-
Validation methodologies for turbulent variable density flows: A jet case study
Authors:
Austin Davis,
Samuel Jones,
John J. Charonko,
Chris M. Malone,
Katherine Prestridge
Abstract:
Comparisons studies between simulated variable density turbulent flows often consist of direct graphical representations where the level of agreement is determined by eye. This work demonstrates a formal validation methodology using an existing validation framework to examine the agreement between a simulated variable density jet flow and corresponding experimental data. Implicit large eddy simula…
▽ More
Comparisons studies between simulated variable density turbulent flows often consist of direct graphical representations where the level of agreement is determined by eye. This work demonstrates a formal validation methodology using an existing validation framework to examine the agreement between a simulated variable density jet flow and corresponding experimental data. Implicit large eddy simulations (ILES's) of a round jet and a plane jet with density ratio $s = 4.2$ were simulated using the compressible hydrodynamic code xRAGE. The jet growth, characterized by the spreading rates, was compared, and the difference between the simulations and the experiment was examined through jet structure diagnostics. The spreading rates were found to be larger than the experimental values, primarily due to resolution issues in the simulations, a fact that is quantified by the validation metric analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Multimaterial Heat Flow Verification
Authors:
Robert L Singleton Jr,
Christopher M Malone,
Cora L Brown
Abstract:
Multimaterial heat diffusion can be a challenging numerical problem when the material boundaries are misaligned with the numerical grid. Even when the boundaries start out aligned, they typically become misaligned through hydrodynamic motion. There are usually a number of methods for handling multimaterial cells in any given hydro code. One of the simplest methods is to replace the multimaterial c…
▽ More
Multimaterial heat diffusion can be a challenging numerical problem when the material boundaries are misaligned with the numerical grid. Even when the boundaries start out aligned, they typically become misaligned through hydrodynamic motion. There are usually a number of methods for handling multimaterial cells in any given hydro code. One of the simplest methods is to replace the multimaterial cell by an average single-material cell whose heat capacity and conductivity are averages over the constituent materials. One can further refine this model by using either the arithmetic or harmonic averages, thereby providing two distinct (albeit naive) multimaterial models for the arithmetic and harmonic averages. More sophisticated models typically involve a surrogate mesh of some kind, as with the thin mesh and static condensation methods. In this paper, we perform rigorous code verification of the multiphysics hydrocode FLAG, including grid resolution studies. We employ a number of newly constructed 2D heat flow solutions that generalize the standard {\em planar sandwich} solution, and this paper offers a smorgasbord of exact solutions for heat flow verification. To perform the analyses and to produce the corresponding convergence plots, we employ the code verification tool ExactPack.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Toward Resolved Simulations of Burning Fronts in Thermonuclear X-ray Bursts
Authors:
M. Zingale,
K. Eiden,
Y. Cavecchi,
A. Harpole,
J. B. Bell,
M. Chang,
I. Hawke,
M. P. Katz,
C. M. Malone,
A. J. Nonaka,
D. E. Willcox,
W. Zhang
Abstract:
We discuss the challenges of modeling X-ray bursts in multi-dimensions, review the different calculations done to date, and discuss our new set of ongoing simulations. We also describe algorithmic improvements that may help in the future to offset some of the expense of these simulations, and describe what may be possible with exascale computing.
We discuss the challenges of modeling X-ray bursts in multi-dimensions, review the different calculations done to date, and discuss our new set of ongoing simulations. We also describe algorithmic improvements that may help in the future to offset some of the expense of these simulations, and describe what may be possible with exascale computing.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2019; v1 submitted 10 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Meeting the Challenges of Modeling Astrophysical Thermonuclear Explosions: Castro, Maestro, and the AMReX Astrophysics Suite
Authors:
M. Zingale,
A. S. Almgren,
M. G. Barrios Sazo,
V. E. Beckner,
J. B. Bell,
B. Friesen,
A. M. Jacobs,
M. P. Katz,
C. M. Malone,
A. J. Nonaka,
D. E. Willcox,
W. Zhang
Abstract:
We describe the AMReX suite of astrophysics codes and their application to modeling problems in stellar astrophysics. Maestro is tuned to efficiently model subsonic convective flows while Castro models the highly compressible flows associated with stellar explosions. Both are built on the block-structured adaptive mesh refinement library AMReX. Together, these codes enable a thorough investigation…
▽ More
We describe the AMReX suite of astrophysics codes and their application to modeling problems in stellar astrophysics. Maestro is tuned to efficiently model subsonic convective flows while Castro models the highly compressible flows associated with stellar explosions. Both are built on the block-structured adaptive mesh refinement library AMReX. Together, these codes enable a thorough investigation of stellar phenomena, including Type Ia supernovae and X-ray bursts. We describe these science applications and the approach we are taking to make these codes performant on current and future many-core and GPU-based architectures.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Modeling Astrophysical Explosions with Sustained Exascale Computing
Authors:
M. Zingale,
A. C. Calder,
C. M. Malone,
F. X. Timmes
Abstract:
Our understanding of stars and their fates is based on coupling observations to theoretical models. Unlike laboratory physicists, we cannot perform experiments on stars, but rather must patiently take what nature allows us to observe. Simulation offers a means of virtual experimentation, enabling a detailed understanding of the most violent ongoing explosions in the Universe---the deaths of stars.
Our understanding of stars and their fates is based on coupling observations to theoretical models. Unlike laboratory physicists, we cannot perform experiments on stars, but rather must patiently take what nature allows us to observe. Simulation offers a means of virtual experimentation, enabling a detailed understanding of the most violent ongoing explosions in the Universe---the deaths of stars.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
The LOFT perspective on neutron star thermonuclear bursts
Authors:
J. J. M. in 't Zand,
D. Altamirano,
D. R. Ballantyne,
S. Bhattacharyya,
E. F. Brown,
Y. Cavecchi,
D. Chakrabarty,
J. Chenevez,
A. Cumming,
N. Degenaar,
M. Falanga,
D. K. Galloway,
A. Heger,
J. José,
L. Keek,
M. Linares,
S. Mahmoodifar,
C. M. Malone,
M. Méndez,
M. C. Miller,
F. B. S. Paerels,
J. Poutanen,
A. Rózanska,
H. Schatz,
M. Serino
, et al. (9 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This is a White Paper in support of the mission concept of the Large Observatory for X-ray Timing (LOFT), proposed as a medium-sized ESA mission. We discuss the potential of LOFT for the study of thermonuclear X-ray bursts on accreting neutron stars. For a summary, we refer to the paper.
This is a White Paper in support of the mission concept of the Large Observatory for X-ray Timing (LOFT), proposed as a medium-sized ESA mission. We discuss the potential of LOFT for the study of thermonuclear X-ray bursts on accreting neutron stars. For a summary, we refer to the paper.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
Comparisons of Two- and Three-Dimensional Convection in Type I X-ray Bursts
Authors:
M. Zingale,
C. M. Malone,
A. Nonaka,
A. S. Almgren,
J. B. Bell
Abstract:
We perform the first detailed three-dimensional simulation of low Mach number convection preceding thermonuclear ignition in a mixed H/He X-ray burst. Our simulations include a moderate-sized, approximate network that captures hydrogen and helium burning up through rp-process breakout. We look in detail at the difference between two- and three-dimensional convective fields, including the details o…
▽ More
We perform the first detailed three-dimensional simulation of low Mach number convection preceding thermonuclear ignition in a mixed H/He X-ray burst. Our simulations include a moderate-sized, approximate network that captures hydrogen and helium burning up through rp-process breakout. We look in detail at the difference between two- and three-dimensional convective fields, including the details of the turbulent convection.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2015; v1 submitted 21 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Multidimensional Modeling of Type I X-ray Bursts. II. Two-Dimensional Convection in a Mixed H/He Accretor
Authors:
C. M. Malone,
M. Zingale,
A. Nonaka,
A. S. Almgren,
J. B. Bell
Abstract:
Type I X-ray Bursts (XRBs) are thermonuclear explosions of accreted material on the surfaces of a neutron stars in low mass X-ray binaries. Prior to the ignition of a subsonic burning front, runaway burning at the base of the accreted layer drives convection that mixes fuel and heavy-element ashes. In this second paper in a series, we explore the behavior of this low Mach number convection in mixe…
▽ More
Type I X-ray Bursts (XRBs) are thermonuclear explosions of accreted material on the surfaces of a neutron stars in low mass X-ray binaries. Prior to the ignition of a subsonic burning front, runaway burning at the base of the accreted layer drives convection that mixes fuel and heavy-element ashes. In this second paper in a series, we explore the behavior of this low Mach number convection in mixed hydrogen/helium layers on the surface of a neutron star using two-dimensional simulations with the Maestro code. Maestro takes advantage of the highly subsonic flow field by filtering dynamically unimportant sound waves while retaining local compressibility effects, such as those due to stratification and energy release from nuclear reactions. In these preliminary calculations, we find that the rp-process approximate network creates a convective region that is split into two layers. While this splitting appears artificial due to the approximations of the network regarding nuclear flow out of the breakout reaction 18Ne(a,p)21Na, these calculations hint at further simplifications and improvements of the burning treatment for use in subsequent calculations in three dimensions for a future paper.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
The Deflagration Stage of Chandrasekhar Mass Models For Type Ia Supernovae: I. Early Evolution
Authors:
C. M. Malone,
A. Nonaka,
S. E. Woosley,
A. S. Almgren,
J. B. Bell,
S. Dong,
M. Zingale
Abstract:
We present high-resolution, full-star simulations of the post-ignition phase of Type Ia supernovae using the compressible hydrodynamics code Castro. Initial conditions, including the turbulent velocity field and ignition site, are imported directly from a simulation of the last few hours of presupernova convection using a low Mach number code, Maestro. Adaptive mesh refinement allows the initial b…
▽ More
We present high-resolution, full-star simulations of the post-ignition phase of Type Ia supernovae using the compressible hydrodynamics code Castro. Initial conditions, including the turbulent velocity field and ignition site, are imported directly from a simulation of the last few hours of presupernova convection using a low Mach number code, Maestro. Adaptive mesh refinement allows the initial burning front to be modeled with an effective resolution of 36,864^3 zones (~136 m/zone). The initial rise and expansion of the deflagration front are tracked until burning reaches the star's edge and the role of the background turbulence on the flame is investigated. The effect of artificially moving the ignition location closer to the star's center is explored. The degree to which turbulence affects the burning front decreases with increasing ignition radius since the buoyancy force is stronger at larger radii. Even central ignition --- in the presence of a background convective flow field --- is rapidly carried off-center as the flame is carried by the flow field. We compare our results to analytic models for burning thermals, and find that they reproduce the general trends of the bubble's size and mass, but underpredict the amount of buoyant acceleration due to simplifying assumptions of the bubble's properties. Overall, we find that the amount of mass that burns prior to flame break out is small, consistent with a "gravitationally confined detonation" occurring at a later epoch, but additional burning will occur following breakout that may modify this conclusion.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2013; v1 submitted 16 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Carbon Deflagration in Type Ia Supernova: I. Centrally Ignited Models
Authors:
H. Ma,
S. E. Woosley,
C. M. Malone,
A. Almgren,
J. B. Bell
Abstract:
A leading model for Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) begins with a white dwarf near the Chandrasekhar mass that ignites a degenerate thermonuclear runaway close to its center and explodes. In a series of papers, we shall explore the consequences of ignition at several locations within such dwarfs. Here we assume central ignition, which has been explored before, however, the problem is worth revisiting,…
▽ More
A leading model for Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) begins with a white dwarf near the Chandrasekhar mass that ignites a degenerate thermonuclear runaway close to its center and explodes. In a series of papers, we shall explore the consequences of ignition at several locations within such dwarfs. Here we assume central ignition, which has been explored before, however, the problem is worth revisiting, if only to validate those previous studies and to further elucidate the relevant physics for future work. A perturbed sphere of hot iron ash with a radius of ~100 km is initialized at the middle of the star. The subsequent explosion is followed in several simulations using a thickened flame model in which the flame speed is either fixed --- within the range expected from turbulent combustion --- or based on the local turbulent intensity. Global results, including the explosion energy and bulk nucleosynthesis (e.g. 56Ni of 0.48--0.56 $\Msun$) turn out to be insensitive to this speed. In all completed runs, the energy released by the nuclear burning is adequate to unbind the star, but not enough to give the energy and brightness of typical SNe Ia. As found previously, the chemical stratification observed in typical events is not reproduced. These models produce a large amount of unburned carbon and oxygen in central low velocity regions, which is inconsistent with spectroscopic observations, and the intermediate mass elements and iron group elements are strongly mixed during the explosion.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Low Mach Number Modeling of Convection in Helium Shells on Sub-Chandrasekhar White Dwarfs. I. Methodology
Authors:
M. Zingale,
A. Nonaka,
A. S. Almgren,
J. B. Bell,
C. M. Malone,
R. J. Orvedahl
Abstract:
We assess the robustness of a low Mach number hydrodynamics algorithm for modeling helium shell convection on the surface of a white dwarf in the context of the sub-Chandrasekhar model for Type Ia supernovae. We use the low Mach number stellar hydrodynamics code, MAESTRO, to perform three-dimensional, spatially-adaptive simulations of convection leading up to the point of the ignition of a burning…
▽ More
We assess the robustness of a low Mach number hydrodynamics algorithm for modeling helium shell convection on the surface of a white dwarf in the context of the sub-Chandrasekhar model for Type Ia supernovae. We use the low Mach number stellar hydrodynamics code, MAESTRO, to perform three-dimensional, spatially-adaptive simulations of convection leading up to the point of the ignition of a burning front. We show that the low Mach number hydrodynamics model provides a robust description of the system.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Multidimensional Modeling of Type I X-ray Bursts. I. Two-Dimensional Convection Prior to the Outburst of a Pure Helium Accretor
Authors:
C. M. Malone,
A. Nonaka,
A. S. Almgren,
J. B. Bell,
M. Zingale
Abstract:
We present multidimensional simulations of the early convective phase preceding ignition in a Type I X-ray burst using the low Mach number hydrodynamics code, MAESTRO. A low Mach number approach is necessary in order to perform long-time integration required to study such phenomena. Using MAESTRO, we are able to capture the expansion of the atmosphere due to large-scale heating while capturing loc…
▽ More
We present multidimensional simulations of the early convective phase preceding ignition in a Type I X-ray burst using the low Mach number hydrodynamics code, MAESTRO. A low Mach number approach is necessary in order to perform long-time integration required to study such phenomena. Using MAESTRO, we are able to capture the expansion of the atmosphere due to large-scale heating while capturing local compressibility effects such as those due to reactions and thermal diffusion. We also discuss the preparation of one-dimensional initial models and the subsequent map** into our multidimensional framework. Our method of initial model generation differs from that used in previous multidimensional studies, which evolved a system through multiple bursts in one dimension before map** onto a multidimensional grid. In our multidimensional simulations, we find that the resolution necessary to properly resolve the burning layer is an order of magnitude greater than that used in the earlier studies mentioned above. We characterize the convective patterns that form and discuss their resulting influence on the state of the convective region, which is important in modeling the outburst itself.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
MAESTRO: An Adaptive Low Mach Number Hydrodynamics Algorithm for Stellar Flows
Authors:
A. Nonaka,
A. S. Almgren,
J. B. Bell,
M. J. Lijewski,
C. M. Malone,
M. Zingale
Abstract:
Many astrophysical phenomena are highly subsonic, requiring specialized numerical methods suitable for long-time integration. In a series of earlier papers we described the development of MAESTRO, a low Mach number stellar hydrodynamics code that can be used to simulate long-time, low-speed flows that would be prohibitively expensive to model using traditional compressible codes. MAESTRO is base…
▽ More
Many astrophysical phenomena are highly subsonic, requiring specialized numerical methods suitable for long-time integration. In a series of earlier papers we described the development of MAESTRO, a low Mach number stellar hydrodynamics code that can be used to simulate long-time, low-speed flows that would be prohibitively expensive to model using traditional compressible codes. MAESTRO is based on an equation set derived using low Mach number asymptotics; this equation set does not explicitly track acoustic waves and thus allows a significant increase in the time step. MAESTRO is suitable for two- and three-dimensional local atmospheric flows as well as three-dimensional full-star flows. Here, we continue the development of MAESTRO by incorporating adaptive mesh refinement (AMR). The primary difference between MAESTRO and other structured grid AMR approaches for incompressible and low Mach number flows is the presence of the time-dependent base state, whose evolution is coupled to the evolution of the full solution. We also describe how to incorporate the expansion of the base state for full-star flows, which involves a novel map** technique between the one-dimensional base state and the Cartesian grid, as well as a number of overall improvements to the algorithm. We examine the efficiency and accuracy of our adaptive code, and demonstrate that it is suitable for further study of our initial scientific application, the convective phase of Type Ia supernovae.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2010;
originally announced May 2010.