-
On the distribution of isometric log-ratio transformations under extra-multinomial count data
Authors:
Noora Kartiosuo,
Joni Virta,
Jaakko Nevalainen,
Olli Raitakari,
Kari Auranen
Abstract:
Compositional data arise when count observations are normalised into proportions adding up to unity. To allow use of standard statistical methods, compositional proportions can be mapped from the simplex into the Euclidean space through the isometric log-ratio (ilr) transformation. When the counts follow a multinomial distribution with fixed class-specific probabilities, the distribution of the en…
▽ More
Compositional data arise when count observations are normalised into proportions adding up to unity. To allow use of standard statistical methods, compositional proportions can be mapped from the simplex into the Euclidean space through the isometric log-ratio (ilr) transformation. When the counts follow a multinomial distribution with fixed class-specific probabilities, the distribution of the ensuing ilr coordinates has been shown to be asymptotically multivariate normal. We here derive an asymptotic normal approximation to the distribution of the ilr coordinates when the counts show overdispersion under the Dirichlet-multinomial mixture model. Using a simulation study, we then investigate the practical applicability of the approximation against the empirical distribution of the ilr coordinates under varying levels of extra-multinomial variation and the total count. The approximation works well, except with a small total count or high amount of overdispersion. These empirical results remain even under population-level heterogeneity in the total count. Our work is motivated by microbiome data, which often exhibit considerable extra-multinomial variation and are increasingly treated as compositional through scaling taxon-specific counts into proportions. We conclude that if the analysis of empirical data relies on normality of the ilr coordinates, it may be advisable to choose a taxonomic level where counts are less sparse so that the distribution of taxon-specific class probabilities remains unimodal.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2024; v1 submitted 14 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Hypothesis-driven mediation analysis for compositional data: an application to gut microbiome
Authors:
Noora Kartiosuo,
Jaakko Nevalainen,
Olli Raitakari,
Katja Pahkala,
Kari Auranen
Abstract:
Biological sequencing data consist of read counts, e.g. of specified taxa and often exhibit sparsity (zero-count inflation) and overdispersion (extra-Poisson variability). As most sequencing techniques provide an arbitrary total count, taxon-specific counts should ideally be treated as proportions under the compositional data-analytic framework. There is increasing interest in the role of the gut…
▽ More
Biological sequencing data consist of read counts, e.g. of specified taxa and often exhibit sparsity (zero-count inflation) and overdispersion (extra-Poisson variability). As most sequencing techniques provide an arbitrary total count, taxon-specific counts should ideally be treated as proportions under the compositional data-analytic framework. There is increasing interest in the role of the gut microbiome composition in mediating the effects of different exposures on health outcomes. Most previous approaches to compositional mediation have addressed the problem of identifying potentially mediating taxa among a large number of candidates. We here consider causal inference in compositional mediation when a priori knowledge is available about the hierarchy for a restricted number of taxa, building on a single hypothesis structured in terms of contrasts between appropriate sub-compositions. Based on the theory on multiple contemporaneous mediators and the assumed causal graph, we define non-parametric estimands for overall and coordinate-wise mediation effects, and show how these indirect effects can be estimated from empirical data based on simple parametric linear models. The mediators have straightforward and coherent interpretations, related to specific causal questions about the interrelationships between the sub-compositions. We perform a simulation study focusing on the impact of sparsity and overdispersion on estimation of mediation. While unbiased, the precision of the estimators depends, for any given magnitude of indirect effect, on sparsity and the relative magnitudes of exposure-to-mediator and mediator-to-outcome effects in a complex manner. We demonstrate the approach on empirical data, finding an inverse association of fibre intake on insulin level, mainly attributable to direct rather than indirect effects.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2024; v1 submitted 30 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Studying X-ray instruments with galaxy clusters
Authors:
J. Nevalainen,
S. Molendi
Abstract:
We applied a scientific approach to the problem of the effective area cross-calibration of the XMM-Newton EPIC instruments. Using a sample of galaxy clusters observed with the XMM-Newton EPIC, we quantified the effective area cross-calibration bias between the EPIC instruments as implemented in the public calibration data base on November 2021 in the 0.5-6.1 keV energy band. We invested significan…
▽ More
We applied a scientific approach to the problem of the effective area cross-calibration of the XMM-Newton EPIC instruments. Using a sample of galaxy clusters observed with the XMM-Newton EPIC, we quantified the effective area cross-calibration bias between the EPIC instruments as implemented in the public calibration data base on November 2021 in the 0.5-6.1 keV energy band. We invested significant efforts in controlling and minimising the systematic uncertainties of the cross-calibration bias below 1%. The statistical uncertainties are similar and thus we can reliably measure effects at 1% level. The effective area cross-calibration in the 0.5-6.1 keV band between MOS and pn is biased at a substantial level. The MOS/pn bias is systematic suggesting that MOS (pn) effective area may be calibrated too low (high), by $\sim$3-27% on average depending on the instrument and energy band. The excellent agreement of the energy dependencies (i.e. shapes) of the effective area of MOS2 and pn suggest that they are correctly calibrated within $\sim$1% in the 0.5-4.5 keV band. Comparison with an independent data set of point sources (3XMM) confirms this. The cluster sample indicates that the MOS1/pn effective area shape cross-calibration has an approximately linear bias amounting to $\sim$10% in maximum in the 0.5-4.5 keV band. The effective area cross-calibration of XMM-Newton/EPIC instruments on November 2021 in the 0.5-4.5 keV band is in a relatively good shape. However, the cluster-to-cluster rms scatter of the bias is substantial compared to the median bias itself. Thus, a statistically robust implementation of the cross-calibration uncertainties to a scientific analysis of XMM-Newton/EPIC data should include the propagation of the scatter to the best-fit parameters, instead of a simple average bias correction of the effective area.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
A search for the missing baryons with X--ray absorption lines towards the blazar 1ES 1553+113
Authors:
D. Spence,
M. Bonamente,
J. Nevalainen,
T. Tuominen,
J. Ahoranta,
J. de Plaa,
W. Liu,
N. Wijers
Abstract:
This paper presents an analysis of XMM X--ray spectra of the quasar 1ES 1553+113, in search for absorption lines from the intervening warm--hot intergalactic medium. A search for OVII, OVIII and NeIX resonance absorption lines was performed at eight fixed redshifts that feature OVI or HI broad Lyman--$α$ absorption lines that were previously detected from HST data. The search yielded one possible…
▽ More
This paper presents an analysis of XMM X--ray spectra of the quasar 1ES 1553+113, in search for absorption lines from the intervening warm--hot intergalactic medium. A search for OVII, OVIII and NeIX resonance absorption lines was performed at eight fixed redshifts that feature OVI or HI broad Lyman--$α$ absorption lines that were previously detected from HST data. The search yielded one possible detection of OVII at a redshift z=0.1877 with an OVI prior, with a statistical significance that is equivalent to a 2.6-$σ$ confidence level. The spectra were also stacked at the wavelengths of the expected redshifted OVII and OVIII lines, but the analysis did not reveal evidence for the presence of additional X--ray absorbing WHIM. Moreover, the spectra were used to investigate two putative OVII absorption lines that were detected serendipitously in an earlier analysis of the same data by F. Nicastro and collaborators. The paper also presents a comprehensive statistical framework for cosmological inferences from the analysis of absorption lines, which makes use of cosmological simulations for the joint probability distributions of FUV and X--ray ions. Accordingly, we conclude that the new possible OVII absorption at z=0.1877 is consistent with a contribution from the hot WHIM to the baryon density in an amount of $Ω_{WHIM,X}/Ω_b = 44\pm22$\%. However, there are large systematic uncertainties associated with the temperature and abundances of the absorbers, and only a larger sample of X-ray sources can provide an accurate determination of the cosmological density of the WHIM.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Cosmic gas highways in C-EAGLE simulations
Authors:
I. Vurm,
J. Nevalainen,
S. E. Hong,
Y. M. Bahé,
C. Dalla Vecchia,
P. Heinämäki
Abstract:
A substantial fraction of the cosmic baryons is expected to hide in the form of diffuse warm-hot intergalactic medium (WHIM), the majority of which resides in the filaments of the Cosmic Web and has proven very difficult to detect due to its low density. Close to galaxy clusters, the filament gas is affected by the cluster's gravitational potential and attains substantial infall velocities, eventu…
▽ More
A substantial fraction of the cosmic baryons is expected to hide in the form of diffuse warm-hot intergalactic medium (WHIM), the majority of which resides in the filaments of the Cosmic Web and has proven very difficult to detect due to its low density. Close to galaxy clusters, the filament gas is affected by the cluster's gravitational potential and attains substantial infall velocities, eventually undergoing a termination shock which may boost its X-ray signal. We aim to identify the optimal locations of the enhanced X-ray emission and absorption arising from cluster-filament interactions, as well as improve our understanding of the various physical processes affecting the WHIM as it approaches the cluster. We applied the DisPerSE filament finder to the galaxy distribution in the surroundings of a Coma-like ($M_{200} \sim 10^{15.4}~{\rm M}_{\odot}$) simulated C-EAGLE galaxy cluster. We characterised the thermodynamic properties of the gas in such filaments as well as their dependence on distance from the cluster, and provided a physical interpretation for the results. The identified filaments account for $\sim 50$% of the hot WHIM ($T > 10^{5.5}$ K) in the cluster vicinity. The filament gas is in approximate free-fall all the way down to $\sim 2 \ r_{200}$ from the cluster, at which stage it begins to slow down due to the increasing pressure of the ambient gas. The deceleration is accompanied by the conversion of gas bulk kinetic energy into heat and the increase of density and temperature from the general Cosmic Web level of $ρ\sim 10ρ_{\rm av}$ and $T = 10^5-10^6$ K towards $ρ\sim 100ρ_{\rm av}$ and $T = 10^7-10^8$ K near the cluster boundary. We conclude that the detection of the cosmic filaments of galaxies around clusters may provide a practical observational avenue for locating the densest and hottest phase of the missing baryons.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Cosmic metal invaders: Intergalactic OVII as a tracer of the warm-hot intergalactic medium within cosmic filaments in the EAGLE simulation
Authors:
T. Tuominen,
J. Nevalainen,
P. Heinämäki,
E. Tempel,
N. Wijers,
M. Bonamente,
M. A. Aragon-Calvo,
A. Finoguenov
Abstract:
The current observational status of the hot (log T(K) > 5.5) warm-hot intergalactic medium (WHIM) remains incomplete. While recent observations from stacking large numbers of Cosmic Web filaments have yielded statistically significant detections, direct measurements of single objects remain scarce. The lack of such a sample currently prevents a robust analysis of the cosmic baryon content composed…
▽ More
The current observational status of the hot (log T(K) > 5.5) warm-hot intergalactic medium (WHIM) remains incomplete. While recent observations from stacking large numbers of Cosmic Web filaments have yielded statistically significant detections, direct measurements of single objects remain scarce. The lack of such a sample currently prevents a robust analysis of the cosmic baryon content composed of the hot WHIM, which could help solve the cosmological missing baryons problem. To improve the search for the missing baryons, we used the EAGLE simulation. Our aim is to understand the metal enrichment and distribution of highly ionised metals in the Cosmic Web. We detected the filaments by applying the Bisous formalism to the simulated galaxies, and characterised the spatial distributions as well as mass and volume fractions of the filamentary oxygen and OVII. We then constructed OVII column density maps and determined their detectability with Athena X-IFU. However, the oxygen and OVII number densities drop fast beyond the virial radii of haloes, falling below detectable levels at 700 kpc. Thus, only ~1% of the filament volumes are filled with OVII at detectable densities. This non-homogeneous distribution of the OVII complicates its usage for tracing the missing baryons. Instead, OVII forms narrow envelopes around haloes. This localised nature results in a low chance (10-20% per sight line) of detecting intergalactic OVII with Athena X-IFU within the SDSS catalogue of filaments. With future filament samples from the 4MOST survey, the chances increase up to a level of ~50%. Nonetheless, based on EAGLE results, this would not be enough to conclusively solve the missing baryon problem, as it would be limited to a few times the virial radii of haloes. Fortunately, the volumes around haloes are dense in hot WHIM, and tracing it could reduce the content of baryons still missing by ~25%.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Quasi-spherical superclusters
Authors:
Pekka Heinämäki,
Pekka Teerikorpi,
Marian Douspis,
Pasi Nurmi,
Maret Einasto,
Mirt Gramann,
Jukka Nevalainen,
Enn Saar
Abstract:
Generally the dynamical state of superclusters is poorly known. We study properties of superclusters and select a sample of quasi-spherical superclusters, the dynamics of which can be studied using the $Λ$ significance diagram. We extracted our supercluster sample with an adaptive local threshold density method from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 7 (SDSS DR7) data and estimated their ma…
▽ More
Generally the dynamical state of superclusters is poorly known. We study properties of superclusters and select a sample of quasi-spherical superclusters, the dynamics of which can be studied using the $Λ$ significance diagram. We extracted our supercluster sample with an adaptive local threshold density method from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 7 (SDSS DR7) data and estimated their masses using the dynamical masses for member galaxies and groups. We used topological analysis based on Minkowski functionals and the positions of galaxies and galaxy groups in superclusters. Finally, we highlight the dynamical state of a few exceptional types of superclusters found in this study using the $Λ$ significance diagram. Our final sample contains 65 superclusters in the distance range of 130 to 450 Mpc. Supercluster masses range between $1.1 \times 10^{15} M_{\sun}$ and $1.4 \times 10^{16} M_{\sun}$ and sizes between 25 Mpc and 87 Mpc. We find that pancake-type superclusters form the low-luminosity, small, poor and low-mass end of superclusters. We find four superclusters of unusual types, exhibiting exceptionally spherical shapes. These so-called quasi-spherical systems contain a high-density core surrounded by a relatively spherical density and galaxy distribution.The mass-to-light ratio of these quasi-sphericals is higher than those of the other superclusters, suggesting a relatively high dark matter content. Using the $Λ$ significance diagram for oblate and prolate spheroids, we find that three quasi-spherical superclusters are gravitationally bound at the present epoch. Quasi-spherical superclusters are among the largest gravitationally bound systems found to date, and form a special class of giant systems that, dynamically, are in between large gravitationally unbound superclusters and clusters of galaxies in an equilibrium configuration.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
The Scaling Relation between Galaxy Luminosity and WHIM Density from EAGLE Simulations with application to SDSS data
Authors:
Patrick Holt,
Toni Tuominen,
Jukka Nevalainen,
Massimiliano Bonamente,
Teet Kuutma,
Pekka Heinämäki,
Elmo Tempel
Abstract:
This paper presents an updated scaling relation between the optical luminosity density (LD) of galaxies in the $r$ band and the density of the warm-hot intergalactic medium (WHIM) in cosmic filaments, using the high-resolution EAGLE simulations. We find a strong degree of correlation between the WHIM density and the galaxy luminosity density, resulting in a scaling relation between the two quantit…
▽ More
This paper presents an updated scaling relation between the optical luminosity density (LD) of galaxies in the $r$ band and the density of the warm-hot intergalactic medium (WHIM) in cosmic filaments, using the high-resolution EAGLE simulations. We find a strong degree of correlation between the WHIM density and the galaxy luminosity density, resulting in a scaling relation between the two quantities that permits to predict the WHIM density of filaments with a scatter of less than $\frac{1}{2}$ dex in a broad range of smoothed filament luminosity densities. In order to estimate the performance of the simulation-based calibration of the LD-WHIM density relation, we applied it to a sample of low-redshift filaments detected with the \emph{Bisous} method in the Legacy Survey SDSS~DR12 data. In the volume covered by the SDSS data, our relation predicts a WHIM density amounting to $31\pm7\pm12$ % (statistical errors followed by systematic) of cosmic baryon density. This agrees, albeit within the large uncertainties, with the current estimates of the cosmological missing baryon fraction, implying that our LD-WHIM density relation may be a useful tool in the search for the missing baryons. This method of analysis provides a new promising avenue to study the physical properties of the missing baryons, using an observable that is available for large volumes of the sky, complementary and independent from WHIM searches with absorption-line systems in the FUV or X-rays.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2022; v1 submitted 23 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Accuracy of the recovered flux of extended sources obscured by bad pixels in the central EPIC FOV
Authors:
J. Nevalainen,
I. Valtchahov,
R. D. Saxton,
S. Molendi
Abstract:
A fraction of the XMM-Newton/EPIC FOV is obscured by the dysfunctional (i.e. bad) pixels. The fraction varies between different EPIC instruments in a given observation. These complications affect the analysis of extended X-ray sources observed with XMM-Newton/EPIC and the consequent scientific interpretation of the results. For example, the accuracy of the widely used cosmological probe of the gas…
▽ More
A fraction of the XMM-Newton/EPIC FOV is obscured by the dysfunctional (i.e. bad) pixels. The fraction varies between different EPIC instruments in a given observation. These complications affect the analysis of extended X-ray sources observed with XMM-Newton/EPIC and the consequent scientific interpretation of the results. For example, the accuracy of the widely used cosmological probe of the gas mass of clusters of galaxies depends on the accuracy of the procedure of removing the obscuration effect from the measured flux. The Science Analysis Software (SAS) includes an option for recovering the lost fraction of the flux measured by a primary instrument by utilising a supplementary image of the same source. The correction may be accurate if the supplementary image is minimally obscured at the locations of the bad pixels of the primary instrument. This can be achieved e.g. by using the observation-based MOS2 image for correcting the pn flux, or by using a synthetic model image. By utilising a sample of 27 galaxy cluster observations we evaluated the accuracy of the recovery method based on observed images, as implemented in SAS 18.0.0. We found that the accuracy of the recovered total flux in the 0.5-7.0 keV band in the full geometric area within the central r = 6 arcmin is better than 0.1% on average while in some individual cases the recovered flux may be uncertain by ~1%.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
An EAGLE view of the missing baryons
Authors:
Toni Tuominen,
Jukka Nevalainen,
Elmo Tempel,
Teet Kuutma,
Nastasha Wijers,
Joop Schaye,
Pekka Heinämäki,
Massimiliano Bonamente,
Punyakoti Ganeshaiah Veena
Abstract:
Context. A significant fraction of the predicted baryons remains undetected in the local universe. We adopted the common assumption that a large fraction of the missing baryons corresponds to the hot (log T(K) = 5.5-7) phase of the Warm Hot Intergalactic Medium (WHIM). We base our missing baryons search on the scenario whereby the WHIM has been heated up via accretion shocks and galactic outflows,…
▽ More
Context. A significant fraction of the predicted baryons remains undetected in the local universe. We adopted the common assumption that a large fraction of the missing baryons corresponds to the hot (log T(K) = 5.5-7) phase of the Warm Hot Intergalactic Medium (WHIM). We base our missing baryons search on the scenario whereby the WHIM has been heated up via accretion shocks and galactic outflows, and is concentrated towards the filaments of the Cosmic Web.
Aims. Our aim is to improve the observational search of the poorly detected hot WHIM.
Methods. We detect the filamentary structure within the EAGLE simulation by applying the Bisous formalism to the galaxy distribution. In addition, we use the MMF/NEXUS+ classification of the large scale environment of the dark matter component in EAGLE. We then study the spatio-thermal distribution of the hot baryons within the extracted filaments.
Results. While the filaments occupy only 5% of the full simulation volume, the diffuse hot intergalactic medium in filaments amounts to 23% $-$ 25% of the total baryon budget, or 79% $-$ 87% of all the hot WHIM. The most optimal filament sample, with a missing baryon mass fraction of 82%, is obtained by selecting Bisous filaments with a high galaxy luminosity density. For these filaments we derived analytic formulae for the radial gas density and temperature profiles, consistent with recent Planck SZ and CMB lensing observations within the central $r$~ 1 Mpc.
Conclusions. Results from EAGLE suggest that the missing baryons are strongly concentrated towards the filament axes. Since the filament finding methods used here are applicable to galaxy surveys, a large fraction of the missing baryons can be localised by focusing the observational efforts on the central 1 Mpc regions of the filaments. Moreover, focusing on high galaxy luminosity density regions will optimise the observational signal.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
(Quasi-)Real-Time Inversion of Airborne Time-Domain Electromagnetic Data via Artificial Neural Network
Authors:
Peng Bai,
Giulio Vignoli,
Andrea Viezzoli,
Jouni Nevalainen,
Giuseppina Vacca
Abstract:
The possibility to have results very quickly after, or even during, the collection of electromagnetic data would be important, not only for quality check purposes, but also for adjusting the location of the proposed flight lines during an airborne time-domain acquisition. This kind of readiness could have a large impact in terms of optimization of the Value of Information of the measurements to be…
▽ More
The possibility to have results very quickly after, or even during, the collection of electromagnetic data would be important, not only for quality check purposes, but also for adjusting the location of the proposed flight lines during an airborne time-domain acquisition. This kind of readiness could have a large impact in terms of optimization of the Value of Information of the measurements to be acquired. In addition, the importance of having fast tools for retrieving resistivity models from airborne time-domain data is demonstrated by the fact that Conductivity-Depth Imaging methodologies are still the standard in mineral exploration. In fact, they are extremely computationally efficient, and, at the same time, they preserve a very high lateral resolution. For these reasons, they are often preferred to inversion strategies even if the latter approaches are generally more accurate in terms of proper reconstruction of the depth of the targets and of reliable retrieval of true resistivity values of the subsurface. In this research, we discuss a novel approach, based on neural network techniques, capable of retrieving resistivity models with a quality comparable with the inversion strategy, but in a fraction of the time. We demonstrate the advantages of the proposed novel approach on synthetic and field datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Hot WHIM counterparts of FUV OVI absorbers: Evidence in the line-of-sight towards quasar 3C 273
Authors:
Jussi Ahoranta,
Jukka Nevalainen,
Nastasha Wijers,
Alexis Finoguenov,
Massimiliano Bonamente,
Elmo Tempel,
Evan Tilton,
Joop Schaye,
Jelle Kaastra,
Ghassem Gozaliasl
Abstract:
We explore the high spectral resolution X-ray data towards the quasar 3C273 to search for signals of hot ($\sim10^{6-7}$ K) X-ray-absorbing gas co-located with two established intergalactic FUV OVI absorbers. We analyze the soft X-ray band grating data of all XMM-Newton and Chandra instruments to search for the hot phase absorption lines at the FUV predicted redshifts. The viability of potential l…
▽ More
We explore the high spectral resolution X-ray data towards the quasar 3C273 to search for signals of hot ($\sim10^{6-7}$ K) X-ray-absorbing gas co-located with two established intergalactic FUV OVI absorbers. We analyze the soft X-ray band grating data of all XMM-Newton and Chandra instruments to search for the hot phase absorption lines at the FUV predicted redshifts. The viability of potential line detections is examined by adopting the constraints of a physically justified absorption model. The WHIM hypothesis is investigated with a complementary 3D galaxy distribution analysis, and by comparison of the measurement results to the WHIM properties in the EAGLE cosmological, hydrodynamical simulation. At FUV redshift z=0.09017, we measured signals of two hot ion species, OVIII and NeIX, with a $3.9σ$ combined significance level. Considering the line features in all instruments collectively and assuming collisional equilibrium for absorbing gas, we were able to constrain the temperature ($kT=0.26\pm0.03$ keV) and the column density ($N_H\times{Z_\odot/Z}=1.3_{-0.5}^{+0.6}\times10^{19}$ cm$^{-2}$) of the absorber. Thermal analysis indicates that FUV and X-ray absorption relate to different phases, with estimated temperatures $T_{FUV}\approx3\times10^5$ and $T_{X-ray}\approx3\times10^6$ K, which match the EAGLE predictions for WHIM at the FUV/X-ray measured $N_{ion}$-ranges. We detected a large scale galactic filament crossing the sightline at the redshift of the absorption, linking the absorption to this structure. This study provides insights into co-existing warm and hot gas within a WHIM filament and estimates the ratio of the hot and warm phases. Because the hot phase is thermally distinct from the OVI gas, the estimated baryon content of the absorber is increased, conveying the promise of X-ray follow-up studies of FUV detected WHIM in refining the picture of the missing baryons.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
New Chandra observations of PG 1116+215 to investigate an extragalactic OVIII WHIM absorption line
Authors:
Massimiliano Bonamente,
Jussi Ahoranta,
Jukka Nevalainen,
Patrick Holt
Abstract:
This is a short AAS Research Note on the analysis of new Chandra observations of PG 1116+215, for which an extragalactic OVIII WHIM line was reported by Bonamente et al. (2016). The new observations occurred at a time when the source flux was three times lower, and the background was three times higher, than in the earlier observations. The analysis described in this research note show that the ne…
▽ More
This is a short AAS Research Note on the analysis of new Chandra observations of PG 1116+215, for which an extragalactic OVIII WHIM line was reported by Bonamente et al. (2016). The new observations occurred at a time when the source flux was three times lower, and the background was three times higher, than in the earlier observations. The analysis described in this research note show that the new observations are consistent with the old one at the wavelengths of the OVIII WHIM line, and the lower signal-to-noise of the new data did not permit a significant detection of the line in the new data.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Summary of the 13th IACHEC Meeting
Authors:
K. K. Madsen,
L. Natalucci,
G. Belanger,
C. E. Grant,
M. Guainazzi,
V. Kashyap,
H. L. Marshall,
E. D. Miller,
J. Nevalainen,
P. P. Plucinsky,
Y. Terada
Abstract:
We summarize the outcome of the 13th meeting of the International Astronomical Consortium for High Energy Calibration (IACHEC), held at Tenuta dei Ciclamini (Avigliano Umbro, Italy) in April 2018. Fifty-one scientists directly involved in the calibration of operational and future high-energy missions gathered during 3.5 days to discuss the current status of the X-ray payload inter-calibration and…
▽ More
We summarize the outcome of the 13th meeting of the International Astronomical Consortium for High Energy Calibration (IACHEC), held at Tenuta dei Ciclamini (Avigliano Umbro, Italy) in April 2018. Fifty-one scientists directly involved in the calibration of operational and future high-energy missions gathered during 3.5 days to discuss the current status of the X-ray payload inter-calibration and possible approaches to improve it. This summary consists of reports from the various working groups with topics ranging from the identification and characterization of standard calibration sources, multi-observatory cross-calibration campaigns, appropriate and new statistical techniques, calibration of instruments and characterization of background, and communication and preservation of knowledge and results for the benefit of the astronomical community.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
To be or not to be: hot WHIM absorption in the blazar PKS 2155-304 sight line?
Authors:
J. Nevalainen,
E. Tempel,
J. Ahoranta,
L. J. Liivamagi,
M. Bonamente,
E. Tilton,
J. Kaastra,
T. Fang,
P. Heinamaki,
E. Saar,
A. Finoguenov
Abstract:
The cosmological missing baryons at z<1 most likely hide in the hot (T$\gtrsim10^{5.5}$ K) phase of the Warm Hot Intergalactic Medium (WHIM). While the hot WHIM is hard to detect due to its high ionisation level, the warm (T$\lesssim10^{5.5}$ K) phase of the WHIM has been very robustly detected in the FUV band. We adopted the assumption that the hot and warm WHIM phases are co-located and thus use…
▽ More
The cosmological missing baryons at z<1 most likely hide in the hot (T$\gtrsim10^{5.5}$ K) phase of the Warm Hot Intergalactic Medium (WHIM). While the hot WHIM is hard to detect due to its high ionisation level, the warm (T$\lesssim10^{5.5}$ K) phase of the WHIM has been very robustly detected in the FUV band. We adopted the assumption that the hot and warm WHIM phases are co-located and thus used the FUV-detected warm WHIM as a tracer for the cosmologically interesting hot WHIM. We utilised the assumption by performing an X-ray follow-up in the sight line of a blazar PKS 2155-304 at the redshifts where previous FUV measurements of OVI, SiIV and BLA absorption have indicated the existence of the warm WHIM. We looked for the OVII He$α$ and OVIII Ly$α$ absorption lines, the most likely hot WHIM tracers. Despite of the very large exposure time ($\approx$ 1 Ms), the XMM-Newton/RGS1 data yielded no significant detection which corresponds to upper limits of $\log{N({\rm OVII})({\rm cm}^{-2}))} \le 14.5-15.2$ and $\log{N({\rm OVIII})({\rm cm}^{-2}))} \le 14.9-15.2$. An analysis of LETG/HRC data yielded consistent results. However, the LETG/ACIS data yielded a detection of an absorption line - like feature at $λ\approx$ 20 Å at simple one parameter uncertainty - based confidence level of 3.7 $σ$, consistently with several earlier LETG/ACIS reports. Given the high statistical quality of the RGS1 data, the possibility of RGS1 accidentally missing the true line at $λ\sim$ 20 Å is very low, 0.006%. Neglecting this, the LETG/ACIS detection can be interpreted as Ly$α$ transition of OVIII at one of the redshifts (z$\approx$ 0.054) of FUV-detected warm WHIM. Given the very convincing X-ray spectral evidence for and against the existence of the $λ\sim$ 20 Å feature, we cannot conclude whether or not it is a true astrophysical absorption line.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Inference on the marginal distribution of clustered data with informative cluster size
Authors:
Jaakko Nevalainen,
Somnath Datta,
Hannu Oja
Abstract:
In spite of recent contributions to the literature, informative cluster size settings are not well known and understood. In this paper, we give a formal definition of the problem and describe it from different viewpoints. Data generating mechanisms, parametric and nonparametric models are considered in light of examples. Our emphasis is on nonparametric and robust approaches to the inference on th…
▽ More
In spite of recent contributions to the literature, informative cluster size settings are not well known and understood. In this paper, we give a formal definition of the problem and describe it from different viewpoints. Data generating mechanisms, parametric and nonparametric models are considered in light of examples. Our emphasis is on nonparametric and robust approaches to the inference on the marginal distribution. Descriptive statistics and parameters of interest are defined as functionals and they are accompanied with a generally applicable testing procedure. The theory is illustrated with an example on patients with incomplete spinal cord injuries.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Nonparametric Analysis of Clustered Multivariate Data
Authors:
Jaakko Nevalainen,
Denis Larocque,
Hannu Oja,
Ilkka Pörsti
Abstract:
There has been a wide interest to extend univariate and multivariate nonparametric procedures to clustered and hierarchical data. Traditionally, parametric mixed models have been used to account for the correlation structures among the dependent observational units. In this work we extend multivariate nonparametric procedures for one-sample and several samples location problems to clustered data s…
▽ More
There has been a wide interest to extend univariate and multivariate nonparametric procedures to clustered and hierarchical data. Traditionally, parametric mixed models have been used to account for the correlation structures among the dependent observational units. In this work we extend multivariate nonparametric procedures for one-sample and several samples location problems to clustered data settings. The results are given for a general score function, but with an emphasis on spatial sign and rank methods. Mixed models notation involving design matrices for fixed and random effects is used throughout. The asymptotic variance formulas and limiting distributions of the test statistics under the null hypothesis and under a sequence of alternatives are derived, as well as the limiting distributions for the corresponding estimates. The approach based on a general score function also shows, for example, how $M$-estimates behave with clustered data. Efficiency studies demonstrate practical advantages and disadvantages of the use of spatial sign and rank scores, and their weighted versions. Small sample procedures based on sign change and permutation principles are discussed. Further development of nonparametric methods for cluster correlated data would benefit from the notation already familiar to statisticians working under normality assumptions.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Summary of the 12th IACHEC Meeting
Authors:
K. Forster,
C. E. Grant,
M. Guainazzi,
V. Kashyap,
H. L. Marshall,
E. D. Miller,
L. Natalucci,
J. Nevalainen,
P. P. Plucinsky,
Y. Terada
Abstract:
We summarize the outcome of the 12th meeting of the International Astronomical Consortium for High Energy Calibration (IACHEC), held at the UCLA conference center in Lake Arrowhead (California) in March 2017. 56 scientists directly involved in the calibration of operational and future high-energy missions gathered during 3.5 days to discuss the status of the X-ray payload inter-calibration, as wel…
▽ More
We summarize the outcome of the 12th meeting of the International Astronomical Consortium for High Energy Calibration (IACHEC), held at the UCLA conference center in Lake Arrowhead (California) in March 2017. 56 scientists directly involved in the calibration of operational and future high-energy missions gathered during 3.5 days to discuss the status of the X-ray payload inter-calibration, as well as possible ways to improve it. The "Thermal Supernovas Remnant" (SNR) Working Group presented a recently published paper on 1E0102.2-7219 as a calibration standard in the 0.5-1.0 keV band. A new method to measure the high-energy spectrum of the Crab Nebula and pulsar with NuSTAR without using its optics may yield a new absolute flux standard in the 3-7 keV band. A new ACIS contamination model - released with CALDB version 4.7.3 - leads to a significant improvement in modeling the spectral, spatial, and temporal properties of the contaminant. The first calibration results of the scientific payload on board Hitomi confirm the excellent performance of the instruments before the spacecraft operation problems leading to its loss. Finally, the meeting discussed extensively a novel statistic approach to formally identify in which direction the effective areas of different instruments would need to be changed to bring them into concordance. This method could inform future further calibration efforts.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Discovery of Galactic OIV and OV X-ray absorption due to transition temperature gas in the PKS 2155-304 spectrum
Authors:
J. Nevalainen,
B. Wakker,
J. Kaastra,
M. Bonamente,
S. Snowden,
F. Paerels,
C. de Vries
Abstract:
FUV observations have revealed the transition temperature gas (TTG; $\log{T({\mathrm{K}})}$ ~ 5), located in the lower Galactic halo and in the High Velocity Clouds. However, the corresponding X-ray absorption has so far remained mostly undetected. In order to make an improvement in this respect in Galactic X-ray absorption studies, we accumulated very deep (~3 Ms) spectra of the blazar PKS 2155-3…
▽ More
FUV observations have revealed the transition temperature gas (TTG; $\log{T({\mathrm{K}})}$ ~ 5), located in the lower Galactic halo and in the High Velocity Clouds. However, the corresponding X-ray absorption has so far remained mostly undetected. In order to make an improvement in this respect in Galactic X-ray absorption studies, we accumulated very deep (~3 Ms) spectra of the blazar PKS 2155-304 obtained with the spectrometers RGS1, RGS2, LETG/HRC and LETG/ACIS-S and studied the absorption lines due to the intervening Galactic components. The very high quality of the data and the coverage of important wavelengths with at least two independent instruments allowed us to reliably detect ten Galactic lines with better than 99.95% confidence. We discovered significant absorption from blended OIV transitions 1s-2p $^2$S (22.571 Å), 1s-2p $^2$P (22.741 Å) and 1s-2p $^2$D (22.777 Å), and from the OV transition 1s-2p (22.370 Å) from TTG at $\log{T({\mathrm{K}})} \thinspace = \thinspace 5.2\pm0.1$. A joint X-ray and FUV analysis indicated that photoionisation is negligible for this component and that the gas is in a cooling transition phase. However, the temperature is high enough that the column density ratio N(OIV)/N(OV) is not significantly different from that in collisional ionisation equilibrium (CIE). Under CIE we obtained $N_{\mathrm{OIV}}$= 3.6$\pm$2.0 $\times 10^{15}$ cm$^{-2}$, corresponding to $N_{\mathrm{H}}$ = 1.0$\pm$0.5 $\times 10^{19} \frac{Z_{\odot}}{Z_{\mathrm{TTG}}}$ cm$^{-2}$.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
A possible Chandra and Hubble Space Telescope detection of extragalactic WHIM towards PG 1116+215
Authors:
M. Bonamente,
J. Nevalainen,
E. Tilton,
J. Liivamagi,
E. Tempel,
P. Heinamaki,
T. Fang
Abstract:
(Abridged) We have analyzed Chandra LETG and XMM-Newton RGS spectra towards the z=0.177 quasar PG 1116+215, a sightline that is rendered particularly interesting by the HST detection of several OVI and HI broad Lyman-alpha absorption lines that may be associated with the warm-hot intergalactic medium. We performed a search for resonance K-alpha absorption lines from OVII and OVIII at the redshifts…
▽ More
(Abridged) We have analyzed Chandra LETG and XMM-Newton RGS spectra towards the z=0.177 quasar PG 1116+215, a sightline that is rendered particularly interesting by the HST detection of several OVI and HI broad Lyman-alpha absorption lines that may be associated with the warm-hot intergalactic medium. We performed a search for resonance K-alpha absorption lines from OVII and OVIII at the redshifts of the detected far-ultraviolet lines. We detected an absorption line in the Chandra spectra at 5.2 sigma confidence level at wavelengths corresponding to OVIII K-alpha at z=0.0911+-0.0004+-0.0005 (statistical followed by systematic error). This redshift is within 3 sigma of that of a HI broad Lyman-alpha of b=130 km/s at z=0.09279+-0.00005. We have also analyzed the available XMM-Newton RGS data towards PG 1116+215. Unfortunately, the XMM-Newton data are not suitable to investigate this line because of instrumental features at the wavelengths of interest. At the same redshift, the Chandra and XMM-Newton spectra have OVII K-alpha absorption line features of significance 1.5 sigma and 1.8 sigma, respectively. We also analyzed the available SDSS spectroscopic galaxy survey data towards PG 1116+215 in the redshift range of interest. We found evidence for a galaxy filament that intersects the PG 1116+215 sightline and additional galaxy structures that may host WHIM. The combination of HST, Chandra, XMM-Newton and SDSS data indicates that we have likely detected a multi-temperature WHIM at z=0.091-0.093 towards PG 1116+215.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Summary of the 2015 IACHEC meeting
Authors:
Xiaobo Li,
Shu Zhang,
Catherine Grant,
Matteo Guainazzi,
Eric Miller,
Lorenzo Natalucci,
Jukka Nevalainen
Abstract:
We summarize the outcome of the 10th meeting of the International Astronomical Consortium for High Energy Calibration (IACHEC), held in Bei**g (People's Republic of China) in April 2015. Over 80 scientists directly involved in the calibration of operational and future high-energy missions gathered during 3.5 days to discuss the status of the X-ray payload inter-calibration, as well as possible wa…
▽ More
We summarize the outcome of the 10th meeting of the International Astronomical Consortium for High Energy Calibration (IACHEC), held in Bei**g (People's Republic of China) in April 2015. Over 80 scientists directly involved in the calibration of operational and future high-energy missions gathered during 3.5 days to discuss the status of the X-ray payload inter-calibration, as well as possible ways to improve it. A recent study on a large sample of galaxy clusters confirmed that the calibration of the effective area shape above 2 keV between XMM-Newton/EPIC and Chandra/ACIS is consistent, but showed a significant discrepancy at lower energies. Temperatures measured by EPIC are therefore smaller, the difference being largest for the highest temperatures, up to ~20% at kT=10 keV (Schellenberger et al. 2015). The latest multi-mission study of the Crab Nebula above 10 keV shows a +/-13% agreement in the relative normalization of the INTEGRAL, NuSTAR, RXTE, and {\it Suzaku} hard X-ray instruments.
△ Less
Submitted 28 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Missing baryons traced by the galaxy luminosity density in the large-scale WHIM filaments
Authors:
J. Nevalainen,
E. Tempel,
L. J. Liivamägi,
E. Branchini,
M. Roncarelli,
C. Giocoli,
P. Heinämäki,
E. Saar,
A. Tamm,
A. Finoguenov,
P. Nurmi,
M. Bonamente
Abstract:
We propose a new approach to the missing baryons problem. Building on the common assumption that the missing baryons are in the form of the Warm Hot Intergalactic Medium (WHIM), we further assumed here that the galaxy luminosity density can be used as a tracer of the WHIM. The latter assumption is supported by our finding of a significant correlation between the WHIM density and the galaxy luminos…
▽ More
We propose a new approach to the missing baryons problem. Building on the common assumption that the missing baryons are in the form of the Warm Hot Intergalactic Medium (WHIM), we further assumed here that the galaxy luminosity density can be used as a tracer of the WHIM. The latter assumption is supported by our finding of a significant correlation between the WHIM density and the galaxy luminosity density in the hydrodynamical simulations of Cui et al. (2012). We further found that the fraction of the gas mass in the WHIM phase is substantially (by a factor of $\sim$1.6) higher within the large scale galactic filaments, i.e. $\sim$70\%, compared to the average in the full simulation volume of $\sim$0.1\,Gpc$^3$. The relation between the WHIM overdensity and the galaxy luminosity overdensity within the galactic filaments is consistent with linear: $δ_{\rm whim}\,=\,0.7\,\pm\,0.1\,\times\,δ_\mathrm{LD}^{0.9 \pm 0.2}$. We applied our procedure to the line of sight to the blazar H2356-309 and found evidence for the WHIM in correspondence of the Sculptor Wall (z $\sim$0.03 and $\log{N_H}$ = $19.9^{+0.1}_{-0.3}$) and Pisces-Cetus superclusters (z $\sim$0.06 and $\log{N_H}$ = $19.7^{+0.2}_{-0.3}$), in agreement with the redshifts and column densities of the X-ray absorbers identified and studied by Fang et al. (2010) and Zappacosta et al. (2010). This agreement indicates that the galaxy luminosity density and galactic filaments are reliable signposts for the WHIM and that our method is robust in estimating the WHIM density. The signal that we detected cannot originate from the halos of the nearby galaxies since they cannot account for the large WHIM column densities that our method and X-ray analysis consistently find in the Sculptor Wall and Pisces-Cetus superclusters.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Unusual A2142 supercluster with a collapsing core: distribution of light and mass
Authors:
Maret Einasto,
Mirt Gramann,
Enn Saar,
Lauri Juhan Liivamagi,
Elmo Tempel,
Jukka Nevalainen,
Pekka Heinamaki,
Changbom Park,
Jaan Einasto
Abstract:
We study the distribution, masses, and dynamical properties of galaxy groups in the A2142 supercluster. We analyse the global luminosity density distribution in the supercluster and divide the supercluster into the high-density core and the low-density outskirts regions. We find galaxy groups and filaments in the regions of different global density, calculate their masses and mass-to-light ratios…
▽ More
We study the distribution, masses, and dynamical properties of galaxy groups in the A2142 supercluster. We analyse the global luminosity density distribution in the supercluster and divide the supercluster into the high-density core and the low-density outskirts regions. We find galaxy groups and filaments in the regions of different global density, calculate their masses and mass-to-light ratios and analyse their dynamical state with several 1D and 3D statistics. We use the spherical collapse model to study the dynamical state of the supercluster. We show that in A2142 supercluster groups and clusters with at least ten member galaxies lie along an almost straight line forming a 50 Mpc/h long main body of the supercluster. The A2142 supercluster has a very high density core surrounded by lower-density outskirt regions. The total estimated mass of the supercluster is M_est = 6.2 10^{15}M_sun. More than a half of groups with at least ten member galaxies in the supercluster lie in the high-density core of the supercluster, centered at the rich X-ray cluster A2142. Most of the galaxy groups in the core region are multimodal. In the outskirts of the supercluster, the number of groups is larger than in the core, and groups are poorer. The orientation of the cluster A2142 axis follows the orientations of its X-ray substructures and radio halo, and is aligned along the supercluster axis. The high-density core of the supercluster with the global density D8 > 17 and perhaps with D8 > 13 may have reached the turnaround radius and started to collapse. A2142 supercluster with luminous, collapsing core and straight body is an unusual object among galaxy superclusters. In the course of the future evolution the supercluster may be split into several separate systems.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2015; v1 submitted 27 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Summary of the 2014 IACHEC Meeting
Authors:
David Burrows,
Fabio Gastaldello,
Catherine E. Grant,
Matteo Guainazzi,
Kristin Madsen,
Eric Miller,
Jukka Nevalainen,
Paul P. Plucinsky,
Steve Sembay
Abstract:
We present the main results of the 9th meeting of the International Astronomical Consortium for High Energy Calibration (IACHEC), held in Warrenton (Virginia) in May 2014. Over 50 scientists directly involved in the calibration of operational and future high-energy missions gathered during 3.5 days to discuss the status of the X-ray payloads inter-calibration, as well as possible ways to improve i…
▽ More
We present the main results of the 9th meeting of the International Astronomical Consortium for High Energy Calibration (IACHEC), held in Warrenton (Virginia) in May 2014. Over 50 scientists directly involved in the calibration of operational and future high-energy missions gathered during 3.5 days to discuss the status of the X-ray payloads inter-calibration, as well as possible ways to improve it. Sect.2 of this Report summarises our current understanding of the energy-dependent inter-calibration status.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Finding and characterising WHIM structures using the luminosity density method
Authors:
J. Nevalainen,
L. J. Liivamagi,
E. Tempel,
E. Branchini,
M. Roncarelli,
C. Giocoli,
P. Heinamaki,
E. Saar,
M. Bonamente,
M. Einasto,
A. Finoguenov,
J. Kaastra,
E. Lindfors,
P. Nurmi,
Y. Ueda
Abstract:
We have developed a new method to approach the missing baryons problem. We assume that the missing baryons reside in a form of Warm Hot Intergalactic Medium, i.e. the WHIM. Our method consists of (a) detecting the coherent large scale structure in the spatial distribution of galaxies that traces the Cosmic Web and that in hydrodynamical simulations is associated to the WHIM, (b) map its luminosity…
▽ More
We have developed a new method to approach the missing baryons problem. We assume that the missing baryons reside in a form of Warm Hot Intergalactic Medium, i.e. the WHIM. Our method consists of (a) detecting the coherent large scale structure in the spatial distribution of galaxies that traces the Cosmic Web and that in hydrodynamical simulations is associated to the WHIM, (b) map its luminosity into a galaxy luminosity density field, (c) use numerical simulations to relate the luminosity density to the density of the WHIM, (d) apply this relation to real data to trace the WHIM using the observed galaxy luminosities in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey and 2dF redshift surveys. In our application we find evidence for the WHIM along the line of sight to the Sculptor Wall, at redshifts consistent with the recently reported X-ray absorption line detections. Our indirect WHIM detection technique complements the standard method based on the detection of characteristic X-ray absorption lines, showing that the galaxy luminosity density is a reliable signpost for the WHIM. For this reason, our method could be applied to current galaxy surveys to optimise the observational strategies for detecting and studying the WHIM and its properties. Our estimates of the WHIM hydrogen column density in Sculptor agree with those obtained via the X-ray analysis. Due to the additional column density estimate, our method has potential for improving the constrains of the physical parameters of the WHIM as derived with X-ray absorption, and thus for improving the understanding of the missing baryons problem.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Reconciling Planck cluster counts and cosmology? Chandra/XMM instrumental calibration and hydrostatic mass bias
Authors:
Holger Israel,
Gerrit Schellenberger,
Jukka Nevalainen,
Richard Massey,
Thomas Reiprich
Abstract:
The mass of galaxy clusters can be inferred from the temperature of their X-ray emitting gas, $T_{\mathrm{X}}$. Their masses may be underestimated if it is assumed that the gas is in hydrostatic equilibrium, by an amount $b^{\mathrm{hyd}}\sim(20\pm10)$ % suggested by simulations. We have previously found consistency between a sample of observed \textit{Chandra} X-ray masses and independent weak le…
▽ More
The mass of galaxy clusters can be inferred from the temperature of their X-ray emitting gas, $T_{\mathrm{X}}$. Their masses may be underestimated if it is assumed that the gas is in hydrostatic equilibrium, by an amount $b^{\mathrm{hyd}}\sim(20\pm10)$ % suggested by simulations. We have previously found consistency between a sample of observed \textit{Chandra} X-ray masses and independent weak lensing measurements. Unfortunately, uncertainties in the instrumental calibration of {\em Chandra} and {\em XMM-Newton} observatories mean that they measure different temperatures for the same gas. In this paper, we translate that relative instrumental bias into mass bias, and infer that \textit{XMM-Newton} masses of $\sim 10^{14}\,\mbox{M}_{\odot}$ ($> 5\cdot 10^{14} \mbox{M}_{\odot}$) clusters are unbiased ($\sim 35$ % lower) compared to WL masses. For massive clusters, \textit{Chandra}'s calibration may thus be more accurate. The opposite appears to be true at the low mass end. We observe the mass bias to increase with cluster mass, but presence of Eddington bias precludes firm conclusions at this stage. Nevertheless, the systematic \textit{Chandra} -- \textit{XMM-Newton} difference is important because {\em Planck}'s detections of massive clusters via the Sunyaev-Zeldovich (SZ) effect are calibrated via {\em XMM-Newton} observations. The number of detected SZ clusters are inconsistent with {\em Planck}'s cosmological measurements of the primary Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB). Given the \textit{Planck} cluster masses, if an (unlikely) uncorrected $\sim 20$ % calibration bias existed, this tension would be eased, but not resolved.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2015; v1 submitted 20 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
XMM-Newton and Chandra Cross Calibration Using HIFLUGCS Galaxy Clusters: Systematic Temperature Differences and Cosmological Impact
Authors:
G. Schellenberger,
T. H. Reiprich,
L. Lovisari,
J. Nevalainen,
L. David
Abstract:
Cosmological constraints from clusters rely on accurate gravitational mass estimates, which strongly depend on cluster gas temperature measurements. Therefore, systematic calibration differences may result in biased, instrument-dependent cosmological constraints. This is of special interest in the light of the tension between the Planck results of the primary temperature anisotropies of the CMB an…
▽ More
Cosmological constraints from clusters rely on accurate gravitational mass estimates, which strongly depend on cluster gas temperature measurements. Therefore, systematic calibration differences may result in biased, instrument-dependent cosmological constraints. This is of special interest in the light of the tension between the Planck results of the primary temperature anisotropies of the CMB and Sunyaev-Zel'dovich plus X-ray cluster counts analyses. We quantify in detail the systematics and uncertainties of the cross-calibration of the effective area between five X-ray instruments, EPIC-MOS1/MOS2/PN onboard XMM-Newton and ACIS-I/S onboard Chandra, and the influence on temperature measurements. Furthermore, we assess the impact of the cross calibration uncertainties on cosmology. Using the HIFLUGCS sample, consisting of the 64 X-ray brightest galaxy clusters, we constrain the ICM temperatures through spectral fitting in the same, mostly isothermal, regions and compare them. Our work is an extension to a previous one using X-ray clusters by the IACHEC. Performing spectral fitting in the full energy band we find that best-fit temperatures determined with XMM-Newton/EPIC are significantly lower than Chandra/ACIS temperatures. We demonstrate that effects like multitemperature structure and different relative sensitivities of the instruments at certain energy bands cannot explain the observed differences. We conclude that using XMM-Newton/EPIC, instead of Chandra/ACIS to derive full energy band temperature profiles for cluster mass determination results in an 8% shift towards lower OmegaM values and <1% shift towards higher sigma8 values in a cosmological analysis of a complete sample of galaxy clusters. Such a shift is insufficient to significantly alleviate the tension between Planck CMB anisotropies and SZ plus XMM-Newton cosmological constraints.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2014; v1 submitted 28 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
The Hot and Energetic Universe: The missing baryons and the warm-hot intergalactic medium
Authors:
Jelle Kaastra,
Alexis Finoguenov,
Fabrizio Nicastro,
Enzo Branchini,
Joop Schaye,
Nico Cappelluti,
Jukka Nevalainen,
Xavier Barcons,
Joel Bregman,
Judith Croston,
Klaus Dolag,
Stefano Ettori,
Massimiliano Galeazzi,
Takaya Ohashi,
Luigi Piro,
Etienne Pointecouteau,
Gabriel Pratt,
Thomas Reiprich,
Mauro Roncarelli,
Jeremy Sanders,
Yoh Takei,
Eugenio Ursino
Abstract:
The backbone of the large-scale structure of the Universe is determined by processes on a cosmological scale and by the gravitational interaction of the dominant dark matter. However, the mobile baryon population shapes the appearance of these structures. Theory predicts that most of the baryons reside in vast unvirialized filamentary structures that connect galaxy groups and clusters, but the obs…
▽ More
The backbone of the large-scale structure of the Universe is determined by processes on a cosmological scale and by the gravitational interaction of the dominant dark matter. However, the mobile baryon population shapes the appearance of these structures. Theory predicts that most of the baryons reside in vast unvirialized filamentary structures that connect galaxy groups and clusters, but the observational evidence is currently lacking. Because the majority of the baryons are supposed to exist in a large-scale, hot and dilute gaseous phase, X-rays provide the ideal tool to progress our understanding. Observations with the Athena+ X-ray Integral Field Unit will reveal the location, chemical composition, physical state and dynamics of the active population of baryons.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
The Hot and Energetic Universe: The astrophysics of galaxy groups and clusters
Authors:
S. Ettori,
G. W. Pratt,
J. de Plaa,
D. Eckert,
J. Nevalainen,
E. S. Battistelli,
S. Borgani,
J. H. Croston,
A. Finoguenov,
J. Kaastra,
M. Gaspari,
F. Gastaldello,
M. Gitti,
S. Molendi,
E. Pointecouteau,
T. J. Ponman,
T. H. Reiprich,
M. Roncarelli,
M. Rossetti,
J. S. Sanders,
M. Sun,
G. Trinchieri,
F. Vazza,
M. Arnaud,
H. Böringher
, et al. (6 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
As the nodes of the cosmic web, clusters of galaxies trace the large-scale distribution of matter in the Universe. They are thus privileged sites in which to investigate the complex physics of structure formation. However, the complete story of how these structures grow, and how they dissipate the gravitational and non-thermal components of their energy budget over cosmic time, is still beyond our…
▽ More
As the nodes of the cosmic web, clusters of galaxies trace the large-scale distribution of matter in the Universe. They are thus privileged sites in which to investigate the complex physics of structure formation. However, the complete story of how these structures grow, and how they dissipate the gravitational and non-thermal components of their energy budget over cosmic time, is still beyond our grasp. Fundamental questions such as How do hot diffuse baryons accrete and dynamically evolve in dark matter potentials? How and when was the energy that we observe in the ICM generated and distributed? Where and when are heavy elements produced and how are they circulated? are still unanswered. Most of the cluster baryons exists in the form of a diffuse, hot, metal-enriched plasma that radiates primarily in the X-ray band (the intracluster medium, ICM), allowing the X-ray observations of the evolving cluster population to provide a unique opportunity to address these topics. Athena+ with its large collecting area and unprecedented combination of high spectral and angular resolution offers the only way to make major advances in answering these questions. Athena+ will show how the baryonic gas evolves in the dark matter potential wells by studying the motions and turbulence in the ICM. Athena+ will be able to resolve the accreting region both spatially and spectroscopically, probing the true nature and physical state of the X-ray emitting plasma. Athena+ has the capabilities to permit a definitive understanding of the formation and evolution of large-scale cosmic structure through the study of the cluster population.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
The Hot and Energetic Universe: The evolution of galaxy groups and clusters
Authors:
E. Pointecouteau,
T. H. Reiprich,
C. Adami,
M. Arnaud,
V. Biffi,
S. Borgani,
K. Borm,
H. Bourdin,
M. Brueggen,
E. Bulbul,
N. Clerc,
J. H. Croston,
K. Dolag,
S. Ettori,
A. Finoguenov,
J. Kaastra,
L. Lovisari,
B. Maughan,
P. Mazzotta,
F. Pacaud,
J. de Plaa,
G. W. Pratt,
M. Ramos-Ceja,
E. Rasia,
J. Sanders
, et al. (23 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Major astrophysical questions related to the formation and evolution of structures, and more specifically of galaxy groups and clusters, will still be open in the coming decade and beyond: what is the interplay of galaxy, supermassive black hole, and intergalactic gas evolution in the most massive objects in the Universe - galaxy groups and clusters? What are the processes driving the evolution of…
▽ More
Major astrophysical questions related to the formation and evolution of structures, and more specifically of galaxy groups and clusters, will still be open in the coming decade and beyond: what is the interplay of galaxy, supermassive black hole, and intergalactic gas evolution in the most massive objects in the Universe - galaxy groups and clusters? What are the processes driving the evolution of chemical enrichment of the hot diffuse gas in large-scale structures? How and when did the first galaxy groups in the Universe, massive enough to bind more than 10^7 K gas, form? Focussing on the period when groups and clusters assembled (0.5<z<2.5), we show that, due to the continuum and line emission of this hot intergalactic gas at X-ray wavelengths, Athena+, combining high sensitivity with excellent spectral and spatial resolution, will deliver breakthrough observations in view of the aforementioned issues. Indeed, the physical and chemical properties of the hot intra-cluster gas, and their evolution across time, are a key to understand the co-evolution of galaxy and supermassive black hole within their environments.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
The Hot and Energetic Universe: A White Paper presenting the science theme motivating the Athena+ mission
Authors:
Kirpal Nandra,
Didier Barret,
Xavier Barcons,
Andy Fabian,
Jan-Willem den Herder,
Luigi Piro,
Mike Watson,
Christophe Adami,
James Aird,
Jose Manuel Afonso,
Dave Alexander,
Costanza Argiroffi,
Lorenzo Amati,
Monique Arnaud,
Jean-Luc Atteia,
Marc Audard,
Carles Badenes,
Jean Ballet,
Lucia Ballo,
Aya Bamba,
Anil Bhardwaj,
Elia Stefano Battistelli,
Werner Becker,
Michaël De Becker,
Ehud Behar
, et al. (215 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This White Paper, submitted to the recent ESA call for science themes to define its future large missions, advocates the need for a transformational leap in our understanding of two key questions in astrophysics: 1) How does ordinary matter assemble into the large scale structures that we see today? 2) How do black holes grow and shape the Universe? Hot gas in clusters, groups and the intergalacti…
▽ More
This White Paper, submitted to the recent ESA call for science themes to define its future large missions, advocates the need for a transformational leap in our understanding of two key questions in astrophysics: 1) How does ordinary matter assemble into the large scale structures that we see today? 2) How do black holes grow and shape the Universe? Hot gas in clusters, groups and the intergalactic medium dominates the baryonic content of the local Universe. To understand the astrophysical processes responsible for the formation and assembly of these large structures, it is necessary to measure their physical properties and evolution. This requires spatially resolved X-ray spectroscopy with a factor 10 increase in both telescope throughput and spatial resolving power compared to currently planned facilities. Feedback from supermassive black holes is an essential ingredient in this process and in most galaxy evolution models, but it is not well understood. X-ray observations can uniquely reveal the mechanisms launching winds close to black holes and determine the coupling of the energy and matter flows on larger scales. Due to the effects of feedback, a complete understanding of galaxy evolution requires knowledge of the obscured growth of supermassive black holes through cosmic time, out to the redshifts where the first galaxies form. X-ray emission is the most reliable way to reveal accreting black holes, but deep survey speed must improve by a factor ~100 over current facilities to perform a full census into the early Universe. The Advanced Telescope for High Energy Astrophysics (Athena+) mission provides the necessary performance (e.g. angular resolution, spectral resolution, survey grasp) to address these questions and revolutionize our understanding of the Hot and Energetic Universe. These capabilities will also provide a powerful observatory to be used in all areas of astrophysics.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Summary of the 2013 IACHEC Meeting
Authors:
Catherine E. Grant,
Matteo Guainazzi,
Lorenzo Natalucci,
Jukka Nevalainen,
Paul P. Plucinsky,
Andrew Pollock,
Steve Sembay
Abstract:
We present the main results of the 8th International Astronomical Consortium for High Energy Calibration (IACHEC) meeting, held in Theddingworth, Leicestershire, between March 25 and 28, 2013. Over 50 scientists directly involved in the calibration of operational and future high-energy missions gathered during 3.5 days to discuss the status of the X-ray payload inter-calibration, as well as possib…
▽ More
We present the main results of the 8th International Astronomical Consortium for High Energy Calibration (IACHEC) meeting, held in Theddingworth, Leicestershire, between March 25 and 28, 2013. Over 50 scientists directly involved in the calibration of operational and future high-energy missions gathered during 3.5 days to discuss the status of the X-ray payload inter-calibration, as well as possible ways to improve it. Sect. 4 of this Report summarises our current understanding of the energy-dependent inter-calibration status.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Cross-calibration of Suzaku XIS and XMM-Newton EPIC using clusters of galaxies
Authors:
K. Kettula,
J. Nevalainen,
E. D. Miller
Abstract:
We extend a previous cross-calibration study by the International Astronomical Consortium for High Energy Calibration (IACHEC) on XMM-Newton/EPIC, Chandra/ACIS and BeppoSAX/MECS X-ray instruments with clusters of galaxies to Suzaku/XIS instruments. Our aim is to study the accuracy of the energy-dependent effective area calibration of the XIS instruments by comparison of spectroscopic temperatures,…
▽ More
We extend a previous cross-calibration study by the International Astronomical Consortium for High Energy Calibration (IACHEC) on XMM-Newton/EPIC, Chandra/ACIS and BeppoSAX/MECS X-ray instruments with clusters of galaxies to Suzaku/XIS instruments. Our aim is to study the accuracy of the energy-dependent effective area calibration of the XIS instruments by comparison of spectroscopic temperatures, fluxes and fit residuals obtained with Suzaku/XIS and XMM-Newton/EPIC-pn for the same cluster. The temperatures measured in the hard 2.0-7.0 keV energy band with all instruments are consistent within 5 %. However, temperatures obtained with the XIS instruments in the soft 0.5-2.0 keV band disagree by 9-29 %. We investigated residuals in the XIS soft band, which showed that if XIS0 effective area shape is accurately calibrated, the effective areas of XIS1 and XIS3 are overestimated below 1.0 keV (or vice versa). Adjustments to the modelling of the column density of the XIS contaminant in the 3-6 arcmin extraction region while forcing consistent emission models in each instrument for a given cluster significantly improved the fits. The oxygen column density in XIS1 and XIS3 contaminant must be increased by 1-2E17 cm^-2 in comparison to the values implemented in the current calibration, while the column density of the XIS0 contaminant given by the analysis is consistent with the public calibration. XIS soft band temperatures obtained with the modification to the column density of the contaminant agree better with temperatures obtained with the EPIC-pn instrument of XMM-Newton, than with those derived using the Chandra-ACIS instrument. However, comparison of hard band fluxes obtained using Suzaku-XIS to fluxes obtained using the Chandra-ACIS and EPIC-pn instruments proved inconclusive.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Bulk motion measurements in clusters of galaxies with ATHENA-like missions
Authors:
J. Nevalainen
Abstract:
The hierarchical formation of clusters of galaxies by accretion of material releases gravitational energy which dissipates into the intracluster gas. The process heats the material and generates gas turbulence and bulk motions and thus kinetic pressure. Map** the velocity fields of the moving subunits would enable a new diagnostics tool for cluster formation studies and unbiased X-ray mass estim…
▽ More
The hierarchical formation of clusters of galaxies by accretion of material releases gravitational energy which dissipates into the intracluster gas. The process heats the material and generates gas turbulence and bulk motions and thus kinetic pressure. Map** the velocity fields of the moving subunits would enable a new diagnostics tool for cluster formation studies and unbiased X-ray mass estimates. The required spatially resolved high resolution spectroscopy is not currently available. I demonstrate here the feasibility of detecting and map** the velocities of the bulk motions using the Doppler shift of the Fe XXV K alpha line with the proposed ATHENA satellite.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Chandra X-ray observations of Abell 1835 to the virial radius
Authors:
M. Bonamente,
D. Landry,
B. Maughan,
P. Giles,
M. Joy,
J. Nevalainen
Abstract:
We report the first Chandra detection of emission out to the virial radius in the cluster Abell 1835 at z=0.253. Our analysis of the soft X-ray surface brightness shows that emission is present out to a radial distance of 10 arcmin or 2.4 Mpc, and the temperature profile has a factor of ten drop from the peak temperature of 10 keV to the value at the virial radius. We model the Chandra data from t…
▽ More
We report the first Chandra detection of emission out to the virial radius in the cluster Abell 1835 at z=0.253. Our analysis of the soft X-ray surface brightness shows that emission is present out to a radial distance of 10 arcmin or 2.4 Mpc, and the temperature profile has a factor of ten drop from the peak temperature of 10 keV to the value at the virial radius. We model the Chandra data from the core to the virial radius and show that the steep temperature profile is not compatible with hydrostatic equilibrium of the hot gas, and that the gas is convectively unstable at the outskirts. A possible interpretation of the Chandra data is the presence of a second phase of warm-hot gas near the cluster's virial radius that is not in hydrostatic equilibrium with the cluster's potential. The observations are also consistent with an alternative scenario in which the gas is significantly clumped at large radii.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2012; v1 submitted 26 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
Simulated performance of a single pixel PIN spectrometer SCXM equipped with concentrator optics in Solar coronal X-ray observations
Authors:
L. Alha,
J. Huovelin,
J. Nevalainen
Abstract:
In this paper we present simulated solar coronal X-ray observations to verify the sensitivity of a new hypothetical instrument design. These simulations are folded through this X-ray spectrometer having a moderate size circular field of view of 1.6 degrees. This SCXM (Solar Coronal X-ray Mapper) is designed to compose of a single pixel silicon PIN detector equipped with a single reflection double…
▽ More
In this paper we present simulated solar coronal X-ray observations to verify the sensitivity of a new hypothetical instrument design. These simulations are folded through this X-ray spectrometer having a moderate size circular field of view of 1.6 degrees. This SCXM (Solar Coronal X-ray Mapper) is designed to compose of a single pixel silicon PIN detector equipped with a single reflection double frustum X-ray optics. A moderate FoV would enable a morphological study of the expanded X-ray emission from the solar corona during a high activity of the Sun. The main scientific task of SCXM would be the map** of the coronal X-ray emission, i.e. to resolve the radial distribution of the X-ray surface brightness around the Sun. These kind of off-limb observations would help to interpret the coronal plasma diagnostics as a function of the elongation angle. Direct solar full disc observations could be also performed with SCXM. In this work we have applied real solar coronal X-ray data obtained by the SMART-1 XSM (X-ray Solar Monitor) to simulate on-solar observations at different flux levels to derive full disc sensitivity and performance of SCXM. A challenging attempt for SCXM would also be to distinguish the X-ray spectrum of the decaying axions around the Sun. These axions are assumed to be created as side products of fusion reactions in the core of the Sun. These axions are predicted to be gravitationally trapped to orbit the Sun forming a halo-like X-ray emitting object. No signature of an axion X-ray emission around the Sun has been observed to this day. This simple X-ray spectrometer with an optical concentrator would be an inexpensive instrument with low mass and telemetry budgets compared with more accurate X-ray instruments of imaging capability. Hence SCXM would be an advanced choice as an auxiliary instrument for solar coronal X-ray observations.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2011; v1 submitted 25 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
X-ray spectroscopy of Abell S1101 with Chandra, XMM-Newton and ROSAT: band-pass dependence of he temperature profile and soft excess emission
Authors:
Max Bonamente,
Jukka Nevalainen
Abstract:
We present spatially-resolved spectroscopy of the galaxy cluster Abell S1101, also known as Sersic 159-03, with Chandra, XMM-Newton and ROSAT, and investigate the presence of soft X-ray excess emission above the contribution from the hot intra-cluster medium. In earlier papers we reported an extremely bright soft excess component that reached 100% of the thermal radiation in the R2 ROSAT band (0.2…
▽ More
We present spatially-resolved spectroscopy of the galaxy cluster Abell S1101, also known as Sersic 159-03, with Chandra, XMM-Newton and ROSAT, and investigate the presence of soft X-ray excess emission above the contribution from the hot intra-cluster medium. In earlier papers we reported an extremely bright soft excess component that reached 100% of the thermal radiation in the R2 ROSAT band (0.2-0.4 keV), using the HI column density measurement by Dickey and Lockman. In this paper we use the newer Leiden-Argentine-Bonn survey measurements of the HI column density towards Abell S1101, significantly lower than the previous value, and show that the soft excess emission in Abell S1101 is now at the level of 10-20% of the hot gas emission, in line with those of a large sample of clusters analyzed by Bonamente et al. in 2002. The ROSAT soft excess emission is detected regardless of calibration uncertainties between Chandra and XMM-Newoton. This new analysis of Abell S1101 indicate that the 1/4keV band emission is compatible with the presence of WHIM filaments connected to the cluster and extending outward into the intergalactic medium; the temperatures we find in this study are typically lower than the WHIM probed in other X-ray studies. We also show that the soft excess emission is compatible with a non-thermal origin as the inverse Compton scattering of relativistic electrons off the cosmic microwave background, with pressure less than 1% of the thermal electrons.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2011;
originally announced July 2011.
-
Planck Early Results XXVI: Detection with Planck and confirmation by XMM-Newton of PLCK G266.6-27.3, an exceptionally X-ray luminous and massive galaxy cluster at z~1
Authors:
Planck Collaboration,
N. Aghanim,
M. Arnaud,
M. Ashdown,
F. Atrio-Barandela,
J. Aumont,
C. Baccigalupi,
A. Balbi,
A. J. Banday,
R. B. Barreiro,
J. G. Bartlett,
E. Battaner,
K. Benabed,
A. Benoît,
J. -P. Bernard,
M. Bersanelli,
R. Bhatia,
H. Böhringer,
A. Bonaldi,
J. R. Bond,
S. Borgani,
J. Borrill,
F. R. Bouchet,
M. L. Brown,
C. Burigana
, et al. (167 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present first results on PLCK G266.6-27.3, a galaxy cluster candidate detected at a signal-to-noise ratio of 5 in the Planck All Sky survey. An XMM-Newton validation observation has allowed us to confirm that the candidate is a bona fide galaxy cluster. With these X-ray data we measure an accurate redshift, z = 0.94 +/- 0.02, and estimate the cluster mass to be M_500 = (7.8 +/- 0.8)e+14 solar m…
▽ More
We present first results on PLCK G266.6-27.3, a galaxy cluster candidate detected at a signal-to-noise ratio of 5 in the Planck All Sky survey. An XMM-Newton validation observation has allowed us to confirm that the candidate is a bona fide galaxy cluster. With these X-ray data we measure an accurate redshift, z = 0.94 +/- 0.02, and estimate the cluster mass to be M_500 = (7.8 +/- 0.8)e+14 solar masses. PLCK G266.6-27.3 is an exceptional system: its luminosity of L_X(0.5-2.0 keV)=(1.4 +/- 0.05)e+45 erg/s, equals that of the two most luminous known clusters in the z > 0.5 universe, and it is one of the most massive clusters at z~1. Moreover, unlike the majority of high-redshift clusters, PLCK G266.6-27.3 appears to be highly relaxed. This observation confirms Planck's capability of detecting high-redshift, high-mass clusters, and opens the way to the systematic study of population evolution in the exponential tail of the mass function.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2011; v1 submitted 7 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
-
Suzaku observations of X-ray excess emission in the cluster of galaxies A3112
Authors:
T. Lehto,
J. Nevalainen,
M. Bonamente,
N. Ota,
J. Kaastra
Abstract:
We analysed the Suzaku XIS1 data of the A3112 cluster of galaxies in order to examine the X-ray excess emission in this cluster reported earlier with the XMM-Newton and Chandra satellites. The best-fit temperature of the intracluster gas depends strongly on the choice of the energy band used for the spectral analysis. This proves the existence of excess emission component in addition to the single…
▽ More
We analysed the Suzaku XIS1 data of the A3112 cluster of galaxies in order to examine the X-ray excess emission in this cluster reported earlier with the XMM-Newton and Chandra satellites. The best-fit temperature of the intracluster gas depends strongly on the choice of the energy band used for the spectral analysis. This proves the existence of excess emission component in addition to the single-temperature MEKAL in A3112. We showed that this effect is not an artifact due to uncertainties of the background modeling, instrument calibration or the amount of Galactic absorption. Neither does the PSF scatter of the emission from the cool core nor the projection of the cool gas in the cluster outskirts produce the effect. Finally we modeled the excess emission either by using an additional MEKAL or powerlaw component. Due to the small differencies between thermal and non-thermal model we can not rule out the non-thermal origin of the excess emission based on the goodness of the fit. Assuming that it has a thermal origin, we further examined the Differential Emission Measure (DEM) models. We utilised two different DEM models, a Gaussian differential emission measure distribution (GDEM) and WDEM model, where the emission measure of a number of thermal components is distributed as a truncated power law. The best-fit XIS1 MEKAL temperature for the 0.4-7.0 keV band is 4.7+-0.1 keV, consistent with that obtained using GDEM and WDEM models.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
-
Cross-calibrating X-ray detectors with clusters of galaxies: an IACHEC study
Authors:
J. Nevalainen,
L. David,
M. Guainazzi
Abstract:
We used a sample of 11 nearby relaxed clusters of galaxies observed with the X-ray instruments XMM-Newton (EPIC) pn and MOS, Chandra ACIS-S and ACIS-I and BeppoSAX MECS to examine the cross-calibration of the energy dependence and normalisation of the effective area of these instruments as of December 2009. We also examined the Fe XXV/XXVI line ratio temperature measurement method for the pn and M…
▽ More
We used a sample of 11 nearby relaxed clusters of galaxies observed with the X-ray instruments XMM-Newton (EPIC) pn and MOS, Chandra ACIS-S and ACIS-I and BeppoSAX MECS to examine the cross-calibration of the energy dependence and normalisation of the effective area of these instruments as of December 2009. We also examined the Fe XXV/XXVI line ratio temperature measurement method for the pn and MOS. We performed X-ray spectral analysis on the XMM-Newton and Chandra data for a sample of 11 clusters. We obtained the information for BeppoSAX from DeGrandi & Molendi (2002). We compared the spectroscopic results obtained with different instruments for the same clusters in order to examine possible systematic calibration effects between the instruments. We did not detect any significant systematic differences between the temperatures derived in the 2-7 keV band using the different instruments. Also, the EPIC temperatures derived from the bremsstrahlung continuum agreed with those obtained from the Fe XXV/XXVI emission line ratio, implying that the energy dependence of the hard band effective area of the above instruments is accurately calibrated. On the other hand, the hard band EPIC/ACIS fluxes disagreed by 5-10% (i.e. at 6-25 sigma level) which indicates a similar level of uncertainty in the normalisations of the effective areas of these instruments in the 2--7 keV band. In the soft energy band (0.5-2.0 keV) there are greater cross-calibration differences between EPIC and ACIS. Due to the high statistical weight of the soft band data, the 0.5-7.0 keV band temperature measurements of clusters of galaxies with EPIC or ACIS are uncertain by ~10-15% on average.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2010;
originally announced August 2010.
-
GMRT observations of the Ophiuchus galaxy cluster
Authors:
M. Murgia,
D. Eckert,
F. Govoni,
C. Ferrari,
M. Pandey-Pommier,
J. Nevalainen,
S. Paltani
Abstract:
VLA observations at 1477 MHz revealed the presence of a radio mini-halo surrounding the faint central point-like radio source in the Ophiuchus cluster of galaxies. In this work we present a study of the radio emission from this cluster of galaxies at lower radio frequencies. We observed the Ophiuchus cluster at 153, 240, and 614 MHz with the GMRT. The mini-halo is clearly detected at 153 and 240…
▽ More
VLA observations at 1477 MHz revealed the presence of a radio mini-halo surrounding the faint central point-like radio source in the Ophiuchus cluster of galaxies. In this work we present a study of the radio emission from this cluster of galaxies at lower radio frequencies. We observed the Ophiuchus cluster at 153, 240, and 614 MHz with the GMRT. The mini-halo is clearly detected at 153 and 240 MHz while it is not detected at 610 MHz. The most prominent feature at low frequencies is a patch of diffuse steep spectrum emission located at about 5' south-east from the cluster center. By combining these images with that at 1477 MHz, we derived the spectral index of the mini-halo. Globally, the mini-halo has a low-frequency spectral index of alpha_240^153 ~1.4 +/- 0.3 and an high-frequency spectral index of alpha_1477^240 ~ 1.60 +/- 0.05. Moreover, we measure a systematic increase of the high-frequency spectral index with radius: the azimuthal radial average of alpha_1477^240 increases from about 1.3, at the cluster center, up to about 2.0 in the mini-halo outskirts. The observed radio spectral index is in agreement with that obtained by modeling the non-thermal hard X-ray emission in this cluster of galaxies. We assume that the X-ray component arises from inverse Compton scattering between the photons of the cosmic microwave background and a population of non-thermal electrons which are isotropically distributed and whose energy spectrum is a power law with index p. We derive that the electrons energy spectrum should extend from a minimum Lorentz factor of gamma_min < 700 up to a maximum Lorentz factor of gamma_max =3.8 x 10^4 with an index p=3.8 +/- 0.4. The volume-averaged strength for a completely disordered intra-cluster magnetic field is B_V ~0.3 +/- 0.1 micro-G.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2010;
originally announced February 2010.
-
XMM-Newton and INTEGRAL analysis of the Ophiuchus cluster of galaxies
Authors:
J. Nevalainen,
D. Eckert,
J. Kaastra,
M. Bonamente,
K. Kettula
Abstract:
We investigated the non-thermal hard X-ray emission in the Ophiuchus cluster of galaxies. Our aim was to characterise the physical properties of the non-thermal component and its interaction with the cosmic microwave background. We performed spatially resolved spectroscopy and imaging using XMM-Newton data to model the thermal emission. Combining this with INTEGRAL ISGRI data, we modeled the 0.6…
▽ More
We investigated the non-thermal hard X-ray emission in the Ophiuchus cluster of galaxies. Our aim was to characterise the physical properties of the non-thermal component and its interaction with the cosmic microwave background. We performed spatially resolved spectroscopy and imaging using XMM-Newton data to model the thermal emission. Combining this with INTEGRAL ISGRI data, we modeled the 0.6-140 keV band total emission in the central 7 arcmin region. The models that best describe both PN and ISGRI data contain a power-law component with a photon index in a range 2.2-2.5. This component produces ~10% of the total flux in the 1-10 keV band. The pressure of the non-thermal electrons is ~1% of that of the thermal electrons. Our results support the scenario whereby a relativistic electron population, which produces the recently detected radio mini-halo in Ophiuchus, also produces the hard X-rays via inverse compton scattering of the CMB photons. The best-fit models imply a differential momentum spectrum of the relativistic electrons with a slope of 3.4-4.0 and a magnetic field strength B=0.05-0.15 microG. The lack of evidence for a recent major merger in the Ophiuchus center allows the possibility that the relativistic electrons are produced by turbulence or hadronic collisions.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2009; v1 submitted 8 October, 2009;
originally announced October 2009.
-
Exploring the spreading layer of GX 9+9 using RXTE and INTEGRAL
Authors:
P. Savolainen,
D. C. Hannikainen,
O. Vilhu,
A. Paizis,
J. Nevalainen,
P. Hakala
Abstract:
We have fitted ~200 RXTE and INTEGRAL spectra of the neutron star LMXB GX 9+9 from 2002-2007 with a model consisting of a disc blackbody and another blackbody representing the spreading layer (SL), i.e. an extended accretion zone on the NS surface as opposed to the more traditional disc-like boundary layer. Contrary to theory, the SL temperature was seen to increase towards low SL luminosities,…
▽ More
We have fitted ~200 RXTE and INTEGRAL spectra of the neutron star LMXB GX 9+9 from 2002-2007 with a model consisting of a disc blackbody and another blackbody representing the spreading layer (SL), i.e. an extended accretion zone on the NS surface as opposed to the more traditional disc-like boundary layer. Contrary to theory, the SL temperature was seen to increase towards low SL luminosities, while the approximate angular extent had a nearly linear luminosity dependency. Comptonization was not required to adequately fit these spectra. Together with the ~70 degree upper bound of inclination implied by the lack of eclipses, the best-fitting normalization of the accretion disc blackbody component implies a distance of ~10 kpc, instead of the usually quoted 5 kpc.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2008;
originally announced November 2008.
-
Future instrumentation for the study of the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium
Authors:
F. B. S. Paerels,
J. S. Kaastra,
T. Ohashi,
P. Richter,
A. M. Bykov,
J. Nevalainen
Abstract:
We briefly review capabilities and requirements for future instrumentation in UV- and X-ray astronomy that can contribute to advancing our understanding of the diffuse, highly ionised intergalactic medium.
We briefly review capabilities and requirements for future instrumentation in UV- and X-ray astronomy that can contribute to advancing our understanding of the diffuse, highly ionised intergalactic medium.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
Nonthermal phenomena in clusters of galaxies
Authors:
Y. Rephaeli,
J. Nevalainen,
T. Ohashi,
A. M. Bykov
Abstract:
Recent observations of high energy (> 20 keV) X-ray emission in a few clusters of galaxies broaden our knowledge of physical phenomena in the intracluster space. This emission is likely to be nonthermal, probably resulting from Compton scattering of relativistic electrons by the cosmic microwave background (CMB) radiation. Direct evidence for the presence of relativistic electrons in some 50 clu…
▽ More
Recent observations of high energy (> 20 keV) X-ray emission in a few clusters of galaxies broaden our knowledge of physical phenomena in the intracluster space. This emission is likely to be nonthermal, probably resulting from Compton scattering of relativistic electrons by the cosmic microwave background (CMB) radiation. Direct evidence for the presence of relativistic electrons in some 50 clusters comes from measurements of extended radio emission in their central regions. We briefly review the main results from observations of extended regions of radio emission, and Faraday rotation measurements of background and cluster radio sources. The main focus of the review are searches for nonthermal X-ray emission conducted with past and currently operating satellites, which yielded appreciable evidence for nonthermal emission components in the spectra of a few clusters. This evidence is clearly not unequivocal, due to substantial observational and systematic uncertainties, in addition to virtually complete lack of spatial information. If indeed the emission has its origin in Compton scattering of relativistic electrons by the CMB, then the mean magnetic field strength and density of relativistic electrons in the cluster can be directly determined. Knowledge of these basic nonthermal quantities is valuable for the detailed description of processes in intracluster gas and for the origin of magnetic fields.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
Soft X-ray and extreme ultraviolet excess emission from clusters of galaxies
Authors:
F. Durret,
J. S. Kaastra,
J. Nevalainen,
T. Ohashi,
N. Werner
Abstract:
An excess over the extrapolation to the extreme ultraviolet and soft X-ray ranges of the thermal emission from the hot intracluster medium has been detected in a number of clusters of galaxies. We briefly present each of the satellites (EUVE, ROSAT PSPC and BeppoSAX, and presently XMM-Newton, Chandra and Suzaku) and their corresponding instrumental issues, which are responsible for the fact that…
▽ More
An excess over the extrapolation to the extreme ultraviolet and soft X-ray ranges of the thermal emission from the hot intracluster medium has been detected in a number of clusters of galaxies. We briefly present each of the satellites (EUVE, ROSAT PSPC and BeppoSAX, and presently XMM-Newton, Chandra and Suzaku) and their corresponding instrumental issues, which are responsible for the fact that this soft excess remains controversial in a number of cases. We then review the evidence for this soft X-ray excess and discuss the possible mechanisms (thermal and non-thermal) which could be responsible for this emission.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
Clusters of galaxies: beyond the thermal view
Authors:
J. S. Kaastra,
A. M. Bykov,
S. Schindler,
J. A. M. Bleeker,
S. Borgani,
A. Diaferio,
K. Dolag,
F. Durret,
J. Nevalainen,
T. Ohashi,
F. B. S. Paerels,
V. Petrosian,
Y. Rephaeli,
P. Richter,
J. Schaye,
N. Werner
Abstract:
We present the work of an international team at the International Space Science Institute (ISSI) in Bern that worked together to review the current observational and theoretical status of the non-virialised X-ray emission components in clusters of galaxies. The subject is important for the study of large-scale hierarchical structure formation and to shed light on the "missing baryon" problem. Th…
▽ More
We present the work of an international team at the International Space Science Institute (ISSI) in Bern that worked together to review the current observational and theoretical status of the non-virialised X-ray emission components in clusters of galaxies. The subject is important for the study of large-scale hierarchical structure formation and to shed light on the "missing baryon" problem. The topics of the team work include thermal emission and absorption from the warm-hot intergalactic medium, non-thermal X-ray emission in clusters of galaxies, physical processes and chemical enrichment of this medium and clusters of galaxies, and the relationship between all these processes. One of the main goals of the team is to write and discuss a series of review papers on this subject. These reviews are intended as introductory text and reference for scientists wishing to work actively in this field. The team consists of sixteen experts in observations, theory and numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
Soft and hard X-ray excess emission in Abell 3112 observed with Chandra
Authors:
M. Bonamente,
J. Nevalainen,
R. Lieu
Abstract:
Chandra ACIS-S observations of the galaxy cluster A3112 feature the presence of an excess of X-ray emission above the contribution from the diffuse hot gas, which can be equally well modeled with an additional non-thermal power-law model or with a low-temperature thermal model of low metal abundance. We show that the excess emission cannot be due to uncertainties in the background subtraction or…
▽ More
Chandra ACIS-S observations of the galaxy cluster A3112 feature the presence of an excess of X-ray emission above the contribution from the diffuse hot gas, which can be equally well modeled with an additional non-thermal power-law model or with a low-temperature thermal model of low metal abundance. We show that the excess emission cannot be due to uncertainties in the background subtraction or in the Galactic HI column density. Calibration uncertainties in the ACIS detector that may affect our results are addressed by comparing the Chandra data to XMM MOS and PN spectra. While differences between the three instruments remain, all detect the excess in similar amounts, providing evidence against an instrumental nature of the excess. Given the presence of non-thermal radio emission near the center of A3112, we argue that the excess X-ray emission is of non-thermal nature and distributed throughout the entire X-ray bandpass, from soft to hard X-rays. The excess can be explained with the presence of a population of relativistic electrons with ~7% of the cluster's gas pressure. We also discuss a possible thermal nature of the excess, and examine the problems associated with such interpretation.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2007;
originally announced July 2007.
-
Constraints on the parameters of radiatively decaying dark matter from the dark matter halo of the Milky Way and Ursa Minor
Authors:
Alexey Boyarsky,
Jukka Nevalainen,
Oleg Ruchayskiy
Abstract:
We improve the earlier restrictions on parameters of the dark matter (DM) in the form of a sterile neutrino. The results were obtained from non-observing the DM decay line in the X-ray spectrum of the Milky Way (using the recent XMM-Newton PN blank sky data). We also present a similar constraint coming from the recent XMM-Newton observation of Ursa Minor -- dark, X-ray quiet dwarf spheroidal gal…
▽ More
We improve the earlier restrictions on parameters of the dark matter (DM) in the form of a sterile neutrino. The results were obtained from non-observing the DM decay line in the X-ray spectrum of the Milky Way (using the recent XMM-Newton PN blank sky data). We also present a similar constraint coming from the recent XMM-Newton observation of Ursa Minor -- dark, X-ray quiet dwarf spheroidal galaxy. The new Milky way data improve on (by as much as the order of magnitude at masses ~3.5 keV) existing constraints. Although the observation of Ursa Minor has relatively poor statistics, the constraints are comparable to those recently obtained using observations of the Large Magellanic Cloud or M31. This confirms a recent proposal that dwarf satellites of the MW are very interesting candidates for the DM search and dedicated studies should be made to this purpose.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2007; v1 submitted 31 October, 2006;
originally announced October 2006.
-
Revisiting the soft X-ray excess emission in clusters of galaxies observed with XMM-Newton
Authors:
J. Nevalainen,
M. Bonamente,
J. Kaastra
Abstract:
We analyze four XMM-Newton galaxy clusters in order to test whether their soft X-ray excess emission in the 0.2-0.5 keV band as reported by Kaastra et al. (2003) maintains after the application of the current knowledge of the XMM-Newton background and calibration. We show that in the bright central 500 kpc regions the details of the background modeling are insignificant. Thus, the cluster soft e…
▽ More
We analyze four XMM-Newton galaxy clusters in order to test whether their soft X-ray excess emission in the 0.2-0.5 keV band as reported by Kaastra et al. (2003) maintains after the application of the current knowledge of the XMM-Newton background and calibration. We show that in the bright central 500 kpc regions the details of the background modeling are insignificant. Thus, the cluster soft excess is not a background artifact, contrary to recent claims by Bregman et al. (2006). We find evidence that the change in PN calibration between years 2002 and 2005 results in significant decrease of the soft excess signal. However, the MOS instruments measure significant amounts of soft excess, or sub-Galactic NH. These differences are compatible with the current level of uncertainty in the calibration of both instruments.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2006; v1 submitted 16 October, 2006;
originally announced October 2006.