-
A Mixed Stirring Mechanism for Debris Discs with Giant and Dwarf Planetary Perturbations
Authors:
Marco A. Muñoz-Gutiérrez,
Jonathan P. Marshall,
Antonio Peimbert
Abstract:
Debris discs consist of belts of bodies ranging in size from dust grains to planetesimals; these belts are visible markers of planetary systems around other stars that can reveal the influence of extrasolar planets through their shape and structure. Two key stirring mechanisms -- self-stirring by planetesimals and secular perturbation by an external giant planet -- have been identified to explain…
▽ More
Debris discs consist of belts of bodies ranging in size from dust grains to planetesimals; these belts are visible markers of planetary systems around other stars that can reveal the influence of extrasolar planets through their shape and structure. Two key stirring mechanisms -- self-stirring by planetesimals and secular perturbation by an external giant planet -- have been identified to explain the dynamics of planetesimal belts; their relative importance has been studied independently, but are yet to be considered in combination. In this work we perform a suite of 286 N-body simulations exploring the evolution of debris discs over 1~Gyr, combining the gravitational perturbations of both dwarf planets embedded in the discs, and an interior giant planet. Our systems were somewhat modeled after the architecture of the outer Solar system: a Solar mass star, a single massive giant planet at 30~au ($M_{\rm GP} =$ 10 to 316~$\mathrm{M}_{\oplus}$), and a debris disc formed by 100 massive dwarf planets and 1000 massless particles ($M_{\rm DD} =$ 3.16 to 31.6~$\mathrm{M}_{\oplus}$). We present the evolution of both the disc and the giant planet after 1~Gyr. The time evolution of the average eccentricity and inclination of the disc is strongly dependent on the giant planet mass as well as on the remaining disc mass. We also found that efficient stirring is achieved even with small disc masses. In general, we find that a mixed mechanism is more efficient in the stirring of cold debris discs than either mechanism acting in isolation.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
A low-inclination neutral Trans-Neptunian Object in a extreme orbit
Authors:
Ying-Tung Chen,
Marielle R. Eduardo,
Marco A. Muñoz-Gutiérrez,
Shiang-Yu Wang,
Matthew J. Lehner,
Chan-Kao Chang
Abstract:
We present photometric observations and numerical simulations of 2016 SD$_{106}$, a low inclination ($i=4.8^{\circ}$) extreme trans-Neptunian Object with a large semi-major axis ($a=350$ au) and perihelion ($q= 42.6$ au). This object possesses a peculiar neutral color of $g-r = 0.45\pm0.05$ and $g-i=0.72\pm0.06$, in comparison with other distant trans-Neptunian objects, all of which have moderate-…
▽ More
We present photometric observations and numerical simulations of 2016 SD$_{106}$, a low inclination ($i=4.8^{\circ}$) extreme trans-Neptunian Object with a large semi-major axis ($a=350$ au) and perihelion ($q= 42.6$ au). This object possesses a peculiar neutral color of $g-r = 0.45\pm0.05$ and $g-i=0.72\pm0.06$, in comparison with other distant trans-Neptunian objects, all of which have moderate-red to ultra-red colors. A numerical integration based on orbital fitting on astrometric data covering eight years of arc confirms that 2016 SD$_{106}$ is a metastable object without significant scattering evolution. Each of the clones survived at the end of the 1 Gyr simulation. However, very few neutral objects with inclinations $<5^{\circ}$ have been found in the outer solar system, even in the main Kuiper belt. Furthermore, most mechanisms which lift perihelion distances are expected to produce a very low number of extreme objects with inclinations $<5^{\circ}$. We thus explored the possibility that a hypothetical distant planet could increase the production of such objects. Our simulations show that no 2016 SD$_{106}$-like orbits can be produced from three Kuiper belt populations tested (i.e. plutinos, twotinos, and Haumea Family) without the presence of an hypothetical planet, while a few similar orbits can be obtained with it; however, the presence of the additional planet produces a wide range of large semimajor-axis / large perihelion objects, in apparent contradiction with the observed scarcity of objects in those regions of phase space. Future studies may determine if there is a connection between the existence of a perihelion gap and a particular orbital configuration of an hypothetical distant planet.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Long-term Dynamical Evolution of Pallene (Saturn XXXIII) and its Diffuse, Dusty Ring
Authors:
Marco A. Muñoz-Gutiérrez,
A. Paula Granados Contreras,
Gustavo Madeira,
Joseph A. A'Hearn,
Silvia Giuliatti Winter
Abstract:
The distinctive set of Saturnian small satellites, Aegaeon, Methone, Anthe, and Pallene, constitutes an excellent laboratory to understand the evolution of systems immersed in co-orbital dusty rings/arcs, subjected to perturbations from larger satellites and non-gravitational forces. In this work, we carried out a comprehensive numerical exploration of the long-term evolution of Pallene and its ri…
▽ More
The distinctive set of Saturnian small satellites, Aegaeon, Methone, Anthe, and Pallene, constitutes an excellent laboratory to understand the evolution of systems immersed in co-orbital dusty rings/arcs, subjected to perturbations from larger satellites and non-gravitational forces. In this work, we carried out a comprehensive numerical exploration of the long-term evolution of Pallene and its ring. Through frequency map analysis, we characterised the current dynamical state around Pallene. A simple tidal evolution model serves to set a time frame for the current orbital configuration of the system. With detailed short and long-term N-body simulations we determine whether Pallene is currently in resonance with one or more of six of Saturn's major moons. We analysed a myriad of resonant arguments extracted from the direct and indirect parts of the disturbing function, finding that Pallene is not in mean motion resonance from the present up to 5~Myr into the future; nonetheless, some resonant arguments exhibit intervals of libration and circulation at different timescales and moon pairings. We studied the dynamical evolution of micrometric particles forming the ring, considering gravitational and non-gravitational forces. Non-gravitational forces are responsible for particles vertical excursions and outward migration. By estimating the satellite's mass production rate, we find that Pallene could be responsible for kee** its ring in steady-state only if it is mainly composed of large micrometre-sized particles. If mainly composed of particles with a few micrometres for which Pallene is the only source, the ring will spread out, both radially and vertically, until it finally disappears.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
FOSSIL: I. The Spin Rate Limit of Jupiter Trojans
Authors:
Chan-Kao Chang,
Ying-Tung Chen,
Wesley C. Fraser,
Fumi Yoshida,
Matthew J. Lehner,
Shiang-Yu Wang,
JJ Kavelaars,
Rosemary E. Pike,
Mike Alexandersen,
Takashi Ito,
Young-Jun Choi,
A. Paula Granados Contreras,
Youngmin JeongAhn,
Jianghui Ji,
Myung-** Kim,
Samantha M. Lawler,
Jian Li,
Zhong-Yi Lin,
Patryk Sofia Lykawka,
Hong-Kyu Moon,
Surhud More,
Marco Munoz-Gutierrez,
Keiji Ohtsuki,
Tsuyoshi Terai,
Seitaro Urakawa
, et al. (3 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Rotation periods of 53 small (diameters $2 < D < 40$ km) Jupiter Trojans (JTs) were derived using the high-cadence light curves obtained by the FOSSIL phase I survey, a Subaru/Hyper Suprime-Cam intensive program. These are the first reported periods measured for JTs with $D < 10$ km. We found a lower limit of the rotation period near 4 hr, instead of the previously published result of 5 hr (Ryan e…
▽ More
Rotation periods of 53 small (diameters $2 < D < 40$ km) Jupiter Trojans (JTs) were derived using the high-cadence light curves obtained by the FOSSIL phase I survey, a Subaru/Hyper Suprime-Cam intensive program. These are the first reported periods measured for JTs with $D < 10$ km. We found a lower limit of the rotation period near 4 hr, instead of the previously published result of 5 hr (Ryan et al. 2017; Szabo et al. 2017, 2020) found for larger JTs. Assuming a rubble-pile structure for JTs, a bulk density of 0.9 gcm$^{-3}$ is required to withstand this spin rate limit, consistent with the value $0.8-1.0$ gcm$^{-3}$ (Marchis et al. 2006; Mueller et al. 2010; Buie et al. 2015; Berthier et al. 2020) derived from the binary JT system, (617) Patroclus-Menoetius system.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Long-term Dynamical Stability in the Outer Solar System I: The Regular and Chaotic Evolution of the 34 Largest Trans-Neptunian Objects
Authors:
M. A. Muñoz-Gutiérrez,
A. Peimbert,
M. J. Lehner,
S. -Y. Wang
Abstract:
We carried out an extensive analysis of the stability of the outer solar system, making use of the frequency analysis technique over short-term integrations of nearly a hundred thousand test particles, as well as a statistical analysis of 200, 1 Gyr long numerical simulations, which consider the mutual perturbations of the giant planets and the 34 largest trans-Neptunian objects (we have called al…
▽ More
We carried out an extensive analysis of the stability of the outer solar system, making use of the frequency analysis technique over short-term integrations of nearly a hundred thousand test particles, as well as a statistical analysis of 200, 1 Gyr long numerical simulations, which consider the mutual perturbations of the giant planets and the 34 largest trans-Neptunian objects (we have called all 34 objects ``dwarf planets'', DPs, even if probably only the largest of them are true DPs).
From the frequency analysis we produced statistical diffusion maps for a wide region of the $a$-$e$ phase-space plane; we also present the average diffusion time for orbits as a function of perihelion. We later turned our attention to the 34 DPs making an individualized analysis for each of them and producing a first approximation of their future stability.
From the 200 distinct realizations of the orbital evolution of the 34 DPs, we classified the sample into three categories including 17 Stable, 11 Unstable, and 6 Resonant objects each; we also found that statistically, 2 objects from the sample will leave the trans-Neptunian region within the next Gyr, most likely being ejected from the solar system, but with a non-negligible probability of going inside the orbit of Neptune, either to collide with a giant planet or even falling to the inner solar system, where our simulations are no longer able to resolve their continuous evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Dynamics of Small Bodies in Orbits Between Jupiter and Saturn
Authors:
Andrew C. Roberts,
Marco A. Muñoz-Gutiérrez
Abstract:
We examine the dynamics of small bodies in orbits similar to that of comet 29P/Schwassmann-Wachmann 1, i.e. near-circular orbits between Jupiter and Saturn. As of late 2019, there are 14 other known bodies in this region that lie in similar orbits. Previous research has shown that this region of the solar system, which in this work we call the "near Centaur region" (NCR), is not stable, suggesting…
▽ More
We examine the dynamics of small bodies in orbits similar to that of comet 29P/Schwassmann-Wachmann 1, i.e. near-circular orbits between Jupiter and Saturn. As of late 2019, there are 14 other known bodies in this region that lie in similar orbits. Previous research has shown that this region of the solar system, which in this work we call the "near Centaur region" (NCR), is not stable, suggesting that any bodies found in it would have very short lifetimes. We performed 20 Myr high-precision numerical simulations of the evolution of massless particles, initially located in the Kuiper belt but close to Neptune, with perihelia slightly below 33 au ("Neptune crossers"). Some of these particles quickly migrate inward, passing through the NCR before becoming Jupiter Family Comets. We find that objects in the NCR do indeed generally travel through it very quickly. However, our simulations reveal that resonant behavior in this region is somewhat common and can trap objects for up to 100 Kyr. We summarize the dynamics of 29P and other observed bodies in the region---two of which seem to be clearly exhibiting resonant behavior---and use our simulations to put limits on the reservoir size of the Neptune crossers, which at its time determines the reservoir size of the Kuiper belt. Finally, we put some constraints on the current population of Centaurs and particularly of the NCR population, based on the injection rates required to keep the observed population of Jupiter family comets in steady-state.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Analysing the region of the rings and small satellites of Neptune
Authors:
D. M. Gaslac Gallardo,
S. M. Giuliatti Winter,
G. Madeira,
M. A. Muñoz-Gutiérrez
Abstract:
The ring system and small satellites of Neptune were discovered during Voyager 2 flyby in 1989 (Smith et al.1989). In this work we analyse the diffusion maps which can give an overview of the system. As a result we found the width of unstable and stable regions close to each satellite. The innermost Galle ring, which is further from the satellites, is located in a stable region, while Lassel ring…
▽ More
The ring system and small satellites of Neptune were discovered during Voyager 2 flyby in 1989 (Smith et al.1989). In this work we analyse the diffusion maps which can give an overview of the system. As a result we found the width of unstable and stable regions close to each satellite. The innermost Galle ring, which is further from the satellites, is located in a stable region, while Lassel ring (W = 4000 km) has its inner border in a stable region depending on its eccentricity. The same happens to the Le Verrier and Adams rings , they are stable for small values of the eccentricity. They can survive to the close satellites perturbation only for values of e < 0.012. When the solar radiation force is taken into account the rings composed by 1{$μ$}m sized particles have a lifetime of about $10^4$ years while larger particles (10{$μ$}m in radius) can survive up to 10 5 years. The satellites Naiad, Thalassa and Despina can help replenish the lost particles of the Le Verrier, Arago and Lassel rings, while the ejecta produced by Galatea, Larissa and Proteus do not have enough velocity to escape from the satellite gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
The Contribution of Dwarf Planets to the Origin of Jupiter Family Comets
Authors:
Marco A. Muñoz-Gutiérrez,
Antonio Peimbert,
Bárbara Pichardo,
Matthew J. Lehner,
Shiang-Yu Wang
Abstract:
We explore the long-term evolution of a bias-free orbital representation of the cometary nuclei (with diameters above 2 km) of the Kuiper belt, using the so-called L7 synthetic model from CFEPS, which consists of three dynamical sub-populations: the Classical, the Resonant, and the Scattering. The dynamical evolution of belt particles is studied under the gravitational influence of the Sun and the…
▽ More
We explore the long-term evolution of a bias-free orbital representation of the cometary nuclei (with diameters above 2 km) of the Kuiper belt, using the so-called L7 synthetic model from CFEPS, which consists of three dynamical sub-populations: the Classical, the Resonant, and the Scattering. The dynamical evolution of belt particles is studied under the gravitational influence of the Sun and the four giant planets, as well as of the 34 largest known trans-Neptunian objects (TNOs with $H_V < 4$). Here we indistinctly call Dwarf Planets (DPs) to the full sample of 34 large TNOs. Over a 1 Gyr timescale, we analyze the secular influence of the DPs over Kuiper belt disk particles and their contribution to the injection rate of new visible Jupiter Family Comets (JFCs). We found that DPs globally increase the number of JFCs by 12.6% when compared with the comets produced by the giant planets alone. When considering each population separately, we find that the increment produced by DPs is 17%, 12%, and 3% for the Classical, Resonant, and Scattering populations, respectively. Given the rate of escapes from the Kuiper belt, we find upper limits to the number of objects in each population required to maintain the JFCs in steady-state; the results are $55.9\times10^6$, $78.5\times10^6$, and $274.3\times10^6$ for the Scattering, Resonant, and Classical populations, respectively. Finally, we find that the Plutinos are the most important source of comets which were originally in a resonant configuration, where the presence of Pluto alone enhances by 10% the number of JFCs.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
The Contribution of Dwarf Planets to the Origin of Low Inclination Comets by the Replenishment of Mean Motion Resonances in Debris Disks
Authors:
Marco A. Muñoz-Gutiérrez,
Antonio Peimbert,
Bárbara Pichardo
Abstract:
In this work we explore a new dynamical path for the delivery of low-inclination comets. In a configuration formed by an interior giant planet and an exterior massive debris disk, where the mass is accounted for by the 50 largest objects in the disk, the strongest mean motion resonances of the giant, located along the belt, are replenished with new material (test particles) due to the influence of…
▽ More
In this work we explore a new dynamical path for the delivery of low-inclination comets. In a configuration formed by an interior giant planet and an exterior massive debris disk, where the mass is accounted for by the 50 largest objects in the disk, the strongest mean motion resonances of the giant, located along the belt, are replenished with new material (test particles) due to the influence of the 50 massive objects. Once in resonance, slow chaotic diffusion stirs the orbital elements of the cometary nuclei enough to encounter the giant and to be scattered by it. When the disk is massive enough, both resonant and non-resonant particles are stirred quickly to encounter the giant and form an scattered disk component, greatly increasing the rate for the delivery of cometary material to the inner part of the system. This mechanism is applicable both to the solar system and extrasolar systems in general. Preliminary results, using a disk as massive as the classical Kuiper belt, indicate that the mechanism here proposed can account for about a tenth of the required injection rate to maintain the population of ecliptic comets in steady state. In a more massive belt of 0.25 M$_\oplus$, an estimated rate of around 0.6 new comets per year is found. Such a high rate would pose a serious risk for the habitability of rocky interior planets, yet would resemble the late heavy bombardment that was present in the early solar system.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Long-term Evolution and Stability of Saturnian Small Satellites: Aegaeon, Methone, Anthe, and Pallene
Authors:
Marco A. Muñoz-Gutiérrez,
Silvia Giuliatti Winter
Abstract:
Aegaeon, Methone, Anthe, and Pallene are four Saturnian small moons, discovered by the Cassini spacecraft. Although their orbital characterization has been carried on by a number of authors, their long-term evolution has not been studied in detail so far. In this work, we numerically explore the long-term evolution, up to $10^5$ yr, of the small moons in a system formed by an oblate Saturn and the…
▽ More
Aegaeon, Methone, Anthe, and Pallene are four Saturnian small moons, discovered by the Cassini spacecraft. Although their orbital characterization has been carried on by a number of authors, their long-term evolution has not been studied in detail so far. In this work, we numerically explore the long-term evolution, up to $10^5$ yr, of the small moons in a system formed by an oblate Saturn and the five largest moons close to the region: Janus, Epimetheus, Mimas, Enceladus, and Tethys. By using frequency analysis we determined the stability of the small moons and characterize, through diffusion maps, the dynamical behavior of a wide region of geometric phase space, $a$ vs $e$, surrounding them. Those maps could shed light on the possible initial number of small bodies close to Mimas, and help to better understand the dynamical origin of the small satellites. We found that the four small moons are long-term stable and no mark of chaos is found for them. Aegaeon, Methone, and Anthe could remain unaltered for at least $\sim0.5$Myr, given the current configuration of the system. They remain well-trapped in the corotation eccentricity resonances with Mimas in which they currently librate. However, perturbations from nearby resonances, such as Lindblad eccentricity resonances with Mimas, seem responsible for largest variations observed for Methone and Anthe. Pallene remains in a non-resonant orbit and it is the more stable, at least for 64 Myr. Nonetheless, it is affected by a quasi-resonance with Mimas, which induces long-term orbital oscillations of its eccentricity and inclination.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Giant Planets Can Act As Stabilizing Agents on Debris Disks
Authors:
Marco A. Muñoz-Gutiérrez,
Bárbara Pichardo,
Antonio Peimbert
Abstract:
We have explored the evolution of a cold debris disk under the gravitational influence of dwarf planet sized objects (DPs), both in the presence and absence of an interior giant planet. Through detailed long-term numerical simulations, we demonstrate that, when the giant planet is not present, DPs can stir the eccentricities and inclinations of disk particles, in linear proportion to the total mas…
▽ More
We have explored the evolution of a cold debris disk under the gravitational influence of dwarf planet sized objects (DPs), both in the presence and absence of an interior giant planet. Through detailed long-term numerical simulations, we demonstrate that, when the giant planet is not present, DPs can stir the eccentricities and inclinations of disk particles, in linear proportion to the total mass of the DPs; on the other hand, when the giant planet is included in the simulations, the stirring is approximately proportional to the mass squared. This creates two regimes: below a disk mass threshold (defined by the total mass of DPs), the giant planet acts as a stabilizing agent of the orbits of cometary nucleii, diminishing the effect of the scatterers; above the threshold, the giant contributes to the dispersion of the particles.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Dynamical Heating Induced by Dwarf Planets on Cold Kuiper Belt-like Debris Disks
Authors:
Marco A. Muñoz-Gutiérrez,
Barbara Pichardo,
Mauricio Reyes-Ruiz,
Antonio Peimbert
Abstract:
With the use of long-term numerical simulations, we study the evolution and orbital behavior of cometary nuclei in cold Kuiper belt-like debris disks under the gravitational influence of dwarf planets (DPs); we carry out these simulations with and without the presence of a Neptune-like giant planet. This exploratory study shows that in the absence of a giant planet, 10 DPs are enough to induce str…
▽ More
With the use of long-term numerical simulations, we study the evolution and orbital behavior of cometary nuclei in cold Kuiper belt-like debris disks under the gravitational influence of dwarf planets (DPs); we carry out these simulations with and without the presence of a Neptune-like giant planet. This exploratory study shows that in the absence of a giant planet, 10 DPs are enough to induce strong radial and vertical heating on the orbits of belt particles. On the other hand, the presence of a giant planet close to the debris disk, acts as a stability agent reducing the radial and vertical heating. With enough DPs, even in the presence of a Neptune-like giant planet some radial heating remains; this heating grows steadily, re-filling resonances otherwise empty of cometary nuclei. Specifically for the solar system, this secular process seems to be able to provide material that, through resonant chaotic diffusion, increase the rate of new comets spiraling into the inner planetary system, but only if more than the $\sim10$ known DP sized objects exist in the trans-Neptunian region.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Chaotic Dynamics of Comet 1P/Halley; Lyapunov Exponent and Survival Time Expectancy
Authors:
M. A. Muñoz-Gutiérrez,
M. Reyes-Ruiz,
B. Pichardo
Abstract:
The orbital elements of comet Halley are known to a very high precision, suggesting that the calculation of its future dynamical evolution is straightforward. In this paper we seek to characterize the chaotic nature of the present day orbit of comet Halley and to quantify the timescale over which its motion can be predicted confidently. In addition, we attempt to determine the timescale over which…
▽ More
The orbital elements of comet Halley are known to a very high precision, suggesting that the calculation of its future dynamical evolution is straightforward. In this paper we seek to characterize the chaotic nature of the present day orbit of comet Halley and to quantify the timescale over which its motion can be predicted confidently. In addition, we attempt to determine the timescale over which its present day orbit will remain stable. Numerical simulations of the dynamics of test particles in orbits similar to that of comet Halley are carried out with the Mercury 6.2 code. On the basis of these we construct survival time maps to assess the absolute stability of Halley's orbit, frequency analysis maps, to study the variability of the orbit and we calculate the Lyapunov exponent for the orbit for variations in initial conditions at the level of the present day uncertainties in our knowledge of its orbital parameters. On the basis of our calculations of the Lyapunov exponent for comet Halley, the chaotic nature of its motion is demonstrated. The e-folding timescale for the divergence of initially very similar orbits is approximately 70 years. The sensitivity of the dynamics on initial conditions is also evident in the self-similarity character of the survival time and frequency analysis maps in the vicinity of Halley's orbit, which indicates that, on average, it is unstable on a timescale of hundreds of thousands of years. The chaotic nature of Halley's present day orbit implies that a precise determination of its motion, at the level of the present day observational uncertainty, is difficult to predict on a timescale of approximately 100 years. Furthermore, we also find that the ejection of Halley from the solar system or its collision with another body could occur on a timescale as short as 10,000 years.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2014; v1 submitted 27 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
