-
Measuring and Improving the Use of Graph Information in Graph Neural Networks
Authors:
Yifan Hou,
Jian Zhang,
James Cheng,
Kaili Ma,
Richard T. B. Ma,
Hongzhi Chen,
Ming-Chang Yang
Abstract:
Graph neural networks (GNNs) have been widely used for representation learning on graph data. However, there is limited understanding on how much performance GNNs actually gain from graph data. This paper introduces a context-surrounding GNN framework and proposes two smoothness metrics to measure the quantity and quality of information obtained from graph data. A new GNN model, called CS-GNN, is…
▽ More
Graph neural networks (GNNs) have been widely used for representation learning on graph data. However, there is limited understanding on how much performance GNNs actually gain from graph data. This paper introduces a context-surrounding GNN framework and proposes two smoothness metrics to measure the quantity and quality of information obtained from graph data. A new GNN model, called CS-GNN, is then designed to improve the use of graph information based on the smoothness values of a graph. CS-GNN is shown to achieve better performance than existing methods in different types of real graphs.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
DiffPerf: Towards Performance Differentiation and Optimization with SDN Implementation
Authors:
Walid Aljoby,
Xin Wang,
Dinil Mon Divakaran,
Tom Z. J. Fu,
Richard T. B. Ma
Abstract:
Continuing the current trend, Internet traffic is expected to grow significantly over the coming years, with video traffic consuming the biggest share. On the one hand, this growth poses challenges to access providers (APs), who have to upgrade their infrastructure to meet the growing traffic demands as well as find new ways to monetize their network resources. On the other hand, despite numerous…
▽ More
Continuing the current trend, Internet traffic is expected to grow significantly over the coming years, with video traffic consuming the biggest share. On the one hand, this growth poses challenges to access providers (APs), who have to upgrade their infrastructure to meet the growing traffic demands as well as find new ways to monetize their network resources. On the other hand, despite numerous optimizations of the underlying transport protocol, a user's utilization of network bandwidth and is thus the user's perceived quality still being largely affected by network latency and buffer size. To address both concerns, we propose DiffPerf, a class-based differentiation framework, that, at a macroscopic level dynamically allocates bandwidth to service classes pre-defined by the APs, and at a microscopic level statistically differentiates and isolates user flows to help them achieve better performance. We implement DiffPerf on OpenDaylight SDN controller and programmable Barefoot Tofino switch and evaluate it from an application perspective for MPEG-DASH video streaming. Our evaluations demonstrate the practicality and flexibility that DiffPerf provides APs with capabilities through which a spectrum of qualities are provisioned at multiple classes. Meanwhile, it assists in achieving better fairness and improving overall user's perceived quality within the same class.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
On SDN-Enabled Online and Dynamic Bandwidth Allocation for Stream Analytics
Authors:
Walid Aljoby,
Xin Wang,
Tom Z. J. Fu,
Richard T. B. Ma
Abstract:
Data communication in cloud-based distributed stream data analytics often involves a collection of parallel and pipelined TCP flows. As the standard TCP congestion control mechanism is designed for achieving "fairness" among competing flows and is agnostic to the application layer contexts, the bandwidth allocation among a set of TCP flows traversing bottleneck links often leads to sub-optimal app…
▽ More
Data communication in cloud-based distributed stream data analytics often involves a collection of parallel and pipelined TCP flows. As the standard TCP congestion control mechanism is designed for achieving "fairness" among competing flows and is agnostic to the application layer contexts, the bandwidth allocation among a set of TCP flows traversing bottleneck links often leads to sub-optimal application-layer performance measures, e.g., stream processing throughput or average tuple complete latency.
Motivated by this and enabled by the rapid development of the Software-Defined Networking (SDN) techniques, in this paper, we re-investigate the design space of the bandwidth allocation problem and propose a cross-layer framework which utilizes the additional information obtained from the application layer and provides on-the-fly and dynamic bandwidth adjustment algorithms for hel** the stream analytics applications achieving better performance during the runtime.
We implement a prototype cross-layer bandwidth allocation framework based on a popular open-source distributed stream processing platform, Apache Storm, together with the OpenDaylight controller, and carry out extensive experiments with real-world analytical workloads on top of a local cluster consisting of 10 workstations interconnected by a SDN-enabled switch. The experiment results clearly validate the effectiveness and efficiency of our proposed framework and algorithms.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2019; v1 submitted 11 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Optimizing Bloom Filter: Challenges, Solutions, and Comparisons
Authors:
Lailong Luo,
Deke Guo,
Richard T. B. Ma,
Ori Rottenstreich,
Xueshan Luo
Abstract:
Bloom filter (BF) has been widely used to support membership query, i.e., to judge whether a given element x is a member of a given set S or not. Recent years have seen a flourish design explosion of BF due to its characteristic of space-efficiency and the functionality of constant-time membership query. The existing reviews or surveys mainly focus on the applications of BF, but fall short in cove…
▽ More
Bloom filter (BF) has been widely used to support membership query, i.e., to judge whether a given element x is a member of a given set S or not. Recent years have seen a flourish design explosion of BF due to its characteristic of space-efficiency and the functionality of constant-time membership query. The existing reviews or surveys mainly focus on the applications of BF, but fall short in covering the current trends, thereby lacking intrinsic understanding of their design philosophy. To this end, this survey provides an overview of BF and its variants, with an emphasis on the optimization techniques. Basically, we survey the existing variants from two dimensions, i.e., performance and generalization. To improve the performance, dozens of variants devote themselves to reducing the false positives and implementation costs. Besides, tens of variants generalize the BF framework in more scenarios by diversifying the input sets and enriching the output functionalities. To summarize the existing efforts, we conduct an in-depth study of the existing literature on BF optimization, covering more than 60 variants. We unearth the design philosophy of these variants and elaborate how the employed optimization techniques improve BF. Furthermore, comprehensive analysis and qualitative comparison are conducted from the perspectives of BF components. Lastly, we highlight the future trends of designing BFs. This is, to the best of our knowledge, the first survey that accomplishes such goals.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2019; v1 submitted 12 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Paid Peering, Settlement-Free Peering, or Both?
Authors:
Xin Wang,
Yinlong Xu,
Richard T. B. Ma
Abstract:
With the rapid growth of congestion-sensitive and data-intensive applications, traditional settlement-free peering agreements with best-effort delivery often do not meet the QoS requirements of content providers (CPs). Meanwhile, Internet access providers (IAPs) feel that revenues from end-users are not sufficient to recoup the upgrade costs of network infrastructures. Consequently, some IAPs have…
▽ More
With the rapid growth of congestion-sensitive and data-intensive applications, traditional settlement-free peering agreements with best-effort delivery often do not meet the QoS requirements of content providers (CPs). Meanwhile, Internet access providers (IAPs) feel that revenues from end-users are not sufficient to recoup the upgrade costs of network infrastructures. Consequently, some IAPs have begun to offer CPs a new type of peering agreement, called paid peering, under which they provide CPs with better data delivery quality for a fee. In this paper, we model a network platform where an IAP makes decisions on the peering types offered to CPs and the prices charged to CPs and end-users. We study the optimal peering schemes for the IAP, i.e., to offer CPs both the paid and settlement-free peering to choose from or only one of them, as the objective is profit or welfare maximization. Our results show that 1) the IAP should always offer the paid and settlement-free peering under the profit-optimal and welfare-optimal schemes, respectively, 2) whether to simultaneously offer the other peering type is largely driven by the type of data traffic, e.g., text or video, and 3) regulators might want to encourage the IAP to allocate more network capacity to the settlement-free peering for increasing user welfare.
△ Less
Submitted 30 December, 2017;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Elasticutor: Rapid Elasticity for Realtime Stateful Stream Processing
Authors:
Li Wang,
Tom Z. J. Fu,
Richard T. B. Ma,
Marianne Winslett,
Zhenjie Zhang
Abstract:
Elasticity is highly desirable for stream processing systems to guarantee low latency against workload dynamics, such as surges in data arrival rate and fluctuations in data distribution. Existing systems achieve elasticity following a resource-centric approach that uses dynamic key partitioning across the parallel instances, i.e. executors, to balance the workload and scale operators. However, su…
▽ More
Elasticity is highly desirable for stream processing systems to guarantee low latency against workload dynamics, such as surges in data arrival rate and fluctuations in data distribution. Existing systems achieve elasticity following a resource-centric approach that uses dynamic key partitioning across the parallel instances, i.e. executors, to balance the workload and scale operators. However, such operator-level key repartitioning needs global synchronization and prohibits rapid elasticity. To address this problem, we propose an executor-centric approach, whose core idea is to avoid operator-level key repartitioning while implementing each executor as the building block of elasticity. Following this new approach, we design the Elasticutor framework with two level of optimizations: i) a novel implementation of executors, i.e., elastic executors, that perform elastic multi-core execution via efficient intra-executor load balancing and executor scaling and ii) a global model-based scheduler that dynamically allocates CPU cores to executors based on the instantaneous workloads. We implemented a prototype of Elasticutor and conducted extensive experiments. Our results show that Elasticutor doubles the throughput and achieves an average processing latency up to 2 orders of magnitude lower than previous methods, for a dynamic workload of real-world applications.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
On Optimal Two-Sided Pricing of Congested Networks
Authors:
Xin Wang,
Richard T. B. Ma,
Yinlong Xu
Abstract:
Traditionally, Internet Access Providers (APs) only charge end-users for Internet access services; however, to recoup infrastructure costs and increase revenues, some APs have recently adopted two-sided pricing schemes under which both end-users and content providers are charged. Meanwhile, with the rapid growth of traffic, network congestion could seriously degrade user experiences and influence…
▽ More
Traditionally, Internet Access Providers (APs) only charge end-users for Internet access services; however, to recoup infrastructure costs and increase revenues, some APs have recently adopted two-sided pricing schemes under which both end-users and content providers are charged. Meanwhile, with the rapid growth of traffic, network congestion could seriously degrade user experiences and influence providers' utility. To optimize profit and social welfare, APs and regulators need to design appropriate pricing strategies and regulatory policies that take the effects of network congestion into consideration. In this paper, we model two-sided networks under which users' traffic demands are influenced by exogenous pricing and endogenous congestion parameters and derive the system congestion under an equilibrium. We characterize the structures and sensitivities of profit- and welfare-optimal two-sided pricing schemes and reveal that 1) the elasticity of system throughput plays a crucial role in determining the structures of optimal pricing, 2) the changes of optimal pricing under varying AP's capacity and users' congestion sensitivity are largely driven by the type of data traffic, e.g., text or video, and 3) APs and regulators will be incentivized to shift from one-sided to two-sided pricing when APs' capacities and user demand for video traffic grow. Our results can help APs design optimal two-sided pricing and guide regulators to legislate desirable policies.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2017; v1 submitted 12 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
On Optimal Service Differentiation in Congested Network Markets
Authors:
Mao Zou,
Richard T. B. Ma,
Xin Wang,
Yinlong Xu
Abstract:
As Internet applications have become more diverse in recent years, users having heavy demand for online video services are more willing to pay higher prices for better services than light users that mainly use e-mails and instant messages. This encourages the Internet Service Providers (ISPs) to explore service differentiations so as to optimize their profits and allocation of network resources. M…
▽ More
As Internet applications have become more diverse in recent years, users having heavy demand for online video services are more willing to pay higher prices for better services than light users that mainly use e-mails and instant messages. This encourages the Internet Service Providers (ISPs) to explore service differentiations so as to optimize their profits and allocation of network resources. Much prior work has focused on the viability of network service differentiation by comparing with the case of a single-class service. However, the optimal service differentiation for an ISP subject to resource constraints has remained unsolved. In this work, we establish an optimal control framework to derive the analytical solution to an ISP's optimal service differentiation, i.e. the optimal service qualities and associated prices. By analyzing the structures of the solution, we reveal how an ISP should adjust the service qualities and prices in order to meet varying capacity constraints and users' characteristics. We also obtain the conditions under which ISPs have strong incentives to implement service differentiation and whether regulators should encourage such practices.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Monet: A User-oriented Behavior-based Malware Variants Detection System for Android
Authors:
Mingshen Sun,
Xiaolei Li,
John C. S. Lui,
Richard T. B. Ma,
Zhenkai Liang
Abstract:
Android, the most popular mobile OS, has around 78% of the mobile market share. Due to its popularity, it attracts many malware attacks. In fact, people have discovered around one million new malware samples per quarter, and it was reported that over 98% of these new malware samples are in fact "derivatives" (or variants) from existing malware families. In this paper, we first show that runtime be…
▽ More
Android, the most popular mobile OS, has around 78% of the mobile market share. Due to its popularity, it attracts many malware attacks. In fact, people have discovered around one million new malware samples per quarter, and it was reported that over 98% of these new malware samples are in fact "derivatives" (or variants) from existing malware families. In this paper, we first show that runtime behaviors of malware's core functionalities are in fact similar within a malware family. Hence, we propose a framework to combine "runtime behavior" with "static structures" to detect malware variants. We present the design and implementation of MONET, which has a client and a backend server module. The client module is a lightweight, in-device app for behavior monitoring and signature generation, and we realize this using two novel interception techniques. The backend server is responsible for large scale malware detection. We collect 3723 malware samples and top 500 benign apps to carry out extensive experiments of detecting malware variants and defending against malware transformation. Our experiments show that MONET can achieve around 99% accuracy in detecting malware variants. Furthermore, it can defend against 10 different obfuscation and transformation techniques, while only incurs around 7% performance overhead and about 3% battery overhead. More importantly, MONET will automatically alert users with intrusion details so to prevent further malicious behaviors.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
The Role of Data Cap in Optimal Two-part Network Pricing
Authors:
Xin Wang,
Richard T. B. Ma,
Yinlong Xu
Abstract:
Internet services are traditionally priced at flat rates; however, many Internet service providers (ISPs) have recently shifted towards two-part tariffs where a data cap is imposed to restrain data demand from heavy users. Although the two-part tariff could generally increase the revenue for ISPs and has been supported by the US FCC, the role of data cap and its optimal pricing structures are not…
▽ More
Internet services are traditionally priced at flat rates; however, many Internet service providers (ISPs) have recently shifted towards two-part tariffs where a data cap is imposed to restrain data demand from heavy users. Although the two-part tariff could generally increase the revenue for ISPs and has been supported by the US FCC, the role of data cap and its optimal pricing structures are not well understood. In this article, we study the impact of data cap on the optimal two-part pricing schemes for congestion-prone service markets. We model users' demand and preferences over pricing and congestion alternatives and derive the market share and congestion of service providers under a market equilibrium. Based on the equilibrium model, we characterize the two-part structures of the revenue- and welfare-optimal pricing schemes. Our results reveal that 1) the data cap provides a mechanism for ISPs to transition from the flat-rate to pay-as-you-go type of schemes, 2) both the revenue and welfare objectives of the ISP will drive the optimal pricing towards usage-based schemes with diminishing data caps, and 3) the welfare-optimal tariff comprises lower fees than the revenue-optimal counterpart, suggesting that regulators might want to promote usage-based pricing but regulate the lump-sum and per-unit fees.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2017; v1 submitted 4 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Optimal Operator State Migration for Elastic Data Stream Processing
Authors:
Jianbing Ding,
Tom Z. J. Fu,
Richard T. B. Ma,
Marianne Winslett,
Yin Yang,
Zhenjie Zhang,
Hongyang Chao
Abstract:
A cloud-based data stream management system (DSMS) handles fast data by utilizing the massively parallel processing capabilities of the underlying platform. An important property of such a DSMS is elasticity, meaning that nodes can be dynamically added to or removed from an application to match the latter's workload, which may fluctuate in an unpredictable manner. For an application involving stat…
▽ More
A cloud-based data stream management system (DSMS) handles fast data by utilizing the massively parallel processing capabilities of the underlying platform. An important property of such a DSMS is elasticity, meaning that nodes can be dynamically added to or removed from an application to match the latter's workload, which may fluctuate in an unpredictable manner. For an application involving stateful operations such as aggregates, the addition / removal of nodes necessitates the migration of operator states. Although the importance of migration has been recognized in existing systems, two key problems remain largely neglected, namely how to migrate and what to migrate, i.e., the migration mechanism that reduces synchronization overhead and result delay during migration, and the selection of the optimal task assignment that minimizes migration costs. Consequently, migration in current systems typically incurs a high spike in result delay caused by expensive synchronization barriers and suboptimal task assignments. Motivated by this, we present the first comprehensive study on efficient operator states migration, and propose designs and algorithms that enable live, progressive, and optimized migrations. Extensive experiments using real data justify our performance claims.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2015; v1 submitted 15 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
DRS: Dynamic Resource Scheduling for Real-Time Analytics over Fast Streams
Authors:
Tom Z. J. Fu,
Jianbing Ding,
Richard T. B. Ma,
Marianne Winslett,
Yin Yang,
Zhenjie Zhang
Abstract:
In a data stream management system (DSMS), users register continuous queries, and receive result updates as data arrive and expire. We focus on applications with real-time constraints, in which the user must receive each result update within a given period after the update occurs. To handle fast data, the DSMS is commonly placed on top of a cloud infrastructure. Because stream properties such as a…
▽ More
In a data stream management system (DSMS), users register continuous queries, and receive result updates as data arrive and expire. We focus on applications with real-time constraints, in which the user must receive each result update within a given period after the update occurs. To handle fast data, the DSMS is commonly placed on top of a cloud infrastructure. Because stream properties such as arrival rates can fluctuate unpredictably, cloud resources must be dynamically provisioned and scheduled accordingly to ensure real-time response. It is quite essential, for the existing systems or future developments, to possess the ability of scheduling resources dynamically according to the current workload, in order to avoid wasting resources, or failing in delivering correct results on time. Motivated by this, we propose DRS, a novel dynamic resource scheduler for cloud-based DSMSs. DRS overcomes three fundamental challenges: (a) how to model the relationship between the provisioned resources and query response time (b) where to best place resources; and (c) how to measure system load with minimal overhead. In particular, DRS includes an accurate performance model based on the theory of \emph{Jackson open queueing networks} and is capable of handling \emph{arbitrary} operator topologies, possibly with loops, splits and joins. Extensive experiments with real data confirm that DRS achieves real-time response with close to optimal resource consumption.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2015; v1 submitted 15 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
Sampling Online Social Networks via Heterogeneous Statistics
Authors:
Xin Wang,
Richard T. B. Ma,
Yinlong Xu,
Zhipeng Li
Abstract:
Most sampling techniques for online social networks (OSNs) are based on a particular sampling method on a single graph, which is referred to as a statistics. However, various realizing methods on different graphs could possibly be used in the same OSN, and they may lead to different sampling efficiencies, i.e., asymptotic variances. To utilize multiple statistics for accurate measurements, we form…
▽ More
Most sampling techniques for online social networks (OSNs) are based on a particular sampling method on a single graph, which is referred to as a statistics. However, various realizing methods on different graphs could possibly be used in the same OSN, and they may lead to different sampling efficiencies, i.e., asymptotic variances. To utilize multiple statistics for accurate measurements, we formulate a mixture sampling problem, through which we construct a mixture unbiased estimator which minimizes asymptotic variance. Given fixed sampling budgets for different statistics, we derive the optimal weights to combine the individual estimators; given fixed total budget, we show that a greedy allocation towards the most efficient statistics is optimal. In practice, the sampling efficiencies of statistics can be quite different for various targets and are unknown before sampling. To solve this problem, we design a two-stage framework which adaptively spends a partial budget to test different statistics and allocates the remaining budget to the inferred best statistics. We show that our two-stage framework is a generalization of 1) randomly choosing a statistics and 2) evenly allocating the total budget among all available statistics, and our adaptive algorithm achieves higher efficiency than these benchmark strategies in theory and experiment.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2015; v1 submitted 13 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
Subsidization Competition: Vitalizing the Neutral Internet
Authors:
Richard T. B. Ma
Abstract:
Unlike telephone operators, which pay termination fees to reach the users of another network, Internet Content Providers (CPs) do not pay the Internet Service Providers (ISPs) of users they reach. While the consequent cross subsidization to CPs has nurtured content innovations at the edge of the Internet, it reduces the investment incentives for the access ISPs to expand capacity. As potential cha…
▽ More
Unlike telephone operators, which pay termination fees to reach the users of another network, Internet Content Providers (CPs) do not pay the Internet Service Providers (ISPs) of users they reach. While the consequent cross subsidization to CPs has nurtured content innovations at the edge of the Internet, it reduces the investment incentives for the access ISPs to expand capacity. As potential charges for terminating CPs' traffic are criticized under the net neutrality debate, we propose to allow CPs to voluntarily subsidize the usagebased fees induced by their content traffic for end-users. We model the regulated subsidization competition among CPs under a neutral network and show how deregulation of subsidization could increase an access ISP's utilization and revenue, strengthening its investment incentives. Although the competition might harm certain CPs, we find that the main cause comes from high access prices rather than the existence of subsidization. Our results suggest that subsidization competition will increase the competitiveness and welfare of the Internet content market; however, regulators might need to regulate access prices if the access ISP market is not competitive enough. We envision that subsidization competition could become a viable model for the future Internet.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Selection Policy: Fighting against Filter Effect in Network of Caches
Authors:
Saeid Montazeri Shahtouri,
Richard T. B. Ma
Abstract:
Many Information Centric Networking (ICN) proposals use a network of caches to bring the contents closer to the consumers, reduce the load on producers and decrease the unnecessary retransmission for ISPs. Nevertheless, the existing cache management scheme for the network of caches obtain poor performance. The main reason for performance degradation in a network of caches is the filter effect of t…
▽ More
Many Information Centric Networking (ICN) proposals use a network of caches to bring the contents closer to the consumers, reduce the load on producers and decrease the unnecessary retransmission for ISPs. Nevertheless, the existing cache management scheme for the network of caches obtain poor performance. The main reason for performance degradation in a network of caches is the filter effect of the replacement policy. A cache serves the requests that generate cache-hits and forwards the requests that generate cache-misses. This filtering changes the pattern of requests and leads to decreased hit ratios in the subsequent caches. In this paper, we propose a coordinated caching scheme to solve the filter effect problem by introducing the selection policy. This policy manages a cache such that: i) the cache obtains a high hit ratio ii) the missed requests from the cache can be used by subsequent caches to obtain a high hit ratio. Our coordinated selection scheme achieves an overall hit ratio of a network of caches equivalent to that of edge routers with big caches. Moreover, our scheme decreases the average number of evictions per cache slot by four order of magnitude compared to the LRU universal caching.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
On the Evolution of the Internet Economic Ecosystem
Authors:
Richard T. B. Ma,
John C. S. Lui,
Vishal Misra
Abstract:
The evolution of the Internet has manifested itself in many ways: the traffic characteristics, the interconnection topologies and the business relationships among the autonomous components. It is important to understand why (and how) this evolution came about, and how the interplay of these dynamics may affect future evolution and services. We propose a network aware, macroscopic model that captur…
▽ More
The evolution of the Internet has manifested itself in many ways: the traffic characteristics, the interconnection topologies and the business relationships among the autonomous components. It is important to understand why (and how) this evolution came about, and how the interplay of these dynamics may affect future evolution and services. We propose a network aware, macroscopic model that captures the characteristics and interactions of the application and network providers, and show how it leads to a market equilibrium of the ecosystem. By analyzing the driving forces and the dynamics of the market equilibrium, we obtain some fundamental understandings of the cause and effect of the Internet evolution, which explain why some historical and recent evolutions have happened. Furthermore, by projecting the likely future evolutions, our model can help application and network providers to make informed business decisions so as to succeed in this competitive ecosystem.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
The Public Option: a Non-regulatory Alternative to Network Neutrality
Authors:
Richard T. B. Ma,
Vishal Misra
Abstract:
Network neutrality and the role of regulation on the Internet have been heavily debated in recent times. Amongst the various definitions of network neutrality, we focus on the one which prohibits paid prioritization of content and we present an analytical treatment of the topic. We develop a model of the Internet ecosystem in terms of three primary players: consumers, ISPs and content providers. O…
▽ More
Network neutrality and the role of regulation on the Internet have been heavily debated in recent times. Amongst the various definitions of network neutrality, we focus on the one which prohibits paid prioritization of content and we present an analytical treatment of the topic. We develop a model of the Internet ecosystem in terms of three primary players: consumers, ISPs and content providers. Our analysis looks at this issue from the point of view of the consumer, and we describe the desired state of the system as one which maximizes consumer surplus. By analyzing different scenarios of monopoly and competition, we obtain different conclusions on the desirability of regulation. We also introduce the notion of a Public Option ISP, an ISP that carries traffic in a network neutral manner. Our major findings are (i) in a monopolistic scenario, network neutral regulations benefit consumers; however, the introduction of a Public Option ISP is even better for consumers, as it aligns the interests of the monopolistic ISP with the consumer surplus and (ii) in an oligopolistic situation, the presence of a Public Option ISP is again preferable to network neutral regulations, although the presence of competing price-discriminating ISPs provides the most desirable situation for the consumers.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2011; v1 submitted 16 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
