-
Paper card-based vs application-based vaccine credentials: a comparison
Authors:
Aryan Mahindra,
Anshuman Sharma,
Priyanshi Katiyar,
Rohan Sukumaran,
Ishaan Singh,
Albert Johnson,
Kasia Jakimowicz,
Akarsh Venkatasubramanian,
Chandan CV,
Shailesh Advani,
Rohan Iyer,
Sheshank Shankar,
Saurish Srivastava,
Sethuraman TV,
Abhishek Singh,
Ramesh Raskar
Abstract:
In this early draft, we provide an overview on similarities and differences in the implementation of a paper card-based vaccine credential system and an app-based vaccine credential system. A vaccine credential's primary goal is to regulate entry and ensure safety of individuals within densely packed public locations and workspaces. This is critical for containing the rapid spread of Covid-19 in d…
▽ More
In this early draft, we provide an overview on similarities and differences in the implementation of a paper card-based vaccine credential system and an app-based vaccine credential system. A vaccine credential's primary goal is to regulate entry and ensure safety of individuals within densely packed public locations and workspaces. This is critical for containing the rapid spread of Covid-19 in densely packed public locations since a single individual can infect a large majority of people in a crowd. A vaccine credential can also provide information such as an individual's Covid-19 vaccination history and adverse symptom reaction history to judge their potential impact on the overall health of individuals within densely packed public locations and workspaces. After completing the comparisons, we believe a card-based implementation will benefit regions with less socioeconomic mobility, limited resources, and stagnant administrations. An app-based implementation on the other hand will benefit regions with equitable internet access and lower technological divide. We also believe an interoperable system of both credential systems will work best for regions with enormous working-class populations and dense housing clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2022; v1 submitted 8 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
MIT SafePaths Card (MiSaCa): Augmenting Paper Based Vaccination Cards with Printed Codes
Authors:
Joseph Bae,
Rohan Sukumaran,
Sheshank Shankar,
Saurish Srivastava,
Rohan Iyer,
Aryan Mahindra,
Qamil Mirza,
Maurizio Arseni,
Anshuman Sharma,
Saras Agrawal,
Orna Mukhopadhyay,
Colin Kang,
Priyanshi Katiyar,
Apurv Shekhar,
Sifat Hasan,
Krishnendu Dasgupta,
Darshan Gandhi,
Sethuramen TV,
Parth Patwa,
Ishaan Singh,
Abhishek Singh,
Ramesh Raskar
Abstract:
In this early draft, we describe a user-centric, card-based system for vaccine distribution. Our system makes use of digitally signed QR codes and their use for phased vaccine distribution, vaccine administration/record-kee**, immunization verification, and follow-up symptom reporting. Furthermore, we propose and describe a complementary scanner app system to be used by vaccination clinics, publ…
▽ More
In this early draft, we describe a user-centric, card-based system for vaccine distribution. Our system makes use of digitally signed QR codes and their use for phased vaccine distribution, vaccine administration/record-kee**, immunization verification, and follow-up symptom reporting. Furthermore, we propose and describe a complementary scanner app system to be used by vaccination clinics, public health officials, and immunization verification parties to effectively utilize card-based framework. We believe that the proposed system provides a privacy-preserving and efficient framework for vaccine distribution in both developed and develo** regions.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2021; v1 submitted 19 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Spatial K-anonymity: A Privacy-preserving Method for COVID-19 Related Geospatial Technologies
Authors:
Rohan Iyer,
Regina Rex,
Kevin P. McPherson,
Darshan Gandhi,
Aryan Mahindra,
Abhishek Singh,
Ramesh Raskar
Abstract:
There is a growing need for spatial privacy considerations in the many geo-spatial technologies that have been created as solutions for COVID-19-related issues. Although effective geo-spatial technologies have already been rolled out, most have significantly sacrificed privacy for utility. In this paper, we explore spatial k-anonymity, a privacy-preserving method that can address this unnecessary…
▽ More
There is a growing need for spatial privacy considerations in the many geo-spatial technologies that have been created as solutions for COVID-19-related issues. Although effective geo-spatial technologies have already been rolled out, most have significantly sacrificed privacy for utility. In this paper, we explore spatial k-anonymity, a privacy-preserving method that can address this unnecessary tradeoff by providing the best of both privacy and utility. After evaluating its past implications in geo-spatial use cases, we propose applications of spatial k-anonymity in the data sharing and managing of COVID-19 contact tracing technologies as well as heat maps showing a user's travel history. We then justify our propositions by comparing spatial k-anonymity with several other spatial privacy methods, including differential privacy, geo-indistinguishability, and manual consent based redaction. Our hope is to raise awareness of the ever-growing risks associated with spatial privacy and how they can be solved with Spatial K-anonymity.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
COVID-19 Tests Gone Rogue: Privacy, Efficacy, Mismanagement and Misunderstandings
Authors:
Manuel Morales,
Rachel Barbar,
Darshan Gandhi,
Sanskruti Landage,
Joseph Bae,
Arpita Vats,
Jil Kothari,
Sheshank Shankar,
Rohan Sukumaran,
Himi Mathur,
Krutika Misra,
Aishwarya Saxena,
Parth Patwa,
Sethuraman T. V.,
Maurizio Arseni,
Shailesh Advani,
Kasia Jakimowicz,
Sunaina Anand,
Priyanshi Katiyar,
Ashley Mehra,
Rohan Iyer,
Srinidhi Murali,
Aryan Mahindra,
Mikhail Dmitrienko,
Saurish Srivastava
, et al. (5 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
COVID-19 testing, the cornerstone for effective screening and identification of COVID-19 cases, remains paramount as an intervention tool to curb the spread of COVID-19 both at local and national levels. However, the speed at which the pandemic struck and the response was rolled out, the widespread impact on healthcare infrastructure, the lack of sufficient preparation within the public health sys…
▽ More
COVID-19 testing, the cornerstone for effective screening and identification of COVID-19 cases, remains paramount as an intervention tool to curb the spread of COVID-19 both at local and national levels. However, the speed at which the pandemic struck and the response was rolled out, the widespread impact on healthcare infrastructure, the lack of sufficient preparation within the public health system, and the complexity of the crisis led to utter confusion among test-takers. Invasion of privacy remains a crucial concern. The user experience of test takers remains low. User friction affects user behavior and discourages participation in testing programs. Test efficacy has been overstated. Test results are poorly understood resulting in inappropriate follow-up recommendations. Herein, we review the current landscape of COVID-19 testing, identify four key challenges, and discuss the consequences of the failure to address these challenges. The current infrastructure around testing and information propagation is highly privacy-invasive and does not leverage scalable digital components. In this work, we discuss challenges complicating the existing covid-19 testing ecosystem and highlight the need to improve the testing experience for the user and reduce privacy invasions. Digital tools will play a critical role in resolving these challenges.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2021; v1 submitted 5 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Digital Landscape of COVID-19 Testing: Challenges and Opportunities
Authors:
Darshan Gandhi,
Rohan Sukumaran,
Priyanshi Katiyar,
Alex Radunsky,
Sunaina Anand,
Shailesh Advani,
Jil Kothari,
Kasia Jakimowicz,
Sheshank Shankar,
Sethuraman T. V.,
Krutika Misra,
Aishwarya Saxena,
Sanskruti Landage,
Richa Sonker,
Parth Patwa,
Aryan Mahindra,
Mikhail Dmitrienko,
Kanishka Vaish,
Ashley Mehra,
Srinidhi Murali,
Rohan Iyer,
Joseph Bae,
Vivek Sharma,
Abhishek Singh,
Rachel Barbar
, et al. (1 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The COVID-19 Pandemic has left a devastating trail all over the world, in terms of loss of lives, economic decline, travel restrictions, trade deficit, and collapsing economy including real-estate, job loss, loss of health benefits, the decline in quality of access to care and services and overall quality of life. Immunization from the anticipated vaccines will not be the stand-alone guideline tha…
▽ More
The COVID-19 Pandemic has left a devastating trail all over the world, in terms of loss of lives, economic decline, travel restrictions, trade deficit, and collapsing economy including real-estate, job loss, loss of health benefits, the decline in quality of access to care and services and overall quality of life. Immunization from the anticipated vaccines will not be the stand-alone guideline that will help surpass the pandemic and return to normalcy. Four pillars of effective public health intervention include diagnostic testing for both asymptomatic and symptomatic individuals, contact tracing, quarantine of individuals with symptoms or who are exposed to COVID-19, and maintaining strict hygiene standards at the individual and community level. Digital technology, currently being used for COVID-19 testing include certain mobile apps, web dashboards, and online self-assessment tools. Herein, we look into various digital solutions adapted by communities across universities, businesses, and other organizations. We summarize the challenges experienced using these tools in terms of quality of information, privacy, and user-centric issues. Despite numerous digital solutions available and being developed, many vary in terms of information being shared in terms of both quality and quantity, which can be overwhelming to the users. Understanding the testing landscape through a digital lens will give a clear insight into the multiple challenges that we face including data privacy, cost, and miscommunication. It is the destiny of digitalization to navigate testing for COVID-19. Block-chain based systems can be used for privacy preservation and ensuring ownership of the data to remain with the user. Another solution involves having digital health passports with relevant and correct information. In this early draft, we summarize the challenges and propose possible solutions to address the same.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Clinical Landscape of COVID-19 Testing: Difficult Choices
Authors:
Darshan Gandhi,
Sanskruti Landage,
Joseph Bae,
Sheshank Shankar,
Rohan Sukumaran,
Parth Patwa,
Sethuraman T V,
Priyanshi Katiyar,
Shailesh Advani,
Rohan Iyer,
Sunaina Anand,
Aryan Mahindra,
Rachel Barbar,
Abhishek Singh,
Ramesh Raskar
Abstract:
The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic has spread rapidly across the world, leading to enormous amounts of human death and economic loss. Until definitive preventive or curative measures are developed, policies regarding testing, contact tracing, and quarantine remain the best public health tools for curbing viral spread. Testing is a crucial component of these efforts, enabling the iden…
▽ More
The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic has spread rapidly across the world, leading to enormous amounts of human death and economic loss. Until definitive preventive or curative measures are developed, policies regarding testing, contact tracing, and quarantine remain the best public health tools for curbing viral spread. Testing is a crucial component of these efforts, enabling the identification and isolation of infected individuals. Differences in testing methodologies, time frames, and outcomes can have an impact on their overall efficiency, usability and efficacy. In this early draft, we draw a comparison between the various types of diagnostic tests including PCR, antigen, and home tests in relation to their relative advantages, disadvantages, and use cases. We also look into alternative and unconventional methods. Further, we analyze the short-term and long-term impacts of the virus and its testing on various verticals such as business, government laws, policies, and healthcare.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2020; v1 submitted 9 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
