast approach which correctly controls the voxelwise false positive rate in fMRI. We employ a big data \cite{Eklund2016} style validation in which we process resting state data from 7000 subjects from the UK BioBank with fake task designs. We resample from this data to create realistic noise and use this to demonstrate that the error rate is correctly controlled.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
The Past, Present, and Future of the Brain Imaging Data Structure (BIDS)
Authors:
Russell A. Poldrack,
Christopher J. Markiewicz,
Stefan Appelhoff,
Yoni K. Ashar,
Tibor Auer,
Sylvain Baillet,
Shashank Bansal,
Leandro Beltrachini,
Christian G. Benar,
Giacomo Bertazzoli,
Suyash Bhogawar,
Ross W. Blair,
Marta Bortoletto,
Mathieu Boudreau,
Teon L. Brooks,
Vince D. Calhoun,
Filippo Maria Castelli,
Patricia Clement,
Alexander L Cohen,
Julien Cohen-Adad,
Sasha D'Ambrosio,
Gilles de Hollander,
María de la iglesia-Vayá,
Alejandro de la Vega,
Arnaud Delorme
, et al. (89 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Brain Imaging Data Structure (BIDS) is a community-driven standard for the organization of data and metadata from a growing range of neuroscience modalities. This paper is meant as a history of how the standard has developed and grown over time. We outline the principles behind the project, the mechanisms by which it has been extended, and some of the challenges being addressed as it evolves.…
▽ More
The Brain Imaging Data Structure (BIDS) is a community-driven standard for the organization of data and metadata from a growing range of neuroscience modalities. This paper is meant as a history of how the standard has developed and grown over time. We outline the principles behind the project, the mechanisms by which it has been extended, and some of the challenges being addressed as it evolves. We also discuss the lessons learned through the project, with the aim of enabling researchers in other domains to learn from the success of BIDS.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2024; v1 submitted 11 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Neuroimaging Meta Regression for Coordinate Based Meta Analysis Data with a Spatial Model
Authors:
Yifan Yu,
Rosario Pintos Lobo,
Michael Cody Riedel,
Katherine Bottenhorn,
Angela R. Laird,
Thomas E. Nichols
Abstract:
Coordinate-based meta-analysis combines evidence from a collection of Neuroimaging studies to estimate brain activation. In such analyses, a key practical challenge is to find a computationally efficient approach with good statistical interpretability to model the locations of activation foci. In this article, we propose a generative coordinate-based meta-regression (CBMR) framework to approximate…
▽ More
Coordinate-based meta-analysis combines evidence from a collection of Neuroimaging studies to estimate brain activation. In such analyses, a key practical challenge is to find a computationally efficient approach with good statistical interpretability to model the locations of activation foci. In this article, we propose a generative coordinate-based meta-regression (CBMR) framework to approximate smooth activation intensity function and investigate the effect of study-level covariates (e.g., year of publication, sample size). We employ spline parameterization to model spatial structure of brain activation and consider four stochastic models for modelling the random variation in foci. To examine the validity of CBMR, we estimate brain activation on $20$ meta-analytic datasets, conduct spatial homogeneity tests at voxel level, and compare to results generated by existing kernel-based approaches.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Neuroscience needs Network Science
Authors:
Dániel L Barabási,
Ginestra Bianconi,
Ed Bullmore,
Mark Burgess,
SueYeon Chung,
Tina Eliassi-Rad,
Dileep George,
István A. Kovács,
Hernán Makse,
Christos Papadimitriou,
Thomas E. Nichols,
Olaf Sporns,
Kim Stachenfeld,
Zoltán Toroczkai,
Emma K. Towlson,
Anthony M Zador,
Hongkui Zeng,
Albert-László Barabási,
Amy Bernard,
György Buzsáki
Abstract:
The brain is a complex system comprising a myriad of interacting elements, posing significant challenges in understanding its structure, function, and dynamics. Network science has emerged as a powerful tool for studying such intricate systems, offering a framework for integrating multiscale data and complexity. Here, we discuss the application of network science in the study of the brain, address…
▽ More
The brain is a complex system comprising a myriad of interacting elements, posing significant challenges in understanding its structure, function, and dynamics. Network science has emerged as a powerful tool for studying such intricate systems, offering a framework for integrating multiscale data and complexity. Here, we discuss the application of network science in the study of the brain, addressing topics such as network models and metrics, the connectome, and the role of dynamics in neural networks. We explore the challenges and opportunities in integrating multiple data streams for understanding the neural transitions from development to healthy function to disease, and discuss the potential for collaboration between network science and neuroscience communities. We underscore the importance of fostering interdisciplinary opportunities through funding initiatives, workshops, and conferences, as well as supporting students and postdoctoral fellows with interests in both disciplines. By uniting the network science and neuroscience communities, we can develop novel network-based methods tailored to neural circuits, paving the way towards a deeper understanding of the brain and its functions.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2023; v1 submitted 10 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Cluster extent inference revisited: quantification and localization of brain activity
Authors:
Jelle J. Goeman,
Paweł\ Górecki,
Ramin Monajemi,
Xu Chen,
Thomas E. Nichols,
Wouter Weeda
Abstract:
Cluster inference based on spatial extent thresholding is the most popular analysis method for finding activated brain areas in neuroimaging. However, the method has several well-known issues. While powerful for finding brain regions with some activation, the method as currently defined does not allow any further quantification or localization of signal. In this paper we repair this gap. We show t…
▽ More
Cluster inference based on spatial extent thresholding is the most popular analysis method for finding activated brain areas in neuroimaging. However, the method has several well-known issues. While powerful for finding brain regions with some activation, the method as currently defined does not allow any further quantification or localization of signal. In this paper we repair this gap. We show that cluster-extent inference can be used (1.) to infer the presence of signal in anatomical regions of interest and (2.) to quantify the percentage of active voxels in any cluster or region of interest. These additional inferences come for free, i.e. they do not require any further adjustment of the alpha-level of tests, while retaining full familywise error control. We achieve this extension of the possibilities of cluster inference by an embedding of the method into a closed testing procedure, and solving the graph-theoretic k-separator problem that results from this embedding. The new method can be used in combination with random field theory or permutations. We demonstrate the usefulness of the method in a large-scale application to neuroimaging data from the Neurovault database.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Confidence regions for the location of peaks of a smooth random field
Authors:
Samuel Davenport,
Thomas E. Nichols,
Armin Schwarzman
Abstract:
Local maxima of random processes are useful for finding important regions and are routinely used, for summarising features of interest (e.g. in neuroimaging). In this work we provide confidence regions for the location of local maxima of the mean and standardized effect size (i.e. Cohen's d) given multiple realisations of a random process. We prove central limit theorems for the location of the ma…
▽ More
Local maxima of random processes are useful for finding important regions and are routinely used, for summarising features of interest (e.g. in neuroimaging). In this work we provide confidence regions for the location of local maxima of the mean and standardized effect size (i.e. Cohen's d) given multiple realisations of a random process. We prove central limit theorems for the location of the maximum of mean and t-statistic random fields and use these to provide asymptotic confidence regions for the location of peaks of the mean and Cohen's d. Under the assumption of stationarity we develop Monte Carlo confidence regions for the location of peaks of the mean that have better finite sample coverage than regions derived based on classical asymptotic normality. We illustrate our methods on 1D MEG data and 2D fMRI data from the UK Biobank.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Bayesian Lesion Estimation with a Structured Spike-and-Slab Prior
Authors:
Anna Menacher,
Thomas E. Nichols,
Chris Holmes,
Habib Ganjgahi
Abstract:
Neural demyelination and brain damage accumulated in white matter appear as hyperintense areas on T2-weighted MRI scans in the form of lesions. Modeling binary images at the population level, where each voxel represents the existence of a lesion, plays an important role in understanding aging and inflammatory diseases. We propose a scalable hierarchical Bayesian spatial model, called BLESS, capabl…
▽ More
Neural demyelination and brain damage accumulated in white matter appear as hyperintense areas on T2-weighted MRI scans in the form of lesions. Modeling binary images at the population level, where each voxel represents the existence of a lesion, plays an important role in understanding aging and inflammatory diseases. We propose a scalable hierarchical Bayesian spatial model, called BLESS, capable of handling binary responses by placing continuous spike-and-slab mixture priors on spatially-varying parameters and enforcing spatial dependency on the parameter dictating the amount of sparsity within the probability of inclusion. The use of mean-field variational inference with dynamic posterior exploration, which is an annealing-like strategy that improves optimization, allows our method to scale to large sample sizes. Our method also accounts for underestimation of posterior variance due to variational inference by providing an approximate posterior sampling approach based on Bayesian bootstrap ideas and spike-and-slab priors with random shrinkage targets. Besides accurate uncertainty quantification, this approach is capable of producing novel cluster size based imaging statistics, such as credible intervals of cluster size, and measures of reliability of cluster occurrence. Lastly, we validate our results via simulation studies and an application to the UK Biobank, a large-scale lesion map** study with a sample size of 40,000 subjects.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2023; v1 submitted 18 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Spatial Confidence Regions for Combinations of Excursion Sets in Image Analysis
Authors:
Thomas Maullin-Sapey,
Armin Schwartzman,
Thomas E. Nichols
Abstract:
The analysis of excursion sets in imaging data is essential to a wide range of scientific disciplines such as neuroimaging, climatology and cosmology. Despite growing literature, there is little published concerning the comparison of processes that have been sampled across the same spatial region but which reflect different study conditions. Given a set of asymptotically Gaussian random fields, ea…
▽ More
The analysis of excursion sets in imaging data is essential to a wide range of scientific disciplines such as neuroimaging, climatology and cosmology. Despite growing literature, there is little published concerning the comparison of processes that have been sampled across the same spatial region but which reflect different study conditions. Given a set of asymptotically Gaussian random fields, each corresponding to a sample acquired for a different study condition, this work aims to provide confidence statements about the intersection, or union, of the excursion sets across all fields. Such spatial regions are of natural interest as they directly correspond to the questions "all random fields exceed a predetermined threshold?", or "Where does at least one random field exceed a predetermined threshold?". To assess the degree of spatial variability present, we develop a method that provides, with a desired confidence, subsets and supersets of spatial regions defined by logical conjunctions (i.e. set intersections) or disjunctions (i.e. set unions), without any assumption on the dependence between the different fields. The method is verified by extensive simulations and demonstrated using a task-fMRI dataset to identify brain regions with activation common to four variants of a working memory task.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Fisher Scoring for crossed factor Linear Mixed Models
Authors:
Thomas Maullin-Sapey,
Thomas E. Nichols
Abstract:
The analysis of longitudinal, heterogeneous or unbalanced clustered data is of primary importance to a wide range of applications. The Linear Mixed Model (LMM) is a popular and flexible extension of the linear model specifically designed for such purposes. Historically, a large proportion of material published on the LMM concerns the application of popular numerical optimization algorithms, such a…
▽ More
The analysis of longitudinal, heterogeneous or unbalanced clustered data is of primary importance to a wide range of applications. The Linear Mixed Model (LMM) is a popular and flexible extension of the linear model specifically designed for such purposes. Historically, a large proportion of material published on the LMM concerns the application of popular numerical optimization algorithms, such as Newton-Raphson, Fisher Scoring and Expectation Maximization to single-factor LMMs (i.e. LMMs that only contain one "factor" by which observations are grouped). However, in recent years, the focus of the LMM literature has moved towards the development of estimation and inference methods for more complex, multi-factored designs. In this paper, we present and derive new expressions for the extension of an algorithm classically used for single-factor LMM parameter estimation, Fisher Scoring, to multiple, crossed-factor designs. Through simulation and real data examples, we compare five variants of the Fisher Scoring algorithm with one another, as well as against a baseline established by the R package lmer, and find evidence of correctness and strong computational efficiency for four of the five proposed approaches. Additionally, we provide a new method for LMM Satterthwaite degrees of freedom estimation based on analytical results, which does not require iterative gradient estimation. Via simulation, we find that this approach produces estimates with both lower bias and lower variance than the existing methods.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2021; v1 submitted 9 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Permutation Inference for Canonical Correlation Analysis
Authors:
Anderson M. Winkler,
Olivier Renaud,
Stephen M. Smith,
Thomas E. Nichols
Abstract:
Canonical correlation analysis (CCA) has become a key tool for population neuroimaging, allowing investigation of associations between many imaging and non-imaging measurements. As other variables are often a source of variability not of direct interest, previous work has used CCA on residuals from a model that removes these effects, then proceeded directly to permutation inference. We show that s…
▽ More
Canonical correlation analysis (CCA) has become a key tool for population neuroimaging, allowing investigation of associations between many imaging and non-imaging measurements. As other variables are often a source of variability not of direct interest, previous work has used CCA on residuals from a model that removes these effects, then proceeded directly to permutation inference. We show that such a simple permutation test leads to inflated error rates. The reason is that residualisation introduces dependencies among the observations that violate the exchangeability assumption. Even in the absence of nuisance variables, however, a simple permutation test for CCA also leads to excess error rates for all canonical correlations other than the first. The reason is that a simple permutation scheme does not ignore the variability already explained by previous canonical variables. Here we propose solutions for both problems: in the case of nuisance variables, we show that transforming the residuals to a lower dimensional basis where exchangeability holds results in a valid permutation test; for more general cases, with or without nuisance variables, we propose estimating the canonical correlations in a stepwise manner, removing at each iteration the variance already explained, while dealing with different number of variables in both sides. We also discuss how to address the multiplicity of tests, proposing an admissible test that is not conservative, and provide a complete algorithm for permutation inference for CCA.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2020; v1 submitted 23 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Reply to Chen et al.: Parametric methods for cluster inference perform worse for two-sided t-tests
Authors:
Anders Eklund,
Hans Knutsson,
Thomas E. Nichols
Abstract:
One-sided t-tests are commonly used in the neuroimaging field, but two-sided tests should be the default unless a researcher has a strong reason for using a one-sided test. Here we extend our previous work on cluster false positive rates, which used one-sided tests, to two-sided tests. Briefly, we found that parametric methods perform worse for two-sided t-tests, and that non-parametric methods pe…
▽ More
One-sided t-tests are commonly used in the neuroimaging field, but two-sided tests should be the default unless a researcher has a strong reason for using a one-sided test. Here we extend our previous work on cluster false positive rates, which used one-sided tests, to two-sided tests. Briefly, we found that parametric methods perform worse for two-sided t-tests, and that non-parametric methods perform equally well for one-sided and two-sided tests.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Cluster Failure Revisited: Impact of First Level Design and Data Quality on Cluster False Positive Rates
Authors:
Anders Eklund,
Hans Knutsson,
Thomas E Nichols
Abstract:
Methodological research rarely generates a broad interest, yet our work on the validity of cluster inference methods for functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) created intense discussion on both the minutia of our approach and its implications for the discipline. In the present work, we take on various critiques of our work and further explore the limitations of our original work. We address…
▽ More
Methodological research rarely generates a broad interest, yet our work on the validity of cluster inference methods for functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) created intense discussion on both the minutia of our approach and its implications for the discipline. In the present work, we take on various critiques of our work and further explore the limitations of our original work. We address issues about the particular event-related designs we used, considering multiple event types and randomisation of events between subjects. We consider the lack of validity found with one-sample permutation (sign flip**) tests, investigating a number of approaches to improve the false positive control of this widely used procedure. We found that the combination of a two-sided test and cleaning the data using ICA FIX resulted in nominal false positive rates for all datasets, meaning that data cleaning is not only important for resting state fMRI, but also for task fMRI. Finally, we discuss the implications of our work on the fMRI literature as a whole, estimating that at least 10% of the fMRI studies have used the most problematic cluster inference method (P = 0.01 cluster defining threshold), and how individual studies can be interpreted in light of our findings. These additional results underscore our original conclusions, on the importance of data sharing and thorough evaluation of statistical methods on realistic null data.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2018; v1 submitted 9 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Notes on Creating a Standardized Version of DVARS
Authors:
Thomas E. Nichols
Abstract:
By constructing a sampling distribution for DVARS we can create a standardized version of DVARS that should be more similar across scanners and datasets.
By constructing a sampling distribution for DVARS we can create a standardized version of DVARS that should be more similar across scanners and datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Accelerating Permutation Testing in Voxel-wise Analysis through Subspace Tracking: A new plugin for SnPM
Authors:
Felipe Gutierrez-Barragan,
Vamsi K. Ithapu,
Chris Hinrichs,
Camille Maumet,
Sterling C. Johnson,
Thomas E. Nichols,
Vikas Singh,
the ADNI
Abstract:
Permutation testing is a non-parametric method for obtaining the max null distribution used to compute corrected $p$-values that provide strong control of false positives. In neuroimaging, however, the computational burden of running such an algorithm can be significant. We find that by viewing the permutation testing procedure as the construction of a very large permutation testing matrix, $T$, o…
▽ More
Permutation testing is a non-parametric method for obtaining the max null distribution used to compute corrected $p$-values that provide strong control of false positives. In neuroimaging, however, the computational burden of running such an algorithm can be significant. We find that by viewing the permutation testing procedure as the construction of a very large permutation testing matrix, $T$, one can exploit structural properties derived from the data and the test statistics to reduce the runtime under certain conditions. In particular, we see that $T$ is low-rank plus a low-variance residual. This makes $T$ a good candidate for low-rank matrix completion, where only a very small number of entries of $T$ ($\sim0.35\%$ of all entries in our experiments) have to be computed to obtain a good estimate. Based on this observation, we present RapidPT, an algorithm that efficiently recovers the max null distribution commonly obtained through regular permutation testing in voxel-wise analysis. We present an extensive validation on a synthetic dataset and four varying sized datasets against two baselines: Statistical NonParametric Map** (SnPM13) and a standard permutation testing implementation (referred as NaivePT). We find that RapidPT achieves its best runtime performance on medium sized datasets ($50 \leq n \leq 200$), with speedups of 1.5x - 38x (vs. SnPM13) and 20x-1000x (vs. NaivePT). For larger datasets ($n \geq 200$) RapidPT outperforms NaivePT (6x - 200x) on all datasets, and provides large speedups over SnPM13 when more than 10000 permutations (2x - 15x) are needed. The implementation is a standalone toolbox and also integrated within SnPM13, able to leverage multi-core architectures when available.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2017; v1 submitted 4 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
A defense of using resting state fMRI as null data for estimating false positive rates
Authors:
Thomas E. Nichols,
Anders Eklund,
Hans Knutsson
Abstract:
A recent Editorial by Slotnick (2017) reconsiders the findings of our paper on the accuracy of false positive rate control with cluster inference in fMRI (Eklund et al, 2016), in particular criticising our use of resting state fMRI data as a source for null data in the evaluation of task fMRI methods. We defend this use of resting fMRI data, as while there is much structure in this data, we argue…
▽ More
A recent Editorial by Slotnick (2017) reconsiders the findings of our paper on the accuracy of false positive rate control with cluster inference in fMRI (Eklund et al, 2016), in particular criticising our use of resting state fMRI data as a source for null data in the evaluation of task fMRI methods. We defend this use of resting fMRI data, as while there is much structure in this data, we argue it is representative of task data noise and as such analysis software should be able to accommodate this noise. We also discuss a potential problem with Slotnick's own method.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2017; v1 submitted 11 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Bayesian log-Gaussian Cox process regression: applications to meta-analysis of neuroimaging working memory studies
Authors:
Pantelis Samartsidis,
Claudia R. Eickhoff,
Simon B. Eickhoff,
Tor D. Wager,
Lisa Feldman Barrett,
Shir Atzil,
Timothy D. Johnson,
Thomas E. Nichols
Abstract:
Working memory (WM) was one of the first cognitive processes studied with functional magnetic resonance imaging. With now over 20 years of studies on WM, each study with tiny sample sizes, there is a need for meta-analysis to identify the brain regions that are consistently activated by WM tasks, and to understand the interstudy variation in those activations. However, current methods in the field…
▽ More
Working memory (WM) was one of the first cognitive processes studied with functional magnetic resonance imaging. With now over 20 years of studies on WM, each study with tiny sample sizes, there is a need for meta-analysis to identify the brain regions that are consistently activated by WM tasks, and to understand the interstudy variation in those activations. However, current methods in the field cannot fully account for the spatial nature of neuroimaging meta-analysis data or the heterogeneity observed among WM studies. In this work, we propose a fully Bayesian random-effects metaregression model based on log-Gaussian Cox processes, which can be used for meta-analysis of neuroimaging studies. An efficient Markov chain Monte Carlo scheme for posterior simulations is presented which makes use of some recent advances in parallel computing using graphics processing units. Application of the proposed model to a real data set provides valuable insights regarding the function of the WM.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2019; v1 submitted 10 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
The coordinate-based meta-analysis of neuroimaging data
Authors:
Pantelis Samartsidis,
Silvia Montagna,
Thomas E. Nichols,
Timothy D. Johnson
Abstract:
Neuroimaging meta-analysis is an area of growing interest in statistics. The special characteristics of neuroimaging data render classical meta-analysis methods inapplicable and therefore new methods have been developed. We review existing methodologies, explaining the benefits and drawbacks of each. A demonstration on a real dataset of emotion studies is included. We discuss some still-open probl…
▽ More
Neuroimaging meta-analysis is an area of growing interest in statistics. The special characteristics of neuroimaging data render classical meta-analysis methods inapplicable and therefore new methods have been developed. We review existing methodologies, explaining the benefits and drawbacks of each. A demonstration on a real dataset of emotion studies is included. We discuss some still-open problems in the field to highlight the need for future research.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2017; v1 submitted 28 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Spatial Bayesian Latent Factor Regression Modeling of Coordinate-based Meta-analysis Data
Authors:
Silvia Montagna,
Tor Wager,
Lisa Feldman-Barrett,
Timothy D. Johnson,
Thomas E. Nichols
Abstract:
Now over 20 years old, functional MRI (fMRI) has a large and growing literature that is best synthesised with meta-analytic tools. As most authors do not share image data, only the peak activation coordinates (foci) reported in the paper are available for Coordinate-based Meta-analysis (CBMA). Neuroimaging meta-analysis is used to 1) identify areas of consistent activation; and 2) build a predicti…
▽ More
Now over 20 years old, functional MRI (fMRI) has a large and growing literature that is best synthesised with meta-analytic tools. As most authors do not share image data, only the peak activation coordinates (foci) reported in the paper are available for Coordinate-based Meta-analysis (CBMA). Neuroimaging meta-analysis is used to 1) identify areas of consistent activation; and 2) build a predictive model of task type or cognitive process for new studies (reverse inference). To simultaneously address these aims, we propose a Bayesian point process hierarchical model for CBMA. We model the foci from each study as a doubly stochastic Poisson process, where the study-specific log intensity function is characterised as a linear combination of a high-dimensional basis set. A sparse representation of the intensities is guaranteed through latent factor modeling of the basis coefficients. Within our framework, it is also possible to account for the effect of study-level covariates (meta-regression), significantly expanding the capabilities of the current neuroimaging meta-analysis methods available. We apply our methodology to synthetic data and a neuroimaging meta-analysis dataset.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
A Bayesian hierarchical spatial point process model for multi-type neuroimaging meta-analysis
Authors:
Jian Kang,
Thomas E. Nichols,
Tor D. Wager,
Timothy D. Johnson
Abstract:
Neuroimaging meta-analysis is an important tool for finding consistent effects over studies that each usually have 20 or fewer subjects. Interest in meta-analysis in brain map** is also driven by a recent focus on so-called "reverse inference": where as traditional "forward inference" identifies the regions of the brain involved in a task, a reverse inference identifies the cognitive processes t…
▽ More
Neuroimaging meta-analysis is an important tool for finding consistent effects over studies that each usually have 20 or fewer subjects. Interest in meta-analysis in brain map** is also driven by a recent focus on so-called "reverse inference": where as traditional "forward inference" identifies the regions of the brain involved in a task, a reverse inference identifies the cognitive processes that a task engages. Such reverse inferences, however, require a set of meta-analysis, one for each possible cognitive domain. However, existing methods for neuroimaging meta-analysis have significant limitations. Commonly used methods for neuroimaging meta-analysis are not model based, do not provide interpretable parameter estimates, and only produce null hypothesis inferences; further, they are generally designed for a single group of studies and cannot produce reverse inferences. In this work we address these limitations by adopting a nonparametric Bayesian approach for meta-analysis data from multiple classes or types of studies. In particular, foci from each type of study are modeled as a cluster process driven by a random intensity function that is modeled as a kernel convolution of a gamma random field. The type-specific gamma random fields are linked and modeled as a realization of a common gamma random field, shared by all types, that induces correlation between study types and mimics the behavior of a univariate mixed effects model. We illustrate our model on simulation studies and a meta-analysis of five emotions from 219 studies and check model fit by a posterior predictive assessment. In addition, we implement reverse inference by using the model to predict study type from a newly presented study. We evaluate this predictive performance via leave-one-out cross-validation that is efficiently implemented using importance sampling techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Analysis of multiple sclerosis lesions via spatially varying coefficients
Authors:
Tian Ge,
Nicole Müller-Lenke,
Kerstin Bendfeldt,
Thomas E. Nichols,
Timothy D. Johnson
Abstract:
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) plays a vital role in the scientific investigation and clinical management of multiple sclerosis. Analyses of binary multiple sclerosis lesion maps are typically "mass univariate" and conducted with standard linear models that are ill suited to the binary nature of the data and ignore the spatial dependence between nearby voxels (volume elements). Smoothing the les…
▽ More
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) plays a vital role in the scientific investigation and clinical management of multiple sclerosis. Analyses of binary multiple sclerosis lesion maps are typically "mass univariate" and conducted with standard linear models that are ill suited to the binary nature of the data and ignore the spatial dependence between nearby voxels (volume elements). Smoothing the lesion maps does not entirely eliminate the non-Gaussian nature of the data and requires an arbitrary choice of the smoothing parameter. Here we present a Bayesian spatial model to accurately model binary lesion maps and to determine if there is spatial dependence between lesion location and subject specific covariates such as MS subtype, age, gender, disease duration and disease severity measures. We apply our model to binary lesion maps derived from $T_2$-weighted MRI images from 250 multiple sclerosis patients classified into five clinical subtypes, and demonstrate unique modeling and predictive capabilities over existing methods.
△ Less
Submitted 31 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Multiple Comparison Procedures for Neuroimaging Genomewide Association Studies
Authors:
Wen-Yu Hua,
Thomas E. Nichols,
Debashis Ghosh,
the Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative
Abstract:
Recent research in neuroimaging has focused on assessing associations between genetic variants that are measured on a genomewide scale and brain imaging phenotypes. A large number of works in the area apply massively univariate analyses on a genomewide basis to find single nucleotide polymorphisms that influence brain structure. In this paper, we propose using various dimensionality reduction meth…
▽ More
Recent research in neuroimaging has focused on assessing associations between genetic variants that are measured on a genomewide scale and brain imaging phenotypes. A large number of works in the area apply massively univariate analyses on a genomewide basis to find single nucleotide polymorphisms that influence brain structure. In this paper, we propose using various dimensionality reduction methods on both brain structural MRI scans and genomic data, motivated by the Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI) study. We also consider a new multiple testing adjustment method and compare it with two existing false discovery rate (FDR) adjustment methods. The simulation results suggest an increase in power for the proposed method. The real data analysis suggests that the proposed procedure is able to find associations between genetic variants and brain volume differences that offer potentially new biological insights.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2014; v1 submitted 11 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
Dynamic filtering of static dipoles in magnetoencephalography
Authors:
Alberto Sorrentino,
Adam M. Johansen,
John A. D. Aston,
Thomas E. Nichols,
Wilfrid S. Kendall
Abstract:
We consider the problem of estimating neural activity from measurements of the magnetic fields recorded by magnetoencephalography. We exploit the temporal structure of the problem and model the neural current as a collection of evolving current dipoles, which appear and disappear, but whose locations are constant throughout their lifetime. This fully reflects the physiological interpretation of th…
▽ More
We consider the problem of estimating neural activity from measurements of the magnetic fields recorded by magnetoencephalography. We exploit the temporal structure of the problem and model the neural current as a collection of evolving current dipoles, which appear and disappear, but whose locations are constant throughout their lifetime. This fully reflects the physiological interpretation of the model. In order to conduct inference under this proposed model, it was necessary to develop an algorithm based around state-of-the-art sequential Monte Carlo methods employing carefully designed importance distributions. Previous work employed a bootstrap filter and an artificial dynamic structure where dipoles performed a random walk in space, yielding nonphysical artefacts in the reconstructions; such artefacts are not observed when using the proposed model. The algorithm is validated with simulated data, in which it provided an average localisation error which is approximately half that of the bootstrap filter. An application to complex real data derived from a somatosensory experiment is presented. Assessment of model fit via marginal likelihood showed a clear preference for the proposed model and the associated reconstructions show better localisation.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2013; v1 submitted 29 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
Brain Network Analysis: Separating Cost from Topology using Cost-integration
Authors:
Cedric E. Ginestet,
Thomas E. Nichols,
Ed T. Bullmore,
Andrew Simmons
Abstract:
A statistically principled way of conducting weighted network analysis is still lacking. Comparison of different populations of weighted networks is hard because topology is inherently dependent on wiring cost, where cost is defined as the number of edges in an unweighted graph. In this paper, we evaluate the benefits and limitations associated with using cost-integrated topological metrics. Our f…
▽ More
A statistically principled way of conducting weighted network analysis is still lacking. Comparison of different populations of weighted networks is hard because topology is inherently dependent on wiring cost, where cost is defined as the number of edges in an unweighted graph. In this paper, we evaluate the benefits and limitations associated with using cost-integrated topological metrics. Our focus is on comparing populations of weighted undirected graphs using global efficiency. We evaluate different approaches to the comparison of weighted networks that differ in mean association weight. Our key result shows that integrating over cost is equivalent to controlling for any monotonic transformation of the weight set of a weighted graph. That is, when integrating over cost, we eliminate the differences in topology that may be due to a monotonic transformation of the weight set. Our result holds for any unweighted topological measure. Cost-integration is therefore helpful in disentangling differences in cost from differences in topology. By contrast, we show that the use of the weighted version of a topological metric does not constitute a valid approach to this problem. Indeed, we prove that, under mild conditions, the use of the weighted version of global efficiency is equivalent to simply comparing weighted costs. Thus, we recommend the reporting of (i) differences in weighted costs and (ii) differences in cost-integrated topological measures. We demonstrate the application of these techniques in a re-analysis of an fMRI working memory task. Finally, we discuss the limitations of integrating topology over cost, which may pose problems when some weights are zero, when multiplicities exist in the ranks of the weights, and when one expects subtle cost-dependent topological differences, which could be masked by cost-integration.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2011; v1 submitted 19 April, 2011;
originally announced April 2011.