-
Exploring nonequilibrium Andreev resonances in ultraclean graphene Andreev interferometers
Authors:
Asmaul Smitha Rashid,
Le Yi,
Takashi Taniguchi,
Kenji Watanabe,
Nitin Samarth,
Régis Mélin,
Morteza Kayyalha
Abstract:
We study nonequilibrium Andreev resonances in a voltage-biased graphene three-terminal Josephson junction (JJ). We observe periodic oscillations of resistance with maxima at multiples of the magnetic flux quantum (noninversion regime). As we increase the bias voltage, we further observe a transition point beyond which oscillations exhibit a $π$ phase shift (inversion regime) with maxima of resista…
▽ More
We study nonequilibrium Andreev resonances in a voltage-biased graphene three-terminal Josephson junction (JJ). We observe periodic oscillations of resistance with maxima at multiples of the magnetic flux quantum (noninversion regime). As we increase the bias voltage, we further observe a transition point beyond which oscillations exhibit a $π$ phase shift (inversion regime) with maxima of resistance occuring at multiples of half-flux quantum. At this transition point, the frequency of the oscillations is doubled. We develop a model based on the coupling of the static Andreev bound states (ABSs) to the nonequilibrium Fermi surface of graphene to explain the observed noninversion to inversion crossovers. Our model associates these crossovers to microscopic phase-sensitive Andreev reflections which couple the normal and superfluid components of the current. Our findings show that multiterminal JJs can be used to engineer unconventional energy-phase relations such as those expected in the $π$-shifted ABSs without relying on quartet and Floquet physics. These nonequilibrium ABSs could potentially find applications in superconducting $π$ qubits.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2024; v1 submitted 5 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Ultraclean Andreev interferometers
Authors:
Régis Mélin,
Asmaul Smitha Rashid,
Morteza Kayyalha
Abstract:
Coupling a two-terminal Josephson junction to the stationary modes of the electromagnetic field produces the so-called Fiske resonances. Here, we propose another mechanism based on the exchange between the static Andreev bound states (ABS) and a nonequilibrium Fermi surface in an ultraclean multiterminal device. As a simple model, we consider an effective $S_a$-$N_{eff}$-$S_b$ double junction conn…
▽ More
Coupling a two-terminal Josephson junction to the stationary modes of the electromagnetic field produces the so-called Fiske resonances. Here, we propose another mechanism based on the exchange between the static Andreev bound states (ABS) and a nonequilibrium Fermi surface in an ultraclean multiterminal device. As a simple model, we consider an effective $S_a$-$N_{eff}$-$S_b$ double junction connecting the superconductors $S_a$ and $S_b$ to the infinite central normal metal $N_{eff}$. We find that the underlying microscopic process of phase-sensitive Andreev reflection (phase-AR) produces the possibility of an inversion, that is, the conductance can be larger at half-flux quantum than in zero field. The inversion-noninversion alternate as the bias voltage is increased. In addition, if the central region $N_{eff}$ is an integrable billiard connected to an infinite normal reservoir, we find that the standard ABS are replaced by one- and two-particle Andreev resonances that can be probed by the bias voltage. Finally, we find that, in the corresponding all-superconducting Andreev interferometer, the superconducting gap produces protection against the short relaxation time of the quasiparticle continua if the time periodic dynamics is treated as a perturbation. The spectrum of the two-particle resonances is then sparse inside the spectrum of the pairs of one-particle resonances. Our work supports the nonFloquet intrinsic resonances in two-dimensional metal-based Andreev interferometers, and challenges the Floquet theory of multiterminal Josephson junctions.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Evidence for $π$-shifted Cooper quartets and few-mode transport in PbTe nanowire three-terminal Josephson junctions
Authors:
Mohit Gupta,
Vipin Khade,
Colin Riggert,
Lior Shani,
Gavin Menning,
Pim Lueb,
Jason Jung,
Régis Mélin,
Erik P. A. M. Bakkers,
Vlad S. Pribiag
Abstract:
Josephson junctions are typically characterized by a single phase difference across two superconductors. This conventional two-terminal Josephson junction can be generalized to a multi-terminal device where the Josephson energy contains terms with contributions from multiple independent phase variables. Such multi-terminal Josephson junctions (MTJJs) are being considered as platforms for engineeri…
▽ More
Josephson junctions are typically characterized by a single phase difference across two superconductors. This conventional two-terminal Josephson junction can be generalized to a multi-terminal device where the Josephson energy contains terms with contributions from multiple independent phase variables. Such multi-terminal Josephson junctions (MTJJs) are being considered as platforms for engineering effective Hamiltonians with non-trivial topologies, such as Weyl crossings and higher-order Chern numbers. This approach offers unique possibilities that are complementary to phenomena attainable in bulk crystals, including topological states in more than three dimensions and real-time gate-tunability of the Hamiltonians. However, these prospects rely on the ability to create MTJJs with non-classical multi-terminal couplings in which only a handful of quantum modes are populated. Here, we demonstrate these requirements by using a three-terminal Josephson junction fabricated on selective-area-grown (SAG) PbTe nanowires. We observe signatures of a $π$-shifted Josephson effect, consistent with inter-terminal couplings mediated by four-particle quantum states called Cooper quartets. We further observe supercurrent co-existent with a non-monotonic evolution of the conductance with gate voltage, indicating transport mediated by a few quantum modes in both two- and three-terminal devices. These results establish a platform for investigations of topological Hamiltonians based on Andreev bound states.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2024; v1 submitted 29 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Magnetointerferometry of multiterminal Josephson junctions
Authors:
Régis Mélin,
Clemens B. Winkelmann,
Romain Danneau
Abstract:
We report a theoretical study of multiterminal Josephson junctions under the influence of a magnetic field $B$. We consider a ballistic rectangular two-dimensional metal $N_0$ connected by the edges to the left, right, top and bottom superconductors $S_L$, $S_R$, $S_T$ and $S_B$, respectively. We numerically calculate in the large-gap approximation the critical current $I_c$ versus $B$ between the…
▽ More
We report a theoretical study of multiterminal Josephson junctions under the influence of a magnetic field $B$. We consider a ballistic rectangular two-dimensional metal $N_0$ connected by the edges to the left, right, top and bottom superconductors $S_L$, $S_R$, $S_T$ and $S_B$, respectively. We numerically calculate in the large-gap approximation the critical current $I_c$ versus $B$ between the left and right $S_L$ and $S_R$ for various aspect ratios, with the top and bottom $S_T$ and $S_B$ playing the role of superconducting mirrors. We find the critical current $I_c$ to be enhanced by orders of magnitude, especially at long distance, due to the phase rigidity provided by the mirrors. We obtain superconducting quantum interference device-like magnetic oscillations. With symmetric couplings, the self-consistent superconducting phase variables of the top and bottom mirrors take the values $0$ or $π$, as for emerging Ising degrees of freedom. We propose a simple effective Josephson junction circuit model that is compatible with these microscopic numerical calculations. From the $I_c(B)$ patterns we infer where the supercurrent flows in various device geometries. In particular in the elongated geometry, we show that the supercurrent flows between all pairs of contacts, which allows exploring the full phase space of the relevant phase differences.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2024; v1 submitted 21 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Proposal for detecting the $π-$shifted Cooper quartet supercurrent
Authors:
Régis Mélin,
Romain Danneau,
Clemens B. Winkelmann
Abstract:
The multiterminal Josephson effect aroused considerable interest recently, in connection with theoretical and experimental evidence for correlations among Cooper pairs, that is, the so-called Cooper quartets. It was further predicted that the spectrum of Andreev bound states in such devices could host Weyl-point singularities. However, the relative phase between the Cooper pair and quartet supercu…
▽ More
The multiterminal Josephson effect aroused considerable interest recently, in connection with theoretical and experimental evidence for correlations among Cooper pairs, that is, the so-called Cooper quartets. It was further predicted that the spectrum of Andreev bound states in such devices could host Weyl-point singularities. However, the relative phase between the Cooper pair and quartet supercurrents has not yet been addressed experimentally. Here, we propose an experiment involving four-terminal Josephson junctions with two independent orthogonal supercurrents, and calculate the critical current contours (CCCs) from a multiterminal Josephson junction circuit theory. We predict a generically $π$-shifted contribution of both the local or nonlocal second-order Josephson harmonics. Furthermore, we show that these lead to marked nonconvex shapes for the CCCs in zero magnetic field, where the dissipative state reenters into the superconducting one. Eventually, we discuss distinctive features of the non-local Josephson processes in the CCCs. The experimental observation of the latter could allow providing firm evidence of the $π$-shifted Cooper quartet current-phase relation.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2023; v1 submitted 22 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
A quantum interferometer for quartets in superconducting three-terminal Josephson junctions
Authors:
Régis Mélin,
Denis Feinberg
Abstract:
An interferometric device is proposed in order to analyze the quartet mode in biased three-terminal Josephson junctions (TTJs), and to provide experimental evidence for emergence of a single stationary phase, the so-called quartet phase. In such a quartet-Superconducting Quantum Interference Device (quartet-SQUID), the flux sensitivity exhibits period ${hc}/{4e}$, which is the fingerprint of a tra…
▽ More
An interferometric device is proposed in order to analyze the quartet mode in biased three-terminal Josephson junctions (TTJs), and to provide experimental evidence for emergence of a single stationary phase, the so-called quartet phase. In such a quartet-Superconducting Quantum Interference Device (quartet-SQUID), the flux sensitivity exhibits period ${hc}/{4e}$, which is the fingerprint of a transient intermediate state involving two entangled Cooper pairs. The quartet-SQUID provides two informations: an amplitude that measures a total ``quartet critical current'', and a phase lapse coming from the superposition of the following two current components: the quartet supercurrent that is odd in the quartet phase, and the phase-sensitive multiple Andreev reflection (phase-MAR) quasiparticle current, that is even in the quartet phase. This makes a TTJ a generically "$θ$-junction". Evidence for phase-MARs plays against conservative scenarii involving synchronization of AC Josephson currents, based on ``adiabatic'' phase dynamics and RSJ-like models.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2023; v1 submitted 27 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Multiterminal ballistic Josephson junctions coupled to normal leads
Authors:
Régis Mélin
Abstract:
Multiterminal Josephson junctions have aroused considerable theoretical interest recently and numerous works aim at putting the predictions of correlations among Coopers (i.e. the so-called quartets) and simulation of topological matter to the test of experiments. The present paper is motivated by recent experimental investigation from the Harvard group reporting $h/4e$-periodic quartet signal in…
▽ More
Multiterminal Josephson junctions have aroused considerable theoretical interest recently and numerous works aim at putting the predictions of correlations among Coopers (i.e. the so-called quartets) and simulation of topological matter to the test of experiments. The present paper is motivated by recent experimental investigation from the Harvard group reporting $h/4e$-periodic quartet signal in a four-terminal configuration containing a loop pierced by magnetic flux, together with inversion controlled by the bias voltage, i.e. the quartet signal can be larger at half-flux quantum than in zero magnetic field. Here, we theoretically focus on devices consisting of finite-size quantum dots connected to four superconducting and to a normal lead. In addition to presenting numerical calculations of the quartet signal within a simplified modeling, we reduce the device to a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian in the infinite-gap limit. Then, relaxation has the surprising effect of producing sharp peaks and log-normal variations in the voltage-sensitivity of the quartet signal in spite of the expected moderate fluctuations in the two-terminal DC-Josephson current. The phenomenon is reminiscent of a resonantly driven harmonic oscillator having amplitude inverse proportional to the dam** rate, and of the thermal noise of a superconducting weak link, inverse proportional to the Dynes parameter. Perspectives involve quantum bath engineering multiterminal Josephson junctions in the circuits of cavity quantum electrodynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2022; v1 submitted 19 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Ultralong-distance quantum correlations in three-terminal Josephson junctions
Authors:
Régis Mélin
Abstract:
The production of entangled pairs of electrons in ferromagnet-superconductor-ferromagnet or normal metal-superconductor-normal metal three-terminal structures has aroused considerable interest in the last twenty years. In these studies, the distance between the contacts is limited by the zero-energy superconducting coherence length. Here, we demonstrate nonlocality and quantum correlations in volt…
▽ More
The production of entangled pairs of electrons in ferromagnet-superconductor-ferromagnet or normal metal-superconductor-normal metal three-terminal structures has aroused considerable interest in the last twenty years. In these studies, the distance between the contacts is limited by the zero-energy superconducting coherence length. Here, we demonstrate nonlocality and quantum correlations in voltage-biased three-terminal Josephson junctions over the ultralong distance that exceeds the superconducting coherence length by orders of magnitude. The effect relies on} the interplay between the time-periodic Floquet-Josephson dynamics, Cooper pair splitting and long-range coupling similar to the two-terminal Tomasch effect. We find cross-over between the ``Floquet-Andreev quartets'' (if the spatial separation is smaller than the superconducting coherence length), and the ``ultralong-distance Floquet-Tomasch clusters of Cooper pairs'' if the separation exceeds the superconducting coherence length, possibly reaching the same $\simeq 30\,μ$m as in the Tomasch experiments. The effect can be detected with DC-transport and zero-frequency quantum current-noise cross-correlation experiments, and it can be used for fundamental studies of superconducting quasiparticle quantum coherence in the circuits of quantum engineering.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2021; v1 submitted 14 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
The dc-Josephson effect with more than four superconducting leads
Authors:
Régis Mélin
Abstract:
By definition, the $p$-terminal dc-Josephson current is sensitive to the superconducting phase variables of $p$ terminals. In the paper, we establish protocol for direct detection of the $p$-terminal dc-Josephson effect with $p\ge 3$ in a device containing $N$ superconducting leads $S_1,\,S_2,\,...,\,S_N$ having the phase variables $\varphi_1,\,\varphi_2,\,...,\,\varphi_N$. The calculated signal…
▽ More
By definition, the $p$-terminal dc-Josephson current is sensitive to the superconducting phase variables of $p$ terminals. In the paper, we establish protocol for direct detection of the $p$-terminal dc-Josephson effect with $p\ge 3$ in a device containing $N$ superconducting leads $S_1,\,S_2,\,...,\,S_N$ having the phase variables $\varphi_1,\,\varphi_2,\,...,\,\varphi_N$. The calculated signal $χ^{(N)}$ can be probed in microwave experiments, and it corresponds to the higher-order nonlocal inverse inductance obtained from differentiating the current $I_1$ through $S_1$ with respect to the remaining $N-2$ independent phase differences $\varphi_2-\varphi_N,\,\varphi_3-\varphi_N,\, ...,\varphi_{N-1}-\varphi_N$. We find that the values $p\le N-2$ do not contribute to $χ^{(N)}$, and that $χ^{(N)}\ne 0$ implies evidence for the $p=N-1$ or the $p=N$-terminal dc-Josephson currents. For $N=4$ superconducting leads, we demonstrate that $χ^{(4)}\ne 0$ implies evidence for the $p=3$ or $p=4$ dc-Josephson effect, irrespective of the $p=2$-terminal dc-Josephson current. Thus, we provide a way to demonstrate the dc-Josephson effect with more than three terminals (i.e. with $p\ge 3$) in a device containing more than four superconducting leads (i.e. with $N\ge 4$). The predicted $χ^{(4)}$ is "yes or no" answer to the $p\ge 3$ dc-Josephson effect, i.e. for $N=4$, nonvanishingly small $χ^{(4)}\ne 0$ implies the $p=3$ or $p=4$-terminal dc-Josephson effect and vanishingly small $χ^{(4)}=0$ implies absence of the $p=3$ and $p=4$-terminal dc-Josephson effect. The paper can be viewed as generalizing the recently considered $\varphi$-junctions in Andreev molecules to arbitrary number $N$ of the superconducting leads, and it relies on basic properties of the dc-Josephson effect that are not directly related to nontrivial topology and Weyl point singularities.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2021; v1 submitted 5 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Evidence for 4e charge of Cooper quartets in a biased multi-terminal graphene-based Josephson junction
Authors:
Ko-Fan Huang,
Yuval Ronen,
Régis Mélin,
Denis Feinberg,
Kenji Watanabe,
Takashi Taniguchi,
Philip Kim
Abstract:
In a Josephson junction (JJ), Cooper pairs are transported via Andreev bound states (ABSs) between superconductors. The ABSs in the weak link of multi-terminal (MT) JJs can coherently hybridize two Cooper pairs among different superconducting electrodes, resulting in the Cooper quartet (CQ) involving four fermions entanglement. The energy spectrum of these CQ-ABS can be controlled by biasing MT-JJ…
▽ More
In a Josephson junction (JJ), Cooper pairs are transported via Andreev bound states (ABSs) between superconductors. The ABSs in the weak link of multi-terminal (MT) JJs can coherently hybridize two Cooper pairs among different superconducting electrodes, resulting in the Cooper quartet (CQ) involving four fermions entanglement. The energy spectrum of these CQ-ABS can be controlled by biasing MT-JJs due to the AC Josephson effect. Here, using gate tunable four-terminal graphene JJs complemented with a flux loop, we construct CQs with a tunable spectrum. The critical quartet supercurrent exhibits magneto-oscillation associated with a charge of 4e; thereby presenting the evidence for interference between entangled CQ-ABS. At a finite bias voltage, we find the DC quartet supercurrent shows non-monotonic bias dependent behavior, attributed to Landau-Zener transitions between different Floquet bands. Our experimental demonstration of coherent non-equilibrium CQ-ABS sets a path for design of artificial topological materials based on MT-JJs.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2022; v1 submitted 7 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Inversion in a four terminal superconducting device on the quartet line: II. Quantum dot and Floquet theory
Authors:
Régis Mélin,
Benoît Douçot
Abstract:
In this paper, we consider a quantum dot connected to four superconducting terminals biased at opposite voltages on the quartet line. The grounded superconductor contains a loop threaded by the magnetic flux $Φ$. We provide Keldysh microscopic calculations and physical pictures for the voltage-$V$ dependence of the quartet current. Superconductivity is expected to be stronger at $Φ/Φ_0=0$ than at…
▽ More
In this paper, we consider a quantum dot connected to four superconducting terminals biased at opposite voltages on the quartet line. The grounded superconductor contains a loop threaded by the magnetic flux $Φ$. We provide Keldysh microscopic calculations and physical pictures for the voltage-$V$ dependence of the quartet current. Superconductivity is expected to be stronger at $Φ/Φ_0=0$ than at $Φ/Φ_0=1/2$. However, inversion $I_{q,c}(V,0)<I_{q,c}(V,1/2)$ is obtained in the critical current $I_{q,c}(V,Φ/Φ_0)$ on the quartet line in the voltage-$V$ ranges which match avoided crossings in the Floquet spectrum at $(V,Φ/Φ_0=0)$ but not at $(V,1/2)$. A reduction in $I_{q,c}$ appears in the vicinity of those avoided crossings, where Landau-Zener tunneling produces dynamical quantum mechanical superpositions of the Andreev bound states. In addition, $π$-$0$ and $0$-$π$ cross-overs emerge in the current-phase relations as $V$ is further increased. The voltage-induced $π$-shift is interpreted as originating from the nonequilibrium Floquet populations produced by voltage biasing. The numerical calculations reveal that the inversion is robust against strong Landau-Zener tunneling and many levels in the quantum dot. Our theory provides a simple ``Floquet level and population'' mechanism for inversion tuned by the bias voltage $V$, which paves the way towards more realistic models for the recent Harvard group experiment where the inversion is observed.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2020; v1 submitted 5 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Inversion in a four-terminal superconducting device on the quartet line: I. Two-dimensional metal and the quartet beam splitter
Authors:
Régis Mélin
Abstract:
In connection with the recent Harvard group experiment on graphene-based four-terminal Josephson junctions containing a grounded loop, we consider biasing at opposite voltages on the quartet line and establish lowest-order perturbation theory in the tunnel amplitudes between a two-dimensional (2D) metal and four superconducting leads in the dirty limit. We present in addition general nonperturbati…
▽ More
In connection with the recent Harvard group experiment on graphene-based four-terminal Josephson junctions containing a grounded loop, we consider biasing at opposite voltages on the quartet line and establish lowest-order perturbation theory in the tunnel amplitudes between a two-dimensional (2D) metal and four superconducting leads in the dirty limit. We present in addition general nonperturbative and nonadiabatic results. The critical current on the quartet line $I_c(Φ/Φ_0)$ depends on the reduced flux $Φ/Φ_0$ via interference between the three-terminal quartets (3TQ) and the nonstandard four-terminal split quartets (4TSQ). The 4TSQ result from synchronizing two Josephson junctions by exchange of two quasiparticles "surfing" on the 2D quantum wake, and this mechanism is already operational at equilibrium. Perturbation theory in the tunnel amplitudes shows that the 3TQ are $π$-shifted but the 4TSQ are $0$-shifted if the contacts have linear dimension which is large compared to the elastic mean free path. We establish the gate voltage dependence of the quartet critical current oscillations $I_c(Φ/Φ_0)$. It is argued that "Observation of $I_c(0)\ne I_c(1/2)$" implies "Evidence for the four-terminal 4TSQ" for finite bias voltage on the quartet line and arbitrary interface transparencies. This statement relies on physically-motivated approximations leading to the Ambegaokar-Baratoff-type formula for the quartet critical current-flux relation. It is concluded that the recent experiment mentioned above finds evidence for the four-terminal 4TSQ.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2020; v1 submitted 5 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Beyond the electric-dipole approximation in simulations of X-ray absorption spectroscopy: Lessons from relativistic theory
Authors:
Nanna Holmgaard List,
Timothé Romain Léo Melin,
Martin van Horn,
Trond Saue
Abstract:
We present three schemes to go beyond the electric-dipole approximation in X-ray absorption spectroscopy calculations within a four-component relativistic framework. The first is based on the full semi-classical light-matter interaction operator, and the two others on a truncated interaction within Coulomb gauge (velocity representation) and multipolar gauge (length representation). We generalize…
▽ More
We present three schemes to go beyond the electric-dipole approximation in X-ray absorption spectroscopy calculations within a four-component relativistic framework. The first is based on the full semi-classical light-matter interaction operator, and the two others on a truncated interaction within Coulomb gauge (velocity representation) and multipolar gauge (length representation). We generalize the derivation of multipolar gauge to an arbitrary expansion point and show that the potentials corresponding to different expansion point are related by a gauge transformation, provided the expansion is not truncated. This suggests that the observed gauge-origin dependence in multipolar gauge is more than just a finite-basis set effect. The simplicity of the relativistic formalism enables arbitrary-order implementations of the truncated interactions, with and without rotational averaging, allowing us to test their convergence behavior numerically by comparison to the full formulation. We confirm the observation that the oscillator strength of the electric-dipole allowed ligand K-edge transition of TiCl$_4$, when calculated to second order in the wave vector, become negative, but also show that inclusion of higher-order contributions allows convergence to the result obtained using the full light-matter interaction. However, at higher energies, the slow convergence of such expansions becomes dramatic and renders such approaches at best impractical. When going beyond the electric-dipole approximation, we therefore recommend the use of the full light-matter interaction.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2020; v1 submitted 29 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Berry phase in superconducting multiterminal quantum dots
Authors:
Benoit Doucot,
Romain Danneau,
Kang Yang,
Jean-Guy Caputo,
Régis Mélin
Abstract:
We report on the study of the non-trivial Berry phase in superconducting multiterminal quantum dots biased at commensurate voltages. Starting with the time-periodic Bogoliubov-de Gennes equations, we obtain a tight binding model in the Floquet space, and we solve these equations in the semiclassical limit. We observe that the parameter space defined by the contact transparencies and quartet phase…
▽ More
We report on the study of the non-trivial Berry phase in superconducting multiterminal quantum dots biased at commensurate voltages. Starting with the time-periodic Bogoliubov-de Gennes equations, we obtain a tight binding model in the Floquet space, and we solve these equations in the semiclassical limit. We observe that the parameter space defined by the contact transparencies and quartet phase splits into two components with a non-trivial Berry phase. We use the Bohr-Sommerfeld quantization to calculate the Berry phase. We find that if the quantum dot level sits at zero energy, then the Berry phase takes the values $\varphi_B=0$ or $\varphi_B=π$. We demonstrate that this non-trivial Berry phase can be observed by tunneling spectroscopy in the Floquet spectra. Consequently, the Floquet-Wannier-Stark ladder spectra of superconducting multiterminal quantum dots are shifted by half-a-period if $\varphi_B=π$. Our numerical calculations based on Keldysh Green's functions show that this Berry phase spectral shift can be observed from the quantum dot tunneling density of states.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2020; v1 submitted 5 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Engineering the Floquet spectrum of superconducting multiterminal quantum dots
Authors:
Régis Mélin,
Romain Danneau,
Kang Yang,
Jean-Guy Caputo,
Benoît Doucot
Abstract:
Here we present a theoretical investigation of the Floquet spectrum in multiterminal quantum dot Josephson junctions biased with commensurate voltages. We first draw an analogy between the electronic band theory and superconductivity which enlightens the time-periodic dynamics of the Andreev bound states. We then show that the equivalent of the Wannier-Stark ladders observed in semiconducting supe…
▽ More
Here we present a theoretical investigation of the Floquet spectrum in multiterminal quantum dot Josephson junctions biased with commensurate voltages. We first draw an analogy between the electronic band theory and superconductivity which enlightens the time-periodic dynamics of the Andreev bound states. We then show that the equivalent of the Wannier-Stark ladders observed in semiconducting superlattices via photocurrent measurements, appears as specific peaks in the finite frequency current fluctuations of superconducting multiterminal quantum dots. In order to probe the Floquet-Wannier-Stark ladder spectra, we have developed an analytical model relying on the sharpness of the resonances. The charge-charge correlation function is obtained as a factorized form of the Floquet wave-function on the dot and the superconducting reservoir populations. We confirm these findings by Keldysh Green's function calculations, in particular regarding the voltage and frequency dependence of the resonance peaks in the current-current correlations. Our results open up a road-map to quantum correlations and coherence in the Floquet dynamics of superconducting devices.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2019; v1 submitted 12 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Nonadiabatic Josephson current pum** by microwave irradiation
Authors:
B. Venitucci,
D. Feinberg,
R. Mélin,
B. Douçot
Abstract:
Irradiating a Josephson junction with microwaves can operate not only on the amplitude but also on the phase of the Josephson current. This requires breaking time inversion symmetry, which is achieved by introducing a phase lapse between the microwave components acting on the two† sides of the junction. General symmetry arguments and the solution of a specific single level quantum dot model show t…
▽ More
Irradiating a Josephson junction with microwaves can operate not only on the amplitude but also on the phase of the Josephson current. This requires breaking time inversion symmetry, which is achieved by introducing a phase lapse between the microwave components acting on the two† sides of the junction. General symmetry arguments and the solution of a specific single level quantum dot model show that this induces chirality in the Cooper pair dynamics, due to the topology of the Andreev bound state wavefunction. Another essential condition is to break electron-hole symmetry within the junction. A shift of the current-phase relation is obtained, which is controllable in sign and amplitude with the microwave phase and an electrostatic gate, thus producing a "chiral" Josephson transistor. The dot model is solved in the infinite gap limit by Floquet theory and in the general case with Keldysh nonequilibrium Green's functions. The chiral current is nonadiabatic: it is extremal and changes sign close to resonant chiral transitions between the Andreev bound states.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2018; v1 submitted 10 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Simple Floquet-Wannier-Stark-Andreev viewpoint and emergence of low-energy scales in a voltage-biased three-terminal Josephson junction
Authors:
Régis Mélin,
Jean-Guy Caputo,
Kang Yang,
Benoît Douçot
Abstract:
A three-terminal Josephson junction consists of three superconductors coupled coherently to a small nonsuperconducting island, such as a diffusive metal, a single or double quantum dot. A specific resonant single quantum dot three-terminal Josephson junction $(S_a,S_b,S_c)$ biased with voltages $(V,-V,0)$ is considered, but the conclusions hold more generally for resonant semi-conducting quantum w…
▽ More
A three-terminal Josephson junction consists of three superconductors coupled coherently to a small nonsuperconducting island, such as a diffusive metal, a single or double quantum dot. A specific resonant single quantum dot three-terminal Josephson junction $(S_a,S_b,S_c)$ biased with voltages $(V,-V,0)$ is considered, but the conclusions hold more generally for resonant semi-conducting quantum wire set-ups. A simple physical picture of the steady state is developed, using Floquet theory. It is shown that the equilibrium Andreev bound states (for $V=0$) evolve into nonequilibrium Floquet-Wannier-Stark-Andreev (FWS-Andreev) ladders of resonances (for $V\ne 0$). These resonances acquire a finite width due to multiple Andreev reflection (MAR) processes. We also consider the effect of an extrinsic line-width broadening on the quantum dot, introduced through a Dynes phenomenological parameter. The DC-quartet current manifests a cross-over between the extrinsic relaxation dominated regime at low voltage to an intrinsic relaxation due to MAR processes at higher voltage. Finally, we study the coupling between the two FWS-Andreev ladders due to Landau-Zener-Stückelberg transitions, and its effect on the cross-over in the relaxation mechanism. Three important low-energy scales are identified, and a perspective is to relate those low-energy scales to a recent noise cross-correlation experiment [Y. Cohen {\it et al.}, arXiv:1606.08436].
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2017; v1 submitted 7 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Non-local Supercurrent of Quartets in a Three-Terminal Josephson Junction
Authors:
Yonatan Cohen,
Yuval Ronen,
Jung-Hyun Kang,
Moty Heiblum,
Denis Feinberg,
Régis Mélin,
Hadas Shtrikman
Abstract:
We report an observation of a new, non dissipative and non local supercurrent, carried by quartets; each consisting of four entangled electrons. The supercurrent is a result of a novel Andreev bound state (ABS), formed among three superconducting terminals. While in a two-terminal Josephson junction the usual ABS, and thus the DC Josephson current, exist only in equilibrium, in the present realiza…
▽ More
We report an observation of a new, non dissipative and non local supercurrent, carried by quartets; each consisting of four entangled electrons. The supercurrent is a result of a novel Andreev bound state (ABS), formed among three superconducting terminals. While in a two-terminal Josephson junction the usual ABS, and thus the DC Josephson current, exist only in equilibrium, in the present realization the ABS exists also in the strongly nonlinear regime (biased terminals). The presence of supercurrent carried by quartets was established by performing non-local conductance and cross-correlation of current fluctuations measurements, in different devices made of aluminum-InAs nanowire junctions. An extensive and detailed theoretical study is intertwined with the experimental results.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2017; v1 submitted 27 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
Partially resummed perturbation theory for multiple Andreev reflections in a short three-terminal Josephson junction
Authors:
Régis Mélin,
Denis Feinberg,
Benoît Douçot
Abstract:
In a transparent three-terminal Josephson junction, modeling nonequilibrium transport is numerically challenging, owing to the interplay between multiple Andreev reflection (MAR) thresholds and multipair resonances in the pair current. An approximate method, coined as "partially resummed perturbation theory in the number of nonlocal Green's functions", is presented that can be operational on a sta…
▽ More
In a transparent three-terminal Josephson junction, modeling nonequilibrium transport is numerically challenging, owing to the interplay between multiple Andreev reflection (MAR) thresholds and multipair resonances in the pair current. An approximate method, coined as "partially resummed perturbation theory in the number of nonlocal Green's functions", is presented that can be operational on a standard computer and demonstrates compatibility with results existing in the literature. In a linear structure made of two neighboring interfaces (with intermediate transparency) connected by a central superconductor, tunneling through each of the interfaces separately is taken into account to all orders. On the contrary, nonlocal processes connecting the two interfaces are accounted for at the lowest relevant order. This yields logarithmically divergent contributions at the gap edges, which are sufficient as a semi-quantitative description. The method is able to describe the current in the full two-dimensional voltage range, including commensurate as well as incommensurate values. The results found for the multipair (for instance quartet) current-phase characteristics as well as the MAR thresholds are compatible with previous results. At intermediate transparency, the multipair critical current is much larger than the background MAR current, which supports an experimental observation of the quartet and multipair resonances. The paper provides a proof of principle for addressing in the future the interplay between quasiparticles and multipairs in four-terminal structures.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2016; v1 submitted 26 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Gate-tunable zero-frequency current cross-correlations of the quartet mode in a voltage-biased three-terminal Josephson junction
Authors:
Régis Mélin,
Moïse Sotto,
Denis Feinberg,
Jean-Guy Caputo,
Benoît Douçot
Abstract:
A three-terminal Josephson junction biased at opposite voltages can sustain a phase-sensitive dc-current carrying three-body static phase coherence, known as the "quartet current". We calculate the zero-frequency current noise cross-correlations and answer the question of whether this current is noisy (like a normal current in response to a voltage drop) or noiseless (like an equilibrium supercurr…
▽ More
A three-terminal Josephson junction biased at opposite voltages can sustain a phase-sensitive dc-current carrying three-body static phase coherence, known as the "quartet current". We calculate the zero-frequency current noise cross-correlations and answer the question of whether this current is noisy (like a normal current in response to a voltage drop) or noiseless (like an equilibrium supercurrent in response to a phase drop). A quantum dot with a level at energy $ε_0$ is connected to three superconductors $S_a$, $S_b$ and $S_c$ with gap $Δ$, biased at $V_a=V$, $V_b=-V$ and $V_c=0$, and with intermediate contact transparencies. At zero temperature, nonlocal quartets (in the sense of four-fermion correlations) are noiseless at subgap voltage in the nonresonant dot regime $ε_0/Δ\gg 1$, which is demonstrated with a semi-analytical perturbative expansion of the cross-correlations. Noise reveals the absence of granularity of the superflow splitting from $S_c$ towards $(S_a,S_b)$ in the nonresonant dot regime, in spite of finite voltage. In the resonant dot regime $ε_0/Δ< 1$, cross-correlations measured in the $(V_a,V_b)$ plane should reveal an "anomaly" in the vicinity of the quartet line $V_a+V_b=0$, related to an additional contribution to the noise, manifesting the phase sensitivity of cross-correlations under the appearance of a three-body phase variable. Phase-dependent effective Fano factors $F_\varphi$ are introduced, defined as the ratio between the amplitudes of phase modulations of the noise and the currents. At low bias, the Fano factors $F_\varphi$ are of order unity in the resonant dot regime $ε_0/Δ< 1$, and they are vanishingly small in the nonresonant dot regime $ε_0/Δ\gg 1$.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2016; v1 submitted 26 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Closing the proximity gap in a metallic Josephson junction between three superconductors
Authors:
C. Padurariu,
T. Jonckheere,
J. Rech,
R. Mélin,
D. Feinberg,
T. Martin,
Yu. V. Nazarov
Abstract:
We describe the proximity effect in a short disordered metallic junction between three superconducting leads. Andreev bound states in the multi-terminal junction may cross the Fermi level. We reveal that for a quasi-continuous metallic density of states, crossings at the Fermi level manifest as closing of the proximity-induced gap. We calculate the local density of states for a wide range of trans…
▽ More
We describe the proximity effect in a short disordered metallic junction between three superconducting leads. Andreev bound states in the multi-terminal junction may cross the Fermi level. We reveal that for a quasi-continuous metallic density of states, crossings at the Fermi level manifest as closing of the proximity-induced gap. We calculate the local density of states for a wide range of transport parameters using quantum circuit theory. The gap closes inside an area of the space spanned by the superconducting phase differences. We derive an approximate analytic expression for the boundary of the area and compare it to the full numerical solution. The size of the area increases with the transparency of the junction and is sensitive to asymmetry. The finite density of states at zero energy is unaffected by electron-hole decoherence present in the junction, although decoherence is important at higher energies. Our predictions can be tested using tunneling transport spectroscopy. To encourage experiments, we calculate the current-voltage characteristic in a typical measurement setup. We show how the structure of the local density of states can be mapped out from the measurement.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2015; v1 submitted 13 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Quartets and the Current-Phase Structure of a Double Quantum Dot Superconducting Bijunction at Equilibrium
Authors:
D. Feinberg,
T. Jonckheere,
J. Rech,
T. Martin,
B. Douçot,
R. Mélin
Abstract:
The equilibrium current-phase structure of a tri-terminal superconducting Josephson junction (bijunction) is analyzed as a function of the two relevant phases. The bijunction is made of two noninteracting quantum dots, each one carrying a single level. Nonlocal processes coupling the three terminals are described in terms of quartet tunneling and pair cotunneling. These couplings are due to nonloc…
▽ More
The equilibrium current-phase structure of a tri-terminal superconducting Josephson junction (bijunction) is analyzed as a function of the two relevant phases. The bijunction is made of two noninteracting quantum dots, each one carrying a single level. Nonlocal processes coupling the three terminals are described in terms of quartet tunneling and pair cotunneling. These couplings are due to nonlocal Andreev and cotunneling processes through the central superconductor $S_0$, as well as direct interdot coupling. In some cases, two degenerate midgap Andreev states appear, symmetric with respect to the ($π,π$) point. The lifting of this degeneracy by interdot couplings induces a strong non-local inductance at low enough temperatures. This effect is compared to the mutual inductance of a two-loop circuit.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
D.C. Josephson transport by quartets and other Andreev resonances in superconducting bijunctions
Authors:
R. Mélin,
D. Feinberg,
H. Courtois,
C. Padurariu,
A. Pfeffer,
J. E. Duvauchelle,
F. Lefloch,
T. Jonckheere,
J. Rech,
T. Martin,
B. Douçot
Abstract:
Bijunctions are three-terminal Josephson junctions where three superconductors are connected by a single weak link made of a metallic region or of quantum dots. Biasing two of the superconductors with commensurate voltages yields Andreev resonances that produce d.c. Josephson currents made of correlated Cooper pairs. For instance with applied voltages (0, V,-V), quartets formed by two entangled Co…
▽ More
Bijunctions are three-terminal Josephson junctions where three superconductors are connected by a single weak link made of a metallic region or of quantum dots. Biasing two of the superconductors with commensurate voltages yields Andreev resonances that produce d.c. Josephson currents made of correlated Cooper pairs. For instance with applied voltages (0, V,-V), quartets formed by two entangled Cooper pairs are emitted by one reservoir towards the two others. Theory involving non-equilibrium Green's functions reveal the microsopic mechanism at play, e.g. multiple coherent Andreev reflections that provide an energy-conserving and fully coherent channel. Recent experiments on diffusive Aluminum-Copper bijunctions show transport anomalies that are interpreted in terms of quartet resonances.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
Proposal for the observation of nonlocal multipair production: the biSQUID
Authors:
J. Rech,
T. Jonckheere,
T. Martin,
B. Douçot,
D. Feinberg,
R. Mélin
Abstract:
We propose an all-superconducting three-terminal setup consisting in a carbon nanotube (or semiconducting nanowire) contacted to three superconducting leads. The resulting device, referred to as a "biSQUID", is made of four quantum dots arranged in two loops of different surface area. We show how this biSQUID can prove a useful tool to probe nonlocal quantum phenomena in an interferometry setup. W…
▽ More
We propose an all-superconducting three-terminal setup consisting in a carbon nanotube (or semiconducting nanowire) contacted to three superconducting leads. The resulting device, referred to as a "biSQUID", is made of four quantum dots arranged in two loops of different surface area. We show how this biSQUID can prove a useful tool to probe nonlocal quantum phenomena in an interferometry setup. We study the measured critical current as a function of the applied magnetic field, which shows peaks in its Fourier spectrum, providing clear signatures of multipair Josephson processes. The device does not require any specific fine-tuning as these features are observed for a wide range of microscopic parameters -- albeit with a non-trivial dependence. Competing effects which may play a significant role in actual experimental realizations are also explored.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2014; v1 submitted 18 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Phase-sensitive transport at a normal metal-superconductor interface close to a Josephson junction
Authors:
David Gosselin,
Gaston Hornecker,
Régis Mélin,
Denis Feinberg
Abstract:
Phase- and voltage bias-sensitive quasiparticle transport at a double $NIS_1IS_2$ interface is considered. The barriers $I$ range from tunnel to transparent, and the intermediate region $S_1$ has a width comparable to the superconducting coherence length. A phase difference $\varphi$ is applied to the Josephson junction $S_1IS_2$. The normal and Andreev reflections at the $NIS_1$ interface become…
▽ More
Phase- and voltage bias-sensitive quasiparticle transport at a double $NIS_1IS_2$ interface is considered. The barriers $I$ range from tunnel to transparent, and the intermediate region $S_1$ has a width comparable to the superconducting coherence length. A phase difference $\varphi$ is applied to the Josephson junction $S_1IS_2$. The normal and Andreev reflections at the $NIS_1$ interface become $\varphi$-sensitive, and transport is governed by interferences within the narrow $S_1$ region, both in the normal and anomalous channels. The subgap conductance is separately (energy $E$)- and (phase $\varphi$)- symmetric. Above the superconducting gap, the conductance is in general not symmetric even if $(E,\varphi)$ is changed in $(-E,-\varphi)$, but the symmetry is restored by averaging Fermi oscillations. The Tomasch oscillations are amplified by the phase difference. The subgap conductance exhibits a resonant structure at the energy of the Andreev bound states (ABS) of the $S_1IS_2$ junction, providing a side-spectroscopy of such states. Depending on the relative transparencies of the junctions, the resonance can increase or reduce the conductance, and it can even vanish for $\varphi=π$, featuring total reflection of quasiparticles at $NS_1$ by the ABS at $S_1S_2$.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2014; v1 submitted 26 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Absence of split pairs in the cross-correlations of a highly transparent normal metal-superconductor-normal metal electron beam splitter
Authors:
Martina Flöser,
Denis Feinberg,
Régis Mélin
Abstract:
The nonlocal conductance and the current cross-correlations are investigated within scattering theory for three-terminal normal metal-superconductor-normal metal (NSN) hybrid structures. The positive cross-correlations at high transparency found by Mélin, Benjamin and Martin [Phys. Rev. B 77, 094512 (2008)] are not due to crossed Andreev reflection. On the other hand, local processes can be enhanc…
▽ More
The nonlocal conductance and the current cross-correlations are investigated within scattering theory for three-terminal normal metal-superconductor-normal metal (NSN) hybrid structures. The positive cross-correlations at high transparency found by Mélin, Benjamin and Martin [Phys. Rev. B 77, 094512 (2008)] are not due to crossed Andreev reflection. On the other hand, local processes can be enhanced by reflectionless tunneling but this mechanism has little influence on nonlocal processes and on current cross-correlations. Therefore Cooper pair splitting cannot be enhanced by reflectionless tunneling. Overall, this shows that NSN structures with highly transparent or effectively highly transparent interfaces are not suited to experimentally producing entangled split pairs of electrons.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Sub-Gap Structure in the Conductance of a Three-Terminal Josephson Junction
Authors:
Andreas H. Pfeffer,
Jean Eudes Duvauchelle,
Hervé Courtois,
Régis Mélin,
Denis Feinberg,
François Lefloch
Abstract:
Three-terminal superconductor (S) - normal metal (N) - superconductor (S) Josephson junctions are investigated. In a geometry where a T-shape normal metal is connected to three superconducting reservoirs, new sub-gap structures appear in the differential resistance for specific combinations of the superconductor chemical potentials. Those correspond to a correlated motion of Cooper pairs within th…
▽ More
Three-terminal superconductor (S) - normal metal (N) - superconductor (S) Josephson junctions are investigated. In a geometry where a T-shape normal metal is connected to three superconducting reservoirs, new sub-gap structures appear in the differential resistance for specific combinations of the superconductor chemical potentials. Those correspond to a correlated motion of Cooper pairs within the device that persist well above the Thouless energy and is consistent with the prediction of quartets formed by two entangled Cooper pairs. A simplified nonequilibrium Keldysh Green's function calculation is presented that supports this interpretation.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2014; v1 submitted 18 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Multipair DC-Josephson Resonances in a biased all-superconducting Bijunction
Authors:
T. Jonckheere,
J. Rech,
T. Martin,
B. Douçot,
D. Feinberg,
R. Mélin
Abstract:
An all-superconducting bijunction consists of a central superconductor contacted to two lateral superconductors, such that non-local crossed Andreev reflection is operating. Then new correlated transport channels for the Cooper pairs appear in addition to those of separated conventional Joseph- son junctions. We study this system in a configuration where the superconductors are connected through g…
▽ More
An all-superconducting bijunction consists of a central superconductor contacted to two lateral superconductors, such that non-local crossed Andreev reflection is operating. Then new correlated transport channels for the Cooper pairs appear in addition to those of separated conventional Joseph- son junctions. We study this system in a configuration where the superconductors are connected through gate-controllable quantum dots. Multipair phase-coherent resonances and phase-dependent multiple Andreev reflections are both obtained when the voltages of the lateral superconductors are commensurate, and they add to the usual local dissipative transport due to quasiparticles. The two-pair resonance (quartets) as well as some other higher order multipair resonances are π-shifted at low voltage. Dot control can be used to dramatically enhance the multipair current when the voltages are resonant with the dot levels.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2013; v1 submitted 10 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Enhancement of Cooper pair splitting by multiple scattering
Authors:
Martina Flöser,
Denis Feinberg,
Régis Mélin
Abstract:
In three-terminal NSN hybrid structures the influence of additional barriers on the nonlocal conductance and on current cross-correlations is studied within a scattering theory. In metallic systems with additional barriers and phase averaging, which simulate disordered regions, local processes can be enhanced by reflectionless tunneling but this mechanism has little influence on nonlocal processes…
▽ More
In three-terminal NSN hybrid structures the influence of additional barriers on the nonlocal conductance and on current cross-correlations is studied within a scattering theory. In metallic systems with additional barriers and phase averaging, which simulate disordered regions, local processes can be enhanced by reflectionless tunneling but this mechanism has little influence on nonlocal processes and on current cross-correlations. Therefore Cooper pair splitting cannot be enhanced by reflectionless tunneling. On the contrary, in ballistic systems, additional barriers lead to Fabry-Perot resonances and allow to separate the different contributions to the conductance and to the current cross-correlations. In particular, crossed Andreev processes can be selectively enhanced by tuning the length or the chemical potential of the interbarrier region.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Production of non-local quartets and phase-sensitive entanglement in a superconducting beam splitter
Authors:
Axel Freyn,
Benoit Douçot,
Denis Feinberg,
Régis Mélin
Abstract:
Three BCS superconductors S_a, S_b, and S and two short normal regions N_a and N_b in a three-terminal S_aN_aSN_bS_b set-up provide a source of non-local quartets spatially separated as two correlated pairs in S_a and S_b, if the distance between the interfaces N_aS and SN_b is comparable to the coherence length in S. Low-temperature dc-transport of non-local quartets from S to S_a and S_b can occ…
▽ More
Three BCS superconductors S_a, S_b, and S and two short normal regions N_a and N_b in a three-terminal S_aN_aSN_bS_b set-up provide a source of non-local quartets spatially separated as two correlated pairs in S_a and S_b, if the distance between the interfaces N_aS and SN_b is comparable to the coherence length in S. Low-temperature dc-transport of non-local quartets from S to S_a and S_b can occur in equilibrium, and also if S_a and S_b are biased at opposite voltages. At higher temperatures, thermal excitations result in correlated current fluctuations which depend on the superconducting phases phi_a and phi_b in S_a and S_b. Phase-sensitive entanglement is obtained at zero temperature if N_a and N_b are replaced by discrete levels.
△ Less
Submitted 25 June, 2011; v1 submitted 11 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
Positive current cross-correlations in a highly transparent normal-superconducting beam splitter due to synchronized Andreev and inverse Andreev reflections
Authors:
Axel Freyn,
Martina Flöser,
Régis Mélin
Abstract:
Predictions are established for linear differential current-current cross-correlations dSab/dV in a symmetrically biased three-terminal normal metal-superconductor-normal metal (NSN) device. Highly transparent contacts turn out to be especially interesting because they feature positive dSab/dV. At high transparency, processes based on Crossed Andreev Reflection (CAR) contribute only negligibly to…
▽ More
Predictions are established for linear differential current-current cross-correlations dSab/dV in a symmetrically biased three-terminal normal metal-superconductor-normal metal (NSN) device. Highly transparent contacts turn out to be especially interesting because they feature positive dSab/dV. At high transparency, processes based on Crossed Andreev Reflection (CAR) contribute only negligibly to the current and to dSab/dV. Under these circumstances, current-current cross-correlations can be plausibly interpreted as a coherent coupling between the two NS interfaces in the form of synchronized Andreev and inverse Andreev reflections, corresponding to the process where a pair of electron-like quasi-particles and a pair of hole-like quasi-particles arrive from the normal electrodes and annihilate in the superconductor. Hence, positive dSab/dV does not automatically imply CAR. For tunnel contacts, dSab/dV is positive because of CAR. In between these two extremities, at intermediate transparencies, dSab/dV is negative because both processes which cause positive correlations, occur only with small amplitude. We use scattering theory to obtain analytic expressions for current and noise, and microscopic calculation using a tight binding model in order to obtain a clear interpretation of the physical processes.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2010; v1 submitted 9 February, 2010;
originally announced February 2010.
-
Self-consistent microscopic calculations for non-local transport through nanoscale superconductors
Authors:
R. Mélin,
F. S. Bergeret,
A. Levy Yeyati
Abstract:
We implement self-consistent microscopic calculations in order to describe out-of-equilibrium non-local transport in normal metal-superconductor-normal metal hybrid structures in the presence of a magnetic field and for arbitrary interface transparencies. A four terminal setup simulating usual experimental situations is described by means of a tight-binding model. We present results for the self…
▽ More
We implement self-consistent microscopic calculations in order to describe out-of-equilibrium non-local transport in normal metal-superconductor-normal metal hybrid structures in the presence of a magnetic field and for arbitrary interface transparencies. A four terminal setup simulating usual experimental situations is described by means of a tight-binding model. We present results for the self-consistent order parameter and current profiles within the sample. These profiles illustrate a crossover from a quasi-equilibrium to a strong non-equilibrium situation when increasing the interface transparencies and the applied voltages. We analyze in detail the behavior of the non-local conductance in these two different regimes. While in quasi-equilibrium conditions this can be expressed as the difference between elastic cotunneling and crossed Andreev transmission coefficients, in a general situation additional contributions due to the voltage dependence of the self-consistent order parameter have to be taken into account. The present results provide a first step towards a self-consistent theory of non-local transport including non-equilibrium effects and describe qualitatively a recent experiment [Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 237003 (2006)].
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2009; v1 submitted 24 November, 2008;
originally announced November 2008.
-
Positive noise cross-correlations in superconducting hybrids: Roles of interfaces and interactions
Authors:
R. Mélin,
C. Benjamin,
T. Martin
Abstract:
Shot noise cross-correlations in normal metal-superconductor-normal metal structures are discussed at arbitrary interface transparencies using both the scattering approach of Blonder, Tinkham and Klapwik and a microscopic Green's function approach. Surprisingly, negative crossed conductance in such set-ups [R. Melin and D. Feinberg, Phys. Rev. B 70, 174509 (2004)] does not preclude the possibility…
▽ More
Shot noise cross-correlations in normal metal-superconductor-normal metal structures are discussed at arbitrary interface transparencies using both the scattering approach of Blonder, Tinkham and Klapwik and a microscopic Green's function approach. Surprisingly, negative crossed conductance in such set-ups [R. Melin and D. Feinberg, Phys. Rev. B 70, 174509 (2004)] does not preclude the possibility of positive noise cross-correlations for almost transparent contacts. We conclude with a phenomenological discussion of interactions in the one dimensional leads connected to the superconductor, which induce sign changes in the noise cross-correlations.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2018; v1 submitted 3 August, 2007;
originally announced August 2007.
-
Equilibrium Low Temperature Heat Capacity of the Spin Density Wave compound (TMTTF)2 Br: effect of a Magnetic Field
Authors:
S. Sahling,
J. C. Lasjaunias,
R. Mélin,
P. Monceau,
G. Reményi
Abstract:
We have investigated the effect of the magnetic field (B) on the very low-temperature equilibrium heat capacity ceq of the quasi-1 D organic compound (TMTTF)2Br, characterized by a commensurate Spin Density Wave (SDW) ground state. Below 1K, ceq is dominated by a Schottky-like contribution, very sensitive to the experimental time scale, a property that we have previously measured in numerous DW…
▽ More
We have investigated the effect of the magnetic field (B) on the very low-temperature equilibrium heat capacity ceq of the quasi-1 D organic compound (TMTTF)2Br, characterized by a commensurate Spin Density Wave (SDW) ground state. Below 1K, ceq is dominated by a Schottky-like contribution, very sensitive to the experimental time scale, a property that we have previously measured in numerous DW compounds. Under applied field (in the range 0.2- 7 T), the equilibrium dynamics, and hence ceq extracted from the time constant, increases enormously. For B = 2-3 T, ceq varies like B2, in agreement with a magnetic Zeeman coupling. Another specific property, common to other Charge/Spin density wave (DW) compounds, is the occurrence of metastable branches in ceq, induced at very low temperature by the field exceeding a critical value. These effects are discussed within a generalization to SDWs in a magnetic field of the available Larkin-Ovchinnikov local model of strong pinning. A limitation of the model when compared to experiments is pointed out.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2007;
originally announced August 2007.
-
Non local Andreev reflection in a carbon nanotube superconducting quantum interference device
Authors:
S. Duhot,
R. Mélin
Abstract:
We investigate a superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID) based on carbon nanotubes in a fork geometry [J.-P. Cleuziou {\it et al.}, Nature Nanotechnology {\bf 1}, 53 (2006)], involving tunneling of evanescent quasiparticles through a superconductor over a distance comparable to the superconducting coherence length, with therefore ``non local'' processes generalizing non local Andreev…
▽ More
We investigate a superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID) based on carbon nanotubes in a fork geometry [J.-P. Cleuziou {\it et al.}, Nature Nanotechnology {\bf 1}, 53 (2006)], involving tunneling of evanescent quasiparticles through a superconductor over a distance comparable to the superconducting coherence length, with therefore ``non local'' processes generalizing non local Andreev reflection and elastic cotunneling. Non local processes induce a reduction of the critical current and modify the current-phase relation. We discuss arbitrary interface transparencies. Such devices in fork geometries are candidates for probing the phase coherence of crossed Andreev reflection.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2007; v1 submitted 29 May, 2007;
originally announced May 2007.
-
Subgap tunneling via quantum-interference effect: insulators and charge density waves
Authors:
S. Duhot,
R. Mélin
Abstract:
A quantum interference effect is discussed for subgap tunneling over a distance comparable to the coherence length, which is a consequence of ``advanced-advanced'' and ``retarded-retarded'' transmission modes [Altland and Zirnbauer, Phys. Rev. B 55, 1142 (1997)]. Effects typical of disorder are obtained from the interplay between multichannel averaging and higher order processes in the tunnel am…
▽ More
A quantum interference effect is discussed for subgap tunneling over a distance comparable to the coherence length, which is a consequence of ``advanced-advanced'' and ``retarded-retarded'' transmission modes [Altland and Zirnbauer, Phys. Rev. B 55, 1142 (1997)]. Effects typical of disorder are obtained from the interplay between multichannel averaging and higher order processes in the tunnel amplitudes. Quantum interference effects similar to those occurring in normal tunnel junctions explain magnetoresistance oscillations of a CDW pierced by nanoholes [Latyshev et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 919 (1997)], having periodicity h/2e as a function of the flux enclosed in the nanohole. Subgap tunneling is coupled to the sliding motion by charge accumulation in the interrupted chains. The effect is within the same trend as random matrix theory for normal metal-CDW hybrids [Visscher et al., Phys. Rev. B 62, 6873 (2000)]. We suggest that the experiment by Latyshev et al. probes weak localization-like properties of evanescent quasiparticles, not an interference effect related to the quantum mechanical ground state.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2007; v1 submitted 30 January, 2007;
originally announced January 2007.
-
Nonlocal transport mediated by nonlocal Hikami boxes: Condensation of evanescent quasiparticles injected into the superconducting gap
Authors:
S. Duhot,
R. Mélin
Abstract:
Evanescent quasiparticles entering a superconductor and propagating over distances larger than the coherence length give rise to intermediate states induced by double Andreev scattering on disorder.The resulting effective attractive interaction between evanescent quasiparticles is retarded at the extremely slow frequency of the applied bias voltage. The non-BCS out-of-equilibrium mesoscopic cond…
▽ More
Evanescent quasiparticles entering a superconductor and propagating over distances larger than the coherence length give rise to intermediate states induced by double Andreev scattering on disorder.The resulting effective attractive interaction between evanescent quasiparticles is retarded at the extremely slow frequency of the applied bias voltage. The non-BCS out-of-equilibrium mesoscopic condensate is compatible with a recent experiment [S. Russo et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 027002 (2005)]. Microscopic theory is discussed in the random phase approximation.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2007; v1 submitted 16 October, 2006;
originally announced October 2006.
-
Strongly disordered Hubbard model in one dimension: spin and orbital infinite randomness and Griffiths phases
Authors:
R. Mélin,
F. Iglói
Abstract:
We study by the strong disorder renormalization group (RG) method the low-energy properties of the one-dimensional Hubbard model with random-hop** matrix-elements $t_{min}<t<t_{max}$, and with random on-site Coulomb repulsion terms $0 \le U_{min}<U<U_{max}$. There are two critical phases, corresponding to an infinite randomness spin random singlet for strong interactions ($U_{min} > t_{max}$)…
▽ More
We study by the strong disorder renormalization group (RG) method the low-energy properties of the one-dimensional Hubbard model with random-hop** matrix-elements $t_{min}<t<t_{max}$, and with random on-site Coulomb repulsion terms $0 \le U_{min}<U<U_{max}$. There are two critical phases, corresponding to an infinite randomness spin random singlet for strong interactions ($U_{min} > t_{max}$) and to an orbital infinite randomness fixed point for vanishing interactions ($U_{max}/t_{max} \to 0$). To each critical infinite randomness fixed point is connected a Griffiths phase, the correlation length and dynamical exponent of which have well defined asymptotic dependences on the corresponding quantum control parameter. The theoretical predictions for the scaling in the vicinity of the critical points compare well to numerical RG simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2006;
originally announced July 2006.
-
Interplay between phase defects and spin polarization in the specific heat of the spin density wave compound (TMTTF)_2Br in a magnetic field
Authors:
R. Mélin,
J. C. Lasjaunias,
S. Sahling,
G. Remenyi,
K. Biljakovic
Abstract:
Equilibrium heat relaxation experiments provide evidence that the ground state of the commensurate spin density wave (SDW) compound (TMTTF)$_2$Br after the application of a sufficient magnetic field is different from the conventional ground state. The experiments are interpreted on the basis of the local model of strong pinning as the deconfinement of soliton-antisoliton pairs triggered by the Z…
▽ More
Equilibrium heat relaxation experiments provide evidence that the ground state of the commensurate spin density wave (SDW) compound (TMTTF)$_2$Br after the application of a sufficient magnetic field is different from the conventional ground state. The experiments are interpreted on the basis of the local model of strong pinning as the deconfinement of soliton-antisoliton pairs triggered by the Zeeman coupling to spin degrees of freedom, resulting in a magnetic field induced density wave glass for the spin carrying phase configuration.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2006;
originally announced June 2006.
-
Dephasing of Andreev pairs entering a charge density wave
Authors:
S. Duhot,
R. Mélin
Abstract:
An Andreev pair from a s-wave superconductor (S) entering a conventional gapless charge density wave (CDW) below the Peierls gap dephases on the Fermi wavelength while one particle states are localized on the CDW coherence length. The paths following different sequences of impurities interfere destructively, due to the different electron and hole densities in the CDW. The same conclusion holds f…
▽ More
An Andreev pair from a s-wave superconductor (S) entering a conventional gapless charge density wave (CDW) below the Peierls gap dephases on the Fermi wavelength while one particle states are localized on the CDW coherence length. The paths following different sequences of impurities interfere destructively, due to the different electron and hole densities in the CDW. The same conclusion holds for averaging over the conduction channels in the ballistic system. We apply two microscopic approaches to this phenomenon: i) a Blonder, Tinkham, Klapwijk (BTK) approach for a single highly transparent S-CDW interface; and ii) the Hamiltonian approach for the Josephson effect in a clean CDW and a CDW with non magnetic disorder. The Josephson effect through a spin density wave (SDW) is limited by the coherence length, not by the Fermi wave-length.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2006; v1 submitted 14 June, 2006;
originally announced June 2006.
-
Thouless energy of a superconductor from non local conductance fluctuations
Authors:
S. Duhot,
R. Mélin
Abstract:
We show that a spin-up electron from a normal metal entering a superconductor propagates as a composite object consisting of a spin-down hole and a pair in the condensate. This leads to a factorization of the non local conductance as two local Andreev reflections at both interfaces and one propagation in the superconductor, which is tested numerically within a one dimensional toy model of reflec…
▽ More
We show that a spin-up electron from a normal metal entering a superconductor propagates as a composite object consisting of a spin-down hole and a pair in the condensate. This leads to a factorization of the non local conductance as two local Andreev reflections at both interfaces and one propagation in the superconductor, which is tested numerically within a one dimensional toy model of reflectionless tunneling. Small area junctions are characterized by non local conductance fluctuations. A treatment ignoring weak localization leads to a Thouless energy inverse proportional to the sample size, as observed in the numerical simulations. We show that weak localization can have a strong effect, and leads to a coupling between evanescent quasiparticles and the condensate by Andreev reflections ``internal'' to the superconductor.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2006; v1 submitted 13 April, 2006;
originally announced April 2006.
-
Possibility of reflectionless tunneling crossed transport at normal metal / superconductor double interfaces
Authors:
S. Duhot,
R. Mélin
Abstract:
We investigate one dimensional models (the Blonder, Tinkham, Klapwijk model and a tight-binding model) of non local transport at normal metal / superconductor (NS) double interfaces. We find a negative elastic cotunneling crossed conductance, strongly enhanced by additional scatterers away from the interfaces, suggesting the possibility of reflectionless tunneling non local transport at double N…
▽ More
We investigate one dimensional models (the Blonder, Tinkham, Klapwijk model and a tight-binding model) of non local transport at normal metal / superconductor (NS) double interfaces. We find a negative elastic cotunneling crossed conductance, strongly enhanced by additional scatterers away from the interfaces, suggesting the possibility of reflectionless tunneling non local transport at double NS interfaces with contacts having a sufficiently small extension.
△ Less
Submitted 19 January, 2006;
originally announced January 2006.
-
Contribution of weak localization to non local transport at normal metal / superconductor double interfaces
Authors:
R. Mélin
Abstract:
In connection with a recent experiment [Russo {\it et al.}, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 95}, 027002 (2005)], we investigate the effect of weak localization on non local transport in normal metal / insulator / superconductor / insulator / normal metal (NISIN) trilayers, with extended interfaces. The negative weak localization contribution to the crossed resistance can exceed in absolute value the posit…
▽ More
In connection with a recent experiment [Russo {\it et al.}, Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 95}, 027002 (2005)], we investigate the effect of weak localization on non local transport in normal metal / insulator / superconductor / insulator / normal metal (NISIN) trilayers, with extended interfaces. The negative weak localization contribution to the crossed resistance can exceed in absolute value the positive elastic cotunneling contribution if the normal metal phase coherence length or the energy are large enough.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2006; v1 submitted 31 October, 2005;
originally announced October 2005.
-
Recent results on energy relaxation in disordered charge and spin density waves
Authors:
R. Mélin,
K. Biljakovic,
J. C. Lasjaunias,
P. Monceau
Abstract:
We briefly review different approaches used recently to describe collective effects in the strong pinning model of disordered charge and spin density waves, in connection with the CRTBT very low temperature heat relaxation experiments.
We briefly review different approaches used recently to describe collective effects in the strong pinning model of disordered charge and spin density waves, in connection with the CRTBT very low temperature heat relaxation experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2005;
originally announced October 2005.
-
Long range statistical fluctuations of the crossed Josephson current
Authors:
R. Mélin
Abstract:
We investigate the crossed Josephson effect in a geometry consisting of a double ferromagnetic bridge between two superconductors, with tunnel interfaces. The crossed Josephson current vanishes on average because the Andreev reflected hole does not follow the same sequence of impurities as the incoming electron. We show that i) the root mean square of the crossed Josephson current distribution i…
▽ More
We investigate the crossed Josephson effect in a geometry consisting of a double ferromagnetic bridge between two superconductors, with tunnel interfaces. The crossed Josephson current vanishes on average because the Andreev reflected hole does not follow the same sequence of impurities as the incoming electron. We show that i) the root mean square of the crossed Josephson current distribution is proportional to the square root of the junction area; and ii) the coherent coupling mediated by fluctuations is ``long range'' since it decays over the ferromagnet phase coherence length $l_φ$, larger than the exchange length. We predict a crossed Josephson current due to fluctuations if the length of the ferromagnets is smaller than $l_φ$ and larger than the exchange length $ξ_h$.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2005; v1 submitted 9 May, 2005;
originally announced May 2005.
-
Strong disorder renormalization group on fractal lattices: Heisenberg models and magnetoresistive effects in tight binding models
Authors:
R. Mélin,
B. Douçot,
F. Iglói
Abstract:
We use a numerical implementation of the strong disorder renormalization group (RG) method to study the low-energy fixed points of random Heisenberg and tight-binding models on different types of fractal lattices. For the Heisenberg model new types of infinite disorder and strong disorder fixed points are found. For the tight-binding model we add an orbital magnetic field and use both diagonal a…
▽ More
We use a numerical implementation of the strong disorder renormalization group (RG) method to study the low-energy fixed points of random Heisenberg and tight-binding models on different types of fractal lattices. For the Heisenberg model new types of infinite disorder and strong disorder fixed points are found. For the tight-binding model we add an orbital magnetic field and use both diagonal and off-diagonal disorder. For this model besides the gap spectra we study also the fraction of frozen sites, the correlation function, the persistent current and the two-terminal current. The lattices with an even number of sites around each elementary plaquette show a dominant $φ_0=h/e$ periodicity. The lattices with an odd number of sites around each elementary plaquette show a dominant $φ_0/2$ periodicity at vanishing diagonal disorder, with a positive weak localization-like magnetoconductance at infinite disorder fixed points. The magnetoconductance with both diagonal and off-diagonal disorder depends on the symmetry of the distribution of on-site energies.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2005;
originally announced March 2005.
-
Crossed conductance in FSF double junctions: role of out-of-equilibrium populations
Authors:
R. Mélin
Abstract:
We discuss a model of Ferromagnet / Superconductor / Ferromagnet (FSF) double junction in which the quasiparticles are not in equilibrium with the condensate in a region of the superconductor containing the two FS contacts. The role of geometry is discussed, as well as the role of a small residual density of states within the superconducting gap, that allows a sequential tunneling crossed curren…
▽ More
We discuss a model of Ferromagnet / Superconductor / Ferromagnet (FSF) double junction in which the quasiparticles are not in equilibrium with the condensate in a region of the superconductor containing the two FS contacts. The role of geometry is discussed, as well as the role of a small residual density of states within the superconducting gap, that allows a sequential tunneling crossed current. With elastic quasiparticle transport and the geometry with lateral contacts, the crossed conductances in the sequential tunneling channel are almost equal in the normal and superconducting phases, if the distance between the FS interfaces is sufficiently small. The sequential tunneling and spatially separated processes (the so-called crossed Andreev reflection and elastic cotunneling processes) lead to different signs of the crossed current in the antiparallel alignment for tunnel interfaces.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2005; v1 submitted 1 February, 2005;
originally announced February 2005.
-
Sign of the crossed conductances at a FSF double interface
Authors:
R. Mélin,
D. Feinberg
Abstract:
Crossed conductance in hybrid Ferromagnet / Superconductor / Ferromagnet (FSF) structures results from the competition between normal transmission and Andreev reflection channels. Crossed Andreev reflection (CAR) and elastic cotunneling (EC) between the ferromagnets are dressed by local Andreev reflections, which play an important role for transparent enough interfaces and intermediate spin pola…
▽ More
Crossed conductance in hybrid Ferromagnet / Superconductor / Ferromagnet (FSF) structures results from the competition between normal transmission and Andreev reflection channels. Crossed Andreev reflection (CAR) and elastic cotunneling (EC) between the ferromagnets are dressed by local Andreev reflections, which play an important role for transparent enough interfaces and intermediate spin polarizations. This modifies the simple result previously obtained at lowest order, and can explain the sign of the crossed resistances in a recent experiment [D. Beckmann {\sl et al.}, cond-mat/0404360]. This holds both in the multiterminal hybrid structure model (where phase averaging over the Fermi oscillations is introduced ``by hand'' within the approximation of a single non local process) and for infinite planar interfaces (where phase averaging naturally results in the microscopic solution with multiple non local processes).
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2004; v1 submitted 12 July, 2004;
originally announced July 2004.
-
F/S interfaces: point contact versus atomic thickness geometries
Authors:
R. Mélin
Abstract:
We contrast perturbative expansions of ferromagnet / superconductor interfaces in two geometries: (i) a point contact geometry where a single weak link connects a 3D ferromagnet to a 3D superconductor and (ii) an atomic thickness geometry with an infinite planar interface connecting a quasi-2D ferromagnet to a quasi-2D superconductor. Perturbation theories are rather different in the two approac…
▽ More
We contrast perturbative expansions of ferromagnet / superconductor interfaces in two geometries: (i) a point contact geometry where a single weak link connects a 3D ferromagnet to a 3D superconductor and (ii) an atomic thickness geometry with an infinite planar interface connecting a quasi-2D ferromagnet to a quasi-2D superconductor. Perturbation theories are rather different in the two approaches but they both break down at order $t^4$ ($t$ is the tunnel amplitude). The regimes of strong ferromagnets are in a qualitative agreement in both geometries. The regime of weak ferromagnets exists only for the atomic thickness geometry and is related to Andreev bound states due to lateral confinement in the superconductor.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2004;
originally announced June 2004.
-
sin(2 phi) current-phase relation in SFS junctions with decoherence in the ferromagnet
Authors:
R. Mélin
Abstract:
We propose a theoretical description of the sin(2 phi) current-phase relation in SFS junctions at the 0-$π$ cross-over obtained in recent experiments by Sellier et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 257005 (2004)] where it was suggested that a strong decoherence in the magnetic alloy can explain the magnitude of the residual supercurrent at the 0-pi cross-over. To describe the interplay between decoheren…
▽ More
We propose a theoretical description of the sin(2 phi) current-phase relation in SFS junctions at the 0-$π$ cross-over obtained in recent experiments by Sellier et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 257005 (2004)] where it was suggested that a strong decoherence in the magnetic alloy can explain the magnitude of the residual supercurrent at the 0-pi cross-over. To describe the interplay between decoherence and elastic scattering in the ferromagnet we use an analogy with crossed Andreev reflection in the presence of disorder. The supercurrent as a function of the length R of the ferromagnet decays exponentially over a length xi, larger than the elastic scattering length $l_d$ in the absence of decoherence, and smaller than the coherence length $l_φ$ in the absence of elastic scattering on impurities. The best fit leads to $ξ\simeq ξ_h^{({\rm diff})}/3$, where $ξ_h^{({\rm diff})}$ is exchange length of the diffusive system without decoherence (also equal to $ξ$ in the absence of decoherence). The fit of experiments works well for the amplitude of both the sin(phi) and sin(2 phi) harmonics.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2004; v1 submitted 11 June, 2004;
originally announced June 2004.