Showing 1–14 of 14 results for author: Magin, T E

Numerical simulation of rarefied supersonic flows using a fourth-order maximum-entropy moment method with interpolative closure

Authors: Stefano Boccelli, Willem Kaufmann, Thierry E. Magin, James G. McDonald

Abstract: Maximum-entropy moment methods allow for the modelling of gases from the continuum regime to strongly rarefied conditions. The development of approximated solutions to the entropy maximization problem has made these methods computationally affordable. In this work, we apply a fourth-order maximum-entropy moment method to the study of supersonic rarefied flows. For such conditions, we compare the m… ▽ More Maximum-entropy moment methods allow for the modelling of gases from the continuum regime to strongly rarefied conditions. The development of approximated solutions to the entropy maximization problem has made these methods computationally affordable. In this work, we apply a fourth-order maximum-entropy moment method to the study of supersonic rarefied flows. For such conditions, we compare the maximum-entropy solutions to results obtained from the kinetic theory of gases at different Knudsen numbers. The analysis is performed for both a simplified model of a gas with a single translational degree of freedom (5-moment system) and for a typical gas with three degrees of freedom (14-moment system). The maximum-entropy method is applied to the study of the Sod shock-tube problem at various rarefaction levels, and to the simulation of two-dimensional low-collisional crossed supersonic jets. We show that, in rarefied supersonic conditions, it is important to employ accurate estimates of the wave speeds. Since analytical expressions are not presently available, we propose an approximation, valid for the 14-moment system. In these conditions, the solution of the maximum-entropy system is shown to realize large degrees of non-equilibrium and to approach the Junk subspace, yet provides a good overall accuracy and agreement with the kinetic theory. Numerical procedures for reaching second-order accurate discretizations are discussed, as well as the implementation of the 14-moment solver on Graphics Processing Units (GPUs). △ Less

Submitted 26 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Modelling high-Mach-number rarefied crossflows past a flat plate using the maximum-entropy moment method

Authors: Stefano Boccelli, Pietro Parodi, Thierry E. Magin, James G. McDonald

Abstract: The 10 and 14-moment maximum-entropy methods are applied to the study of high-Mach-number non-reacting crossflows past a flat plate at large degrees of rarefaction. The moment solutions are compared to particle-based kinetic solutions, showing a varying degree of accuracy. At a Knudsen number of 0.1, the 10-moment method is able to reproduce the shock layer, while it fails to predict the low-densi… ▽ More The 10 and 14-moment maximum-entropy methods are applied to the study of high-Mach-number non-reacting crossflows past a flat plate at large degrees of rarefaction. The moment solutions are compared to particle-based kinetic solutions, showing a varying degree of accuracy. At a Knudsen number of 0.1, the 10-moment method is able to reproduce the shock layer, while it fails to predict the low-density wake region, due to the lack of a heat flux. Conversely, the 14-moment method results in accurate predictions of both regions. At a Knudsen number of 1, the 10-moment method produces unphysical results in both the shock layer and in the wake. The 14-moment method also shows a reduced accuracy, but manages to predict a reasonable shock region, free of unphysical sub-shocks, and in qualitative agreement with the kinetic solution. Accuracy is partially lost in the wake, where the 14-moment method predicts a thin unphysical high-density layer, concentrated on the centreline. An analysis of the velocity distribution functions (VDF) indicates strongly non-Maxwellian shapes, and the presence of distinct particle populations, in the wake, crossing each other at the centreline. The particle-based and the 14-moment method VDFs are in qualitative agreement. △ Less

Submitted 1 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

14-moment maximum-entropy modelling of collisionless ions for Hall thruster discharges

Authors: Stefano Boccelli, James G. McDonald, Thierry E. Magin

Abstract: Ions in Hall effect thrusters are often characterized by a low collisionality. In the presence of acceleration fields and azimuthal electric field waves, this results in strong deviations from thermodynamic equilibrium, introducing kinetic effects. This work investigates the application of the 14-moment maximum-entropy model to this problem. This method consists in a set of 14 PDEs for the density… ▽ More Ions in Hall effect thrusters are often characterized by a low collisionality. In the presence of acceleration fields and azimuthal electric field waves, this results in strong deviations from thermodynamic equilibrium, introducing kinetic effects. This work investigates the application of the 14-moment maximum-entropy model to this problem. This method consists in a set of 14 PDEs for the density, momentum, pressure tensor components, heat flux vector and fourth-order moment associated to the particle velocity distribution function. The model is applied to the study of collisionless ion dynamics in a Hall thruster-like configuration, and its accuracy is assessed against different models, including the Vlasov kinetic equation. Three test cases are considered: a purely axial acceleration problem, the problem of ion-wave trap** and finally the evolution of ions in the axial-azimuthal plane. Most of this work considers ions only, and the coupling with electrons is removed by prescribing reasonable values of the electric field. This allows us to obtain a direct comparison among different ion models. However, the possibility to run self-consistent plasma simulations is also briefly discussed, considering quasi-neutral or multi-fluid models. The maximum-entropy system appears to be a robust and accurate option for the considered test cases. The accuracy is improved over the simpler pressureless gas model (cold ions) and the Euler equations for gas dynamics, while the computational cost shows to remain much lower than direct kinetic simulations. △ Less

Submitted 31 July, 2022; v1 submitted 8 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Numerical investigation of reversed gas feed configurations for Hall thrusters

Authors: Stefano Boccelli, Thierry E. Magin, Aldo Frezzotti

Abstract: A reversed gas feed configuration for Hall thrusters is proposed and studied numerically. As an alternative to standard direct injection, we investigate the effect of injecting the propellant near the channel exit and directing it backwards, towards the anode. The resulting neutral density and average velocity fields are studied with the Direct Simulation Monte Carlo method for both cold and warm… ▽ More A reversed gas feed configuration for Hall thrusters is proposed and studied numerically. As an alternative to standard direct injection, we investigate the effect of injecting the propellant near the channel exit and directing it backwards, towards the anode. The resulting neutral density and average velocity fields are studied with the Direct Simulation Monte Carlo method for both cold and warm anode conditions. The residence time of neutral particles inside the channel and in the ionization region is computed using a test-particle Monte Carlo method. The computations indicate that the reversed injection allows for increasing the mass utilization efficiency of a standard feed configuration from 2-5% to a maximum of 20-30% depending on the initial efficiency. △ Less

Submitted 14 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

A 14-moment maximum-entropy description of electrons in crossed electric and magnetic fields

Authors: Stefano Boccelli, Fabien Giroux, Thierry E. Magin, Clinton P. T. Groth, James G. McDonald

Abstract: A 14-moment maximum-entropy system of equations is applied to the description of non-equilibrium electrons in crossed electric and magnetic fields and in the presence of low collisionality, characteristic of low-temperature plasma devices. The flexibility of this formulation is analyzed through comparison with analytical results for steady-state non-equilibrium velocity distribution functions and… ▽ More A 14-moment maximum-entropy system of equations is applied to the description of non-equilibrium electrons in crossed electric and magnetic fields and in the presence of low collisionality, characteristic of low-temperature plasma devices. The flexibility of this formulation is analyzed through comparison with analytical results for steady-state non-equilibrium velocity distribution functions and against particle-based solutions of the time-dependent kinetic equation. Electric and magnetic source terms are derived for the 14-moment equations, starting from kinetic theory. A simplified BGK-like collision term is formulated to describe the collision of electrons with background neutrals, accounting for the large mass disparity and for energy exchange. An approximated expression is proposed for the collision frequency, to include the effect of the electrons drift velocity, showing good accuracy in the considered conditions. The capabilities of the proposed 14-moment closure to capture accurately non-equilibrium behaviour of electrons for space homogeneous problems under conditions representative of those found in Hall thrusters is demonstrated. △ Less

Submitted 26 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

MSC Class: 82-08

Journal ref: Physics of Plasmas 27, 123506 (2020)

How to build coarse-grain transport models consistent from the kinetic to fluid regimes

Authors: Erik Torres, Georgios Bellas-Chatzigeorgis, Thierry E. Magin

Abstract: In this paper, we examine how to build coarse-grain transport models consistently from the kinetic to fluid regimes. The internal energy of the gas particles is described through a state-to-state approach. A kinetic equation allows us to study transport phenomena in phase space for a non-homogeneous gas mixture. Internal energy excitation is modeled using a binary collision operator, whereas the g… ▽ More In this paper, we examine how to build coarse-grain transport models consistently from the kinetic to fluid regimes. The internal energy of the gas particles is described through a state-to-state approach. A kinetic equation allows us to study transport phenomena in phase space for a non-homogeneous gas mixture. Internal energy excitation is modeled using a binary collision operator, whereas the gas chemical processes rely on a reactive collision operator. We obtain an asymptotic fluid model by means of a Chapman-Enskog perturbative solution to the Boltzmann equation in the Maxwellian reaction regime. The macroscopic conservation equations of species mass, mixture momentum, and energy are given, as well as expressions of the transport properties. Reversibility relations for elementary processes are formulated in the coarse-grain model at the kinetic level and are enforced in the collision algorithm of the direct simulation Monte Carlo method used to solve the kinetic equation. Furthermore, respecting these reversibility relations is key to deriving a fluid model that is well-posed and compatible with the second law of thermodynamics. Consistency between the kinetic and fluid simulations is assessed for the simulation of a shock wave in a nitrogen gas using the uniform rovibrational collisional coarse-grain model. The kinetic and fluid simulations show consistency for the macroscopic properties and transport fluxes between both regimes. △ Less

Submitted 11 November, 2020; v1 submitted 1 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: Submitted to Physics of Fluids, 59 pages, 16 figures, minor changes to abstract and main text, major changes to introduction and conclusions, corrected typos, added references, updated affiliations

Journal ref: Phys. Fluids (2021)

A surrogate-based optimal likelihood function for the Bayesian calibration of catalytic recombination in atmospheric entry protection materials

Authors: Anabel del Val, Olivier P. Le Maître, Olivier Chazot, Thierry E. Magin, Pietro M. Congedo

Abstract: This work deals with the inference of catalytic recombination parameters from plasma wind tunnel experiments for reusable thermal protection materials. One of the critical factors affecting the performance of such materials is the contribution to the heat flux of the exothermic recombination reactions at the vehicle surface. The main objective of this work is to develop a dedicated Bayesian framew… ▽ More This work deals with the inference of catalytic recombination parameters from plasma wind tunnel experiments for reusable thermal protection materials. One of the critical factors affecting the performance of such materials is the contribution to the heat flux of the exothermic recombination reactions at the vehicle surface. The main objective of this work is to develop a dedicated Bayesian framework that allows us to compare uncertain measurements with model predictions which depend on the catalytic parameter values. Our framework accounts for uncertainties involved in the model definition and incorporates all measured variables with their respective uncertainties. The physical model used for the estimation consists of a 1D boundary layer solver along the stagnation line. The chemical production term included in the surface mass balance depends on the catalytic recombination efficiency. As not all the different quantities needed to simulate a reacting boundary layer can be measured or known (such as the flow enthalpy at the inlet boundary), we propose an optimization procedure built on the construction of the likelihood function to determine their most likely values based on the available experimental data. This procedure avoids the need to introduce any a priori estimates on the nuisance quantities, namely, the boundary layer edge enthalpy, wall temperatures, static and dynamic pressures, which would entail the use of very wide priors. We substitute the optimal likelihood of the experimental data with a surrogate model to make the inference procedure both faster and more robust. We show that the resulting Bayesian formulation yields meaningful and accurate posterior distributions of the catalytic parameters with a reduction of more than 20% of the standard deviation with respect to previous works. We also study the implications of an extension of the experimental procedure. △ Less

Submitted 9 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

Collisionless ion modeling in Hall thrusters: analytical axial velocity distribution function and heat flux closures

Authors: Stefano Boccelli, Thomas Charoi, Alejandro Alvarez-Laguna, Pascal Chabert, Anne Bourdon, Thierry E. Magin

Abstract: The genesis of the ion axial velocity distribution function (VDF) is analyzed for collisionless Hall thruster discharges. An analytical form for the VDF is obtained from the Vlasov equation, by applying the Tonks-Langmuir theory in the thruster channel, under the simplifying assumptions of monoenergetic creation of ions and steady state. The equivalent set of 1D unsteady anisotropic moment equatio… ▽ More The genesis of the ion axial velocity distribution function (VDF) is analyzed for collisionless Hall thruster discharges. An analytical form for the VDF is obtained from the Vlasov equation, by applying the Tonks-Langmuir theory in the thruster channel, under the simplifying assumptions of monoenergetic creation of ions and steady state. The equivalent set of 1D unsteady anisotropic moment equations is derived from the Vlasov equation, and simple phenomenological closures are formulated, assuming a polynomial shape for the ions VDF. The analytical results and the anisotropic moment equations are compared to collisionless PIC simulations, employing either a zero heat flux (Euler-like equations) or the polynomial-VDF closure for the heat flux. The analytical ion VDF and its moments are then compared to experimental measurements. △ Less

Submitted 9 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Mutation++: MUlticomponent Thermodynamic And Transport properties for IONized gases in C++

Authors: James B. Scoggins, Vincent Leroy, Georgios Bellas-Chatzigeorgis, Bruno Dias, Thierry E. Magin

Abstract: The Mutation++ library provides accurate and efficient computation of physicochemical properties associated with partially ionized gases in various degrees of thermal nonequilibrium. With v1.0.0, users can compute thermodynamic and transport properties, multiphase linearly-constrained equilibria, chemical production rates, energy transfer rates, and gas-surface interactions. The framework is based… ▽ More The Mutation++ library provides accurate and efficient computation of physicochemical properties associated with partially ionized gases in various degrees of thermal nonequilibrium. With v1.0.0, users can compute thermodynamic and transport properties, multiphase linearly-constrained equilibria, chemical production rates, energy transfer rates, and gas-surface interactions. The framework is based on an object-oriented design in C++, allowing users to plug-and-play various models, algorithms, and data as necessary. Mutation++ is available open-source under the GNU Lesser General Public License v3.0. △ Less

Submitted 5 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Comments: Mutation++ is available open-source at https://github.com/mutationpp/Mutationpp

Lagrangian diffusive reactor for detailed thermochemical computations of plasma flows

Authors: Stefano Boccelli, Federico Bariselli, Bruno Dias, Thierry E. Magin

Abstract: The simulation of thermochemical nonequilibrium for the atomic and molecular energy level populations in plasma flows requires a comprehensive modeling of all the elementary collisional and radiative processes involved. Coupling detailed chemical mechanisms to flow solvers is computationally expensive and often limits their application to 1D simulations. We develop an efficient Lagrangian diffusiv… ▽ More The simulation of thermochemical nonequilibrium for the atomic and molecular energy level populations in plasma flows requires a comprehensive modeling of all the elementary collisional and radiative processes involved. Coupling detailed chemical mechanisms to flow solvers is computationally expensive and often limits their application to 1D simulations. We develop an efficient Lagrangian diffusive reactor moving along the streamlines of a baseline flow simulation to compute detailed thermochemical effects. In addition to its efficiency, the method allows us to model both continuum and rarefied flows, while including mass and energy diffusion. The Lagrangian solver is assessed for several testcases including strong normal shockwaves, as well as 2D axisymmetric blunt-body hypersonic rarefied flows. In all the testcases performed, the Lagrangian reactor improves drastically the baseline simulations. The computational cost of a Lagrangian recomputation is typically orders of magnitude smaller with respect to a full solution of the problem. The solver has the additional benefit of being immune from statistical noise, which strongly affects the accuracy of DSMC simulations, especially considering minor species in the mixture. The results demonstrate that the method enables applying detailed mechanisms to multidimensional solvers to study thermo-chemical nonequilibrium flows. △ Less

Submitted 10 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Coupling of state-resolved rovibrational coarse-grain model for nitrogen to stochastic particle method for simulating internal energy excitation and dissociation

Authors: Erik Torres, Thierry E. Magin

Abstract: We propose to couple a state-resolved rovibrational coarse-grain model to a stochastic particle method for simulating internal energy excitation and dissociation of a molecular gas. An existing coarse-grain model based on the NASA Ames ab initio database for the N2-N system is modified using variably-spaced energy bins. Thermodynamic properties of the new coarse-grained model closely match those o… ▽ More We propose to couple a state-resolved rovibrational coarse-grain model to a stochastic particle method for simulating internal energy excitation and dissociation of a molecular gas. An existing coarse-grain model based on the NASA Ames ab initio database for the N2-N system is modified using variably-spaced energy bins. Thermodynamic properties of the new coarse-grained model closely match those of the full set of rovibrational levels over a wide temperature range, using a number of bins much smaller than the complete mechanism. The chemical-kinetic behavior of the original equally -- and new variably -- spaced bin formulations is compared by simulating excitation and dissociation of N2 in an adiabatic, isochoric reactor. The variably-spaced formulation is better suited for reproducing the dynamics of the full database at conditions of interest in Earth reentry. Furthermore, we discuss details of our Direct Simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) implementation for the coarse-grain model and describe changes to the collision algorithm necessary to accommodate our state-resolved reaction mechanism. The DSMC code is then verified against equivalent master equation (ME) calculations. In these simulations, state-resolved cross sections are used in analytical form. They verify micro-reversibility for the bins and allow for faster execution of the code. In our verification, we obtain very close agreement for the N and N2 concentrations, as well as the translational and rovibrational mode temperatures obtained independently using both methods. In addition to macroscopic moments, we compare internal energy populations predicted at selected time steps via DSMC and ME. We observe good agreement between both methods within the statistical scatter limits imposed by DSMC. In future work, the rovibrational coarse-grain model coupled to the particle method will allow us to study 3D reentry flow configurations. △ Less

Submitted 25 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 40 pages, 19 figures

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 149, 174106 (2018)

State-resolved coarse-grain cross sections for rovibrational excitation and dissociation of nitrogen based on ab initio data for the N2-N system

Authors: Erik Torres, Richard L. Jaffe, David Schwenke, Thierry E. Magin

Abstract: In this paper, we present a method to generate state-resolved reaction cross sections in analytical form for rovibrational energy excitation and dissociation of a molecular gas. The method is applied to an ab initio database for the N2-N system devel- oped at NASA Ames Research Center. The detailed information on N2 +N collisions contained in this database has been reduced by adapting a Uniform Ro… ▽ More In this paper, we present a method to generate state-resolved reaction cross sections in analytical form for rovibrational energy excitation and dissociation of a molecular gas. The method is applied to an ab initio database for the N2-N system devel- oped at NASA Ames Research Center. The detailed information on N2 +N collisions contained in this database has been reduced by adapting a Uniform RoVibrational- Collisional bin model originally developed for rate coefficients. Using a 10-bin system as an example, a comparison is made between two sets of coarse-grain cross sections, obtained by analytical inversion and direct binning respectively. The analytical in- version approach is especially powerful, because it manages to compress the entire set of rovibrational-level-specific data from the Ames database into a much smaller set of numerical parameters, sufficient to reconstruct all coarse-grain cross sections for any particular N2 +N-collision pair. As a result of this approach, the computational cost in in large-scale Direct Simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) flow simulations is sig- nificantly reduced, both in terms of memory requirements and execution time. The intended application is the simulation of high-temperature gas-dynamics phenomena in shock-heated flows via the DSMC method. Such conditions are typically encoun- tered in high-altitude, high-speed atmospheric entry, or in shock-tube experiments. Using this coarse-grain model together with ab initio rate data will enable more accu- rate modeling nonequilibrium phenomena, such as vibrationally-favored dissociation, an effect that is not well-captured by the conventional models prevalent in DSMC (i.e. Larsen-Borgnakke and Total Collision Energy). △ Less

Submitted 24 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 33 pages, 14 figures

Journal ref: Chemical Physics, 533 (2020), 110701

A Spectral-Lagrangian Boltzmann Solver for a Multi-Energy Level Gas

Authors: Alessandro Munafo, Jeffrey R. Haack, Irene M. Gamba, Thierry E. Magin

Abstract: In this paper a spectral-Lagrangian method for the Boltzmann equation for a multi-energy level gas is proposed. Internal energy levels are treated as separate species and inelastic collisions (leading to internal energy excitation and relaxation) are accounted for. The formulation developed can also be used for the case of a mixture of monatomic gases without internal energy (where only elastic co… ▽ More In this paper a spectral-Lagrangian method for the Boltzmann equation for a multi-energy level gas is proposed. Internal energy levels are treated as separate species and inelastic collisions (leading to internal energy excitation and relaxation) are accounted for. The formulation developed can also be used for the case of a mixture of monatomic gases without internal energy (where only elastic collisions occur). The advantage of the spectral-Lagrangian method lies in the generality of the algorithm in use for the evaluation of the elastic and inelastic collision operators. The computational procedure is based on the Fourier transform of the partial elastic and inelastic collision operators and exploits the fact that these can be written as weighted convolutions in Fourier space with no restriction on the cross- section model. The conservation of mass, momentum and energy during collisions is enforced through the solution of constrained optimization problems. Numerical solutions are obtained for both space homogeneous and space in- homogeneous problems. Computational results are compared with those obtained by means of the DSMC method in order to assess the accuracy of the proposed spectral-Lagrangian method. △ Less

Submitted 22 May, 2013; originally announced May 2013.

Kinetic Theory of Plasmas: Translational Energy

Authors: Benjamin Graille, Thierry E. Magin, Marc Massot

Abstract: In the present contribution, we derive from kinetic theory a unified fluid model for multicomponent plasmas by accounting for the electromagnetic field influence. We deal with a possible thermal nonequilibrium of the translational energy of the particles, neglecting their internal energy and the reactive collisions. Given the strong disparity of mass between the electrons and heavy particles, su… ▽ More In the present contribution, we derive from kinetic theory a unified fluid model for multicomponent plasmas by accounting for the electromagnetic field influence. We deal with a possible thermal nonequilibrium of the translational energy of the particles, neglecting their internal energy and the reactive collisions. Given the strong disparity of mass between the electrons and heavy particles, such as molecules, atoms, and ions, we conduct a dimensional analysis of the Boltzmann equation. We then generalize the Chapman-Enskog method, emphasizing the role of a multiscale perturbation parameter on the collisional operator, the streaming operator, and the collisional invariants of the Boltzmann equation. The system is examined at successive orders of approximation, each of which corresponding to a physical time scale. The multicomponent Navier-Stokes regime is reached for the heavy particles, which follow a hyperbolic scaling, and is coupled to first order drift-diffusion equations for the electrons, which follow a parabolic scaling. The transport coefficients exhibit an anisotropic behavior when the magnetic field is strong enough. We also give a complete description of the Kolesnikov effect, i.e., the crossed contributions to the mass and energy transport fluxes coupling the electrons and heavy particles. Finally, the first and second principles of thermodynamics are proved to be satisfied by deriving a total energy equation and an entropy equation. Moreover, the system of equations is shown to be conservative and the purely convective system hyperbolic, thus leading to a well-defined structure. △ Less

Submitted 5 November, 2007; originally announced November 2007.

Journal ref: Mathematical Models and Methods in Applied Sciences, Vol. 19, 04 (2009) 527-599