-
Map** the Design Space of Teachable Social Media Feed Experiences
Authors:
K. J. Kevin Feng,
Xander Koo,
Lawrence Tan,
Amy Bruckman,
David W. McDonald,
Amy X. Zhang
Abstract:
Social media feeds are deeply personal spaces that reflect individual values and preferences. However, top-down, platform-wide content algorithms can reduce users' sense of agency and fail to account for nuanced experiences and values. Drawing on the paradigm of interactive machine teaching (IMT), an interaction framework for non-expert algorithmic adaptation, we map out a design space for teachab…
▽ More
Social media feeds are deeply personal spaces that reflect individual values and preferences. However, top-down, platform-wide content algorithms can reduce users' sense of agency and fail to account for nuanced experiences and values. Drawing on the paradigm of interactive machine teaching (IMT), an interaction framework for non-expert algorithmic adaptation, we map out a design space for teachable social media feed experiences to empower agential, personalized feed curation. To do so, we conducted a think-aloud study (N=24) featuring four social media platforms -- Instagram, Mastodon, TikTok, and Twitter -- to understand key signals users leveraged to determine the value of a post in their feed. We synthesized users' signals into taxonomies that, when combined with user interviews, inform five design principles that extend IMT into the social media setting. We finally embodied our principles into three feed designs that we present as sensitizing concepts for teachable feed experiences moving forward.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2024; v1 submitted 25 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Canvil: Designerly Adaptation for LLM-Powered User Experiences
Authors:
K. J. Kevin Feng,
Q. Vera Liao,
Ziang Xiao,
Jennifer Wortman Vaughan,
Amy X. Zhang,
David W. McDonald
Abstract:
Advancements in large language models (LLMs) are poised to spark a proliferation of LLM-powered user experiences. In product teams, designers are often tasked with crafting user experiences that align with user needs. To involve designers and leverage their user-centered perspectives to create effective and responsible LLM-powered products, we introduce the practice of designerly adaptation for en…
▽ More
Advancements in large language models (LLMs) are poised to spark a proliferation of LLM-powered user experiences. In product teams, designers are often tasked with crafting user experiences that align with user needs. To involve designers and leverage their user-centered perspectives to create effective and responsible LLM-powered products, we introduce the practice of designerly adaptation for engaging with LLMs as an adaptable design material. We first identify key characteristics of designerly adaptation through a formative study with designers experienced in designing for LLM-powered products (N=12). These characteristics are 1) have a low technical barrier to entry, 2) leverage designers' unique perspectives bridging users and technology, and 3) encourage model tinkering. Based on this characterization, we build Canvil, a Figma widget that operationalizes designerly adaptation. Canvil supports structured authoring of system prompts to adapt LLM behavior, testing of adapted models on diverse user inputs, and integration of model outputs into interface designs. We use Canvil as a technology probe in a group-based design study (6 groups, N=17) to investigate the implications of integrating designerly adaptation into design workflows. We find that designers are able to iteratively tinker with different adaptation approaches and reason about interface affordances to enhance end-user interaction with LLMs. Furthermore, designers identified promising collaborative workflows for designerly adaptation. Our work opens new avenues for collaborative processes and tools that foreground designers' user-centered expertise in the crafting and deployment of LLM-powered user experiences.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
How Do UX Practitioners Communicate AI as a Design Material? Artifacts, Conceptions, and Propositions
Authors:
K. J. Kevin Feng,
Maxwell James Coppock,
David W. McDonald
Abstract:
UX practitioners (UXPs) face novel challenges when working with and communicating artificial intelligence (AI) as a design material. We explore how UXPs communicate AI concepts when given hands-on experience training and experimenting with AI models. To do so, we conducted a task-based design study with 27 UXPs in which they prototyped and created a design presentation for a AI-enabled interface w…
▽ More
UX practitioners (UXPs) face novel challenges when working with and communicating artificial intelligence (AI) as a design material. We explore how UXPs communicate AI concepts when given hands-on experience training and experimenting with AI models. To do so, we conducted a task-based design study with 27 UXPs in which they prototyped and created a design presentation for a AI-enabled interface while having access to a simple AI model training tool. Through analyzing UXPs' design presentations and post-activity interviews, we found that although UXPs struggled to clearly communicate some AI concepts, tinkering with AI broadened common ground when communicating with technical stakeholders. UXPs also identified key risks and benefits of AI in their designs, and proposed concrete next steps for both UX and AI work. We conclude with a sensitizing concept and recommendations for design and AI tools to enhance multi-stakeholder communication and collaboration when crafting human-centered AI experiences.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Addressing UX Practitioners' Challenges in Designing ML Applications: an Interactive Machine Learning Approach
Authors:
K. J. Kevin Feng,
David W. McDonald
Abstract:
UX practitioners face novel challenges when designing user interfaces for machine learning (ML)-enabled applications. Interactive ML paradigms, like AutoML and interactive machine teaching, lower the barrier for non-expert end users to create, understand, and use ML models, but their application to UX practice is largely unstudied. We conducted a task-based design study with 27 UX practitioners wh…
▽ More
UX practitioners face novel challenges when designing user interfaces for machine learning (ML)-enabled applications. Interactive ML paradigms, like AutoML and interactive machine teaching, lower the barrier for non-expert end users to create, understand, and use ML models, but their application to UX practice is largely unstudied. We conducted a task-based design study with 27 UX practitioners where we asked them to propose a proof-of-concept design for a new ML-enabled application. During the task, our participants were given opportunities to create, test, and modify ML models as part of their workflows. Through a qualitative analysis of our post-task interview, we found that direct, interactive experimentation with ML allowed UX practitioners to tie ML capabilities and underlying data to user goals, compose affordances to enhance end-user interactions with ML, and identify ML-related ethical risks and challenges. We discuss our findings in the context of previously established human-AI guidelines. We also identify some limitations of interactive ML in UX processes and propose research-informed machine teaching as a supplement to future design tools alongside interactive ML.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Ease on Down the Code: Complex Collaborative Qualitative Coding Simplified with 'Code Wizard'
Authors:
Abbas Ganji,
Mania Orand,
David W. McDonald
Abstract:
This paper describes the design and development of a preliminary qualitative coding tool as well as a method to improve the process of achieving inter-coder reliability (ICR) in small teams. Software applications that support qualitative coding do not sufficiently assist collaboration among coders and overlook some fundamental issues related to ICR. We propose a new dimension of collaborative codi…
▽ More
This paper describes the design and development of a preliminary qualitative coding tool as well as a method to improve the process of achieving inter-coder reliability (ICR) in small teams. Software applications that support qualitative coding do not sufficiently assist collaboration among coders and overlook some fundamental issues related to ICR. We propose a new dimension of collaborative coding called "coders' certainty" and demonstrate its ability to illustrate valuable code disagreements that are missing from existing approaches. Through a case study, we describe the utility of our tool, Code Wizard, and how it helped a group of researchers effectively collaborate to code naturalistic observation data. We report the valuable lessons we learned from the development of our tool and method: (1) identifying coders' certainty constitutes an important part of determining the quality of data analysis and facilitates identifying overlap** and ambiguous codes, (2) making the details of coding process visible helps streamline the coding process and leads to a sense of ownership of the research results, and (3) there is valuable information hidden in coding disagreements that can be leveraged for improving the process of data analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 30 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Dissecting a Social Botnet: Growth, Content and Influence in Twitter
Authors:
Norah Abokhodair,
Daisy Yoo,
David W. McDonald
Abstract:
Social botnets have become an important phenomenon on social media. There are many ways in which social bots can disrupt or influence online discourse, such as, spam hashtags, scam twitter users, and astroturfing. In this paper we considered one specific social botnet in Twitter to understand how it grows over time, how the content of tweets by the social botnet differ from regular users in the sa…
▽ More
Social botnets have become an important phenomenon on social media. There are many ways in which social bots can disrupt or influence online discourse, such as, spam hashtags, scam twitter users, and astroturfing. In this paper we considered one specific social botnet in Twitter to understand how it grows over time, how the content of tweets by the social botnet differ from regular users in the same dataset, and lastly, how the social botnet may have influenced the relevant discussions. Our analysis is based on a qualitative coding for approximately 3000 tweets in Arabic and English from the Syrian social bot that was active for 35 weeks on Twitter before it was shutdown. We find that the growth, behavior and content of this particular botnet did not specifically align with common conceptions of botnets. Further we identify interesting aspects of the botnet that distinguish it from regular users.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.