-
Interpretation of field emission current-voltage data: background theory and detailed simulation testing of a user-friendly webtool
Authors:
Mohammad M. Allaham,
Richard G. Forbes,
Alexandr Knapek,
Dinara Sobola,
Daniel Burdaa,
Petr Sedlak,
Marwan S. Mousa
Abstract:
In field electron emission (FE) studies, to interpret current-voltage data and extract characterization parameters, we use smooth planar metal-like emitter (SPME) methodology and a data-analysis plot. Three types exist: Millikan-Lauritsen (ML), Fowler-Nordheim (FN) and Murphy-Good (MG) plots. In SPME methodology, ML and FN plots are slightly curved but a MG plot is nearly straight. 1956 MG FE theo…
▽ More
In field electron emission (FE) studies, to interpret current-voltage data and extract characterization parameters, we use smooth planar metal-like emitter (SPME) methodology and a data-analysis plot. Three types exist: Millikan-Lauritsen (ML), Fowler-Nordheim (FN) and Murphy-Good (MG) plots. In SPME methodology, ML and FN plots are slightly curved but a MG plot is nearly straight. 1956 MG FE theory is better physics than 1928 FN theory, so we expect MG plots to be more precise than ML or FN plots. Current-voltage data are often converted: measured voltage to (apparent) macroscopic field, current to macroscopic current density. Thus, four different data-input forms exist. Over-simplified models of system behaviour are widely assumed. Whether simple use of a data-analysis plot is a valid interpretation method is often neglected. Published FE studies seem to contain a high incidence of spurious values for "field enhancement factor". A procedure (the "Orthodoxy Test") described in 2013 allows a validity check: around 40 % of a small sample of results were spuriously high. To assist data interpretation and validity checks, a simple user-friendly webtool has been designed by the lead author. As inputs, this needs system specification data and "range-limits" data from any of the three plot forms, using any of the four data-input forms. The webtool then applies the Orthodoxy Test, and -- if passed -- extracts characterization parameters. This study reports: (1) systematic tests of webtool functionality, using simulated input data prepared using Extended MG FE theory; and (2) systematic comparisons of the three different data-plot types, to check how well extracted parameter values match simulation input values. A summary review of relevant theory is given. For formal emission areas, the MG plot performs better than FN and ML plots. This is important for FE science.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2022; v1 submitted 9 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
A Suggested Alternative to Dark Matter in Galaxies: I. Theoretical Considerations
Authors:
Hanna A. Sabat,
Raed Z. Bani-Abdoh,
Marwan S. Mousa
Abstract:
Dark matter is the generally accepted paradigm in astrophysics and cosmology as a solution to the higher rate of rotation in galaxies, among many other reasons. But since there are still some problems encountered by the standard dark matter paradigm at the galactic scale, we have resorted to an alternative solution, similar to Milgrom's Modified Newtonian dynamics (MOND). Here, we have assumed tha…
▽ More
Dark matter is the generally accepted paradigm in astrophysics and cosmology as a solution to the higher rate of rotation in galaxies, among many other reasons. But since there are still some problems encountered by the standard dark matter paradigm at the galactic scale, we have resorted to an alternative solution, similar to Milgrom's Modified Newtonian dynamics (MOND). Here, we have assumed that: (i) either the gravitational constant, G, is a function of distance (scale): G = G(r), or, (ii) the gravitational-to-inertial mass ratio, mg/mi, is a function of distance (scale): f(r). We have used a linear approximation of each function, from which two new parameters appeared that have to be determined: G1, the first-order coefficient of gravitational coupling, and C1, the first-order coefficient of gravitational-to-inertial mass ratio. In the current part of this research, we have generated simplified theoretical rotation curves for some hypothetical galaxies by varying the parameters. We have concluded that our model gives a qualitatively and quantitatively acceptable behavior of the galactic rotation curves for some values of these parameters. The values of the 1st-order coefficients that give quantitatively acceptable description of galactic rotation curves are: G1 between around 10^-31 to 10^-30 m^2 s^-2 kg^-1; and, C1 between 10^-21 to 10^-20 m^-1. Furthermore, our model implies the existence of a critical distance at which the MOND effects become significant rather than a critical acceleration. In fact, Milgrom's MOND converges with our model if the critical acceleration is not a constant but a linear function of the galactic baryonic mass.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2021; v1 submitted 4 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Implementation of the orthodoxy test as a validity check on experimental field emission data
Authors:
Mohammad M. Allaham,
Richard G. Forbes,
Alexander Knapek,
Marwan S. Mousa
Abstract:
In field electron emission (FE) studies, it is important to check and analyse the quality and validity of experimental current-voltage data, which is usually plotted in one of a small number of standard forms. These include the so-called Fowler-Nordheim (FN), Millikan-Lauritsen (ML) and Murphy-Good (MG) plots. The Field Emission Orthodoxy Test is a simple quantitative test that aims to check for t…
▽ More
In field electron emission (FE) studies, it is important to check and analyse the quality and validity of experimental current-voltage data, which is usually plotted in one of a small number of standard forms. These include the so-called Fowler-Nordheim (FN), Millikan-Lauritsen (ML) and Murphy-Good (MG) plots. The Field Emission Orthodoxy Test is a simple quantitative test that aims to check for the reasonableness of the values of the parameter "scaled field" that can be extracted from these plots. This is done in order to establish whether characterization parameters extracted from the plot will be reliable or, alternative, likely to be spurious. This paper summarises the theory behind the orthodoxy test, for each of the plot forms, and confirms that it is easy to apply it to the newly developed MG plot. A simple web tool has been developed that extracts scaled-field values from any of these three plot forms, and tests for lack of field emission orthodoxy.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Applying the field emission orthodoxy test to Murphy-Good plots
Authors:
Mohammad M. Allam,
Richard G. Forbes,
Marwan S. Mousa
Abstract:
In field electron emission (FE) studies, it is important to check and analyse the quality and validity of results experimentally obtained from samples, using suitably plotted current-voltage [I(V)] measurements. For the traditional plotting method, the Fowler-Nordheim (FN) plot, there exists a so-called "orthodoxy test" that can be applied to the FN plot, in order to check whether the FE device/sy…
▽ More
In field electron emission (FE) studies, it is important to check and analyse the quality and validity of results experimentally obtained from samples, using suitably plotted current-voltage [I(V)] measurements. For the traditional plotting method, the Fowler-Nordheim (FN) plot, there exists a so-called "orthodoxy test" that can be applied to the FN plot, in order to check whether the FE device/system generating the results is "ideal". If it is not ideal, then emitter characterization parameters deduced from the FN plot are likely to be spurious. A new form of FE I(V) data plot, the so-called "Murphy-Good (MG) plot" has recently been introduced (R.G. Forbes, Roy. Soc. Open Sci. 6 (2019) 190912. This aims to improve the precision with which characterization-parameter values (particularly values of formal emission area) can be extracted from FE I(V) data. The present paper compares this new plotting form with the older FN and Millikan-Lauritsen (ML) forms, and makes an independent assessment of the consistency with which slope (and hence scaled-field) estimates can be extracted from a MG plot. It is shown that, by using a revised formula for the extraction of scaled-field values, the existing orthodoxy test can be applied to Murphy-Good plots. The development is reported of a prototype web tool that can apply the orthodoxy test to all three forms of FE data plot (ML, MG and FN).
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Numerical testing by a transfer-matrix technique of Simmons' equation for the local current density in metal-vacuum-metal junctions
Authors:
Alexandre Mayer,
Marwan S. Mousa,
Mark J. Hagmann,
Richard G. Forbes
Abstract:
We test the consistency with which Simmons' model can predict the local current density obtained for flat metal-vacuum-metal junctions. The image potential energy used in Simmons' original papers had a missing factor of 1/2. Besides this technical issue, Simmons' model relies on a mean-barrier approximation for electron transmission through the potential-energy barrier between the metals. In order…
▽ More
We test the consistency with which Simmons' model can predict the local current density obtained for flat metal-vacuum-metal junctions. The image potential energy used in Simmons' original papers had a missing factor of 1/2. Besides this technical issue, Simmons' model relies on a mean-barrier approximation for electron transmission through the potential-energy barrier between the metals. In order to test Simmons' expression for the local current density when the correct image potential energy is included, we compare the results of this expression with those provided by a transfer-matrix technique. This technique is known to provide numerically exact solutions of Schrodinger's equation for this barrier model. We also consider the current densities provided by a numerical integration of the transmission probability obtained with the WKB approximation and Simmons' mean-barrier approximation. The comparison between these different models shows that Simmons' expression for the local current density actually provides results that are in good agreement with those provided by the transfer-matrix technique, for a range of conditions of practical interest. We show that Simmons' model provides good results in the linear and field-emission regimes of current density versus voltage plots. It loses its applicability when the top of the potential-energy barrier drops below the Fermi level of the emitting metal.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Fowler-Nordheim Plot Analysis: a Progress Report
Authors:
Richard G. Forbes,
Jonathan H. B. Deane,
Andreas Fischer,
Marwan S. Mousa
Abstract:
The commonest method of characterizing a cold field electron emitter is to measure its current-voltage characteristics, and the commonest method of analysing these characteristics is by means of a Fowler-Nordheim (FN) plot. This tutorial/review-type paper outlines a more systematic method of setting out the Fowler-Nordheim-type theory of cold field electron emission, and brings together and summar…
▽ More
The commonest method of characterizing a cold field electron emitter is to measure its current-voltage characteristics, and the commonest method of analysing these characteristics is by means of a Fowler-Nordheim (FN) plot. This tutorial/review-type paper outlines a more systematic method of setting out the Fowler-Nordheim-type theory of cold field electron emission, and brings together and summarises the current state of work by the authors on develo** the theory and methodology of FN plot analysis. This has turned out to be far more complicated than originally expected. Emphasis is placed in this paper on: (a) the interpretation of FN-plot slopes, which is currently both easier and of more experimental interest than the analysis of FN-plot intercepts; and (b) preliminary explorations into develo** methodology for interpreting current-voltage characteristics when there is series resistance in the conduction path from the high-voltage generator to the emitter's emitting regions. This work reinforces our view that FN-plot analysis is best carried out on the raw measured current-voltage data, without pre-conversion into another data format, particularly if series resistance is present in the measuring circuit. Relevant formulae are given for extracting field-enhancement-factor values from such an analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2016; v1 submitted 23 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Influence of barrier form on Fowler-Nordheim plot analysis
Authors:
Andreas Fischer,
Marwan S. Mousa,
Richard G. Forbes
Abstract:
Recent research has described an improved method of Fowler-Nordheim plot analysis, based on the definition and evaluation of a slope correction factor and a new form of intercept correction factor. In this improved approach there exists a basic approximation that neglects certain terms in the general theory, and focuses on the influence of the form of the tunneling barrier on the values of basic s…
▽ More
Recent research has described an improved method of Fowler-Nordheim plot analysis, based on the definition and evaluation of a slope correction factor and a new form of intercept correction factor. In this improved approach there exists a basic approximation that neglects certain terms in the general theory, and focuses on the influence of the form of the tunneling barrier on the values of basic slope (σB) and intercept (ρB) correction factors. Simple formulae exist that allow these to be evaluated numerically for a barrier of arbitrary well-behaved form. This paper makes an initial exploration of the effects of barrier form on FN plot analysis. For a planar emitter, two models for the correlation-and-exchange (C and E) potential energy (PE) are used. For the Schottky-Nordheim barrier, it is shown that numerical and analytical approaches generate equivalent results. This agreement supports the validity of the numerical methods used. Comparisons with results for the Cutler-Gibbons barrier show that small differences in the assumed C and E PE make little difference to values of σB and ρB. Schottky's planar image PE has then been used, in conjunction with the electrostatic PE variation associated with a spherical emitter model, to explore the influence of apex radius r_a on correction-factor values, for values of r_a greater than 20 nm. Both σB and ρB increase significantly as r_a decreases, especially ρB. At low values of barrier field F, σB depends approximately linearly on 1/F, with a slope that depends on r_a. Suggestions are made for how the exploratory work described in this paper might be extended.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Illustrating field emission theory by using Lauritsen plots of transmission probability and barrier strength
Authors:
Richard G. Forbes,
Jonathan H. B. Deane,
Andreas Fischer,
Marwan S. Mousa
Abstract:
This technical note relates to the theory of cold field electron emission (CFE). It starts by suggesting that, to emphasize common properties in relation to CFE theory, the term 'Lauritsen plot' could be used to describe all graphical plots made with the reciprocal of barrier field (or the reciprocal of a quantity proportional to barrier field) on the horizontal axis. It then argues that Lauritsen…
▽ More
This technical note relates to the theory of cold field electron emission (CFE). It starts by suggesting that, to emphasize common properties in relation to CFE theory, the term 'Lauritsen plot' could be used to describe all graphical plots made with the reciprocal of barrier field (or the reciprocal of a quantity proportional to barrier field) on the horizontal axis. It then argues that Lauritsen plots related to barrier strength (G) and transmission probability (D) could play a useful role in discussion of CFE theory. Such plots would supplement conventional Fowler-Nordheim (FN) plots. All these plots would be regarded as particular types of Lauritsen plot. The Lauritsen plots of -G and lnD can be used to illustrate how basic aspects of FN tunnelling theory are influenced by the mathematical form of the tunnelling barrier. These, in turn, influence local emission current density and emission current. Illustrative applications used in this note relate to the well-known exact triangular and Schottky-Nordheim barriers, and to the Coulomb barrier (i.e., the electrostatic component of the electron potential energy barrier outside a model spherical emitter). For the Coulomb barrier, a good analytical series approximation has been found for the barrier-form correction factor; this can be used to predict the existence (and to some extent the properties) of related curvature in FN plots.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2012; v1 submitted 23 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
Improved approach to Fowler-Nordheim plot analysis
Authors:
Richard G. Forbes,
Andreas Fischer,
Marwan S. Mousa
Abstract:
This article introduces an improved approach to Fowler-Nordheim (FN) plot analysis, based on a new type of intercept correction factor. This factor is more cleanly defined than the factor previously used. General enabling theory is given that applies to any type of FN plot of data that can be fitted using a FN-type equation. Practical use is limited to emission situations where slope correction fa…
▽ More
This article introduces an improved approach to Fowler-Nordheim (FN) plot analysis, based on a new type of intercept correction factor. This factor is more cleanly defined than the factor previously used. General enabling theory is given that applies to any type of FN plot of data that can be fitted using a FN-type equation. Practical use is limited to emission situations where slope correction factors can be reliably predicted. By making a series of well-defined assumptions and approximations, it is shown how the general formulas reduce to provide an improved theory of orthodox FN-plot data analysis. This applies to situations where the circuit current is fully controlled by the emitter characteristics, and tunneling can be treated as taking place through a Schottky-Nordheim (SN) barrier. For orthodox emission, good working formulas make numerical evaluation of the slope correction factor and the new intercept correction factor quick and straightforward. A numerical illustration, using simulated emission data, shows how to use this improved approach to derive values for parameters in the full FN-type equation for the SN barrier. Good self-consistency is demonstrated. The general enabling formulas also pave the way for research aimed at develo** analogous data-analysis procedures for non-orthodox emission situations.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2012; v1 submitted 19 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
