-
Saturn: Efficient Multi-Large-Model Deep Learning
Authors:
Kabir Nagrecha,
Arun Kumar
Abstract:
In this paper, we propose Saturn, a new data system to improve the efficiency of multi-large-model training (e.g., during model selection/hyperparameter optimization). We first identify three key interconnected systems challenges for users building large models in this setting -- parallelism technique selection, distribution of GPUs over jobs, and scheduling. We then formalize these as a joint pro…
▽ More
In this paper, we propose Saturn, a new data system to improve the efficiency of multi-large-model training (e.g., during model selection/hyperparameter optimization). We first identify three key interconnected systems challenges for users building large models in this setting -- parallelism technique selection, distribution of GPUs over jobs, and scheduling. We then formalize these as a joint problem, and build a new system architecture to tackle these challenges simultaneously. Our evaluations show that our joint-optimization approach yields 39-49% lower model selection runtimes than typical current DL practice.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Saturn: An Optimized Data System for Large Model Deep Learning Workloads
Authors:
Kabir Nagrecha,
Arun Kumar
Abstract:
Large language models such as GPT-3 & ChatGPT have transformed deep learning (DL), powering applications that have captured the public's imagination. These models are rapidly being adopted across domains for analytics on various modalities, often by finetuning pre-trained base models. Such models need multiple GPUs due to both their size and computational load, driving the development of a bevy of…
▽ More
Large language models such as GPT-3 & ChatGPT have transformed deep learning (DL), powering applications that have captured the public's imagination. These models are rapidly being adopted across domains for analytics on various modalities, often by finetuning pre-trained base models. Such models need multiple GPUs due to both their size and computational load, driving the development of a bevy of "model parallelism" techniques & tools. Navigating such parallelism choices, however, is a new burden for end users of DL such as data scientists, domain scientists, etc. who may lack the necessary systems knowhow. The need for model selection, which leads to many models to train due to hyper-parameter tuning or layer-wise finetuning, compounds the situation with two more burdens: resource apportioning and scheduling. In this work, we tackle these three burdens for DL users in a unified manner by formalizing them as a joint problem that we call SPASE: Select a Parallelism, Allocate resources, and SchedulE. We propose a new information system architecture to tackle the SPASE problem holistically, representing a key step toward enabling wider adoption of large DL models. We devise an extensible template for existing parallelism schemes and combine it with an automated empirical profiler for runtime estimation. We then formulate SPASE as an MILP.
We find that direct use of an MILP-solver is significantly more effective than several baseline heuristics. We optimize the system runtime further with an introspective scheduling approach. We implement all these techniques into a new data system we call Saturn. Experiments with benchmark DL workloads show that Saturn achieves 39-49% lower model selection runtimes than typical current DL practice.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2023; v1 submitted 3 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
InTune: Reinforcement Learning-based Data Pipeline Optimization for Deep Recommendation Models
Authors:
Kabir Nagrecha,
Lingyi Liu,
Pablo Delgado,
Prasanna Padmanabhan
Abstract:
Deep learning-based recommender models (DLRMs) have become an essential component of many modern recommender systems. Several companies are now building large compute clusters reserved only for DLRM training, driving new interest in cost- and time- saving optimizations. The systems challenges faced in this setting are unique; while typical deep learning training jobs are dominated by model executi…
▽ More
Deep learning-based recommender models (DLRMs) have become an essential component of many modern recommender systems. Several companies are now building large compute clusters reserved only for DLRM training, driving new interest in cost- and time- saving optimizations. The systems challenges faced in this setting are unique; while typical deep learning training jobs are dominated by model execution, the most important factor in DLRM training performance is often online data ingestion.
In this paper, we explore the unique characteristics of this data ingestion problem and provide insights into DLRM training pipeline bottlenecks and challenges. We study real-world DLRM data processing pipelines taken from our compute cluster at Netflix to observe the performance impacts of online ingestion and to identify shortfalls in existing pipeline optimizers. We find that current tooling either yields sub-optimal performance, frequent crashes, or else requires impractical cluster re-organization to adopt. Our studies lead us to design and build a new solution for data pipeline optimization, InTune.
InTune employs a reinforcement learning (RL) agent to learn how to distribute the CPU resources of a trainer machine across a DLRM data pipeline to more effectively parallelize data loading and improve throughput. Our experiments show that InTune can build an optimized data pipeline configuration within only a few minutes, and can easily be integrated into existing training workflows. By exploiting the responsiveness and adaptability of RL, InTune achieves higher online data ingestion rates than existing optimizers, thus reducing idle times in model execution and increasing efficiency. We apply InTune to our real-world cluster, and find that it increases data ingestion throughput by as much as 2.29X versus state-of-the-art data pipeline optimizers while also improving both CPU & GPU utilization.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Systems for Parallel and Distributed Large-Model Deep Learning Training
Authors:
Kabir Nagrecha
Abstract:
Deep learning (DL) has transformed applications in a variety of domains, including computer vision, natural language processing, and tabular data analysis. The search for improved DL model accuracy has led practitioners to explore increasingly large neural architectures, with some recent Transformer models spanning hundreds of billions of learnable parameters. These designs have introduced new sca…
▽ More
Deep learning (DL) has transformed applications in a variety of domains, including computer vision, natural language processing, and tabular data analysis. The search for improved DL model accuracy has led practitioners to explore increasingly large neural architectures, with some recent Transformer models spanning hundreds of billions of learnable parameters. These designs have introduced new scale-driven systems challenges for the DL space, such as memory bottlenecks, poor runtime efficiency, and high costs of model development. Efforts to address these issues have explored techniques such as parallelization of neural architectures, spilling data across the memory hierarchy, and memory-efficient data representations. This survey will explore the large-model training systems landscape, highlighting key challenges and the various techniques that have been used to address them.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Hydra: A System for Large Multi-Model Deep Learning
Authors:
Kabir Nagrecha,
Arun Kumar
Abstract:
Scaling up model depth and size is now a common approach to raise accuracy in many deep learning (DL) applications, as evidenced by the widespread success of multi-billion or even trillion parameter models in natural language processing (NLP) research. Despite success in DL research and at major technology companies, broader practical adoption of such large models among domain scientists and busin…
▽ More
Scaling up model depth and size is now a common approach to raise accuracy in many deep learning (DL) applications, as evidenced by the widespread success of multi-billion or even trillion parameter models in natural language processing (NLP) research. Despite success in DL research and at major technology companies, broader practical adoption of such large models among domain scientists and businesses is still bottlenecked by GPU memory limits, high training costs, and low GPU availability, even on public clouds. Model selection needs further compound these resource challenges: users often need to compare dozens of models with different hyper-parameters or neural architectures to suit their specific task and dataset. In this paper, we present Hydra, a system designed to tackle such challenges by enabling out-of-the-box scaling for multi-large-model DL workloads on even commodity GPUs in a resource-efficient manner. Hydra is the first approach to holistically optimize the execution of multi-model workloads for large DL models. We do this by adapting prior "model-parallel" execution schemes to work with scalable parameter offloading across the memory hierarchy and further hybridizing this approach with task-parallel job scheduling techniques. Hydra decouples scalability of model parameters from parallelism of execution, thus enabling DL users to train even a 6-billion parameter model on a single commodity GPU. It also fully exploits the speedup potential of task parallelism in multi-GPU setups, yielding near-linear strong scaling and making rigorous model selection perhaps more practical for such models. We evaluate end-to-end performance by fine-tuning GPT-2 for language modeling. We find that Hydra offers between 50% and 100% higher training throughput than even the best settings of state-of-the-art industrial frameworks such as DeepSpeed and GPipe for multi-large-model training.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2022; v1 submitted 16 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Model-Parallel Model Selection for Deep Learning Systems
Authors:
Kabir Nagrecha
Abstract:
As deep learning becomes more expensive, both in terms of time and compute, inefficiencies in machine learning (ML) training prevent practical usage of state-of-the-art models for most users. The newest model architectures are simply too large to be fit onto a single processor. To address the issue, many ML practitioners have turned to model parallelism as a method of distributing the computationa…
▽ More
As deep learning becomes more expensive, both in terms of time and compute, inefficiencies in machine learning (ML) training prevent practical usage of state-of-the-art models for most users. The newest model architectures are simply too large to be fit onto a single processor. To address the issue, many ML practitioners have turned to model parallelism as a method of distributing the computational requirements across several devices. Unfortunately, the sequential nature of neural networks causes very low efficiency and device utilization in model parallel training jobs. We propose a new form of "shard parallelism" combining task and model parallelism, then package it into a framework we name Hydra. Hydra recasts the problem of model parallelism in the multi-model context to produce a fine-grained parallel workload of independent model shards, rather than independent models. This new parallel design promises dramatic speedups relative to the traditional model parallelism paradigm.
△ Less
Submitted 13 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
