-
Interpreting the Value of Flexibility in AC Security-Constrained Transmission Expansion Planning via a Cooperative Game Framework
Authors:
Andrey Churkin,
Wangwei Kong,
Mohammad Iman Alizadeh,
Florin Capitanescu,
Pierluigi Mancarella,
Eduardo A. Martínez Ceseña
Abstract:
Security-constrained transmission expansion planning (SCTEP) is an inherently complex problem that requires simultaneously solving multiple contingency states of the system (usually corresponding to N-1 security criterion). Existing studies focus on effectively finding optimal solutions; however, single optimal solutions are not sufficient to interpret the value of flexibility (e.g., from energy s…
▽ More
Security-constrained transmission expansion planning (SCTEP) is an inherently complex problem that requires simultaneously solving multiple contingency states of the system (usually corresponding to N-1 security criterion). Existing studies focus on effectively finding optimal solutions; however, single optimal solutions are not sufficient to interpret the value of flexibility (e.g., from energy storage systems) and support system planners in well-informed decision making. In view of planning uncertainties, it is necessary to estimate the contributions of flexibility to various objectives and prioritise the most effective investments. In this regard, this work introduces a SCTEP tool that enables interpreting the value of flexibility in terms of contributions to avoided load curtailment and total expected system cost reduction. Inspired by cooperative game theory, the tool ranks the contributions of flexibility providers and compares them against traditional line reinforcements. This information can be used by system planners to prioritise investments with higher contributions and synergistic capabilities.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2024; v1 submitted 5 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Impacts of Distribution Network Reconfiguration on Aggregated DER Flexibility
Authors:
Andrey Churkin,
Miguel Sanchez-Lopez,
Mohammad Iman Alizadeh,
Florin Capitanescu,
Eduardo A. Martínez Ceseña,
Pierluigi Mancarella
Abstract:
The ongoing integration of controllable distributed energy resources (DER) makes distribution networks capable of aggregating flexible power and providing flexibility services at both transmission and distribution levels. The aggregated flexibility of an active distribution network (ADN) can be represented as its feasible operating area in the P-Q space. The limits of this area are pivotal for arr…
▽ More
The ongoing integration of controllable distributed energy resources (DER) makes distribution networks capable of aggregating flexible power and providing flexibility services at both transmission and distribution levels. The aggregated flexibility of an active distribution network (ADN) can be represented as its feasible operating area in the P-Q space. The limits of this area are pivotal for arranging flexibility markets and coordinating transmission and distribution system operators (TSOs and DSOs). However, motivated by the current technical limitations of distribution networks (e.g., protection schemes), existing literature on ADN flexibility and TSO-DSO coordination mostly focuses on radial networks, overlooking the potential benefits of network reconfiguration. This paper, using a realistic meshed distribution system from the UK and the exact ACOPF model for flexibility estimation, demonstrates that network reconfiguration can increase the limits of ADN aggregated flexibility and improve the economic efficiency of flexibility markets.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Tracing, Ranking and Valuation of Aggregated DER Flexibility in Active Distribution Networks
Authors:
Andrey Churkin,
Wangwei Kong,
Jose N. Melchor Gutierrez,
Eduardo A. Martínez Ceseña,
Pierluigi Mancarella
Abstract:
The integration of distributed energy resources (DER) makes active distribution networks (ADNs) natural providers of flexibility services. However, the optimal operation of flexible units in ADNs is highly complex, which poses challenges for distribution system operators (DSOs) in aggregating DER flexibility. For example, to maximise the provision of services, flexible units must be strongly coord…
▽ More
The integration of distributed energy resources (DER) makes active distribution networks (ADNs) natural providers of flexibility services. However, the optimal operation of flexible units in ADNs is highly complex, which poses challenges for distribution system operators (DSOs) in aggregating DER flexibility. For example, to maximise the provision of services, flexible units must be strongly coordinated to manage network constraints, e.g., perform power swaps. Furthermore, due to the nonlinearities of aggregated DER flexibility provision, some units may need to rapidly change their outputs to enable the services. To address these challenges, this paper brings together exact AC optimal power flow (OPF) models and a cooperative game formulation and presents a new framework for tracing, ranking, and valuation of aggregated DER flexibility in ADNs. Extensive tests and simulations performed for the 33-bus radial distribution network demonstrate that the framework enables translating complex DER interactions into useful information for DSOs by ranking the criticality of flexible units and performing flexibility valuation based on its cost or economic surplus. Additionally, the framework proposes no-swap constraints and a nonlinearity metric which can be used by DSOs to identify unreliable operating regions with power swaps or rapid changes in flexible unit dispatch.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2023; v1 submitted 7 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Assessing Active Distribution Network Flexibility: On the Effects of Nonlinearities and Nonconvexities
Authors:
Andrey Churkin,
Pierluigi Mancarella,
Eduardo A. Martinez Cesena
Abstract:
A widespread approach to characterise the aggregated flexibility of active distribution networks (ADNs) is to estimate the boundary of the feasible network operating areas using convex polygons in the P-Q space. However, such approximations can be inaccurate under realistic conditions where, for example, the nonlinear nature of the network is captured, and the behaviour of flexible units is constr…
▽ More
A widespread approach to characterise the aggregated flexibility of active distribution networks (ADNs) is to estimate the boundary of the feasible network operating areas using convex polygons in the P-Q space. However, such approximations can be inaccurate under realistic conditions where, for example, the nonlinear nature of the network is captured, and the behaviour of flexible units is constrained. This letter demonstrates, using a small ADN example with four flexible units and considering only nonlinearities from the network, that reaching the full P-Q flexibility areas would require perfect coordination of units and high ram** rates. Without these requirements, the P-Q areas become nonconvex. Thus, if the effects of nonlinearities and nonconvexities are ignored, existing approaches in the literature can result in overestimation of ADN flexibility and give rise to impractical solutions, hampering coordination between transmission and distribution system operators.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Towards Optimal Integrated Planning of Electricity and Hydrogen Infrastructure for Large-Scale Renewable Energy Transport
Authors:
Sleiman Mhanna,
Isam Saedi,
Guanchi Liu,
Pierluigi Mancarella
Abstract:
The imminent advent of large-scale green hydrogen (H2) production raises the central question of which of the two options, transporting "green" molecules, or transporting "green" electrons, is the most cost-effective one. This paper proposes a first-of-its-kind mathematical framework for the optimal integrated planning of electricity and H2 infrastructure for transporting large-scale variable rene…
▽ More
The imminent advent of large-scale green hydrogen (H2) production raises the central question of which of the two options, transporting "green" molecules, or transporting "green" electrons, is the most cost-effective one. This paper proposes a first-of-its-kind mathematical framework for the optimal integrated planning of electricity and H2 infrastructure for transporting large-scale variable renewable energy (VRE). In contrast to most existing works, this work incorporates essential nonlinearities such as voltage drops due to losses in high-voltage alternating current (HVAC) and high-voltage direct current (HVDC) transmission lines, losses in HVDC converter stations, reactive power flow, pressure drops in pipelines, and linepack, all of which play an important role in determining the optimal infrastructure investment decision. Capturing these nonlinearities requires casting the problem as a nonconvex mixed-integer nonlinear program (MINLP), whose complexity is further exacerbated by its large size due to the relatively high temporal resolution of RES forecasts. This work then leverages recent advancements in convex relaxations to instead solve a tractable alternative in the form of a mixed-integer quadratically constrained programming (MIQCP) problem. The impact of other fundamental factors such as transmission distance and RES capacity is also thoroughly analysed on a canonical two-node system. The integrated planning model is then demonstrated on a real-world case study involving renewable energy zones in Australia.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2022; v1 submitted 7 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Assessing Distribution Network Flexibility via Reliability-based P-Q Area Segmentation
Authors:
Andrey Churkin,
Wangwei Kong,
Jose N. Melchor Gutierrez,
Pierluigi Mancarella,
Eduardo A. Martinez Cesena
Abstract:
This paper proposes a framework to assess the flexibility of active distribution networks (ADNs) via P-Q area segmentation, considering the reliability of flexible units (FUs). A mixed-integer quadratically constrained programming (MIQCP) model is formulated to analyse flexible active and reactive power support at the interface with transmission networks, explicitly capturing the contributions and…
▽ More
This paper proposes a framework to assess the flexibility of active distribution networks (ADNs) via P-Q area segmentation, considering the reliability of flexible units (FUs). A mixed-integer quadratically constrained programming (MIQCP) model is formulated to analyse flexible active and reactive power support at the interface with transmission networks, explicitly capturing the contributions and reliability of FUs that provide flexibility services within an ADN. The numerical simulations performed for a real 124-bus UK distribution network demonstrate the optimal flexibility provision by different FUs, as well as the corresponding reliability and the impact of network reconfiguration. Distribution system operators (DSOs) can use the proposed framework to identify critical units, select an adequate combination of flexibility volumes, and manage its reliability.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2023; v1 submitted 3 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Modelling and Characterisation of Flexibility\\from Distributed Energy Resources
Authors:
Shariq Riaz,
Pierluigi Mancarella
Abstract:
Harnessing flexibility from distributed energy resources (DER) to participate in various markets while accounting for relevant technical and commercial constraints is essential for the development of low-carbon grids. However, there is no clear definition or even description of the salient features of aggregated DER flexibility, including its steady-state and dynamic features and how these are imp…
▽ More
Harnessing flexibility from distributed energy resources (DER) to participate in various markets while accounting for relevant technical and commercial constraints is essential for the development of low-carbon grids. However, there is no clear definition or even description of the salient features of aggregated DER flexibility, including its steady-state and dynamic features and how these are impacted by network constraints and market requirements. This paper proposes a comprehensive DER flexibility modelling and characterisation framework that is based on the concept of nodal operating envelope (NOE). In particular, capacity, ramp, duration and cost are identified as key flexibility metrics and associated with different but consistent NOEs describing capability, feasibility, ramp, duration, economic, technical and commercial flexibility features. These NOEs, which conceptually arise from a Venn diagram, can be built via optimal power flow (OPF) analysis, visualised in the active-reactive power space, and used by different stakeholders. Results from a canonical test system and a real distribution system illustrate the value and applicability of the proposed framework to model and characterise provision of flexibility and market services from DER for different use cases.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Iterative LP-based Methods for the Multiperiod Optimal Electricity and Gas Flow Problem
Authors:
Sleiman Mhanna,
Isam Saedi,
Pierluigi Mancarella
Abstract:
In light of the increasing coupling between electricity and gas networks, this paper introduces two novel iterative methods for efficiently solving the multiperiod optimal electricity and gas flow (MOEGF) problem. The first is an iterative MILP-based method and the second is an iterative LP-based method with an elaborate procedure for ensuring an integral solution. The convergence of the two appro…
▽ More
In light of the increasing coupling between electricity and gas networks, this paper introduces two novel iterative methods for efficiently solving the multiperiod optimal electricity and gas flow (MOEGF) problem. The first is an iterative MILP-based method and the second is an iterative LP-based method with an elaborate procedure for ensuring an integral solution. The convergence of the two approaches is founded on two key features. The first is a penalty term with a single, automatically tuned, parameter for controlling the step size of the gas network iterates. The second is a sequence of supporting hyperplanes together with an increasing number of carefully constructed halfspaces for controlling the convergence of the electricity network iterates. Moreover, the two proposed algorithms use as a warm start the solution from a novel polyhedral relaxation of the MOEGF problem, for a noticeable improvement in computation time as compared to a cold start. Unlike the first method, which invokes a branch-and-bound algorithm to find an integral solution, the second method implements an elaborate steering procedure that guides the continuous variables to take integral values at the solution. Numerical evaluation demonstrates that the two proposed methods can converge to high-quality feasible solutions in computation times at least two orders of magnitude faster than both a state-of-the-art nonlinear branch-and-bound (NLBB) MINLP solver and a mixed-integer convex programming (MICP) relaxation of the MOEGF problem. The experimental setup consists of five test cases, three of which involve the real electricity and gas transmission networks of the state of Victoria with actual linepack and demand profiles.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Online Security Assessment of Low-Inertia Power Systems: A Real-Time Frequency Stability Tool for the Australian South-West Interconnected System
Authors:
Alireza Fereidouni,
Julius Susanto,
Pierluigi Mancarella,
Nicky Hong,
Teresa Smit,
Dean Sharafi
Abstract:
In small/medium-sized isolated power networks with low rotational inertia and high penetration of renewables, generation/load contingency events may cause large frequency excursions, potentially leading to cascading failures and even blackouts. Therefore, it is crucial for system operators to be able to monitor the state of the network in real-time and predict the maximum possible frequency deviat…
▽ More
In small/medium-sized isolated power networks with low rotational inertia and high penetration of renewables, generation/load contingency events may cause large frequency excursions, potentially leading to cascading failures and even blackouts. Therefore, it is crucial for system operators to be able to monitor the state of the network in real-time and predict the maximum possible frequency deviations at all times.
This paper presents a real-time frequency stability (RTFS) tool developed by the Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) and operationalized in the control room for the South West Interconnected System (SWIS) to ensure that the available spinning reserve is sufficient and fast enough to arrest frequency excursions under any conditions, and particularly low-inertia ones. To reduce the computational burden and complexity of the different turbine-governor models, a simple first-order lag function with two adjustable variables has been used for each of the generator. These adjustable parameters, along with other key model parameters such as load dam** and inertia, have been calibrated against actual frequency response using high-speed fault recorder data from historical events. As demonstrated in several case studies, the real-time tool has proven to be accurate at predicting the trajectory of system frequency after credible contingencies, thus suggesting that similar implementations could be carried out elsewhere while power systems worldwide progress towards lower inertia.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Closed-Form Solutions for a Low-Order System Fast Frequency Response Model
Authors:
Julius Susanto,
Alireza Fereidouni,
Pierluigi Mancarella,
Dean Sharafi
Abstract:
This paper presents a novel closed-form solution for a low-order system frequency response (SFR) model that is accurate for all time periods and an accompanying approximation for representing primary frequency responses at two different speeds while still maintaining mathematical tractability. This allows for the inclusion of both fast frequency responses (e.g. from battery energy storage systems)…
▽ More
This paper presents a novel closed-form solution for a low-order system frequency response (SFR) model that is accurate for all time periods and an accompanying approximation for representing primary frequency responses at two different speeds while still maintaining mathematical tractability. This allows for the inclusion of both fast frequency responses (e.g. from battery energy storage systems) and more conventional responses (e.g. from thermal generation) in a single SFR formulation. The closed-form expressions can be efficiently used in applications that use the SFR model such as frequency stability studies and security-constrained unit commitment (SCUC) studies.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
On Feasibility and Flexibility Operating Regions of Virtual Power Plants and TSO/DSO interfaces
Authors:
Shariq Riaz,
Pierluigi Mancarella
Abstract:
Distributed energy resources are an ideal candidate for the provision of additional flexibility required by power system to support the increasing penetration of renewable energy sources. The integrating large number of resources in the existing market structure, particularly in the light of providing flexibility services, is envisioned through the concept of virtual power plant (VPP). To this end…
▽ More
Distributed energy resources are an ideal candidate for the provision of additional flexibility required by power system to support the increasing penetration of renewable energy sources. The integrating large number of resources in the existing market structure, particularly in the light of providing flexibility services, is envisioned through the concept of virtual power plant (VPP). To this end, it is crucial to establish a clear methodology for VPP flexibility modelling. In this context, this paper first puts forward the need to clarify the difference between feasibility and flexibility potential of a VPP, and then propose a methodology for the evaluation of relevant operating regions. Similar concepts can also be used to modelling TSO/DSO interface operation. Several case studies are designed to reflect the distinct information conveyed by feasibility and flexibility operating regions in the presence of "slow" and "fast" responding resources for a VPP partaking in provision of energy and grid support services. The results also highlight the impact of flexible load and importantly network topology on the VPP feasibility (FOR) and flexibility (FXOR) operating regions.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Using Mobile Phone Data for Electricity Infrastructure Planning
Authors:
Eduardo Alejandro Martinez-Cesena,
Pierluigi Mancarella,
Mamadou Ndiaye,
Markus Schläpfer
Abstract:
Detailed knowledge of the energy needs at relatively high spatial and temporal resolution is crucial for the electricity infrastructure planning of a region. However, such information is typically limited by the scarcity of data on human activities, in particular in develo** countries where electrification of rural areas is sought. The analysis of society-wide mobile phone records has recently p…
▽ More
Detailed knowledge of the energy needs at relatively high spatial and temporal resolution is crucial for the electricity infrastructure planning of a region. However, such information is typically limited by the scarcity of data on human activities, in particular in develo** countries where electrification of rural areas is sought. The analysis of society-wide mobile phone records has recently proven to offer unprecedented insights into the spatio-temporal distribution of people, but this information has never been used to support electrification planning strategies anywhere and for rural areas in develo** countries in particular. The aim of this project is the assessment of the contribution of mobile phone data for the development of bottom-up energy demand models, in order to enhance energy planning studies and existing electrification practices. More specifically, this work introduces a framework that combines mobile phone data analysis, socioeconomic and geo-referenced data analysis, and state-of-the-art energy infrastructure engineering techniques to assess the techno-economic feasibility of different centralized and decentralized electrification options for rural areas in a develo** country. Specific electrification options considered include extensions of the existing medium voltage (MV) grid, diesel engine-based community-level Microgrids, and individual household-level solar photovoltaic (PV) systems. The framework and relevant methodology are demonstrated throughout the paper using the case of Senegal and the mobile phone data made available for the 'D4D-Senegal' innovation challenge. The results are extremely encouraging and highlight the potential of mobile phone data to support more efficient and economically attractive electrification plans.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Probabilistic Modeling and Simulation of Transmission Line Temperatures under Fluctuating Power Flows
Authors:
Markus Schläpfer,
Pierluigi Mancarella
Abstract:
Increasing shares of fluctuating renewable energy sources induce higher and higher power flow variability at the transmission level. The question arises as to what extent existing networks can absorb additional fluctuating power injection without exceeding thermal limits. At the same time, the resulting power flow characteristics call for revisiting classical approaches to line temperature predict…
▽ More
Increasing shares of fluctuating renewable energy sources induce higher and higher power flow variability at the transmission level. The question arises as to what extent existing networks can absorb additional fluctuating power injection without exceeding thermal limits. At the same time, the resulting power flow characteristics call for revisiting classical approaches to line temperature prediction. This paper presents a probabilistic modeling and simulation methodology for estimating the occurrence of critical line temperatures in the presence of fluctuating power flows. Cumbersome integration of the dynamic thermal equations at each Monte Carlo simulation trial is sped up by a specific algorithm that makes use of a variance reduction technique adapted from the telecommunications field. The substantial reduction in computational time allows estimations closer to real time, relevant to short-term operational assessments. A case study performed on a single line model provides fundamental insights into the probability of hitting critical line temperatures under given power flow fluctuations. A transmission system application shows how the proposed method can be used for a fast yet accurate operational assessment.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
Computational Logic Foundations of KGP Agents
Authors:
Antonis Kakas,
Paolo Mancarella,
Fariba Sadri,
Kostas Stathis,
Francesca Toni
Abstract:
This paper presents the computational logic foundations of a model of agency called the KGP (Knowledge, Goals and Plan model. This model allows the specification of heterogeneous agents that can interact with each other, and can exhibit both proactive and reactive behaviour allowing them to function in dynamic environments by adjusting their goals and plans when changes happen in such environments…
▽ More
This paper presents the computational logic foundations of a model of agency called the KGP (Knowledge, Goals and Plan model. This model allows the specification of heterogeneous agents that can interact with each other, and can exhibit both proactive and reactive behaviour allowing them to function in dynamic environments by adjusting their goals and plans when changes happen in such environments. KGP provides a highly modular agent architecture that integrates a collection of reasoning and physical capabilities, synthesised within transitions that update the agents state in response to reasoning, sensing and acting. Transitions are orchestrated by cycle theories that specify the order in which transitions are executed while taking into account the dynamic context and agent preferences, as well as selection operators for providing inputs to transitions.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
The CIFF Proof Procedure for Abductive Logic Programming with Constraints: Theory, Implementation and Experiments
Authors:
P. Mancarella,
G. Terreni,
F. Sadri,
F. Toni,
U. Endriss
Abstract:
We present the CIFF proof procedure for abductive logic programming with constraints, and we prove its correctness. CIFF is an extension of the IFF proof procedure for abductive logic programming, relaxing the original restrictions over variable quantification (allowedness conditions) and incorporating a constraint solver to deal with numerical constraints as in constraint logic programming. Fin…
▽ More
We present the CIFF proof procedure for abductive logic programming with constraints, and we prove its correctness. CIFF is an extension of the IFF proof procedure for abductive logic programming, relaxing the original restrictions over variable quantification (allowedness conditions) and incorporating a constraint solver to deal with numerical constraints as in constraint logic programming. Finally, we describe the CIFF system, comparing it with state of the art abductive systems and answer set solvers and showing how to use it to program some applications. (To appear in Theory and Practice of Logic Programming - TPLP).
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2009;
originally announced June 2009.
