-
Addressing misconceptions in university physics: A review and experiences from quantum physics educators
Authors:
Shayan Majidy
Abstract:
Students often enter physics classrooms with deeply ingrained misconceptions stemming from everyday experiences. These misconceptions challenge educators, as students often resist information that conflicts with their preconceptions. The first aim of this manuscript is to summarize the existing literature on misconceptions in university physics, reviewing misconceptions' sources, diagnoses, and re…
▽ More
Students often enter physics classrooms with deeply ingrained misconceptions stemming from everyday experiences. These misconceptions challenge educators, as students often resist information that conflicts with their preconceptions. The first aim of this manuscript is to summarize the existing literature on misconceptions in university physics, reviewing misconceptions' sources, diagnoses, and remediation strategies. Most of this literature has concentrated on classical physics. However, quantum physics poses unique challenges because its concepts are removed from everyday experiences. This signals the need to ask how well existing strategies for addressing misconceptions apply to quantum physics. This is underscored by the recent surge of people from diverse backgrounds entering quantum physics because of the growing significance of quantum technologies. To help answer this question, we conducted in-depth interviews with quantum physics instructors at the University of Waterloo who have collectively taught over 100 quantum physics courses. These interviews explored common misconceptions in quantum physics, their origins, and effective instructional techniques to address them. We highlight specific misconceptions, such as misunderstanding of entanglement and spin, and successful teaching strategies, including ``misconception-trap quizzes.'' We integrate insights from the literature review with our interview data to provide an overview of current best practices in addressing physics misconceptions. Furthermore, we identify key research questions that warrant further exploration, such as the efficacy of multi-tier tests in quantum physics and develo** a cohesive quantum curriculum. This paper aims to inform educators and curriculum developers, offering practical recommendations and setting a research agenda to improve conceptual understanding in classical and quantum physics.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Noncommuting charges' effect on the thermalization of local observables
Authors:
Shayan Majidy
Abstract:
Studying noncommuting conserved quantities (or `charges') has produced a conceptual puzzle. Recent results suggest that noncommuting charges hinder thermalization in some ways yet promote it in others. To help resolve this puzzle, we demonstrate how noncommuting charges can promote thermalization by reducing the number of local observables that thermalize according to the Eigenstate Thermalization…
▽ More
Studying noncommuting conserved quantities (or `charges') has produced a conceptual puzzle. Recent results suggest that noncommuting charges hinder thermalization in some ways yet promote it in others. To help resolve this puzzle, we demonstrate how noncommuting charges can promote thermalization by reducing the number of local observables that thermalize according to the Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis. We first establish a correspondence between charges and sufficient conditions for local observables not to thermalize. These conditions are known as `dynamical symmetries.' We demonstrate that a corresponding charge exists for each pair of dynamical symmetries a Hamiltonian has. We prove that the reciprocal relationship holds for many charges and Hamiltonians. Using this correspondence, we demonstrate that introducing a new charge into a system can either increase or decrease the number of non-thermalizing local observables. If the new charge commutes with the existing ones, the system's non-thermalizing observables are preserved, and new ones may emerge. Conversely, if it does not commute, the existing non-thermalizing observables will thermalize. We illustrate our results using various models, showing that noncommuting charges eliminate the non-thermalizing dynamics arising from dynamical symmetries.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2024; v1 submitted 19 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Noncommuting conserved charges in quantum thermodynamics and beyond
Authors:
Shayan Majidy,
William F. Braasch Jr.,
Aleksander Lasek,
Twesh Upadhyaya,
Amir Kalev,
Nicole Yunger Halpern
Abstract:
Thermodynamic systems typically conserve quantities ("charges") such as energy and particle number. The charges are often assumed implicitly to commute with each other. Yet quantum phenomena such as uncertainty relations rely on observables' failure to commute. How do noncommuting charges affect thermodynamic phenomena? This question, upon arising at the intersection of quantum information theory…
▽ More
Thermodynamic systems typically conserve quantities ("charges") such as energy and particle number. The charges are often assumed implicitly to commute with each other. Yet quantum phenomena such as uncertainty relations rely on observables' failure to commute. How do noncommuting charges affect thermodynamic phenomena? This question, upon arising at the intersection of quantum information theory and thermodynamics, spread recently across many-body physics. Charges' noncommutation has been found to invalidate derivations of the thermal state's form, decrease entropy production, conflict with the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis, and more. This Perspective surveys key results in, opportunities for, and work adjacent to the quantum thermodynamics of noncommuting charges. Open problems include a conceptual puzzle: Evidence suggests that noncommuting charges may hinder thermalization in some ways while enhancing thermalization in others.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2023; v1 submitted 31 May, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Critical phase and spin sharpening in SU(2)-symmetric monitored quantum circuits
Authors:
Shayan Majidy,
Utkarsh Agrawal,
Sarang Gopalakrishnan,
Andrew C. Potter,
Romain Vasseur,
Nicole Yunger Halpern
Abstract:
Monitored quantum circuits exhibit entanglement transitions at certain measurement rates. Such a transition separates phases characterized by how much information an observer can learn from the measurement outcomes. We study SU(2)-symmetric monitored quantum circuits, using exact numerics and a map** onto an effective statistical-mechanics model. Due to the symmetry's non-Abelian nature, measuri…
▽ More
Monitored quantum circuits exhibit entanglement transitions at certain measurement rates. Such a transition separates phases characterized by how much information an observer can learn from the measurement outcomes. We study SU(2)-symmetric monitored quantum circuits, using exact numerics and a map** onto an effective statistical-mechanics model. Due to the symmetry's non-Abelian nature, measuring qubit pairs allows for nontrivial entanglement scaling even in the measurement-only limit. We find a transition between a volume-law entangled phase and a critical phase whose diffusive purification dynamics emerge from the non-Abelian symmetry. Additionally, we numerically identify a "spin-sharpening transition." On one side is a phase in which the measurements can efficiently identify the system's total spin quantum number; on the other side is a phase in which measurements cannot.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2023; v1 submitted 22 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Non-Abelian symmetry can increase entanglement entropy
Authors:
Shayan Majidy,
Aleksander Lasek,
David A. Huse,
Nicole Yunger Halpern
Abstract:
The pillars of quantum theory include entanglement and operators' failure to commute. The Page curve quantifies the bipartite entanglement of a many-body system in a random pure state. This entanglement is known to decrease if one constrains extensive observables that commute with each other (Abelian ``charges''). Non-Abelian charges, which fail to commute with each other, are of current interest…
▽ More
The pillars of quantum theory include entanglement and operators' failure to commute. The Page curve quantifies the bipartite entanglement of a many-body system in a random pure state. This entanglement is known to decrease if one constrains extensive observables that commute with each other (Abelian ``charges''). Non-Abelian charges, which fail to commute with each other, are of current interest in quantum thermodynamics. For example, noncommuting charges were shown to reduce entropy-production rates and may enhance finite-size deviations from eigenstate thermalization. Bridging quantum thermodynamics to many-body physics, we quantify the effects of charges' noncommutation -- of a symmetry's non-Abelian nature -- on Page curves. First, we construct two models that are closely analogous but differ in whether their charges commute. We show analytically and numerically that the noncommuting-charge case has more entanglement. Hence charges' noncommutation can promote entanglement.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2023; v1 submitted 28 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
How to build Hamiltonians that transport noncommuting charges in quantum thermodynamics
Authors:
Nicole Yunger Halpern,
Shayan Majidy
Abstract:
Noncommuting conserved quantities have recently launched a subfield of quantum thermodynamics. In conventional thermodynamics, a system of interest and an environment exchange quantities -- energy, particles, electric charge, etc. -- that are globally conserved and are represented by Hermitian operators. These operators were implicitly assumed to commute with each other, until a few years ago. Fre…
▽ More
Noncommuting conserved quantities have recently launched a subfield of quantum thermodynamics. In conventional thermodynamics, a system of interest and an environment exchange quantities -- energy, particles, electric charge, etc. -- that are globally conserved and are represented by Hermitian operators. These operators were implicitly assumed to commute with each other, until a few years ago. Freeing the operators to fail to commute has enabled many theoretical discoveries -- about reference frames, entropy production, resource-theory models, etc. Little work has bridged these results from abstract theory to experimental reality. This paper provides a methodology for building this bridge systematically: We present a prescription for constructing Hamiltonians that conserve noncommuting quantities globally while transporting the quantities locally. The Hamiltonians can couple arbitrarily many subsystems together and can be integrable or nonintegrable. Our Hamiltonians may be realized physically with superconducting qudits, with ultracold atoms, and with trapped ions.
△ Less
Submitted 19 January, 2022; v1 submitted 25 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Detecting violations of macrorealism when the original Leggett-Garg inequalities are satisfied
Authors:
Shayan Majidy,
Jonathan J. Halliwell,
Raymond Laflamme
Abstract:
Macroscopic realism (MR) is the notion that a time-evolving system possesses definite properties, irrespective of past or future measurements. Quantum mechanical theories can, however, produce violations of MR. Most research to date has focused on a single set of conditions for MR, the Leggett-Garg inequalities (LGIs), and on a single data set, the "standard data set", which consists of single-tim…
▽ More
Macroscopic realism (MR) is the notion that a time-evolving system possesses definite properties, irrespective of past or future measurements. Quantum mechanical theories can, however, produce violations of MR. Most research to date has focused on a single set of conditions for MR, the Leggett-Garg inequalities (LGIs), and on a single data set, the "standard data set", which consists of single-time averages and second-order correlators of a dichotomic variable Q for three times. However, if such conditions are all satisfied, then where is the quantum behaviour? In this paper, we provide an answer to this question by considering expanded data sets obtained from finer-grained measurements and MR conditions on those sets. We consider three different situations in which there are violations of MR that go undetected by the standard LGIs. First, we explore higher-order LGIs on a data set involving third- and fourth-order correlators, using a spin-1/2 and spin-1 system. Second, we explore the pentagon inequalities (PIs) and a data set consisting of all possible averages and second-order correlators for measurements of Q at five times. Third, we explore the LGIs for a trichotomic variable and measurements made with a trichotomic operator to, again, identify violations for a spin-1 system beyond those seen with a single dichotomic variable. We also explore the regimes in which combinations of two and three-time LGIs can be satisfied and violated in a spin-1 system, extending recent work. We discuss the possible experimental implementation of all the above results.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2021; v1 submitted 28 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Exploration of an augmented set of Leggett-Garg inequalities using a noninvasive continuous-in-time velocity measurement
Authors:
Shayan-Shawn Majidy,
Hemant Katiyar,
Galit Anikeeva,
Jonathan Halliwell,
Raymond Laflamme
Abstract:
Macroscopic realism (MR) is the view that a system may possess definite properties at any time independent of past or future measurements, and may be tested experimentally using the Leggett-Garg inequalities (LGIs). In this work we advance the study of LGIs in two ways using experiments carried out on a nuclear magnetic resonance spectrometer. Firstly, we addresses the fact that the LGIs are only…
▽ More
Macroscopic realism (MR) is the view that a system may possess definite properties at any time independent of past or future measurements, and may be tested experimentally using the Leggett-Garg inequalities (LGIs). In this work we advance the study of LGIs in two ways using experiments carried out on a nuclear magnetic resonance spectrometer. Firstly, we addresses the fact that the LGIs are only necessary conditions for MR but not sufficient ones. We implement a recently-proposed test of necessary and sufficient conditions for MR which consists of a combination of the original four three-time LGIs augmented with a set of twelve two-time LGIs. We explore different regimes in which the two- and three-time LGIs may each be satisfied or violated. Secondly, we implement a recent proposal for a measurement protocol which determines the temporal correlation functions in an approximately non-invasive manner. It employs a measurement of the velocity of a dichotomic variable $Q$, continuous in time, from which a possible sign change of $Q$ may be determined in a single measurement of an ancilla coupled to the velocity. This protocol involves a significantly different set of assumptions to the traditional ideal negative measurement protocol and a comparison with the latter is carried out.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2019; v1 submitted 11 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
A unification of the coding theory and OAQEC perspective on hybrid codes
Authors:
Shayan Majidy
Abstract:
There is an advantage in simultaneously transmitting both classical and quantum information over a quantum channel compared to sending independent transmissions. The successful implementation of simultaneous transmissions of quantum and classical information will require the development of hybrid quantum-classical error-correcting codes, known as hybrid codes. The characterization of hybrid codes…
▽ More
There is an advantage in simultaneously transmitting both classical and quantum information over a quantum channel compared to sending independent transmissions. The successful implementation of simultaneous transmissions of quantum and classical information will require the development of hybrid quantum-classical error-correcting codes, known as hybrid codes. The characterization of hybrid codes has been performed from a coding theory perspective and an operator algebra quantum error correction (OAQEC) perspective. First, we demonstrate that these two perspectives are equivalent and that the coding theory characterization is a specific case of the OAQEC model. Second, we include a generalization of the quantum Hamming bound for hybrid error-correcting codes. We discover a necessary condition for develo** non-trivial hybrid codes -- they must be degenerate. Finally, we construct an example of a non-trivial degenerate 4-qubit hybrid code.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2023; v1 submitted 10 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
