Showing 1–50 of 52 results for author: Metzger, P

Rocket Exhaust Blowing Soil in Near Vacuum Conditions is Faster than Predicted by Continuum Scaling Laws

Authors: Philip T. Metzger

Abstract: Experiments were performed to study how rocket exhaust blows soil in lunar and Martian conditions. Jets of gas were blown downwardly at various granular materials while a camera recorded the formation of scour holes as the material was removed. The experiments were performed in a series of conditions ranging from ambient 101 kPa pressure down to 0.3 kPa. This includes the range that is relevant fo… ▽ More Experiments were performed to study how rocket exhaust blows soil in lunar and Martian conditions. Jets of gas were blown downwardly at various granular materials while a camera recorded the formation of scour holes as the material was removed. The experiments were performed in a series of conditions ranging from ambient 101 kPa pressure down to 0.3 kPa. This includes the range that is relevant for lunar conditions, because it is not hard vacuum inside the rocket exhaust where soil is being eroded. Prior work in ambient conditions showed that erosion rate is proportional to the square of the densimetric Froude number. However, the prior work was not performed at low pressures. In the new work, preliminary results show that as the gas density is so low that gas flow around the sand grains is no longer in the continuum regime, then erosion rate is faster than predicted by the earlier results. The dependency of erosion rate on various parameters is determined, but it turns out to be more complex than expected so additional experimental work will be required to develop complete scaling relationships. △ Less

Submitted 21 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Comments: 9 pages, 7 figures. ASCE Earth & Space 2016 conference

Journal ref: Proceedings of 15th Biennial ASCE Conference on Engineering, Science, Construction, and Operations in Challenging Environments (Earth & Space 2016), pp. 58-66. Reston, VA: American Society of Civil Engineers, 2016

Erosion rate of lunar soil under a landing rocket, part 2: benchmarking and predictions

Authors: Philip Metzger

Abstract: In the companion paper ("Erosion rate of lunar soil under a landing rocket, part 1: identifying the rate-limiting physics", this issue) an equation was developed for the rate that lunar soil erodes under the exhaust of a landing rocket. That equation has only one parameter that is not calibrated from first principles, so here it is calibrated by the blowing soil's optical density curve during an A… ▽ More In the companion paper ("Erosion rate of lunar soil under a landing rocket, part 1: identifying the rate-limiting physics", this issue) an equation was developed for the rate that lunar soil erodes under the exhaust of a landing rocket. That equation has only one parameter that is not calibrated from first principles, so here it is calibrated by the blowing soil's optical density curve during an Apollo landing. An excellent fit is obtained, hel** validate the equation. However, when extrapolating the erosion rate all the way to touchdown on the lunar surface, a soil model is needed to handle the increased resistance to erosion as the deeper, more compacted soil is exposed. Relying on models derived from Apollo measurements and from Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter (LRO) Diviner thermal inertia measurements, only one additional soil parameter is unknown: the scale of increasing cohesive energy with soil compaction. Treating this as an additional fitting parameter results in some degeneracy in the solutions, but the depth of erosion scour in the post-landing imagery provides an additional constraint on the solution. The results show that about 4 to 10 times more soil was blown in each Apollo landing than previously believed, so the potential for sandblasting damage is worse than prior estimates. This also shows that, with further development, instruments to measure the soil erosion during lunar landings can constrain the soil column's density profile complementary to the thermal inertia measurements, providing insight into the landing site's geology. △ Less

Submitted 27 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 20 pages, 8 figures

Erosion rate of lunar soil under a landing rocket, part 1: identifying the rate-limiting physics

Authors: Philip Metzger

Abstract: Multiple nations are planning activity on the Moon's surface, and to deconflict lunar operations we must understand the sandblasting damage from rocket exhaust blowing soil. Prior research disagreed over the scaling of the erosion rate, which determines the magnitude of the damage. Reduced gravity experiments and two other lines of evidence now indicate that the erosion rate scales with the kineti… ▽ More Multiple nations are planning activity on the Moon's surface, and to deconflict lunar operations we must understand the sandblasting damage from rocket exhaust blowing soil. Prior research disagreed over the scaling of the erosion rate, which determines the magnitude of the damage. Reduced gravity experiments and two other lines of evidence now indicate that the erosion rate scales with the kinetic energy flux at the bottom of the laminar sublayer of the gas. Because the rocket exhaust is so fast, eroded particles lifted higher in the boundary layer do not impact the surface for kilometers (if at all; some leave the Moon entirely), so there is no saltation in the vicinity of the gas. As a result, there is little transport of gas kinetic energy from higher in the boundary layer down to the surface, so the emission of soil into the gas is a surprisingly low energy process. In low lunar gravity, a dominant source of resistance to this small energy flux turns out to be the cohesive energy density of the lunar soil, which arises primarily from particles in the 0.3 to 3 micron size range. These particles constitute only a tiny fraction of the mass of lunar soil and have been largely ignored in most studies, so they are poorly characterized. △ Less

Submitted 27 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 18 pages, 2 figures

Cohesion and Shear Strength of Compacted Lunar and Martian Regolith Simulants

Authors: B. Dotson, D. Sanchez Valencia, C. Millwater, P. Easter, J. Long-Fox, D. Britt, P. Metzger

Abstract: Shear strength and cohesion of granular materials are important geotechnical properties that play a crucial role in the stability and behavior of lunar and Martian regolith, as well as their terrestrial analog materials. To characterize and predict shear strength and cohesion for future space missions, it is also important to understand the effects of particle size distribution and density on thes… ▽ More Shear strength and cohesion of granular materials are important geotechnical properties that play a crucial role in the stability and behavior of lunar and Martian regolith, as well as their terrestrial analog materials. To characterize and predict shear strength and cohesion for future space missions, it is also important to understand the effects of particle size distribution and density on these fundamental geotechnical properties. Generalized equations have been established using empirical data from direct shear measurements of lunar and Martian regolith simulants to quantify the effects of particle size distribution and density on cohesion and shear strength. Preliminary results are also presented highlighting the effects of atmospheric absorbed water on shear strength and cohesion when conducting experiments in atmospheric conditions on Earth. The results of this study show that cohesion increases exponentially with bulk density, while the exponential growth constant is also dependent on particle size distribution. △ Less

Submitted 16 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

A new launch pad failure mode: Analysis of fine particles from the launch of the first Starship orbital test flight

Authors: B. Dotson, P. Metzger, J. Hafner, A. Shackelford, K. Birkenfeld, D. Britt, A. Ford, R. Truscott, S. Truscott, J. Zavaleta, J. Zemke, K. Purvis, M. Scudder, C. Johnson, J. Galloway, J. DeShetler

Abstract: This study examines the characteristics, composition, and origin of fine particle debris samples collected following the launch of the first Starship orbital test flight, which suggests a new launch pad failure mode previously unknown. Particle shapes, sizes, bulk densities, and VIS/NIR/MIR spectra, of collected fine particle material from Port Isabel, TX, were analyzed and compared to pulverized… ▽ More This study examines the characteristics, composition, and origin of fine particle debris samples collected following the launch of the first Starship orbital test flight, which suggests a new launch pad failure mode previously unknown. Particle shapes, sizes, bulk densities, and VIS/NIR/MIR spectra, of collected fine particle material from Port Isabel, TX, were analyzed and compared to pulverized concrete, Fondag (high temperature concrete), limestone, and sand recovered from the area near the Starship launch pad after this test flight. Raman spectroscopy was also used to determine mineral compositions of each sample. Results suggest that the fine particle material lofted by the Starship launch is consistent with sand derived from the launch site. These results imply that the destruction of the launch pad eroded and lofted material into the air from the underlying sandy, base-layer. From calculations, this lofted material likely remained suspended in the air for minutes following the launch from recirculation, allowing for transport over an extended range. Most of the recovered material was too coarse to be a respiration hazard, as a small mass fraction of the particles (<1%) had diameters of 10 um or less. Video analysis and ballistic models also provide insight into the failure mechanism associated with the launch pad, which was consistent with a high-pressure eruption from the region below the failed launch pad. △ Less

Submitted 15 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Lunar Cold Trap Contamination by Landing Vehicles

Authors: Scott T. Shipley, John E. Lane, Philip T. Metzger

Abstract: Tools have been developed to model and simulate the effects of lunar landing vehicles on the lunar environment, mostly addressing the effects of regolith erosion by rocket plumes and the fate of the ejected lunar soil particles. The KSC Granular Mechanics and Regolith Operations Lab tools have now been expanded to address volatile contamination of the lunar surface (Stern, 1999). Landing nearby su… ▽ More Tools have been developed to model and simulate the effects of lunar landing vehicles on the lunar environment, mostly addressing the effects of regolith erosion by rocket plumes and the fate of the ejected lunar soil particles. The KSC Granular Mechanics and Regolith Operations Lab tools have now been expanded to address volatile contamination of the lunar surface (Stern, 1999). Landing nearby such a crater will result in the migration of significant exhaust plume gas into the cold trap of the crater, and will also create an unnatural atmosphere over the volatile reservoirs that are to be studied. Our calculations address: 1) the time for the plume-induced local atmosphere above cold traps to decay to normal levels, 2) the efficiency of gas migration into a permanently shadowed crater when the landing is outside it but nearby, and 3) reduction on contamination afforded by moving the landing site further from the crater or by topographically shielding the crater from the direct flux of a lander's ground jet. We also address plume volatiles adsorbed onto and driven inside soil ejecta particles from their residence in the high pressure stagnation region of the engine exhaust plume, and how their mechanical dispersal across the lunar surface contributes to the induced atmosphere. One additional question is whether the collection of soil ejecta along the base of a topographic feature will produce a measurable plume volatile release distinct from the background. We mostly address item 2). Item 3) is obvious from our results excepting that the removal distances may be large, but changes to landing strategy can improve the situation. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 13 pages, 18 figures. Presented at Earth & Space 2014 conference

Thermal Extraction of Volatiles from Lunar and Asteroid Regolith in Axisymmetric Crank-Nicholson Modeling

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, Kris Zacny, Phillip Morrison

Abstract: A physics-based computer model has been developed to support the development of volatile extraction from regolith of the Moon and asteroids. The model is based upon empirical data sets for extraterrestrial soils and simulants, including thermal conductivity of regolith and mixed composition ice, heat capacity of soil and mixed composition ice, hydrated mineral volatile release patterns, and sublim… ▽ More A physics-based computer model has been developed to support the development of volatile extraction from regolith of the Moon and asteroids. The model is based upon empirical data sets for extraterrestrial soils and simulants, including thermal conductivity of regolith and mixed composition ice, heat capacity of soil and mixed composition ice, hydrated mineral volatile release patterns, and sublimation of ice. A new thermal conductivity relationship is derived that generalizes cases of regolith with varying temperature, soil porosity, and pore vapor pressure. Ice composition is based upon measurements of icy ejecta from the Lunar CRater Observation and Sensing Satellite (LCROSS) impact and it is shown that thermal conductivity and heat capacity equations for water ice provide adequate accuracy at the present level of development. The heat diffusion equations are integrated with gas diffusion equations using multiple adaptive timesteps. The entire model is placed into a Crank-Nicholson framework where the finite difference formalism was extended to two dimensions in axisymmetry. The one-dimensional version of the model successfully predicts heat transfer that matches lunar and asteroid data sets. The axisymmetric model has been used to study heat dissipation around lunar drills and water extraction in asteroid coring devices. △ Less

Submitted 6 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 50 pages, 23 figures

Journal ref: J. Aerospace Engineering 33, no.6 (Nov. 2020): 04020075

Modeling the Thermal Extraction of Water Ice from Regolith

Authors: Philip Metzger

Abstract: Modeling has been developed to support the development of volatile extraction technologies for the Moon, Mars, asteroids, or other bodies. This type of modeling capability is important to avoid the high cost of multiple test campaigns in simulated lunar conditions as the hardware design is iterated. The modeling uses the Crank-Nicholson algorithm applied in a two dimensional (2D) axisymmetric (ext… ▽ More Modeling has been developed to support the development of volatile extraction technologies for the Moon, Mars, asteroids, or other bodies. This type of modeling capability is important to avoid the high cost of multiple test campaigns in simulated lunar conditions as the hardware design is iterated. The modeling uses the Crank-Nicholson algorithm applied in a two dimensional (2D) axisymmetric (extendable to 3D) finite difference formalism. It uses soil thermal parameters developed from Apollo soil measurements with adaptations for asteroid regolith. Simulations show that it successfully replicates thermal measurements on the surfaces of asteroids and the Moon and helps interpret those measurements to provide insight into the subsurface properties of those bodies. The 2D simulations have provided insight into the cooling of a lunar drill bit and provide a method to determine the original subsurface temperature despite the presence of the warm bit. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 12 pages, 3 figures. Presented at Earth & Space 2018 conference

Results of the 2015 Workshop on Asteroid Simulants

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, Daniel T. Britt, Stephen D. Covey, John S. Lewis

Abstract: The first asteroid simulants workshop was held in late 2015. These materials are needed for tests of technologies and mission operational concepts, for training astronauts , for medical studies, and a variety of other purposes. The new program is based on lessons learned from the earlier lunar simulants program. It aims to deliver families of simulants for major spectral classes of asteroids both… ▽ More The first asteroid simulants workshop was held in late 2015. These materials are needed for tests of technologies and mission operational concepts, for training astronauts , for medical studies, and a variety of other purposes. The new program is based on lessons learned from the earlier lunar simulants program. It aims to deliver families of simulants for major spectral classes of asteroids both in cobble and regolith form, beginning with one type of carbonaceous chondrite and rapidly expanding to provide four to six more asteroid classes. These simulants will replicate a selected list of asteroid properties, but not all known properties, in order to serve the greatest number of users at an affordable price. They will be benchmarked by a variety of data sets including laboratory analysis of meteorites, observation of bolides, remote sensing of asteroids, data from asteroid missions, and scientific modeling. A variety of laboratory tests will verify the as-manufactured simulants are accurately and repeatedly providing the specified characteristics. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 13 pages, no figures. Presented at Earth & Space 2016 conference

Further Analysis on the Mystery of the Surveyor III Dust Deposits

Authors: John Lane, Steven Trigwell, Paul Hintze, Philip Metzger

Abstract: The Apollo 12 lunar module (LM) landing near the Surveyor III spacecraft at the end of 1969 has remained the primary experimental verification of the predicted physics of plume ejecta effects from a rocket engine interacting with the surface of the moon. This was made possible by the return of the Surveyor III camera housing by the Apollo 12 astronauts, allowing detailed analysis of the compositio… ▽ More The Apollo 12 lunar module (LM) landing near the Surveyor III spacecraft at the end of 1969 has remained the primary experimental verification of the predicted physics of plume ejecta effects from a rocket engine interacting with the surface of the moon. This was made possible by the return of the Surveyor III camera housing by the Apollo 12 astronauts, allowing detailed analysis of the composition of dust deposited by the LM plume. It was soon realized after the initial analysis of the camera housing that the LM plume tended to remove more dust than it had deposited. In the present study, coupons from the camera housing have been reexamined. In addition, plume effects recorded in landing videos from each Apollo mission have been studied for possible clues. Several likely scenarios are proposed to explain the Surveyor III dust observations. These include electrostatic levitation of the dust from the surface of the Moon as a result of periodic passing of the day-night terminator; dust blown by the Apollo 12 LM flyby while on its descent trajectory; dust ejected from the lunar surface due to gas forced into the soil by the Surveyor III rocket nozzle, based on Darcy's law; and mechanical movement of dust during the Surveyor landing. Even though an absolute answer may not be possible based on available data and theory, various computational models are employed to estimate the feasibility of each of these proposed mechanisms. Scenarios are then discussed which combine multiple mechanisms to produce results consistent with observations. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 10 pages, 10 figures. Presented at Earth & Space 2012 conference

Soil Test Apparatus for Lunar Surfaces

Authors: Laila A. Rahmatian, Philip T. Metzger

Abstract: We have studied several field geotechnical test instruments for their applicability to lunar soil simulants and analog soils. Their performance was evaluated in a series of tests in lunar simulants JSC-1A, NU-LHT-2M, and CHENOBI each prepared in carefully controlled states of compaction through vibration on a shake table with overburden. In general, none of the instruments is adequate for a low-co… ▽ More We have studied several field geotechnical test instruments for their applicability to lunar soil simulants and analog soils. Their performance was evaluated in a series of tests in lunar simulants JSC-1A, NU-LHT-2M, and CHENOBI each prepared in carefully controlled states of compaction through vibration on a shake table with overburden. In general, none of the instruments is adequate for a low-cohesion, frictional soil, but we find that a modified version of a shear vane tester allows us to extract several of the important soil parameters. This modified instrument may be useful for use on the lunar surface by astronauts or a robotic lander. We have also found that JSC-1A does not behave mechanically like the other lunar soil simulants, probably because its particle shapes are more rounded. Furthermore we have studied a soil material, BP-1, identified as very lunar-like at a lunar analog location. We find this material has a natural particle size distribution similar to that of lunar soil and arguably better than JSC-1A. We find that BP-1 behaves very similarly to the high fidelity lunar simulants NU-LHT-2M and CHENOBI. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 15 pages, 14 figures. Presented at Earth & Space 2010 conference

Rocket Cratering in Simulated Lunar and Martian Environments

Authors: Christopher Immer, Philip Metzger

Abstract: With NASA's planned return to the moon and possibly with lunar outposts being formed, repeated landings at the same site will be necessary. Understanding rocket plume interaction with lunar and Martian surfaces is of paramount importance in order to safely land and protect hardware surrounding the landing site. This work will report on results of three small experiments intended to explore plume i… ▽ More With NASA's planned return to the moon and possibly with lunar outposts being formed, repeated landings at the same site will be necessary. Understanding rocket plume interaction with lunar and Martian surfaces is of paramount importance in order to safely land and protect hardware surrounding the landing site. This work will report on results of three small experiments intended to explore plume im**ement onto lunar and Martian surfaces: Handheld Observation of Scour Holes (HOOSH), Handheld Angle of Repose Measurements of Lunar Simulants (HARMLuS), and Mars Architecture Team study (MATS). The first two experiments were performed during two sorties of reduced gravity flights. HOOSH was designed to investigate crater formation as a function of gravitational level (lunar and Martian gravity). HARMLuS was designed to measure the Angle of Failure (related to the angle of repose) at lunar and Martian gravity. Both experiments have complex findings indicative of the hysteretic behavior of granular materials, especially resulting from reduced gravity. The MATS experiment was designed to investigate the effects of regolith compaction on the granular mechanics of crater formation. In general, the granular mechanics is a much stronger function of compaction than gravitation acceleration. Crater formation is greatly enhanced at reduced gravity (resulting in much larger craters). The angle of failure of the lunar simulants increases with decreasing gravitational acceleration, and occasionally becomes infinite for some compactions at lunar gravity. The angle of failure also increases with increasing compaction. While compaction does play a role in the time development of crater formation, the asymptotic behavior is largely unaffected. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 9 pages, 8 figures. Presented at Earth & Space 2010 conference

The Physical State of Lunar Soil in the Permanently Shadowed Craters of the Moon

Authors: Jacob N. Gamsky, Philip T. Metzger

Abstract: The physical state of the lunar soil in the permanently shadowed craters of the moon is inferred from experimental investigation. The permanently shadowed craters do not undergo the same thermal cycling experienced by other parts of the moon and therefore could be slightly less compacted. This study is significant because excavating, roving, and landing interactions, along with the energy budgets… ▽ More The physical state of the lunar soil in the permanently shadowed craters of the moon is inferred from experimental investigation. The permanently shadowed craters do not undergo the same thermal cycling experienced by other parts of the moon and therefore could be slightly less compacted. This study is significant because excavating, roving, and landing interactions, along with the energy budgets and deployment schedules for associated technology, need to be scaled and designed properly. Results indicate that the degree of compaction due to thermal cycling is a function of the depth in the soil column. △ Less

Submitted 31 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: 6 pages, 3 figures. Presented at Earth & Space 2010 conference

Lagrangian Trajectory Modeling of Lunar Dust Particles

Authors: John E. Lane, Philip T. Metzger, Christopher D. Immer, Xiaoyi Li

Abstract: A mathematical model and software implementation developed to predict trajectories of single lunar dust particles acted on by a high velocity gas flow is discussed. The model uses output from a computation fluid dynamics (CFD) or direct simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) simulation of a rocket nozzle hot gas jet. The gas density, velocity vector field, and temperature predicted by the CFD/DSMC simulati… ▽ More A mathematical model and software implementation developed to predict trajectories of single lunar dust particles acted on by a high velocity gas flow is discussed. The model uses output from a computation fluid dynamics (CFD) or direct simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) simulation of a rocket nozzle hot gas jet. The gas density, velocity vector field, and temperature predicted by the CFD/DSMC simulations, provide the data necessary to compute the forces and accelerations acting on a single particle of regolith. All calculations of trajectory assume that the duration of particle flight is much shorter than the change in gas properties, i.e., the particle trajectory calculations take into account the spatial variation of the gas jet, but not the temporal variation. This is a reasonable first-order assumption. Final results are compared to photogrammetry derived estimates of dust angles form Apollo landing videos. △ Less

Submitted 31 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: 9 pages, 9 figures. Presented at Earth & Space 2008 conference

The Damage to Lunar Orbiting Spacecraft Caused by the Ejecta of Lunar Landers

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, James G. Mantovani

Abstract: This manuscript analyzes lunar lander soil erosion models and trajectory models to calculate how much damage will occur to spacecraft orbiting in the vicinity of the Moon. The soil erosion models have considerable uncertainty due to gaps in our understanding of the basic physics. The results for ~40 t landers show that the Lunar Orbital Gateway will be impacted by 1000s to 10,000s of particles per… ▽ More This manuscript analyzes lunar lander soil erosion models and trajectory models to calculate how much damage will occur to spacecraft orbiting in the vicinity of the Moon. The soil erosion models have considerable uncertainty due to gaps in our understanding of the basic physics. The results for ~40 t landers show that the Lunar Orbital Gateway will be impacted by 1000s to 10,000s of particles per square meter but the particle sizes are very small and the impact velocity is low so the damage will be slight. However, a spacecraft in Low Lunar Orbit that happens to pass through the ejecta sheet will sustain extensive damage with hundreds of millions of impacts per square meter: although they are small, they are in the hypervelocity regime, and exposed glass on the spacecraft will sustain spallation over 4% of its surface. △ Less

Submitted 20 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: 10 pagers, 8 figures

Journal ref: In Earth and Space 2021, pp. 136-145. 2021

Economics of In-Space Industry and Competitiveness of Lunar-Derived Rocket Propellant

Authors: Philip Metzger

Abstract: Economic parameters are identified for an in-space industry where the capital is made on one planet, it is transported to and teleoperated on a second planet, and the product is transported off the second planet for consumption. This framework is used to model the long-run cost of lunar propellant production to help answer whether it is commercially competitive against propellant launched from Ear… ▽ More Economic parameters are identified for an in-space industry where the capital is made on one planet, it is transported to and teleoperated on a second planet, and the product is transported off the second planet for consumption. This framework is used to model the long-run cost of lunar propellant production to help answer whether it is commercially competitive against propellant launched from Earth. The prior techno-economic analyses (TEAs) of lunar propellant production had disagreed over this. The "gear ratio on cost" for capital transport, G, and the production mass ratio of the capital, phi, are identified as the most important factors determining competitiveness. The prior TEAs are examined for how they handled these two metrics. This identifies crucial mistakes in some of the TEAs: choosing transportation architectures with high G, and neglecting to make choices for the capital that could achieve adequate phi. The tent sublimation technology has a value of phi that is an order of magnitude better than the threshold for competitiveness even in low Earth orbit (LEO). The strip mining technology is closer to the threshold, but technological improvements plus several years of operating experience will improve its competitiveness, according to the model. Objections from members of the aerospace community are discussed, especially the question whether the technology can attain adequate reliability in the lunar environment. The results suggest that lunar propellant production will be commercially viable and that it should lower the cost of doing everything else in space. △ Less

Submitted 15 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: To be published in Acta Astronautica. 50 pages, 16 figures

Temperature distribution in a gas-solid fixed bed probed by rapid magnetic resonance imaging

Authors: M. Raquel Serial, Stefan Benders, Perrine Rotzetter, Daniel L. Brummerloh, Jens P. Metzger, Simon P. Gross, Jennifer Nussbaumc, Christoph R. Müller, Klaas P. Pruessmann, Alexander Penn

Abstract: Controlling the temperature distribution inside catalytic fixed bed reactors is crucial for yield optimization and process stability. Yet, in situ temperature measurements with spatial and temporal resolution are still challenging. In this work, we perform temperature measurements in a cylindrical fixed bed reactor by combining the capabilities of real-time magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with th… ▽ More Controlling the temperature distribution inside catalytic fixed bed reactors is crucial for yield optimization and process stability. Yet, in situ temperature measurements with spatial and temporal resolution are still challenging. In this work, we perform temperature measurements in a cylindrical fixed bed reactor by combining the capabilities of real-time magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with the temperature-dependent proton resonance frequency (PRF) shift of water. Three-dimensional (3D) temperature maps are acquired while heating the bed from room temperature to 60~$^{\circ}$C using hot air. The obtained results show a clear temperature gradient along the axial and radial dimensions and agree with optical temperature probe measurements with an average error of $\pm$ 1.5~$^{\circ}$C. We believe that the MR thermometry methodology presented here opens new perspectives for the fundamental study of mass and heat transfer in gas-solid fixed beds and in the future might be extended to the study of reactive gas-solid systems. △ Less

Submitted 24 November, 2022; originally announced November 2022.

Fingering instabilities in binary granular systems

Authors: Meng Liu, Nicholas A. Conzelmann, Louis Girardin, Fabian J. Dickhardt, Christopher P. McLaren, Jens. P. Metzger, Christoph R. Müller

Abstract: Fingering instabilities akin to the Rayleigh-Taylor (RT) instability in fluids have been observed in a binary granular system consisting of dense and small particles layered on top of lighter and larger particles, when the system is subjected to vertical vibration and fluidizing gas flow. Using observations from experiments and numerical modelling we explore whether the theory developed to describ… ▽ More Fingering instabilities akin to the Rayleigh-Taylor (RT) instability in fluids have been observed in a binary granular system consisting of dense and small particles layered on top of lighter and larger particles, when the system is subjected to vertical vibration and fluidizing gas flow. Using observations from experiments and numerical modelling we explore whether the theory developed to describe the Rayleigh-Taylor (RT) instability in fluids is also applicable to binary granular systems. Our results confirm the applicability of the classic RT instability theory for binary granular systems demonstrating that several key features are observed in both types of systems, viz: (i) The characteristic wavenumber of the instability is constant with time, (ii) the amplitude of the characteristic wavenumber initially grows exponentially and (iii) the dispersion relation between the wavenumbers k of the interface instability and the growth rates n(k) of their amplitudes holds in both fluid-fluid and binary granular systems. Our results also demonstrate that inter-particle friction is essential for the RT instability to occur in granular media. For zero particle friction the interface instability bears a greater resembles to the Richtmyer-Meshkov instability. We further define a yield criterion Y for the interface by treating the granular medium as a viscoplastic material; only for Y > 15 fingering occurs. Interestingly, previous work has shown that instabilities in the Earth's lower mantle, another viscoplastic material, also occur for similar values of Y. △ Less

Submitted 22 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

Comments: 13 pages, 14 figures (including appendices)

The Cost of Lunar Landing Pads with a Trade Study of Construction Methods

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, Greg W. Autry

Abstract: This study estimates the cost of building lunar landing pads and examines whether any construction methods are economically superior to others. Some proposed methods require large amounts of mass transported from the Earth, others require high energy consumption on the lunar surface, and others have a long construction time. Each of these factors contributes direct and indirect costs to lunar acti… ▽ More This study estimates the cost of building lunar landing pads and examines whether any construction methods are economically superior to others. Some proposed methods require large amounts of mass transported from the Earth, others require high energy consumption on the lunar surface, and others have a long construction time. Each of these factors contributes direct and indirect costs to lunar activities. The most important economic variables turn out to be the transportation cost to the lunar surface and the magnitude of the program delay cost imposed by a construction method. The cost of a landing pad depends sensitively on the optimization of the mass and speed of the construction equipment, so a minimum-cost set of equipment exists for each construction method within a specified economic scenario. Several scenarios have been analyzed across a range of transportation costs with both high and low program delay costs. It is found that microwave sintering is currently the most favorable method to build the inner, high temperature zone of a lunar landing pad, although other methods are within the range of uncertainty. The most favorable method to build the outer, low temperature zone of the landing pad is also sintering when transportation costs are high, but it switches to polymer infusion when transportation costs drop below about \$110K/kg to the lunar surface. It is estimated that the Artemis Basecamp could build a landing pad with a budgeted line-item cost of \$229M assuming that transportation costs will be reduced modestly from the current rate \$1M/kg to the lunar surface to \$300K/kg. A landing pad drops to \$130M when the transportation cost drops further to \$100K/kg, or to \$47M if transportation costs fall below \$10K/kg. Ultimately, landing pads can be built around the Moon at very low cost, due to economies of scale. △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Comments: 50 pages, 15 figures

Moons Are Planets: Scientific Usefulness Versus Cultural Teleology in the Taxonomy of Planetary Science

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, William M. Grundy, Mark Sykes, S. Alan Stern, James F. Bell III, Charlene E. Detelich, Kirby D. Runyon, Michael Summers

Abstract: We argue that taxonomical concept development is vital for planetary science as in all branches of science, but its importance has been obscured by unique historical developments. The literature shows that the concept of planet developed by scientists during the Copernican Revolution was theory-laden and pragmatic for science. It included both primaries and satellites as planets due to their commo… ▽ More We argue that taxonomical concept development is vital for planetary science as in all branches of science, but its importance has been obscured by unique historical developments. The literature shows that the concept of planet developed by scientists during the Copernican Revolution was theory-laden and pragmatic for science. It included both primaries and satellites as planets due to their common intrinsic, geological characteristics. About two centuries later the non-scientific public had just adopted heliocentrism and was motivated to preserve elements of geocentrism including teleology and the assumptions of astrology. This motivated development of a folk concept of planet that contradicted the scientific view. The folk taxonomy was based on what an object orbits, making satellites out to be non-planets and ignoring most asteroids. Astronomers continued to keep primaries and moons classed together as planets and continued teaching that taxonomy until the 1920s. The astronomical community lost interest in planets ca. 1910 to 1955 and during that period complacently accepted the folk concept. Enough time has now elapsed so that modern astronomers forgot this history and rewrote it to claim that the folk taxonomy is the one that was created by the Copernican scientists. Starting ca. 1960 when spacecraft missions were developed to send back detailed new data, there was an explosion of publishing about planets including the satellites, leading to revival of the Copernican planet concept. We present evidence that taxonomical alignment with geological complexity is the most useful scientific taxonomy for planets. It is this complexity of both primary and secondary planets that is a key part of the chain of origins for life in the cosmos. △ Less

Submitted 22 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Comments: 68 pages, 16 figures. For supplemental data files, see https://www.philipmetzger.com/moons_are_planets/

On the rising and sinking of granular bubbles and droplets

Authors: Jens P. Metzger, Louis Girardin, Nicholas A. Conzelmann, Christoph R. Müller

Abstract: Recently, the existence of so-called granular bubbles and droplets has been demonstrated experimentally. Granular bubbles and droplets are clusters of particles that respectively rise and sink if submerged in an aerated and vibrated bed of another granular material of different size and/or density. However, currently there is no model that explains the coherent motion of these clusters and predict… ▽ More Recently, the existence of so-called granular bubbles and droplets has been demonstrated experimentally. Granular bubbles and droplets are clusters of particles that respectively rise and sink if submerged in an aerated and vibrated bed of another granular material of different size and/or density. However, currently there is no model that explains the coherent motion of these clusters and predicts the transition between a rising and sinking motion. Here, we propose an analytical model predicting accurately the neutral buoyancy limit of a granular bubble/droplet. This model allows the compilation of a regime map identifying five distinct regimes of granular bubble/droplet motion. △ Less

Submitted 15 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

MSC Class: 76T25

The sinking dynamics and splitting of a granular droplet

Authors: Jens P. Metzger, Christopher P. McLaren, Sebastian Pinzello, Nicholas A. Conzelmann, Christopher M. Boyce, Christoph R. Müller

Abstract: Recent experimental results have shown that vibro-fluidized, binary granular materials exhibit Rayleigh-Taylor-like instabilities that manifest themselves in rising plumes, rising bubbles and the sinking and splitting of granular droplets. This work explores the physics behind the splitting of a granular droplet that is composed of smaller and denser particles in a bed of larger and lighter partic… ▽ More Recent experimental results have shown that vibro-fluidized, binary granular materials exhibit Rayleigh-Taylor-like instabilities that manifest themselves in rising plumes, rising bubbles and the sinking and splitting of granular droplets. This work explores the physics behind the splitting of a granular droplet that is composed of smaller and denser particles in a bed of larger and lighter particles. During its sinking motion, a granular droplet undergoes a series of binary splits resembling the fragmentation of a liquid droplet falling in a miscible fluid. However, different physical mechanisms cause a granular droplet to split. By applying particle-image-velocimetry and numerical simulations, we demonstrate that the droplet of high-density particles causes the formation of an immobilized zone underneath the droplet. This zone obstructs the downwards motion of the droplet and causes the droplet to spread and ultimately to split. The resulting fragments sink at inclined trajectories around the immobilized zone until another splitting event is initiated. The occurrence of consecutive splitting events is explained by the re-formation of an immobilized zone underneath the droplet fragments. Our investigations identified three requirements for a granular droplet to split: 1) frictional inter-particle contacts, 2) a higher density of the particles composing the granular droplet compared to the bulk particles and 3) and a minimal granular droplet diameter. △ Less

Submitted 6 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Scaling of Erosion Rate in Subsonic Jet Experiments and Apollo Lunar Module Landings

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, John E. Lane, Christopher D. Immer, Jacob N. Gamsky, Whitney Hauslein, Xiaoyi Li, Robert C. Latta III, Carly M. Donahue

Abstract: Small scale jet-induced erosion experiments are useful for identifying the scaling of erosion with respect to the various physical parameters (gravity, grain size, gas velocity, gas density, grain density, etc.), and because they provide a data set for benchmarking numerical flow codes. We have performed experiments varying the physical parameters listed above (e.g., gravity was varied in reduced… ▽ More Small scale jet-induced erosion experiments are useful for identifying the scaling of erosion with respect to the various physical parameters (gravity, grain size, gas velocity, gas density, grain density, etc.), and because they provide a data set for benchmarking numerical flow codes. We have performed experiments varying the physical parameters listed above (e.g., gravity was varied in reduced gravity aircraft flights). In all these experiments, a subsonic jet of gas im**es vertically on a bed of sand or lunar soil simulant forming a localized scour hole beneath the jet. Videography captures the erosion and scour hole formation processes, and analysis of these videos post-test identifies the scaling of these processes. This has produced important new insights into the physics of erosion. Based on these insights, we have developed an erosion rate model that can be applied to generalized situations, such as the erosion of soil beneath a horizontal gas flow on a planetary surface. This is important to lunar exploration because the rate of erosion beneath the rocket exhaust plume of a landing spacecraft will determine the amount of sand-blasting damage that can be inflicted upon surrounding hardware. Although the rocket exhaust plume at the exit of the nozzle is supersonic, the boundary layer on the lunar surface where erosion occurs is subsonic. The model has been benchmarked through comparison with the Apollo landing videos, which show the blowing lunar soil, and computational fluid dynamics simulations of those landings. △ Less

Submitted 12 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 17 pages, 11 figures

Journal ref: 12th Biennial International Conference on Engineering, Construction, and Operations in Challenging Environments (Earth & Space 2010), March 14-17, 2010, Honolulu, Hawaii, United States

Apollo Video Photogrammetry Estimation of Plume Im**ement Effects (conference version)

Authors: Christopher Immer, John Lane, Philip Metzger, Sandra Clements

Abstract: The Constellation Project's planned return to the moon requires numerous landings at the same site. Since the top few centimeters are loosely packed regolith, plume im**ement from the Lander ejects the granular material at high velocities. Much work is needed to understand the physics of plume im**ement during landing in order to protect hardware surrounding the landing sites. While mostly qua… ▽ More The Constellation Project's planned return to the moon requires numerous landings at the same site. Since the top few centimeters are loosely packed regolith, plume im**ement from the Lander ejects the granular material at high velocities. Much work is needed to understand the physics of plume im**ement during landing in order to protect hardware surrounding the landing sites. While mostly qualitative in nature, the Apollo Lunar Module landing videos can provide a wealth of quantitative information using modern photogrammetry techniques. The authors have used the digitized videos to quantify plume im**ement effects of the landing exhaust on the lunar surface. The dust ejection angle from the plume is estimated at 1-3 degrees. The lofted particle density is estimated at 10^8 - 10^13 particles/m^3. Additionally, evidence for ejection of large 10-15 cm sized objects and a dependence of ejection angle on thrust are presented. Further work is ongoing to continue quantitative analysis of the landing videos. △ Less

Submitted 16 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 9 pages, 9 figures

Journal ref: In: 11th Biennial ASCE Aerospace Division International Conference on Engineering, Science, Construction, and Operations in Challenging Environments (Earth & Space 2008), March 3-5, 2008, Long Beach, California, United States

Lunar Dust Particles Blown By Lander Engine Exhaust in Rarefied and Compressible Flow

Authors: John E. Lane, Philip T. Metzger, Jeffrey W. Carlson

Abstract: Previously we presented a numerical model that predicts trajectories of lunar dust, soil, and gravel blown by the engine exhaust of a lunar lander. The model uses the gas density, velocity vector field, and temperature predicted by computational fluid dynamics (CFD) or Direct Simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) simulations to compute the forces and accelerations acting on the regolith particles, one par… ▽ More Previously we presented a numerical model that predicts trajectories of lunar dust, soil, and gravel blown by the engine exhaust of a lunar lander. The model uses the gas density, velocity vector field, and temperature predicted by computational fluid dynamics (CFD) or Direct Simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) simulations to compute the forces and accelerations acting on the regolith particles, one particle at a time (ignoring particle collisions until more advanced models are developed). Here we present significant improvements to the model, including the implementation of particle drag and lift formulas to account for the rarefaction and compressibility of the flow. It turns out that the drag force is reduced due to the rarefaction, but the lift is increased due to several effects such as particle rotation. A data matrix of particle sizes, engine thrusts (descent and ascent values for Altair), horizontal and vertical starting distances, and lander height above ground, have been tested using the latest version of the software. These results suggest that the previously reported 3 degree trajectory angle limit can be exceeded in several cases by as much as a factor of five. Particles that originate at a height of 1 cm above the surface from an outer crater rim can be propelled to angles of 5 degrees or more. Particles that start at 10 cm above the surface can be ejected with angles of up to 15 degrees. Mechanisms responsible for placing particles at starting heights above the surface may include the kinetics of horizontal collisions, as suggested by Discrete Element Method (DEM) simulations. We also present results showing the distance particles travel and their impact velocities. We then use the model to evaluate the effectiveness of berms or other methods to block the spray of soil at a lunar landing site. △ Less

Submitted 12 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 9 pages, 6 figures

Journal ref: 12th Biennial International Conference on Engineering, Construction, and Operations in Challenging Environments (Earth & Spac3 2010), March 14-17, 2010, Honolulu, Hawaii, United States

ISRU Implications for Lunar and Martian Plume Effects

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, Xiaoyi Li, Christopher D. Immer, John E. Lane

Abstract: Experiments, analyses, and simulations have shown that the engine exhaust plume of a Mars lander large enough for human spaceflight will create a deep crater in the martian soil, blowing ejecta to approximately 1 km distance, damaging the bottom of the lander with high-momentum rock impacts, and possibly tilting the lander as the excavated hole collapses to become a broad residual crater upon engi… ▽ More Experiments, analyses, and simulations have shown that the engine exhaust plume of a Mars lander large enough for human spaceflight will create a deep crater in the martian soil, blowing ejecta to approximately 1 km distance, damaging the bottom of the lander with high-momentum rock impacts, and possibly tilting the lander as the excavated hole collapses to become a broad residual crater upon engine cutoff. Because of this, we deem that we will not have adequate safety margins to land humans on Mars unless we robotically stabilize the soil to form in situ landing pads prior to the mission. It will take a significant amount of time working in a harsh off-planet environment to develop and certify the new technologies and procedures for in situ landing pad construction. The only place to reasonably accomplish this is on the Moon. △ Less

Submitted 12 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 19 pages, 17 figures

Journal ref: In: 47th AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting including The New Horizons Forum and Aerospace Exposition. 05 January 2009 - 08 January 2009. Orlando, Florida

Modification of Roberts' Theory for Rocket Exhaust Plumes Eroding Lunar Soil

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, John E. Lane, Christopher D. Immer

Abstract: Roberts' model of lunar soil erosion beneath a landing rocket has been updated in several ways to predict the effects of future lunar landings. The model predicts, among other things, the number of divots that would result on surrounding hardware due to the impact of high velocity particulates, the amount and depth of surface material removed, the volume of ejected soil, its velocity, and the dist… ▽ More Roberts' model of lunar soil erosion beneath a landing rocket has been updated in several ways to predict the effects of future lunar landings. The model predicts, among other things, the number of divots that would result on surrounding hardware due to the impact of high velocity particulates, the amount and depth of surface material removed, the volume of ejected soil, its velocity, and the distance the particles travel on the Moon. The results are compared against measured results from the Apollo program and predictions are made for mitigating the spray around a future lunar outpost. △ Less

Submitted 12 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 8 pages, 8 figures

Journal ref: In: 11th ASCE Aerospace Division International Conference (Earth and Space 2008), Long Beach, CA, USA, March 3-6, 2008

Cratering of Soil by Im**ing Jets of Gas, with Application to Landing Rockets on Planetary Surfaces

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, Bruce T. Vu, D. E. Taylor, M. J. Kromann, M. Fuchs, B. Yutko, Adam Dokos, Christopher D. Immer, John E. Lane, M. B. Dunkel, Carly M. Donahue, Robert C. Latta III

Abstract: Several physical mechanisms are involved in excavating granular materials beneath a vertical jet of gas. These occur, for example, beneath the exhaust plume of a rocket landing on the soil of the Moon or Mars. A series of experiments and simulations have been performed to provide a detailed view of the complex gas/soil interactions. Measurements have also been taken from the Apollo lunar landing v… ▽ More Several physical mechanisms are involved in excavating granular materials beneath a vertical jet of gas. These occur, for example, beneath the exhaust plume of a rocket landing on the soil of the Moon or Mars. A series of experiments and simulations have been performed to provide a detailed view of the complex gas/soil interactions. Measurements have also been taken from the Apollo lunar landing videos and from photographs of the resulting terrain, and these help to demonstrate how the interactions extrapolate into the lunar environment. It is important to understand these processes at a fundamental level to support the on-going design of higher-fidelity numerical simulations and larger-scale experiments. These are needed to enable future lunar exploration wherein multiple hardware assets will be placed on the Moon within short distances of one another. The high-velocity spray of soil from landing spacecraft must be accurately predicted and controlled lest it erosively damage the surrounding hardware. △ Less

Submitted 12 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 6 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: In: 18th Engineering Mechanics Division Conference (EMD2007), Blacksburg, Virginia, USA, June 3-6, 2007

Empirical Scaling Laws of Rocket Exhaust Cratering

Authors: Carly M. Donohue, Philip T. Metzger, Christopher D. Immer

Abstract: When launching or landing a spacecraft on the regolith of a terrestrial surface, special attention needs to be paid to the rocket exhaust cratering effects. If the effects are not controlled, the rocket cratering could damage the spacecraft or other surrounding hardware. The cratering effects of a rocket landing a planet's surface are not understood well, especially for the lunar case with the plu… ▽ More When launching or landing a spacecraft on the regolith of a terrestrial surface, special attention needs to be paid to the rocket exhaust cratering effects. If the effects are not controlled, the rocket cratering could damage the spacecraft or other surrounding hardware. The cratering effects of a rocket landing a planet's surface are not understood well, especially for the lunar case with the plume expanding in vacuum. As a result, the blast effects cannot be estimated sufficiently using analytical theories. It is necessary to develop physics-based simulation tools in order to calculate mission-essential parameters. In this work we test out the scaling laws of the physics in regard to growth rate of the crater depth. This will provide the physical insight necessary to begin the physics-based modeling. △ Less

Submitted 11 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 3 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: In: 56th Intemational Astronautical Congress, October 17-21, 2005, Fukuoka, Japan

Furthering Asteroid Resource Utilization in the Next Decade through Technology Leadership

Authors: Chris Lewicki, Amara Graps, Martin Elvis, Philip Metzger, Andrew Rivkin

Abstract: A significant opportunity for synergy between pure research and asteroid resource research exists. We provide an overview of the state of the art in asteroid resource utilization, and highlight where we can accelerate the closing of knowledge gaps, leading to the utilization of asteroid resources for growing economic productivity in space. A significant opportunity for synergy between pure research and asteroid resource research exists. We provide an overview of the state of the art in asteroid resource utilization, and highlight where we can accelerate the closing of knowledge gaps, leading to the utilization of asteroid resources for growing economic productivity in space. △ Less

Submitted 1 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: 7 page whitepaper submitted to Planetary Science Decadal Survey

Understanding and Mitigating Plume Effects During Powered Descents on the Moon and Mars

Authors: Ryan N. Watkins, Philip T. Metzger, Manish Mehta, Daoru Han, Parvathy Prem, Laurent Sibille, Adrienne Dove, Bradley Jolliff, Daniel P. Moriarty III, Donald C. Barker, Ed Patrick, Matthew Kuhns, Michael Laine

Abstract: This 2020 Decadal Survey White Paper reviews what is known about lunar and martian lander Plume Surface Interactions (PSI) during powered descent. This includes an overview of the phenomenology and a description of the induced hardware and environmental impacts. Then it provides an overview of mitigation techniques and a summary of the outstanding questions and strategic knowledge gaps. It finishe… ▽ More This 2020 Decadal Survey White Paper reviews what is known about lunar and martian lander Plume Surface Interactions (PSI) during powered descent. This includes an overview of the phenomenology and a description of the induced hardware and environmental impacts. Then it provides an overview of mitigation techniques and a summary of the outstanding questions and strategic knowledge gaps. It finishes with five recommendations: to include dedicated descent imagers on every surface mission so that PSI can be directly recorded and reviewed by ground teams; as far as possible, to make all data related to PSI effects publicly accessible; to develop methods and instruments for making key measurements of PSI; to assess and record key flight data; and to invest funding into studies of long-term infrastructure architectures and mitigation techniques. △ Less

Submitted 24 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Comments: 8 pages

Asteroid Resource Utilization: Ethical Concerns and Progress

Authors: Andrew S. Rivkin, Moses Milazzo, Aparna Venkatesan, Elizabeth Frank, Monica R. Vidaurri, Phil Metzger, Chris Lewicki

Abstract: As asteroid mining moves toward reality, the high bar to entering the business may limit participation and increase inequality, reducing or eliminating any benefit gained by marginalized people or develo** nations. Consideration of ethical issues is urgently needed, as well as participation in international, not merely multilateral, solutions. As asteroid mining moves toward reality, the high bar to entering the business may limit participation and increase inequality, reducing or eliminating any benefit gained by marginalized people or develo** nations. Consideration of ethical issues is urgently needed, as well as participation in international, not merely multilateral, solutions. △ Less

Submitted 6 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: Submitted to Planetary Science Decadal Survey. 19 co-signers, with names listed on cover page

Measuring the Fidelity of Asteroid Regolith and Cobble Simulants

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, Daniel T. Britt, Stephen Covey, Cody Schultz, Kevin M. Cannon, Kevin D. Grossman, James G. Mantovani, Robert P. Mueller

Abstract: NASA has developed a "Figure of Merit" method to grade the fidelity of lunar simulants for scientific and engineering purposes. Here we extend the method to grade asteroid simulants, both regolith and cobble variety, and we apply the method to the newly developed asteroid regolith and cobble simulant UCF/DSI-CI-2. The reference material that is used to evaluate this simulant for most asteroid prop… ▽ More NASA has developed a "Figure of Merit" method to grade the fidelity of lunar simulants for scientific and engineering purposes. Here we extend the method to grade asteroid simulants, both regolith and cobble variety, and we apply the method to the newly developed asteroid regolith and cobble simulant UCF/DSI-CI-2. The reference material that is used to evaluate this simulant for most asteroid properties is the Orgueil meteorite. Those properties are the mineralogical and elemental composition, grain density, bulk density of cobbles, magnetic susceptibility, mechanical strength of cobbles, and volatile release patterns. To evaluate the regolith simulant's particle sizing we use a reference model that was based upon the sample returned from Itokawa by Hayabusa, the boulder count on Hayabusa, and four cases of disrupted asteroids that indicate particle sizing of the subsurface material. Compared to these references, the simulant has high figures of merit, indicating it is a good choice for a wide range of scientific and engineering applications. We recommend this methodology to the wider asteroid community and in the near future will apply it to additional asteroid simulants currently under development. △ Less

Submitted 23 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Comments: 42 pages, 11 figures

Journal ref: Icarus 321, 15 March 2019, 632-646

Model for Asteroid Regolith to Guide Simulant Development

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, Daniel T. Britt

Abstract: When creating asteroid regolith simulant, it is necessary to have a model of asteroid regolith to guide and to evaluate the simulant. We created a model through evaluation and synthesis of the available data sets including (1) the returned sample from Itokawa by the Hayabusa spacecraft, (2) imagery from the Hayabusa and NEAR spacecraft visiting Itokawa and Eros, respectively, (3) thermal infrared… ▽ More When creating asteroid regolith simulant, it is necessary to have a model of asteroid regolith to guide and to evaluate the simulant. We created a model through evaluation and synthesis of the available data sets including (1) the returned sample from Itokawa by the Hayabusa spacecraft, (2) imagery from the Hayabusa and NEAR spacecraft visiting Itokawa and Eros, respectively, (3) thermal infrared observations from asteroids, (4) the texture of meteorite regolith breccias, and (5) observations and modeling of the ejecta clouds from disrupted asteroids. Comparison of the Hayabusa returned sample with other data sets suggest the surficial material in the smooth regions of asteroids is dissimilar to the bulk regolith, probably due to removal of fines by photoionization and solar wind interaction or by preferential migration of mid-sized particles into the smooth terrain. We found deep challenges interpreting and applying the thermal infrared data so we were unable to use those observations in the model. Texture of regolith breccias do not agree with other data sets, suggesting the source regolith on Vesta was coarser than typical asteroid regolith. The observations of disrupted asteroids present a coherent picture of asteroid bulk regolith in collisional equilibrium, unlike lunar regolith, HED textures, and the Itokawa returned sample. The model we adopt consists of power laws for the bulk regolith in unspecified terrain (differential power index -3.5, representing equilibrium), and the surficial regolith in smooth terrain (differential power index -2.5, representing disequilibrium). Available data do not provide adequate constraints on maximum and minimum particle sizes for these power laws, so the model treats them as user-selectable parameters for the simulant. △ Less

Submitted 25 December, 2019; v1 submitted 22 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Comments: 15 pages, 4 figures

The Reclassification of Asteroids from Planets to Non-Planets

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, Mark V. Sykes, Alan Stern, Kirby Runyon

Abstract: It is often claimed that asteroids' sharing of orbits is the reason they were re-classified from planets to non-planets. A critical review of the literature from the 19th Century to the present shows this is factually incorrect. The literature shows the term asteroid was broadly recognized as a subset of planet for 150 years. On-going discovery of asteroids resulted in a de facto stretching of the… ▽ More It is often claimed that asteroids' sharing of orbits is the reason they were re-classified from planets to non-planets. A critical review of the literature from the 19th Century to the present shows this is factually incorrect. The literature shows the term asteroid was broadly recognized as a subset of planet for 150 years. On-going discovery of asteroids resulted in a de facto stretching of the concept of planet to include the ever-smaller bodies. Scientists found utility in this taxonomic identification as it provided categories needed to argue for the leading hypothesis of planet formation, Laplace's nebular hypothesis. In the 1950s, developments in planet formation theory found it no longer useful to maintain taxonomic identification between asteroids and planets, Ceres being the primary exception. At approximately the same time, there was a flood of publications on the geophysical nature of asteroids showing them to be geophysically different than the large planets. This is when the terminology in asteroid publications calling them planets abruptly plunged from a high level of usage where it had hovered during the period 1801 - 1957 to a low level that held constant thereafter. This marks the point where the community effectively formed consensus that asteroids should be taxonomically distinct from planets. The evidence demonstrates this consensus formed on the basis of geophysical differences between asteroids and planets, not the sharing of orbits. We suggest attempts to build consensus around planetary taxonomy not rely on the non-scientific process of voting, but rather through precedent set in scientific literature and discourse, by which perspectives evolve with additional observations and information, just as they did in the case of asteroids. △ Less

Submitted 7 September, 2018; v1 submitted 10 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Comments: 31 pages, 5 figures

Experiments Indicate Regolith is Looser in the Lunar Polar Regions than at the Lunar Landing Sites

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, Seamus Anderson, Anthony Colaprete

Abstract: Since the Apollo program or earlier it has been widely believed that the lunar regolith was compacted through vibrations including nearby impact events, thermal stress release in the regolith, deep moon quakes, and shallow moon quakes. Experiments have shown that vibrations both compact and re-loosen regolith as a function of depth in the lunar soil column and amplitude of the vibrational accelera… ▽ More Since the Apollo program or earlier it has been widely believed that the lunar regolith was compacted through vibrations including nearby impact events, thermal stress release in the regolith, deep moon quakes, and shallow moon quakes. Experiments have shown that vibrations both compact and re-loosen regolith as a function of depth in the lunar soil column and amplitude of the vibrational acceleration. Experiments have also identified another process that is extremely effective at compacting regolith: the expansion and contraction of individual regolith grains due to thermal cycling in the upper part of the regolith where the diurnal thermal wave exists. Remote sensing data sets from the Moon suggest that the soil is less compacted in regions where there is less thermal cycling, including infrared emissions measured by the Diviner radiometer on the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter (LRO). Here, we performed additional experiments in thermal cycling simulated lunar regolith and confirm that it is an effective compaction mechanism and may explain the remote sensing data. This creates a consistent picture that the soil really is looser in the upper layers in polar regions, which may be a challenge for rovers that must drive in the looser soil. △ Less

Submitted 17 January, 2018; originally announced January 2018.

Comments: 9 pages. Earth & Space 2018 Conference (ASCE)

A phenomenological relationship between vertical air motion and disdrometer derived A-b coefficients

Authors: John Lane, Takis Kasparis, Silas Michaelides, Philip Metzger

Abstract: Using the well-known Z-R power law, Z = A R^b, A-b parameters derived from a single disdrometer are readily found and can provide useful information to study rainfall drop size distributions (DSDs). However, large variations in values are often seen when comparing A-b sets from various researchers. Values of b typically range from 1.25 to 1.55 for both stratiform and convective events. The values… ▽ More Using the well-known Z-R power law, Z = A R^b, A-b parameters derived from a single disdrometer are readily found and can provide useful information to study rainfall drop size distributions (DSDs). However, large variations in values are often seen when comparing A-b sets from various researchers. Values of b typically range from 1.25 to 1.55 for both stratiform and convective events. The values of A approximately fall into three groups: 150 to 200 for convective, 200 to 400 for stratiform, and 400 to 500 for convective. Computing the A-b parameters using the gamma DSD, coupled with a modified drop terminal velocity model, vD(D) = vT(D) - w, where D is drop diameter, vT(D) is still air drop terminal velocity, and w is an estimate of vertical velocity of the air well above the disdrometer, shows an interesting result. This model predicts three regions of A, corresponding to w < 0, w = 0, and w > 0. Additional models that incorporate a constant vertical air velocity are also investigated. A-b sets derived from a Joss Waldvogel (JW) disdrometer and DSD data acquired near Athalassa, Cyprus, using selected 24 hour data sets from 2011 to 2014, are compared to the above models. The data is separated into two main groups: stratiform events defined by rainfall rates that did not exceed 10 mm/h at any time during the 24-hour period, and convective events defined by rainfall rates not flagged as stratiform. The convective rainfall is further separated into two groups: A-b pairs that fall to the left of the stratiform pairs and pairs that fall to the right. This procedure is repeated with data from other researchers that corresponds to seasonal averages. In all cases, the three vertical grou**s of the A-b parameter plot seem to correlate to DSD simulations where various values of positive and negative vertical velocities are used. △ Less

Submitted 17 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Affordable, Rapid Bootstrap** of the Space Industry and Solar System Civilization

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, Anthony Muscatello, Robert P. Mueller, James Mantovani

Abstract: Advances in robotics and additive manufacturing have become game-changing for the prospects of space industry. It has become feasible to bootstrap a self-sustaining, self-expanding industry at reasonably low cost. Simple modeling was developed to identify the main parameters of successful bootstrap**. This indicates that bootstrap** can be achieved with as little as 12 metric tons (MT) landed… ▽ More Advances in robotics and additive manufacturing have become game-changing for the prospects of space industry. It has become feasible to bootstrap a self-sustaining, self-expanding industry at reasonably low cost. Simple modeling was developed to identify the main parameters of successful bootstrap**. This indicates that bootstrap** can be achieved with as little as 12 metric tons (MT) landed on the Moon during a period of about 20 years. The equipment will be teleoperated and then transitioned to full autonomy so the industry can spread to the asteroid belt and beyond. The strategy begins with a sub-replicating system and evolves it toward full self-sustainability (full closure) via an in situ technology spiral. The industry grows exponentially due to the free real estate, energy, and material resources of space. The mass of industrial assets at the end of bootstrap** will be 156 MT with 60 humanoid robots, or as high as 40,000 MT with as many as 100,000 humanoid robots if faster manufacturing is supported by launching a total of 41 MT to the Moon. Within another few decades with no further investment, it can have millions of times the industrial capacity of the United States. Modeling over wide parameter ranges indicates this is reasonable, but further analysis is needed. This industry promises to revolutionize the human condition. △ Less

Submitted 9 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: 24 pages, 14 figures

Journal ref: Journal of Aerospace Engineering 26.2, 18-29 (2013)

ASIME 2016 White Paper: In-Space Utilisation of Asteroids: "Answers to Questions from the Asteroid Miners"

Authors: Amara L. Graps, Philippe Blondel, Grant Bonin, Daniel Britt, Simone Centuori, Marco Delbo, Line Drube, Rene Duffard, Martin Elvis, Daniel Faber, Elizabeth Frank, JL Galache, Simon F. Green, Jan Thimo Grundmann, Henry Hsieh, Akos Kereszturi, Pauli Laine, Anny-Chantal Levasseur-Regourd, Philipp Maier, Philip Metzger, Patrick Michel, Migo Mueller, Thomas Mueller, Naomi Murdoch, Alex Parker , et al. (6 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: The aim of the Asteroid Science Intersections with In-Space Mine Engineering (ASIME) 2016 conference on September 21-22, 2016 in Luxembourg City was to provide an environment for the detailed discussion of the specific properties of asteroids, with the engineering needs of space missions that utilize asteroids. The ASIME 2016 Conference produced a layered record of discussions from the asteroid… ▽ More The aim of the Asteroid Science Intersections with In-Space Mine Engineering (ASIME) 2016 conference on September 21-22, 2016 in Luxembourg City was to provide an environment for the detailed discussion of the specific properties of asteroids, with the engineering needs of space missions that utilize asteroids. The ASIME 2016 Conference produced a layered record of discussions from the asteroid scientists and the asteroid miners to understand each other's key concerns and to address key scientific questions from the asteroid mining companies: Planetary Resources, Deep Space Industries and TransAstra. These Questions were the focus of the two day conference, were addressed by scientists inside and outside of the ASIME Conference and are the focus of this White Paper. The Questions from the asteroid mining companies have been sorted into the three asteroid science themes: 1) survey, 2) surface and 3) subsurface and 4) Other. The answers to those Questions have been provided by the scientists with their conference presentations or edited directly into an early open-access collaborative Google document (August 2016-October 2016), or inserted by A. Graps using additional reference materials. During the ASIME 2016 last two-hours, the scientists turned the Questions from the Asteroid Miners around by presenting their own key concerns: Questions from the Asteroid Scientists . These answers in this White Paper will point to the Science Knowledge Gaps (SKGs) for advancing the asteroid in-space resource utilisation domain. △ Less

Submitted 16 January, 2017; v1 submitted 2 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: 81 pages, 18 figures. White Paper from the Asteroid Science Intersections with In-Space Mine Engineering (ASIME) 2016 conference on September 21-22, 2016 in Luxembourg City

Space Development and Space Science Together, an Historic Opportunity

Authors: Philip Metzger

Abstract: The national space programs have an historic opportunity to help solve the global-scale economic and environmental problems of Earth while becoming more effective at science through the use of space resources. Space programs will be more cost-effective when they work to establish a supply chain in space, mining and manufacturing then replicating the assets of the supply chain so it grows to larger… ▽ More The national space programs have an historic opportunity to help solve the global-scale economic and environmental problems of Earth while becoming more effective at science through the use of space resources. Space programs will be more cost-effective when they work to establish a supply chain in space, mining and manufacturing then replicating the assets of the supply chain so it grows to larger capacity. This has become achievable because of advances in robotics and artificial intelligence. It is roughly estimated that develo** a lunar outpost that relies upon and also develops the supply chain will cost about 1/3 or less of the existing annual budgets of the national space programs. It will require a sustained commitment of several decades to complete, during which time science and exploration become increasingly effective. At the end, this space industry will capable of addressing global-scale challenges including limited resources, clean energy, economic development, and preservation of the environment. Other potential solutions, including nuclear fusion and terrestrial renewable energy sources, do not address the root problem of our limited globe and there are real questions whether they will be inadequate or too late. While industry in space likewise cannot provide perfect assurance, it is uniquely able to solve the root problem, and it gives us an important chance that we should grasp. What makes this such an historic opportunity is that the space-based solution is obtainable as a side-benefit of doing space science and exploration within their existing budgets. Thinking pragmatically, it may take some time for policymakers to agree that setting up a complete supply chain is an achievable goal, so this paper describes a strategy of incremental progress. △ Less

Submitted 7 November, 2016; v1 submitted 2 September, 2016; originally announced September 2016.

Comments: 38 pages. Accepted for publication in Space Policy journal

Journal ref: Space Policy 37.2, 77-91 (2016)

Estimation of Apollo lunar dust transport using optical extinction measurements

Authors: John E. Lane, Philip T. Metzger

Abstract: A technique to estimate mass erosion rate of surface soil during landing of the Apollo Lunar Module (LM) and total mass ejected due to the rocket plume interaction is proposed and tested. The erosion rate is proportional to the product of the second moment of the lofted particle size distribution N(D), and third moment of the normalized soil size distribution S(D), divided by the integral of S(D)D… ▽ More A technique to estimate mass erosion rate of surface soil during landing of the Apollo Lunar Module (LM) and total mass ejected due to the rocket plume interaction is proposed and tested. The erosion rate is proportional to the product of the second moment of the lofted particle size distribution N(D), and third moment of the normalized soil size distribution S(D), divided by the integral of S(D)D^2/v(D), where D is particle diameter and v(D) is the vertical component of particle velocity. The second moment of N(D) is estimated by optical extinction analysis of the Apollo cockpit video. Because of the similarity between mass erosion rate of soil as measured by optical extinction and rainfall rate as measured by radar reflectivity, traditional NWS radar/rainfall correlation methodology can be applied to the lunar soil case where various S(D) models are assumed corresponding to specific lunar sites. △ Less

Submitted 28 February, 2015; originally announced March 2015.

Comments: Acta Geophysica 2015

In Situ Disdrometer Calibration Using Multiple DSD Moments

Authors: John Lane, Takis Kasparis, Philip Metzger, W. Linwood Jones

Abstract: In situ calibration is a proposed strategy for continuous as well as initial calibration of an impact disdrometer. In previous work, a collocated tip** bucket had been utilized to provide a rainfall rate based ~11/3 moment reference to an impact disdrometer's signal processing system for implementation of adaptive calibration. Using rainfall rate only, transformation of impulse amplitude to a dr… ▽ More In situ calibration is a proposed strategy for continuous as well as initial calibration of an impact disdrometer. In previous work, a collocated tip** bucket had been utilized to provide a rainfall rate based ~11/3 moment reference to an impact disdrometer's signal processing system for implementation of adaptive calibration. Using rainfall rate only, transformation of impulse amplitude to a drop volume based on a simple power law was used to define an error surface in the model's parameter space. By incorporating optical extinction second moment measurements with rainfall rate data, an improved in situ disdrometer calibration algorithm results due to utilization of multiple (two or more) independent moments of the drop size distribution in the error function definition. The resulting improvement in calibration performance can be quantified by detailed examination of the parameter space error surface using simulation as well as real data. △ Less

Submitted 9 June, 2014; v1 submitted 4 June, 2014; originally announced June 2014.

Comments: 21 pages, 16 figures, Acta Geophysica 2014

Photogrammetry and ballistic analysis of a high-flying projectile in the STS-124 space shuttle launch

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, John E. Lane, Robert A. Carilli, Jason M. Long, Kathy L. Shawn

Abstract: A method combining photogrammetry with ballistic analysis is demonstrated to identify flying debris in a rocket launch environment. Debris traveling near the STS-124 Space Shuttle was captured on cameras viewing the launch pad within the first few seconds after launch. One particular piece of debris caught the attention of investigators studying the release of flame trench fire bricks because it… ▽ More A method combining photogrammetry with ballistic analysis is demonstrated to identify flying debris in a rocket launch environment. Debris traveling near the STS-124 Space Shuttle was captured on cameras viewing the launch pad within the first few seconds after launch. One particular piece of debris caught the attention of investigators studying the release of flame trench fire bricks because its high trajectory could indicate a flight risk to the Space Shuttle. Digitized images from two pad perimeter high-speed 16-mm film cameras were processed using photogrammetry software based on a multi-parameter optimization technique. Reference points in the image were found from 3D CAD models of the launch pad and from surveyed points on the pad. The three-dimensional reference points were matched to the equivalent two-dimensional camera projections by optimizing the camera model parameters using a gradient search optimization technique. Using this method of solving the triangulation problem, the xyz position of the object's path relative to the reference point coordinate system was found for every set of synchronized images. This trajectory was then compared to a predicted trajectory while performing regression analysis on the ballistic coefficient and other parameters. This identified, with a high degree of confidence, the object's material density and thus its probable origin within the launch pad environment. Future extensions of this methodology may make it possible to diagnose the underlying causes of debris-releasing events in near-real time, thus improving flight safety. △ Less

Submitted 22 October, 2009; originally announced October 2009.

Comments: 26 pages, 11 figures, 3 tables

Journal ref: Acta Astronautica 67(1), 217-229 (2010)

Hyperstaticity and loops in frictional granular packings

Authors: Antoinette Tordesillas, Edward Lam, Philip T. Metzger

Abstract: The hyperstatic nature of granular packings of perfectly rigid disks is analyzed algebraically and through numerical simulation. The elementary loops of grains emerge as a fundamental element in addressing hyperstaticity. Loops consisting of an odd number of grains behave differently than those with an even number. For odd loops, the latent stresses are exterior and are characterized by the sum… ▽ More The hyperstatic nature of granular packings of perfectly rigid disks is analyzed algebraically and through numerical simulation. The elementary loops of grains emerge as a fundamental element in addressing hyperstaticity. Loops consisting of an odd number of grains behave differently than those with an even number. For odd loops, the latent stresses are exterior and are characterized by the sum of frictional forces around each loop. For even loops, the latent stresses are interior and are characterized by the alternating sum of frictional forces around each loop. The statistics of these two types of loop sums are found to be Gibbsian with a "temperature" that is linear with the friction coefficient mu when mu<1. △ Less

Submitted 9 June, 2009; originally announced June 2009.

Comments: 4 pages; Powders and Grains 2009, Golden, Colorado, USA

Electric Potential Due to a System of Conducting Spheres

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, John E. Lane

Abstract: Equations describing the complete series of image charges for a system of conducting spheres are presented. The method of image charges, originally described by J. C. Maxwell in 1873, has been and continues to be a useful method for solving many three dimensional electrostatic problems. Here we demonstrate that as expected when the series is truncated to any finite order N, the electric field re… ▽ More Equations describing the complete series of image charges for a system of conducting spheres are presented. The method of image charges, originally described by J. C. Maxwell in 1873, has been and continues to be a useful method for solving many three dimensional electrostatic problems. Here we demonstrate that as expected when the series is truncated to any finite order N, the electric field resulting from the truncated series becomes qualitatively more similar to the correct field as N increases. A method of charge normalization is developed which provides significant improvement for truncated low order solutions. The formulation of the normalization technique and its solution via a matrix inversion has similarities to the method of moments, which is a numerical solution of Poisson's equation, using an integral equation for the unknown charge density with a known boundary potential. The last section of this paper presents a gradient search method to optimize a set of L point charges for M spheres. This method may use the image charge series to initialize the gradient search. We demonstrate quantitatively how the metric can be optimized by adjusting the locations and amounts of charge for the set of points, and that an optimized set of charges generally performs better than truncated normalized image charges, at the expense of gradient search iteration time. △ Less

Submitted 8 June, 2009; originally announced June 2009.

Comments: 25 pages, 9 figures. To appear in The Open Applied Physics Journal, http://www.bentham.org/open/toapj/

Journal ref: The Open Applied Physics Journal 2, 32-48 (2009)

Spatial and Temporal Extrapolation of Disdrometer Size Distributions Based on a Lagrangian Trajectory Model of Falling Rain

Authors: John E. Lane, Takis Kasparis, Philip T. Metzger, W. Linwood Jones

Abstract: Methodologies to improve disdrometer processing, loosely based on mathematical techniques common to the field of particle flow and fluid mechanics, are examined and tested. The inclusion of advection and vertical wind field estimates appears to produce significantly improved results in a Lagrangian hydrometeor trajectory model, in spite of very strict assumptions of noninteracting hydrometeors,… ▽ More Methodologies to improve disdrometer processing, loosely based on mathematical techniques common to the field of particle flow and fluid mechanics, are examined and tested. The inclusion of advection and vertical wind field estimates appears to produce significantly improved results in a Lagrangian hydrometeor trajectory model, in spite of very strict assumptions of noninteracting hydrometeors, constant vertical air velocity, and time independent advection during a radar scan time interval. Wind field data can be extracted from each radar elevation scan by plotting and analyzing reflectivity contours over the disdrometer site and by collecting the radar radial velocity data to obtain estimates of advection. Specific regions of disdrometer spectra (drop size versus time) often exhibit strong gravitational sorting signatures, from which estimates of vertical velocity can be extracted. These independent wind field estimates can be used as initial conditions to the Lagrangian trajectory simulation of falling hydrometeors. △ Less

Submitted 8 June, 2009; originally announced June 2009.

Comments: 25 pages, 15 figures, 4 tables. Submitted to The Open Atmospheric Science Journal, http://www.bentham.org/open/toascj/

Journal ref: The Open Atmospheric Science Journal 3, 172-186 (2009)

Jet-induced cratering of a granular surface with application to lunar spaceports

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, Christopher D. Immer, Carly M. Donahue, Bruce M. Vu, Robert C. Latta III, Matthew Deyo-Svendsen

Abstract: The erosion of lunar soil by rocket exhaust plumes is investigated experimentally. This has identified the diffusion-driven flow in the bulk of the sand as an important but previously unrecognized mechanism for erosion dynamics. It has also shown that slow regime cratering is governed by the recirculation of sand in the widening geometry of the crater. Scaling relationships and erosion mechanism… ▽ More The erosion of lunar soil by rocket exhaust plumes is investigated experimentally. This has identified the diffusion-driven flow in the bulk of the sand as an important but previously unrecognized mechanism for erosion dynamics. It has also shown that slow regime cratering is governed by the recirculation of sand in the widening geometry of the crater. Scaling relationships and erosion mechanisms have been characterized in detail for the slow regime. The diffusion-driven flow occurs in both slow and fast regime cratering. Because diffusion-driven flow had been omitted from the lunar erosion theory and from the pressure cratering theory of the Apollo and Viking era, those theories cannot be entirely correct. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2009; originally announced June 2009.

Comments: 13 pages, link to published version: http://cedb.asce.org/cgi/WWWdisplay.cgi?0900004

Journal ref: J. Aerospace Engineering Vol. 21, No. 1, January 2009, pp. 24-32,

Craters Formed in Granular Beds by Im**ing Jets of Gas

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, Robert C. Latta III, Jason M. Schuler, Christopher D. Immer

Abstract: When a jet of gas im**es vertically on a granular bed and forms a crater, the grains may be moved by several different mechanisms: viscous erosion, diffused gas eruption, bearing capacity failure, and/or diffusion-driven shearing. The relative importance of these mechanisms depends upon the flow regime of the gas, the mechanical state of the granular material, and other physical parameters. He… ▽ More When a jet of gas im**es vertically on a granular bed and forms a crater, the grains may be moved by several different mechanisms: viscous erosion, diffused gas eruption, bearing capacity failure, and/or diffusion-driven shearing. The relative importance of these mechanisms depends upon the flow regime of the gas, the mechanical state of the granular material, and other physical parameters. Here we report research in two specific regimes: viscous erosion forming scour holes as a function of particle size and gravity; and bearing capacity failure forming deep transient craters as a function of soil compaction. △ Less

Submitted 29 May, 2009; originally announced May 2009.

Comments: 4 pages; Powders and Grains 2009, Golden, Colorado, USA

Journal ref: Powders and Grains 2009, Proc. 6th Int Conf Micromech Granul Media 1145(1), 767-770

H theorem for contact forces in granular materials

Authors: Philip T. Metzger

Abstract: A maximum entropy theorem is developed and tested for granular contact forces. Although it is idealized, describing two dimensional packings of round, rigid, frictionless, cohesionless disks with coordination number Z=4, it appears to describe a central part of the physics present in the more general cases. The theorem does not make the strong claims of Edwards' hypothesis, nor does it rely upon… ▽ More A maximum entropy theorem is developed and tested for granular contact forces. Although it is idealized, describing two dimensional packings of round, rigid, frictionless, cohesionless disks with coordination number Z=4, it appears to describe a central part of the physics present in the more general cases. The theorem does not make the strong claims of Edwards' hypothesis, nor does it rely upon Edwards' hypothesis at any point. Instead, it begins solely from the physical assumption that closed loops of grains are unable to impose strong force correlations around the loop. This statement is shown to be a generalization of Boltzmann's Assumption of Molecular Chaos (his \textit{stosszahlansatz}), allowing for the extra symmetries of granular stress propagation compared to the more limited symmetries of momentum propagation in a thermodynamic system. The theorem that follows from this is similar to Boltzmann's $H$ theorem and is presented as an alternative to Edwards' hypothesis for explaining some granular phenomena. It identifies a very interesting feature of granular packings: if the generalized \textit{stosszahlansatz} is correct, then the bulk of homogeneous granular packings must satisfy a maximum entropy condition simply by virtue of being stable, without any exploration of phase space required. This leads to an independent derivation of the contact force statistics, and these predictions have been compared to numerical simulation data in the isotropic case. The good agreement implies that the generalized \textit{stosszahlansatz} is indeed accurate at least for the isotropic state of the idealized case studied here, and that it is the reductionist explanation for contact force statistics in this case. △ Less

Submitted 11 December, 2007; v1 submitted 12 June, 2006; originally announced June 2006.

Comments: 15 pages, 8 figures, to appear in Phys. Rev. E

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 77, 011307 (2008)

Elegance of disordered granular packings: a validation of Edwards' hypothesis

Authors: Philip T. Metzger, Carly M. Donahue

Abstract: We have found a way to analyze Edwards' density of states for static granular packings in the special case of round, rigid, frictionless grains assuming constant coordination number. It obtains the most entropic density of single grain states, which predicts several observables including the distribution of contact forces. We compare these results against empirical data obtained in dynamic simul… ▽ More We have found a way to analyze Edwards' density of states for static granular packings in the special case of round, rigid, frictionless grains assuming constant coordination number. It obtains the most entropic density of single grain states, which predicts several observables including the distribution of contact forces. We compare these results against empirical data obtained in dynamic simulations of granular packings. The agreement is quite good, hel** validate the use of statistical mechanics methods in granular physics. The differences between theory and empirics are mainly related to the coordination number, and when the empirical data are sorted by that number we obtain several insights that suggest an underlying elegance in the density of states. △ Less

Submitted 14 April, 2005; v1 submitted 16 March, 2005; originally announced March 2005.

Comments: 4 pages, 5 figures, Changes in the references

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 148001 (2005)