-
Deforming ice with drops
Authors:
Duco van Buuren,
Pallav Kant,
Jochem G. Meijer,
Christian Diddens,
Detlef Lohse
Abstract:
A uniform solidification front undergoes non-trivial deformations when encountering an insoluble dispersed particle in a melt. For solid particles, the overall deformation characteristics are primarily dictated by heat transfer between the particle and the surroundings, remaining unaffected by the rate of approach of the solidification front. In this Letter, we show that, conversely, when interact…
▽ More
A uniform solidification front undergoes non-trivial deformations when encountering an insoluble dispersed particle in a melt. For solid particles, the overall deformation characteristics are primarily dictated by heat transfer between the particle and the surroundings, remaining unaffected by the rate of approach of the solidification front. In this Letter, we show that, conversely, when interacting with a droplet or a bubble, the deformation behaviour exhibits entirely different and unexpected behaviour. It arises from an interfacial dynamics which is specific to particles with free interfaces, namely thermal Marangoni forces. Our study employs a combination of experiments, theory, and numerical simulations to investigate the interaction between the droplet and the freezing front and unveils its surprising behaviour. In particular, we quantitatively understand the dependence of the front deformation $Δ$ on the front propagation velocity, which, for large front velocities, can even revert from attraction ($Δ< 0$) to repulsion ($Δ> 0$).
△ Less
Submitted 29 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Universal equation describes the shape of air bubbles trapped in ice
Authors:
Virgile Thiévenaz,
Jochem G. Meijer,
Detlef Lohse,
Alban Sauret
Abstract:
Water usually contains dissolved gases, and because freezing is a purifying process these gases must be expelled for ice to form. Bubbles appear at the freezing front and are trapped in ice, making pores. These pores come in a range of sizes from microns to millimeters and their shapes are peculiar; never spherical but elongated, and usually fore-aft asymmetric. We show that these remarkable shape…
▽ More
Water usually contains dissolved gases, and because freezing is a purifying process these gases must be expelled for ice to form. Bubbles appear at the freezing front and are trapped in ice, making pores. These pores come in a range of sizes from microns to millimeters and their shapes are peculiar; never spherical but elongated, and usually fore-aft asymmetric. We show that these remarkable shapes result of a delicate balance between freezing, capillarity, and mass diffusion. A non-linear ordinary differential equation suffices to describe the bubbles, with only two non-dimensional parameters representing the supersaturation and the freezing rate. Our experiments provide us with a large variety of pictures of bubble shapes. We show that all of them have their rounded tip well described by an asymptotic regime of the differential equation, and that most of them can have their full shape quantitatively matched by a full solution. This enables the measurement of the freezing conditions of ice samples, and the design of freeze-cast porous materials. Furthermore, the equation exhibits a bifurcation that explains why some bubbles grow indefinitely and make long cylindrical ``ice worms'', well known to glaciologists.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2024; v1 submitted 20 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Enhanced bubble growth near an advancing solidification front
Authors:
Jochem G. Meijer,
Duarte Rocha,
Annemarie M. Linnenbank,
Christian Diddens,
Detlef Lohse
Abstract:
Frozen water might appear opaque since impurities or gas bubbles can get trapped in the ice during the freezing process. The latter nucleate and then grow near the advancing solidification front, due to the formation of a gas supersaturation region in its vicinity. A delicate interplay between the rate of mass transfer and the rate of freezing dictates the final shapes and sizes of the entrapped g…
▽ More
Frozen water might appear opaque since impurities or gas bubbles can get trapped in the ice during the freezing process. The latter nucleate and then grow near the advancing solidification front, due to the formation of a gas supersaturation region in its vicinity. A delicate interplay between the rate of mass transfer and the rate of freezing dictates the final shapes and sizes of the entrapped gas bubbles. In this work, we experimentally and numerically investigate the initial growth of such gas bubbles that nucleate and grow near the advancing ice front. We show that the initial growth of these bubbles is governed by diffusion and is enhanced due to a combination of the presence of the background gas concentration gradient and the motion of the approaching front. Additionally, we recast the problem into that of mass transfer to a moving spherical object in a homogeneous concentration field, finding good agreement between our experimental data and the existing scaling relations for that latter problem. Lastly, we address how fluid flow around the bubble might further affect this growth and qualitatively explore this through numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Freezing-induced topological transition of double-emulsion
Authors:
Jochem G. Meijer,
Pallav Kant,
Detlef Lohse
Abstract:
Solidification of complex liquids is pertinent to numerous natural and industrial processes. Here, we examine the freezing of a W/O/W double-emulsion, i.e., water-in-oil compound droplets dispersed in water. We show that the solidification of such hierarchical emulsions can trigger a topological transition; for example, in our case, we observe the transition from the stable W/O/W state to a (froze…
▽ More
Solidification of complex liquids is pertinent to numerous natural and industrial processes. Here, we examine the freezing of a W/O/W double-emulsion, i.e., water-in-oil compound droplets dispersed in water. We show that the solidification of such hierarchical emulsions can trigger a topological transition; for example, in our case, we observe the transition from the stable W/O/W state to a (frozen) O/W single-emulsion configuration. Strikingly, this transition is characterised by sudden expulsion of the inner water drop from the encapsulating oil droplet. We propose that this topological transition is triggered by the freezing of the encapsulating oil droplet from the outside in, putting tension on the inner water drop thus, destabilizing the W/O/W configuration. Using high-speed imaging we characterize the destabilization process. Interestingly, we find that below a critical size of the inner drop, $R_{\mathrm{in,crit}} \approx 19 \, μ\mathrm{m}$, the topological transition does not occur any more and the double-emulsion remains stable, in line with our interpretation.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2024; v1 submitted 7 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Frozen Cheerios effect: Particle-particle interaction induced by an advancing solidification front
Authors:
Jochem G. Meijer,
Vincent Bertin,
Detlef Lohse
Abstract:
Particles at liquid interfaces have the tendency to cluster due to capillary forces competing to gravitational buoyancy (i.e., normal to the distorted free surface). This is known as the Cheerios effect. Here we experimentally and theoretically study the interaction between two submerged particles near an advancing water-ice interface during the freezing process. Particles that are thermally more…
▽ More
Particles at liquid interfaces have the tendency to cluster due to capillary forces competing to gravitational buoyancy (i.e., normal to the distorted free surface). This is known as the Cheerios effect. Here we experimentally and theoretically study the interaction between two submerged particles near an advancing water-ice interface during the freezing process. Particles that are thermally more conductive than water are observed to attract each other and form clusters once frozen. We call this feature the frozen Cheerios effect, where interactions are driven by alterations to the direction of the experienced repelling force (i.e., normal to the distorted isotherm). On the other hand, particles less conductive than water separate, highlighting the importance of thermal conduction during freezing. Based on existing models for single particle trap** in ice, we develop an understanding of multiple particle interaction. We find that the overall efficacy of the particle-particle interaction critically depends on the solidification front velocity. Our theory explains why the thermal conductivity mismatch between the particles and water dictates the attractive/repulsive nature of the particle-particle interaction.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2024; v1 submitted 15 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
On the rising and sinking motion of bouncing oil drops in strongly stratified liquids
Authors:
Jochem G. Meijer,
Yanshen Li,
Christian Diddens,
Detlef Lohse
Abstract:
When an immiscible oil drop is immersed in a stably stratified ethanol-water mixture, the Marangoni flow on the surface of the drop can experience an oscillatory instability, so that the drop undergoes a transition from levitating to bouncing. The onset of the instability and its mechanisms have been studied previously, yet the bouncing motion of the drop itself, which is a completely different pr…
▽ More
When an immiscible oil drop is immersed in a stably stratified ethanol-water mixture, the Marangoni flow on the surface of the drop can experience an oscillatory instability, so that the drop undergoes a transition from levitating to bouncing. The onset of the instability and its mechanisms have been studied previously, yet the bouncing motion of the drop itself, which is a completely different problem, has not yet been investigated. Here we study how the bouncing characteristics (jum** height, rising and sinking time) depend on the control parameters (drop radius, stratification strength, drop viscosity). We first record experimentally the bouncing trajectories of drops of different viscosities in different stratifications. Then a simplified dynamical analysis is performed to get the scaling relations of the jum** height and the rising and sinking times. The rising and sinking time scales are found to depend on the drag coefficient of the drop $C_D^S$ in the stratified liquid, which is determined empirically for the current parameter space. For low viscosity (5 cSt) oil drops the results on the drag coefficient match the ones from the literature. For high viscosity (100 cSt) oil drops the parameter space had not been explored and the drag coefficients are not readily available. Numerical simulations are therefore performed to provide external verification for the drag coefficients, which well match with the experimental results.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Thin-Film-Mediated Deformation of Droplet during Cryopreservation
Authors:
Jochem G. Meijer,
Pallav Kant,
Duco Van Buuren,
Detlef Lohse
Abstract:
Freezing of dispersions is omnipresent in science and technology. While the passing of a freezing front over a solid particle is reasonably understood, this is not so for soft particles. Here, using an oil-in-water emulsion as a model system, we show that when engulfed into a growing ice front, a soft particle severely deforms. This deformation strongly depends on the engulfment velocity $V$, even…
▽ More
Freezing of dispersions is omnipresent in science and technology. While the passing of a freezing front over a solid particle is reasonably understood, this is not so for soft particles. Here, using an oil-in-water emulsion as a model system, we show that when engulfed into a growing ice front, a soft particle severely deforms. This deformation strongly depends on the engulfment velocity $V$, even forming pointy-tip shapes for low values of $V$. We find such singular deformations are mediated by interfacial flows in $\textit{nanometric}$ thin liquid films separating the non-solidifying dispersed droplets and the solidifying bulk. We model the fluid flow in these intervening thin films using a lubrication approximation and then relate it to the deformation sustained by the dispersed droplet.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Marangoni instabilities of drops of different viscosities in stratified liquids
Authors:
Yanshen Li,
Jochem G. Meijer,
Detlef Lohse
Abstract:
For an immiscible oil drop immersed in a stably stratified ethanol-water mixture, a downwards solutal Marangoni flow is generated on the surface of the drop, owing to the concentration gradient, and the resulting propulsion competes against the downwards gravitational acceleration of the heavy drop. In prior work of Li et al. (Phys. Rev. Lett., vol. 126, issue 12, 2021, 124502), we found that for…
▽ More
For an immiscible oil drop immersed in a stably stratified ethanol-water mixture, a downwards solutal Marangoni flow is generated on the surface of the drop, owing to the concentration gradient, and the resulting propulsion competes against the downwards gravitational acceleration of the heavy drop. In prior work of Li et al. (Phys. Rev. Lett., vol. 126, issue 12, 2021, 124502), we found that for drops of low viscosity, an oscillatory instability of the Marangoni flow is triggered once the Marangoni advection is too strong for diffusion to restore the stratified concentration field around the drop. Here we experimentally explore the parameter space of the concentration gradient and drop radius for large oil viscosities and find a different and new mechanism for triggering the oscillatory instability in which diffusion is no longer the limiting factor. For such drops of higher viscosities, the instability is triggered when the gravitational effect is too strong so that the viscous stress cannot maintain a stable Marangoni flow. This leads to a critical drop radius above which the equilibrium is always unstable. Subsequently, a unifying scaling theory that includes both the mechanisms for low and for high viscosities of the oil drops is developed. The transition between the two mechanisms is found to be controlled by two length scales: The drop radius $R$ and the boundary layer thickness $δ$ of the Marangoni flow around the drop. The instability is dominated by diffusion for $δ<R$ and by viscosity for $R<δ$. The experimental results for various drops of different viscosities can well be described with this unifying scaling theory. Our theoretical description thus provides a unifying view of physicochemical hydrodynamic problems in which the Marangoni stress is competing with a stable stratification.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
