-
Locational Aspect of Fast Frequency Reserves in Low-Inertia Systems -- Control Performance Analysis
Authors:
Georgios Misyris,
Deepak Ramasubramanian,
Parag Mitra,
Vikas Singhvi
Abstract:
This paper evaluates the frequency performance of an AC system when primary frequency response is provided by inverter-based resources located at remote-areas. Due to potentially larger wave propagation constants over longer lines, fast active power response from inverter based resources may have a negative impact on the system frequency response. Within this context, this paper presents a control…
▽ More
This paper evaluates the frequency performance of an AC system when primary frequency response is provided by inverter-based resources located at remote-areas. Due to potentially larger wave propagation constants over longer lines, fast active power response from inverter based resources may have a negative impact on the system frequency response. Within this context, this paper presents a control performance analysis is presented in order to identify limitations for improving the frequency stability when inverter-based resources in remote locations use local frequency measurements. Our results suggest that there exists a trafeoff between disturbance rejection and stability robustness when allocating primary frequency control. In particular, fast frequency control can have a negative impact on the dam** ratio of poorly damped electromechanical modes.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Frequency dynamics of the Northern European AC/DC power system: a look-ahead study
Authors:
Matas Dijokas,
Danilo Obradovic,
Georgios Misyris,
Tilman Weckesser,
Thierry Van Cutsem
Abstract:
A large share of renewable energy sources integrated into the national grids and an increased interconnection capacity with asynchronous networks, are the main contributors in reducing the kinetic energy storage in the Nordic Power System. Challenges arise to operate system after a loss of generation and to minimize the offshore systems interaction with onshore grids. To assess the associated chal…
▽ More
A large share of renewable energy sources integrated into the national grids and an increased interconnection capacity with asynchronous networks, are the main contributors in reducing the kinetic energy storage in the Nordic Power System. Challenges arise to operate system after a loss of generation and to minimize the offshore systems interaction with onshore grids. To assess the associated challenges, a novel dynamic model was developed under the phasor approximation to represent the future Northern European Power System, including High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) links and future offshore energy islands in the North Sea. First, the future frequency response is provided for two large disturbances to highlight the benefit of the developed model and point out potential future frequency issues. Consequently, further actions are investigated to better utilize the existing frequency containment reserves or to partially replace them using emergency droop-based power control of HVDC links. Lastly, the offshore grid interaction and frequency support to the Nordic network is investigated, and the dynamic response is compared for zero- and low-inertia designs of the offshore energy islands. The simulations were performed using industrial software, and the associated material is made publicly available.
△ Less
Submitted 29 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Transient Stability Analysis with Physics-Informed Neural Networks
Authors:
Jochen Stiasny,
Georgios S. Misyris,
Spyros Chatzivasileiadis
Abstract:
We explore the possibility to use physics-informed neural networks to drastically accelerate the solution of ordinary differential-algebraic equations that govern the power system dynamics. When it comes to transient stability assessment, the traditionally applied methods either carry a significant computational burden, require model simplifications, or use overly conservative surrogate models. Co…
▽ More
We explore the possibility to use physics-informed neural networks to drastically accelerate the solution of ordinary differential-algebraic equations that govern the power system dynamics. When it comes to transient stability assessment, the traditionally applied methods either carry a significant computational burden, require model simplifications, or use overly conservative surrogate models. Conventional neural networks can circumvent these limitations but are faced with high demand of high-quality training datasets, while they ignore the underlying governing equations. Physics-informed neural networks are different: they incorporate the power system differential algebraic equations directly into the neural network training and drastically reduce the need for training data. This paper takes a deep dive into the performance of physics-informed neural networks for power system transient stability assessment. Introducing a new neural network training procedure to facilitate a thorough comparison, we explore how physics-informed neural networks compare with conventional differential-algebraic solvers and classical neural networks in terms of computation time, requirements in data, and prediction accuracy. We illustrate the findings on the Kundur two-area system, and assess the opportunities and challenges of physics-informed neural networks to serve as a transient stability analysis tool, highlighting possible pathways to further develop this method.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2023; v1 submitted 25 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Capturing Power System Dynamics by Physics-Informed Neural Networks and Optimization
Authors:
Georgios S. Misyris,
Jochen Stiasny,
Spyros Chatzivasileiadis
Abstract:
This paper proposes a tractable framework to determine key characteristics of non-linear dynamic systems by converting physics-informed neural networks to a mixed integer linear program. Our focus is on power system applications. Traditional methods in power systems require the use of a large number of simulations and other heuristics to determine parameters such as the critical clearing time, i.e…
▽ More
This paper proposes a tractable framework to determine key characteristics of non-linear dynamic systems by converting physics-informed neural networks to a mixed integer linear program. Our focus is on power system applications. Traditional methods in power systems require the use of a large number of simulations and other heuristics to determine parameters such as the critical clearing time, i.e. the maximum allowable time within which a disturbance must be cleared before the system moves to instability. The work proposed in this paper uses physics-informed neural networks to capture the power system dynamic behavior and, through an exact transformation, converts them to a tractable optimization problem which can be used to determine critical system indices. By converting neural networks to mixed integer linear programs, our framework also allows to adjust the conservativeness of the neural network output with respect to the existing stability boundaries. We demonstrate the performance of our methods on the non-linear dynamics of converter-based generation in response to voltage disturbances.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Towards Optimal Coordination between Regional Groups: HVDC Supplementary Power Control
Authors:
Andrea Tosatto,
Georgios Misyris,
Adrià Junyent-Ferré,
Fei Teng,
Spyros Chatzivasileiadis
Abstract:
With Europe dedicated to limiting climate change and greenhouse gas emissions, large shares of Renewable Energy Sources (RES) are being integrated in the national grids, phasing out conventional generation. The new challenges arising from the energy transition will require a better coordination between neighboring system operators to maintain system security. To this end, this paper studies the be…
▽ More
With Europe dedicated to limiting climate change and greenhouse gas emissions, large shares of Renewable Energy Sources (RES) are being integrated in the national grids, phasing out conventional generation. The new challenges arising from the energy transition will require a better coordination between neighboring system operators to maintain system security. To this end, this paper studies the benefit of exchanging primary frequency reserves between asynchronous areas using the Supplementary Power Control (SPC) functionality of High-Voltage Direct-Current (HVDC) lines. First, we focus on the derivation of frequency metrics for asynchronous AC systems coupled by HVDC interconnectors. We compare two different control schemes for HVDC converters, which allow for unilateral or bilateral exchanges of reserves between neighboring systems. Second, we formulate frequency constraints and include them in a unit commitment problem to ensure the N-1 security criterion. A data-driven approach is proposed to better represent the frequency nadir constraint by means of cutting hyperplanes. Our results suggest that the exchange of primary reserves through HVDC can reduce up to 10% the cost of reserve procurement while maintaining the system N-1 secure.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2021; v1 submitted 25 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Zero-inertia Offshore Grids: N-1 Security and Active Power Sharing
Authors:
Georgios S. Misyris,
Andrea Tosatto,
Spyros Chatzivasileiadis,
Tilman Weckesser
Abstract:
With Denmark dedicated to maintaining its leading position in the integration of massive shares of wind energy, the construction of new offshore energy islands has been recently approved by the Danish government. These new islands will be zero-inertia systems, meaning that no synchronous generation will be installed in the island and that power imbalances will be shared only among converters. To t…
▽ More
With Denmark dedicated to maintaining its leading position in the integration of massive shares of wind energy, the construction of new offshore energy islands has been recently approved by the Danish government. These new islands will be zero-inertia systems, meaning that no synchronous generation will be installed in the island and that power imbalances will be shared only among converters. To this end, this paper proposes a methodology to calculate and update the frequency droops gains of the offshore converters in compliance with the N-1 security criterion in case of converter outage. The frequency droop gains are calculated solving an optimization problem which takes into consideration the power limitations of the converters as well as the stability of the system. As a consequence, the proposed controller ensures safe operation of off-shore systems in the event of any power imbalance and allows for greater loadability at pre-fault state, as confirmed by the simulation results.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2021; v1 submitted 23 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
North Sea Wind Power Hub: System Configurations, Grid Implementation and Techno-economic Assessment
Authors:
Georgios Misyris,
Thierry Van Cutsem,
Jakob Møller,
Matas Dijokas,
Ona Renom Estragués,
Bertrand Bastin,
Spyros Chatzivasileiadis,
Arne Nielsen,
Tilman Weckesser,
Jacob Østergaard,
Fitim Kryezi
Abstract:
In 2017, Energinet and TenneT, the Danish and Dutch Transmission System Operators (TSOs), have announced the North Sea Wind Power Hub (NSWPH) project. The project aims at increasing by 36 GW the North Sea offshore wind capacity, with an artificial island collecting all the power produced by wind turbines and several HVDC links transmitting this power to the onshore grids. This project brings toget…
▽ More
In 2017, Energinet and TenneT, the Danish and Dutch Transmission System Operators (TSOs), have announced the North Sea Wind Power Hub (NSWPH) project. The project aims at increasing by 36 GW the North Sea offshore wind capacity, with an artificial island collecting all the power produced by wind turbines and several HVDC links transmitting this power to the onshore grids. This project brings together new opportunities and new challenges, both from a technical and economic point of view. In this regard, this paper presents three analyses regarding the design and operation of such an offshore system. First, we perform a techno-economic assessment of different grid configurations for the collection of the power produced by wind farms and its transmission to the hub. In this analysis, two frequencies and two voltage levels for the operation of the offshore grid are investigated. Our findings show that the nominal-frequency high-voltage option is the more suitable, as low-frequency does not bring any advantage and low-voltage would results in higher costs. The second analysis is related to the differences in operating the system with low- or zero-inertia; different dynamic studies are performed for each configuration to identify proper control actions and their stability properties. Comparing the outcomes of the simulations, we observed that voltage and frequency oscillations are better damped in the zero-inertia system; however, the risk of propagating offshore faults in the connected onshore grids is mitigated with the inclusion of the synchronous condensers. Lastly, a comparison of ElectroMagnetic Transient (EMT) and phasor-mode (also known as RMS) models is presented, in order to understand their appropriateness of simulating low- and zero- inertia systems. The results show that phasor approximation modelling can be used, as long as eigen-frequencies in power network are well damped.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Physics-Informed Neural Networks for Non-linear System Identification for Power System Dynamics
Authors:
Jochen Stiasny,
George S. Misyris,
Spyros Chatzivasileiadis
Abstract:
Varying power-infeed from converter-based generation units introduces great uncertainty on system parameters such as inertia and dam**. As a consequence, system operators face increasing challenges in performing dynamic security assessment and taking real-time control actions. Exploiting the widespread deployment of phasor measurement units (PMUs) and aiming at develo** a fast dynamic state an…
▽ More
Varying power-infeed from converter-based generation units introduces great uncertainty on system parameters such as inertia and dam**. As a consequence, system operators face increasing challenges in performing dynamic security assessment and taking real-time control actions. Exploiting the widespread deployment of phasor measurement units (PMUs) and aiming at develo** a fast dynamic state and parameter estimation tool, this paper investigates the performance of Physics-Informed Neural Networks (PINN) for discovering the frequency dynamics of future power systems. PINNs have the potential to address challenges such as the stronger non-linearities of low-inertia systems, increased measurement noise, and limited availability of data. The estimator is demonstrated in several test cases using a 4-bus system, and compared with state of the art algorithms, such as the Unscented Kalman Filter (UKF), to assess its performance.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2021; v1 submitted 8 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Multi-Terminal DC Fault Identification for MMC-HVDC Systems based on Modal Analysis -- A Localized Protection Scheme
Authors:
Vaibhav Nougain,
Sukumar Mishra,
George S. Misyris,
Spyros Chatzivasileiadis
Abstract:
We propose a localized protection scheme based on modal analysis in multi-terminal modular multilevel converter (MMC) based high voltage DC (HVDC) systems. The paper addresses the issues of localized protection scheme based DC fault identification, such as differentiating between external and internal faults, classification of type of fault contingency i.e., pole to pole (\textit{PTP}) or pole to…
▽ More
We propose a localized protection scheme based on modal analysis in multi-terminal modular multilevel converter (MMC) based high voltage DC (HVDC) systems. The paper addresses the issues of localized protection scheme based DC fault identification, such as differentiating between external and internal faults, classification of type of fault contingency i.e., pole to pole (\textit{PTP}) or pole to ground (\textit{PTG}) for high impedance faults (HIFs) in the system. The scheme works on equivalent network of multi-terminal MMC-HVDC system for a DC fault, using phase-modal transformation to analyse line-mode and zero-mode voltage across the current limiting reactor (CLR) for different possible contingencies in the presence of fault resistance. The protection scheme is validated to be reliable for HIFs and in the presence of White Gaussian Noise (WGN) in measurement. The scheme operation is validated to be intact for varying fault location, fault resistances and system transients.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2020; v1 submitted 23 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Neural Networks for Encoding Dynamic Security-Constrained Optimal Power Flow
Authors:
Ilgiz Murzakhanov,
Andreas Venzke,
George S. Misyris,
Spyros Chatzivasileiadis
Abstract:
This paper introduces a framework to capture previously intractable optimization constraints and transform them to a mixed-integer linear program, through the use of neural networks. We encode the feasible space of optimization problems characterized by both tractable and intractable constraints, e.g. differential equations, to a neural network. Leveraging an exact mixed-integer reformulation of n…
▽ More
This paper introduces a framework to capture previously intractable optimization constraints and transform them to a mixed-integer linear program, through the use of neural networks. We encode the feasible space of optimization problems characterized by both tractable and intractable constraints, e.g. differential equations, to a neural network. Leveraging an exact mixed-integer reformulation of neural networks, we solve mixed-integer linear programs that accurately approximate solutions to the originally intractable non-linear optimization problem. We apply our methods to the AC optimal power flow problem (AC-OPF), where directly including dynamic security constraints renders the AC-OPF intractable. Our proposed approach has the potential to be significantly more scalable than traditional approaches. We demonstrate our approach for power system operation considering N-1 security and small-signal stability, showing how it can efficiently obtain cost-optimal solutions which at the same time satisfy both static and dynamic security constraints.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2022; v1 submitted 17 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Zero-inertia Systems: Sufficient Conditions for Phasor Modeling
Authors:
Georgios Misyris,
Spyros Chatzivasileiadis,
Tilman Weckesser
Abstract:
Time-domain simulations are a critical tool for power system operators. Depending on the instability mechanism under consideration and the system characteristics, such as the time constants of controllers, either phasor or Electro-Magnetic Transient (EMT) models should be employed. On the one hand, EMT models provide a detailed-modeling of the system dynamics, thus increase the reliability of stab…
▽ More
Time-domain simulations are a critical tool for power system operators. Depending on the instability mechanism under consideration and the system characteristics, such as the time constants of controllers, either phasor or Electro-Magnetic Transient (EMT) models should be employed. On the one hand, EMT models provide a detailed-modeling of the system dynamics, thus increase the reliability of stability analysis; on the other end, using these models increase the computational times of simulations, slowing down the security assessment process. To decrease computational time, system operators could resort to phasor-mode simulations for a (hopefully large) subset of disturbances. This paper investigates the appropriateness of phasor-approximation models on simulating events related to power supply and balance stability in zero-inertia systems. First, the stability boundaries, which each model is able to identify, are analyzed; then sufficient conditions for control parameters are derived, which allow using phasor-approximation models to monitor power sharing among grid-forming converter-based resources. Time-domain simulations are performed in PowerFactory DigSilent to verify the results.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Physics-Informed Neural Networks for Power Systems
Authors:
George S. Misyris,
Andreas Venzke,
Spyros Chatzivasileiadis
Abstract:
This paper introduces for the first time, to our knowledge, a framework for physics-informed neural networks in power system applications. Exploiting the underlying physical laws governing power systems, and inspired by recent developments in the field of machine learning, this paper proposes a neural network training procedure that can make use of the wide range of mathematical models describing…
▽ More
This paper introduces for the first time, to our knowledge, a framework for physics-informed neural networks in power system applications. Exploiting the underlying physical laws governing power systems, and inspired by recent developments in the field of machine learning, this paper proposes a neural network training procedure that can make use of the wide range of mathematical models describing power system behavior, both in steady-state and in dynamics. Physics-informed neural networks require substantially less training data and can result in simpler neural network structures, while achieving high accuracy. This work unlocks a range of opportunities in power systems, being able to determine dynamic states, such as rotor angles and frequency, and uncertain parameters such as inertia and dam** at a fraction of the computational time required by conventional methods. This paper focuses on introducing the framework and showcases its potential using a single-machine infinite bus system as a guiding example. Physics-informed neural networks are shown to accurately determine rotor angle and frequency up to 87 times faster than conventional methods.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2020; v1 submitted 9 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
