Showing 1–13 of 13 results for author: Mathis, C

Experimental Measurement of Assembly Indices are Required to Determine The Threshold for Life

Authors: Sara I. Walker, Cole Mathis, Stuart Marshall, Leroy Cronin

Abstract: Assembly Theory (AT) was developed to help distinguish living from non-living systems. The theory is simple as it posits that the amount of selection or Assembly is a function of the number of complex objects where their complexity can be objectively determined using assembly indices. The assembly index of a given object relates to the number of recursive joining operations required to build that… ▽ More Assembly Theory (AT) was developed to help distinguish living from non-living systems. The theory is simple as it posits that the amount of selection or Assembly is a function of the number of complex objects where their complexity can be objectively determined using assembly indices. The assembly index of a given object relates to the number of recursive joining operations required to build that object and can be not only rigorously defined mathematically but can be experimentally measured. In pervious work we outlined the theoretical basis, but also extensive experimental measurements that demonstrated the predictive power of AT. These measurements showed that is a threshold in assembly indices for organic molecules whereby abiotic chemical systems could not randomly produce molecules with an assembly index greater or equal than 15. In a recent paper by Hazen et al [1] the authors not only confused the concept of AT with the algorithms used to calculate assembly indices, but also attempted to falsify AT by calculating theoretical assembly indices for objects made from inorganic building blocks. A fundamental misunderstanding made by the authors is that the threshold is a requirement of the theory, rather than experimental observation. This means that exploration of inorganic assembly indices similarly requires an experimental observation, correlated with the theoretical calculations. Then and only then can the exploration of complex inorganic molecules be done using AT and the threshold for living systems, as expressed with such building blocks, be determined. Since Hazen et al.[1] present no experimental measurements of assembly theory, their analysis is not falsifiable. △ Less

Submitted 10 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Comments: 6 pages, 11 references

What it takes to solve the Origin(s) of Life: An integrated review of techniques

Authors: OoLEN, Silke Asche, Carla Bautista, David Boulesteix, Alexandre Champagne-Ruel, Cole Mathis, Omer Markovitch, Zhen Peng, Alyssa Adams, Avinash Vicholous Dass, Arnaud Buch, Eloi Camprubi, Enrico Sandro Colizzi, Stephanie Colón-Santos, Hannah Dromiack, Valentina Erastova, Amanda Garcia, Ghjuvan Grimaud, Aaron Halpern, Stuart A Harrison, Seán F. Jordan, Tony Z Jia, Amit Kahana, Artemy Kolchinsky, Odin Moron-Garcia , et al. (13 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: Understanding the origin(s) of life (OoL) is a fundamental challenge for science in the 21st century. Research on OoL spans many disciplines, including chemistry, physics, biology, planetary sciences, computer science, mathematics and philosophy. The sheer number of different scientific perspectives relevant to the problem has resulted in the coexistence of diverse tools, techniques, data, and sof… ▽ More Understanding the origin(s) of life (OoL) is a fundamental challenge for science in the 21st century. Research on OoL spans many disciplines, including chemistry, physics, biology, planetary sciences, computer science, mathematics and philosophy. The sheer number of different scientific perspectives relevant to the problem has resulted in the coexistence of diverse tools, techniques, data, and software in OoL studies. This has made communication between the disciplines relevant to the OoL extremely difficult because the interpretation of data, analyses, or standards of evidence can vary dramatically. Here, we hope to bridge this wide field of study by providing common ground via the consolidation of tools and techniques rather than positing a unifying view on how life emerges. We review the common tools and techniques that have been used significantly in OoL studies in recent years. In particular, we aim to identify which information is most relevant for comparing and integrating the results of experimental analyses into mathematical and computational models. This review aims to provide a baseline expectation and understanding of technical aspects of origins research, rather than being a primer on any particular topic. As such, it spans broadly -- from analytical chemistry to mathematical models -- and highlights areas of future work that will benefit from a multidisciplinary approach to tackling the mystery of life's origin. Ultimately, we hope to empower a new generation of OoL scientists by reviewing how they can investigate life's origin, rather than dictating how to think about the problem. △ Less

Submitted 24 August, 2023; v1 submitted 22 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Determining Molecular Complexity using Assembly Theory and Spectroscopy

Authors: Michael Jirasek, Abhishek Sharma, Jessica R. Bame, S. Hessam M. Mehr, Nicola Bell, Stuart M. Marshall, Cole Mathis, Alasdair Macleod, Geoffrey J. T. Cooper, Marcel Swart, Rosa Mollfulleda, Leroy Cronin

Abstract: Determining the complexity of molecules has important applications from molecular design to understanding the history of the process that led to the formation of the molecule. Currently, it is not possible to experimentally determine, without full structure elucidation, how complex a molecule is. Assembly Theory has been developed to quantify the complexity of a molecule by finding the shortest pa… ▽ More Determining the complexity of molecules has important applications from molecular design to understanding the history of the process that led to the formation of the molecule. Currently, it is not possible to experimentally determine, without full structure elucidation, how complex a molecule is. Assembly Theory has been developed to quantify the complexity of a molecule by finding the shortest path to construct the molecule from building blocks, revealing its molecular assembly index (MA). In this study, we present an approach to rapidly and exhaustively calculate the MA of molecules from the spectroscopic measurements. We demonstrate that molecular complexity (MA) can be experimentally estimated using three independent techniques: nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS), and infrared spectroscopy (IR), and these give consistent results with good correlations with the theoretically determined values from assembly theory. By identifying and analysing the number of absorbances in IR spectra, carbon resonances in NMR, or molecular fragments in tandem MS, the molecular assembly of an unknown molecule can be reliably estimated from experimental data. This represents the first experimentally quantifiable approach to defining molecular assembly, a reliable metric for complexity, as an intrinsic property of molecules and can also be performed on complex mixtures. This paves the way to use spectroscopic and spectrometric techniques to unambiguously detect alien life in the solar system, and beyond on exoplanets. △ Less

Submitted 7 November, 2023; v1 submitted 24 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Comments: 27 pages, 7 figures plus supplementary data

Community Report from the Biosignatures Standards of Evidence Workshop

Authors: Victoria Meadows, Heather Graham, Victor Abrahamsson, Zach Adam, Elena Amador-French, Giada Arney, Laurie Barge, Erica Barlow, Anamaria Berea, Maitrayee Bose, Dina Bower, Marjorie Chan, Jim Cleaves, Andrea Corpolongo, Miles Currie, Shawn Domagal-Goldman, Chuanfei Dong, Jennifer Eigenbrode, Allison Enright, Thomas J. Fauchez, Martin Fisk, Matthew Fricke, Yuka Fujii, Andrew Gangidine, Eftal Gezer , et al. (50 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: The search for life beyond the Earth is the overarching goal of the NASA Astrobiology Program, and it underpins the science of missions that explore the environments of Solar System planets and exoplanets. However, the detection of extraterrestrial life, in our Solar System and beyond, is sufficiently challenging that it is likely that multiple measurements and approaches, spanning disciplines and… ▽ More The search for life beyond the Earth is the overarching goal of the NASA Astrobiology Program, and it underpins the science of missions that explore the environments of Solar System planets and exoplanets. However, the detection of extraterrestrial life, in our Solar System and beyond, is sufficiently challenging that it is likely that multiple measurements and approaches, spanning disciplines and missions, will be needed to make a convincing claim. Life detection will therefore not be an instantaneous process, and it is unlikely to be unambiguous-yet it is a high-stakes scientific achievement that will garner an enormous amount of public interest. Current and upcoming research efforts and missions aimed at detecting past and extant life could be supported by a consensus framework to plan for, assess and discuss life detection claims (c.f. Green et al., 2021). Such a framework could help increase the robustness of biosignature detection and interpretation, and improve communication with the scientific community and the public. In response to this need, and the call to the community to develop a confidence scale for standards of evidence for biosignature detection (Green et al., 2021), a community-organized workshop was held on July 19-22, 2021. The meeting was designed in a fully virtual (flipped) format. Preparatory materials including readings, instructional videos and activities were made available prior to the workshop, allowing the workshop schedule to be fully dedicated to active community discussion and prompted writing sessions. To maximize global interaction, the discussion components of the workshop were held during business hours in three different time zones, Asia/Pacific, European and US, with daily information hand-off between group organizers. △ Less

Submitted 8 December, 2022; v1 submitted 25 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: 86 pages, 14 figures, workshop report

False positives and the challenge of testing the alien hypothesis

Authors: Searra Foote, Pritvik Sinhadc, Cole Mathis, Sara Imari Walker

Abstract: The origin of life and the detection of alien life have historically been treated as separate scientific research problems. However, they are not strictly independent. Here, we discuss the need for a better integration of the sciences of life detection and origins of life. Framing these dual problems within the formalism of Bayesian hypothesis testing, we show via simple examples how high confiden… ▽ More The origin of life and the detection of alien life have historically been treated as separate scientific research problems. However, they are not strictly independent. Here, we discuss the need for a better integration of the sciences of life detection and origins of life. Framing these dual problems within the formalism of Bayesian hypothesis testing, we show via simple examples how high confidence in life detection claims require either (1) a strong prior hypothesis about the existence of life in a particular alien environment, or conversely, (2) signatures of life that are not susceptible to false positives. As a case study, we discuss the role of priors and hypothesis testing in recent results reporting potential detection of life in the Venusian atmosphere and in the icy plumes of Enceladus. While many current leading biosignature candidates are subject to false positives because they are not definitive of life, our analyses demonstrate why it is necessary to shift focus to candidate signatures that are definitive. This indicates a necessity to develop methods that lack false positives, by using observables for life that rely on prior hypotheses with strong theoretical and empirical support in identifying defining features of life. Abstract theories developed in pursuit of understanding universal features of life are more likely to be definitive and to apply to life-as-we-don't-know-it. In the absence of alien examples these are best validated in origin of life experiments, substantiating the need for better integration between origins of life and biosignature science research communities. △ Less

Submitted 1 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

The Futility of Exoplanet Biosignatures

Authors: Harrison B. Smith, Cole Mathis

Abstract: The ultimate goal of astrobiology is to determine the distribution and diversity of life in the universe. But as the word "biosignature" suggests, what will be detected is not life itself, but an observation implicating a particular process associated with living systems. Technical constraints and our limited access to other worlds suggest we are more likely to detect an out-of-equilibrium suite o… ▽ More The ultimate goal of astrobiology is to determine the distribution and diversity of life in the universe. But as the word "biosignature" suggests, what will be detected is not life itself, but an observation implicating a particular process associated with living systems. Technical constraints and our limited access to other worlds suggest we are more likely to detect an out-of-equilibrium suite of gasses than a writhing octopus. Yet, anything short of a writhing octopus will raise skepticism among astrobiologists about what has been detected. Resolving that skepticism requires a theory to delineate processes due to life and those due solely to abiotic mechanisms. This poses an existential question for the endeavor of life detection: How do astrobiologists plan to detect life via features shared between non-living and living systems? We argue that you cannot without an underlying theory of life. We illustrate this by analyzing the hypothetical detection of an "Earth 2.0" exoplanet. In the absence of a theory of life, we argue the community should focus on identifying unambiguous features of life via four areas of active research: understanding the principles of life on Earth, building life in the lab, detecting life in the solar system and searching for technosignatures. Ultimately, we ask, what exactly do astrobiologists hope to learn by searching for life? △ Less

Submitted 16 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Comments: 15 pages, 2 figures, 1 box

Journal ref: BioEssays (2023)

Utilizing Shannon's Entropy to Create Privacy Aware Architectures

Authors: Abhinav Palia, Rajat Tandon, Carl Mathis

Abstract: Privacy is an individual choice to determine which personal details can be collected, used and shared. Individual consent and transparency are the core tenets for earning customers trust and this motivates the organizations to adopt privacy enhancing practices while creating the systems. The goal of a privacy-aware design is to protect information in a way that does not increase an adversary's exi… ▽ More Privacy is an individual choice to determine which personal details can be collected, used and shared. Individual consent and transparency are the core tenets for earning customers trust and this motivates the organizations to adopt privacy enhancing practices while creating the systems. The goal of a privacy-aware design is to protect information in a way that does not increase an adversary's existing knowledge about an individual beyond what is permissible. This becomes critical when these data elements can be linked with the wealth of auxiliary information available outside the system to identify an individual. Privacy regulations around the world provide directives to protect individual privacy but are generally complex and vague, making their translation into actionable and technical privacy-friendly architectures challenging. In this paper, we utilize Shannon's Entropy to create an objective metric that can help simplify the state-of-the-art Privacy Design Strategies proposed in the literature and aid our key technical design decisions to create privacy aware architectures. △ Less

Submitted 13 September, 2021; v1 submitted 9 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: 8 pages, 1 figure

Individual perception dynamics in drunk games

Authors: Alberto Antonioni, Luis A. Martinez-Vaquero, Cole Mathis, Leto Peel, Massimo Stella

Abstract: We study the effects of individual perceptions of payoffs in two-player games. In particular we consider the setting in which individuals' perceptions of the game are influenced by their previous experiences and outcomes. Accordingly, we introduce a framework based on evolutionary games where individuals have the capacity to perceive their interactions in different ways. Starting from the narrativ… ▽ More We study the effects of individual perceptions of payoffs in two-player games. In particular we consider the setting in which individuals' perceptions of the game are influenced by their previous experiences and outcomes. Accordingly, we introduce a framework based on evolutionary games where individuals have the capacity to perceive their interactions in different ways. Starting from the narrative of social behaviors in a pub as an illustration, we first study the combination of the prisoner's dilemma and harmony game as two alternative perceptions of the same situation. Considering a selection of game pairs, our results show that the interplay between perception dynamics and game payoffs gives rise to non-linear phenomena unexpected in each of the games separately, such as catastrophic phase transitions in the cooperation basin of attraction, Hopf bifurcations and cycles of cooperation and defection. Combining analytical techniques with multi-agent simulations we also show how introducing individual perceptions can cause non-trivial dynamical behaviors to emerge, which cannot be obtained by analyzing the system as a whole. Specifically, initial heterogeneities at the microscopic level can yield a polarization effect that is unpredictable at the macroscopic level. This framework opens the door to the exploration of new ways of understanding the link between the emergence of cooperation and individual preferences and perceptions, with potential applications beyond social interactions. △ Less

Submitted 23 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Comments: 13 pages, 8 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 99, 052311 (2019)

The Emergence of Life as a First Order Phase Transition

Authors: Cole Mathis, Tanmoy Bhattacharya, Sara Imari Walker

Abstract: It is well known that life on Earth alters its environment over evolutionary and geological timescales. An important open question is whether this is a result of evolutionary optimization or a universal feature of life. In the latter case, the origin of life would be coincident with a shift in environmental conditions. Here we present a model for the emergence of life in which replicators are expl… ▽ More It is well known that life on Earth alters its environment over evolutionary and geological timescales. An important open question is whether this is a result of evolutionary optimization or a universal feature of life. In the latter case, the origin of life would be coincident with a shift in environmental conditions. Here we present a model for the emergence of life in which replicators are explicitly coupled to their environment through the recycling of a finite supply of resources. The model exhibits a dynamic, first-order phase transition from non-life to "life," where the life phase is distinguished by selection on replicators. We show that environmental coupling plays an important role in the dynamics of the transition. The transition corresponds to a redistribution of matter in replicators and their environment, driven by selection on replicators, exhibiting an explosive growth in diversity as replicators are selected. The transition is accurately tracked by the mutual information shared between replicators and their environment. In the absence of successfully repartitioning system resources, the transition fails to complete, leading to the possibility of many frustrated trials before life first emerges. Often, the replicators that initiate the transition are not those that are ultimately selected. The results are consistent with the view that life's propensity to shape its environment is indeed a universal feature of replicators, characteristic of the transition from non-life to life. We discuss the implications of these results for understanding life's emergence and evolutionary transitions more broadly. △ Less

Submitted 25 April, 2017; v1 submitted 10 March, 2015; originally announced March 2015.

Horizon effects for surface waves in wave channels and circular jumps

Authors: Gil Jannes, Romain Piquet, Jennifer Chaline, Philippe Maïssa, Christian Mathis, Germain Rousseaux

Abstract: Surface waves in classical fluids experience a rich array of black/white hole horizon effects. The dispersion relation depends on the characteristics of the fluid (in our case, water and silicon oil) as well as on the fluid depth and the wavelength regime. In some cases, it can be tuned to obtain a relativistic regime plus high-frequency dispersive effects. We discuss two types of ongoing analogue… ▽ More Surface waves in classical fluids experience a rich array of black/white hole horizon effects. The dispersion relation depends on the characteristics of the fluid (in our case, water and silicon oil) as well as on the fluid depth and the wavelength regime. In some cases, it can be tuned to obtain a relativistic regime plus high-frequency dispersive effects. We discuss two types of ongoing analogue white-hole experiments: deep water waves propagating against a counter-current in a wave channel and shallow waves on a circular hydraulic jump. △ Less

Submitted 15 February, 2011; originally announced February 2011.

Comments: 4 pages, 2 figs. To appear in: Proceedings of the Spanish Relativity Meeting (ERE2010)

Journal ref: J.Phys.Conf.Ser.314:012031,2011

Experimental demonstration of the supersonic-subsonic bifurcation in the circular jump: A hydrodynamic white hole

Authors: G. Jannes, R. Piquet, P. Maissa, C. Mathis, G. Rousseaux

Abstract: We provide an experimental demonstration that the circular hydraulic jump represents a hydrodynamic white hole or gravitational fountain (the time-reverse of a black hole) by measuring the angle of the Mach cone created by an object in the "supersonic" inner flow region. We emphasise the general character of this gravitational analogy by showing theoretically that the white hole horizon constitute… ▽ More We provide an experimental demonstration that the circular hydraulic jump represents a hydrodynamic white hole or gravitational fountain (the time-reverse of a black hole) by measuring the angle of the Mach cone created by an object in the "supersonic" inner flow region. We emphasise the general character of this gravitational analogy by showing theoretically that the white hole horizon constitutes a stationary and spatial saddle-node bifurcation within dynamical-systems theory. We also demonstrate that the inner region has a "superluminal" dispersion relation, i.e., that the group velocity of the surface waves increases with frequency, and discuss some possible consequences with respect to the robustness of Hawking radiation. Finally, we point out that our experiment shows a concrete example of a possible "transplanckian distortion" of black/white holes. △ Less

Submitted 12 May, 2011; v1 submitted 8 October, 2010; originally announced October 2010.

Comments: 5 pages, 5 figures. New "transplanckian effect" described. Several clarifications, additional figures and references. Published version

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.E83:056312,2011

Horizon effects with surface waves on moving water

Authors: Germain Rousseaux, Philippe Maissa, Christian Mathis, Pierre Coullet, Thomas G. Philbin, Ulf Leonhardt

Abstract: Surface waves on a stationary flow of water are considered, in a linear model that includes the surface tension of the fluid. The resulting gravity-capillary waves experience a rich array of horizon effects when propagating against the flow. In some cases three horizons (points where the group velocity of the wave reverses) exist for waves with a single laboratory frequency. Some of these effects… ▽ More Surface waves on a stationary flow of water are considered, in a linear model that includes the surface tension of the fluid. The resulting gravity-capillary waves experience a rich array of horizon effects when propagating against the flow. In some cases three horizons (points where the group velocity of the wave reverses) exist for waves with a single laboratory frequency. Some of these effects are familiar in fluid mechanics under the name of wave blocking, but other aspects, in particular waves with negative co-moving frequency and the Hawking effect, were overlooked until surface waves were investigated as examples of analogue gravity [Schützhold R and Unruh W G 2002 Phys. Rev. D 66 044019]. A comprehensive presentation of the various horizon effects for gravity-capillary waves is given, with emphasis on the deep water/short wavelength case kh>>1 where many analytical results can be derived. A similarity of the state space of the waves to that of a thermodynamic system is pointed out. △ Less

Submitted 1 October, 2010; v1 submitted 30 April, 2010; originally announced April 2010.

Comments: 30 pages, 15 figures. Minor changes

Journal ref: New J. Phys. 12 (2010) 095018

Observation of negative-frequency waves in a water tank: A classical analogue to the Hawking effect?

Authors: Germain Rousseaux, Christian Mathis, Philippe Maissa, Thomas G. Philbin, Ulf Leonhardt

Abstract: The conversion of positive-frequency waves into negative-frequency waves at the event horizon is the mechanism at the heart of the Hawking radiation of black holes. In black-hole analogues, horizons are formed for waves propagating in a medium against the current when and where the flow exceeds the wave velocity. We report on the first direct observation of negative-frequency waves converted fro… ▽ More The conversion of positive-frequency waves into negative-frequency waves at the event horizon is the mechanism at the heart of the Hawking radiation of black holes. In black-hole analogues, horizons are formed for waves propagating in a medium against the current when and where the flow exceeds the wave velocity. We report on the first direct observation of negative-frequency waves converted from positive-frequency waves in a moving medium. The measured degree of mode conversion is significantly higher than expected from theory. △ Less

Submitted 1 March, 2008; v1 submitted 29 November, 2007; originally announced November 2007.

Journal ref: NewJ.Phys.10:053015,2008