-
Saturn's Interior After the Cassini Grand Finale
Authors:
J. J. Fortney,
B. Militzer,
C. R. Mankovich,
R. Helled,
S. M. Wahl,
N. Nettelmann,
W. B. Hubbard,
D. J. Stevenson,
L. Iess,
M. S. Marley,
N. Movshovitz
Abstract:
We present a review of Saturn's interior structure and thermal evolution, with a particular focus on work in the past 5 years. Data from the Cassini mission, including a precise determination of the gravity field from the Grand Finale orbits, and the still ongoing identification of ring wave features in Saturn's C-ring tied to seismic modes in the planet, have led to dramatic advances in our under…
▽ More
We present a review of Saturn's interior structure and thermal evolution, with a particular focus on work in the past 5 years. Data from the Cassini mission, including a precise determination of the gravity field from the Grand Finale orbits, and the still ongoing identification of ring wave features in Saturn's C-ring tied to seismic modes in the planet, have led to dramatic advances in our understanding of Saturn's structure. Models that match the gravity field suggest that differential rotation, as seen in the visible atmosphere, extends down to at least a depth of 10,000 km (1/6$^{\rm th}$ the planet's radius). At greater depths, a variety of different investigations all now point to a deep Saturn rotation rate of 10 hours and 33 minutes. There is very compelling evidence for a central heavy element concentration (``core''), that in most recent models is 12-20 Earth masses. Ring seismology strongly suggests that the core is not entirely compact, but is dilute (mixed in with the overlying H/He), and has a substantial radial extent, perhaps out to around one-half of the planet's radius. A wide range of thermal evolution scenarios can match the planet's current luminosity, with progress on better quantifying the helium rain scenario hampered by Saturn's poorly known atmospheric helium abundance. We discuss the relevance of magnetic field data on understanding the planet's current interior structure. We point towards additional future work that combines seismology and gravity within a framework that includes differential rotation, and the utility of a Saturn entry probe.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
The Promise and Limitations of Precision Gravity: Application to the Interior Structure of Uranus and Neptune
Authors:
Naor Movshovitz,
Jonathan J. Fortney
Abstract:
We study the constraining power of a high-precision measurement of the gravity field for Uranus and Neptune, as could be delivered by a low periapse orbiter. Our study is practical, assessing the possible deliverables and limitations of such a mission with respect to the structure of the planets. Our study is also academic, assessing in a general way the relative importance of the low order gravit…
▽ More
We study the constraining power of a high-precision measurement of the gravity field for Uranus and Neptune, as could be delivered by a low periapse orbiter. Our study is practical, assessing the possible deliverables and limitations of such a mission with respect to the structure of the planets. Our study is also academic, assessing in a general way the relative importance of the low order gravity, high order gravity, rotation rate, and moment of inertia (MOI) in constraining planetary structure. We attempt to explore all possible interior density structures of a planet that are consistent with hypothetical gravity data, via MCMC sampling of parameterized density profiles. When the gravity field is poorly known, as it is today, uncertainties in the rotation rate on the order of 10 minutes are unimportant, as they are interchangeable with uncertainties in the gravity coefficients. By the same token, when the gravity field is precisely determined the rotation rate must be known to comparable precision. When gravity and rotation are well known the MOI becomes well-constrained, limiting the usefulness of independent MOI determinations unless they are extraordinarily precise. For Uranus and Neptune, density profiles can be well-constrained. However, the non-uniqueness of the relative roles of H/He, watery volatiles, and rock in the deep interior will still persist with high-precision gravity data. Nevertheless, the locations and magnitudes (in pressure-space) of any large-scale composition gradient regions can likely be identified, offering a crucially better picture of the interiors of Uranus or Neptune.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
The nature of gas giant planets
Authors:
Ravit Helled,
Naor Movshovitz,
Nadine Nettelmann
Abstract:
Revealing the true nature of the gas giant planets in our Solar System is challenging. The masses of Jupiter and Saturn are about 318 and 95 Earth masses, respectively. While they mostly consist of hydrogen and helium, the total mass and distribution of the heavier elements, which reveal information on their origin, are still unknown. Recent accurate measurements of the gravitational fields of Jup…
▽ More
Revealing the true nature of the gas giant planets in our Solar System is challenging. The masses of Jupiter and Saturn are about 318 and 95 Earth masses, respectively. While they mostly consist of hydrogen and helium, the total mass and distribution of the heavier elements, which reveal information on their origin, are still unknown. Recent accurate measurements of the gravitational fields of Jupiter and Saturn together with knowledge of the behavior of planetary materials at high pressures allow us to better constrain their interiors. Updated structure models of Jupiter and Saturn suggest that both planets have complex interiors that include composition inhomogeneities, non-convective regions, and fuzzy cores. In addition, it is clear that there are significant differences between Jupiter and Saturn and that each giant planet is unique. This has direct implications for giant exoplanet characterization and for our understanding of gaseous planets as a class of astronomical objects. In this review we summarize the methods used to model giant planet interiors and recent developments in giant planet structure models.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Theory of Figures to the 7th order and the interiors of Jupiter and Saturn
Authors:
N. Nettelmann,
N. Movshovitz,
D. Ni,
J. J. Fortney,
E. Galanti,
Y. Kaspi,
R. Helled,
C. R. Mankovich,
S. Bolton
Abstract:
Interior modeling of Jupiter and Saturn has advanced to a state where thousands of models are generated that cover the uncertainty space of many parameters. This approach demands a fast method of computing their gravity field and shape. Moreover, the Cassini mission at Saturn and the ongoing Juno mission delivered gravitational harmonics up to J12. Here, we report the expansion of the Theory of Fi…
▽ More
Interior modeling of Jupiter and Saturn has advanced to a state where thousands of models are generated that cover the uncertainty space of many parameters. This approach demands a fast method of computing their gravity field and shape. Moreover, the Cassini mission at Saturn and the ongoing Juno mission delivered gravitational harmonics up to J12. Here, we report the expansion of the Theory of Figures, which is a fast method for gravity field and shape computation, to the 7th-order (ToF7), which allows for computation of up to J14. We apply three different codes to compare the accuracy using polytropic models. We apply ToF7 to Jupiter and Saturn interior models in conjunction with CMS-19 H/He-EOS. For Jupiter, we find that J6 is best matched by a transition from He-depleted to He-enriched envelope at 2-2.5 Mbar. However, the atmospheric metallicity reaches 1xtimes solar only if the adiabat is perturbed toward lower densities, or if the surface temperature is enhanced by ~14 K from the Galileo value. Our Saturn models imply a largely homogeneous-in-Z envelope at 1.5-4x solar atop a small core. Perturbing the adiabat yields metallicity profiles with extended, heavy-element enriched deep interior (diffuse core) out to 0.4 RSat, as for Jupiter. Classical models with compact, dilute, or no core are possible as long as the deep interior is enriched in heavy-elements. Including a thermal wind fitted to the observed wind speeds, representative Jupiter and Saturn models are consistent with all observed Jn values.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Connecting gravity field, moment of inertia, and core properties in Jupiter through empirical structure models
Authors:
Benno A. Neuenschwander,
Ravit Helled,
Naor Movshovitz,
Jonathan J. Fortney
Abstract:
Constraining Jupiter's internal structure is crucial for understanding its formation and evolution history. Recent interior models of Jupiter that fit Juno's measured gravitational field suggest an inhomogeneous interior and potentially the existence of a diluted core. These models, however, strongly depend on the model assumptions and the equations of state used. A complementary modelling approac…
▽ More
Constraining Jupiter's internal structure is crucial for understanding its formation and evolution history. Recent interior models of Jupiter that fit Juno's measured gravitational field suggest an inhomogeneous interior and potentially the existence of a diluted core. These models, however, strongly depend on the model assumptions and the equations of state used. A complementary modelling approach is to use empirical structure models. These can later be used to reveal new insights on the planetary interior and be compared to standard models. Here we present empirical structure models of Jupiter where the density profile is constructed by piecewise-polytropic equations. With these models we investigate the relation between the normalized moment of inertia (MoI) and the gravitational moments $J_2$ and $J_4$. Given that only the first few gravitational moments of Jupiter are measured with high precision, we show that an accurate and independent measurement of the MoI value could be used to further constrain Jupiter's interior. An independent measurement of the MoI with an accuracy better than $\sim 0.1\%$ could constrain Jupiter's core region and density discontinuities in its envelope. We find that models with a density discontinuity at $\sim$ 1 Mbar, as would produce a presumed hydrogen-helium separation, correspond to a fuzzy core in Jupiter. We next test the appropriateness of using polytropes, by comparing them with empirical models based on polynomials. We conclude that both representations result in similar density profiles and ranges of values for quantities like core mass and MoI.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Saturn's Probable Interior: An Exploration of Saturn's Potential Interior Density Structures
Authors:
Naor Movshovitz,
Jonathan J. Fortney,
Chris Mankovich,
Daniel Thorngren,
Ravit Helled
Abstract:
The gravity field of a giant planet is typically our best window into its interior structure and composition. Through comparison of a model planet's calculated gravitational potential with the observed potential, inferences can be made about interior quantities, including possible composition and the existence of a core. Necessarily, a host of assumptions go into such calculations, making every in…
▽ More
The gravity field of a giant planet is typically our best window into its interior structure and composition. Through comparison of a model planet's calculated gravitational potential with the observed potential, inferences can be made about interior quantities, including possible composition and the existence of a core. Necessarily, a host of assumptions go into such calculations, making every inference about a giant planet's structure strongly model dependent. In this work we present a more general picture by setting Saturn's gravity field, as measured during the \emph{Cassini} Grand Finale, as a likelihood function driving a Markov-Chain Monte Carlo exploration of the possible interior density profiles. The result is a posterior distribution of the interior structure that is not tied to assumed composition, thermal state, or material equations of state. Constraints on interior structure derived in this Bayesian framework are necessarily less informative, but are also less biased and more general. These empirical and probabilistic constraints on the density structure are our main data product which we archive for continued analysis. We find that the outer half of Saturn's radius is relatively well constrained, and we interpret our findings as suggesting a significant metal enrichment, in line with atmospheric abundances from remote sensing. As expected, the inner half of Saturn's radius is less well-constrained by gravity, but we generally find solutions that include a significant density enhancement, which can be interpreted as a core, although this core is often lower in density and larger in radial extent than typically found by standard models. This is consistent with a dilute core and/or composition gradients.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Cassini Ring Seismology as a Probe of Saturn's Interior I: Rigid Rotation
Authors:
Christopher Mankovich,
Mark S. Marley,
Jonathan J. Fortney,
Naor Movshovitz
Abstract:
Seismology of the gas giants holds the potential to resolve long-standing questions about their internal structure and rotation state. We construct a family of Saturn interior models constrained by the gravity field and compute their adiabatic mode eigenfrequencies and corresponding Lindblad and vertical resonances in Saturn's C ring, where more than twenty waves with pattern speeds faster than th…
▽ More
Seismology of the gas giants holds the potential to resolve long-standing questions about their internal structure and rotation state. We construct a family of Saturn interior models constrained by the gravity field and compute their adiabatic mode eigenfrequencies and corresponding Lindblad and vertical resonances in Saturn's C ring, where more than twenty waves with pattern speeds faster than the ring mean motion have been detected and characterized using high-resolution Cassini Visual and Infrared Map** Spectrometer (VIMS) stellar occultation data. We present identifications of the fundamental modes of Saturn that appear to be the origin of these observed ring waves, and use their observed pattern speeds and azimuthal wavenumbers to estimate the bulk rotation period of Saturn's interior to be $10{\rm h}\, 33{\rm m}\, 38{\rm s}^{+1{\rm m}\, 52{\rm s}}_{-1{\rm m}\, 19{\rm s}}$ (median and 5%/95% quantiles), significantly faster than Voyager and Cassini measurements of periods in Saturn's kilometric radiation, the traditional proxy for Saturn's bulk rotation period. The global fit does not exhibit any clear systematics indicating strong differential rotation in Saturn's outer envelope.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2018; v1 submitted 25 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Comparing Jupiter interior structure models to Juno gravity measurements and the role of a dilute core
Authors:
S. M. Wahl,
W. B. Hubbard,
B. Militzer,
T. Guillot,
Y. Miguel,
N. Movshovitz,
Y. Kaspi,
R. Helled,
D. Reese,
E. Galanti,
S. Levin,
J. E. Connerney,
S. J. Bolton
Abstract:
The Juno spacecraft has measured Jupiter's low-order, even gravitational moments, $J_2$--$J_8$, to an unprecedented precision, providing important constraints on the density profile and core mass of the planet. Here we report on a selection of interior models based on ab initio computer simulations of hydrogen-helium mixtures. We demonstrate that a dilute core, expanded to a significant fraction o…
▽ More
The Juno spacecraft has measured Jupiter's low-order, even gravitational moments, $J_2$--$J_8$, to an unprecedented precision, providing important constraints on the density profile and core mass of the planet. Here we report on a selection of interior models based on ab initio computer simulations of hydrogen-helium mixtures. We demonstrate that a dilute core, expanded to a significant fraction of the planet's radius, is helpful in reconciling the calculated $J_n$ with Juno's observations. Although model predictions are strongly affected by the chosen equation of state, the prediction of an enrichment of $Z$ in the deep, metallic envelope over that in the shallow, molecular envelope holds. We estimate Jupiter's core to contain an 7--25 Earth mass of heavy elements. We discuss the current difficulties in reconciling measured $J_n$ with the equations of state, and with theory for formation and evolution of the planet.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Numerical modeling of the disruption of Comet D/1993 F2 Shoemaker-Levy 9 representing the progenitor by a gravitationally bound assemblage of randomly shaped polyhedra
Authors:
Naor Movshovitz,
Erik Asphaug,
Donald Korycansky
Abstract:
We advance the modeling of rubble-pile solid bodies by re-examining the tidal breakup of comet Shoemaker-Levy 9, an event that occurred during a 1.33 Jupiter radii encounter with that planet in July 1992. Tidal disruption of the comet nucleus led to a chain of sub-nuclei about 100-1000 m in diameter; these went on to collide with the planet two years later (Chodas & Yeomans 1996). They were intens…
▽ More
We advance the modeling of rubble-pile solid bodies by re-examining the tidal breakup of comet Shoemaker-Levy 9, an event that occurred during a 1.33 Jupiter radii encounter with that planet in July 1992. Tidal disruption of the comet nucleus led to a chain of sub-nuclei about 100-1000 m in diameter; these went on to collide with the planet two years later (Chodas & Yeomans 1996). They were intensively studied prior to and during the collisions, making SL9 the best natural benchmark for physical models of small body disruption. For the first time in the study of this event, we use numerical codes treating rubble-piles as collections of polyhedra (Korycansky & Asphaug 2009). This introduces forces of dilatation and friction, and inelastic response. As in our previous studies (Asphaug & Benz 1994,1996) we conclude that the progenitor must have been a rubble-pile, and we obtain approximately the same pre-breakup diameter (about 1.5 km) in our best fits to the data. We find that the inclusion of realistic fragment shapes leads to grain locking and dilatancy, so that even in the absence of friction or other dissipation we find that disruption is overall more difficult than in our spheres-based simulations. We constrain the comet's bulk density at about 300-400 kg/m^3, half that of our spheres-based predictions and consistent with recent estimates derived from spacecraft observations.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2012; v1 submitted 13 July, 2012;
originally announced July 2012.
-
Formation of Jupiter using opacities based on detailed grain physics
Authors:
Naor Movshovitz,
Peter Bodenheimer,
Morris Podolak,
Jack J. Lissauer
Abstract:
Numerical simulations, based on the core-nucleated accretion model, are presented for the formation of Jupiter at 5.2 AU in 3 primordial disks with three different assumed values of the surface density of solid particles. The grain opacities in the envelope of the protoplanet are computed using a detailed model that includes settling and coagulation of grains and that incorporates a recalculation…
▽ More
Numerical simulations, based on the core-nucleated accretion model, are presented for the formation of Jupiter at 5.2 AU in 3 primordial disks with three different assumed values of the surface density of solid particles. The grain opacities in the envelope of the protoplanet are computed using a detailed model that includes settling and coagulation of grains and that incorporates a recalculation of the grain size distribution at each point in time and space. We generally find lower opacities than the 2% of interstellar values used in previous calculations [Hubickyj, O., Bodenheimer, P., Lissauer, J. J., 2005. Icarus 179, 415--431; Lissauer, J. J., Hubickyj, O., D'Angelo, G., Bodenheimer, P., 2009. Icarus 199, 338-350]. These lower opacities result in more rapid heat loss from and more rapid contraction of the protoplanetary envelope. For a given surface density of solids, the new calculations result in a substantial speedup in formation time as compared with those previous calculations. Formation times are calculated to be 1.0, 1.9, and 4.0 Myr, and solid core masses are found to be 16.8, 8.9, and 4.7 Earth masses, for solid surface densities, sigma, of 10, 6, and 4 grams per squared centimeter, respectively. For sigma=10 and sigma=6 g/cm^2, respectively, these formation times are reduced by more than 50% and more than 80% compared with those in a previously published calculation with the old approximation to the opacity.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2010;
originally announced May 2010.
-
The opacity of grains in protoplanetary atmospheres
Authors:
Naor Movshovitz,
Morris Podolak
Abstract:
We have computed the size distribution of silicate grains in the outer radiative region of the envelope of a protoplanet evolving according to the scenario of Pollack et al. (1996). Our computation includes grain growth due to Brownian motion and overtake of smaller grains by larger ones. We also include the input of new grains due to the breakup of planetesimals in the atmosphere. We follow the…
▽ More
We have computed the size distribution of silicate grains in the outer radiative region of the envelope of a protoplanet evolving according to the scenario of Pollack et al. (1996). Our computation includes grain growth due to Brownian motion and overtake of smaller grains by larger ones. We also include the input of new grains due to the breakup of planetesimals in the atmosphere. We follow the procedure of Podolak (2003), but have speeded it up significantly. This allows us to test the sensitivity of the code to various parameters. We have also made a more careful estimate of the resulting grain opacity. We find that the grain opacity is of the order of $10^{-2}\ \mathrm{cm^2 g^{-1}}$ throughout most of the outer radiative zone as Hubickyj et al. (2005) assumed for their low opacity case, but near the outer edge of the envelope, the opacity can increase to $\sim{1} \mathrm{cm^2 g^{-1}}$. We discuss the effect of this on the evolution of the models.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2007;
originally announced October 2007.