-
Enhancing detection of labor violations in the agricultural sector: A multilevel generalized linear regression model of H-2A violation counts
Authors:
Arezoo Jafari,
Priscila De Azevedo Drummond,
Dominic Nishigaya,
Shawn Bhimani,
Aidong Adam Ding,
Amy Farrell,
Kayse Lee Maass
Abstract:
Agricultural workers are essential to the supply chain for our daily food and yet, many face harmful work conditions, including garnished wages, and other labor violations. Workers on H-2A visas are particularly vulnerable due to the precarity of their immigration status being tied to their employer. Although worksite inspections are one mechanism to detect such violations, many labor violations a…
▽ More
Agricultural workers are essential to the supply chain for our daily food and yet, many face harmful work conditions, including garnished wages, and other labor violations. Workers on H-2A visas are particularly vulnerable due to the precarity of their immigration status being tied to their employer. Although worksite inspections are one mechanism to detect such violations, many labor violations affecting agricultural workers go undetected due to limited inspection resources. In this study, we identify multiple state and industry level factors that correlate with H-2A violations identified by the U.S. Department of Labor Wage and Hour Division using a multilevel zero-inflated negative binomial model. We find that three state-level factors (average farm acreage size, the number of agricultural establishments with less than 20 employees, and higher poverty rates) are correlated with H-2A violations. These findings provide guidance for inspection agencies regarding how to prioritize their limited resources to more effectively inspect agricultural workplaces, thereby improving workplace conditions for H-2A workers.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Policy Interventions to Improve Inpatient Mental Healthcare Access: A Discrete Event Simulation Study
Authors:
Nathan O. Adeyemi,
Kayse Lee Maass,
Amanda M. Graham,
Kalyan S. Pasupathy
Abstract:
For a large portion of mental health patients, the Emergency Department is the first point of contact when in crisis and in need of urgent acute care. Unfortunately, those who have already received an admission disposition may wait hours or days after before being placed in a psychiatric inpatient (IP) care unit. Known as ED boarding, one primary contributor is the inability to locate an available…
▽ More
For a large portion of mental health patients, the Emergency Department is the first point of contact when in crisis and in need of urgent acute care. Unfortunately, those who have already received an admission disposition may wait hours or days after before being placed in a psychiatric inpatient (IP) care unit. Known as ED boarding, one primary contributor is the inability to locate an available IP bed for transferred patients. In this study, we develop a discrete event simulation modeling patients arriving at numerous EDs throughout the region, as they're either internally placed in a psychiatric IP care unit or externally transferred to an IP unit located outside the ED they originally arrived. This simulation is then used to investigate the effect of three proposed interventions to the IP bed placement process on key performance indicators like patient treatment delay, a metric incorporating both the patient's ED boarding period and time to travel to their eventual IP destination.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Queue Routing Strategies to Improve Equitable Housing Coordination in New York City
Authors:
Yaren Bilge Kaya,
Kayse Lee Maass
Abstract:
Runaway and homeless youth (RHY) are a group of youth and young adults who are at high risk of being exploited through human trafficking. Although access to housing and support services is an effective way to decrease their vulnerability to being exploited, research reveals that coordination of these services provided to RHY by non-profit and government organizations is neither standardized, nor e…
▽ More
Runaway and homeless youth (RHY) are a group of youth and young adults who are at high risk of being exploited through human trafficking. Although access to housing and support services is an effective way to decrease their vulnerability to being exploited, research reveals that coordination of these services provided to RHY by non-profit and government organizations is neither standardized, nor efficient. This situation often causes decreased, delayed, and inequitable access to these scarce housing resources. In this study, we aim to increase the housing system efficiency and reduce the barriers that are contributing to inequitable access to housing through simulation modeling and analyses. Specifically, we simulate a set of crisis and emergency shelters in New York City, funded by a single governmental organization, considering a queuing network with pools of multiple parallel servers, servers with demographic eligibility criteria, stochastic RHY arrival, impatient youth behaviour (possibility of abandonment), and a decision-maker (coordinator) that determines which server pool RHY is routed to. This simulation allows us to evaluate the impact of different queue routing strategies. Our simulation results show that by changing the way RHY is routed to shelters, we can reduce the average wait time by approximately a day and decrease the proportion of RHY abandoning the shelters by 13%.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
On the Optimization of Benefit to Cost Ratios for Public Sector Decision Making
Authors:
Frederick "Forrest" Miller,
Yaren Bilge Kaya,
Geri L. Dimas,
Renata Konrad,
Kayse Lee Maass,
Andrew C. Trapp
Abstract:
Decision making in the public sector centers on delivering resources and services for the common good, emphasizing an expansive set of objectives such as equity and efficiency, beyond immediate short term returns to reflect the broader cares of society and public beneficiaries. Cost-benefit analysis is a prevailing decision-making framework in the public sector that often uses the benefit to cost…
▽ More
Decision making in the public sector centers on delivering resources and services for the common good, emphasizing an expansive set of objectives such as equity and efficiency, beyond immediate short term returns to reflect the broader cares of society and public beneficiaries. Cost-benefit analysis is a prevailing decision-making framework in the public sector that often uses the benefit to cost ratio (BCR) to compare viable alternatives, yet no systematic framework exists for evaluating many alternatives beyond the status quo of doing nothing. We propose a new framework to maximize the BCR for public sector decisions, seeking the largest improvement per marginal deployment of capacity. Requiring a status quo representable through (constrained) decision variables, the framework is generally applicable and useful to a broad set of decision contexts that involve maximizing the BCR for marginal deployments of resources. We demonstrate the applicability of our framework on a compelling case study for the New York City runaway and homeless youth shelter system, an area of high societal need. We represent this problem as a mixed integer linear fractional program (MILFP) and employ Dinkelbach's algorithm that converts the MILFP to a series of linearized mixed-integer optimization problems, making our approach tractable for fairly large problem instances. Our optimization-based algorithmic framework yields data-informed recommendations for making New York City shelter expansion decisions to better serve runaway and homeless youth, and generalizes to reveal managerial insights for optimizing the BCR. More broadly, our algorithmic decision making framework allows for iteration and comparison across multiple potential constraints ensuring action away from the status quo, thereby empowering effective assessment of marginal deployment of additional resources.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2023; v1 submitted 8 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Leveraging Priority Thresholds to Improve Equitable Housing Access for Unhoused-at-Risk Youth
Authors:
Yaren Bilge Kaya,
Kayse Lee Maass
Abstract:
Approximately 4.2 million youth and young adults experience homelessness each year in the United States and lack of basic necessities puts this population at high-risk of being trafficked or exploited. Although all runaway and homeless youth (RHY) are at risk of being victims of human trafficking, certain racial, ethnic, and gender groups are disproportionately affected. Motivated by these facts,…
▽ More
Approximately 4.2 million youth and young adults experience homelessness each year in the United States and lack of basic necessities puts this population at high-risk of being trafficked or exploited. Although all runaway and homeless youth (RHY) are at risk of being victims of human trafficking, certain racial, ethnic, and gender groups are disproportionately affected. Motivated by these facts, our goal is to improve equitable access to housing resources for at-risk RHY in New York City (NYC) by expanding the current housing capacity, while utilizing priority thresholds that guide decisions regarding which youth should start receiving service based on the number of beds idle in the system. Our approach involves an $M/M/N/\{K_j\}+M$ queuing model with many statistically identical servers (beds) and RHY from different demographic groups with limited patience arriving to the a large crisis and emergency shelter in NYC. The queuing model allows us to: (i) investigate the populations and demographics that are facing access barriers, (ii) project the minimum number of beds required to provide a certain global service quality level to all youth, regardless of demographic characteristics, and (iii) use priority thresholds while matching RHY with beds to promote equity. The recommendations regarding the capacity expansion and priority thresholds improves equitable access to this crisis and emergency shelter by decreasing the average number of RHY abandoning the system by 92%, with a particular reduction in the abandonment of RHY who are at high-risk of experiencing trafficking.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Multi-Period Max Flow Network Interdiction with Restructuring for Disrupting Domestic Sex Trafficking Networks
Authors:
Daniel Kosmas,
Thomas C Sharkey,
John E Mitchell,
Kayse Lee Maass,
Lauren Martin
Abstract:
We consider a new class of multi-period network interdiction problems, where interdiction and restructuring decisions are decided upon before the network is operated and implemented throughout the time horizon. We discuss how we apply this new problem to disrupting domestic sex trafficking networks, and introduce a variant where a second cooperating attacker has the ability to interdict victims an…
▽ More
We consider a new class of multi-period network interdiction problems, where interdiction and restructuring decisions are decided upon before the network is operated and implemented throughout the time horizon. We discuss how we apply this new problem to disrupting domestic sex trafficking networks, and introduce a variant where a second cooperating attacker has the ability to interdict victims and prevent the recruitment of prospective victims. This problem is modeled as a bilevel mixed integer linear program (BMILP), and is solved using column-and-constraint generation with partial information. We also simplify the BMILP when all interdictions are implemented before the network is operated. Modeling-based augmentations are proposed to significantly improve the solution time in a majority of instances tested. We apply our method to synthetic domestic sex trafficking networks, and discuss policy implications from our model. In particular, we show how preventing the recruitment of prospective victims may be as essential to disrupting sex trafficking as interdicting existing participants.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2022; v1 submitted 9 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Discrete Event Simulation to Evaluate Shelter Capacity Expansion Options for LGBTQ+ Homeless Youth
Authors:
Yaren Bilge Kaya,
Sophia Mantell,
Kayse Lee Maass,
Renata Konrad,
Andrew C. Trapp,
Geri L. Dimas,
Meredith Dank
Abstract:
The New York City (NYC) youth shelter system provides housing, counseling, and other support services to runaway and homeless youth and young adults (RHY). These resources reduce RHYs vulnerability to human trafficking, yet most shelters are unable to meet demand. This paper presents a Discrete Event Simulation (DES) model of a crisis-emergency and drop-in center for LGBTQ+ youth in NYC, which aim…
▽ More
The New York City (NYC) youth shelter system provides housing, counseling, and other support services to runaway and homeless youth and young adults (RHY). These resources reduce RHYs vulnerability to human trafficking, yet most shelters are unable to meet demand. This paper presents a Discrete Event Simulation (DES) model of a crisis-emergency and drop-in center for LGBTQ+ youth in NYC, which aims to analyze the current operations and test potential capacity expansion interventions. The model uses data from publicly available resources and interviews with service providers and key stakeholders. The simulated shelter has 66 crisis-emergency beds, offers five different support services, and serves on average 1,399 LGBTQ+ RHY per year. The capacity expansion interventions examined in this paper are adding crisis-emergency beds and psychiatric therapists. This application of DES serves as a tool to communicate with policymakers, funders, and service providers potentially having a strong humanitarian impact.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2022; v1 submitted 27 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
A Transdisciplinary Approach for Generating Synthetic but Realistic Domestic Sex Trafficking Networks
Authors:
Daniel Kosmas,
Christina Melander,
Emily Singerhouse,
Thomas C. Sharkey,
Kayse Lee Maass,
Kelle Barrick,
Lauren Martin
Abstract:
One of the major challenges associated with applying operations research (OR) models to disrupting human trafficking networks is the limited amount of reliable data sources readily available for public use, since operations are intentionally hidden to prevent detection, and data from known operations are often incomplete. To help address this data gap, we propose a network generator for domestic s…
▽ More
One of the major challenges associated with applying operations research (OR) models to disrupting human trafficking networks is the limited amount of reliable data sources readily available for public use, since operations are intentionally hidden to prevent detection, and data from known operations are often incomplete. To help address this data gap, we propose a network generator for domestic sex trafficking networks by integrating OR concepts and qualitative research. Multiple sources regarding sex trafficking in the upper Midwest of the United States have been triangulated to ensure that networks produced by the generator are realistic, including law enforcement case file analysis, interviews with domain experts, and a survivor-centered advisory group with first-hand knowledge of sex trafficking. The output models the relationships between traffickers, so-called "bottoms", and victims. This generator allows operations researchers to access realistic sex trafficking network structures in a responsible manner that does not disclose identifiable details of the people involved. We demonstrate the use of output networks in exploring policy recommendations from max flow network interdiction with restructuring. To do so, we propose a novel conceptualization of flow as the ability of a trafficker to control their victims. Our results show the importance of understanding how sex traffickers react to disruptions, especially in terms of recruiting new victims.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2023; v1 submitted 3 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Improving Access to Housing and Supportive Services for Runaway and Homeless Youth: Reducing Vulnerability to Human Trafficking in New York City
Authors:
Yaren Bilge Kaya,
Kayse Lee Maass,
Geri L. Dimas,
Renata Konrad,
Andrew C. Trapp,
Meredith Dank
Abstract:
Recent estimates indicate that there are over 1 million runaway and homeless youth and young adults (RHY) in the United States (US). Exposure to trauma, violence, and substance abuse, coupled with a lack of community support services, puts homeless youth at high risk of being exploited and trafficked. Although access to safe housing and supportive services such as physical and mental healthcare is…
▽ More
Recent estimates indicate that there are over 1 million runaway and homeless youth and young adults (RHY) in the United States (US). Exposure to trauma, violence, and substance abuse, coupled with a lack of community support services, puts homeless youth at high risk of being exploited and trafficked. Although access to safe housing and supportive services such as physical and mental healthcare is an effective response to youths vulnerability towards being trafficked, the number of youth experiencing homelessness exceeds the capacity of available housing resources in most US communities. We undertake a RHY-informed, systematic, and data driven approach to project the collective capacity required by service providers to adequately meet the needs of homeless youth in New York City, including those most at risk of being trafficked. Our approach involves an integer linear programming model that extends the multiple multidimensional knapsack problem and is informed by partnerships with key stakeholders. The mathematical model allows for time-dependent allocation and capacity expansion, while incorporating stochastic youth arrivals and length of stays, services provided in a periodic fashion, and service delivery time windows. Our RHY and service provider-centered approach is an important step toward meeting the actual, rather than presumed, survival needs of vulnerable youth, particularly those at-risk of being trafficked.
△ Less
Submitted 31 August, 2022; v1 submitted 31 January, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Operations Research and Analytics to Combat Human Trafficking: A Systematic Review of Academic Literature
Authors:
Geri L. Dimas,
Renata A. Konrad,
Kayse Lee Maass,
Andrew C. Trapp
Abstract:
Human trafficking is a widespread and compound social, economic, and human rights issue occurring in every region of the world. While there have been an increasing number of anti-human trafficking works from the Operations Research and Analytics domains in recent years, no systematic review of this literature currently exists. We fill this gap by providing a systematic literature review that ident…
▽ More
Human trafficking is a widespread and compound social, economic, and human rights issue occurring in every region of the world. While there have been an increasing number of anti-human trafficking works from the Operations Research and Analytics domains in recent years, no systematic review of this literature currently exists. We fill this gap by providing a systematic literature review that identifies and classifies the body of Operations Research and Analytics research related to the anti-human trafficking domain, thereby illustrating the collective impact of the field to date. We classify 142 studies to identify current trends in methodologies, theoretical approaches, data sources, trafficking contexts, target regions, victim-survivor demographics, and focus within the well-established 4Ps principles. Using these findings, we discuss the extent to which the current literature aligns with the global demographics of human trafficking and identify existing research gaps to propose an agenda for Operations Research and Analytics researchers.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2022; v1 submitted 30 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Estimating Effectiveness of Identifying Human Trafficking via Data Envelopment Analysis
Authors:
Geri L. Dimas,
Malak El Khalkhali,
Alex Bender,
Kayse Lee Maass,
Renata Konrad,
Jeffrey S. Blom,
Joe Zhu,
Andrew C. Trapp
Abstract:
Transit monitoring is a preventative approach used to identify possible cases of human trafficking prior to exploitation while an individual is in transit or before one crosses a border. Transit monitoring is often conducted by non-governmental organizations (NGOs) who train staff to identify and intercept suspicious activity. Love Justice International (LJI) is a well-established NGO that has bee…
▽ More
Transit monitoring is a preventative approach used to identify possible cases of human trafficking prior to exploitation while an individual is in transit or before one crosses a border. Transit monitoring is often conducted by non-governmental organizations (NGOs) who train staff to identify and intercept suspicious activity. Love Justice International (LJI) is a well-established NGO that has been conducting transit monitoring for years along the Nepal-India border at multiple monitoring stations. In partnership with LJI, we developed a system that uses data envelopment analysis (DEA) to help LJI decision-makers evaluate the performance of these stations at intercepting potential human-trafficking victims given the amount of resources (e.g. staff, etc.) available and make specific operational improvement recommendations. Our model consists of 91 decision-making units (DMUs) from 7 stations over 13 quarters and considers three inputs, four outputs, and 3 homogeneity criteria. Using this model we identified efficient stations, compared rankings of station performance, and recommended strategies to improve efficiency. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first application of DEA in the anti-human trafficking domain.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2022; v1 submitted 9 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Interdicting Restructuring Networks with Applications in Illicit Trafficking
Authors:
Daniel Kosmas,
Thomas C. Sharkey,
John E. Mitchell,
Kayse Lee Maass,
Lauren Martin
Abstract:
We consider a new class of max flow network interdiction problems, where the defender is able to introduce new arcs to the network after the attacker has made their interdiction decisions. We prove properties of when this restructuring will not increase the value of the minimum cut, which has important practical interpretations for problems of disrupting drug trafficking networks. In particular, i…
▽ More
We consider a new class of max flow network interdiction problems, where the defender is able to introduce new arcs to the network after the attacker has made their interdiction decisions. We prove properties of when this restructuring will not increase the value of the minimum cut, which has important practical interpretations for problems of disrupting drug trafficking networks. In particular, it demonstrates that disrupting lower levels of these networks will not impact their operations when replacing the disrupted participants is easy. For the bilevel mixed integer linear programming formulation of this problem, we devise a column-and-constraint generation (C&CG) algorithm to solve it. Our approach uses partial information on the feasibility of restructuring plans and is shown to be orders of magnitude faster than previous C&CG methods. We demonstrate that applying decisions from standard max flow network interdiction problems can result in significantly higher flows than interdictions that account for the restructuring.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2022; v1 submitted 13 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Perspectives on How To Conduct Responsible Anti-Human Trafficking Research in Operations and Analytics
Authors:
Renata Konrad,
Kayse Lee Maass,
Geri L. Dimas,
Andrew C. Trapp
Abstract:
Human trafficking, the commercial exploitation of individuals, is a gross violation of human rights and harms societies, economies, health and development. The related disciplines of Operations Management (OM), Analytics, and Operations Research (OR) are uniquely positioned to support trafficking prevention and intervention efforts by efficiently evaluating a plethora of decision alternatives, and…
▽ More
Human trafficking, the commercial exploitation of individuals, is a gross violation of human rights and harms societies, economies, health and development. The related disciplines of Operations Management (OM), Analytics, and Operations Research (OR) are uniquely positioned to support trafficking prevention and intervention efforts by efficiently evaluating a plethora of decision alternatives, and providing quantitative, actionable insights. As operations and analytical efforts in the counter-trafficking field emerge, it is imperative to grasp subtle yet distinctive nuances associated with human trafficking. This note is intended to inform those practitioners working in the field by highlighting key features of human trafficking activity. We grouped nine themes around three broad categories: (1) representation of human trafficking, (2) consideration of survivors and communities, and (3) analytics related. These insights are derived from our collective experience in working in this area and substantiated by domain expertise.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2022; v1 submitted 29 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.