"Just a little bit on the outside for the whole time": Social belonging confidence and the persistence of Machine Learning and Artificial Intelligence students
Authors:
Katherine Mao,
Sharon Ferguson,
James Magarian,
Alison Olechowski
Abstract:
The growing field of machine learning (ML) and artificial intelligence (AI) presents a unique and unexplored case within persistence research, meaning it is unclear how past findings from engineering will apply to this develo** field. We conduct an exploratory study to gain an initial understanding of persistence in this field and identify fruitful directions for future work. One factor that has…
▽ More
The growing field of machine learning (ML) and artificial intelligence (AI) presents a unique and unexplored case within persistence research, meaning it is unclear how past findings from engineering will apply to this develo** field. We conduct an exploratory study to gain an initial understanding of persistence in this field and identify fruitful directions for future work. One factor that has been shown to predict persistence in engineering is belonging; we study belonging through the lens of confidence, and discuss how attention to social belonging confidence may help to increase diversity in the profession. In this research paper, we conduct a small set of interviews with students in ML/AI courses. Thematic analysis of these interviews revealed initial differences in how students see a career in ML/AI, which diverge based on interest and programming confidence. We identified how exposure and initiation, the interpretation of ML and AI field boundaries, and beliefs of the skills required to succeed might influence students' intentions to persist. We discuss differences in how students describe being motivated by social belonging and the importance of close mentorship. We motivate further persistence research in ML/AI with particular focus on social belonging and close mentorship, the role of intersectional identity, and introductory ML/AI courses.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
Advancing a Model of Students' Intentional Persistence in Machine Learning and Artificial Intelligence
Authors:
Sharon Ferguson,
Katherine Mao,
James Magarian,
Alison Olechowski
Abstract:
Machine Learning (ML) and Artificial Intelligence (AI) are powering the applications we use, the decisions we make, and the decisions made about us. We have seen numerous examples of non-equitable outcomes, from facial recognition algorithms to recidivism algorithms, when they are designed without diversity in mind. Thus, we must take action to promote diversity among those in this field. A critic…
▽ More
Machine Learning (ML) and Artificial Intelligence (AI) are powering the applications we use, the decisions we make, and the decisions made about us. We have seen numerous examples of non-equitable outcomes, from facial recognition algorithms to recidivism algorithms, when they are designed without diversity in mind. Thus, we must take action to promote diversity among those in this field. A critical step in this work is understanding why some students who choose to study ML/AI later leave the field. While the persistence of diverse populations has been studied in engineering, there is a lack of research investigating factors that influence persistence in ML/AI. In this work, we present the advancement of a model of intentional persistence in ML/AI by surveying students in ML/AI courses. We examine persistence across demographic groups, such as gender, international student status, student loan status, and visible minority status. We investigate independent variables that distinguish ML/AI from other STEM fields, such as the varying emphasis on non-technical skills, the ambiguous ethical implications of the work, and the highly competitive and lucrative nature of the field. Our findings suggest that short-term intentional persistence is associated with academic enrollment factors such as major and level of study. Long-term intentional persistence is correlated with measures of professional role confidence. Unique to our study, we show that wanting your work to have a positive social benefit is a negative predictor of long-term intentional persistence, and women generally care more about this. We provide recommendations to educators to meaningfully discuss ML/AI ethics in classes and encourage the development of interpersonal skills to help increase diversity in the field.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
