Showing 1–42 of 42 results for author: McKeon, B J

Lagrangian Gradient Regression for the Detection of Coherent Structures from Sparse Trajectory Data

Authors: Tanner D. Harms, Steven L. Brunton, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: Lagrangian Coherent Structures (LCS) are flow features which are defined to objectively characterize complex fluid behavior over a finite time regardless of the orientation of the observer. Fluidic applications of LCS include geophysical, aerodynamic, biological, and bio-inspired flows -- among others -- and can be generalized to broader classes of dynamical systems. One of the prevailing paradigm… ▽ More Lagrangian Coherent Structures (LCS) are flow features which are defined to objectively characterize complex fluid behavior over a finite time regardless of the orientation of the observer. Fluidic applications of LCS include geophysical, aerodynamic, biological, and bio-inspired flows -- among others -- and can be generalized to broader classes of dynamical systems. One of the prevailing paradigms for identifying LCS involves examining continuum-mechanical properties of the underlying flow. Such methods, including finite-time Lyapunov exponent (FTLE) and Lagrangian-averaged vorticity deviation (LAVD) analyses, provide consistent and physically-meaningful results but require expensive computations on a dense array of numerically integrated trajectories. Faster, more robust, sparse methods, on the other hand, are typically non-deterministic and require a-priori intuition of flow field behavior for interpretation. If LCS are to be used in the decision-making protocol of future autonomous technologies, a bridge between dense and sparse approaches must be made. This work begins to address this goal through the development of Lagrangian gradient regression (LGR), which enables the computation of deformation gradients and velocity gradients from sparse data via regression. Using LGR, velocity gradients, flow map Jacobians (thereby FTLE), and rotational Lagrangian metrics like the LAVD are accurately computed from sparse trajectory data which is orders of magnitude less dense than traditional approaches require. Moreover, there is no need to compute velocity or numerically differentiate at any point when using LGR. Therefore, it is a purely Lagrangian technique. △ Less

Submitted 17 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 46 pages, 13 figures

Spatio-temporal characterization of non-linear forcing in turbulence

Authors: Yuting Huang, Simon S. Toedtli, Gregory P. Chini, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: The quadratic convection term in the incompressible Navier-Stokes equations is considered as a non-linear forcing to the linear operator, and it is studied in the Fourier domain through the analysis of interactions between triadically compatible wavenumber-frequency triplets. Interaction coefficients are proposed to quantify the contribution to the forcing by each pair of triplets and are computed… ▽ More The quadratic convection term in the incompressible Navier-Stokes equations is considered as a non-linear forcing to the linear operator, and it is studied in the Fourier domain through the analysis of interactions between triadically compatible wavenumber-frequency triplets. Interaction coefficients are proposed to quantify the contribution to the forcing by each pair of triplets and are computed using data from direct numerical simulations of a turbulent channel at $Re_τ \approx 550$. The coefficients show the importance of interactions involving streamwise large scales. The regions of non-linear interactions permitted under the quasi-linear (QL) and generalized quasi-linear (GQL) assumptions are shown to be significant contributors to the forcing and increasing the number of GQL-large scales is shown to monotonically increase the total forcing captured, providing a possible reason for the success of QL and GQL simulations. The tools presented are expected to be useful for improving modeling of the nonlinearity, especially in QL, GQL, and resolvent analyses, and understanding the amplitude modulation mechanism relating large-scale fluctuations to the modulation of near-wall structures. △ Less

Submitted 28 April, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

The transformative potential of machine learning for experiments in fluid mechanics

Authors: Ricardo Vinuesa, Steven L. Brunton, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: The field of machine learning has rapidly advanced the state of the art in many fields of science and engineering, including experimental fluid dynamics, which is one of the original big-data disciplines. This perspective will highlight several aspects of experimental fluid mechanics that stand to benefit from progress advances in machine learning, including: 1) augmenting the fidelity and quality… ▽ More The field of machine learning has rapidly advanced the state of the art in many fields of science and engineering, including experimental fluid dynamics, which is one of the original big-data disciplines. This perspective will highlight several aspects of experimental fluid mechanics that stand to benefit from progress advances in machine learning, including: 1) augmenting the fidelity and quality of measurement techniques, 2) improving experimental design and surrogate digital-twin models and 3) enabling real-time estimation and control. In each case, we discuss recent success stories and ongoing challenges, along with caveats and limitations, and outline the potential for new avenues of ML-augmented and ML-enabled experimental fluid mechanics. △ Less

Submitted 29 March, 2023; v1 submitted 28 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

From resolvent to Gramians: extracting forcing and response modes for control

Authors: Benjamin Herrmann, Peter J. Baddoo, Scott T. M. Dawson, Richard Semaan, Steven L. Brunton, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: During the last decade, forcing and response modes produced by resolvent analysis have demonstrated great potential to guide sensor and actuator placement and design in flow control applications. However, resolvent modes are frequency-dependent, which, although responsible for their success in identifying scale interactions in turbulence, complicates their use for control purposes. In this work, w… ▽ More During the last decade, forcing and response modes produced by resolvent analysis have demonstrated great potential to guide sensor and actuator placement and design in flow control applications. However, resolvent modes are frequency-dependent, which, although responsible for their success in identifying scale interactions in turbulence, complicates their use for control purposes. In this work, we seek orthogonal bases of forcing and response modes that are the most responsive and receptive, respectively, across all frequencies. We show that these frequency-independent bases of \emph{representative} resolvent modes are given by the eigenvectors of the observability and controllability Gramians of the system considering full state inputs and outputs. We present several numerical examples where we leverage these bases by building orthogonal or interpolatory projectors onto the dominant forcing and response subspaces. Gramian-based forcing modes are used to identify dynamically relevant disturbances, to place point sensors to measure disturbances, and to design actuators for feedforward control in the subcritical linearized Ginzburg--Landau equation. Gramian-based response modes are used to identify coherent structures and for point sensor placement aiming at state reconstruction in the turbulent flow in a minimal channel at $\mathrm{Re}_τ=185$. The approach does not require data snapshots and relies only on knowledge of the steady or mean flow. △ Less

Submitted 31 January, 2023; v1 submitted 30 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Towards real-time reconstruction of velocity fluctuations in turbulent channel flow

Authors: Rahul Arun, H. Jane Bae, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: We develop a framework for efficient streaming reconstructions of turbulent velocity fluctuations from limited sensor measurements with the goal of enabling real-time applications. The reconstruction process is simplified by computing linear estimators using flow statistics from an initial training period and evaluating their performance during a subsequent testing period with data obtained from d… ▽ More We develop a framework for efficient streaming reconstructions of turbulent velocity fluctuations from limited sensor measurements with the goal of enabling real-time applications. The reconstruction process is simplified by computing linear estimators using flow statistics from an initial training period and evaluating their performance during a subsequent testing period with data obtained from direct numerical simulation. We address cases where (i) no, (ii) limited, and (iii) full-field training data are available using estimators based on (i) resolvent modes, (ii) resolvent-based estimation, and (iii) spectral proper orthogonal decomposition modes. During training, we introduce blockwise inversion to accurately and efficiently compute the resolvent operator in an interpretable manner. During testing, we enable efficient streaming reconstructions by using a temporal sliding discrete Fourier transform to recursively update Fourier coefficients using incoming measurements. We use this framework to reconstruct with minimal time delay the turbulent velocity fluctuations in a minimal channel at ${\rm Re}_τ\approx 186$ from sparse planar measurements. We evaluate reconstruction accuracy in the context of the extent of data required and thereby identify potential use cases for each estimator. The reconstructions capture large portions of the dynamics from relatively few measurement planes when the linear estimators are computed with sufficient fidelity. We also evaluate the efficiency of our reconstructions and show that the present framework has the potential to help enable real-time reconstructions of turbulent velocity fluctuations in an analogous experimental setting. △ Less

Submitted 27 June, 2023; v1 submitted 17 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Comments: 36 pages, 22 figures, accepted by Physical Review Fluids

Journal ref: Physical Review Fluids 8, 064612 (2023)

Subsonic and supersonic mechanisms in compressible turbulent boundary layers: a perspective from resolvent analysis

Authors: Anagha Madhusudanan, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: In this study we isolate the mechanisms that are separately responsible for amplifying the two distinct sets of modes that appear in a linearized Navier-Stokes based model for compressible turbulent boundary layer flows. These two sets of modes are: (i) the subsonic modes that have equivalents in the incompressible flow regime, and (ii) the supersonic modes that do not have such equivalents in the… ▽ More In this study we isolate the mechanisms that are separately responsible for amplifying the two distinct sets of modes that appear in a linearized Navier-Stokes based model for compressible turbulent boundary layer flows. These two sets of modes are: (i) the subsonic modes that have equivalents in the incompressible flow regime, and (ii) the supersonic modes that do not have such equivalents in the incompressible flow regime. The resolvent analysis framework is used to analyze the linear model, where the non-linear terms of the equations are taken to be a forcing to the linear terms. The most sensitive forcing and correspondingly the most amplified response are then analyzed. We find that, when considering the subsonic response modes, only the solenoidal component of the forcing to the momentum equations can amplify these modes. This is consistent with observations in the literature regarding incompressible flows. Next, when considering the supersonic response modes, we find that these are pressure fluctuations that radiate into the freestream. Within the freestream, these modes closely follow the trends of the inviscid Mach waves. There are three different forcing mechanisms that are found to amplify these modes. First, the forcing to the continuity and energy equations contribute. Second, the dilatational component of the forcing to the momentum equations has a significant role. Finally, although less significant for the resolvent amplification, there is also a contribution from the solenoidal component of the forcing. Using these identified forcing mechanisms, a decomposition of the forcing to the compressible resolvent operator, i.e. of the non-linear terms of the linearized Navier-Stokes equations, is proposed, that can approximately isolate the subsonic and the supersonic modes in turbulent boundary layers over adiabatic as well as cooled walls, and for a range of Mach numbers. △ Less

Submitted 28 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: 32 pages, 16 figures

Physics-informed dynamic mode decomposition (piDMD)

Authors: Peter J. Baddoo, Benjamin Herrmann, Beverley J. McKeon, J. Nathan Kutz, Steven L. Brunton

Abstract: In this work, we demonstrate how physical principles -- such as symmetries, invariances, and conservation laws -- can be integrated into the dynamic mode decomposition (DMD). DMD is a widely-used data analysis technique that extracts low-rank modal structures and dynamics from high-dimensional measurements. However, DMD frequently produces models that are sensitive to noise, fail to generalize out… ▽ More In this work, we demonstrate how physical principles -- such as symmetries, invariances, and conservation laws -- can be integrated into the dynamic mode decomposition (DMD). DMD is a widely-used data analysis technique that extracts low-rank modal structures and dynamics from high-dimensional measurements. However, DMD frequently produces models that are sensitive to noise, fail to generalize outside the training data, and violate basic physical laws. Our physics-informed DMD (piDMD) optimization, which may be formulated as a Procrustes problem, restricts the family of admissible models to a matrix manifold that respects the physical structure of the system. We focus on five fundamental physical principles -- conservation, self-adjointness, localization, causality, and shift-invariance -- and derive several closed-form solutions and efficient algorithms for the corresponding piDMD optimizations. With fewer degrees of freedom, piDMD models are less prone to overfitting, require less training data, and are often less computationally expensive to build than standard DMD models. We demonstrate piDMD on a range of challenging problems in the physical sciences, including energy-preserving fluid flow, travelling-wave systems, the Schrödinger equation, solute advection-diffusion, a system with causal dynamics, and three-dimensional transitional channel flow. In each case, piDMD significantly outperforms standard DMD in metrics such as spectral identification, state prediction, and estimation of optimal forcings and responses. △ Less

Submitted 8 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: 36 pages, 9 figures

Kernel Learning for Robust Dynamic Mode Decomposition: Linear and Nonlinear Disambiguation Optimization (LANDO)

Authors: Peter J. Baddoo, Benjamin Herrmann, Beverley J. McKeon, Steven L. Brunton

Abstract: Research in modern data-driven dynamical systems is typically focused on the three key challenges of high dimensionality, unknown dynamics, and nonlinearity. The dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) has emerged as a cornerstone for modeling high-dimensional systems from data. However, the quality of the linear DMD model is known to be fragile with respect to strong nonlinearity, which contaminates the… ▽ More Research in modern data-driven dynamical systems is typically focused on the three key challenges of high dimensionality, unknown dynamics, and nonlinearity. The dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) has emerged as a cornerstone for modeling high-dimensional systems from data. However, the quality of the linear DMD model is known to be fragile with respect to strong nonlinearity, which contaminates the model estimate. In contrast, sparse identification of nonlinear dynamics (SINDy) learns fully nonlinear models, disambiguating the linear and nonlinear effects, but is restricted to low-dimensional systems. In this work, we present a kernel method that learns interpretable data-driven models for high-dimensional, nonlinear systems. Our method performs kernel regression on a sparse dictionary of samples that appreciably contribute to the underlying dynamics. We show that this kernel method efficiently handles high-dimensional data and is flexible enough to incorporate partial knowledge of system physics. It is possible to accurately recover the linear model contribution with this approach, disambiguating the effects of the implicitly defined nonlinear terms, resulting in a DMD-like model that is robust to strongly nonlinear dynamics. We demonstrate our approach on data from a wide range of nonlinear ordinary and partial differential equations that arise in the physical sciences. This framework can be used for many practical engineering tasks such as model order reduction, diagnostics, prediction, control, and discovery of governing laws. △ Less

Submitted 2 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 44 pages, 12 figures

Tollmien-Schlichting route to elastoinertial turbulence in channel flow

Authors: Ashwin Shekar, Ryan M. McMullen, Beverley J. McKeon, Michael D. Graham

Abstract: Direct simulations of two-dimensional channel flow of a viscoelastic fluid have revealed the existence of a family of Tollmien-Schlichting (TS) attractors that is nonlinearly self-sustained by viscoelasticity [Shekar et al., J.Fluid Mech. 893, A3 (2020)]. Here, we describe the evolution of this branch in parameter space and its connections to the Newtonian TS attractor and to elastoinertial turbul… ▽ More Direct simulations of two-dimensional channel flow of a viscoelastic fluid have revealed the existence of a family of Tollmien-Schlichting (TS) attractors that is nonlinearly self-sustained by viscoelasticity [Shekar et al., J.Fluid Mech. 893, A3 (2020)]. Here, we describe the evolution of this branch in parameter space and its connections to the Newtonian TS attractor and to elastoinertial turbulence (EIT). At Reynolds number $Re=3000$, there is a solution branch with TS-wave structure but which is not connected to the Newtonian solution branch. At fixed Weissenberg number, $Wi$ and increasing Reynolds number from 3000-10000, this attractor goes from displaying a striation of weak polymer stretch localized at the critical layer to an extended sheet of very large polymer stretch. We show that this transition is directly tied to the strength of the TS critical layer fluctuations and can be attributed to a coil-stretch transition when the local Weissenberg number at the hyperbolic stagnation point of the Kelvin cat's eye structure of the TS wave exceeds $\frac{1}{2}$. At $Re=10000$, unlike $3000$, the Newtonian TS attractor evolves continuously into the EIT state as $Wi$ is increased from zero to about $13$. We describe how the structure of the flow and stress fields changes, highlighting in particular a "sheet-shedding" process by which the individual sheets associated with the critical layer structure break up to form the layered multisheet structure characteristic of EIT. △ Less

Submitted 14 September, 2021; v1 submitted 20 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: Accepted to Physical Review Fluids

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Fluids 6, 093301 (2021)

Closing the loop: nonlinear Taylor vortex flow through the lens of resolvent analysis

Authors: Benedikt Barthel, Xiaojue Zhu, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: We present an optimization-based method to efficiently calculate accurate nonlinear models of Taylor vortex flow. We use the resolvent formulation of McKeon & Sharma (2010) to model these Taylor vortex solutions by treating the nonlinearity not as an inherent part of the governing equations but rather as a triadic constraint which must be satisfied by the model solution. We exploit the low rank li… ▽ More We present an optimization-based method to efficiently calculate accurate nonlinear models of Taylor vortex flow. We use the resolvent formulation of McKeon & Sharma (2010) to model these Taylor vortex solutions by treating the nonlinearity not as an inherent part of the governing equations but rather as a triadic constraint which must be satisfied by the model solution. We exploit the low rank linear dynamics of the system to calculate an efficient basis for our solution, the coefficients of which are then calculated through an optimization problem where the cost function to be minimized is the triadic consistency of the solution with itself as well as with the input mean flow. Our approach constitutes, what is to the best of our knowledge, the first fully nonlinear and self-sustaining, resolvent-based model described in the literature. We compare our results to direct numerical simulation of Taylor Couette flow at up to five times the critical Reynolds number, and show that our model accurately captures the structure of the flow. Additionally, we find that as the Reynolds number increases the flow undergoes a fundamental transition from a classical weakly nonlinear regime, where the forcing cascade is strictly down scale, to a fully nonlinear regime characterized by the emergence of an inverse (up scale) forcing cascade. Triadic contributions from the inverse and traditional cascade destructively interfere implying that the accurate modeling of a certain Fourier mode requires knowledge of its immediate harmonic and sub-harmonic. We show analytically that this finding is a direct consequence of the structure of the quadratic nonlinearity of the governing equations formulated in Fourier space. Finally, we show that using our model solution as an initial condition to a higher Reynolds number DNS significantly reduces the time to convergence. △ Less

Submitted 17 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Resolvent analysis of stratification effects on wall-bounded shear flows

Authors: M. A. Ahmed, H. J. Bae, A. F. Thompson, B. J. McKeon

Abstract: The interaction between shear driven turbulence and stratification is a key process in a wide array of geophysical flows with spatio-temporal scales that span many orders of magnitude. A quick numerical model prediction based on external parameters of stratified boundary layers could greatly benefit the understanding of the interaction between velocity and scalar flux at varying scales. For these… ▽ More The interaction between shear driven turbulence and stratification is a key process in a wide array of geophysical flows with spatio-temporal scales that span many orders of magnitude. A quick numerical model prediction based on external parameters of stratified boundary layers could greatly benefit the understanding of the interaction between velocity and scalar flux at varying scales. For these reasons, here, we use the resolvent framework to investigate the effects of an active scalar on incompressible wall-bounded turbulence. We obtain the state of the flow system by applying the linear resolvent operator to the nonlinear terms in the governing Navier-Stokes equations with the Boussinesq approximation. This extends the formulation to include the scalar advection equation with the scalar component acting in the wall-normal direction in the momentum equations. We use the mean velocity profiles from a DNS of a stably-stratified turbulent channel flow at varying friction Richardson number. The results obtained from the resolvent analysis are compared to the premultiplied energy spectra, auto-correlation coefficient, and the energy budget terms obtained from the DNS. It is shown that despite using only a very limited range of representative scales, the resolvent model is able to reproduce the balance of energy budget terms as well as provide meaningful insight of coherent structures occurring in the flow. Computation of the leading resolvent models, despite considering a limited range of scales, reproduces the balance of energy budget terms, provides meaningful predictions of coherent structures in the flow, and is more cost-effective than performing full-scale simulations. This quick model can provide further understanding of stratified flows with only information about the mean profile and prior knowledge of energetic scales of motion in the neutrally-buoyant boundary layers. △ Less

Submitted 27 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Fluids 6, 084804 (2021)

Data-driven resolvent analysis

Authors: Benjamin Herrmann, Peter J. Baddoo, Richard Semaan, Steven L. Brunton, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: Resolvent analysis identifies the most responsive forcings and most receptive states of a dynamical system, in an input--output sense, based on its governing equations. Interest in the method has continued to grow during the past decade due to its potential to reveal structures in turbulent flows, to guide sensor/actuator placement, and for flow control applications. However, resolvent analysis re… ▽ More Resolvent analysis identifies the most responsive forcings and most receptive states of a dynamical system, in an input--output sense, based on its governing equations. Interest in the method has continued to grow during the past decade due to its potential to reveal structures in turbulent flows, to guide sensor/actuator placement, and for flow control applications. However, resolvent analysis requires access to high-fidelity numerical solvers to produce the linearized dynamics operator. In this work, we develop a purely data-driven algorithm to perform resolvent analysis to obtain the leading forcing and response modes, without recourse to the governing equations, but instead based on snapshots of the transient evolution of linearly stable flows. The formulation of our method follows from two established facts: $1)$ dynamic mode decomposition can approximate eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the underlying operator governing the evolution of a system from measurement data, and $2)$ a projection of the resolvent operator onto an invariant subspace can be built from this learned eigendecomposition. We demonstrate the method on numerical data of the linearized complex Ginzburg--Landau equation and of three-dimensional transitional channel flow, and discuss data requirements. The ability to perform resolvent analysis in a completely equation-free and adjoint-free manner will play a significant role in lowering the barrier of entry to resolvent research and applications. △ Less

Submitted 5 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

From unsteady to quasi-steady dynamics in the streamwise-oscillating cylinder wake

Authors: Maysam Shamai, Scott T. M. Dawson, Igor Mezić, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: The flow around a cylinder oscillating in the streamwise direction with a frequency, $f_f$, much lower than the shedding frequency, $f_s$, has been relatively less studied than the case when these frequencies have the same order of magnitude, or the transverse oscillation configuration. In this study, Particle Image Velocimetry and Koopman Mode Decomposition are used to investigate the streamwise-… ▽ More The flow around a cylinder oscillating in the streamwise direction with a frequency, $f_f$, much lower than the shedding frequency, $f_s$, has been relatively less studied than the case when these frequencies have the same order of magnitude, or the transverse oscillation configuration. In this study, Particle Image Velocimetry and Koopman Mode Decomposition are used to investigate the streamwise-oscillating cylinder wake for forcing frequencies $f_f/f_s \sim 0.04-0.2$ and mean Reynolds number, $Re_0 = 900$. The amplitude of oscillation is such that the instantaneous Reynolds number remains above the critical value for vortex shedding at all times. Characterization of the wake reveals a range of phenomena associated with the interaction of the two frequencies, including modulation of both the amplitude and frequency of the wake structure by the forcing. Koopman analysis reveals a frequency spreading of Koopman modes. A scaling parameter and associated transformation are developed to relate the unsteady, or forced, dynamics of a system to that of a quasi-steady, or unforced, system. For the streamwise-oscillating cylinder, it is shown that this transformation leads to a Koopman Mode Decomposition similar to that of the unforced system. △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

Interaction of forced Orr-Sommerfeld and Squire modes in a low-order representation of turbulent channel flow

Authors: Ryan M. McMullen, Kevin Rosenberg, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: A resolvent-based reduced-order representation is used to capture time-averaged second-order statistics in turbulent channel flow. The recently-proposed decomposition of the resolvent operator into two distinct families related to the Orr-Sommerfeld and Squire operators [K. Rosenberg and B. J. McKeon, Efficient representation of exact coherent states of the Navier-Stokes equations using resolvent… ▽ More A resolvent-based reduced-order representation is used to capture time-averaged second-order statistics in turbulent channel flow. The recently-proposed decomposition of the resolvent operator into two distinct families related to the Orr-Sommerfeld and Squire operators [K. Rosenberg and B. J. McKeon, Efficient representation of exact coherent states of the Navier-Stokes equations using resolvent analysis, Fluid Dynamics Research 51, 011401 (2019)] results in dramatic improvement in the ability to match all components of the energy spectra and the $uv$ cospectrum. The success of the new representation relies on the ability of the Squire modes to compete with the vorticity generated by Orr-Sommerfeld modes, which is demonstrated by decomposing the statistics into contributions from each family. It is then shown that this competition can be used to infer a phase relationship between the two sets of modes. Additionally, the relative Reynolds number scalings for the two families of resolvent weights are derived for the universal classes of resolvent modes presented by Moarref et al. [R. Moarref, A. S. Sharma, J. A. Tropp, and B. J. McKeon, Model-based scaling of the streamwise energy density in high-Reynolds-number turbulent channels, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 734, 275 (2013)]. These developments can be viewed as a starting point for further modeling efforts to quantify nonlinear interactions in wall-bounded turbulence. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Fluids 5, 084607 (2020)

Nonlinear mechanism of the self-sustaining process in the buffer and logarithmic layer of wall-bounded flows

Authors: Hyunji Jane Bae, Adrian Lozano-Duran, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: The nonlinear mechanism in the self-sustaining process (SSP) of wall-bounded turbulence is investigated. Resolvent analysis is used to identify the principal forcing mode which produces the maximum amplification of the velocities in numerical simulations of the minimal channel for the buffer layer and a modified logarithmic (log) layer. The wavenumbers targeted in this study are those of the funda… ▽ More The nonlinear mechanism in the self-sustaining process (SSP) of wall-bounded turbulence is investigated. Resolvent analysis is used to identify the principal forcing mode which produces the maximum amplification of the velocities in numerical simulations of the minimal channel for the buffer layer and a modified logarithmic (log) layer. The wavenumbers targeted in this study are those of the fundamental mode that is infinitely long in the streamwise direction and once periodic in the spanwise direction. The identified mode is then projected out from the nonlinear term of the Navier-Stokes equations at each time step from the simulation of the corresponding minimal channel. The results show that the removal of the principal forcing mode of the fundamental wavenumber can inhibit turbulence in both the buffer and log layer, with the effect being greater in the buffer layer. Removing other modes instead of the principal mode of the fundamental wavenumber only marginally affects the flow. Closer inspection of the dyadic interactions in the nonlinear term shows that contributions toward the principal forcing mode come from a limited set of wavenumber interactions. Using conditional averaging, the flow structures that are responsible for generating the nonlinear interaction to self-sustain turbulence are identified as spanwise rolls interacting with oblique streaks. This method, based on the equations of motion, validates the similarities in the SSP of the buffer and log layer, and characterises the underlying quadratic interactions in the SSP of the minimal channel. △ Less

Submitted 13 November, 2020; v1 submitted 16 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Journal ref: Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 914, A3 (2021)

Self-sustained elastoinertial Tollmien-Schlichting waves

Authors: Ashwin Shekar, Ryan M. McMullen, Beverley J. McKeon, Michael D. Graham

Abstract: Direct simulations of two-dimensional plane channel flow of a viscoelastic fluid at Reynolds number Re = 3000 reveal the existence of a family of attractors whose structure closely resembles the linear Tollmien-Schlichting (TS) mode, and in particular exhibits strongly localized stress fluctuations at the critical layer position of the TS mode. At the parameter values chosen, this solution branch… ▽ More Direct simulations of two-dimensional plane channel flow of a viscoelastic fluid at Reynolds number Re = 3000 reveal the existence of a family of attractors whose structure closely resembles the linear Tollmien-Schlichting (TS) mode, and in particular exhibits strongly localized stress fluctuations at the critical layer position of the TS mode. At the parameter values chosen, this solution branch is not connected to the nonlinear TS solution branch found for Newtonian flow, and thus represents a solution family that is nonlinearly self-sustained by viscoelasticity. The ratio between stress and velocity fluctuations is in quantitative agreement for the attractor and the linear TS mode, and increases strongly with Weissenberg number, Wi. For the latter, there is a transition in the scaling of this ratio as Wi increases, and the Wi at which the nonlinear solution family comes into existence is just above this transition. Finally, evidence indicates that this branch is connected through an unstable solution branch to two-dimensional elastoinertial turbulence (EIT). These results suggest that, in the parameter range considered here, the bypass transition leading to EIT is mediated by nonlinear amplification and self-sustenance of perturbations that excite the Tollmien-Schlichting mode. △ Less

Submitted 5 May, 2020; v1 submitted 24 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Comments: 15 pages, 7 figures; Accepted in the Journal of Fluid Mechanics

Resolvent-based study of compressibility effects on supersonic turbulent boundary layers

Authors: H. Jane Bae, Scott T. M. Dawson, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: The resolvent formulation of McKeon & Sharma (2010) is applied to supersonic turbulent boundary layers to study the validity of Morkovin's hypothesis, which postulates that high-speed turbulence structures in zero pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers remain largely the same as its incompressible counterpart. Supersonic zero-pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers with adiabatic wall bou… ▽ More The resolvent formulation of McKeon & Sharma (2010) is applied to supersonic turbulent boundary layers to study the validity of Morkovin's hypothesis, which postulates that high-speed turbulence structures in zero pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers remain largely the same as its incompressible counterpart. Supersonic zero-pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers with adiabatic wall boundary conditions at Mach numbers ranging from 2 to 4 are considered. Resolvent analysis highlights two distinct regions of the supersonic turbulent boundary layer in the wave parameter space: the relatively supersonic region and the relatively subsonic region. In the relatively supersonic region, where the flow is supersonic relative to the freestream, resolvent modes display structures consistent with Mach wave radiation that are absent in the incompressible regime. In the relatively subsonic region, we show that the low-rank approximation of the resolvent operator is an effective approximation of the full system and that the response modes predicted by the model exhibit universal and geometrically self-similar behaviour via a transformation given by the semi-local scaling. Moreover, with the semi-local scaling, we show that the resolvent modes follow the same scaling law as their incompressible counterparts in this region, which has implications for modelling and the prediction of turbulent high-speed wall-bounded flows. We also show that the thermodynamic variables exhibit similar mode shapes to the streamwise velocity modes, supporting the strong Reynolds analogy. Finally, we demonstrate that the principal resolvent modes can be used to capture the energy distribution between momentum and thermodynamic fluctuations. △ Less

Submitted 21 October, 2019; v1 submitted 29 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Journal ref: Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 883, A29 (2020)

A tale of two airfoils: resolvent-based modelling of an oscillator vs. an amplifier from an experimental mean

Authors: Sean Symon, Denis Sipp, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: The flows around a NACA 0018 airfoil at a Reynolds number of 10250 and angles of attack of alpha = 0 (A0) and alpha = 10 (A10) are modelled using resolvent analysis and limited experimental measurements obtained from particle image velocimetry. The experimental mean velocity profiles are data-assimilated so that they are solutions of the incompressible Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes equations for… ▽ More The flows around a NACA 0018 airfoil at a Reynolds number of 10250 and angles of attack of alpha = 0 (A0) and alpha = 10 (A10) are modelled using resolvent analysis and limited experimental measurements obtained from particle image velocimetry. The experimental mean velocity profiles are data-assimilated so that they are solutions of the incompressible Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes equations forced by Reynolds stress terms which are derived from experimental data. Spectral proper orthogonal decompositions (SPOD) of the velocity fluctuations and nonlinear forcing find low-rank behaviour at the shedding frequency and its higher harmonics for the A0 case. In the A10 case, low-rank behaviour is observed for the velocity fluctuations in two bands of frequencies. Resolvent analysis of the data-assimilated means identifies low-rank behaviour only in the vicinity of the shedding frequency for A0 and none of its harmonics. The resolvent operator for the A10 case, on the other hand, identifies two linear mechanisms whose frequencies are a close match with those identified by SPOD. It is also shown that the second linear mechanism, corresponding to the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability in the shear layer, cannot be identified just by considering the time-averaged experimental measurements as a mean flow due to the fact that experimental data are missing near the leading edge. The A0 case is classified as an oscillator where the flow is organised around an intrinsic instability while the A10 case behaves like an amplifier whose forcing is unstructured. For both cases, resolvent modes resemble those from SPOD when the operator is low-rank. To model the higher harmonics where this is not the case, we add parasitic resolvent modes, as opposed to classical resolvent modes which are the most amplified, by approximating the nonlinear forcing from limited triadic interactions of known resolvent modes. △ Less

Submitted 22 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Comments: 32 pages, 23 figures

The role of parasitic modes in nonlinear closure via the resolvent feedback loop

Authors: Kevin Rosenberg, Sean Symon, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: We use the feedback loop of McKeon \& Sharma (2010), where the nonlinear term in the Navier-Stokes equations is treated as an intrinsic forcing of the linear resolvent operator, to educe the structure of fluctuations in the range of scales (wavenumbers) where linear mechanisms are not active. In this region, the absence of dominant linear mechanisms is reflected in the lack of low-rank characteris… ▽ More We use the feedback loop of McKeon \& Sharma (2010), where the nonlinear term in the Navier-Stokes equations is treated as an intrinsic forcing of the linear resolvent operator, to educe the structure of fluctuations in the range of scales (wavenumbers) where linear mechanisms are not active. In this region, the absence of dominant linear mechanisms is reflected in the lack of low-rank characteristics of the resolvent and in the disagreement between the structure of resolvent modes and actual flow features. To demonstrate the procedure, we choose low Reynolds number cylinder flow and the Couette equilibrium solution EQ1, which are representative of very low-rank flows dominated by one linear mechanism. The former is evolving in time, allowing us to compare resolvent modes with Dynamic Mode Decomposition (DMD) modes at the first and second harmonics of the shedding frequency. There is a match between the modes at the first harmonic but not at the second harmonic where there is no separation of the resolvent operator's singular values. We compute the self-interaction of the resolvent mode at the shedding frequency and illustrate its similarity to the nonlinear forcing of the second harmonic. When it is run through the resolvent operator, the `forced' resolvent mode shows better agreement with the DMD mode. A similar phenomenon is observed for the fundamental streamwise wavenumber of the EQ1 solution and its second harmonic. The importance of parasitic modes, labeled as such since they are driven by the amplified frequencies, is their contribution to the nonlinear forcing of the main amplification mechanisms as shown for the shedding mode, which has subtle discrepancies with its DMD counterpart. △ Less

Submitted 6 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

On the shape of resolvent modes in wall-bounded turbulence

Authors: Scott T. M. Dawson, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: The resolvent formulation of the Navier$\text{--}$Stokes equations gives a means for the characterization and prediction of features of turbulent flows$\text{---}$such as statistics, structures and their nonlinear interactions$\text{---}$using the singular value decomposition of the resolvent operator based on the appropriate turbulent mean, following the framework developed by McKeon & Sharma (20… ▽ More The resolvent formulation of the Navier$\text{--}$Stokes equations gives a means for the characterization and prediction of features of turbulent flows$\text{---}$such as statistics, structures and their nonlinear interactions$\text{---}$using the singular value decomposition of the resolvent operator based on the appropriate turbulent mean, following the framework developed by McKeon & Sharma (2010). This work will describe a methodology for approximating leading resolvent (i.e., pseudospectral) modes for shear-driven turbulent flows using prescribed analytic functions. We will demonstrate that these functions, which arise from the consideration of wavepacket pseudoeigenmodes of simplified linear operators (Trefethen 2005), in particular give an accurate approximation of the class of nominally wall-detached modes that are centered about the critical layer. Focusing in particular on modeling wall-normal vorticity modes, we present a series of simplifications to the governing equations that result in scalar differential operators that are amenable to such analysis. We demonstrate that the leading wall-normal vorticity response mode for the full Navier$\text{--}$Stokes equations may be accurately approximated by considering a second order scalar operator, equipped with a non-standard inner product. The variation in mode shape as a function of wavenumber and Reynolds number may be captured by evolving a low dimensional differential equation in parameter space. This characterization provides a theoretical framework for understanding the origin of observed structures, and allows for rapid estimation of dominant resolvent mode characteristics without the need for operator discretization or large numerical computations. We relate our findings to classical lift-up and Orr amplification mechanisms in shear-driven flows. △ Less

Submitted 30 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Journal ref: J. Fluid Mech. 877 (2019) 682-716

Critical-layer structures and mechanisms in elastoinertial turbulence

Authors: Ashwin Shekar, Ryan M. McMullen, Sung-Ning Wang, Beverley J. McKeon, Michael D. Graham

Abstract: Simulations of elastoinertial turbulence (EIT) of a polymer solution at low Reynolds number are shown to display localized polymer stretch fluctuations. These are very similar to structures arising from linear stability (Tollmien-Schlichting (TS) modes) and resolvent analyses: i.e., critical-layer structures localized where the mean fluid velocity equals the wavespeed. Computation of self-sustaine… ▽ More Simulations of elastoinertial turbulence (EIT) of a polymer solution at low Reynolds number are shown to display localized polymer stretch fluctuations. These are very similar to structures arising from linear stability (Tollmien-Schlichting (TS) modes) and resolvent analyses: i.e., critical-layer structures localized where the mean fluid velocity equals the wavespeed. Computation of self-sustained nonlinear TS waves reveals that the critical layer exhibits stagnation points that generate sheets of large polymer stretch. These kinematics may be the genesis of similar structures in EIT. △ Less

Submitted 4 April, 2019; v1 submitted 1 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures; Accepted in Physical Review Letters

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 124503 (2019)

On non-normality and classification of amplification mechanisms in stability and resolvent analysis

Authors: Sean Symon, Kevin Rosenberg, Scott T. M. Dawson, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: We seek to quantify non-normality of the most amplified resolvent modes and predict their features based on the characteristics of the base or mean velocity profile. A 2-by-2 model linear Navier-Stokes (LNS) operator illustrates how non-normality from mean shear distributes perturbation energy in different velocity components of the forcing and response modes. The inverse of their inner product, w… ▽ More We seek to quantify non-normality of the most amplified resolvent modes and predict their features based on the characteristics of the base or mean velocity profile. A 2-by-2 model linear Navier-Stokes (LNS) operator illustrates how non-normality from mean shear distributes perturbation energy in different velocity components of the forcing and response modes. The inverse of their inner product, which is unity for a purely normal mechanism, is proposed as a measure to quantify non-normality. In flows where there is downstream spatial dependence of the base/mean, mean flow advection separates the spatial support of forcing and response modes which impacts the inner product. Success of mean stability analysis depends on the normality of amplification. If the amplification is normal, the resolvent operator written in its dyadic representation reveals that the adjoint and forward stability modes are proportional to the forcing and response resolvent modes. If the amplification is non-normal, then resolvent analysis is required to understand the origin of observed flow structures. Eigenspectra and pseudospectra are used to characterize these phenomena. Two test cases are studied: low Reynolds number cylinder flow and turbulent channel flow. The first deals mainly with normal mechanisms and quantification of non-normality using the inverse inner product of the leading forcing and response modes agrees well with the product of the resolvent norm and distance between the imaginary axis and least stable eigenvalue. In turbulent channel flow, structures result from both normal and non-normal mechanisms. Mean shear is exploited most efficiently by stationary disturbances while bounds on the pseudospectra illustrate how non-normality is responsible for the most amplified disturbances at spatial wavenumbers and temporal frequencies corresponding to well-known turbulent structures. △ Less

Submitted 14 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Fluids 3, 053902 (2018)

Nonlinear forcing in the resolvent analysis of exact coherent states of the Navier-Stokes equations

Authors: Kevin Rosenberg, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: The resolvent analysis of McKeon & Sharma (2010) recasts the Navier-Stokes equations into an input/output form in which the nonlinear term is treated as a forcing that acts upon the linear dynamics to yield a velocity response. The framework has shown promise with regards to producing low-dimensional representations of exact coherent states. Previous work has focused on a primitive variable output… ▽ More The resolvent analysis of McKeon & Sharma (2010) recasts the Navier-Stokes equations into an input/output form in which the nonlinear term is treated as a forcing that acts upon the linear dynamics to yield a velocity response. The framework has shown promise with regards to producing low-dimensional representations of exact coherent states. Previous work has focused on a primitive variable output; here we show a velocity-vorticity formulation of the governing equations along with a Helmholtz decomposition of the nonlinear forcing term reveals a simplified input/output form in the resolvent analysis. This approach leads to an improved method for compact representations of exact coherent states for both forcing and response fields, with a significant reduction in degrees of freedom in comparison to the primitive variable approach. △ Less

Submitted 30 May, 2017; originally announced May 2017.

Comments: 10 pages

Modal Analysis of Fluid Flows: An Overview

Authors: Kunihiko Taira, Steven L. Brunton, Scott T. M. Dawson, Clarence W. Rowley, Tim Colonius, Beverley J. McKeon, Oliver T. Schmidt, Stanislav Gordeyev, Vassilios Theofilis, Lawrence S. Ukeiley

Abstract: Simple aerodynamic configurations under even modest conditions can exhibit complex flows with a wide range of temporal and spatial features. It has become common practice in the analysis of these flows to look for and extract physically important features, or modes, as a first step in the analysis. This step typically starts with a modal decomposition of an experimental or numerical dataset of the… ▽ More Simple aerodynamic configurations under even modest conditions can exhibit complex flows with a wide range of temporal and spatial features. It has become common practice in the analysis of these flows to look for and extract physically important features, or modes, as a first step in the analysis. This step typically starts with a modal decomposition of an experimental or numerical dataset of the flow field, or of an operator relevant to the system. We describe herein some of the dominant techniques for accomplishing these modal decompositions and analyses that have seen a surge of activity in recent decades. For a non-expert, kee** track of recent developments can be daunting, and the intent of this document is to provide an introduction to modal analysis that is accessible to the larger fluid dynamics community. In particular, we present a brief overview of several of the well-established techniques and clearly lay the framework of these methods using familiar linear algebra. The modal analysis techniques covered in this paper include the proper orthogonal decomposition (POD), balanced proper orthogonal decomposition (Balanced POD), dynamic mode decomposition (DMD), Koopman analysis, global linear stability analysis, and resolvent analysis. △ Less

Submitted 9 August, 2017; v1 submitted 5 February, 2017; originally announced February 2017.

Comments: 43 pages, 17 figures

Scaling and interaction of self-similar modes in models of high-Reynolds number wall turbulence

Authors: A S Sharma, R Moarref, B J McKeon

Abstract: Previous work has established the usefulness of the resolvent operator that maps the terms nonlinear in the turbulent fluctuations to the fluctuations themselves. Further work has described the self-similarity of the resolvent arising from that of the mean velocity profile. The orthogonal modes provided by the resolvent analysis describe the wall-normal coherence of the motions and inherit that se… ▽ More Previous work has established the usefulness of the resolvent operator that maps the terms nonlinear in the turbulent fluctuations to the fluctuations themselves. Further work has described the self-similarity of the resolvent arising from that of the mean velocity profile. The orthogonal modes provided by the resolvent analysis describe the wall-normal coherence of the motions and inherit that self-similarity. In this contribution, we present the implications of this similarity for the nonlinear interaction between modes with different scales and wall-normal locations. By considering the nonlinear interactions between modes, it is shown that much of the turbulence scaling behaviour in the logarithmic region can be determined from a single arbitrarily chosen reference plane. Thus, the geometric scaling of the modes is impressed upon the nonlinear interaction between modes. Implications of these observations on the self-sustaining mechanisms of wall turbulence, modelling and simulation are outlined. △ Less

Submitted 22 September, 2016; originally announced September 2016.

Comments: Accepted for publication in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A. arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:1409.6047

On the design of optimal compliant walls for turbulence control

Authors: M. Luhar, A. S. Sharma, B. J. McKeon

Abstract: This paper employs the theoretical framework developed by Luhar et al. (J. Fluid Mech., 768, 415-441) to consider the design of compliant walls for turbulent skin friction reduction. Specifically, the effects of simple spring-damper walls are contrasted with the effects of more complex walls incorporating tension, stiffness and anisotropy. In addition, varying mass ratios are tested to provide ins… ▽ More This paper employs the theoretical framework developed by Luhar et al. (J. Fluid Mech., 768, 415-441) to consider the design of compliant walls for turbulent skin friction reduction. Specifically, the effects of simple spring-damper walls are contrasted with the effects of more complex walls incorporating tension, stiffness and anisotropy. In addition, varying mass ratios are tested to provide insight into differences between aerodynamic and hydrodynamic applications. Despite the differing physical responses, all the walls tested exhibit some important common features. First, the effect of the walls (positive or negative) is greatest at conditions close to resonance, with sharp transitions in performance across the resonant frequency or phase speed. Second, compliant walls are predicted to have a more pronounced effect on slower-moving structures because such structures generally have larger wall-pressure signatures. Third, two-dimensional (spanwise constant) structures are particularly susceptible to further amplification. These features are consistent with many previous experiments and simulations, suggesting that mitigating the rise of such two-dimensional structures is essential to designing performance-improving walls. For instance, it is shown that further amplification of such large-scale two-dimensional structures explains why the optimal anisotropic walls identified by Fukagata et al. via DNS (J. Turb., 9, 1-17) only led to drag reduction in very small domains. The above observations are used to develop design and methodology guidelines for future research on compliant walls. △ Less

Submitted 18 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

On the correspondence between Koopman mode decomposition, resolvent mode decomposition, and invariant solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations

Authors: Ati S. Sharma, Igor Mezić, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: The relationship between Koopman mode decomposition, resolvent mode decomposition and exact invariant solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations is clarified. The correspondence rests upon the invariance of the system operators under symmetry operations such as spatial translation. The usual interpretation of the Koopman operator is generalised to permit combinations of such operations, in addition… ▽ More The relationship between Koopman mode decomposition, resolvent mode decomposition and exact invariant solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations is clarified. The correspondence rests upon the invariance of the system operators under symmetry operations such as spatial translation. The usual interpretation of the Koopman operator is generalised to permit combinations of such operations, in addition to translation in time. This invariance is related to the spectrum of a spatio-temporal Koopman operator, which has a travelling wave interpretation. The relationship leads to a generalisation of dynamic mode decomposition, in which symmetry operations are applied to restrict the dynamic modes to span a subspace subject to those symmetries. The resolvent is interpreted as the map** between the Koopman modes of the Reynolds stress divergence and the velocity field. It is shown that the singular vectors of the resolvent (the resolvent modes) are the optimal basis in which to express the velocity field Koopman modes where the latter are not a priori known. △ Less

Submitted 21 June, 2016; v1 submitted 28 March, 2016; originally announced March 2016.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Fluids 1, 032402 (2016)

Low-dimensional representations of exact coherent states of the Navier-Stokes equations from the resolvent model of wall turbulence

Authors: Ati S. Sharma, Rashad Moarref, Beverley J. McKeon, Jae Sung Park, Michael D. Graham, Ashley P. Willis

Abstract: We report that many exact invariant solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations for both pipe and channel flows are well represented by just few modes of the model of McKeon & Sharma J. Fl. Mech. 658, 356 (2010). This model provides modes that act as a basis to decompose the velocity field, ordered by their amplitude of response to forcing arising from the interaction between scales. The model was or… ▽ More We report that many exact invariant solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations for both pipe and channel flows are well represented by just few modes of the model of McKeon & Sharma J. Fl. Mech. 658, 356 (2010). This model provides modes that act as a basis to decompose the velocity field, ordered by their amplitude of response to forcing arising from the interaction between scales. The model was originally derived from the Navier-Stokes equations to represent turbulent flows and has been used to explain coherent structure and to predict turbulent statistics. This establishes a surprising new link between the two distinct approaches to understanding turbulence. △ Less

Submitted 25 January, 2016; v1 submitted 5 March, 2015; originally announced March 2015.

Comments: 21 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 93, 021102 (2016)

A framework for studying the effect of compliant surfaces on wall turbulence

Authors: M. Luhar, A. S. Sharma, B. J. McKeon

Abstract: This paper extends the resolvent formulation proposed by McKeon & Sharma (2010) to consider turbulence-compliant wall interactions. Under this formulation, the turbulent velocity field is expressed as a linear superposition of propagating modes, identified via a gain-based decomposition of the Navier-Stokes equations. Compliant surfaces, modeled as a complex wall-admittance linking pressure and ve… ▽ More This paper extends the resolvent formulation proposed by McKeon & Sharma (2010) to consider turbulence-compliant wall interactions. Under this formulation, the turbulent velocity field is expressed as a linear superposition of propagating modes, identified via a gain-based decomposition of the Navier-Stokes equations. Compliant surfaces, modeled as a complex wall-admittance linking pressure and velocity, affect the gain and structure of these modes. With minimal computation, this framework accurately predicts the emergence of the quasi-2D propagating waves observed in recent direct numerical simulations. Further, the analysis also enables the rational design of compliant surfaces, with properties optimized to suppress flow structures energetic in wall turbulence. It is shown that walls with unphysical negative dam** are required to interact favorably with modes resembling the energetic near-wall cycle, which could explain why previous studies have met with limited success. Positive-dam** walls are effective for modes resembling the so-called very large-scale motions (VLSMs), indicating that compliant surfaces may be better suited for application at higher Reynolds number. Unfortunately, walls that suppress structures energetic in natural turbulence are also predicted to have detrimental effects elsewhere in spectral space. Consistent with previous experiments and simulations, slow-moving spanwise-constant structures are particularly susceptible to further amplification. Mitigating these adverse effects will be central to the development of compliant coatings that have a net positive influence on the flow. △ Less

Submitted 5 February, 2015; v1 submitted 24 November, 2014; originally announced November 2014.

Journal ref: J. Fluid Mech (2015), 769, pp. 687-722

A foundation for analytical developments in the logarithmic region of turbulent channels

Authors: Rashad Moarref, Ati S. Sharma, Joel A. Tropp, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: An analytical framework for studying the logarithmic region of turbulent channels is formulated. We build on recent findings (Moarref et al., J. Fluid Mech., 734, 2013) that the velocity fluctuations in the logarithmic region can be decomposed into a weighted sum of geometrically self-similar resolvent modes. The resolvent modes and the weights represent the linear amplification mechanisms and the… ▽ More An analytical framework for studying the logarithmic region of turbulent channels is formulated. We build on recent findings (Moarref et al., J. Fluid Mech., 734, 2013) that the velocity fluctuations in the logarithmic region can be decomposed into a weighted sum of geometrically self-similar resolvent modes. The resolvent modes and the weights represent the linear amplification mechanisms and the scaling influence of the nonlinear interactions in the Navier-Stokes equations (NSE), respectively (McKeon & Sharma, J. Fluid Mech., 658, 2010). Originating from the NSE, this framework provides an analytical support for Townsend's attached-eddy model. Our main result is that self-similarity enables order reduction in modeling the logarithmic region by establishing a quantitative link between the self-similar structures and the velocity spectra. Specifically, the energy intensities, the Reynolds stresses, and the energy budget are expressed in terms of the resolvent modes with speeds corresponding to the top of the logarithmic region. The weights of the triad modes -the modes that directly interact via the quadratic nonlinearity in the NSE- are coupled via the interaction coefficients that depend solely on the resolvent modes (McKeon et al., Phys. Fluids, 25, 2013). We use the hierarchies of self-similar modes in the logarithmic region to extend the notion of triad modes to triad hierarchies. It is shown that the interaction coefficients for the triad modes that belong to a triad hierarchy follow an exponential function. The combination of these findings can be used to better understand the dynamics and interaction of flow structures in the logarithmic region. The compatibility of the proposed model with theoretical and experimental results is further discussed. △ Less

Submitted 21 September, 2014; originally announced September 2014.

Comments: Submitted to J. Fluid Mech

A low-order decomposition of turbulent channel flow via resolvent analysis and convex optimization

Authors: R. Moarref, M. R. Jovanovic, J. A. Tropp, A. S. Sharma, B. J. McKeon

Abstract: We combine resolvent-mode decomposition with techniques from convex optimization to optimally approximate velocity spectra in a turbulent channel. The velocity is expressed as a weighted sum of resolvent modes that are dynamically significant, non-empirical, and scalable with Reynolds number. To optimally represent DNS data at friction Reynolds number $2003$, we determine the weights of resolvent… ▽ More We combine resolvent-mode decomposition with techniques from convex optimization to optimally approximate velocity spectra in a turbulent channel. The velocity is expressed as a weighted sum of resolvent modes that are dynamically significant, non-empirical, and scalable with Reynolds number. To optimally represent DNS data at friction Reynolds number $2003$, we determine the weights of resolvent modes as the solution of a convex optimization problem. Using only $12$ modes per wall-parallel wavenumber pair and temporal frequency, we obtain close agreement with DNS-spectra, reducing the wall-normal and temporal resolutions used in the simulation by three orders of magnitude. △ Less

Submitted 21 May, 2014; v1 submitted 24 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

Journal ref: Phys. Fluids, 26: 051701, 2014

Deconstructing wall turbulence -visualization of resolvent modes

Authors: Daniel Barella, Sarah Churng, Conrad Egan, Rashad Moarref, Mitul Luhar, Hillary Mushkin, Scott Davidoff, Maggie Hendrie, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: This article accompanies a fluid dynamics video entered into the Gallery of Fluid Motion of the 66th Annual Meeting of the APS Division of Fluid Dynamics. This article accompanies a fluid dynamics video entered into the Gallery of Fluid Motion of the 66th Annual Meeting of the APS Division of Fluid Dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 10 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Comments: High and low resolution videos associated with this manuscript can be found as ancillary files

Influence of a local change of depth on the behavior of bouncing oil drops

Authors: Remi Carmigniani, Simon Lapointe, Sean Symon, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: The work of Couder \textit{et al} (see also Bush \textit{et al}) inspired consideration of the impact of a submerged obstacle, providing a local change of depth, on the behavior of oil drops in the bouncing regime. In the linked videos, we recreate some of their results for a drop bouncing on a uniform depth bath of the same liquid undergoing vertical oscillations just below the conditions for Far… ▽ More The work of Couder \textit{et al} (see also Bush \textit{et al}) inspired consideration of the impact of a submerged obstacle, providing a local change of depth, on the behavior of oil drops in the bouncing regime. In the linked videos, we recreate some of their results for a drop bouncing on a uniform depth bath of the same liquid undergoing vertical oscillations just below the conditions for Faraday instability, and show a range of new behaviors associated with change of depth. This article accompanies a fluid dynamics video entered into the Gallery of Fluid Motion of the 66th Annual Meeting of the APS Division of Fluid Dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 9 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Comments: High and low resolutions videos included as ancillary files

Model-based scaling of the streamwise energy density in high-Reynolds number turbulent channels

Authors: Rashad Moarref, Ati S. Sharma, Joel A. Tropp, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: We study the Reynolds number scaling and the geometric self-similarity of a gain-based, low-rank approximation to turbulent channel flows, determined by the resolvent formulation of McKeon & Sharma (2010), in order to obtain a description of the streamwise turbulence intensity from direct consideration of the Navier-Stokes equations. Under this formulation, the velocity field is decomposed into pr… ▽ More We study the Reynolds number scaling and the geometric self-similarity of a gain-based, low-rank approximation to turbulent channel flows, determined by the resolvent formulation of McKeon & Sharma (2010), in order to obtain a description of the streamwise turbulence intensity from direct consideration of the Navier-Stokes equations. Under this formulation, the velocity field is decomposed into propagating waves (with single streamwise and spanwise wavelengths and wave speed) whose wall-normal shapes are determined from the principal singular function of the corresponding resolvent operator. Using the accepted scalings of the mean velocity in wall-bounded turbulent flows, we establish that the resolvent operator admits three classes of wave parameters that induce universal behavior with Reynolds number on the low-rank model, and which are consistent with scalings proposed throughout the wall turbulence literature. In addition, it was shown that a necessary condition for geometrically self-similar resolvent modes is the presence of a logarithmic turbulent mean velocity. We identify the scalings that constitute hierarchies of self-similar modes that are parameterized by the critical wall-normal location where the speed of the mode equals the local turbulent mean velocity. For the rank-1 model subject to broadband forcing, the integrated streamwise energy density takes a universal form which is consistent with the dominant near-wall turbulent motions. When the shape of the forcing is optimized to enforce matching with results from direct numerical simulations at low turbulent Reynolds numbers, further similarity appears. Representation of these weight functions using similarity laws enables prediction of the Reynolds number and wall-normal variations of the streamwise energy intensity at high Reynolds numbers (${Re}_τ\approx 10^3 - 10^{10}$). △ Less

Submitted 3 October, 2013; v1 submitted 6 February, 2013; originally announced February 2013.

Comments: The paper is to appear in the Journal of Fluid Mechanics

Journal ref: J. Fluid Mech. 734:275-316, 2013

On coherent structure in wall turbulence

Authors: A S Sharma, B J McKeon

Abstract: A new theory of coherent structure in wall turbulence is presented. The theory is the first to predict packets of hairpin vortices and other structure in turbulence, and their dynamics, based on an analysis of the Navier-Stokes equations, under an assumption of a turbulent mean profile. The assumption of the turbulent mean acts as a restriction on the class of possible structures. It is shown th… ▽ More A new theory of coherent structure in wall turbulence is presented. The theory is the first to predict packets of hairpin vortices and other structure in turbulence, and their dynamics, based on an analysis of the Navier-Stokes equations, under an assumption of a turbulent mean profile. The assumption of the turbulent mean acts as a restriction on the class of possible structures. It is shown that the coherent structure is a manifestation of essentially low-dimensional flow dynamics, arising from a critical layer mechanism. Using the decomposition presented in McKeon & Sharma (J. Fluid Mech, 658, 2010), complex coherent structure is recreated from minimal superpositions of response modes predicted by the analysis, which take the form of radially-varying travelling waves. By way of example, simple combinations of these modes are offered that predicts hairpins and modulated hairpin packets. The phase interaction also predicts important skewness and correlation results known in the literature. It is also shown that the very large scale motions act to organise hairpin-like structures such that they co-locate with areas of low streamwise momentum, by a mechanism of locally varying the shear profile. The relationship between Taylor's hypothesis and coherence is discussed and both are shown to be the consequence of the localisation of the response modes around the critical layer. A pleasing link is made to the classical laminar inviscid theory, whereby the essential mechanism underlying the hairpin vortex is captured by two obliquely interacting Kelvin-Stuart (cat's eye) vortices. Evidence for the theory is presented based on comparison to observations of structure reported in the experimental, transitional flow and turbulent flow numerical simulation literature. △ Less

Submitted 17 June, 2013; v1 submitted 31 January, 2013; originally announced January 2013.

Comments: Accepted for publication in the Journal of Fluid Mechanics. 41 pages

Journal ref: J. Fl, Mech. (2013), 728, pp 196-238

Relaminarisation of Re_τ = 100 channel flow with globally stabilising linear feedback control

Authors: A S Sharma, J F Morrison, B J McKeon, D J N L Limebeer, W H Koberg, S J Sherwin

Abstract: The problems of nonlinearity and high dimension have so far prevented a complete solution of the control of turbulent flow. Addressing the problem of nonlinearity, we propose a flow control strategy which ensures that the energy of any perturbation to the target profile decays monotonically. The controller's estimate of the flow state is similarly guaranteed to converge to the true value. We prese… ▽ More The problems of nonlinearity and high dimension have so far prevented a complete solution of the control of turbulent flow. Addressing the problem of nonlinearity, we propose a flow control strategy which ensures that the energy of any perturbation to the target profile decays monotonically. The controller's estimate of the flow state is similarly guaranteed to converge to the true value. We present a one-time off-line synthesis procedure, which generalises to accommodate more restrictive actuation and sensing arrangements, with conditions for existence for the controller given in this case. The control is tested in turbulent channel flow ($Re_τ=100$) using full-domain sensing and actuation on the wall-normal velocity. Concentrated at the point of maximum inflection in the mean profile, the control directly counters the supply of turbulence energy arising from the interaction of the wall-normal perturbations with the flow shear. It is found that the control is only required for the larger-scale motions, specifically those above the scale of the mean streak spacing. Minimal control effort is required once laminar flow is achieved. The response of the near-wall flow is examined in detail, with particular emphasis on the pressure and wall-normal velocity fields, in the context of Landahl's theory of sheared turbulence. △ Less

Submitted 21 January, 2013; originally announced January 2013.

Journal ref: Physics of Fluids 23, 125105 (2011)

A streamwise-constant model of turbulent pipe flow

Authors: Jean-Loup Bourguignon, Beverley J. McKeon

Abstract: A streamwise-constant model is presented to investigate the basic mechanisms responsible for the change in mean flow occuring during pipe flow transition. Using a single forced momentum balance equation, we show that the shape of the velocity profile is robust to changes in the forcing profile and that both linear non-normal and nonlinear effects are required to capture the change in mean flow ass… ▽ More A streamwise-constant model is presented to investigate the basic mechanisms responsible for the change in mean flow occuring during pipe flow transition. Using a single forced momentum balance equation, we show that the shape of the velocity profile is robust to changes in the forcing profile and that both linear non-normal and nonlinear effects are required to capture the change in mean flow associated with transition to turbulence. The particularly simple form of the model allows for the study of the momentum transfer directly by inspection of the equations. The distribution of the high- and low-speed streaks over the cross-section of the pipe produced by our model is remarkably similar to one observed in the velocity field near the trailing edge of the puff structures present in pipe flow transition. Under stochastic forcing, the model exhibits a quasi-periodic self-sustaining cycle characterized by the creation and subsequent decay of "streamwise-constant puffs", so-called due to the good agreement between the temporal evolution of their velocity field and the projection of the velocity field associated with three-dimensional puffs in a frame of reference moving at the bulk velocity. We establish that the flow dynamics are relatively insensitive to the regeneration mechanisms invoked to produce near-wall streamwise vortices and that using small, unstructured background disturbances to regenerate the streamwise vortices is sufficient to capture the formation of the high- and low-speed streaks and their segregation leading to the blunting of the velocity profile characteristic of turbulent pipe flow. △ Less

Submitted 11 January, 2011; originally announced January 2011.

Predicting structural and statistical features of wall turbulence

Authors: B. J. McKeon, A. S. Sharma, I. Jacobi

Abstract: The majority of practical flows, particularly those flows in applications of importance to transport, distribution and climate, are turbulent and as a result experience complex three-dimensional motion with increased drag compared with the smoother, laminar condition. In this study, we describe the development of a simple model that predicts important structural and scaling features of wall turbul… ▽ More The majority of practical flows, particularly those flows in applications of importance to transport, distribution and climate, are turbulent and as a result experience complex three-dimensional motion with increased drag compared with the smoother, laminar condition. In this study, we describe the development of a simple model that predicts important structural and scaling features of wall turbulence. We show that a simple linear superposition of modes derived from a forcing-response analysis of the Navier-Stokes equations can be used to reconcile certain key statistical and structural descriptions of wall turbulence. The computationally cheap approach explains and predicts vortical structures and velocity statistics of turbulent flows that have previously been identified only in experiments or by direct numerical simulation. In particular, we propose an economical explanation for the meandering appearance of very large scale motions observed in turbulent pipe flow, and likewise demonstrate that hairpin vortices are predicted by the model. This new capability has clear implications for modeling, simulation and control of a ubiquitous class of wall flows. △ Less

Submitted 2 December, 2010; originally announced December 2010.

Comments: 15 pages, 4 figures

Amplification and Nonlinear Mechanisms in Plane Couette Flow

Authors: Dennice F. Gayme, Beverley J. McKeon, Bassam Bamieh, Antonis Papachristodoulou, John C. Doyle

Abstract: We study the input-output response of a streamwise constant projection of the Navier-Stokes equations for plane Couette flow, the so-called 2D/3C model. Study of a streamwise constant model is motivated by numerical and experimental observations that suggest the prevalence and importance of streamwise and quasi-streamwise elongated structures. Periodic spanwise/wall-normal (z-y) plane stream funct… ▽ More We study the input-output response of a streamwise constant projection of the Navier-Stokes equations for plane Couette flow, the so-called 2D/3C model. Study of a streamwise constant model is motivated by numerical and experimental observations that suggest the prevalence and importance of streamwise and quasi-streamwise elongated structures. Periodic spanwise/wall-normal (z-y) plane stream functions are used as input to develop a forced 2D/3C streamwise velocity field that is qualitatively similar to a fully turbulent spatial field of DNS data. The input-output response associated with the 2D/3C nonlinear coupling is used to estimate the energy optimal spanwise wavelength over a range of Reynolds numbers. The results of the input-output analysis agree with previous studies of the linearized Navier-Stokes equations. The optimal energy corresponds to minimal nonlinear coupling. On the other hand, the nature of the forced 2D/3C streamwise velocity field provides evidence that the nonlinear coupling in the 2D/3C model is responsible for creating the well known characteristic "S" shaped turbulent velocity profile. This indicates that there is an important tradeoff between energy amplification, which is primarily linear and the seemingly nonlinear momentum transfer mechanism that produces a turbulent-like mean profile. △ Less

Submitted 25 November, 2010; originally announced November 2010.

Comments: Submitted to Physics of Fluids, under review

A critical layer model for turbulent pipe flow

Authors: B. J. McKeon, A. S. Sharma

Abstract: A model-based description of the scaling and radial location of turbulent fluctuations in turbulent pipe flow is presented and used to illuminate the scaling behaviour of the very large scale motions. The model is derived by treating the nonlinearity in the perturbation equation (involving the Reynolds stress) as an unknown forcing, yielding a linear relationship between the velocity field respo… ▽ More A model-based description of the scaling and radial location of turbulent fluctuations in turbulent pipe flow is presented and used to illuminate the scaling behaviour of the very large scale motions. The model is derived by treating the nonlinearity in the perturbation equation (involving the Reynolds stress) as an unknown forcing, yielding a linear relationship between the velocity field response and this nonlinearity. We do not assume small perturbations. We examine propagating modes, permitting comparison of our results to experimental data, and identify the steady component of the velocity field that varies only in the wall-normal direction as the turbulent mean profile. The "optimal" forcing shape, that gives the largest velocity response, is assumed to lead to modes that will be dominant and hence observed in turbulent pipe flow. An investigation of the most amplified velocity response at a given wavenumber-frequency combination reveals critical layer-like behaviour reminiscent of the neutrally stable solutions of the Orr-Sommerfeld equation in linearly unstable flow. Two distinct regions in the flow where the influence of viscosity becomes important can be identified, namely a wall layer that scales with $R^{+1/2}$ and a critical layer, where the propagation velocity is equal to the local mean velocity, that scales with $R^{+2/3}$ in pipe flow. This framework appears to be consistent with several scaling results in wall turbulence and reveals a mechanism by which the effects of viscosity can extend well beyond the immediate vicinity of the wall. △ Less

Submitted 18 January, 2010; originally announced January 2010.

Comments: Submitted to the Journal of Fluid Mechanics and currently under review

Journal ref: J. Fluid Mech. (2010), vol. 658, pp. 336-382

Large-eddy simulation of large-scale structures in long channel flow

Authors: D. Chung, B. J. McKeon

Abstract: We investigate statistics of large-scale structures from large-eddy simulation (LES) of turbulent channel flow at friction Reynolds numbers $Re_τ= 2 {\rm k}$ and $200 {\rm k}$. To properly capture the behaviour of large-scale structures, the channel length is chosen to be 96 times the channel half-height. In agreement with experiments, these large-scale structures are found to give rise to an ap… ▽ More We investigate statistics of large-scale structures from large-eddy simulation (LES) of turbulent channel flow at friction Reynolds numbers $Re_τ= 2 {\rm k}$ and $200 {\rm k}$. To properly capture the behaviour of large-scale structures, the channel length is chosen to be 96 times the channel half-height. In agreement with experiments, these large-scale structures are found to give rise to an apparent amplitude modulation of the underlying small-scale fluctuations. This effect is explained in terms of the phase relationship between the large- and small-scale activity. The shape of the dominant large-scale structure is investigated by conditional averages based on the large-scale velocity, determined using a filter width equal to the channel half-height. The conditioned field demonstrates coherence on a scale of several times the filter width, and the small-scale--large-scale relative phase difference increases away from the wall, passing through $π/2$ in the overlap region of the mean velocity before approaching $π$ further from the wall. We also found that, near the wall, the convection velocity of the large-scales departs slightly, but unequivocally, from the mean velocity. △ Less

Submitted 18 January, 2010; originally announced January 2010.

Comments: Submitted to the Journal of Fluid Mechanics and currently under review

A Streamwise Constant Model of Turbulence in Plane Couette Flow

Authors: D. F. Gayme, B. J. McKeon, A. Papachristodoulou, B. Bamieh, J. C. Doyle

Abstract: Streamwise and quasi-streamwise elongated structures have been shown to play a significant role in turbulent shear flows. We model the mean behavior of fully turbulent plane Couette flow using a streamwise constant projection of the Navier Stokes equations. This results in a two-dimensional, three velocity component ($2D/3C$) model. We first use a steady state version of the model to demonstrate t… ▽ More Streamwise and quasi-streamwise elongated structures have been shown to play a significant role in turbulent shear flows. We model the mean behavior of fully turbulent plane Couette flow using a streamwise constant projection of the Navier Stokes equations. This results in a two-dimensional, three velocity component ($2D/3C$) model. We first use a steady state version of the model to demonstrate that its nonlinear coupling provides the mathematical mechanism that shapes the turbulent velocity profile. Simulations of the $2D/3C$ model under small amplitude Gaussian forcing of the cross-stream components are compared to DNS data. The results indicate that a streamwise constant projection of the Navier Stokes equations captures salient features of fully turbulent plane Couette flow at low Reynolds numbers. A system theoretic approach is used to demonstrate the presence of large input-output amplification through the forced $2D/3C$ model. It is this amplification coupled with the appropriate nonlinearity that enables the $2D/3C$ model to generate turbulent behaviour under the small amplitude forcing employed in this study. △ Less

Submitted 25 November, 2010; v1 submitted 5 January, 2010; originally announced January 2010.

Comments: Journal of Fluid Mechanics 2010, in press