-
Polar alignment of a dusty circumbinary disc -- I. Dust ring formation
Authors:
Jeremy L. Smallwood,
Min-Kai Lin,
Hossam Aly,
Rebecca Nealon,
Cristiano Longarini
Abstract:
We investigate the formation of dust traffic jams in polar-aligning circumbinary discs. We use 3D smoothed particle hydrodynamical simulations of both gas and dust to model an initially highly misaligned circumbinary disc around an eccentric binary. As the circumbinary disc evolves to a polar configuration (perpendicular to the binary orbital plane), the difference in the precession between the ga…
▽ More
We investigate the formation of dust traffic jams in polar-aligning circumbinary discs. We use 3D smoothed particle hydrodynamical simulations of both gas and dust to model an initially highly misaligned circumbinary disc around an eccentric binary. As the circumbinary disc evolves to a polar configuration (perpendicular to the binary orbital plane), the difference in the precession between the gas and dust produces dust traffic jams, which become dense dust rings. We find the formation of dust rings exists for different Stokes number, binary eccentricity, and initial disc tilt. Dust rings are only produced while the circumbinary disc is misaligned to the binary orbital plane. When the disc becomes polar aligned, the dust rings are still present and long-lived. Once these dust rings are formed, they drift inward. The drift timescale depends on the Stokes number. The lower the Stokes number, the faster the dust ring drifts near the inner edge of the disc. The dust rings will have an increased midplane dust-to-go ratio, which may be a favourable environment for the steaming instability to operate.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
V892 Tau: A tidally perturbed circumbinary disc in a triple stellar system
Authors:
Antoine Alaguero,
Nicolás Cuello,
François Ménard,
Simone Ceppi,
Álvaro Ribas,
Rebecca Nealon,
Miguel Vioque,
Andrés Izquierdo,
James Miley,
Enrique Macías,
Daniel J. Price
Abstract:
V892 Tau is a young binary star surrounded by a circumbinary disc which show hints of interaction with the low-mass nearby star V892 Tau NE. The goal of this paper is to constrain the orbit of V892 Tau NE and to determine the resulting circumbinary disc dynamics. We present new ALMA observations of the V892 Tau circumbinary disc at a twice higher angular and spectral resolution. We model the data…
▽ More
V892 Tau is a young binary star surrounded by a circumbinary disc which show hints of interaction with the low-mass nearby star V892 Tau NE. The goal of this paper is to constrain the orbit of V892 Tau NE and to determine the resulting circumbinary disc dynamics. We present new ALMA observations of the V892 Tau circumbinary disc at a twice higher angular and spectral resolution. We model the data with V892 Tau as a triple system and perform a grid of hydrodynamical simulations testing several orbits of the companion. The simulation outputs are then post-processed to build synthetic maps that we compare to the observations. The 12CO emission of the disc shows clear non-Keplerian features such as spiral arms. When comparing the data with our synthetic observations, we interpret these features as ongoing interactions with the companion. Our simulations indicate that an eccentricity of 0.5 of the companion is needed to reproduce the observed disc extent and that a mutual inclination of approximately 60° with the inner binary reproduces the measured disc tilt. In order to explain most of the features of the circumbinary disc, we propose that V892 Tau NE follows a misaligned eccentric orbit, with an eccentricity between 0.2 and 0.5 and a mutual inclination between 30° and 60°. Such a misaligned companion suggests the disc is oscillating and precessing with time, stabilising in an intermediate plane with a non-zero mutual inclination with the inner binary. Given that orbital configuration, we show that the stability of future planets is compromised in the second half of the disc once the gas has dissipated.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Atmospheric characterisation and tighter constraints on the orbital misalignment of WASP-94 A b with HARPS
Authors:
E. Ahrer,
J. V. Seidel,
L. Doyle,
S. Gandhi,
B. Prinoth,
H. M. Cegla,
C. H. McDonald,
N. Astudillo-Defru,
E. Ayache,
R. Nealon,
Dimitri Veras,
P. J. Wheatley,
D. Ehrenreich
Abstract:
We present high spectral resolution observations of the hot Jupiter WASP-94 A b using the HARPS instrument on ESO's 3.6m telescope in La Silla, Chile. We probed for Na absorption in its atmosphere as well as constrained the previously reported misaligned retrograde orbit using the Rossiter-McLaughlin effect. Additionally, we undertook a combined atmospheric retrieval analysis with previously publi…
▽ More
We present high spectral resolution observations of the hot Jupiter WASP-94 A b using the HARPS instrument on ESO's 3.6m telescope in La Silla, Chile. We probed for Na absorption in its atmosphere as well as constrained the previously reported misaligned retrograde orbit using the Rossiter-McLaughlin effect. Additionally, we undertook a combined atmospheric retrieval analysis with previously published low-resolution data. We confirm the retrograde orbit as well as constrain the orbital misalignment with our measurement of a projected spin-orbit obliquity of $λ= 123.0 \pm 3.0 ^\circ$. We find a tentative detection of Na absorption in the atmosphere of WASP-94 A b, independent of the treatment of the Rossiter-McLaughlin effect in our analysis (3.6$σ$ and 4.4$σ$). We combine our HARPS high resolution data with low resolution data from the literature and find that while the posterior distribution of the Na abundance results in a tighter constraint than using a single data set, the detection significance does not improve (3.2$σ$), which we attribute to degeneracies between the low and high resolution data.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
The orbit of HD 142527 B is too compact to explain many of the disc features
Authors:
M. Nowak,
S. Rowther,
S. Lacour,
F. Meru,
R. Nealon,
D. J. Price
Abstract:
HD 142527 A is a young and massive Herbig Ae/Be star surrounded by a highly structured disc. The disc shows numerous morphological structures, such as spiral arms, a horseshoe region of dust emission, a set of shadows cast by an inner disc on the outer disc, and a large cavity extending from $\simeq{}$30 au to $\simeq{}$130 au. HD 142527 A also has a lower mass companion, HD 142527 B (M = 0.13…
▽ More
HD 142527 A is a young and massive Herbig Ae/Be star surrounded by a highly structured disc. The disc shows numerous morphological structures, such as spiral arms, a horseshoe region of dust emission, a set of shadows cast by an inner disc on the outer disc, and a large cavity extending from $\simeq{}$30 au to $\simeq{}$130 au. HD 142527 A also has a lower mass companion, HD 142527 B (M = 0.13 $\pm$ 0.03 $M_\odot{}$), which is thought to be responsible for most of the structures observed in the surrounding disc. We gathered VLTI/GRAVITY observations of HD 142527, either from our own programmes or from the ESO archive. We used this inhomogeneous set of data to extract a total of seven high-precision measurements of the relative astrometry between HD 142527 A and B, spread from mid-2017 to early 2021. Combined with what is available in the literature, we now have 9 yr of astrometric monitoring on HD 142527. We used orbit fitting tools to determine the orbital parameters of HD 142527 B, and used them as inputs for a 3D hydrodynamical model of the disc to determine whether or not the binary is able to create the structures observed in the disc. Our VLTI/GRAVITY astrometry gives excellent constraints on the orbit of HD 142527 B. We show that the secondary is following an orbit of semi-major axis a = 10.80 $\pm$ 0.22 au, with moderate eccentricity (e = 0.47 $\pm$ 0.01). With such a compact orbit, we show that HD 142527 B can only generate a gap and spiral arms of $\sim$30 au in the disc, which is much smaller than what is revealed by observations. Even from a theoretical standpoint, the observed cavity size of $\sim$100 au far exceeds even the most generous predictions for a companion like HD 142527 B on such a compact orbit. Thus, we conclude that the low-mass companion cannot be solely responsible for the observed morphology of the disc surrounding the system.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
The Role of Drag and Gravity on Dust Concentration in a Gravitationally Unstable Disc
Authors:
Sahl Rowther,
Rebecca Nealon,
Farzana Meru,
James Wurster,
Hossam Aly,
Richard Alexander,
Ken Rice,
Richard A. Booth
Abstract:
We carry out three dimensional smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations to study the role of gravitational and drag forces on the concentration of large dust grains (St > 1) in the spiral arms of gravitationally unstable protoplanetary discs, and the resulting implications for planet formation. We find that both drag and gravity play an important role in the evolution of large dust grains. If w…
▽ More
We carry out three dimensional smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations to study the role of gravitational and drag forces on the concentration of large dust grains (St > 1) in the spiral arms of gravitationally unstable protoplanetary discs, and the resulting implications for planet formation. We find that both drag and gravity play an important role in the evolution of large dust grains. If we include both, grains that would otherwise be partially decoupled will become well coupled and trace the spirals. For the dust grains most influenced by drag (with Stokes numbers near unity), the dust disc quickly becomes gravitationally unstable and rapidly forms clumps with masses between 0.15 - 6 Earth masses. A large fraction of clumps are below the threshold where runaway gas accretion can occur. However, if dust self-gravity is neglected, the dust is unable to form clumps, despite still becoming trapped in the gas spirals. When large dust grains are unable to feel either gas gravity or drag, the dust is unable to trace the gas spirals. Hence, full physics is needed to properly simulate dust in gravitationally unstable discs.
Dust trap** of large grains in spiral arms of discs stable to gas fragmentation could explain planet formation in very young discs by a population of planetesimals formed due to the combined roles of drag and gravity in the earliest stages of a disc's evolution. Furthermore, it highlights that gravitationally unstable discs are not just important for forming gas giants quickly, it can also rapidly form Earth mass bodies.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2024; v1 submitted 17 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
WInDI: a Warp-Induced Dust Instability in protoplanetary discs
Authors:
Hossam Aly,
Rebecca Nealon,
Jean-François Gonzalez
Abstract:
We identify a new dust instability that occurs in warped discs. The instability is caused by the oscillatory gas motions induced by the warp in the bending wave regime. We first demonstrate the instability using a local 1D (vertical) toy model based on the warped shearing box coordinates and investigate the effects of the warp magnitude and dust Stokes number on the growth of the instability. We t…
▽ More
We identify a new dust instability that occurs in warped discs. The instability is caused by the oscillatory gas motions induced by the warp in the bending wave regime. We first demonstrate the instability using a local 1D (vertical) toy model based on the warped shearing box coordinates and investigate the effects of the warp magnitude and dust Stokes number on the growth of the instability. We then run 3D SPH simulations and show that the instability is manifested globally by producing unique dust structures that do not correspond to gas pressure maxima. The 1D and SPH analysis suggest that the instability grows on dynamical timescales and hence is potentially significant for planet formation.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Formation of misaligned second-generation discs through flyby encounters
Authors:
Jeremy L. Smallwood,
Rebecca Nealon,
Nicolás Cuello,
Ruobing Dong,
Richard A. Booth
Abstract:
Observations reveal protoplanetary discs being perturbed by flyby candidates. We simulate a scenario where an unbound perturber, i.e., a flyby, undergoes an inclined grazing encounter, capturing material and forming a second-generation protoplanetary disc. We run $N$--body and three-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations of a parabolic flyby grazing a particle disc and a gas-rich protoplanetary di…
▽ More
Observations reveal protoplanetary discs being perturbed by flyby candidates. We simulate a scenario where an unbound perturber, i.e., a flyby, undergoes an inclined grazing encounter, capturing material and forming a second-generation protoplanetary disc. We run $N$--body and three-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations of a parabolic flyby grazing a particle disc and a gas-rich protoplanetary disc, respectively. In both our $N$--body and hydrodynamic simulations, we find that the captured, second-generation disc forms at a tilt twice the initial flyby tilt. This relationship is robust to variations in the flyby's tilt, position angle, periastron, and mass. We extend this concept by also simulating the case where the flyby has a disc of material prior to the encounter but we do not find the same trend. An inclined disc with respect to the primary disc around a misaligned flyby is tilted by a few degrees, remaining close to its initial disc tilt. Therefore, if a disc is present around the flyby before the encounter, the disc may not tilt up to twice the perturber tilt depending on the balance between the angular momentum of the circumsecondary disc and captured particles. In the case where the perturber has no initial disc, analyzing the orientation of these second-generation discs can give information about the orbital properties of the flyby encounter.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
The surprising evolution of the shadow on the TW Hya disk
Authors:
J. Debes,
R. Nealon,
R. Alexander,
A. J. Weinberger,
S. G. Wolff,
D. Hines,
J. Kastner,
H. Jang-Condell,
C. Pinte,
P. Plavchan,
L. Pueyo
Abstract:
We report new total intensity visible light high contrast imaging of the TW Hya disk taken with the Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph (STIS) on the Hubble Space Telescope (HST). This represents the first published images of the disk with STIS since 2016, when a moving shadow on the disk surface was reported. We continue to see the shadow moving in a counter-clockwise fashion, but in these new i…
▽ More
We report new total intensity visible light high contrast imaging of the TW Hya disk taken with the Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph (STIS) on the Hubble Space Telescope (HST). This represents the first published images of the disk with STIS since 2016, when a moving shadow on the disk surface was reported. We continue to see the shadow moving in a counter-clockwise fashion, but in these new images the shadow has evolved into two separate shadows, implying a change in behavior for the occulting structure. Based on radiative transfer models of optically thick disk structures casting shadows, we infer that a plausible explanation for the change is that there are now two misaligned components of the inner disk. The first of these disks is located between 5-6au with an inclination of 5.5\arcdeg and PA of 170\arcdeg, the second between 6-7au with and inclination of 7\arcdeg and PA of 50\arcdeg. Finally, we speculate on the implications of the new shadow structure and determine that additional observations are needed to disentangle the nature of TW Hya's inner disk architecture.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Continuing to Hide Signatures of Gravitational Instability in Protoplanetary Discs with Planets
Authors:
Sahl Rowther,
Rebecca Nealon,
Farzana Meru
Abstract:
We carry out three dimensional smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations to study the impact of planet-disc interactions on a gravitationally unstable protoplanetary disc. We find that the impact of a planet on the disc's evolution can be described by three scenarios. If the planet is sufficiently massive, the spiral wakes generated by the planet dominate the evolution of the disc and gravitatio…
▽ More
We carry out three dimensional smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations to study the impact of planet-disc interactions on a gravitationally unstable protoplanetary disc. We find that the impact of a planet on the disc's evolution can be described by three scenarios. If the planet is sufficiently massive, the spiral wakes generated by the planet dominate the evolution of the disc and gravitational instabilities are completely suppressed. If the planet's mass is too small, then gravitational instabilities are unaffected. If the planet's mass lies between these extremes, gravitational instabilities are weakened. We present mock Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) continuum observations showing that the observability of large-scale spiral structures is diminished or completely suppressed when the planet is massive enough to influence the disc's evolution. Our results show that massive discs that would be expected to be gravitationally unstable can appear axisymmetric in the presence of a planet. Thus, the absence of observed large-scale spiral structures alone is not enough to place upper limits on the disc's mass, which could have implications on observations of young Class I discs with rings & gaps.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
The Bardeen-Petterson effect in accreting supermassive black-hole binaries: disc breaking and critical obliquity
Authors:
Rebecca Nealon,
Enrico Ragusa,
Davide Gerosa,
Giovanni Rosotti,
Riccardo Barbieri
Abstract:
The inspiral of supermassive black-hole binaries in gas-rich environment is driven by the presence of an accretion disc and viscous interactions tend to align the spin of the black holes with the orbital angular momentum of the disc. Recent work introduced a new iterative approach to describe the alignment process and the resulting non-linear evolution of the surrounding warped accretion disc. The…
▽ More
The inspiral of supermassive black-hole binaries in gas-rich environment is driven by the presence of an accretion disc and viscous interactions tend to align the spin of the black holes with the orbital angular momentum of the disc. Recent work introduced a new iterative approach to describe the alignment process and the resulting non-linear evolution of the surrounding warped accretion disc. Their model predicted that black-hole spins reach either full alignment or a critical obliquity where solutions to the warp equations cease to exist. In this paper, we show that this critical region corresponds to the disc breaking phenomenon, where the disc is disrupted into two or more discrete sections. We use 3D hydrodynamical simulations to (i) recover the predictions of the semi-analytic model and (ii) unveil a richer phenomenology where the disc exhibits either unsuccessful, single and multiple breaks. We additionally identify hydrodynamic effects such as spiral arms that are able to stabilise the disc against breaking beyond criticality. Our results show that when disc breaking occurs, the ability of black holes and disc to align is compromised and in some cases even prevented as the binary inspirals.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
War** Away Gravitational Instabilities in Protoplanetary Discs
Authors:
Sahl Rowther,
Rebecca Nealon,
Farzana Meru
Abstract:
We perform 3D SPH simulations of warped, non-coplanar gravitationally unstable discs to show that as the warp propagates through the self-gravitating disc, it heats up the disc rendering it gravitationally stable. Thus losing their spiral structure and appearing completely axisymmetric. In their youth, protoplanetary discs are expected to be massive and self-gravitating, which results in non-axisy…
▽ More
We perform 3D SPH simulations of warped, non-coplanar gravitationally unstable discs to show that as the warp propagates through the self-gravitating disc, it heats up the disc rendering it gravitationally stable. Thus losing their spiral structure and appearing completely axisymmetric. In their youth, protoplanetary discs are expected to be massive and self-gravitating, which results in non-axisymmetric spiral structures. However recent observations of young protoplanetary discs with ALMA have revealed that discs with large-scale spiral structure are rarely observed in the midplane. Instead, axisymmetric discs with some also having ring & gap structures are more commonly observed. Our work invloving warps, non-coplanar disc structures that are expected to commonly occur in young discs, potentially resolves this discrepancy between observations and theoretical predictions. We demonstrate that they are able to suppress the large-scale spiral structure of self-gravitating protoplanetary discs.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2021; v1 submitted 12 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Dust Traffic Jams in Inclined Circumbinary Protoplanetary Discs I. Morphology and Formation Theory
Authors:
Hossam Aly,
Jean-François Gonzalez,
Rebecca Nealon,
Cristiano Longarini,
Giuseppe Lodato,
Daniel J. Price
Abstract:
Gas and dust in inclined orbits around binaries experience precession induced by the binary gravitational torque. The difference in precession between gas and dust alters the radial drift of weakly coupled dust and leads to density enhancements where the radial drift is minimised. We explore this phenomenon using 3D hydrodynamical simulations to investigate the prominence of these `dust traffic ja…
▽ More
Gas and dust in inclined orbits around binaries experience precession induced by the binary gravitational torque. The difference in precession between gas and dust alters the radial drift of weakly coupled dust and leads to density enhancements where the radial drift is minimised. We explore this phenomenon using 3D hydrodynamical simulations to investigate the prominence of these `dust traffic jams' and the evolution of the resulting dust sub-structures at different disc inclinations and binary eccentricities. We then derive evolution equations for the angular momentum of warped dust discs and implement them in a 1D code and present calculations to further explain these traffic jams. We find that dust traffic jams in inclined circumbinary discs provide significant dust density enhancements that are long lived and can have important consequences for planetesimal formation.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
GW Ori: circumtriple rings and planets
Authors:
Jeremy L. Smallwood,
Rebecca Nealon,
Cheng Chen,
Rebecca G. Martin,
Jiaqing Bi,
Ruobing Dong,
Christophe Pinte
Abstract:
GW Ori is a hierarchical triple star system with a misaligned circumtriple protoplanetary disc. Recent ALMA observations have identified three dust rings with a prominent gap at $100\, \rm au$ and misalignments between each of the rings. A break in the gas disc may be driven either by the torque from the triple star system or a planet that is massive enough to carve a gap in the disc. Once the dis…
▽ More
GW Ori is a hierarchical triple star system with a misaligned circumtriple protoplanetary disc. Recent ALMA observations have identified three dust rings with a prominent gap at $100\, \rm au$ and misalignments between each of the rings. A break in the gas disc may be driven either by the torque from the triple star system or a planet that is massive enough to carve a gap in the disc. Once the disc is broken, the rings nodally precess on different timescales and become misaligned. We investigate the origins of the dust rings by means of $N$-body integrations and 3-dimensional hydrodynamic simulations. We find that for observationally-motivated parameters of protoplanetary discs, the disc does not break due to the torque from the star system. We suggest that the presence of a massive planet (or planets) in the disc separates the inner and outer disc. We conclude that the disc breaking in GW Ori is likely caused by undetected planets -- the first planet(s) in a circumtriple orbit.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Chemical signatures of a warped protoplanetary disc
Authors:
Alison K. Young,
Richard Alexander,
Catherine Walsh,
Rebecca Nealon,
Alice Booth,
Christophe Pinte
Abstract:
Circumstellar discs may become warped or broken into distinct planes if there is a stellar or planetary companion with an orbit that is misaligned with respect to the disc. There is mounting observational evidence for protoplanetary discs with misaligned inner discs and warps that may be caused by such interactions with a previously undetected companion, giving us a tantalising indication of possi…
▽ More
Circumstellar discs may become warped or broken into distinct planes if there is a stellar or planetary companion with an orbit that is misaligned with respect to the disc. There is mounting observational evidence for protoplanetary discs with misaligned inner discs and warps that may be caused by such interactions with a previously undetected companion, giving us a tantalising indication of possible planets forming there. Hydrodynamical and radiative transfer models indicate that the temperature varies azimuthally in warped discs due to the variable angle at which the disc surface faces the star and this impacts the disc chemistry. We perform chemical modelling based on a hydrodynamical model of a protoplanetary disc with an embedded planet orbiting at a 12$^{\circ}$ inclination to the disc. Even for this small misalignment, abundances of species including CO and HCO$^+$ vary azimuthally and this results in detectable azimuthal variations in submillimetre line emission. Azimuthal variations in line emission may therefore indicate the presence of an unseen embedded companion. Nonaxisymmetric chemical abundances should be considered when interpreting molecular line maps of warped or shadowed protoplanetary discs.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Formation of eccentric gas discs from sublimating or partially disrupted asteroids orbiting white dwarfs
Authors:
David Trevascus,
Daniel J. Price,
Rebecca Nealon,
David Liptai,
Christopher J. Manser,
Dimitri Veras
Abstract:
Of the 21 known gaseous debris discs around white dwarfs, a large fraction of them display observational features that are well described by an eccentric distribution of gas. In the absence of embedded objects or additional forces, these discs should not remain eccentric for long timescales, and should instead circularise due to viscous spreading. The metal pollution and infrared excess we observe…
▽ More
Of the 21 known gaseous debris discs around white dwarfs, a large fraction of them display observational features that are well described by an eccentric distribution of gas. In the absence of embedded objects or additional forces, these discs should not remain eccentric for long timescales, and should instead circularise due to viscous spreading. The metal pollution and infrared excess we observe from these stars is consistent with the presence of tidally disrupted sub-stellar bodies. We demonstrate, using smoothed particle hydrodynamics, that a sublimating or partially disrupting planet on an eccentric orbit around a white dwarf will form and maintain a gas disc with an eccentricity within 0.1 of, and lower than, that of the orbiting body. We also demonstrate that the eccentric gas disc observed around the white dwarf SDSS J1228+1040 can be explained by the same hypothesis.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
HD 143006: circumbinary planet or misaligned disc?
Authors:
G. Ballabio,
R. Nealon,
R. D. Alexander,
N. Cuello,
C. Pinte,
D. J. Price
Abstract:
Misalignments within protoplanetary discs are now commonly observed, and features such as shadows in scattered light images indicate departure from a co-planar geometry. VLT/SPHERE observations of the disc around HD 143006 show a large-scale asymmetry, and two narrow dark lanes which are indicative of shadowing. ALMA observations also reveal the presence of rings and gaps in the disc, along with a…
▽ More
Misalignments within protoplanetary discs are now commonly observed, and features such as shadows in scattered light images indicate departure from a co-planar geometry. VLT/SPHERE observations of the disc around HD 143006 show a large-scale asymmetry, and two narrow dark lanes which are indicative of shadowing. ALMA observations also reveal the presence of rings and gaps in the disc, along with a bright arc at large radii. We present new hydrodynamic simulations of HD 143006, and show that a configuration with both a strongly inclined binary and an outer planetary companion is the most plausible to explain the observed morphological features. We compute synthetic observations from our simulations, and successfully reproduce both the narrow shadows and the brightness asymmetry seen in IR scattered light. Additionally, we reproduce the large dust observed in the mm continuum, due to a 10 Jupiter mass planet detected in the CO kinematics. Our simulations also show the formation of a circumplanetary disc, which is misaligned with respect to the outer disc. The narrow shadows cast by the inner disc and the planet-induced "kink" in the disc kinematics are both expected to move on a time-scale of $\sim$ 5-10 years, presenting a potentially observable test of our model. If confirmed, HD 143006 would be the first known example of a circumbinary planet on a strongly misaligned orbit.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Dwarf Galaxies and the Black-Hole Scaling Relations
Authors:
Andrew King,
Rebecca Nealon
Abstract:
The sample of dwarf galaxies with measured central black hole masses $M$ and velocity dispersions $σ$ has recently doubled, and gives a close fit to the extrapolation of the $M \propto σ$ relation for more massive galaxies. We argue that this is difficult to reconcile with suggestions that the scaling relations between galaxies and their central black holes are simply a statistical consequence of…
▽ More
The sample of dwarf galaxies with measured central black hole masses $M$ and velocity dispersions $σ$ has recently doubled, and gives a close fit to the extrapolation of the $M \propto σ$ relation for more massive galaxies. We argue that this is difficult to reconcile with suggestions that the scaling relations between galaxies and their central black holes are simply a statistical consequence of assembly through repeated mergers. This predicts black hole masses significantly larger than those observed in dwarf galaxies unless the initial distribution of uncorrelated seed black hole and stellar masses is confined to much smaller masses than earlier assumed. It also predicts a noticeable flattening of the $M \propto σ$ relation for dwarfs, to $M \propto σ^2$ compared with the observed $M \propto σ^4$. In contrast black hole feedback predicts that black hole masses tend towards a universal $M \propto σ^4$ relation in all galaxies, and correctly gives the properties of powerful outflows recently observed in dwarf galaxies. These considerations emphasize once again that the fundamental physical black-hole -- galaxy scaling relation is between $M$ and $σ$. The relation of $M$ to the bulge mass $M_b$ is acausal, and depends on the quite independent connection between $M_b$ and $σ$ set by stellar feedback.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Hiding Signatures of Gravitational Instability in Protoplanetary Discs with Planets
Authors:
Sahl Rowther,
Farzana Meru,
Grant M. Kennedy,
Rebecca Nealon,
Christophe Pinte
Abstract:
We carry out three dimensional SPH simulations to show that a migrating giant planet strongly suppresses the spiral structure in self-gravitating discs. We present mock ALMA continuum observations which show that in the absence of a planet, spiral arms due to gravitational instability are easily observed. Whereas in the presence of a giant planet, the spiral structures are suppressed by the migrat…
▽ More
We carry out three dimensional SPH simulations to show that a migrating giant planet strongly suppresses the spiral structure in self-gravitating discs. We present mock ALMA continuum observations which show that in the absence of a planet, spiral arms due to gravitational instability are easily observed. Whereas in the presence of a giant planet, the spiral structures are suppressed by the migrating planet resulting in a largely axisymmetric disc with a ring and gap structure. Our modelling of the gas kinematics shows that the planet's presence could be inferred, for example, using optically thin 13C16O. Our results show that it is not necessary to limit the gas mass of discs by assuming high dust-to-gas mass ratios in order to explain a lack of spiral features that would otherwise be expected in high mass discs.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Spirals, shadows & precession in HD 100453 -- II. The hidden companion
Authors:
Rebecca Nealon,
Nicolás Cuello,
Jean-François Gonzalez,
Gerrit van der Plas,
Christophe Pinte,
Richard Alexander,
François Ménard,
Daniel J. Price
Abstract:
The protoplanetary disc HD 100453 exhibits a curious combination of spirals, shadows and a relative misalignment between the observed outer disc and inferred inner disc. This disc is accompanied by a secondary star on a bound orbit exterior to the disc. Recent observations have suggested there may be an additional low-mass companion residing within the disc inner cavity. In our companion paper the…
▽ More
The protoplanetary disc HD 100453 exhibits a curious combination of spirals, shadows and a relative misalignment between the observed outer disc and inferred inner disc. This disc is accompanied by a secondary star on a bound orbit exterior to the disc. Recent observations have suggested there may be an additional low-mass companion residing within the disc inner cavity. In our companion paper the orbit of the secondary was shown to be misaligned by 61 degrees to the plane of the outer disc. Here we investigate the properties of the inner companion and the origin of the misalignment between the inner and outer disc. Using numerical simulations and synthetic observations, we show that the disc structure and kinematics are consistent with a $\lesssim$ 5 Jupiter mass planet located at 15-20au. We find that the disc evolution over around 50 binary orbits (about 10$^5$ yrs) is governed by differential precession and to a lesser extent, the Kozai-Lidov effect. In our proposed model the misalignment observed between the outer and inner disc arises naturally as a result of the misaligned outer companion driving the outer disc to precess more rapidly than the inner disc.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Spirals, shadows & precession in HD 100453 -- I. The orbit of the binary
Authors:
Jean-François Gonzalez,
Gerrit van der Plas,
Christophe Pinte,
Nicolás Cuello,
Rebecca Nealon,
François Ménard,
Alexandre Revol,
Laetitia Rodet,
Maud Langlois,
Anne-Lise Maire
Abstract:
In recent years, several protoplanetary discs have been observed to exhibit spirals, both in scattered light and (sub)millimetre continuum data. The HD 100453 binary star system hosts such a disc around its primary. Previous work has argued that the spirals were caused by the gravitational interaction of the secondary, which was assumed to be on a circular orbit, coplanar with the disc (meaning he…
▽ More
In recent years, several protoplanetary discs have been observed to exhibit spirals, both in scattered light and (sub)millimetre continuum data. The HD 100453 binary star system hosts such a disc around its primary. Previous work has argued that the spirals were caused by the gravitational interaction of the secondary, which was assumed to be on a circular orbit, coplanar with the disc (meaning here the large outer disc, as opposed to the very small inner disc). However, recent observations of the CO gas emission were found incompatible with this assumption. In this paper, we run SPH simulations of the gas and dust disc for seven orbital configurations taken from astrometric fits and compute synthetic observations from their results. Comparing to high-resolution ALMA $^{12}$CO data, we find that the best agreement is obtained for an orbit with eccentricity $e=0.32$ and semi-major axis $a=207$ au, inclined by $61^\circ$ relative to the disc plane. The large misalignment between the disc and orbit planes is compatible with the tidal evolution of a circumprimary disc in an eccentric, unequal-mass binary star.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Rocking shadows in broken circumbinary discs
Authors:
Rebecca Nealon,
Daniel Price,
Christophe Pinte
Abstract:
We use three dimensional simulations with coupled hydrodynamics and Monte Carlo radiative transfer to show that shadows cast by the inner disc in broken circumbinary discs move within a confined range of position angles on the outer disc. Over time, shadows appear to rock back and forth in azimuth as the inner disc precesses. The effect occurs because the inner disc precesses around a vector that…
▽ More
We use three dimensional simulations with coupled hydrodynamics and Monte Carlo radiative transfer to show that shadows cast by the inner disc in broken circumbinary discs move within a confined range of position angles on the outer disc. Over time, shadows appear to rock back and forth in azimuth as the inner disc precesses. The effect occurs because the inner disc precesses around a vector that is not the angular momentum vector of the outer disc. We relate our findings to recent observations of shadows in discs.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Flyby-induced misalignments in planet-hosting discs
Authors:
Rebecca Nealon,
Nicolás Cuello,
Richard Alexander
Abstract:
We now have several observational examples of misaligned broken protoplanetary discs, where the disc inner regions are strongly misaligned with respect to the outer disc. Current models suggest that this disc structure can be generated with an internal misaligned companion (stellar or planetary), but the occurrence rate of these currently unobserved companions remains unknown. Here we explore whet…
▽ More
We now have several observational examples of misaligned broken protoplanetary discs, where the disc inner regions are strongly misaligned with respect to the outer disc. Current models suggest that this disc structure can be generated with an internal misaligned companion (stellar or planetary), but the occurrence rate of these currently unobserved companions remains unknown. Here we explore whether a strong misalignment between the inner and outer disc can be formed without such a companion. We consider a disc that has an existing gap --- essentially separating the disc into two regions --- and use a flyby to disturb the discs, leading to a misalignment. Despite considering the most optimistic parameters for this scenario, we find maximum misalignments between the inner and outer disc of $\sim$45$^{\circ}$ and that these misalignments are short-lived. We thus conclude that the currently observed misaligned discs must harbour internal, misaligned companions.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Flybys in protoplanetary discs: II. Observational signatures
Authors:
Nicolás Cuello,
Fabien Louvet,
Daniel Mentiplay,
Christophe Pinte,
Daniel J. Price,
Andrew J. Winter,
Rebecca Nealon,
François Ménard,
Giuseppe Lodato,
Giovanni Dipierro,
Valentin Christiaens,
Matías Montesinos,
Jorge Cuadra,
Guillaume Laibe,
Lucas Cieza,
Ruobing Dong,
Richard Alexander
Abstract:
Tidal encounters in star clusters perturb discs around young protostars. In Cuello et al. (2019a, Paper I) we detailed the dynamical signatures of a stellar flyby in both gas and dust. Flybys produce warped discs, spirals with evolving pitch angles, increasing accretion rates, and disc truncation. Here we present the corresponding observational signatures of these features in optical/near-infrared…
▽ More
Tidal encounters in star clusters perturb discs around young protostars. In Cuello et al. (2019a, Paper I) we detailed the dynamical signatures of a stellar flyby in both gas and dust. Flybys produce warped discs, spirals with evolving pitch angles, increasing accretion rates, and disc truncation. Here we present the corresponding observational signatures of these features in optical/near-infrared scattered light and (sub-) millimeter continuum and CO line emission. Using representative prograde and retrograde encounters for direct comparison, we post-process hydrodynamical simulations with radiative transfer methods to generate a catalogue of multi-wavelength observations. This provides a reference to identify flybys in recent near-infrared and sub-millimetre observations (e.g., RW Aur, AS 205, HV Tau & DO Tau, FU Ori, V2775 Ori, and Z CMa).
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Gravitational wave emission from unstable accretion discs in tidal disruption events
Authors:
M. Toscani,
G. Lodato,
R. Nealon
Abstract:
Gravitational waves can be emitted by accretion discs if they undergo instabilities that generate a time varying mass quadrupole. In this work we investigate the gravitational signal generated by a thick accretion disc of $1 M_{\odot}$ around a static super-massive black hole of $10^{6}M_{\odot}$, assumed to be formed after the tidal disruption of a solar type star. This torus has been shown to be…
▽ More
Gravitational waves can be emitted by accretion discs if they undergo instabilities that generate a time varying mass quadrupole. In this work we investigate the gravitational signal generated by a thick accretion disc of $1 M_{\odot}$ around a static super-massive black hole of $10^{6}M_{\odot}$, assumed to be formed after the tidal disruption of a solar type star. This torus has been shown to be unstable to a global non-axisymmetric hydrodynamic instability, the Papaloizou-Pringle instability, in the case where it is not already accreting and has a weak magnetic field. We start by deriving analytical estimates of the maximum amplitude of the gravitational wave signal, with the aim to establish its detectability by the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA). Then, we compare these estimates with those obtained through a numerical simulation of the torus, made with a 3D smoothed particle hydrodynamics code. Our numerical analysis shows that the measured strain is two orders of magnitude lower than the maximum value obtained analytically. However, accretion discs affected by the Papaloizou-Pringle instability may still be interesting sources for LISA, if we consider discs generated after deeply penetrating tidal disruptions of main sequence stars of higher mass.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Supermassive Black Hole Demographics: Evading $M - σ$
Authors:
Andrew King,
Rebecca Nealon
Abstract:
We consider black hole - galaxy coevolution using simple analytic arguments. We focus on the fact that several supermassive black holes are known with masses significantly larger than suggested by the $M - σ$ relation, sometimes also with rather small stellar masses. We show that these are likely to have descended from extremely compact `blue nugget' galaxies born at high redshift, whose very high…
▽ More
We consider black hole - galaxy coevolution using simple analytic arguments. We focus on the fact that several supermassive black holes are known with masses significantly larger than suggested by the $M - σ$ relation, sometimes also with rather small stellar masses. We show that these are likely to have descended from extremely compact `blue nugget' galaxies born at high redshift, whose very high velocity dispersions allowed the black holes to reach unusually large masses. Subsequent interactions reduce the velocity dispersion, so the black holes lie above the usual $M - σ$ relation and expel a large fraction of the bulge gas (as in WISE J104222.11+164115.3) that would otherwise make stars, before ending at low redshift as very massive holes in galaxies with relatively low stellar masses, such as NGC 4889 and NGC 1600. We further suggest the possible existence of two new types of galaxy: low-mass dwarfs whose central black holes lie below the $M - σ$ relation at low redshift, and galaxies consisting of very massive ($\gtrsim 10^{11}$M$_{\odot}$) black holes with extremely small stellar masses. This second group would be very difficult to detect electromagnetically, but potentially offer targets of considerable interest for LISA.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Generalised warped disk equations
Authors:
Rebecca G. Martin,
Stephen H. Lubow,
J. E. Pringle,
Alessia Franchini,
Zhaohuan Zhu,
Stephen Lepp,
Rebecca Nealon,
C. J. Nixon,
David Vallet
Abstract:
The manner in which warps in accretion disks evolve depends on the magnitude of the viscosity. For small viscosity $(α< H/R)$ the warp evolves in a wave-like manner; for large viscosity $H/R<α\ll 1$ it evolves diffusively. Here $α$ is the viscosity parameter and $H/R$ the disk aspect ratio. Currently there is no simple set of equations which describes the evolution in both regimes. In this paper w…
▽ More
The manner in which warps in accretion disks evolve depends on the magnitude of the viscosity. For small viscosity $(α< H/R)$ the warp evolves in a wave-like manner; for large viscosity $H/R<α\ll 1$ it evolves diffusively. Here $α$ is the viscosity parameter and $H/R$ the disk aspect ratio. Currently there is no simple set of equations which describes the evolution in both regimes. In this paper we describe a possible solution to this problem and introduce a set of one-dimensional equations that describe the evolution of a warped disk that are applicable in both high and low viscosity regimes for arbitrary tilts, but small warps.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Scattered light shadows in warped protoplanetary discs
Authors:
Rebecca Nealon,
Christophe Pinte,
Richard Alexander,
Daniel Mentiplay,
Giovanni Dipierro
Abstract:
Three-dimensional hydrodynamic numerical simulations have demonstrated that the structure of a protoplanetary disc may be strongly affected by a planet orbiting in a plane that is misaligned to the disc. When the planet is able to open a gap, the disc is separated into an inner, precessing disc and an outer disc with a warp. In this work, we compute infrared scattered light images to investigate t…
▽ More
Three-dimensional hydrodynamic numerical simulations have demonstrated that the structure of a protoplanetary disc may be strongly affected by a planet orbiting in a plane that is misaligned to the disc. When the planet is able to open a gap, the disc is separated into an inner, precessing disc and an outer disc with a warp. In this work, we compute infrared scattered light images to investigate the observational consequences of such an arrangement. We find that an inner disc misaligned by a less than a degree to the outer disc is indeed able to cast a shadow at larger radii. In our simulations a planet of around 6 Jupiter masses inclined by around 2 degrees is enough to warp the disc and cast a shadow with a depth of more than 10% of the average flux at that radius. We also demonstrate that warp in the outer disc can cause a variation in the azimuthal brightness profile at large radii. Importantly, this latter effect is a function of the distance from the star and is most prominent in the outer disc. We apply our model to the TW Hya system, where a misaligned, precessing inner disc has been invoked to explain an recently observed shadow in the outer disc. Consideration of the observational constraints suggest that an inner disc precessing due to a misaligned planet is an unlikely explanation for the features found in TW Hya.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
War** a protoplanetary disc with a planet on an inclined orbit
Authors:
Rebecca Nealon,
Giovanni Dipierro,
Richard Alexander,
Rebecca Martin,
Chris Nixon
Abstract:
Recent observations of several protoplanetary discs have found evidence of departures from flat, circular motion in the inner regions of the disc. One possible explanation for these observations is a disc warp, which could be induced by a planet on a misaligned orbit. We present three-dimensional numerical simulations of the tidal interaction between a protoplanetary disc and a misaligned planet.…
▽ More
Recent observations of several protoplanetary discs have found evidence of departures from flat, circular motion in the inner regions of the disc. One possible explanation for these observations is a disc warp, which could be induced by a planet on a misaligned orbit. We present three-dimensional numerical simulations of the tidal interaction between a protoplanetary disc and a misaligned planet. For low planet masses we show that our simulations accurately model the evolution of inclined planet orbit (up to moderate inclinations). For a planet massive enough to carve a gap, the disc is separated into two components and the gas interior and exterior to the planet orbit evolve separately, forming an inner and outer disc. Due to the inclination of the planet, a warp develops across the planet orbit such that there is a relative tilt and twist between these discs. We show that when other parameters are held constant, the relative inclination that develops between the inner and outer disc depends on the outer radius of the total disc modelled. For a given disc mass, our results suggest that the observational relevance of the warp depends more strongly on the mass of the planet rather than the inclination of the orbit.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
On the Papaloizou-Pringle instability in tidal disruption events
Authors:
Rebecca Nealon,
Daniel J. Price,
Clément Bonnerot,
Giuseppe Lodato
Abstract:
We demonstrate that the compact, thick disc formed in a tidal disruption event may be unstable to non-axisymmetric perturbations in the form of the Papaloizou-Pringle instability. We show this can lead to rapid redistribution of angular momentum that can be parameterised in terms of an effective Shakura-Sunyaev $α$ parameter. For remnants that have initially weak magnetic fields, this may be respo…
▽ More
We demonstrate that the compact, thick disc formed in a tidal disruption event may be unstable to non-axisymmetric perturbations in the form of the Papaloizou-Pringle instability. We show this can lead to rapid redistribution of angular momentum that can be parameterised in terms of an effective Shakura-Sunyaev $α$ parameter. For remnants that have initially weak magnetic fields, this may be responsible for driving mass accretion prior to the onset of the magneto-rotational instability. For tidal disruptions around a $10^6$ M$_{\odot}$ black hole, the measured accretion rate is super-Eddington but is not sustainable over many orbits. We thus identify a method by which the torus formed in tidal disruption event may be significantly accreted before the magneto-rotational instability is established.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2017; v1 submitted 12 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Phantom: A smoothed particle hydrodynamics and magnetohydrodynamics code for astrophysics
Authors:
Daniel J. Price,
James Wurster,
Terrence S. Tricco,
Chris Nixon,
Stéven Toupin,
Alex Pettitt,
Conrad Chan,
Daniel Mentiplay,
Guillaume Laibe,
Simon Glover,
Clare Dobbs,
Rebecca Nealon,
David Liptai,
Hauke Worpel,
Clément Bonnerot,
Giovanni Dipierro,
Giulia Ballabio,
Enrico Ragusa,
Christoph Federrath,
Roberto Iaconi,
Thomas Reichardt,
Duncan Forgan,
Mark Hutchison,
Thomas Constantino,
Ben Ayliffe
, et al. (2 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present Phantom, a fast, parallel, modular and low-memory smoothed particle hydrodynamics and magnetohydrodynamics code developed over the last decade for astrophysical applications in three dimensions. The code has been developed with a focus on stellar, galactic, planetary and high energy astrophysics and has already been used widely for studies of accretion discs and turbulence, from the bir…
▽ More
We present Phantom, a fast, parallel, modular and low-memory smoothed particle hydrodynamics and magnetohydrodynamics code developed over the last decade for astrophysical applications in three dimensions. The code has been developed with a focus on stellar, galactic, planetary and high energy astrophysics and has already been used widely for studies of accretion discs and turbulence, from the birth of planets to how black holes accrete. Here we describe and test the core algorithms as well as modules for magnetohydrodynamics, self-gravity, sink particles, H_2 chemistry, dust-gas mixtures, physical viscosity, external forces including numerous galactic potentials as well as implementations of Lense-Thirring precession, Poynting-Robertson drag and stochastic turbulent driving. Phantom is hereby made publicly available.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2018; v1 submitted 13 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Apsidal precession, disc breaking and viscosity in warped discs
Authors:
Rebecca Nealon,
Chris Nixon,
Daniel J. Price,
Andrew King
Abstract:
We demonstrate the importance of general relativistic apsidal precession in warped black hole accretion discs by comparing three - dimensional smoothed particle hydrodynamic simulations in which this effect is first neglected, and then included. If apsidal precession is neglected, we confirm the results of an earlier magnetohydrodynamic simulation which made this assumption, showing that at least…
▽ More
We demonstrate the importance of general relativistic apsidal precession in warped black hole accretion discs by comparing three - dimensional smoothed particle hydrodynamic simulations in which this effect is first neglected, and then included. If apsidal precession is neglected, we confirm the results of an earlier magnetohydrodynamic simulation which made this assumption, showing that at least in this case the $α$ viscosity model produces very similar results to those of simulations where angular momentum transport is due to the magnetorotational instability. Including apsidal precession significantly changes the predicted disc evolution. For moderately inclined discs thick enough that tilt is transported by bending waves, we find a disc tilt which is nonzero at the inner disc edge and oscillates with radius, consistent with published analytic results. For larger inclinations we find disc breaking.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
On the Bardeen-Petterson Effect in black hole accretion discs
Authors:
Rebecca Nealon,
Daniel Price,
Chris Nixon
Abstract:
We investigate the effect of black hole spin on warped or misaligned accretion discs - in particular i) whether or not the inner disc edge aligns with the black hole spin and ii) whether the disc can maintain a smooth transition between an aligned inner disc and a misaligned outer disc, known as the Bardeen-Petterson effect. We employ high resolution 3D smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations…
▽ More
We investigate the effect of black hole spin on warped or misaligned accretion discs - in particular i) whether or not the inner disc edge aligns with the black hole spin and ii) whether the disc can maintain a smooth transition between an aligned inner disc and a misaligned outer disc, known as the Bardeen-Petterson effect. We employ high resolution 3D smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations of $α$-discs subject to Lense-Thirring precession, focussing on the bending wave regime where the disc viscosity is smaller than the aspect ratio $α\lesssim H/R$. We first address the controversy in the literature regarding possible steady-state oscillations of the tilt close to the black hole. We successfully recover such oscillations in 3D at both small and moderate inclinations ($\lesssim 15^{\circ}$), provided both Lense-Thirring and Einstein precession are present, sufficient resolution is employed, and provided the disc is not so thick so as to simply accrete misaligned. Second, we find that discs inclined by more than a few degrees in general steepen and break rather than maintain a smooth transition, again in contrast to previous findings, but only once the disc scale height is adequately resolved. Finally, we find that when the disc plane is misaligned to the black hole spin by a large angle, the disc 'tears' into discrete rings which precess effectively independently and cause rapid accretion, consistent with previous findings in the diffusive regime ($α\gtrsim H/R$). Thus misalignment between the disc and the spin axis of the black hole provides a robust mechanism for growing black holes quickly, regardless of whether the disc is thick or thin.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
