-
Transformers represent belief state geometry in their residual stream
Authors:
Adam S. Shai,
Sarah E. Marzen,
Lucas Teixeira,
Alexander Gietelink Oldenziel,
Paul M. Riechers
Abstract:
What computational structure are we building into large language models when we train them on next-token prediction? Here, we present evidence that this structure is given by the meta-dynamics of belief updating over hidden states of the data-generating process. Leveraging the theory of optimal prediction, we anticipate and then find that belief states are linearly represented in the residual stre…
▽ More
What computational structure are we building into large language models when we train them on next-token prediction? Here, we present evidence that this structure is given by the meta-dynamics of belief updating over hidden states of the data-generating process. Leveraging the theory of optimal prediction, we anticipate and then find that belief states are linearly represented in the residual stream of transformers, even in cases where the predicted belief state geometry has highly nontrivial fractal structure. We investigate cases where the belief state geometry is represented in the final residual stream or distributed across the residual streams of multiple layers, providing a framework to explain these observations. Furthermore we demonstrate that the inferred belief states contain information about the entire future, beyond the local next-token prediction that the transformers are explicitly trained on. Our work provides a framework connecting the structure of training data to the computational structure and representations that transformers use to carry out their behavior.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Complexity-calibrated Benchmarks for Machine Learning Reveal When Next-Generation Reservoir Computer Predictions Succeed and Mislead
Authors:
Sarah E. Marzen,
Paul M. Riechers,
James P. Crutchfield
Abstract:
Recurrent neural networks are used to forecast time series in finance, climate, language, and from many other domains. Reservoir computers are a particularly easily trainable form of recurrent neural network. Recently, a "next-generation" reservoir computer was introduced in which the memory trace involves only a finite number of previous symbols. We explore the inherent limitations of finite-past…
▽ More
Recurrent neural networks are used to forecast time series in finance, climate, language, and from many other domains. Reservoir computers are a particularly easily trainable form of recurrent neural network. Recently, a "next-generation" reservoir computer was introduced in which the memory trace involves only a finite number of previous symbols. We explore the inherent limitations of finite-past memory traces in this intriguing proposal. A lower bound from Fano's inequality shows that, on highly non-Markovian processes generated by large probabilistic state machines, next-generation reservoir computers with reasonably long memory traces have an error probability that is at least ~ 60% higher than the minimal attainable error probability in predicting the next observation. More generally, it appears that popular recurrent neural networks fall far short of optimally predicting such complex processes. These results highlight the need for a new generation of optimized recurrent neural network architectures. Alongside this finding, we present concentration-of-measure results for randomly-generated but complex processes. One conclusion is that large probabilistic state machines -- specifically, large $ε$-machines -- are key to generating challenging and structurally-unbiased stimuli for ground-truthing recurrent neural network architectures.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Inference, Prediction, and Entropy-Rate Estimation of Continuous-time, Discrete-event Processes
Authors:
S. E. Marzen,
J. P. Crutchfield
Abstract:
Inferring models, predicting the future, and estimating the entropy rate of discrete-time, discrete-event processes is well-worn ground. However, a much broader class of discrete-event processes operates in continuous-time. Here, we provide new methods for inferring, predicting, and estimating them. The methods rely on an extension of Bayesian structural inference that takes advantage of neural ne…
▽ More
Inferring models, predicting the future, and estimating the entropy rate of discrete-time, discrete-event processes is well-worn ground. However, a much broader class of discrete-event processes operates in continuous-time. Here, we provide new methods for inferring, predicting, and estimating them. The methods rely on an extension of Bayesian structural inference that takes advantage of neural network's universal approximation power. Based on experiments with complex synthetic data, the methods are competitive with the state-of-the-art for prediction and entropy-rate estimation.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Probabilistic Deterministic Finite Automata and Recurrent Networks, Revisited
Authors:
S. E. Marzen,
J. P. Crutchfield
Abstract:
Reservoir computers (RCs) and recurrent neural networks (RNNs) can mimic any finite-state automaton in theory, and some workers demonstrated that this can hold in practice. We test the capability of generalized linear models, RCs, and Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) RNN architectures to predict the stochastic processes generated by a large suite of probabilistic deterministic finite-state automata (…
▽ More
Reservoir computers (RCs) and recurrent neural networks (RNNs) can mimic any finite-state automaton in theory, and some workers demonstrated that this can hold in practice. We test the capability of generalized linear models, RCs, and Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) RNN architectures to predict the stochastic processes generated by a large suite of probabilistic deterministic finite-state automata (PDFA). PDFAs provide an excellent performance benchmark in that they can be systematically enumerated, the randomness and correlation structure of their generated processes are exactly known, and their optimal memory-limited predictors are easily computed. Unsurprisingly, LSTMs outperform RCs, which outperform generalized linear models. Surprisingly, each of these methods can fall short of the maximal predictive accuracy by as much as 50% after training and, when optimized, tend to fall short of the maximal predictive accuracy by ~5%, even though previously available methods achieve maximal predictive accuracy with orders-of-magnitude less data. Thus, despite the representational universality of RCs and RNNs, using them can engender a surprising predictive gap for simple stimuli. One concludes that there is an important and underappreciated role for methods that infer "causal states" or "predictive state representations".
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Optimized Bacteria are Environmental Prediction Engines
Authors:
Sarah E. Marzen,
James P. Crutchfield
Abstract:
Experimentalists have observed phenotypic variability in isogenic bacteria populations. We explore the hypothesis that in fluctuating environments this variability is tuned to maximize a bacterium's expected log growth rate, potentially aided by epigenetic markers that store information about past environments. We show that, in a complex, memoryful environment, the maximal expected log growth rate…
▽ More
Experimentalists have observed phenotypic variability in isogenic bacteria populations. We explore the hypothesis that in fluctuating environments this variability is tuned to maximize a bacterium's expected log growth rate, potentially aided by epigenetic markers that store information about past environments. We show that, in a complex, memoryful environment, the maximal expected log growth rate is linear in the instantaneous predictive information---the mutual information between a bacterium's epigenetic markers and future environmental states. Hence, under resource constraints, optimal epigenetic markers are causal states---the minimal sufficient statistics for prediction. This is the minimal amount of information about the past needed to predict the future as well as possible. We suggest new theoretical investigations into and new experiments on bacteria phenotypic bet-hedging in fluctuating complex environments.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Prediction and Power in Molecular Sensors: Uncertainty and Dissipation When Conditionally Markovian Channels Are Driven by Semi-Markov Environments
Authors:
Sarah E. Marzen,
James P. Crutchfield
Abstract:
Sensors often serve at least two purposes: predicting their input and minimizing dissipated heat. However, determining whether or not a particular sensor is evolved or designed to be accurate and efficient is difficult. This arises partly from the functional constraints being at cross purposes and partly since quantifying the predictive performance of even in silico sensors can require prohibitive…
▽ More
Sensors often serve at least two purposes: predicting their input and minimizing dissipated heat. However, determining whether or not a particular sensor is evolved or designed to be accurate and efficient is difficult. This arises partly from the functional constraints being at cross purposes and partly since quantifying the predictive performance of even in silico sensors can require prohibitively long simulations. To circumvent these difficulties, we develop expressions for the predictive accuracy and thermodynamic costs of the broad class of conditionally Markovian sensors subject to unifilar hidden semi-Markov (memoryful) environmental inputs. Predictive metrics include the instantaneous memory and the mutual information between present sensor state and input future, while dissipative metrics include power consumption and the nonpredictive information rate. Success in deriving these formulae relies heavily on identifying the environment's causal states, the input's minimal sufficient statistics for prediction. Using these formulae, we study the simplest nontrivial biological sensor model---that of a Hill molecule, characterized by the number of ligands that bind simultaneously, the sensor's cooperativity. When energetic rewards are proportional to total predictable information, the closest cooperativity that optimizes the total energy budget generally depends on the environment's past hysteretically. In this way, the sensor gains robustness to environmental fluctuations. Given the simplicity of the Hill molecule, such hysteresis will likely be found in more complex predictive sensors as well. That is, adaptations that only locally optimize biochemical parameters for prediction and dissipation can lead to sensors that "remember" the past environment.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Structure and Randomness of Continuous-Time Discrete-Event Processes
Authors:
S. E. Marzen,
J. P. Crutchfield
Abstract:
Loosely speaking, the Shannon entropy rate is used to gauge a stochastic process' intrinsic randomness; the statistical complexity gives the cost of predicting the process. We calculate, for the first time, the entropy rate and statistical complexity of stochastic processes generated by finite unifilar hidden semi-Markov models---memoryful, state-dependent versions of renewal processes. Calculatin…
▽ More
Loosely speaking, the Shannon entropy rate is used to gauge a stochastic process' intrinsic randomness; the statistical complexity gives the cost of predicting the process. We calculate, for the first time, the entropy rate and statistical complexity of stochastic processes generated by finite unifilar hidden semi-Markov models---memoryful, state-dependent versions of renewal processes. Calculating these quantities requires introducing novel mathematical objects (ε-machines of hidden semi-Markov processes) and new information-theoretic methods to stochastic processes.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Nearly Maximally Predictive Features and Their Dimensions
Authors:
Sarah E. Marzen,
James P. Crutchfield
Abstract:
Scientific explanation often requires inferring maximally predictive features from a given data set. Unfortunately, the collection of minimal maximally predictive features for most stochastic processes is uncountably infinite. In such cases, one compromises and instead seeks nearly maximally predictive features. Here, we derive upper-bounds on the rates at which the number and the coding cost of n…
▽ More
Scientific explanation often requires inferring maximally predictive features from a given data set. Unfortunately, the collection of minimal maximally predictive features for most stochastic processes is uncountably infinite. In such cases, one compromises and instead seeks nearly maximally predictive features. Here, we derive upper-bounds on the rates at which the number and the coding cost of nearly maximally predictive features scales with desired predictive power. The rates are determined by the fractal dimensions of a process' mixed-state distribution. These results, in turn, show how widely-used finite-order Markov models can fail as predictors and that mixed-state predictive features offer a substantial improvement.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Informational and Causal Architecture of Continuous-time Renewal and Hidden Semi-Markov Processes
Authors:
Sarah E. Marzen,
James P. Crutchfield
Abstract:
We introduce the minimal maximally predictive models (ε-machines) of processes generated by certain hidden semi-Markov models. Their causal states are either hybrid discrete-continuous or continuous random variables and causal-state transitions are described by partial differential equations. Closed-form expressions are given for statistical complexities, excess entropies, and differential informa…
▽ More
We introduce the minimal maximally predictive models (ε-machines) of processes generated by certain hidden semi-Markov models. Their causal states are either hybrid discrete-continuous or continuous random variables and causal-state transitions are described by partial differential equations. Closed-form expressions are given for statistical complexities, excess entropies, and differential information anatomy rates. We present a complete analysis of the ε-machines of continuous-time renewal processes and, then, extend this to processes generated by unifilar hidden semi-Markov models and semi-Markov models. Our information-theoretic analysis leads to new expressions for the entropy rate and the rates of related information measures for these very general continuous-time process classes.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Statistical Signatures of Structural Organization: The case of long memory in renewal processes
Authors:
Sarah E. Marzen,
James P. Crutchfield
Abstract:
Identifying and quantifying memory are often critical steps in develo** a mechanistic understanding of stochastic processes. These are particularly challenging and necessary when exploring processes that exhibit long-range correlations. The most common signatures employed rely on second-order temporal statistics and lead, for example, to identifying long memory in processes with power-law autoco…
▽ More
Identifying and quantifying memory are often critical steps in develo** a mechanistic understanding of stochastic processes. These are particularly challenging and necessary when exploring processes that exhibit long-range correlations. The most common signatures employed rely on second-order temporal statistics and lead, for example, to identifying long memory in processes with power-law autocorrelation function and Hurst exponent greater than $1/2$. However, most stochastic processes hide their memory in higher-order temporal correlations. Information measures---specifically, divergences in the mutual information between a process' past and future (excess entropy) and minimal predictive memory stored in a process' causal states (statistical complexity)---provide a different way to identify long memory in processes with higher-order temporal correlations. However, there are no ergodic stationary processes with infinite excess entropy for which information measures have been compared to autocorrelation functions and Hurst exponents. Here, we show that fractal renewal processes---those with interevent distribution tails $\propto t^{-α}$---exhibit long memory via a phase transition at $α= 1$. Excess entropy diverges only there and statistical complexity diverges there and for all $α< 1$. When these processes do have power-law autocorrelation function and Hurst exponent greater than $1/2$, they do not have divergent excess entropy. This analysis breaks the intuitive association between these different quantifications of memory. We hope that the methods used here, based on causal states, provide some guide as to how to construct and analyze other long memory processes.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
The evolution of lossy compression
Authors:
Sarah E. Marzen,
Simon DeDeo
Abstract:
In complex environments, there are costs to both ignorance and perception. An organism needs to track fitness-relevant information about its world, but the more information it tracks, the more resources it must devote to memory and processing. Rate-distortion theory shows that, when errors are allowed, remarkably efficient internal representations can be found by biologically-plausible hill-climbi…
▽ More
In complex environments, there are costs to both ignorance and perception. An organism needs to track fitness-relevant information about its world, but the more information it tracks, the more resources it must devote to memory and processing. Rate-distortion theory shows that, when errors are allowed, remarkably efficient internal representations can be found by biologically-plausible hill-climbing mechanisms. We identify two regimes: a high-fidelity regime where perceptual costs scale logarithmically with environmental complexity, and a low-fidelity regime where perceptual costs are, remarkably, independent of the environment. When environmental complexity is rising, Darwinian evolution should drive organisms to the threshold between the high- and low-fidelity regimes. Organisms that code efficiently will find themselves able to make, just barely, the most subtle distinctions in their environment.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Time Resolution Dependence of Information Measures for Spiking Neurons: Atoms, Scaling, and Universality
Authors:
Sarah E. Marzen,
Michael R. DeWeese,
James P. Crutchfield
Abstract:
The mutual information between stimulus and spike-train response is commonly used to monitor neural coding efficiency, but neuronal computation broadly conceived requires more refined and targeted information measures of input-output joint processes. A first step towards that larger goal is to develop information measures for individual output processes, including information generation (entropy r…
▽ More
The mutual information between stimulus and spike-train response is commonly used to monitor neural coding efficiency, but neuronal computation broadly conceived requires more refined and targeted information measures of input-output joint processes. A first step towards that larger goal is to develop information measures for individual output processes, including information generation (entropy rate), stored information (statistical complexity), predictable information (excess entropy), and active information accumulation (bound information rate). We calculate these for spike trains generated by a variety of noise-driven integrate-and-fire neurons as a function of time resolution and for alternating renewal processes. We show that their time-resolution dependence reveals coarse-grained structural properties of interspike interval statistics; e.g., $τ$-entropy rates that diverge less quickly than the firing rate indicate interspike interval correlations. We also find evidence that the excess entropy and regularized statistical complexity of different types of integrate-and-fire neurons are universal in the continuous-time limit in the sense that they do not depend on mechanism details. This suggests a surprising simplicity in the spike trains generated by these model neurons. Interestingly, neurons with gamma-distributed ISIs and neurons whose spike trains are alternating renewal processes do not fall into the same universality class. These results lead to two conclusions. First, the dependence of information measures on time resolution reveals mechanistic details about spike train generation. Second, information measures can be used as model selection tools for analyzing spike train processes.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
