-
R-Trans -- A Recurrent Transformer Model for Clinical Feedback in Surgical Skill Assessment
Authors:
Julien Quarez,
Matthew Elliot,
Oscar Maccormac,
Nawal Khan,
Marc Modat,
Sebastien Ourselin,
Jonathan Shapey,
Alejandro Granados
Abstract:
In surgical skill assessment, Objective Structured Assessments of Technical Skills (OSATS scores) and the Global Rating Scale (GRS) are established tools for evaluating the performance of surgeons during training. These metrics, coupled with feedback on their performance, enable surgeons to improve and achieve standards of practice. Recent studies on the open-source dataset JIGSAW, which contains…
▽ More
In surgical skill assessment, Objective Structured Assessments of Technical Skills (OSATS scores) and the Global Rating Scale (GRS) are established tools for evaluating the performance of surgeons during training. These metrics, coupled with feedback on their performance, enable surgeons to improve and achieve standards of practice. Recent studies on the open-source dataset JIGSAW, which contains both GRS and OSATS labels, have focused on regressing GRS scores from kinematic signals, video data, or a combination of both. In this paper, we argue that regressing the GRS score, a unitless value, by itself is too restrictive, and variations throughout the surgical trial do not hold significant clinical meaning. To address this gap, we developed a recurrent transformer model that outputs the surgeon's performance throughout their training session by relating the model's hidden states to five OSATS scores derived from kinematic signals. These scores are averaged and aggregated to produce a GRS prediction, enabling assessment of the model's performance against the state-of-the-art (SOTA). We report Spearman's Correlation Coefficient (SCC), demonstrating that our model outperforms SOTA models for all tasks, except for Suturing under the leave-one-subject-out (LOSO) scheme (SCC 0.68-0.89), while achieving comparable performance for suturing and across tasks under the leave-one-user-out (LOUO) scheme (SCC 0.45-0.68) and beating SOTA for Needle Passing (0.69). We argue that relating final OSATS scores to short instances throughout a surgeon's procedure is more clinically meaningful than a single GRS score. This approach also allows us to translate quantitative predictions into qualitative feedback, which is crucial for any automated surgical skill assessment pipeline. A senior surgeon validated our model's behaviour and agreed with the semi-supervised predictions 77 \% (p = 0.006) of the time.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Synthetic white balancing for intra-operative hyperspectral imaging
Authors:
Anisha Bahl,
Conor C. Horgan,
Mirek Janatka,
Oscar J. MacCormac,
Philip Noonan,
Yi**g Xie,
Jianrong Qiu,
Nicola Cavalcanti,
Philipp Fürnstahl,
Michael Ebner,
Mads S. Bergholt,
Jonathan Shapey,
Tom Vercauteren
Abstract:
Hyperspectral imaging shows promise for surgical applications to non-invasively provide spatially-resolved, spectral information. For calibration purposes, a white reference image of a highly-reflective Lambertian surface should be obtained under the same imaging conditions. Standard white references are not sterilizable, and so are unsuitable for surgical environments. We demonstrate the necessit…
▽ More
Hyperspectral imaging shows promise for surgical applications to non-invasively provide spatially-resolved, spectral information. For calibration purposes, a white reference image of a highly-reflective Lambertian surface should be obtained under the same imaging conditions. Standard white references are not sterilizable, and so are unsuitable for surgical environments. We demonstrate the necessity for in situ white references and address this by proposing a novel, sterile, synthetic reference construction algorithm. The use of references obtained at different distances and lighting conditions to the subject were examined. Spectral and color reconstructions were compared with standard measurements qualitatively and quantitatively, using $ΔE$ and normalised RMSE respectively. The algorithm forms a composite image from a video of a standard sterile ruler, whose imperfect reflectivity is compensated for. The reference is modelled as the product of independent spatial and spectral components, and a scalar factor accounting for gain, exposure, and light intensity. Evaluation of synthetic references against ideal but non-sterile references is performed using the same metrics alongside pixel-by-pixel errors. Finally, intraoperative integration is assessed though cadaveric experiments. Improper white balancing leads to increases in all quantitative and qualitative errors. Synthetic references achieve median pixel-by-pixel errors lower than 6.5% and produce similar reconstructions and errors to an ideal reference. The algorithm integrated well into surgical workflow, achieving median pixel-by-pixel errors of 4.77%, while maintaining good spectral and color reconstruction.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Deep Reinforcement Learning Based System for Intraoperative Hyperspectral Video Autofocusing
Authors:
Charlie Budd,
Jianrong Qiu,
Oscar MacCormac,
Martin Huber,
Christopher Mower,
Mirek Janatka,
Théo Trotouin,
Jonathan Shapey,
Mads S. Bergholt,
Tom Vercauteren
Abstract:
Hyperspectral imaging (HSI) captures a greater level of spectral detail than traditional optical imaging, making it a potentially valuable intraoperative tool when precise tissue differentiation is essential. Hardware limitations of current optical systems used for handheld real-time video HSI result in a limited focal depth, thereby posing usability issues for integration of the technology into t…
▽ More
Hyperspectral imaging (HSI) captures a greater level of spectral detail than traditional optical imaging, making it a potentially valuable intraoperative tool when precise tissue differentiation is essential. Hardware limitations of current optical systems used for handheld real-time video HSI result in a limited focal depth, thereby posing usability issues for integration of the technology into the operating room. This work integrates a focus-tunable liquid lens into a video HSI exoscope, and proposes novel video autofocusing methods based on deep reinforcement learning. A first-of-its-kind robotic focal-time scan was performed to create a realistic and reproducible testing dataset. We benchmarked our proposed autofocus algorithm against traditional policies, and found our novel approach to perform significantly ($p<0.05$) better than traditional techniques ($0.070\pm.098$ mean absolute focal error compared to $0.146\pm.148$). In addition, we performed a blinded usability trial by having two neurosurgeons compare the system with different autofocus policies, and found our novel approach to be the most favourable, making our system a desirable addition for intraoperative HSI.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Spatial gradient consistency for unsupervised learning of hyperspectral demosaicking: Application to surgical imaging
Authors:
Peichao Li,
Muhammad Asad,
Conor Horgan,
Oscar MacCormac,
Jonathan Shapey,
Tom Vercauteren
Abstract:
Hyperspectral imaging has the potential to improve intraoperative decision making if tissue characterisation is performed in real-time and with high-resolution. Hyperspectral snapshot mosaic sensors offer a promising approach due to their fast acquisition speed and compact size. However, a demosaicking algorithm is required to fully recover the spatial and spectral information of the snapshot imag…
▽ More
Hyperspectral imaging has the potential to improve intraoperative decision making if tissue characterisation is performed in real-time and with high-resolution. Hyperspectral snapshot mosaic sensors offer a promising approach due to their fast acquisition speed and compact size. However, a demosaicking algorithm is required to fully recover the spatial and spectral information of the snapshot images. Most state-of-the-art demosaicking algorithms require ground-truth training data with paired snapshot and high-resolution hyperspectral images, but such imagery pairs with the exact same scene are physically impossible to acquire in intraoperative settings. In this work, we present a fully unsupervised hyperspectral image demosaicking algorithm which only requires exemplar snapshot images for training purposes. We regard hyperspectral demosaicking as an ill-posed linear inverse problem which we solve using a deep neural network. We take advantage of the spectral correlation occurring in natural scenes to design a novel inter spectral band regularisation term based on spatial gradient consistency. By combining our proposed term with standard regularisation techniques and exploiting a standard data fidelity term, we obtain an unsupervised loss function for training deep neural networks, which allows us to achieve real-time hyperspectral image demosaicking. Quantitative results on hyperspetral image datasets show that our unsupervised demosaicking approach can achieve similar performance to its supervised counter-part, and significantly outperform linear demosaicking. A qualitative user study on real snapshot hyperspectral surgical images confirms the results from the quantitative analysis. Our results suggest that the proposed unsupervised algorithm can achieve promising hyperspectral demosaicking in real-time thus advancing the suitability of the modality for intraoperative use.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
