-
Metal enrichment: the apex accretor perspective
Authors:
S. Molendi,
S. Ghizzardi,
S. De Grandi,
M. Balboni,
I. Bartalucci,
D. Eckert,
F. Gastaldello,
L. Lovisari,
G. Riva,
M. Rossetti
Abstract:
Aims. The goal of this work is to devise a description of the enrichment process in large-scale structure that explains the available observations and makes predictions for future measurements. Methods. We took a spartan approach to this study, employing observational results and algebra to connect stellar assembly in star-forming halos with metal enrichment of the intra-cluster and group medium.…
▽ More
Aims. The goal of this work is to devise a description of the enrichment process in large-scale structure that explains the available observations and makes predictions for future measurements. Methods. We took a spartan approach to this study, employing observational results and algebra to connect stellar assembly in star-forming halos with metal enrichment of the intra-cluster and group medium. Results. On one hand, our construct is the first to provide an explanation for much of the phenomenology of metal enrichment in clusters and groups. It sheds light on the lack of redshift evolution in metal abundance, as well as the small scatter of metal abundance profiles, the entropy versus abundance anti-correlation found in cool core clusters, and the so-called Fe conundrum, along with several other aspects of cluster enrichment. On the other hand, it also allows us to infer the properties of other constituents of large-scale structure. We find that gas that is not bound to halos must have a metal abundance similar to that of the ICM and only about one-seventh to one-third of the Fe in the Universe is locked in stars. A comparable amount is found in gas in groups and clusters and, lastly and most importantly, about three-fifths of the total Fe is contained in a tenuous warm or hot gaseous medium in or between galaxies. We point out that several of our results follow from two critical but well motivated assumptions: 1) the stellar mass in massive halos is currently underestimated and 2) the adopted Fe yield is only marginally consistent with predictions from synthesis models and SN rates. Conclusions. One of the most appealing features of the work presented here is that it provides an observationally grounded construct where vital questions on chemical enrichment in the large-scale structure can be addressed. We hope that it may serve as a useful baseline for future works.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
CHEX-MATE : turbulence in the ICM from X-ray surface brightness fluctuations
Authors:
Simon Dupourqué,
Nicolas Clerc,
Etienne Pointecouteau,
Dominique Eckert,
Massimo Gaspari,
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Gabriel W. Pratt,
Elena Rasia,
Mariachiara Rossetti,
Franco Vazza,
Marco Balboni,
Iacopo Bartalucci,
Hervé Bourdin,
Federico De Luca,
Marco De Petris,
Stefano Ettori,
Simona Ghizzardi,
Pasquale Mazzotta
Abstract:
The intra-cluster medium is prone to turbulent motion that will contribute to the non-thermal heating of the gas, complicating the use of galaxy clusters as cosmological probes. Indirect approaches can estimate the intensity and structure of turbulent motions by studying the associated fluctuations in gas density and X-ray surface brightness. In this work, we want to constrain the gas density fluc…
▽ More
The intra-cluster medium is prone to turbulent motion that will contribute to the non-thermal heating of the gas, complicating the use of galaxy clusters as cosmological probes. Indirect approaches can estimate the intensity and structure of turbulent motions by studying the associated fluctuations in gas density and X-ray surface brightness. In this work, we want to constrain the gas density fluctuations at work in the CHEX-MATE sample to obtain a detailed view of their properties in a large population of clusters. We use a simulation-based approach to constrain the parameters of the power spectrum of density fluctuations, assuming a Kolmogorov-like spectrum and including the sample variance, further providing an approximate likelihood for each cluster. This method requires clusters to be not too disturbed, as fluctuations can originate from dynamic processes such as merging. Accordingly, we remove the less relaxed clusters (centroid shift $w>0.02$) from our sample, resulting in a sample of 64 clusters. We define different subsets of CHEX-MATE to determine properties of density fluctuations as a function of dynamical state, mass and redshift, and investigate the correlation with the presence or not of a radio halo. We found a positive correlation between the dynamical state and density fluctuation variance, a non-trivial behaviour with mass and no specific trend with redshift or the presence/absence of a radio halo. The injection scale is mostly constrained by the core region. The slope in the inertial range is consistent with Kolmogorov theory. When interpreted as originating from turbulent motion, the density fluctuations in $R_{500}$ yield an average Mach number of $M_{3D}\simeq 0.4\pm 0.2$, an associated non-thermal pressure support of $ P_{turb}/P_{tot}\simeq (9\pm 6) \%$ or a hydrostatic mass bias $b_{turb}\simeq 0.09\pm 0.06$, in line with what is expected from the literature.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
CHEX-MATE: A LOFAR pilot X-ray$-$radio study on five radio halo clusters
Authors:
M. Balboni,
F. Gastaldello,
A. Bonafede,
A. Botteon,
I. Bartalucci,
H. Bourdin,
G. Brunetti,
R. Cassano,
S. De Grandi,
F. De Luca,
S. Ettori,
S. Ghizzardi,
M. Gitti,
A. Iqbal,
M. Johnston-Hollitt,
L. Lovisari,
P. Mazzotta,
S. Molendi,
E. Pointecouteau,
G. W. Pratt,
G. Riva,
M. Rossetti,
H. Rottgering,
M. Sereno,
R. J. van Weeren
, et al. (2 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The connection between the thermal and non-thermal properties in galaxy clusters hosting radio halos seems fairly well established. However, a comprehensive analysis of such a connection has been made only for integrated quantities (e.g. $L_X - P_{radio}$ relation). In recent years new-generation radio telescopes have enabled the unprecedented possibility to study the non-thermal properties of gal…
▽ More
The connection between the thermal and non-thermal properties in galaxy clusters hosting radio halos seems fairly well established. However, a comprehensive analysis of such a connection has been made only for integrated quantities (e.g. $L_X - P_{radio}$ relation). In recent years new-generation radio telescopes have enabled the unprecedented possibility to study the non-thermal properties of galaxy clusters on a spatially resolved basis. Here, we perform a pilot study to investigate the mentioned properties on five targets, by combining X-ray data from the CHEX-MATE project with the second data release from the LOFAR Two meter Sky survey. We find a strong correlation ($r_s \sim 0.7$) with a slope less than unity between the radio and X-ray surface brightness. We also report differences in the spatially resolved properties of the radio emission in clusters which show different levels of dynamical disturbance. In particular, less perturbed clusters (according to X-ray parameters) show peaked radio profiles in the centre, with a flattening in the outer regions, while the three dynamically disturbed clusters have steeper profiles in the outer regions. We fit a model to the radio emission in the context of turbulent re-acceleration with a constant ratio between thermal and non-thermal particles energy density and a magnetic field profile linked to the thermal gas density as $B(r) \propto n_{th}^{0.5}$. We found that this simple model cannot reproduce the behaviour of the observed radio emission.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2024; v1 submitted 28 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
CHEX-MATE: Robust reconstruction of temperature profiles in galaxy clusters with XMM-Newton
Authors:
M. Rossetti,
D. Eckert,
F. Gastaldello,
E. Rasia,
G. W. Pratt,
S. Ettori,
S. Molendi,
M. Arnaud,
M. Balboni,
I. Bartalucci,
R. M. Batalha,
S. Borgani,
H. Bourdin,
S. De Grandi,
F. De Luca,
M. De Petris,
W. Forman,
M. Gaspari,
S. Ghizzardi,
A. Iqbal,
S. Kay,
L. Lovisari,
B. J. Maughan,
P. Mazzotta,
E. Pointecouteau
, et al. (3 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The "Cluster HEritage project with \xmm: Mass Assembly and Thermodynamics at the Endpoint of structure formation" (CHEX-MATE) is a multi-year Heritage program, to obtain homogeneous XMM-Newton observations of a representative sample of 118 galaxy clusters. The observations are tuned to reconstruct the distribution of the main thermodynamic quantities of the ICM up to $R_{500}$ and to obtain indivi…
▽ More
The "Cluster HEritage project with \xmm: Mass Assembly and Thermodynamics at the Endpoint of structure formation" (CHEX-MATE) is a multi-year Heritage program, to obtain homogeneous XMM-Newton observations of a representative sample of 118 galaxy clusters. The observations are tuned to reconstruct the distribution of the main thermodynamic quantities of the ICM up to $R_{500}$ and to obtain individual mass measurements, via the hydrostatic-equilibrium equation, with a precision of 15-20%. Temperature profiles are a necessary ingredient for the scientific goals of the project and it is thus crucial to derive the best possible temperature measurements from our data. This is why we have built a new pipeline for spectral extraction and analysis of XMM-Newton data, based on a new physically motivated background model and on a Bayesian approach with Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods, that we present in this paper for the first time. We applied this new method to a subset of 30 galaxy clusters representative of the CHEX-MATE sample and show that we can obtain reliable temperature measurements up to regions where the source intensity is as low as 20% of the background, kee** systematic errors below 10%. We compare the median profile of our sample and the best fit slope at large radii with literature results and we find a good agreement with other measurements based on XMM-Newton data. Conversely, when we exclude from our analysis the most contaminated regions, where the source intensity is below 20 of the background, we find significantly flatter profiles, in agreement with predictions from numerical simulations and independent measurements with a combination of Sunyaev-Zeldovich and X-ray imaging data.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Understanding the Nature of the Ultra-Steep Spectrum Diffuse Radio Source in the Galaxy Cluster Abell 272
Authors:
Arthur Whyley,
Scott W. Randall,
Tracy E. Clarke,
Reinout J. van Weeren,
Kamlesh Rajpurohit,
William R. Forman,
Alastair C. Edge,
Elizabeth L. Blanton,
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Huib T. Intema
Abstract:
Ultra-steep spectrum (USS) radio sources with complex filamentary morphologies are a poorly understood subclass of diffuse radio source found in galaxy clusters. They are characterised by power law spectra with spectral indices less than -1.5, and are typically located in merging clusters. We present X-ray and radio observations of the galaxy cluster A272, containing a USS diffuse radio source. Th…
▽ More
Ultra-steep spectrum (USS) radio sources with complex filamentary morphologies are a poorly understood subclass of diffuse radio source found in galaxy clusters. They are characterised by power law spectra with spectral indices less than -1.5, and are typically located in merging clusters. We present X-ray and radio observations of the galaxy cluster A272, containing a USS diffuse radio source. The system is an ongoing major cluster merger with an extended region of bright X-ray emission south of the core. Surface brightness analysis yields a $3σ$ detection of a merger shock front in this region. We obtain shock Mach numbers $M_ρ= 1.20 \pm 0.09$ and $M_T = 1.7 \pm 0.3$ from the density and temperature jumps, respectively. Optical data reveals that the system is a merger between a northern cool core cluster and a southern non-cool core cluster. We find that the USS source, with spectral index $α^{\text{74 MHz}}_{\text{1.4 GHz}} = -1.9 \pm 0.1$, is located in the bright southern region. Radio observations show that the source has a double-lobed structure with complex filaments, and is centred on the brightest cluster galaxy of the southern subcluster. We provide two suggestions for the origin of this source; the first posits the source as an AGN relic that has been re-energised by the passing of a merger shock front, while the second interprets the complex structure as the result of two overlap** AGN radio outbursts. We also present constraints on the inverse Compton emission at the location of the source.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
CHEX-MATE: Characterization of the intra-cluster medium temperature distribution
Authors:
L. Lovisari,
S. Ettori,
E. Rasia,
M. Gaspari,
H. Bourdin,
M. G. Campitiello,
M. Rossetti,
I. Bartalucci,
S. De Grandi,
F. De Luca,
M. De Petris,
D. Eckert,
W. Forman,
F. Gastaldello,
S. Ghizzardi,
C. Jones,
S. Kay,
J. Kim,
B. J. Maughan,
P. Mazzotta,
E. Pointecouteau,
G. W. Pratt,
J. Sayers,
M. Sereno,
M. Simonte
, et al. (1 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We study the perturbations in the temperature (and density) distribution for 28 clusters selected from the CHEX-MATE sample to evaluate and characterize the level of inhomogeneities and the related dynamical state of the ICM. We use these spatially resolved 2D distributions to measure the global and radial scatter and identify the regions that deviate the most from the average distribution. During…
▽ More
We study the perturbations in the temperature (and density) distribution for 28 clusters selected from the CHEX-MATE sample to evaluate and characterize the level of inhomogeneities and the related dynamical state of the ICM. We use these spatially resolved 2D distributions to measure the global and radial scatter and identify the regions that deviate the most from the average distribution. During this process, we introduce three dynamical state estimators and produce clean temperature profiles after removing the most deviant regions. We find that the temperature distribution of most of the clusters is skewed towards high temperatures and is well described by a log-normal function. There is no indication that the number of regions deviating more than 1$σ$ from the azimuthal value is correlated with the dynamical state inferred from morphological estimators. The removal of these regions leads to local temperature variations up to 10-20% and an average increase of $\sim$5% in the overall cluster temperatures. The measured relative intrinsic scatter within $R_{500}$, $σ_{T,int}/T$, has values of 0.17$^{+0.08}_{-0.05}$, and is almost independent of the cluster mass and dynamical state. Comparing the scatter of temperature and density profiles to hydrodynamic simulations, we constrain the average Mach number regime of the sample to $M_{3D}$=0.36$^{+0.16}_{-0.09}$. We infer the ratio between the energy in turbulence and the thermal energy, and translate this ratio in terms of a predicted hydrostatic mass bias $b$, estimating an average value of $b\sim$0.11 (covering a range between 0 and 0.37) within $R_{500}$. This study provides detailed temperature fluctuation measurements for 28 CHEX-MATE clusters which can be used to study turbulence, derive the mass bias, and make predictions on the scaling relation properties.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Weak-Lensing Analysis of the Complex Cluster Merger Abell 746 with Subaru/Hyper Suprime-Cam
Authors:
Kim HyeongHan,
Hyejeon Cho,
M. James Jee,
David Wittman,
Sangjun Cha,
Wonki Lee,
Kyle Finner,
Kamlesh Rajpurohit,
Marcus Brüggen,
William Forman,
Christine Jones,
Reinout van Weeren,
Andrea Botteon,
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Andra Stroe,
Paola Domínguez-Fernández,
Ewan O'Sullivan,
Jan Vrtilek
Abstract:
The galaxy cluster Abell 746 (A746; $z$=0.214), featuring a double radio relic system, two isolated radio relics, a possible radio halo, disturbed V-shaped X-ray emission, and intricate galaxy distributions, is a unique and complex merging system. We present a weak-lensing analysis of A746 based on wide-field imaging data from Subaru/Hyper Suprime-Cam observations. The mass distribution is charact…
▽ More
The galaxy cluster Abell 746 (A746; $z$=0.214), featuring a double radio relic system, two isolated radio relics, a possible radio halo, disturbed V-shaped X-ray emission, and intricate galaxy distributions, is a unique and complex merging system. We present a weak-lensing analysis of A746 based on wide-field imaging data from Subaru/Hyper Suprime-Cam observations. The mass distribution is characterized by a main peak which coincides with the center of the X-ray emission. At this main peak, we detect two extensions toward the north and west, tracing the cluster galaxy and X-ray distributions. Despite the ongoing merger, our estimate of the A746 global mass $M_{500}=4.4\pm1.0\times10^{14}~M_{\odot}$ is consistent with the previous results from SZ and X-ray observations. We conclude that reconciling the distributions of mass, galaxies, and intracluster medium with the double radio relic system and other radio features remains challenging.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2024; v1 submitted 1 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
A combined LOFAR and XMM-Newton analysis of the disturbed cluster PSZ2G113.91-37.01
Authors:
M. G. Campitiello,
A. Bonafede,
A. Botteon,
L. Lovisari,
S. Ettori,
G. Brunetti,
F. Gastaldello,
M. Rossetti,
R. Cassano,
A. Ignesti,
R. J. van Weeren,
M. Brüggen,
M. Hoeft
Abstract:
In this work, we investigated the interplay between the X-ray and radio emission of the cluster PSZ2G113.91-37.01 (z = 0.371) using the high-quality XMM-Newton observations of the CHEX-MATE project, and the images of the LoTSS-DR2. The cluster is undergoing a merger along the north-south axis, and shows a central radio halo and two radio relics, one in the southern and one in the northern regions.…
▽ More
In this work, we investigated the interplay between the X-ray and radio emission of the cluster PSZ2G113.91-37.01 (z = 0.371) using the high-quality XMM-Newton observations of the CHEX-MATE project, and the images of the LoTSS-DR2. The cluster is undergoing a merger along the north-south axis, and shows a central radio halo and two radio relics, one in the southern and one in the northern regions. The analysis of the intracluster medium distribution revealed the presence of a northern surface brightness jump associated to the merger event. By extracting spectra across this discontinuity, we classified the edge as a cold front. Furthermore, we made use of upgraded Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope observations that allowed us to perform a spectral analysis of the G113 radio emission. We found evidence of re-acceleration of particles in the northern relic, and we measured an associated Mach number of M = 1.95 $\pm$ 0.01, as inferred from radio observations. We then performed a point-to-point analysis of the X-ray and radio emission both in the halo and in the northern relic regions. We found a strong correlation for the halo and an anti-correlation for the relic. The former behaviour is in agreement with previous studies. The relic anti-correlation is likely related to the reverse radial distribution of the X-ray (increasing towards the cluster centre) and radio (decreasing towards the cluster centre) emissions. Finally, we performed a point-to-point analysis of the radio emission and the residuals obtained by subtracting a double beta model to the X-ray emission. We found a strong correlation between the two quantities. This behaviour suggests the presence of a connection between the process responsible for the radio emission and the one that leaves fluctuations in the X-ray observations.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
CHEX-MATE: A non-parametric deep learning technique to deproject and deconvolve galaxy cluster X-ray temperature profiles
Authors:
A. Iqbal,
G. W. Pratt,
J. Bobin,
M. Arnaud,
E. Rasia,
M. Rossetti,
R. T. Duffy,
I. Bartalucci,
H. Bourdin,
F. De Luca,
M. De Petris,
M. Donahue,
D. Eckert,
S. Ettori,
A. Ferragamo,
M. Gaspari,
F. Gastaldello,
R. Gavazzi,
S. Ghizzardi,
L. Lovisari,
P. Mazzotta,
B. J. Maughan,
E. Pointecouteau,
M. Sereno
Abstract:
Temperature profiles of the hot galaxy cluster intracluster medium (ICM) have a complex non-linear structure that traditional parametric modelling may fail to fully approximate. For this study, we made use of neural networks, for the first time, to construct a data-driven non-parametric model of ICM temperature profiles. A new deconvolution algorithm was then introduced to uncover the true (3D) te…
▽ More
Temperature profiles of the hot galaxy cluster intracluster medium (ICM) have a complex non-linear structure that traditional parametric modelling may fail to fully approximate. For this study, we made use of neural networks, for the first time, to construct a data-driven non-parametric model of ICM temperature profiles. A new deconvolution algorithm was then introduced to uncover the true (3D) temperature profiles from the observed projected (2D) temperature profiles. An auto-encoder-inspired neural network was first trained by learning a non-linear interpolatory scheme to build the underlying model of 3D temperature profiles in the radial range of [0.02-2] R$_{500}$, using a sparse set of hydrodynamical simulations from the THREE HUNDRED PROJECT. A deconvolution algorithm using a learning-based regularisation scheme was then developed. The model was tested using high and low resolution input temperature profiles, such as those expected from simulations and observations, respectively. We find that the proposed deconvolution and deprojection algorithm is robust with respect to the quality of the data, the morphology of the cluster, and the deprojection scheme used. The algorithm can recover unbiased 3D radial temperature profiles with a precision of around 5\% over most of the fitting range. We apply the method to the first sample of temperature profiles obtained with XMM{\it -Newton} for the CHEX-MATE project and compared it to parametric deprojection and deconvolution techniques. Our work sets the stage for future studies that focus on the deconvolution of the thermal profiles (temperature, density, pressure) of the ICM and the dark matter profiles in galaxy clusters, using deep learning techniques in conjunction with X-ray, Sunyaev Zel'Dovich (SZ) and optical datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2023; v1 submitted 5 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Abell 746: A highly disturbed cluster undergoing multiple mergers
Authors:
K. Rajpurohit,
L. Lovisari,
A. Botteon,
C. Jones,
W. Forman,
E. O'Sullivan,
R. J. van Weeren,
K. HyeongHan,
A. Bonafede,
M. J. Jee,
F. Vazza,
G. Brunetti,
H. Cho,
P. Domínguez-Fernández,
A. Stroe,
K. Finner,
M. Brüggen,
J. M. Vrtilek,
L. P. David,
G. Schellenberger,
D. Wittman,
G. Lusetti,
R. Kraft,
F. de. Gasperin
Abstract:
We present deep XMM-Newton, Karl Jansky Very Large Array, and upgraded Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope observations of Abell 746, a cluster that hosts a plethora of diffuse emission sources that provide evidence for the acceleration of relativistic particles. Our new XMM-Newton images reveal a complex morphology of the thermal gas with several substructures. We observe an asymmetric temperature di…
▽ More
We present deep XMM-Newton, Karl Jansky Very Large Array, and upgraded Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope observations of Abell 746, a cluster that hosts a plethora of diffuse emission sources that provide evidence for the acceleration of relativistic particles. Our new XMM-Newton images reveal a complex morphology of the thermal gas with several substructures. We observe an asymmetric temperature distribution across the cluster: the southern regions exhibit higher temperatures, reaching ~9 keV, while the northern regions have lower temperatures (below 4 keV), likely due to a complex merger. We find evidence of four surface brightness edges, of which three are merger-driven shock fronts. Combining our new data with the published LOw-Frequency ARray observations has unveiled the nature of diffuse sources in this system. The bright northwest relic shows thin filaments and high degree of polarization with aligned magnetic field vectors. We detect a density jump, aligned with the fainter relic to the north. To the south, we detect high-temperature regions, consistent with shock-heated regions and density jump coincident with the northern tip of the southern radio structure. Its integrated spectrum shows a high-frequency steepening. Lastly, we find that the cluster hosts large-scale radio halo emission. The comparison of the thermal and nonthermal emission reveals an anticorrelation between the bright radio and X-ray features at the center. Our findings suggest that Abell 746 is a complex system that involves multiple mergers.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2024; v1 submitted 4 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
LOFAR detection of extended emission around a mini-halo in the galaxy cluster Abell 1413
Authors:
Giulia Lusetti,
Annalisa Bonafede,
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Myriam Gitti,
Stefano Ettori,
Rossella Cassano,
Christopher J. Riseley,
Federica Govoni,
Marcus Brüggen,
Luca Bruno,
Reinout J. van Weeren,
Andrea Botteon,
Duy N. Hoang,
Fabio Gastaldello,
Alessandro Ignesti,
Mariachiara Rossetti,
Timothy W. Shimwell
Abstract:
The relation between giant radio halos and mini-halos in galaxy clusters is not understood. The former are usually associated with merging clusters, the latter are found in relaxed systems. In the last years, the advent of low-frequency radio observations has challenged this dichotomy, finding intermediate objects with a hybrid radio morphology. We aim to investigate the presence of diffuse radio…
▽ More
The relation between giant radio halos and mini-halos in galaxy clusters is not understood. The former are usually associated with merging clusters, the latter are found in relaxed systems. In the last years, the advent of low-frequency radio observations has challenged this dichotomy, finding intermediate objects with a hybrid radio morphology. We aim to investigate the presence of diffuse radio emission in the cluster Abell 1413 and determine its dynamical status. We used LOFAR HBA observations centred at 144 MHz to study the diffuse emission hosted by this cluster.To investigate the dynamical state of the system, we complete our study with newly analysed XMM-Newton archival data. A1413 shows features that are typically present in both relaxed (e.g., peaked x-ray surface brightness distribution and little large-scale inhomogeneities) and disturbed (e.g., flatter temperature and metallicity profiles) clusters.This evidence supports the scenario that A1413 is neither a disturbed nor fully relaxed object. We argue that it is an intermediate-phase cluster.Using radio observations at 144 MHz, we discover the presence of a wider diffuse component surrounding the previously reported mini-halo at the cluster centre. By fitting the radio surface brightness profile with a double-exponential model, we can disentangle the two components. We find an inner mini-halo with an e-folding radius r_e1=28 kpc and the extended component with r_e2 = 290 kpc. We also performed point-to-point correlations between radio and X-ray surface brightness, finding a sub-linear relation for the outer emission and a super-linear relation for the mini-halo.The mini-halo and the diffuse emission extend over different scales and show different features, confirming the double nature of the radio emission and suggesting that the mechanisms responsible for the re-acceleration of the radio-emitting particle might be different.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2024; v1 submitted 3 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
CHEX-MATE: CLUster Multi-Probes in Three Dimensions (CLUMP-3D), I. Gas Analysis Method using X-ray and Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect Data
Authors:
Junhan Kim,
Jack Sayers,
Mauro Sereno,
Iacopo Bartalucci,
Loris Chappuis,
Sabrina De Grandi,
Federico De Luca,
Marco De Petris,
Megan E. Donahue,
Dominique Eckert,
Stefano Ettori,
Massimo Gaspari,
Fabio Gastaldello,
Raphael Gavazzi,
Adriana Gavidia,
Simona Ghizzardi,
Asif Iqbal,
Scott Kay,
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Ben J. Maughan,
Pasquale Mazzotta,
Nobuhiro Okabe,
Etienne Pointecouteau,
Gabriel W. Pratt,
Mariachiara Rossetti
, et al. (1 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Galaxy clusters are the products of structure formation through myriad physical processes that affect their growth and evolution throughout cosmic history. As a result, the matter distribution within galaxy clusters, or their shape, is influenced by cosmology and astrophysical processes, in particular the accretion of new material due to gravity. We introduce an analysis method to investigate the…
▽ More
Galaxy clusters are the products of structure formation through myriad physical processes that affect their growth and evolution throughout cosmic history. As a result, the matter distribution within galaxy clusters, or their shape, is influenced by cosmology and astrophysical processes, in particular the accretion of new material due to gravity. We introduce an analysis method to investigate the 3D triaxial shapes of galaxy clusters from the Cluster HEritage project with XMM-Newton -- Mass Assembly and Thermodynamics at the Endpoint of structure formation (CHEX-MATE). In this work, the first paper of a CHEX-MATE triaxial analysis series, we focus on utilizing X-ray data from XMM and Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect maps from Planck and ACT to obtain a three dimensional triaxial description of the intracluster medium (ICM) gas. We present the forward modeling formalism of our technique, which projects a triaxial ellipsoidal model for the gas density and pressure to compare directly with the observed two dimensional distributions in X-rays and the SZ effect. A Markov chain Monte Carlo is used to estimate the posterior distributions of the model parameters. Using mock X-ray and SZ observations of a smooth model, we demonstrate that the method can reliably recover the true parameter values. In addition, we apply the analysis to reconstruct the gas shape from the observed data of one CHEX-MATE galaxy cluster, Abell 1689, to illustrate the technique. The inferred parameters are in agreement with previous analyses for that cluster, and our results indicate that the geometrical properties, including the axial ratios of the ICM distribution, are constrained to within a few percent. With much better precision than previous studies, we thus further establish that Abell 1689 is significantly elongated along the line of sight, resulting in its exceptional gravitational lensing properties.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2024; v1 submitted 10 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
CHEX-MATE: Constraining the origin of the scatter in galaxy cluster radial X-ray surface brightness profiles
Authors:
I. Bartalucci,
S. Molendi,
E. Rasia,
G. W. Pratt,
M. Arnaud,
M. Rossetti,
F. Gastaldello,
D. Eckert,
M. Balboni,
S. Borgani,
H. Bourdin,
M. G. Campitiello,
S. De Grandi,
M. De Petris,
R. T. Duffy,
S. Ettori,
A. Ferragamo,
M. Gaspari,
R. Gavazzi,
S. Ghizzardi,
A. Iqbal,
S. T. Kay,
L. Lovisari,
P. Mazzotta,
B. J. Maughan
, et al. (3 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We investigate the statistical properties and the origin of the scatter within the spatially resolved surface brightness profiles of the CHEX-MATE sample, formed by 118 galaxy clusters selected via the SZ effect. These objects have been drawn from the Planck SZ catalogue and cover a wide range of masses, M$_{500}=[2-15] \times 10^{14} $M$_{\odot}$, and redshift, z=[0.05,0.6]. We derived the surfac…
▽ More
We investigate the statistical properties and the origin of the scatter within the spatially resolved surface brightness profiles of the CHEX-MATE sample, formed by 118 galaxy clusters selected via the SZ effect. These objects have been drawn from the Planck SZ catalogue and cover a wide range of masses, M$_{500}=[2-15] \times 10^{14} $M$_{\odot}$, and redshift, z=[0.05,0.6]. We derived the surface brightness and emission measure profiles and determined the statistical properties of the full sample. We found that there is a critical scale, R$\sim 0.4 R_{500}$, within which morphologically relaxed and disturbed object profiles diverge. The median of each sub-sample differs by a factor of $\sim 10$ at $0.05\,R_{500}$. There are no significant differences between mass- and redshift-selected sub-samples once proper scaling is applied. We compare CHEX-MATE with a sample of 115 clusters drawn from the The Three Hundred suite of cosmological simulations. We found that simulated emission measure profiles are systematically steeper than those of observations. For the first time, the simulations were used to break down the components causing the scatter between the profiles. We investigated the behaviour of the scatter due to object-by-object variation. We found that the high scatter, approximately 110%, at $R<0.4R_{500}$ is due to a genuine difference between the distribution of the gas in the core. The intermediate scale, $R_{500} =[0.4-0.8]$, is characterised by the minimum value of the scatter on the order of 0.56, indicating a region where cluster profiles are the closest to the self-similar regime. Larger scales are characterised by increasing scatter due to the complex spatial distribution of the gas. Also for the first time, we verify that the scatter due to projection effects is smaller than the scatter due to genuine object-by-object variation in all the considered scales. [abridged]
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
A 600 kpc complex radio source at the center of Abell 3718 discovered by the EMU and POSSUM surveys
Authors:
F. Loi,
M. Brienza,
C. J. Riseley,
L. Rudnick,
W. Boschin,
L. Lovisari,
E. Carretti,
B. Koribalski,
C. Stuardi,
S. P. O'Sullivan,
A. Bonafede,
M. D. Filipović,
A. Hopkins
Abstract:
Multifrequency studies of galaxy clusters are crucial for inferring their dynamical states and physics. Moreover, these studies allow us to investigate cluster-embedded sources, whose evolution is affected by the physical and dynamical condition of the cluster itself. So far, these kinds of studies have been preferentially conducted on clusters visible from the northern hemisphere due to the high-…
▽ More
Multifrequency studies of galaxy clusters are crucial for inferring their dynamical states and physics. Moreover, these studies allow us to investigate cluster-embedded sources, whose evolution is affected by the physical and dynamical condition of the cluster itself. So far, these kinds of studies have been preferentially conducted on clusters visible from the northern hemisphere due to the high-fidelity imaging capabilities of ground-based radio interferometers located there. In this paper, we conducted a multifrequency study of the poorly known galaxy cluster Abell 3718. We investigated the unknown origin of an extended radio source with a length of $\sim$612 kpc at 943 MHz detected in images from the Evolutionary Map of the Universe (EMU) and POlarisation Sky Survey of the Universe's Magnetism (POSSUM) surveys. We analyzed optical and X-ray data to infer the dynamical state of the cluster and, in particular, the merger activity. We conducted a radio spectral index study from 943 MHz up to 9 GHz. We also evaluated the polarization properties of the brightest cluster-embedded sources to understand if they are related to the radio emission observed on larger scales. [Abstract truncated due to arxiv limit! Please see the pdf version]
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Line Emission Mapper (LEM): Probing the physics of cosmic ecosystems
Authors:
Ralph Kraft,
Maxim Markevitch,
Caroline Kilbourne,
Joseph S. Adams,
Hiroki Akamatsu,
Mohammadreza Ayromlou,
Simon R. Bandler,
Marco Barbera,
Douglas A. Bennett,
Anil Bhardwaj,
Veronica Biffi,
Dennis Bodewits,
Akos Bogdan,
Massimiliano Bonamente,
Stefano Borgani,
Graziella Branduardi-Raymont,
Joel N. Bregman,
Joseph N. Burchett,
Jenna Cann,
Jenny Carter,
Priyanka Chakraborty,
Eugene Churazov,
Robert A. Crain,
Renata Cumbee,
Romeel Dave
, et al. (85 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Line Emission Mapper (LEM) is an X-ray Probe for the 2030s that will answer the outstanding questions of the Universe's structure formation. It will also provide transformative new observing capabilities for every area of astrophysics, and to heliophysics and planetary physics as well. LEM's main goal is a comprehensive look at the physics of galaxy formation, including stellar and black-hole…
▽ More
The Line Emission Mapper (LEM) is an X-ray Probe for the 2030s that will answer the outstanding questions of the Universe's structure formation. It will also provide transformative new observing capabilities for every area of astrophysics, and to heliophysics and planetary physics as well. LEM's main goal is a comprehensive look at the physics of galaxy formation, including stellar and black-hole feedback and flows of baryonic matter into and out of galaxies. These processes are best studied in X-rays, and emission-line map** is the pressing need in this area. LEM will use a large microcalorimeter array/IFU, covering a 30x30' field with 10" angular resolution, to map the soft X-ray line emission from objects that constitute galactic ecosystems. These include supernova remnants, star-forming regions, superbubbles, galactic outflows (such as the Fermi/eROSITA bubbles in the Milky Way and their analogs in other galaxies), the Circumgalactic Medium in the Milky Way and other galaxies, and the Intergalactic Medium at the outskirts and beyond the confines of galaxies and clusters. LEM's 1-2 eV spectral resolution in the 0.2-2 keV band will make it possible to disentangle the faintest emission lines in those objects from the bright Milky Way foreground, providing groundbreaking measurements of the physics of these plasmas, from temperatures, densities, chemical composition to gas dynamics. While LEM's main focus is on galaxy formation, it will provide transformative capability for all classes of astrophysical objects, from the Earth's magnetosphere, planets and comets to the interstellar medium and X-ray binaries in nearby galaxies, AGN, and cooling gas in galaxy clusters. In addition to pointed observations, LEM will perform a shallow all-sky survey that will dramatically expand the discovery space.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2023; v1 submitted 17 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
The cavity of 3CR 196.1: H$α$ emission spatially associated with an X-ray cavity
Authors:
A. Jimenez-Gallardo,
E. Sani,
F. Ricci,
C. Mazzucchelli,
B. Balmaverde,
F. Massaro,
A. Capetti,
W. R. Forman,
R. P. Kraft,
G. Venturi,
M. Gendron-Marsolais,
M. A. Prieto,
A. Marconi,
H. A. Peña-Herazo,
S. A. Baum,
C. P. O'Dea,
L. Lovisari,
R. Gilli,
E. Torresi,
A. Paggi,
V. Missaglia,
G. R. Tremblay,
B. J. Wilkes
Abstract:
We present a multifrequency analysis of the radio galaxy 3CR 196.1 ($z = 0.198$), associated with the brightest galaxy of the cool core cluster CIZAJ0815.4-0303. This nearby radio galaxy shows a hybrid radio morphology and an X-ray cavity, all signatures of a turbulent past activity, potentially due to merger events and AGN outbursts. We present results of the comparison between $Chandra$ and VLT/…
▽ More
We present a multifrequency analysis of the radio galaxy 3CR 196.1 ($z = 0.198$), associated with the brightest galaxy of the cool core cluster CIZAJ0815.4-0303. This nearby radio galaxy shows a hybrid radio morphology and an X-ray cavity, all signatures of a turbulent past activity, potentially due to merger events and AGN outbursts. We present results of the comparison between $Chandra$ and VLT/MUSE data for the inner region of the galaxy cluster, on a scale of tens of kpc. We discovered H$α$ + [N II]$\lambda6584$ emission spatially associated with the X-ray cavity (at $\sim$10 kpc from the galaxy nucleus) instead of with its rim. This result differs from previous discoveries of ionized gas surrounding X-ray cavities in other radio galaxies harbored in galaxy clusters and could represent the first reported case of ionized gas filling an X-ray cavity, either due to different AGN outbursts or to the cooling of warm ($10^4<T\leq10^7$ K) AGN outflows. We also found that the H$α$, [N II]$λ\lambda6548,6584$ and [S II]$λ\lambda6718,6733$ emission lines show an additional redward component, at $\sim$1000 km$\,$s$^{-1}$ from rest frame, with no detection in H$β$ or [O III]$λ\lambda4960,5008$. We believe the most likely explanation for this redward component is the presence of a background gas cloud since there appears to be a discrete difference in velocities between this component and the rest frame.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
$i(cm)z$, a semi-analytic model for the thermodynamic properties in galaxy clusters: calibrations with mass and redshift, and implication for the hydrostatic bias
Authors:
S. Ettori,
L. Lovisari,
D. Eckert
Abstract:
In the self-similar scenario for galaxy cluster formation and evolution, the thermodynamic properties of the X-ray emitting plasma can be predicted in their dependencies on the halo mass and redshift only. However, several departures from this simple self-similar scenario have been observed. We show how our semi-analytic model $i(cm)z$, which modifies the self-similar predictions through two tempe…
▽ More
In the self-similar scenario for galaxy cluster formation and evolution, the thermodynamic properties of the X-ray emitting plasma can be predicted in their dependencies on the halo mass and redshift only. However, several departures from this simple self-similar scenario have been observed. We show how our semi-analytic model $i(cm)z$, which modifies the self-similar predictions through two temperature-dependent quantities, the gas mass fraction $f_g=f_0 T^{f_1} E_z^{f_z}$ and the temperature variation $f_T=t_0 T^{t_1} E_z^{t_z}$, can be calibrated to incorporate the mass and redshift dependencies. We used a published set of 17 scaling relations to constrain the parameters of the model. We were subsequently able to make predictions as to the slope of any observed scaling relation within a few percent of the central value and about one $σ$ of the nominal error. Contextually, the evolution of these scaling laws was also determined, with predictions within $1.5 σ$ and within 10 percent of the observational constraints. Relying on this calibration, we have also evaluated the consistency of the predictions on the radial profiles with some observational datasets. For a sample of high-quality data (X-COP), we were able to constrain a further parameter of the model, the hydrostatic bias $b$. By calibrating the model, we have determined that (i) the slopes of the temperature dependence are $f_1=0.403 (\pm0.009)$ and $t_1=0.144 (\pm0.017)$; and that (ii) the dependence upon $E_z$ are constrained to be $f_z=-0.004 (\pm 0.023)$ and $t_z=0.349 (\pm 0.059)$. These values permit one to estimate directly how the normalizations of a given quantity $Q_Δ$ changes as a function of the mass (or temperature) and redshift halo in the form $Q_Δ \sim M^{a_M} E_z^{a_z} \sim T^{a_T} E_z^{a_{Tz}}$, in very good agreement with the current observational constraints.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2022; v1 submitted 6 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
CHEX-MATE: pressure profiles of 6 galaxy clusters as seen by SPT and Planck
Authors:
Filippo Oppizzi,
Federico De Luca,
Hervé Bourdin,
Pasquale Mazzotta,
Stefano Ettori,
Fabio Gastaldello,
Scott Kay,
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Ben J. Maughan,
Etienne Pointecouteau,
Gabriel W. Pratt,
Mariachiara Rossetti,
Jack Sayers,
Mauro Sereno
Abstract:
Pressure profiles are sensitive probes of the thermodynamic conditions and the internal structure of galaxy clusters. The intra-cluster gas resides in hydrostatic equilibrium within the Dark Matter gravitational potential. However, this equilibrium may be perturbed, e.g. as a consequence of thermal energy losses, feedback and non-thermal pressure supports. Accurate measures of the gas pressure ove…
▽ More
Pressure profiles are sensitive probes of the thermodynamic conditions and the internal structure of galaxy clusters. The intra-cluster gas resides in hydrostatic equilibrium within the Dark Matter gravitational potential. However, this equilibrium may be perturbed, e.g. as a consequence of thermal energy losses, feedback and non-thermal pressure supports. Accurate measures of the gas pressure over the cosmic times are crucial to constrain the cluster evolution as well as the contribution of astrophysical processes. In this work we presented a novel algorithm to derive the pressure profiles of galaxy clusters from the Sunyaev-Zeldovich (SZ) signal measured on a combination of Planck and South Pole Telescope (SPT) observations. The synergy of the two instruments made it possible to track the profiles on a wide range of spatial scales. We exploited the sensitivity to the larger scales of the Planck High-Frequency Instrument to observe the faint peripheries, and the higher spatial resolution of SPT to solve the innermost regions. We developed a two-step pipeline to take advantage of the specifications of each instrument. We first performed a component separation on the two data-sets separately to remove the background (CMB) and foreground (galactic emission) contaminants. Then we jointly fitted a parametric pressure profile model on a combination of Planck and SPT data. We validated our technique on a sample of 6 CHEX-MATE clusters detected by SPT. We compare the results of the SZ analysis with profiles derived from X-ray observations with XMM-Newton. We find an excellent agreement between these two independent probes of the gas pressure structure.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
CHEX-MATE: Morphological analysis of the sample
Authors:
Maria Giulia Campitiello,
Stefano Ettori,
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Iacopo Bartalucci,
Dominique Eckert,
Elena Rasia,
Mariachiara Rossetti,
Fabio Gastaldello,
Gabriel W. Pratt,
Ben Maughan,
Etienne Pointecouteau,
Mauro Sereno,
Veronica Biffi,
Stefano Borgani,
Federico De Luca,
Marco De Petris,
Massimo Gaspari,
Simona Ghizzardi,
Pasquale Mazzotta,
Silvano Molendi
Abstract:
In this work, we performed an analysis of the X-ray morphology of the 118 CHEX-MATE (Cluster HEritage project with XMM-Newton - Mass Assembly and Thermodynamics at the Endpoint of structure formation) galaxy clusters, with the aim to provide a classification of their dynamical state. To investigate the link between the X-ray appearance and the dynamical state, we considered four morphological para…
▽ More
In this work, we performed an analysis of the X-ray morphology of the 118 CHEX-MATE (Cluster HEritage project with XMM-Newton - Mass Assembly and Thermodynamics at the Endpoint of structure formation) galaxy clusters, with the aim to provide a classification of their dynamical state. To investigate the link between the X-ray appearance and the dynamical state, we considered four morphological parameters: the surface brightness concentration, the centroid shift, and the second- and third-order power ratios. These indicators result to be: strongly correlated with each other, powerful in identifying the disturbed and relaxed population, characterised by a unimodal distribution and not strongly influenced by systematic uncertainties. In order to obtain a continuous classification of the CHEX-MATE objects, we combined these four parameters in a single quantity, M, which represents the grade of relaxation of a system. On the basis of the M value, we identified the most extreme systems of the sample, finding 15 very relaxed and 27 very disturbed galaxy clusters. From a comparison with previous analysis on X-ray selected samples, we confirmed that the Sunyaev-Zeldovich (SZ) clusters tend to be more disturbed. Finally, by applying our analysis on a simulated sample, we found a general agreement between the observed and simulated results, with the only exception of the concentration. This latter behaviour, is partially related to the presence of particles with high smoothed-particle hydrodynamics density in the central regions of the simulated clusters due to the action of the idealised isotropic thermal Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) feedback.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2022; v1 submitted 23 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Scaling relations of clusters and groups, and their evolution
Authors:
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Ben J. Maughan
Abstract:
X-ray observations of the hot intra-cluster medium (ICM) in galaxy groups and clusters provide quantities such as their gas mass, X-ray luminosity, and temperature. The analysis of the scaling relations between these observable properties gives considerable insight into the physical processes taking place in the ICM. Furthermore, an understanding of the scaling relations between ICM properties and…
▽ More
X-ray observations of the hot intra-cluster medium (ICM) in galaxy groups and clusters provide quantities such as their gas mass, X-ray luminosity, and temperature. The analysis of the scaling relations between these observable properties gives considerable insight into the physical processes taking place in the ICM. Furthermore, an understanding of the scaling relations between ICM properties and the total cluster mass is essential for cosmological studies with clusters. For these reasons, the X-ray scaling relations of groups and clusters have been a major focus of research over the past several decades. In this Chapter, after presenting the expectations from the self-similar model, based on the assumption that only gravity drives the evolution of the ICM, we discuss how the processes of gas cooling and non-gravitational heating are believed to be responsible for the observed deviations from the self-similar scenario. We also describe important complications that must be considered when measuring and interpreting the scaling relations.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Detection of a Superluminous Spiral Galaxy in the Heart of a Massive Galaxy Cluster
Authors:
Akos Bogdan,
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Patrick Ogle,
Orsolya E. Kovacs,
Thomas Jarrett,
Christine Jones,
William R. Forman,
Lauranne Lanz
Abstract:
It is well established that brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs), residing in the center of galaxy clusters, are typically massive and quenched galaxies with cD or elliptical morphology. An optical survey suggested that an exotic galaxy population, superluminous spiral and lenticular galaxies could be the BCGs of some galaxy clusters. Because the cluster membership and the centroid of a cluster canno…
▽ More
It is well established that brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs), residing in the center of galaxy clusters, are typically massive and quenched galaxies with cD or elliptical morphology. An optical survey suggested that an exotic galaxy population, superluminous spiral and lenticular galaxies could be the BCGs of some galaxy clusters. Because the cluster membership and the centroid of a cluster cannot be accurately determined based solely on optical data, we followed up a sample of superluminous disk galaxies and their environment using XMM-Newton X-ray observations. Specifically, we explored seven superluminous spiral and lenticular galaxies that are candidate BCGs. We detected massive galaxy clusters around five superluminous disk galaxies and established that one superluminous spiral, 2MASX J16273931+3002239, is the central BCG of a galaxy cluster. The temperature and total mass of the cluster are $kT_{\rm 500}=3.55^{+0.18}_{-0.20}$ keV and $M_{\rm 500} = (2.39 \pm 0.19) \times 10^{14} \ \rm{M_{\odot}} $. We identified the central galaxies of the four clusters that do not host the superluminous disk galaxy at their cores and established that the centrals are massive elliptical galaxies. However, for two of the clusters, the offset superluminous spirals are brighter than the central galaxies, implying that the superluminous disk galaxies are the brightest cluster galaxies. Our results demonstrate that superluminous disk galaxies are rarely the central systems of galaxy clusters. This is likely because galactic disks are destroyed by major mergers, which are more frequent in high-density environments. We speculate that the disks of superluminous disk galaxies in cluster cores may have been re-formed due to mergers with a gas-rich satellite.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2022; v1 submitted 28 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
The galaxy group NGC 507: newly detected AGN remnant plasma transported by sloshing
Authors:
M. Brienza,
L. Lovisari,
K. Rajpurohit,
A. Bonafede,
F. Gastaldello,
M. Murgia,
F. Vazza,
E. Bonnassieux,
A. Botteon,
G. Brunetti,
A. Drabent,
M. J. Hardcastle,
T. Pasini,
C. J. Riseley,
H. J. A. Röttgering,
T. Shimwell,
A. Simionescu,
R. J. van Weeren
Abstract:
Jets from active galactic nuclei (AGN) are known to recurrently enrich their surrounding medium with mildly-relativistic particles and magnetic fields. Here, we present a detailed multi-frequency analysis of the nearby (z=0.01646) galaxy group NGC 507. In particular, we present new high-sensitivity and high spatial resolution radio images in the frequency range 144-675 MHz obtained using LOFAR and…
▽ More
Jets from active galactic nuclei (AGN) are known to recurrently enrich their surrounding medium with mildly-relativistic particles and magnetic fields. Here, we present a detailed multi-frequency analysis of the nearby (z=0.01646) galaxy group NGC 507. In particular, we present new high-sensitivity and high spatial resolution radio images in the frequency range 144-675 MHz obtained using LOFAR and uGMRT observations. These reveal the presence of previously undetected diffuse radio emission with complex, filamentary morphology, likely related to a previous outburst of the central galaxy. Based on spectral ageing considerations, we derived that the plasma was first injected by the AGN 240-380 Myr ago and is now cooling. Our analysis of deep archival XMM-Newton data confirms that the system is dynamically disturbed, as previously suggested. We detect two discontinuities in the X-ray surface brightness distribution (in East and South direction) tracing a spiral pattern, which we interpret as cold fronts produced by sloshing motions. The remarkable spatial coincidence observed between the newly-detected arc-like radio filament and the southern concave X-ray discontinuity strongly suggests that the remnant plasma has been displaced by the sloshing motions on large scales. Overall, NGC 507 represents one of the clearest examples known to date in which a direct interaction between old AGN remnant plasma and the external medium is observed in a galaxy group. Our results are consistent with simulations, which suggest that filamentary emission can be created by the cluster/group weather disrupting AGN lobes and spreading their relativistic content into the surrounding medium.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2022; v1 submitted 12 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
The unusually weak and exceptionally steep radio relic in Abell 2108
Authors:
Gerrit Schellenberger,
Simona Giacintucci,
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Ewan O'Sullivan,
Jan Vrtilek,
Laurence P. David,
Jean-Baptiste Melin,
Dharam Vir Lal,
Stefano Ettori,
Konstantinos Kolokythas,
Mauro Sereno,
Somak Raychaudhury
Abstract:
Mergers between galaxy clusters often drive shocks into the intra cluster medium (ICM), the effects of which are sometimes visible via temperature and density jumps in the X-ray, and via radio emission from relativistic particles energized by the shock's passage. Abell2108 was selected as a likely merger system through comparing the X-ray luminosity to the Planck Sunyaev-Zeldovich signal, where th…
▽ More
Mergers between galaxy clusters often drive shocks into the intra cluster medium (ICM), the effects of which are sometimes visible via temperature and density jumps in the X-ray, and via radio emission from relativistic particles energized by the shock's passage. Abell2108 was selected as a likely merger system through comparing the X-ray luminosity to the Planck Sunyaev-Zeldovich signal, where this cluster appeared highly X-ray underluminous. Follow up observations confirmed it to be a merging low mass cluster featuring two distinct subclusters, both with a highly disturbed X-ray morphology. Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (GMRT) data covering 120-750MHz show an extended radio feature resembling a radio relic, near the location of a temperature discontinuity in the X-rays. We measure a Mach number from the X-ray temperature jump. Several characteristics of radio relics are found in Abell2108, making this cluster one of the few low mass mergers likely hosting a radio relic. The radio spectrum is exceptionally steep, and the radio power is very weak (P1.4GHz=1E22W/Hz). To account for the shock/relic offset, we propose a scenario in which the shock created the relic by re-accelerating a cloud of pre-existing relativistic electrons and then moved away, leaving behind a fading relic. The electron aging timescale derived from the high-frequency steepening in the relic spectrum is consistent with the shock travel time to the observed X-ray discontinuity. However, the lower flux in GMRT band 4 data causing the steepening could be due to instrumental limitations, and deeper radio data are needed to constrain the spectral slope of the relic at high frequencies.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
On the dynamical and morphological state of the CHEX-MATE clusters
Authors:
Maria Giulia Campitiello,
Stefano Ettori,
Lorenzo Lovisari,
the CHEX-MATE collaboration
Abstract:
The CHEX-MATE sample was built to provide an overview of the statistical properties of the underlying cluster population and to set the stage for future X-ray missions. In this work, we perform a morphological analysis of the 118 clusters included in the sample with the aim to provide a classification of their dynamical state which will be useful for future studies of the collaboration.
The CHEX-MATE sample was built to provide an overview of the statistical properties of the underlying cluster population and to set the stage for future X-ray missions. In this work, we perform a morphological analysis of the 118 clusters included in the sample with the aim to provide a classification of their dynamical state which will be useful for future studies of the collaboration.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2021; v1 submitted 2 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
The thermalisation of massive galaxy clusters
Authors:
Mauro Sereno,
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Weiguang Cui,
Gerrit Schellenberger
Abstract:
In the hierarchical scenario of structure formation, galaxy clusters are the ultimate virialised products in mass and time. Hot baryons in the intracluster medium (ICM) and cold baryons in galaxies inhabit a dark matter dominated halo. Internal processes, accretion, and mergers can perturb the equilibrium, which is established only at later times. However, the cosmic time when thermalisation is ef…
▽ More
In the hierarchical scenario of structure formation, galaxy clusters are the ultimate virialised products in mass and time. Hot baryons in the intracluster medium (ICM) and cold baryons in galaxies inhabit a dark matter dominated halo. Internal processes, accretion, and mergers can perturb the equilibrium, which is established only at later times. However, the cosmic time when thermalisation is effective is still to be assessed. Here we show that massive clusters in the observed universe attained an advanced thermal equilibrium $\sim~1.8~\text{Gyr}$ ago, at redshift $z =0.14\pm0.06$, when the universe was $11.7\pm0.7~\text{Gyr}$ old. Hot gas is mostly thermalised after the time when cosmic densities of matter and dark energy match. We find in a statistically nearly complete and homogeneous sample of 120 clusters from the {\it Planck} Early Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (ESZ) sample that the kinetic energy traced by the galaxy velocity dispersion is a faithful probe of the gravitational energy since a look back time of at least $\sim5.4~\text{Gyr}$, whereas the efficiency of hot gas in converting kinetic to thermal energy, as measured through X-ray observations in the core-excised area within $r_{500}$, steadily increases with time. The evolution is detected at the $\sim 98$ per cent probability level. Our results demonstrate that halo mass accretion history plays a larger role for cluster thermal equilibrium than radiative physics. The evolution of hot gas is strictly connected to the cosmic structure formation.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Scaling Properties of Galaxy Groups
Authors:
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Stefano Ettori,
Massimo Gaspari,
Paul A. Giles
Abstract:
Galaxy groups and poor clusters are more common than rich clusters, and host the largest fraction of matter content in the Universe. Hence, their studies are key to understand the gravitational and thermal evolution of the bulk of the cosmic matter. Moreover, because of their shallower gravitational potential, galaxy groups are systems where non-gravitational processes (e.g., cooling, AGN feedback…
▽ More
Galaxy groups and poor clusters are more common than rich clusters, and host the largest fraction of matter content in the Universe. Hence, their studies are key to understand the gravitational and thermal evolution of the bulk of the cosmic matter. Moreover, because of their shallower gravitational potential, galaxy groups are systems where non-gravitational processes (e.g., cooling, AGN feedback, star formation) are expected to have a higher impact on the distribution of baryons, and on the general physical properties, than in more massive objects, inducing systematic departures from the expected scaling relations. Despite their paramount importance from the astrophysical and cosmological point of view, the challenges in their detection have limited the studies of galaxy groups. Upcoming large surveys will change this picture, reassigning to galaxy groups their central role in studying the structure formation and evolution in the Universe, and in measuring the cosmic baryonic content. Here, we review the recent literature on various scaling relations between X-ray and optical properties of these systems, focusing on the observational measurements, and the progress in our understanding of the deviations from the self-similar expectations on groups' scales. We discuss some of the sources of these deviations, and how feedback from supernovae and/or AGNs impacts the general properties and the reconstructed scaling laws. Finally, we discuss future prospects in the study of galaxy groups.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Cosmological implications of the anisotropy of ten galaxy cluster scaling relations
Authors:
K. Migkas,
F. Pacaud,
G. Schellenberger,
J. Erler,
N. T. Nguyen-Dang,
T. H. Reiprich,
M. E. Ramos-Ceja,
L. Lovisari
Abstract:
The hypothesis that the late Universe is isotropic and homogeneous is adopted by most cosmological studies. The expansion rate $H_0$ is thought to be spatially constant, while bulk flows are often presumed to be negligible compared to the Hubble expansion, even at local scales. Their effects on the redshift-distance conversion are hence usually ignored. Any deviation from this consensus can strong…
▽ More
The hypothesis that the late Universe is isotropic and homogeneous is adopted by most cosmological studies. The expansion rate $H_0$ is thought to be spatially constant, while bulk flows are often presumed to be negligible compared to the Hubble expansion, even at local scales. Their effects on the redshift-distance conversion are hence usually ignored. Any deviation from this consensus can strongly bias the results of such studies and thus the importance of testing these assumptions cannot be understated. Scaling relations of galaxy clusters can be effectively used for that. In previous works, we observed strong anisotropies in cluster scaling relations, whose origins remain ambiguous. By measuring many different cluster properties, several scaling relations with different sensitivities can be built. Nearly independent tests of cosmic isotropy and bulk flows are then feasible. We make use of up to 570 clusters with measured properties at X-ray, microwave, and infrared wavelengths, to construct 10 different cluster scaling relations (five of them presented for the first time) and test the isotropy of the local Universe. Through rigorous tests, we ensure that our analysis is not prone to generally known systematic biases and X-ray absorption issues. By combining all available information, we detect an apparent $9\%$ spatial variation in the local $H_0$ between $(l,b)\sim ({280^{\circ}}^{+35^{\circ}}_{-35^{\circ}},{-15^{\circ}}^{+20^{\circ}}_{-20^{\circ}})$ and the rest of the sky. The observed anisotropy has a nearly dipole form. Using Monte Carlo simulations, we assess the statistical significance of the anisotropy to be $>5σ$. This result could also be attributed to a $\sim 900$ km/s bulk flow which seems to extend out to at least $\sim 500$ Mpc. These two effects are indistinguishable until more high$-z$ clusters are observed by future all-sky surveys, such as eROSITA.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Chandra Observations of the Planck ESZ Sample: A Re-Examination of Masses and Mass Proxies
Authors:
Felipe Andrade-Santos,
Gabriel W. Pratt,
Jean-Baptiste Melin,
Monique Arnaud,
Christine Jones,
William R. Forman,
Etienne Pointecouteau,
Iacopo Bartalucci,
Alexey Vikhlinin,
Stephen S. Murray,
Pasquale Mazzotta,
Stefano Borgani,
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Reinout J. van Weeren,
Ralph P. Kraft,
Laurence P. David,
Simona Giacintucci
Abstract:
Using Chandra observations, we derive the $Y_{\rm X}$ proxy and associated total mass measurement, $M_{500}^{\rm Y_X}$, for 147 clusters with $z \leq 0.35$ from the Planck Early Sunyaev-Zel'dovich catalog, and for 80 clusters with $z \leq 0.30$ from an X-ray flux-limited sample. We re-extract the Planck $Y_{\rm SZ}$ measurements and obtain the corresponding mass proxy, $M_{500}^{\rm SZ}$, from the…
▽ More
Using Chandra observations, we derive the $Y_{\rm X}$ proxy and associated total mass measurement, $M_{500}^{\rm Y_X}$, for 147 clusters with $z \leq 0.35$ from the Planck Early Sunyaev-Zel'dovich catalog, and for 80 clusters with $z \leq 0.30$ from an X-ray flux-limited sample. We re-extract the Planck $Y_{\rm SZ}$ measurements and obtain the corresponding mass proxy, $M_{500}^{\rm SZ}$, from the full Planck mission maps, minimizing the Malmquist bias due to observational scatter. The masses re-extracted using the more precise X-ray position and characteristic size agree with the published PSZ2 values, but yield a significant reduction in the scatter (by a factor of two) in the $M_{500}^{\rm SZ}$-$M_{500}^{\rm X}$ relation. The slope is $0.93\pm0.03$, and the median ratio, $M_{500}^{\rm SZ}/M_{500}^{\rm X}= 0.91\pm0.01$, is within the expectations from known X-ray calibration systematics. The $Y_{\rm SZ}/Y_{\rm X}$ ratio is $0.88\pm0.02$, in good agreement with predictions from cluster structure, and implying a low level of clumpiness. In agreement with the findings of the Planck Collaboration, the slope of the $Y_{\rm SZ}$-$D_{\rm A}^{-2} Y_{X}$ flux relation is significantly less than unity ($0.89\pm0.01$). Using extensive simulations, we show that this result is not due to selection effects, intrinsic scatter, or covariance between quantities. We demonstrate analytically that changing the $Y_{\rm SZ}$-$Y_{X}$ relation from apparent flux to intrinsic properties results in a best-fit slope that is closer to unity and increases the dispersion about the relation. The redistribution resulting from this transformation implies that the best fit parameters of the $M_{500}^{\rm SZ}$-$M_{500}^{\rm X}$ relation will be sample-dependent.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2021; v1 submitted 12 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
The intra-cluster magnetic field in the double relic galaxy cluster Abell 2345
Authors:
C. Stuardi,
A. Bonafede,
L. Lovisari,
P. Domínguez-Fernández,
F. Vazza,
M. Brüggen,
R. J. van Weeren,
F. de Gasperin
Abstract:
Magnetic fields are ubiquitous in galaxy clusters, yet their radial profile, power spectrum, and connection to host cluster properties are poorly known. Merging galaxy clusters hosting diffuse polarized emission in the form of radio relics offer a unique possibility to study the magnetic fields in these complex systems. In this paper, we investigate the intra-cluster magnetic field in Abell 2345.…
▽ More
Magnetic fields are ubiquitous in galaxy clusters, yet their radial profile, power spectrum, and connection to host cluster properties are poorly known. Merging galaxy clusters hosting diffuse polarized emission in the form of radio relics offer a unique possibility to study the magnetic fields in these complex systems. In this paper, we investigate the intra-cluster magnetic field in Abell 2345. This cluster hosts two radio relics that we detected in polarization with 1-2 GHz JVLA observations. X-ray XMM-Newton images show a very disturbed morphology. We derived the Rotation Measure (RM) of five polarized sources within $\sim$ 1 Mpc from the cluster center applying the RM synthesis. Both, the average RM and the RM dispersion radial profiles probe the presence of intra-cluster magnetic fields. Using the thermal electron density profile derived from X-ray analysis and simulating a 3D magnetic field with fluctuations following a power spectrum derived from magneto-hydrodynamical cosmological simulations, we build mock RM images of the cluster. We constrained the magnetic field profile in the eastern radio relic sector by comparing simulated and observed RM images. We find that, within the framework of our model, the data require a magnetic field scaling with thermal electron density as $B(r)\propto n_e(r)$. The best model has a central magnetic field (within a 200 kpc radius) of $2.8\pm0.1$ $μ$G. The average magnetic field at the position of the eastern relic is $\sim$0.3 $μ$G, a factor 2.7 lower than the equipartition estimate.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
The Cluster HEritage project with XMM-Newton: Mass Assembly and Thermodynamics at the Endpoint of structure formation. I. Programme overview
Authors:
The CHEX-MATE Collaboration,
:,
M. Arnaud,
S. Ettori,
G. W. Pratt,
M. Rossetti,
D. Eckert,
F. Gastaldello,
R. Gavazzi,
S. T. Kay,
L. Lovisari,
B. J. Maughan,
E. Pointecouteau,
M. Sereno,
I. Bartalucci,
A. Bonafede,
H. Bourdin,
R. Cassano,
R. T. Duffy,
A. Iqbal,
S. Maurogordato,
E. Rasia,
J. Sayers,
F. Andrade-Santos,
H. Aussel
, et al. (45 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Cluster HEritage project with XMM-Newton - Mass Assembly and Thermodynamics at the Endpoint of structure formation (CHEX-MATE) is a three mega-second Multi-Year Heritage Programme to obtain X-ray observations of a minimally-biased, signal-to-noise limited sample of 118 galaxy clusters detected by Planck through the Sunyaev-Zeldovich effect. The programme, described in detail in this paper, aim…
▽ More
The Cluster HEritage project with XMM-Newton - Mass Assembly and Thermodynamics at the Endpoint of structure formation (CHEX-MATE) is a three mega-second Multi-Year Heritage Programme to obtain X-ray observations of a minimally-biased, signal-to-noise limited sample of 118 galaxy clusters detected by Planck through the Sunyaev-Zeldovich effect. The programme, described in detail in this paper, aims to study the ultimate products of structure formation in time and mass. It is composed of a census of the most recent objects to have formed (Tier-1: 0.05 < z < 0.2; 2 x 10e14 M_sun < M_500 < 9 x 10e14 M_sun), together with a sample of the highest-mass objects in the Universe (Tier-2: z < 0.6; M_500 > 7.25 x 10e14 M_sun). The programme will yield an accurate vision of the statistical properties of the underlying population, measure how the gas properties are shaped by collapse into the dark matter halo, uncover the provenance of non-gravitational heating, and resolve the major uncertainties in mass determination that limit the use of clusters for cosmological parameter estimation. We will acquire X-ray exposures of uniform depth, designed to obtain individual mass measurements accurate to 15-20% under the hydrostatic assumption. We present the project motivations, describe the programme definition, and detail the ongoing multi-wavelength observational (lensing, SZ, radio) and theoretical effort that is being deployed in support of the project.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2021; v1 submitted 22 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Abell 1430: A merging cluster with exceptional diffuse radio emission
Authors:
M. Hoeft,
C. Dumba,
A. Drabent,
K. Rajpurohit,
M. Rossetti,
S. E. Nuza,
R. J. van Weeren,
H. Meusinger,
A. Botteon,
G. Brunetti,
T. W. Shimwell,
R. Cassano,
M. Brüggen,
H. J. A. Röttgering,
F. Gastaldello,
L. Lovisari,
G. Yepes,
F. Andrade-Santos,
D. Eckert
Abstract:
Diffuse radio emission has been found in many galaxy clusters, predominantly in massive systems which are in the state of merging. The radio emission can usually be classified as relic or halo emission, which are believed to be related to merger shocks or volume-filling turbulence, respectively. Recent observations have revealed radio bridges for some pairs of very closeby galaxy clusters. The mec…
▽ More
Diffuse radio emission has been found in many galaxy clusters, predominantly in massive systems which are in the state of merging. The radio emission can usually be classified as relic or halo emission, which are believed to be related to merger shocks or volume-filling turbulence, respectively. Recent observations have revealed radio bridges for some pairs of very closeby galaxy clusters. The mechanisms that may allow to explain the high specific density of relativistic electrons, necessary to explain the radio luminosity of these bridge regions, are poorly explored. We analyse the galaxy cluster Abell 1430 with LoTSS data in detail and complement it with recent JVLA L-band observations, XMM-Newton, Chandra, and SDSS data. Moreover, we compare our results to clusters extracted from the "The Three Hundred Project" cosmological simulation. We find that Abell 1430 consists of two components, namely A1430-A and A1430-B. We speculate that the two components undergo an off-axis merger. The more massive component shows diffuse radio emission which can be classified as radio halo showing a low radio power given the mass of the cluster. Most interestingly, there is extended diffuse radio emission, dubbed as the `Pillow', which is apparently related to A1430-B and thus related to low density intracluster or intergalactic medium. To date, a only few examples for emission originating from such regions are known. These discoveries are crucial to constrain possible acceleration mechanisms, which may allow to explain the presence of relativistic electrons in these regions. Our results indicate a spectral index of $α_{144\,\text{MHz}}^{1.5\,\text{GHz}}=-1.4\pm0.5$ for the Pillow. If future observations confirm a slope as flat as the central value of -1.4 or even flatter, this would pose a severe challenge for the electron acceleration scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2021; v1 submitted 20 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
From "universal" profiles to "universal" scaling laws in X-ray galaxy clusters
Authors:
S. Ettori,
L. Lovisari,
M. Sereno
Abstract:
As the end products of the hierarchical process of cosmic structure formation, galaxy clusters present some predictable properties, like those mostly driven by gravity, and some others, more affected by astrophysical dissipative processes, that can be recovered from observations and that show remarkable "universal" behaviour once rescaled by halo mass and redshift. However, a consistent picture th…
▽ More
As the end products of the hierarchical process of cosmic structure formation, galaxy clusters present some predictable properties, like those mostly driven by gravity, and some others, more affected by astrophysical dissipative processes, that can be recovered from observations and that show remarkable "universal" behaviour once rescaled by halo mass and redshift. However, a consistent picture that links these universal radial profiles and the integrated values of the thermodynamical quantities of the intracluster medium, also quantifying the deviations from the standard self-similar gravity-driven scenario, has to be demonstrated. In this work, we use a semi-analytic model based on a universal pressure profile in hydrostatic equilibrium within a cold dark matter halo with a defined relation between mass and concentration to reconstruct the scaling laws between the X-ray properties of galaxy clusters. We also quantify any deviation from the self-similar predictions in terms of temperature dependence of a few physical quantities such as the gas mass fraction, the relation between spectroscopic temperature and its global value, and, if present, the hydrostatic mass bias. This model allows to reconstruct both the observed profiles and the scaling laws between integrated quantities. We use the Planck-selected ESZ sample to calibrate the predicted scaling laws between gas mass, temperature, luminosity and total mass. Our universal model reproduces well the observed thermodynamic properties and provides a way to interpret the observed deviations from the standard self-similar behaviour. By combining these results with the constraints on the observed $Y_{SZ}-T$ relation, we show how we can quantify the level of gas clum** affecting the studied sample, estimate the clum**-free gas mass fraction, and suggest the average level of hydrostatic bias present.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2020; v1 submitted 8 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Comparing different mass estimators for a large subsample of the {\it Planck}-ESZ clusters
Authors:
L. Lovisari,
S. Ettori,
M. Sereno,
G. Schellenberger,
W. R. Forman,
F. Andrade-Santos,
C. Jones
Abstract:
Total mass is arguably the most fundamental property for cosmological studies with galaxy clusters. We investigate the present differences in the mass estimates obtained through independent X-ray, weak-lensing, and dynamical studies. We quantify the differences as the mean ratio 1-$b$=M$_{\rm HE}$/M$_{\rm WL,dyn}$, where HE refers to hydrostatic masses obtained from X-ray observations, WL refers t…
▽ More
Total mass is arguably the most fundamental property for cosmological studies with galaxy clusters. We investigate the present differences in the mass estimates obtained through independent X-ray, weak-lensing, and dynamical studies. We quantify the differences as the mean ratio 1-$b$=M$_{\rm HE}$/M$_{\rm WL,dyn}$, where HE refers to hydrostatic masses obtained from X-ray observations, WL refers to the results of weak-lensing measurements, and dyn refers to the mass estimates either from velocity dispersion or from the caustic technique. Recent X-ray masses reported by independent groups show average differences smaller than $\sim$10$\%$, posing a strong limit on the systematics that can be ascribed to the differences in the X-ray analysis when studying the hydrostatic bias. The mean ratio between our X-ray masses and the weak-lensing masses in the LC$^2$-single catalog is 1-$b$=0.74$\pm$0.06. However, the mean mass ratios inferred from the WL masses of different projects vary by a large amount, with APEX-SZ showing a bias consistent with zero (1-$b$=1.02$\pm$0.12), LoCuSS and CCCP/MENeaCS showing a significant difference (1-$b$=0.76$\pm$0.09 and 1-$b$=0.77$\pm$0.10, respectively), and WtG pointing to the largest deviation (1-$b$=0.61$\pm$0.12). At odds with the WL results, the dynamical mass measurements show better agreement with the X-ray hydrostatic masses, although there are significant differences when relaxed or disturbed clusters are used. The different ratios obtained using different mass estimators suggest that there are still systematics that are not accounted for in all the techniques used to recover cluster masses. This prevents the determination of firm constraints on the level of hydrostatic mass bias in galaxy clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Probing cosmic isotropy with a new X-ray galaxy cluster sample through the $L_{\text{X}}-T$ scaling relation
Authors:
K. Migkas,
G. Schellenberger,
T. H. Reiprich,
F. Pacaud,
M. E. Ramos-Ceja,
L. Lovisari
Abstract:
The isotropy of the late Universe is an assumption greatly used in astronomy. However, many studies have recently reported deviations from isotropy with a definitive conclusion yet to be made. New, independent methods to robustly test the cosmic isotropy are of crucial importance. In this work, we investigate the directional behavior of the X-ray luminosity-temperature ($L_X-T$) relation of galaxy…
▽ More
The isotropy of the late Universe is an assumption greatly used in astronomy. However, many studies have recently reported deviations from isotropy with a definitive conclusion yet to be made. New, independent methods to robustly test the cosmic isotropy are of crucial importance. In this work, we investigate the directional behavior of the X-ray luminosity-temperature ($L_X-T$) relation of galaxy clusters. A tight correlation exists between the luminosity and temperature of the X-ray-emitting intracluster medium. While the measured luminosity depends on the underlying cosmology, the temperature can be determined without any cosmological assumptions. By exploiting this property one can effectively test the isotropy of cosmological parameters over the full extragalactic sky. Here, we used 313 homogeneously selected X-ray galaxy clusters from the MCXC catalog and obtained core-excised temperatures for all of them. We find that the behavior of the $L_X-T$ relation heavily depends on the direction of the sky. Strong anisotropies are detected at a $\sim 4σ$ level toward $(l,b)\sim (280^{\circ}, -20^{\circ})$. Several X-ray and cluster-related effects that could potentially explain these anisotropies were examined, but none did so. Interestingly, two other available cluster samples appear to have a similar behavior throughout the sky, while being fully independent of each other and our sample. Performing a joint analysis of the three samples, the final anisotropy is further intensified ($\sim 5σ$), toward $(l,b)\sim (303^{\circ}, -27^{\circ})$, which is in good agreement with other cosmological probes. This result demonstrates that X-ray galaxy cluster studies that assume perfect isotropy can produce strongly biased results whether the underlying reason is cosmological or related to X-rays. The identification of the exact nature of these anisotropies is therefore crucial.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
X-ray scaling relations for a representative sample of Planck selected clusters observed with XMM-Newton
Authors:
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Gerrit Schellenberger,
Mauro Sereno,
Stefano Ettori,
Gabriel W. Pratt,
William R. Forman,
Christine Jones,
Felipe Andrade-Santos,
Scott Randall,
Ralph Kraft
Abstract:
We report the scaling relations derived by fitting the X-ray parameters determined from analyzing the XMM-Newton observations of 120 galaxy clusters in the Planck Early Sunyaev-Zel'dovich sample spanning the redshift range of 0.059$<$$z$$<$0.546. We find that the slopes of all the investigated scaling relations significantly deviate from the self-similar predictions, if self-similar redshift evolu…
▽ More
We report the scaling relations derived by fitting the X-ray parameters determined from analyzing the XMM-Newton observations of 120 galaxy clusters in the Planck Early Sunyaev-Zel'dovich sample spanning the redshift range of 0.059$<$$z$$<$0.546. We find that the slopes of all the investigated scaling relations significantly deviate from the self-similar predictions, if self-similar redshift evolution is assumed. When the redshift evolution is left free to vary, the derived slopes are more in agreement with the self-similar predictions. Relaxed clusters have on average $\sim$30$\%$ higher X-ray luminosity than disturbed clusters at a given mass, a difference that, depending on the relative fraction of relaxed and disturbed clusters in the samples (e.g. SZ vs X-ray selected), have a strong impact in the normalization obtained in different studies. Using the core-excised cluster luminosities reduces the scatter and brings into better agreement the $L$-$M_{tot}$ and $L$-$T$ relations determined for different samples. $M_{tot}$-$T$, $M_{tot}$-$Y_X$, and $M_{tot}$-$M_{gas}$ relations show little dependence on the dynamical state of the clusters, but the normalizations of these relations may depend on the mass range investigated. Although most of the clusters investigated in this work reside at relatively low redshift, the fits prefer values of $γ$, the parameter accounting for the redshift evolution, different from the self-similar predictions. This suggests an evolution ($<$2$σ$ level, with the exception of the $M_{tot}$-$T$ relation) of the scaling relations. For the first time, we find significant evolution ($>$3$σ$) of the $M_{tot}$-$T$ relation, pointing to an increase of the kinetic-to-thermal energy ratio with redshift. This is consistent with a scenario in which higher redshift clusters are on average more disturbed than their lower redshift counterparts.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
The discovery of radio halos in the Frontier Fields clusters Abell S1063 and Abell 370
Authors:
C. Xie,
R. J. van Weeren,
L. Lovisari,
F. Andrade-Santos,
A. Botteon,
M. Brüggen,
E. Bulbul,
E. Churazov,
T. E. Clarke,
W. R. Forman,
H. T. Intema,
C. Jones,
R. P. Kraft,
D. V. Lal,
T. Mroczkowski,
A. Zitrin
Abstract:
Massive merging galaxy clusters often host diffuse Mpc-scale radio synchrotron emission. This emission originates from relativistic electrons in the ionized intracluster medium (ICM). An important question is how these synchrotron emitting relativistic electrons are accelerated. Our aim is to search for diffuse emission in the Frontier Fields clusters Abell S1063 and Abell 370 and characterize its…
▽ More
Massive merging galaxy clusters often host diffuse Mpc-scale radio synchrotron emission. This emission originates from relativistic electrons in the ionized intracluster medium (ICM). An important question is how these synchrotron emitting relativistic electrons are accelerated. Our aim is to search for diffuse emission in the Frontier Fields clusters Abell S1063 and Abell 370 and characterize its properties. While these clusters are very massive and well studied at some other wavelengths, no diffuse emission has been reported for these clusters so far. We obtained 325 MHz Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (GMRT) and 1--4 GHz Jansky Very Large Array (VLA) observations of Abell S1063 and Abell 370. We complement these data with Chandra and XMM-Newton X-ray observations. In our sensitive images, we discover radio halos in both clusters. In Abell S1063, a giant radio halo is found with a size of $\sim 1.2$ Mpc. The integrated spectral index between 325 MHz and 1.5 GHz is $-0.94\pm0.08$ and it steepens to $-1.77 \pm 0.20$ between 1.5 and 3.0 GHz. This spectral steepening provides support for the turbulent re-acceleration model for radio halo formation. Abell 370 hosts a faint radio halo mostly centred on the southern part of this binary merging cluster, with a size of $\sim 500-700$ kpc. The spectral index between 325 MHz and 1.5 GHz is $-1.10\pm0.09$. Both radio halos follow the known scaling relation between the cluster mass proxy $Y_{500}$ and radio power, consistent with the idea that they are related to ongoing cluster merger events.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
RELICS: A Very Large ($θ_{E}\sim40"$) Cluster Lens -- RXC J0032.1+1808
Authors:
Ana Acebron,
Adi Zitrin,
Dan Coe,
Guillaume Mahler,
Keren Sharon,
Masamune Oguri,
Maruša Bradač,
Larry Bradley,
Brenda Frye,
Christine J. Forman,
Victoria Strait,
Yuanyuan Su,
Keiichi Umetsu,
Felipe Andrade-Santos,
Roberto J. Avila,
Daniela Carrasco,
Catherine Cerny,
Nicole G. Czakon,
William A. Dawson,
Carter Fox,
Austin T. Hoag,
Kuang-Han Huang,
Traci L. Johnson,
Shotaro Kikuchihara,
Daniel Lam
, et al. (16 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Extensive surveys with the \textit{Hubble Space Telescope} (HST) over the past decade, targeting some of the most massive clusters in the sky, have uncovered dozens of galaxy-cluster strong lenses. The massive cluster strong-lens scale is typically $θ_{E}\sim10\arcsec$ to $\sim30-35\arcsec$, with only a handful of clusters known with Einstein radii $θ_{E}\sim40\arcsec$ or above (for…
▽ More
Extensive surveys with the \textit{Hubble Space Telescope} (HST) over the past decade, targeting some of the most massive clusters in the sky, have uncovered dozens of galaxy-cluster strong lenses. The massive cluster strong-lens scale is typically $θ_{E}\sim10\arcsec$ to $\sim30-35\arcsec$, with only a handful of clusters known with Einstein radii $θ_{E}\sim40\arcsec$ or above (for $z_{source}=2$, nominally). Here we report another very large cluster lens, RXC J0032.1+1808 ($z=0.3956$), the second richest cluster in the redMapper cluster catalog and the 85th most massive cluster in the Planck Sunyaev-Zel'dovich catalog. With our Light-Traces-Mass and fully parametric (dPIEeNFW) approaches, we construct strong lensing models based on 18 multiple images of 5 background galaxies newly identified in the \textit{Hubble} data mainly from the \textit{Reionization Lensing Cluster Survey} (RELICS), in addition to a known sextuply imaged system in this cluster. Furthermore, we compare these models to Lenstool and GLAFIC models that were produced independently as part of the RELICS program. All models reveal a large effective Einstein radius of $θ_{E}\simeq40\arcsec$ ($z_{source}=2$), owing to the obvious concentration of substructures near the cluster center. Although RXC J0032.1+1808 has a very large critical area and high lensing strength, only three magnified high-redshift candidates are found within the field targeted by RELICS. Nevertheless, we expect many more high-redshift candidates will be seen in wider and deeper observations with \textit{Hubble} or \emph{JWST}. Finally, the comparison between several algorithms demonstrates that the total error budget is largely dominated by systematic uncertainties.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2020; v1 submitted 5 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Using X-Ray Morphological Parameters to Strengthen Galaxy Cluster Mass Estimates via Machine Learning
Authors:
Sheridan B. Green,
Michelle Ntampaka,
Daisuke Nagai,
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Klaus Dolag,
Dominique Eckert,
John A. ZuHone
Abstract:
We present a machine learning approach for estimating galaxy cluster masses, trained using both Chandra and eROSITA mock X-ray observations of 2,041 clusters from the Magneticum simulations. We train a random forest regressor, an ensemble learning method based on decision tree regression, to predict cluster masses using an input feature set. The feature set uses core-excised X-ray luminosity and a…
▽ More
We present a machine learning approach for estimating galaxy cluster masses, trained using both Chandra and eROSITA mock X-ray observations of 2,041 clusters from the Magneticum simulations. We train a random forest regressor, an ensemble learning method based on decision tree regression, to predict cluster masses using an input feature set. The feature set uses core-excised X-ray luminosity and a variety of morphological parameters, including surface brightness concentration, smoothness, asymmetry, power ratios, and ellipticity. The regressor is cross-validated and calibrated on a training sample of 1,615 clusters (80% of sample), and then results are reported as applied to a test sample of 426 clusters (20% of sample). This procedure is performed for two different mock observation series in an effort to bracket the potential enhancement in mass predictions that can be made possible by including dynamical state information. The first series is computed from idealized Chandra-like mock cluster observations, with high spatial resolution, long exposure time (1 Ms), and the absence of background. The second series is computed from realistic-condition eROSITA mocks with lower spatial resolution, short exposures (2 ks), instrument effects, and background photons modeled. We report a 20% reduction in the mass estimation scatter when either series is used in our random forest model compared to a standard regression model that only employs core-excised luminosity. The morphological parameters that hold the highest feature importance are smoothness, asymmetry, and surface brightness concentration. Hence, these parameters, which encode the dynamical state of the cluster, can be used to make more accurate predictions of cluster masses in upcoming surveys, offering a crucial step forward for cosmological analyses.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2019; v1 submitted 7 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
The Most Massive galaxy Clusters (M2C) across cosmic time: link between radial total mass distribution and dynamical state
Authors:
I. Bartalucci,
M. Arnaud,
G. W. Pratt,
J. Démoclès,
L. Lovisari
Abstract:
We study the dynamical state and the integrated total mass profiles of 75 massive (M500 > 5 e+14 M_sun) SZ-selected clusters at 0.08<z< 1.1. The sample is built from the Planck catalogue, with the addition of 4 SPT clusters at z>0.9. Using XMM imaging observations, we characterise the dynamical state with the centroid shift, the concentration, and their combination, M, which simultaneously probes…
▽ More
We study the dynamical state and the integrated total mass profiles of 75 massive (M500 > 5 e+14 M_sun) SZ-selected clusters at 0.08<z< 1.1. The sample is built from the Planck catalogue, with the addition of 4 SPT clusters at z>0.9. Using XMM imaging observations, we characterise the dynamical state with the centroid shift, the concentration, and their combination, M, which simultaneously probes the core and the large scale gas morphology. Using spatially-resolved spectroscopy and assuming hydrostatic equilibrium, we derive the total integrated mass profiles. The mass profile shape is quantified by the sparsity, the ratio of M500 to M2500, the masses at density contrast 500 and 2500, respectively. We study the correlations between the various parameters and their dependence on redshift. We confirm that SZ-selected samples, thought to reflect most closely the underlying cluster population, are dominated by disturbed and non-cool core objects at all z. There is no significant evolution or mass dependence of either the cool core fraction or the centroid shift parameter. The M parameter evolves slightly with z, having a correlation coefficient of rho= -0.2 $\pm$ 0.1 and a null hypothesis p-value of 0.01. In the high mass regime considered here, the sparsity evolves minimally with redshift, increasing by 10% between z<0.2 and z>0.55, an effect significant at less than 2 sigma. In contrast, the dependence of the sparsity on dynamical state is much stronger, increasing by a factor of $\sim$60% from the 1/3 most relaxed to the 1/3 most disturbed objects, an effect significant at more than 3 sigma. This is the first observational evidence that the shape of the integrated total mass profile in massive clusters is principally governed by the dynamical state, and is only mildly dependent on redshift. We discuss the consequences for the comparison between observations and theoretical predictions.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2019; v1 submitted 5 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Extended X-ray study of M49: the frontier of the Virgo Cluster
Authors:
Y. Su,
R. P. Kraft,
P. E. J. Nulsen,
C. Jones,
T. J. Maccarone,
F. Mernier,
L. Lovisari,
A. Sheardown,
S. W. Randall,
E. Roediger,
T. M. Fish,
W. R. Forman,
E. Churazov
Abstract:
The M49 group, resident outside the virial radius of the Virgo cluster, is falling onto the cluster from the south. We report results from deep {\sl XMM-Newton} mosaic observations of M49. Its hot gas temperature is 0.8\,keV at the group center and rises to 1.5\,keV beyond the brightest group galaxy (BGG). The group gas extends to radii of $\sim300$\,kpc to the north and south. The observations re…
▽ More
The M49 group, resident outside the virial radius of the Virgo cluster, is falling onto the cluster from the south. We report results from deep {\sl XMM-Newton} mosaic observations of M49. Its hot gas temperature is 0.8\,keV at the group center and rises to 1.5\,keV beyond the brightest group galaxy (BGG). The group gas extends to radii of $\sim300$\,kpc to the north and south. The observations reveal a cold front $\sim20$\,kpc north of the BGG center and an X-ray bright stripped tail 70\,kpc long and 10\,kpc wide to the southwest of the BGG. We argue that the atmosphere of the infalling group was slowed by its encounter with the Virgo cluster gas, causing the BGG to move forward subsonically relative to the group gas. We measure declining temperature and metallicity gradients along the stripped tail. The tail gas can be traced back to the cooler and enriched gas uplifted from the BGG center by buoyant bubbles, implying that AGN outbursts may have intensified the strip** process. We extrapolate to a virial radius of 740\,kpc and derive a virial mass of $4.6\times10^{13}\,M_\odot$ for the M49 group. Its group atmosphere appears truncated and deficient when compared with isolated galaxy groups of similar temperatures. If M49 is on its first infall to Virgo, the infall region of a cluster could have profound impacts on galaxies and groups that are being accreted onto galaxy clusters. Alternatively, M49 may have already passed through Virgo once.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2019; v1 submitted 26 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Projection effects in galaxy cluster samples: insights from X-ray redshifts
Authors:
M. E. Ramos-Ceja,
F. Pacaud,
T. H. Reiprich,
K. Migkas,
L. Lovisari,
G. Schellenberger
Abstract:
Up to now, the largest sample of galaxy clusters selected in X-rays comes from the ROSAT All-Sky Survey (RASS). Although there have been many interesting clusters discovered with the RASS data, the broad point spread function (PSF) of the ROSAT satellite limits the amount of spatial information of the detected objects. This leads to the discovery of new cluster features when a re-observation is pe…
▽ More
Up to now, the largest sample of galaxy clusters selected in X-rays comes from the ROSAT All-Sky Survey (RASS). Although there have been many interesting clusters discovered with the RASS data, the broad point spread function (PSF) of the ROSAT satellite limits the amount of spatial information of the detected objects. This leads to the discovery of new cluster features when a re-observation is performed with higher resolution X-ray satellites. Here we present the results from XMM-Newton observations of three clusters: RXCJ2306.6-1319, ZwCl1665 and RXCJ0034.6-0208, for which the observations reveal a double or triple system of extended components. These clusters belong to the extremely expanded HIghest X-ray FLUx Galaxy Cluster Sample (eeHIFLUGCS), which is a flux-limited cluster sample ($f_\textrm{X,500}\geq 5\times10^{-12}$ erg s$^{-1}$ cm$^{-2}$ in the $0.1-2.4$ keV energy band). For each structure in each cluster, we determine the redshift with the X-ray spectrum and find that the components are not part of the same cluster. This is confirmed by an optical spectroscopic analysis of the galaxy members. Therefore, the total number of clusters is actually 7 and not 3. We derive global cluster properties of each extended component. We compare the measured properties to lower-redshift group samples, and find a good agreement. Our flux measurements reveal that only one component of the ZwCl1665 cluster has a flux above the eeHIFLUGCS limit, while the other clusters will no longer be part of the sample. These examples demonstrate that cluster-cluster projections can bias X-ray cluster catalogues and that with high-resolution X-ray follow-up this bias can be corrected.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Expanding the Sample: The Relationship Between the Black Hole Mass of BCGs and the Total Mass of Galaxy Clusters
Authors:
Frederika Phipps,
Akos Bogdan,
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Orsolya E. Kovacs,
Marta Volonteri,
Yohan Dubois
Abstract:
Supermassive Black Holes (BHs) residing in brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs) are overly massive when considering the local relationships between the BH mass and stellar bulge mass or velocity dispersion. Due to the location of these BHs within the cluster, large-scale cluster processes may aid the growth of BHs in BCGs. In this work, we study a sample of 71 galaxy clusters to explore the relations…
▽ More
Supermassive Black Holes (BHs) residing in brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs) are overly massive when considering the local relationships between the BH mass and stellar bulge mass or velocity dispersion. Due to the location of these BHs within the cluster, large-scale cluster processes may aid the growth of BHs in BCGs. In this work, we study a sample of 71 galaxy clusters to explore the relationship between the BH mass, stellar bulge mass of the BCG, and the total gravitating mass of the host clusters. Due to difficulties in obtaining dynamically measured BH masses in distant galaxies, we use the Fundamental Plane relationship of BHs to infer their masses. We utilize X-ray observations taken by $Chandra$ to measure the temperature of the intra-cluster medium (ICM), which is a proxy for the total mass of the cluster. We analyze the $\rm M_{BH}-kT$ and $\rm M_{BH}-M_{Bulge}$ relationships and establish the best-fitting power laws:$\log_{10}(M_{\rm BH} /10^9 M_{\odot})=-0.35+2.08 \log_{10}(kT / 1 \rm keV)$ and $\log_{10}(\rm M_{BH}/10^9M_{\odot})= -1.09+ 1.92 \log_{10}(M_{\rm bulge}/10^{11}M_{\odot})$. Both relations are comparable with that established earlier for a sample of brightest group/cluster galaxies with dynamically measured BH masses. Although both the $\rm M_{BH}-kT$ and the $\rm M_{BH}-M_{Bulge}$ relationships exhibit large intrinsic scatter, based on Monte Carlo simulations we conclude that dominant fraction of the scatter originates from the Fundamental Plane relationship. We split the sample into cool core and non-cool core resembling clusters, but do not find statistically significant differences in the $\rm M_{BH}-kT$ relation. We speculate that the overly massive BHs in BCGs may be due to frequent mergers and cool gas inflows onto the cluster center.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
RELICS: Reionization Lensing Cluster Survey
Authors:
Dan Coe,
Brett Salmon,
Marusa Bradac,
Larry D. Bradley,
Keren Sharon,
Adi Zitrin,
Ana Acebron,
Catherine Cerny,
Nathalia Cibirka,
Victoria Strait,
Rachel Paterno-Mahler,
Guillaume Mahler,
Roberto J. Avila,
Sara Ogaz,
Kuang-Han Huang,
Debora Pelliccia,
Daniel P. Stark,
Ramesh Mainali,
Pascal A. Oesch,
Michele Trenti,
Daniela Carrasco,
William A. Dawson,
Steven A. Rodney,
Louis-Gregory Strolger,
Adam G. Riess
, et al. (32 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Large surveys of galaxy clusters with the Hubble and Spitzer Space Telescopes, including CLASH and the Frontier Fields, have demonstrated the power of strong gravitational lensing to efficiently deliver large samples of high-redshift galaxies. We extend this strategy through a wider, shallower survey named RELICS, the Reionization Lensing Cluster Survey. This survey, described here, was designed p…
▽ More
Large surveys of galaxy clusters with the Hubble and Spitzer Space Telescopes, including CLASH and the Frontier Fields, have demonstrated the power of strong gravitational lensing to efficiently deliver large samples of high-redshift galaxies. We extend this strategy through a wider, shallower survey named RELICS, the Reionization Lensing Cluster Survey. This survey, described here, was designed primarily to deliver the best and brightest high-redshift candidates from the first billion years after the Big Bang. RELICS observed 41 massive galaxy clusters with Hubble and Spitzer at 0.4-1.7um and 3.0-5.0um, respectively. We selected 21 clusters based on Planck PSZ2 mass estimates and the other 20 based on observed or inferred lensing strength. Our 188-orbit Hubble Treasury Program obtained the first high-resolution near-infrared images of these clusters to efficiently search for lensed high-redshift galaxies. We observed 46 WFC3/IR pointings (~200 arcmin^2) with two orbits divided among four filters (F105W, F125W, F140W, and F160W) and ACS imaging as needed to achieve single-orbit depth in each of three filters (F435W, F606W, and F814W). As previously reported by Salmon et al., we discovered 322 z ~ 6 - 10 candidates, including the brightest known at z ~ 6, and the most distant spatially-resolved lensed arc known at z ~ 10. Spitzer IRAC imaging (945 hours awarded, plus 100 archival) has crucially enabled us to distinguish z ~ 10 candidates from z ~ 2 interlopers. For each cluster, two HST observing epochs were staggered by about a month, enabling us to discover 11 supernovae, including 3 lensed supernovae, which we followed up with 20 orbits from our program. We delivered reduced HST images and catalogs of all clusters to the public via MAST and reduced Spitzer images via IRSA. We have also begun delivering lens models of all clusters, to be completed before the JWST GO call for proposals.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
The Non-Uniformity of Galaxy Cluster Metallicity Profiles
Authors:
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Thomas Reiprich
Abstract:
We study a sample of 207 nearby galaxy groups and clusters observed with XMM-Newton. Key aspects of this sample include the large size, the high data quality, and the large diversity of cluster dynamical states. We determine the overall metallicity within 0.3R$_{500}$ and the radial distribution of the metals. On average, we find a mild dependence of the core metallicity with the average temperatu…
▽ More
We study a sample of 207 nearby galaxy groups and clusters observed with XMM-Newton. Key aspects of this sample include the large size, the high data quality, and the large diversity of cluster dynamical states. We determine the overall metallicity within 0.3R$_{500}$ and the radial distribution of the metals. On average, we find a mild dependence of the core metallicity with the average temperature of the system in agreement with previous results. However, we identify the cause of this mild dependence to be due to relaxed systems only; disturbed systems do not show this trend, on average. The large scatter observed in this relation is strongly associated with the dynamical state of the systems: relaxed systems have on average a higher metallicity in the core than disturbed objects. The radial profiles of relaxed systems are centrally peaked and show a steep decrease with radius, flattening beyond 0.3-0.4R$_{500}$. The metallicity of disturbed systems is also higher in the center but at much lower values than what is observed for relaxed objects. This finding is consistent with the picture that cluster mergers mix the abundance distribution by inducing large scale motions. The scatter of the radial profiles is quite large, but while for relaxed systems it decreases almost monotonically as function of the radius, for disturbed systems it shows a significant boost at large radii. Systems with a central radio source have a flatter profile indicating that central AGNs are an efficient mechanism to uplift and redistribute the metals in the ICM.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Detection of a Star Forming Galaxy in the Center of a Low-Mass Galaxy Cluster
Authors:
Akos Bogdan,
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Orsolya E. Kovacs,
Felipe Andrade-Santos,
Christine Jones,
William R. Forman,
Ralph P. Kraft
Abstract:
Brightest Cluster Galaxies (BCGs) residing in the centers of galaxy clusters are typically quenched giant ellipticals. A recent study hinted that star-forming galaxies with large disks, so-called superluminous spirals and lenticulars, are the BCGs of a subset of galaxy clusters. Based on the existing optical data it was not possible to constrain whether the superluminous disk galaxies reside at th…
▽ More
Brightest Cluster Galaxies (BCGs) residing in the centers of galaxy clusters are typically quenched giant ellipticals. A recent study hinted that star-forming galaxies with large disks, so-called superluminous spirals and lenticulars, are the BCGs of a subset of galaxy clusters. Based on the existing optical data it was not possible to constrain whether the superluminous disk galaxies reside at the center of galaxy clusters. In this work, we utilize XMM-Newton X-ray observations of five galaxy clusters to map the morphology of the intracluster medium (ICM), characterize the galaxy clusters, determine the position of the cluster center, and measure the offset between the cluster center and the superluminous disk galaxies. We demonstrate that one superluminous lenticular galaxy, 2MASX J10405643-0103584, resides at the center of a low-mass ($M_{\rm 500} = 10^{14} \ \rm{M_{\odot}}$) galaxy cluster. This represents the first conclusive evidence that a superluminous disk galaxy is the central BCG of a galaxy cluster. We speculate that the progenitor of 2MASX J10405643-0103584 was an elliptical galaxy, whose extended disk was re-formed due to the merger of galaxies. We exclude the possibility that the other four superluminous disk galaxies reside at the center of galaxy clusters, as their projected distance from the cluster center is $150-1070$ kpc, which corresponds to $(0.27-1.18)R_{\rm 500}$. We conclude that these clusters host quiescent massive elliptical galaxies at their center.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
RELICS: Strong Lensing Analysis of MACS J0417.5-1154 and Predictions for Observing the Magnified High-Redshift Universe with JWST
Authors:
Guillaume Mahler,
Keren Sharon,
Carter Fox,
Dan Coe,
Mathilde Jauzac,
Victoria Strait,
Alastair Edge,
Ana Acebron,
Felipe Andrade-Santos,
Roberto J. Avila,
Maruša Bradač,
Larry D. Bradley,
Daniela Carrasco,
Catherine Cerny,
Nathália Cibirka,
Nicole G. Czakon,
William A. Dawson,
Brenda L. Frye,
Austin T. Hoag,
Kuang-Han Huang,
Traci L. Johnson,
Christine Jones,
Shotaro Kikuchihara,
15 Daniel Lam,
Rachael Livermore
, et al. (15 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Strong gravitational lensing by clusters of galaxies probes the mass distribution at the core of each cluster and magnifies the universe behind it. MACS J0417.5-1154 at z=0.443 is one of the most massive clusters known based on weak lensing, X-ray, and Sunyaev-Zel'dovich analyses. Here we compute a strong lens model of MACS J0417 based on Hubble Space Telescope imaging observations collected, in p…
▽ More
Strong gravitational lensing by clusters of galaxies probes the mass distribution at the core of each cluster and magnifies the universe behind it. MACS J0417.5-1154 at z=0.443 is one of the most massive clusters known based on weak lensing, X-ray, and Sunyaev-Zel'dovich analyses. Here we compute a strong lens model of MACS J0417 based on Hubble Space Telescope imaging observations collected, in part, by the Reionization Lensing Cluster Survey (RELICS), and recently reported spectroscopic redshifts from the MUSE instrument on the Very Large Telescope (VLT). We measure an Einstein radius of ThetaE=36'' at z = 9 and a mass projected within 200 kpc of M(200 kpc) = 1.78+0.01-0.03x10**14Msol. Using this model, we measure a ratio between the mass attributed to cluster-member galaxy halos and the main cluster halo of order 1:100. We assess the probability to detect magnified high-redshift galaxies in the field of this cluster, both for comparison with RELICS HST results and as a prediction for the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) Guaranteed Time Observations upcoming for this cluster. Our lensing analysis indicates that this cluster has similar lensing strength to other clusters in the RELICS program. Our lensing analysis predicts a detection of at least a few z~6-8 galaxies behind this cluster, at odds with a recent analysis that yielded no such candidates in this field. Reliable strong lensing models are crucial for accurately predicting the intrinsic properties of lensed galaxies. As part of the RELICS program, our strong lensing model produced with the Lenstool parametric method is publicly available through the Mikulski Archive for Space Telescopes (MAST).
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2019; v1 submitted 31 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
RELICS: High-Resolution Constraints on the Inner Mass Distribution of the z=0.83 Merging Cluster RXJ0152.7-1357 from strong lensing
Authors:
Ana Acebron,
May Alon,
Adi Zitrin,
Guillaume Mahler,
Dan Coe,
Keren Sharon,
Nathália Cibirka,
Maruša Bradač,
Michele Trenti,
Keiichi Umetsu,
Felipe Andrade-Santos,
Roberto J. Avila,
Larry Bradley,
Daniela Carrasco,
Catherine Cerny,
Nicole G. Czakon,
William A. Dawson,
Brenda Frye,
Austin T. Hoag,
Kuang-Han Huang,
Traci L. Johnson,
Christine Jones,
Shotaro Kikuchihara,
Daniel Lam,
Rachael C. Livermore
, et al. (15 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Strong gravitational lensing (SL) is a powerful means to map the distribution of dark matter. In this work, we perform a SL analysis of the prominent X-ray cluster RXJ0152.7-1357 (z=0.83, also known as CL 0152.7-1357) in \textit{Hubble Space Telescope} images, taken in the framework of the Reionization Lensing Cluster Survey (RELICS). On top of a previously known $z=3.93$ galaxy multiply imaged by…
▽ More
Strong gravitational lensing (SL) is a powerful means to map the distribution of dark matter. In this work, we perform a SL analysis of the prominent X-ray cluster RXJ0152.7-1357 (z=0.83, also known as CL 0152.7-1357) in \textit{Hubble Space Telescope} images, taken in the framework of the Reionization Lensing Cluster Survey (RELICS). On top of a previously known $z=3.93$ galaxy multiply imaged by RXJ0152.7-1357, for which we identify an additional multiple image, guided by a light-traces-mass approach we identify seven new sets of multiply imaged background sources lensed by this cluster, spanning the redshift range [1.79-3.93]. A total of 25 multiple images are seen over a small area of ~0.4 $arcmin^2$, allowing us to put relatively high-resolution constraints on the inner matter distribution. Although modestly massive, the high degree of substructure together with its very elongated shape make RXJ0152.7-1357 a very efficient lens for its size. This cluster also comprises the third-largest sample of z~6-7 candidates in the RELICS survey. Finally, we present a comparison of our resulting mass distribution and magnification estimates with those from a Lenstool model. These models are made publicly available through the MAST archive.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2019; v1 submitted 18 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Stormy weather in 3C 196.1: nuclear outbursts and merger events shape the environment of the hybrid radio galaxy 3C 196.1
Authors:
F. Ricci,
L. Lovisari,
R. P. Kraft,
F. Massaro,
A. Paggi,
E. Liuzzo,
G. Tremblay,
W. R. Forman,
S. Baum,
C. O'Dea,
B. Wilkes
Abstract:
We present a multi-wavelength analysis based on archival radio, optical and X-ray data of the complex radio source 3C 196.1, whose host is the brightest cluster galaxy of a $z=0.198$ cluster. HST data show H$α$+[N II] emission aligned with the jet 8.4 GHz radio emission. An H$α$+[N II] filament coincides with the brightest X-ray emission, the northern hotspot. Analysis of the X-ray and radio image…
▽ More
We present a multi-wavelength analysis based on archival radio, optical and X-ray data of the complex radio source 3C 196.1, whose host is the brightest cluster galaxy of a $z=0.198$ cluster. HST data show H$α$+[N II] emission aligned with the jet 8.4 GHz radio emission. An H$α$+[N II] filament coincides with the brightest X-ray emission, the northern hotspot. Analysis of the X-ray and radio images reveals cavities located at galactic- and cluster- scales. The galactic-scale cavity is almost devoid of 8.4 GHz radio emission and the south-western H$α$+[N II] emission is bounded (in projection) by this cavity. The outer cavity is co-spatial with the peak of 147 MHz radio emission, and hence we interpret this depression in X-ray surface brightness as being caused by a buoyantly rising bubble originating from an AGN outburst $\sim$280 Myrs ago. A \textit{Chandra} snapshot observation allowed us to constrain the physical parameters of the cluster, which has a cool core with a low central temperature $\sim$2.8 keV, low central entropy index $\sim$13 keV cm$^2$ and a short cooling time of $\sim$500 Myr, which is $<0.05$ of the age of the Universe at this redshift. By fitting jumps in the X-ray density we found Mach numbers between 1.4 and 1.6, consistent with a shock origin. We also found compelling evidence of a past merger, indicated by a morphology reminiscent of gas sloshing in the X-ray residual image. Finally, we computed the pressures, enthalpies $E_{cav}$ and jet powers $P_{jet}$ associated with the cavities: $E_{cav}\sim7\times10^{58}$ erg, $P_{jet}\sim1.9\times10^{44}$ erg s$^{-1}$ for the inner cavity and $E_{cav}\sim3\times10^{60}$ erg, $P_{jet}\sim3.4\times10^{44}$ erg s$^{-1}$ for the outer cavity.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
RELICS: A Strong Lens Model for SPT-CLJ0615-5746, a z=0.972 Cluster
Authors:
Rachel Paterno-Mahler,
Keren Sharon,
Dan Coe,
Guillaume Mahler,
Catherine Cerny,
Traci Johnson,
Tim Schrabback,
Felipe Andrade-Santos,
Roberto J. Avila,
Marusa Bradac,
Larry D. Bradley,
Daniela Carrasco,
Nicole G. Czakon,
William A. Dawson,
Brenda L. Frye,
Austin T. Hoag,
Kuang-Han Huang,
Christine Jones,
Daniel Lam,
Rachael Livermore,
Lorenzo Lovisari,
Ramesh Mainali,
Pascal A. Oesch,
Sara Ogaz,
Matthew Past
, et al. (8 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present a lens model for the cluster SPT-CLJ0615$-$5746, which is the highest redshift ($z=0.972$) system in the Reionization of Lensing Clusters Survey (RELICS), making it the highest redshift cluster for which a full strong lens model is published. We identify three systems of multiply-imaged lensed galaxies, two of which we spectroscopically confirm at $z=1.358$ and $z=4.013$, which we use a…
▽ More
We present a lens model for the cluster SPT-CLJ0615$-$5746, which is the highest redshift ($z=0.972$) system in the Reionization of Lensing Clusters Survey (RELICS), making it the highest redshift cluster for which a full strong lens model is published. We identify three systems of multiply-imaged lensed galaxies, two of which we spectroscopically confirm at $z=1.358$ and $z=4.013$, which we use as constraints for the model. We find a foreground structure at $z\sim0.4$, which we include as a second cluster-sized halo in one of our models; however two different statistical tests find the best-fit model consists of one cluster-sized halo combined with three individually optimized galaxy-sized halos, as well as contributions from the cluster galaxies themselves. We find the total projected mass density within $r=26.7"$ (the region where the strong lensing constraints exist) to be $M=2.51^{+0.15}_{-0.09}\times 10^{14}$~M$_{\odot}$. If we extrapolate out to $r_{500}$, our projected mass density is consistent with the mass inferred from weak lensing and from the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect ($M\sim10^{15}$~M$_{\odot}$). This cluster is lensing a previously reported $z\sim10$ galaxy, which, if spectroscopically confirmed, will be the highest-redshift strongly lensed galaxy known.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2018; v1 submitted 24 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
RELICS: Strong Lensing analysis of the galaxy clusters Abell S295, Abell 697, MACS J0025.4-1222, and MACS J0159.8-0849
Authors:
Nathália Cibirka,
Ana Acebron,
Adi Zitrin,
Dan Coe,
Irene Agulli,
Felipe Andrade-Santos,
Maruša Bradač,
Brenda Frye,
Rachael C. Livermore,
Guillaume Mahler,
Brett Salmon,
Keren Sharon,
Michele Trenti,
Keiichi Umetsu,
Roberto Avila,
Larry Bradley,
Daniela Carrasco,
Catherine Cerny,
Nicole G. Czakon,
William A. Dawson,
Austin T. Hoag,
Kuang-Han Huang,
Traci L. Johnson,
Christine Jones,
Shotaro Kikuchihara
, et al. (15 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present a strong-lensing analysis of four massive galaxy clusters imaged with the Hubble Space Telescope in the Reionization Lensing Cluster Survey. We use a Light-Traces-Mass technique to uncover sets of multiply images and constrain the mass distribution of the clusters. These mass models are the first published for Abell S295 and MACS J0159.8-0849, and are improvements over previous models f…
▽ More
We present a strong-lensing analysis of four massive galaxy clusters imaged with the Hubble Space Telescope in the Reionization Lensing Cluster Survey. We use a Light-Traces-Mass technique to uncover sets of multiply images and constrain the mass distribution of the clusters. These mass models are the first published for Abell S295 and MACS J0159.8-0849, and are improvements over previous models for Abell 697 and MACS J0025.4-1222. Our analysis for MACS J0025.4-1222 and Abell S295 shows a bimodal mass distribution supporting the merger scenarios proposed for these clusters. The updated model for MACS J0025.4-1222 suggests a substantially smaller critical area than previously estimated. For MACS J0159.8-0849 and Abell 697 we find a single peak and relatively regular morphology, revealing fairly relaxed clusters. Despite being less prominent lenses, three of these clusters seem to have lensing strengths, i.e. cumulative area above certain magnification, similar to the Hubble Frontier Fields clusters (e.g., A($μ>5$) $\sim 1-3$ arcmin$^2$, A($μ>10$) $\sim 0.5-1.5$ arcmin$^2$), which in part can be attributed to their merging configurations. We make our lens models publicly available through the Mikulski Archive for Space Telescopes. Finally, using Gemini-N/GMOS spectroscopic observations we detect a single emission line from a high-redshift $J_{125}\simeq25.7$ galaxy candidate lensed by Abell 697. While we cannot rule out a lower-redshift solution, we interpret the line as Ly$α$ at $z=5.800\pm 0.001$, in agreement with its photometric redshift and dropout nature. Within this scenario we measure a Ly$α$ rest-frame equivalent width of $52\pm22$ Å, and an observed Gaussian width of $117\pm 15$ km/s.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2018; v1 submitted 26 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.