-
Accurate Free Energy Estimations of Molecular Systems Via Flow-based Targeted Free Energy Perturbation
Authors:
Soo Jung Lee,
Amr H. Mahmoud,
Markus A. Lill
Abstract:
The Targeted Free Energy Perturbation (TFEP) method aims to overcome the time-consuming and computer-intensive stratification process of standard methods for estimating the free energy difference between two states. To achieve this, TFEP uses a map** function between the high-dimensional probability densities of these states. The bijectivity and invertibility of normalizing flow neural networks…
▽ More
The Targeted Free Energy Perturbation (TFEP) method aims to overcome the time-consuming and computer-intensive stratification process of standard methods for estimating the free energy difference between two states. To achieve this, TFEP uses a map** function between the high-dimensional probability densities of these states. The bijectivity and invertibility of normalizing flow neural networks fulfill the requirements for serving as such a map** function. Despite its theoretical potential for free energy calculations, TFEP has not yet been adopted in practice due to challenges in entropy correction, limitations in energy-based training, and mode collapse when learning density functions of larger systems with a high number of degrees of freedom. In this study, we expand flow-based TFEP to systems with variable number of atoms in the two states of consideration by exploring the theoretical basis of entropic contributions of dummy atoms, and validate our reasoning with analytical derivations for a model system containing coupled particles. We also extend the TFEP framework to handle systems of hybrid topology, propose auxiliary additions to improve the TFEP architecture, and demonstrate accurate predictions of relative free energy differences for large molecular systems. Our results provide the first practical application of the fast and accurate deep learning-based TFEP method for biomolecules and introduce it as a viable free energy estimation method within the context of drug design.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Graph-convolution neural network-based flexible docking utilizing coarse-grained distance matrix
Authors:
Amr H. Mahmoud,
Jonas F. Lill,
Markus A. Lill
Abstract:
Prediction of protein-ligand complexes for flexible proteins remains still a challenging problem in computational structural biology and drug design. Here we present two novel deep neural network approaches with significant improvement in efficiency and accuracy of binding mode prediction on a large and diverse set of protein systems compared to standard docking. Whereas the first graph convolutio…
▽ More
Prediction of protein-ligand complexes for flexible proteins remains still a challenging problem in computational structural biology and drug design. Here we present two novel deep neural network approaches with significant improvement in efficiency and accuracy of binding mode prediction on a large and diverse set of protein systems compared to standard docking. Whereas the first graph convolutional network is used for re-ranking poses the second approach aims to generate and rank poses independent of standard docking approaches. This novel approach relies on the prediction of distance matrices between ligand atoms and protein C_alpha atoms thus incorporating side-chain flexibility implicitly.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
On-the-fly Prediction of Protein Hydration Densities and Free Energies using Deep Learning
Authors:
Ahmadreza Ghanbarpour,
Amr H. Mahmoud,
Markus A. Lill
Abstract:
The calculation of thermodynamic properties of biochemical systems typically requires the use of resource-intensive molecular simulation methods. One example thereof is the thermodynamic profiling of hydration sites, i.e. high-probability locations for water molecules on the protein surface, which play an essential role in protein-ligand associations and must therefore be incorporated in the predi…
▽ More
The calculation of thermodynamic properties of biochemical systems typically requires the use of resource-intensive molecular simulation methods. One example thereof is the thermodynamic profiling of hydration sites, i.e. high-probability locations for water molecules on the protein surface, which play an essential role in protein-ligand associations and must therefore be incorporated in the prediction of binding poses and affinities. To replace time-consuming simulations in hydration site predictions, we developed two different types of deep neural-network models aiming to predict hydration site data. In the first approach, meshed 3D images are generated representing the interactions between certain molecular probes placed on regular 3D grids, encompassing the binding pocket, with the static protein. These molecular interaction fields are mapped to the corresponding 3D image of hydration occupancy using a neural network based on an U-Net architecture. In a second approach, hydration occupancy and thermodynamics were predicted point-wise using a neural network based on fully-connected layers. In addition to direct protein interaction fields, the environment of each grid point was represented using moments of a spherical harmonics expansion of the interaction properties of nearby grid points. Application to structure-activity relationship analysis and protein-ligand pose scoring demonstrates the utility of the predicted hydration information.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
VoroCrust: Voronoi Meshing Without Clip**
Authors:
Ahmed Abdelkader,
Chandrajit L. Bajaj,
Mohamed S. Ebeida,
Ahmed H. Mahmoud,
Scott A. Mitchell,
John D. Owens,
Ahmad A. Rushdi
Abstract:
Polyhedral meshes are increasingly becoming an attractive option with particular advantages over traditional meshes for certain applications. What has been missing is a robust polyhedral meshing algorithm that can handle broad classes of domains exhibiting arbitrarily curved boundaries and sharp features. In addition, the power of primal-dual mesh pairs, exemplified by Voronoi-Delaunay meshes, has…
▽ More
Polyhedral meshes are increasingly becoming an attractive option with particular advantages over traditional meshes for certain applications. What has been missing is a robust polyhedral meshing algorithm that can handle broad classes of domains exhibiting arbitrarily curved boundaries and sharp features. In addition, the power of primal-dual mesh pairs, exemplified by Voronoi-Delaunay meshes, has been recognized as an important ingredient in numerous formulations. The VoroCrust algorithm is the first provably-correct algorithm for conforming polyhedral Voronoi meshing for non-convex and non-manifold domains with guarantees on the quality of both surface and volume elements. A robust refinement process estimates a suitable sizing field that enables the careful placement of Voronoi seeds across the surface circumventing the need for clip** and avoiding its many drawbacks. The algorithm has the flexibility of filling the interior by either structured or random samples, while preserving all sharp features in the output mesh. We demonstrate the capabilities of the algorithm on a variety of models and compare against state-of-the-art polyhedral meshing methods based on clipped Voronoi cells establishing the clear advantage of VoroCrust output.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2023; v1 submitted 23 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Sampling Conditions for Conforming Voronoi Meshing by the VoroCrust Algorithm
Authors:
Ahmed Abdelkader,
Chandrajit L. Bajaj,
Mohamed S. Ebeida,
Ahmed H. Mahmoud,
Scott A. Mitchell,
John D. Owens,
Ahmad A. Rushdi
Abstract:
We study the problem of decomposing a volume bounded by a smooth surface into a collection of Voronoi cells. Unlike the dual problem of conforming Delaunay meshing, a principled solution to this problem for generic smooth surfaces remained elusive. VoroCrust leverages ideas from $α$-shapes and the power crust algorithm to produce unweighted Voronoi cells conforming to the surface, yielding the fir…
▽ More
We study the problem of decomposing a volume bounded by a smooth surface into a collection of Voronoi cells. Unlike the dual problem of conforming Delaunay meshing, a principled solution to this problem for generic smooth surfaces remained elusive. VoroCrust leverages ideas from $α$-shapes and the power crust algorithm to produce unweighted Voronoi cells conforming to the surface, yielding the first provably-correct algorithm for this problem. Given an $ε$-sample on the bounding surface, with a weak $σ$-sparsity condition, we work with the balls of radius $δ$ times the local feature size centered at each sample. The corners of this union of balls are the Voronoi sites, on both sides of the surface. The facets common to cells on opposite sides reconstruct the surface. For appropriate values of $ε$, $σ$ and $δ$, we prove that the surface reconstruction is isotopic to the bounding surface. With the surface protected, the enclosed volume can be further decomposed into an isotopic volume mesh of fat Voronoi cells by generating a bounded number of sites in its interior. Compared to state-of-the-art methods based on clip**, VoroCrust cells are full Voronoi cells, with convexity and fatness guarantees. Compared to the power crust algorithm, VoroCrust cells are not filtered, are unweighted, and offer greater flexibility in meshing the enclosed volume by either structured grids or random samples.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2018; v1 submitted 16 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
