Cost-benefit analysis of ecosystem modelling to support fisheries management
Authors:
Matthew H. Holden,
Eva E. Plagányi,
Elizabeth A. Fulton,
Alexander B. Campbell,
Rachel Janes,
Robyn A. Lovett,
Montana Wickens,
Matthew P. Adams,
Larissa Lubiana Botelho,
Catherine M. Dichmont,
Philip Erm,
Kate J Helmstedt,
Ryan F. Heneghan,
Manuela Mendiolar,
Anthony J. Richardson,
Jacob G. D. Rogers,
Kate Saunders,
Liam Timms
Abstract:
Mathematical and statistical models underlie many of the world's most important fisheries management decisions. Since the 19th century, difficulty calibrating and fitting such models has been used to justify the selection of simple, stationary, single-species models to aid tactical fisheries management decisions. Whereas these justifications are reasonable, it is imperative that we quantify the va…
▽ More
Mathematical and statistical models underlie many of the world's most important fisheries management decisions. Since the 19th century, difficulty calibrating and fitting such models has been used to justify the selection of simple, stationary, single-species models to aid tactical fisheries management decisions. Whereas these justifications are reasonable, it is imperative that we quantify the value of different levels of model complexity for supporting fisheries management, especially given a changing climate, where old methodologies may no longer perform as well as in the past. Here we argue that cost-benefit analysis is an ideal lens to assess the value of model complexity in fisheries management. While some studies have reported the benefits of model complexity in fisheries, modeling costs are rarely considered. In the absence of cost data in the literature, we report, as a starting point, relative costs of single-species stock assessment and marine ecosystem models from two Australian organizations. We found that costs varied by two orders of magnitude, and that ecosystem model costs increased with model complexity. Using these costs, we walk through a hypothetical example of cost-benefit analysis. The demonstration is intended to catalyze the reporting of modeling costs and benefits.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
Capturing episodic impacts of environmental signals
Authors:
Manuela Mendiolar,
Jerzy A. Filar,
Wen-Hsi Yang,
Susannah Leahy,
Anthony Courtney
Abstract:
Environmental scientists frequently rely on time series of explanatory variables to explain their impact on an important response variable. However, sometimes, researchers are less interested in raw observations of an explanatory variable than in derived indices induced by episodes embedded in its time series. Often these episodes are intermittent, occur within a specific limited memory, persist f…
▽ More
Environmental scientists frequently rely on time series of explanatory variables to explain their impact on an important response variable. However, sometimes, researchers are less interested in raw observations of an explanatory variable than in derived indices induced by episodes embedded in its time series. Often these episodes are intermittent, occur within a specific limited memory, persist for varying durations, at varying levels of intensity, and overlap important periods with respect to the response variable. We develop a generic, parametrised, family of weighted indices extracted from an environmental signal called IMPIT indices. To facilitate their construction and calibration, we developed a user friendly app in Shiny R referred to as IMPIT-a. We construct examples of IMPIT indices extracted from the Southern Oscillation Index and sea surface temperature signals. We illustrate their applications to two fished species in Queensland waters (i.e., snapper and saucer scallop) and wheat yield in New South Wales.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
