-
Validation of hydrodynamic and kinetic simulations with a plasma interpenetration ICF hohlraum experiment
Authors:
Steven E. Anderson,
Luis Chacón,
Andrei N. Simakov,
Brian M. Haines,
David S. Montgomery
Abstract:
We report on simulations of counter-propagating laser-produced plasmas in an inertial confinement fusion (ICF) hohlraum surrogate, aiming to replicate observations reported by Le Pape et. al in recent work. The conditions of the colliding plasmas are relevant to ICF hohlraums used for indirect-drive ignition, and are obtained both with and without low-density He-gas fill. We compare experimental d…
▽ More
We report on simulations of counter-propagating laser-produced plasmas in an inertial confinement fusion (ICF) hohlraum surrogate, aiming to replicate observations reported by Le Pape et. al in recent work. The conditions of the colliding plasmas are relevant to ICF hohlraums used for indirect-drive ignition, and are obtained both with and without low-density He-gas fill. We compare experimental diagnostics to outputs from simulations using the 1D-2V Vlasov-Fokker-Planck kinetic code iFP and the xRAGE radiation-hydrodynamics code. These include the inferred radial lineouts of inferred ion number fraction and ion and electron temperatures, as well as the reported experimental Thomson-scattering (TS) spectra (compared via synthetic TS diagnostics). We observe that 1D kinetic simulations capture the plasma states reported in the experimental diagnostics quite well. Counter-intuitively, the kinetic simulations capture the gas-fill experiment (expected to be more `hydro-like') better than the vacuum experiment, while the reverse is observed for hydrodynamic simulations. This is attributed to the presence of non-trivial multi-dimensional hydrodynamic effects which are more dominant in the vacuum experiment. These effects are somewhat inhibited in the gas-fill experiment, permitting quasi-1D kinetic plasma transport to play more of a role in producing plasma interpenetration. Differences between the effects of Maxwellian vs. non-Maxwellian (`full f') synthetic TS diagnostics are investigated for the kinetic simulations. We find non-Maxwellian TS spectra differ non-trivially from Maxwellian spectra, which suggests caution may be warranted when applying Maxwellian TS models to infer plasma conditions via backward modeling when kinetic effects may be present.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Radiation and Heat Transport in Divergent Shock-Bubble Interactions
Authors:
Kelin Kurzer-Ogul,
Brian M. Haines,
David S. Montgomery,
Silvia Pandolfi,
Joshua P. Sauppe,
Andrew F. T. Leong,
Daniel Hodge,
Pawel M. Kozlowski,
Stefano Marchesini,
Eric Cunningham,
Eric Galtier,
Dimitri Khaghani,
Hae Ja Lee,
Bob Nagler,
Richard L. Sandberg,
Arianna E. Gleason,
Hussein Aluie,
Jessica K. Shang
Abstract:
Shock-bubble interactions (SBI) are important across a wide range of physical systems. In inertial confinement fusion, interactions between laser-driven shocks and micro-voids in both ablators and foam targets generate instabilities that are a major obstacle in achieving ignition. Experiments imaging the collapse of such voids at high energy densities (HED) are constrained by spatial and temporal…
▽ More
Shock-bubble interactions (SBI) are important across a wide range of physical systems. In inertial confinement fusion, interactions between laser-driven shocks and micro-voids in both ablators and foam targets generate instabilities that are a major obstacle in achieving ignition. Experiments imaging the collapse of such voids at high energy densities (HED) are constrained by spatial and temporal resolution, making simulations a vital tool in understanding these systems. In this study, we benchmark several radiation and thermal transport models in the xRAGE hydrodynamic code against experimental images of a collapsing mesoscale void during the passage of a 300 GPa shock. We also quantitatively examine the role of transport physics in the evolution of the SBI. This allows us to understand the dynamics of the interaction at timescales shorter than experimental imaging framerates. We find that all radiation models examined reproduce empirical shock velocities within experimental error. Radiation transport is found to reduce shock pressures by providing an additional energy pathway in the ablation region, but this effect is small ($\sim$1\% of total shock pressure). Employing a flux-limited Spitzer model for heat conduction, we find that flux limiters between 0.03 and 0.10 produce agreement with experimental velocities, suggesting that the system is well-within the Spitzer regime. Higher heat conduction is found to lower temperatures in the ablated plasma and to prevent secondary shocks at the ablation front, resulting in weaker primary shocks. Finally, we confirm that the SBI-driven instabilities observed in the HED regime are baroclinically driven, as in the low energy case.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Neural Network for 3D ICF Shell Reconstruction from Single Radiographs
Authors:
Bradley T. Wolfe,
Zhizhong Han,
Jonathan S. Ben-Benjamin,
John L. Kline,
David S. Montgomery,
Elizabeth C. Merritt,
Paul A. Keiter,
Eric Loomis,
Brian M. Patterson,
Lindsey Kuettner,
Zhehui Wang
Abstract:
In inertial confinement fusion (ICF), X-ray radiography is a critical diagnostic for measuring implosion dynamics, which contains rich 3D information. Traditional methods for reconstructing 3D volumes from 2D radiographs, such as filtered backprojection, require radiographs from at least two different angles or lines of sight (LOS). In ICF experiments, space for diagnostics is limited and cameras…
▽ More
In inertial confinement fusion (ICF), X-ray radiography is a critical diagnostic for measuring implosion dynamics, which contains rich 3D information. Traditional methods for reconstructing 3D volumes from 2D radiographs, such as filtered backprojection, require radiographs from at least two different angles or lines of sight (LOS). In ICF experiments, space for diagnostics is limited and cameras that can operate on the fast timescales are expensive to implement, limiting the number of projections that can be acquired. To improve the imaging quality as a result of this limitation, convolutional neural networks (CNN) have recently been shown to be capable of producing 3D models from visible light images or medical X-ray images rendered by volumetric computed tomography LOS (SLOS). We propose a CNN to reconstruct 3D ICF spherical shells from single radiographs. We also examine sensitivity of the 3D reconstruction to different illumination models using preprocessing techniques such as pseudo-flat fielding. To resolve the issue of the lack of 3D supervision, we show that training the CNN utilizing synthetic radiographs produced by known simulation methods allows for reconstruction of experimental data as long as the experimental data is similar to the synthetic data. We also show that the CNN allows for 3D reconstruction of shells that possess low mode asymmetries. Further comparisons of the 3D reconstructions with direct multiple LOS measurements are justified.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2021; v1 submitted 10 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Optical Mixing Controlled Stimulated Scattering instabilities: Suppression of SRS by the Controlled Introduction of Ion Acoustic and Electron Plasma Wave Turbulence
Authors:
Bedros Afeyan,
M. Mardirian,
K. Won,
D. S. Montgomery,
J. Hammer,
R. K. Kirkwood,
A. J. Schmitt
Abstract:
In a series of experiments on the Omega laser facility at LLE, we have demonstrated the suppression of SRS in prescribed spectral windows due to the presence of externally controlled levels of ion acoustic waves (IAW, by crossing two blue beams at the Mach -1 surface) and electron plasma waves (EPW, by crossing a blue and a green beam around a tenth critical density plasma) generated via optical m…
▽ More
In a series of experiments on the Omega laser facility at LLE, we have demonstrated the suppression of SRS in prescribed spectral windows due to the presence of externally controlled levels of ion acoustic waves (IAW, by crossing two blue beams at the Mach -1 surface) and electron plasma waves (EPW, by crossing a blue and a green beam around a tenth critical density plasma) generated via optical mixing. We have further observed SRS backscattering of a green beam when crossed with a blue pump beam, in whose absence, that (green beam) backscattering signature was five times smaller. This is direct evidence for green beam amplification when crossed with the blue. Additional proof comes from transmitted green beam measurements. A combination of these techniques may allow the suppression of unacceptable levels of SRS near the light entrance hole of large-scale hohlraums on the NIF or LMJ.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Demonstration of an optical mixing technique to drive Kinetic Electrostatic Electron Nonlinear waves in laser produced plasmas
Authors:
J. L. Kline,
B. Afeyan,
W. A. Bertsche,
N. A. Kurnit,
D. S. Montgomery,
R. P. Johnson,
C. Niemann
Abstract:
A nitrogen gas Raman cell system has been constructed to shift a 70 J 527 nm laser beam to 600 nm with 20 J of energy. The 600 nm probe and a 200J, 527 nm pump beam were optically mixed in a laser produced (gas jet) plasma. The beating of the two laser beams formed a ponderomotive force that can drive Kinetic Electrostatic Electron Nonlinear (KEEN) waves discovered in Vlasov-Poisson simulations by…
▽ More
A nitrogen gas Raman cell system has been constructed to shift a 70 J 527 nm laser beam to 600 nm with 20 J of energy. The 600 nm probe and a 200J, 527 nm pump beam were optically mixed in a laser produced (gas jet) plasma. The beating of the two laser beams formed a ponderomotive force that can drive Kinetic Electrostatic Electron Nonlinear (KEEN) waves discovered in Vlasov-Poisson simulations by Afeyan et al [1,2]. KEEN waves were detected in these experiments where traditional plasma theory would declare there to be a spectral gap (ie no linear waves possible). The detection was done using Thomson scattering with probe wavelengths of both 351 nm and 263.5 nm.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
