-
Analytical model of precessing binaries using post-Newtonian theory in the extreme mass-ratio limit I: General Formalism
Authors:
Nicholas Loutrel,
Sajal Mukherjee,
Andrea Maselli,
Paolo Pani
Abstract:
We develop a fully analytical waveform model for precessing binaries with arbitrary spin vectors using post-Newtonian theory in the extreme mass-ratio limit and a hierarchical multi-scale analysis. Although the post-Newtonian series poorly converges in this limit, our results can be used to estimate how precession affects the measurability of certain binary parameters, and to inform and compare wi…
▽ More
We develop a fully analytical waveform model for precessing binaries with arbitrary spin vectors using post-Newtonian theory in the extreme mass-ratio limit and a hierarchical multi-scale analysis. Although the post-Newtonian series poorly converges in this limit, our results can be used to estimate how precession affects the measurability of certain binary parameters, and to inform and compare with other waveform approximants, such as effective-one-body models, hybrid waveforms, and self-force calculations.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2024; v1 submitted 13 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Relevance of Precession for Tests of the Black Hole No Hair Theorems
Authors:
Nicholas Loutrel,
Richard Brito,
Andrea Maselli,
Paolo Pani
Abstract:
The multipole moments of black holes in general relativity obey certain consistency relations known as the no-hair theorems. The details of this multipolar structure are imprinted into the gravitational waves emitted by binary black holes, particularly if the binary is precessing. If black holes do not obey the vacuum field equations of general relativity, then the no-hair theorems may be broken,…
▽ More
The multipole moments of black holes in general relativity obey certain consistency relations known as the no-hair theorems. The details of this multipolar structure are imprinted into the gravitational waves emitted by binary black holes, particularly if the binary is precessing. If black holes do not obey the vacuum field equations of general relativity, then the no-hair theorems may be broken, and the observed gravitational waves will be modified, thus providing an important test of the no-hair theorems. Recently, analytic solutions to the precession dynamics and inspiral waveforms were computed within the context of binaries possessing non-axisymmetric mass quadrupole moments, which are parametrized by a modulus $q_{m}$ and phase $a_{m}$ with $m = 1,2$ the azimuthal spherical harmonic number. Here, we use a Fisher analysis to study plausible constraints one may obtain on generic, non-axisymmetry quadrupole configurations using current and future ground-based detectors. For non-precessing binaries, we generically find that no meaningful constraints can be placed on the non-axisymmetry parameters $(q_{m}, a_{m})$ due to the presence of strong degeneracies with other waveform parameters. For precessing configurations, the exact value of the uncertainty is strongly dependent on the sky location, system orientation relative to the line of sight, and initial inclination angle of the orbital angular momentum. After averaging over these parameters, we find that with GWTC-3-like events, one should be able to plausibly constraint non-axisymmetric mass quadrupole deviations to $Δq_{m} \sim 10^{-2}$ for LIGO at design sensitivity, and $Δq_{m} \sim 10^{-4}$ for the same sources with Einstein Telescope and Cosmic Explorer.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Eccentric Catastrophes & What To Do With Them
Authors:
Nicholas Loutrel
Abstract:
Analytic modeling of gravitational waves from inspiraling eccentric binaries poses an interesting mathematical challenge. When constructing analytic waveforms in the frequency domain, one has to contend with the fact that the phase of the Fourier integral in non-monotonic, resulting in a breakdown of the standard stationary phase approximation. In this work, we study this breakdown within the cont…
▽ More
Analytic modeling of gravitational waves from inspiraling eccentric binaries poses an interesting mathematical challenge. When constructing analytic waveforms in the frequency domain, one has to contend with the fact that the phase of the Fourier integral in non-monotonic, resulting in a breakdown of the standard stationary phase approximation. In this work, we study this breakdown within the context of catastrophe theory. We find that the stationary phase approximation holds in the context of eccentric Keplerian orbits when the Fourier frequency satisfies $f_{\rm min} < f < f_{\rm max}$, where $f_{\rm min/max}$ are integer multiples of the apocenter/pericenter frequencies, respectively. For values outside of this interval, the phase undergoes a fold catastrophe, giving rise to an Airy function approximation of the Fourier integral. Using these two different approximations, we generate a matched asymptotic expansion that approximates generic Fourier integrals of Keplerian motion for bound orbits across all frequency values. This asymptotic expansion is purely analytic and closed-form. We discuss several applications of this investigation and the resulting approximation, specifically: 1) the development and improvement of effective fly-by waveforms for binary black holes, 2) the transition from burst emission in the high eccentricity limit to wave-like emission in the quasi-circular limit, which results in an analogy between eccentric gravitational wave bursts and Bose-Einstein condensates, and 3) the calculation of f-mode amplitudes in eccentric binary neutron stars and black hole-neutron star binaries in terms of complex Hansen coefficients. The techniques and approximations developed herein are generic, and will be useful for future studies of gravitational waves from eccentric binaries within the context of post-Newtonian theory.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2023; v1 submitted 3 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Eccentricity or spin precession? Distinguishing subdominant effects in gravitational-wave data
Authors:
Isobel M. Romero-Shaw,
Davide Gerosa,
Nicholas Loutrel
Abstract:
Eccentricity and spin precession are key observables in gravitational-wave astronomy, encoding precious information about the astrophysical formation of compact binaries together with fine details of the relativistic two-body problem. However, the two effects can mimic each other in the emitted signals, raising issues around their distinguishability. Since inferring the existence of both eccentric…
▽ More
Eccentricity and spin precession are key observables in gravitational-wave astronomy, encoding precious information about the astrophysical formation of compact binaries together with fine details of the relativistic two-body problem. However, the two effects can mimic each other in the emitted signals, raising issues around their distinguishability. Since inferring the existence of both eccentricity and spin precession simultaneously is -- at present -- not possible, current state-of-the-art analyses assume that either one of the effects may be present in the data. In such a setup, what are the conditions required for a confident identification of either effect? We present simulated parameter inference studies in realistic LIGO/Virgo noise, studying events consistent with either spin precessing or eccentric binary black hole coalescences and recovering under the assumption that either of the two effects may be at play. We quantify how the distinguishability of eccentricity and spin precession increases with the number of visible orbital cycles, confirming that the signal must be sufficiently long for the two effects to be separable. The threshold depends on the injected source, with inclination, eccentricity, and effective spin playing crucial roles. In particular, for injections similar to GW190521, we find that it is impossible to confidently distinguish eccentricity from spin precession.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2023; v1 submitted 14 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Inferring Interference: Identifying a Perturbing Tertiary with Eccentric Gravitational Wave Burst Timing
Authors:
Isobel M. Romero-Shaw,
Nicholas Loutrel,
Michael Zevin
Abstract:
[Abridged] Binary black holes may form and merge dynamically. These binaries are likely to become bound with high eccentricities, resulting in a burst of gravitational radiation at their point of closest approach. When such a binary is perturbed by a third body, the evolution of the orbit is affected, and gravitational-wave burst times are altered. The bursts times therefore encode information abo…
▽ More
[Abridged] Binary black holes may form and merge dynamically. These binaries are likely to become bound with high eccentricities, resulting in a burst of gravitational radiation at their point of closest approach. When such a binary is perturbed by a third body, the evolution of the orbit is affected, and gravitational-wave burst times are altered. The bursts times therefore encode information about the tertiary. In order to extract this information, we require a prescription for the relationship between the tertiary properties and the gravitational-wave burst times. In this paper, we demonstrate a toy model for the burst times of a secular three-body system. We show how Bayesian inference can be employed to deduce the tertiary properties when the bursts are detected by next-generation ground-based gravitational-wave detectors. We study the bursts from an eccentric binary with a total mass of $60$~M$_\odot$ orbiting an $6 \times 10^{8}$~M$_\odot$ supermassive black hole. When we assume no knowledge of the eccentric binary, we are unable to tightly constrain the existence or properties of the tertiary, and we recover biased posterior probability distributions for the parameters of the eccentric binary. However, when the properties of the binary are already well-known -- as is likely if the late inspiral and merger are also detected -- we are able to more accurately infer the mass of the perturber, $m_3$, and its distance from the binary, $R$. When we assume measurement precision on the binary parameters consistent with expectations for next-generation gravitational-wave detectors, we can be greater than $90\%$ confident that the binary is perturbed. [...]
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2023; v1 submitted 14 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Parameterized Post-Einsteinian Framework for Precessing Binaries
Authors:
Nicholas Loutrel,
Paolo Pani,
Nicolás Yunes
Abstract:
In general relativity, isolated black holes obey the no hair theorems, which fix the multipolar structure of their exterior spacetime. However, in modified gravity, or when the compact objects are not black holes, the exterior spacetime may have a different multipolar structure. When two black holes are in a binary, this multipolar structure determines the morphology of the dynamics of orbital and…
▽ More
In general relativity, isolated black holes obey the no hair theorems, which fix the multipolar structure of their exterior spacetime. However, in modified gravity, or when the compact objects are not black holes, the exterior spacetime may have a different multipolar structure. When two black holes are in a binary, this multipolar structure determines the morphology of the dynamics of orbital and spin precession. In turn, the precession dynamics imprint onto the gravitational waves emitted by an inspiraling compact binary through specific amplitude and phase modulations. The detection and characterization of these amplitude and phase modulations can therefore lead to improved constraints on fundamental physics with gravitational waves. Recently, analytic precessing waveforms were calculated in two scenarios: (i) dynamical Chern-Simons gravity, where the no-hair theorems are violated, and (ii) deformed compact objects with generic mass quadrupole moments. In this work, we use these two examples to propose an extension of the parameterized post-Einsteinian~(ppE) framework to include precession effects. The new framework contains $2n$ ppE parameters $(\mathscr{b}^{\rm ppE}_{(m',n)}, b^{\rm ppE}_{(m',n)})$ for the waveform phase, and $2n$ ppE parameters $(\mathscr{a}^{\rm ppE}_{(m',n)}, a^{\rm ppE}_{(m',n)})$ for the waveform amplitudes. The number of ppE corrections $n$ corresponds to the minimum number of harmonics necessary to achieve a given likelihood threshold when comparing the truncated ppE waveform with the exact one, and $(m',n)$ corresponds to the harmonic numbers of the harmonics containing ppE parameters. We show explicitly how these ppE parameters map to the specific example waveforms discussed above. The proposed ppE framework can serve as a basis for future tests of general relativity with gravitational waves from precessing binaries.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2023; v1 submitted 19 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Parity Violation in Spin-Precessing Binaries: Gravitational Waves from the Inspiral of Black Holes in Dynamical Chern-Simons Gravity
Authors:
Nicholas Loutrel,
Nicolas Yunes
Abstract:
Spin precession in compact binaries is intricately tuned to the multipole structure of the underlying bodies. For black holes, violations of the no-hair theorems induced by modifications to general relativity correct the precession dynamics, which in turn imprints onto the amplitude and phase modulations of the gravitational waves emitted by the binary. Recently, the spin precession equations were…
▽ More
Spin precession in compact binaries is intricately tuned to the multipole structure of the underlying bodies. For black holes, violations of the no-hair theorems induced by modifications to general relativity correct the precession dynamics, which in turn imprints onto the amplitude and phase modulations of the gravitational waves emitted by the binary. Recently, the spin precession equations were derived up to second order in spin for dynamical Chern-Simons gravity, a parity violating modified theory of gravity. We here solve these equations and construct, for the first time, analytic expressions for the time- and frequency-domain gravitational waves emitted in the quasi-circular inspiral of spin-precessing black hole binaries in a modified theory of gravity using the post-Newtonian approximation. Working within the small coupling approximation and using multiple scale analysis, we show that the corrections to the nutation phase enter at relative 1PN order, and the corrections to the precession angle and Thomas phase enter at relative 0PN order. Making use of the stationary phase approximation and shifted uniform asymptotics, we find that the Fourier phase of the waveform is characterized by three modifications, two due to the back-reaction of the precession dynamics onto the spin-orbit and spin-spin couplings that enter at 1.5PN and 2PN orders, and a 2PN modification due to the emission of dipole radiation. We also find that back-reaction of the precession dynamics forces the dCS corrections to the Fourier amplitude to enter at 0PN order, as opposed to 2PN order, as expected for spin-aligned binaries. Our work lays the first foundational stones to build an inspiral-merger-ringdown phenomenological model for spin-precessing binaries in a modified theory of gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2022; v1 submitted 5 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Inspiralling compact objects with generic deformations
Authors:
Nicholas Loutrel,
Richard Brito,
Andrea Maselli,
Paolo Pani
Abstract:
Self-gravitating bodies can have an arbitrarily complex shape, which implies a much richer multipolar structure than that of a black hole in General Relativity. With this motivation, we study the corrections to the dynamics of a binary system due to generic, nonaxisymmetric mass quadrupole moments to leading post-Newtonian (PN) order. Utilizing the method of osculating orbits and a multiple scale…
▽ More
Self-gravitating bodies can have an arbitrarily complex shape, which implies a much richer multipolar structure than that of a black hole in General Relativity. With this motivation, we study the corrections to the dynamics of a binary system due to generic, nonaxisymmetric mass quadrupole moments to leading post-Newtonian (PN) order. Utilizing the method of osculating orbits and a multiple scale analysis, we find analytic solutions to the precession and orbital dynamics of a (generically eccentric) binary in terms of the dimensionless modulus parameters $ε_{m}$, corresponding to axial $m=1$ and polar $m=2$ corrections from oblateness/prolateness. The solutions to the precession dynamics are exact for $0 \le ε_{2} < 1$, and perturbative in $ε_{1} \ll 1$. We further compute the leading order corrections to the gravitational wave amplitude and phase for a quasi-circular binary due to mass quadrupole effects. Making use of the stationary phase approximation and shifted uniform asymptotics (SUA), the corrections to the phase enter at relative 2PN order, while the amplitude modulations enter at -0.5PN order with a SUA amplitude correction at 3.25PN order, relative 2PN order to the leading order SUA correction. By investigating the dephasing due to generic quadrupole moments, we find that a phase difference $\gtrsim 0.1$~radians is achievable for $ε_{m} \gtrsim 10^{-3}$, which suggests that constraints with current and future ground-based gravitational wave detectors are possible. Our results can be implemented in parameter estimation studies to constrain generic multipolar deformations of the Kerr geometry and of neutron stars.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2022; v1 submitted 3 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
How to assess the primordial origin of single gravitational-wave events with mass, spin, eccentricity, and deformability measurements
Authors:
Gabriele Franciolini,
Roberto Cotesta,
Nicholas Loutrel,
Emanuele Berti,
Paolo Pani,
Antonio Riotto
Abstract:
A population of primordial black holes formed in the early Universe could contribute to at least a fraction of the black-hole merger events detectable by current and future gravitational-wave interferometers. With the ever-increasing number of detections, an important open problem is how to discriminate whether a given event is of primordial or astrophysical origin. We systematically present a com…
▽ More
A population of primordial black holes formed in the early Universe could contribute to at least a fraction of the black-hole merger events detectable by current and future gravitational-wave interferometers. With the ever-increasing number of detections, an important open problem is how to discriminate whether a given event is of primordial or astrophysical origin. We systematically present a comprehensive and interconnected list of discriminators that would allow us to rule out, or potentially claim, the primordial origin of a binary by measuring different parameters, including redshift, masses, spins, eccentricity, and tidal deformability. We estimate how accurately future detectors (such as the Einstein Telescope and LISA) could measure these quantities, and we quantify the constraining power of each discriminator for current interferometers. We apply this strategy to the GWTC-3 catalog of compact binary mergers. We show that current measurement uncertainties do not allow us to draw solid conclusions on the primordial origin of individual events, but this may become possible with next-generation ground-based detectors.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2022; v1 submitted 20 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Neutron Stars in the Effective Fly-By Framework: $f$-Mode Re-summation
Authors:
Jose Nijaid Arredondo,
Nicholas Loutrel
Abstract:
Eccentric compact binaries pose not only a challenge for gravitational wave detectors, but also provide a probe into the nuclear equation of state if one of the objects is a neutron star. At the short pericenter passage, tidal interactions excite f-modes on the star, which in turn emit their own gravitational waves. We derive an analytic waveform for these stellar oscillations within the effective…
▽ More
Eccentric compact binaries pose not only a challenge for gravitational wave detectors, but also provide a probe into the nuclear equation of state if one of the objects is a neutron star. At the short pericenter passage, tidal interactions excite f-modes on the star, which in turn emit their own gravitational waves. We derive an analytic waveform for these stellar oscillations within the effective fly-by framework, modeling the emission to leading post-Newtonian order. At this order, the f-mode response can be written in a Fourier decomposition in terms of orbital harmonics, with the amplitudes of each harmonic depending on Hansen coefficients. Re-summing the harmonics of the f-mode results in a simple decaying harmonic oscillator, with the amplitude now determined by a Hansen coefficient of complex harmonic number. We compute the match between the re-summed f-mode and numerical integrations of the tidal response, and find ${\cal{M}} > 0.98$ for systems with high orbital eccentricity $(e > 0.8)$ and low semi-latus rectum $(p < 15M)$ for three equations of state. We further compare our model to modes generated from subsequent pericenter passages under the effect of radiation reaction, and develop an accurate model to time pericenter passages. We show how the timing model can be used to specify initial conditions to accurately track the f-mode excitation across multiple pericenter passages.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2022; v1 submitted 26 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Deep Learning with Quantized Neural Networks for Gravitational Wave Forecasting of Eccentric Compact Binary Coalescence
Authors:
Wei Wei,
E. A. Huerta,
Mengshen Yun,
Nicholas Loutrel,
Md Arif Shaikh,
Prayush Kumar,
Roland Haas,
Volodymyr Kindratenko
Abstract:
We present the first application of deep learning forecasting for binary neutron stars, neutron star - black hole systems, and binary black hole mergers that span an eccentricity range e <= 0.9. We train neural networks that describe these astrophysical populations, and then test their performance by injecting simulated eccentric signals in advanced LIGO noise available at the \texttt{Gravitationa…
▽ More
We present the first application of deep learning forecasting for binary neutron stars, neutron star - black hole systems, and binary black hole mergers that span an eccentricity range e <= 0.9. We train neural networks that describe these astrophysical populations, and then test their performance by injecting simulated eccentric signals in advanced LIGO noise available at the \texttt{Gravitational Wave Open Science Center} to: 1) quantify how fast neural networks identify these signals before the binary components merge; 2) quantify how accurately neural networks estimate the time to merger once gravitational waves are identified; and 3) estimate the time-dependent sky localization of these events from early detection to merger. Our findings show that deep learning can identify eccentric signals from a few seconds (for binary black holes) up to tens of seconds (for binary neutron stars) prior to merger. A quantized version of our neural networks achieves 4x reduction in model size, and up to 2.5x inference speed up. These novel algorithms may be used to facilitate time-sensitive multi-messenger astrophysics observations of compact binaries in dense stellar environments.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2021; v1 submitted 7 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Numerical computation of second order vacuum perturbations of Kerr black holes
Authors:
Justin L. Ripley,
Nicholas Loutrel,
Elena Giorgi,
Frans Pretorius
Abstract:
Motivated by the desire to understand the leading order nonlinear gravitational wave interactions around arbitrarily rapidly rotating Kerr black holes, we describe a numerical code designed to compute second order vacuum perturbations on such spacetimes. A general discussion of the formalism we use is presented in (arXiv:2008.11770); here we show how we numerically implement that formalism with a…
▽ More
Motivated by the desire to understand the leading order nonlinear gravitational wave interactions around arbitrarily rapidly rotating Kerr black holes, we describe a numerical code designed to compute second order vacuum perturbations on such spacetimes. A general discussion of the formalism we use is presented in (arXiv:2008.11770); here we show how we numerically implement that formalism with a particular choice of coordinates and tetrad conditions, and give example results for black holes with dimensionless spin parameters $a=0.7$ and $a=0.998$. We first solve the Teukolsky equation for the linearly perturbed Weyl scalar $Ψ_4^{(1)}$, followed by direct reconstruction of the spacetime metric from $Ψ_4^{(1)}$, and then solve for the dynamics of the second order perturbed Weyl scalar $Ψ_4^{(2)}$. This code is a first step toward a more general purpose second order code, and we outline how our basic approach could be further developed to address current questions of interest, including extending the analysis of ringdown in black hole mergers to before the linear regime, exploring gravitational wave "turbulence" around near-extremal Kerr black holes, and studying the physics of extreme mass ratio inspiral.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2021; v1 submitted 30 September, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Repeated Bursts: Gravitational Waves from Highly Eccentric Binaries
Authors:
Nicholas Loutrel
Abstract:
Compact object binaries formed from dynamics interactions will generically have non-zero orbital eccentricity. The gravitational waves from such binaries can change drastically depending on how large the eccentricity is, ranging from emitted in small a subset of orbital harmonics at low eccentricities, to being concentrated into intense bursts of radiation from each pericenter passage at large ecc…
▽ More
Compact object binaries formed from dynamics interactions will generically have non-zero orbital eccentricity. The gravitational waves from such binaries can change drastically depending on how large the eccentricity is, ranging from emitted in small a subset of orbital harmonics at low eccentricities, to being concentrated into intense bursts of radiation from each pericenter passage at large eccentricities. Gravitational waves from such highly eccentric binaries present themselves an intriguing systems for probing fundamental physics, but also present interesting challenges in terms of detection. The presence of orbital eccentricity in the gravitational wave signature gives an unequivocal method of determining the origin of the binary, while the highly dynamical nature of pericenter passage often enhances the physics associated with matter and gravity. The generation of faithful models of the repeated burst signals has proven challenging, and often sub-optimal detection strategies like power stacking are considered for detection. This chapter reviews our current understanding of eccentric binaries, the leading efforts to model their gravitational wave emission, and the physics that can be probed with these detections.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2021; v1 submitted 23 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Second Order Perturbations of Kerr Black Holes: Reconstruction of the Metric
Authors:
Nicholas Loutrel,
Justin L. Ripley,
Elena Giorgi,
Frans Pretorius
Abstract:
Motivated by gravitational wave observations of binary black hole mergers, we present a procedure to compute the leading order nonlinear gravitational wave interactions around a Kerr black hole. We describe the formalism used to derive the equations for second order perturbations. We develop a procedure that allows us to reconstruct the first order metric perturbation solely from knowledge of the…
▽ More
Motivated by gravitational wave observations of binary black hole mergers, we present a procedure to compute the leading order nonlinear gravitational wave interactions around a Kerr black hole. We describe the formalism used to derive the equations for second order perturbations. We develop a procedure that allows us to reconstruct the first order metric perturbation solely from knowledge of the solution to the first order Teukolsky equation, without the need of Hertz potentials. Finally, we illustrate this metric reconstruction procedure in the asymptotic limit for the first order quasi-normal modes of Kerr. In a companion paper, we present a numerical implementation of these ideas.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2021; v1 submitted 26 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Fast Frequency-Domain Effective Fly-By Waveforms
Authors:
Nicholas Loutrel
Abstract:
Recently, we developed effective fly-by (EFB) waveforms designed to model the burst of gravitational radiation from highly eccentric binaries. We here present a faster to evaluate frequency domain EFB waveform. The waveform is constructed through the use of asymptotic expansions of hypergeometric functions. Since the waveform is fully analytic, we study the accuracy to which the binary's parameter…
▽ More
Recently, we developed effective fly-by (EFB) waveforms designed to model the burst of gravitational radiation from highly eccentric binaries. We here present a faster to evaluate frequency domain EFB waveform. The waveform is constructed through the use of asymptotic expansions of hypergeometric functions. Since the waveform is fully analytic, we study the accuracy to which the binary's parameters can be measured using a Fisher analysis. We find that degeneracies exist among the parameters, such that the waveform is parameterized in terms of the chirp mass ${\cal{M}}$ and orbital radius of curvature ${\cal{P}}$, instead of the total mass, symmetric mass ratio, and semi-latus rectum of the binary. By computing the Fisher matrix for single bursts from two thousand binary systems, we find that most of the systems will have greater than one hundred percent uncertainty in the chirp mass, luminosity distance, and inclination angle, while roughly half will have less than one hundred percent uncertainty in the orbital radius of curvature, orbital eccentricity, and polarization angle. Further, we repeat this analysis after including additional bursts within the inspiral sequence and find that the uncertainties in the waveform's parameters can improve by orders of magnitude with a sufficient timing model for the bursts.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2021; v1 submitted 30 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Analytic Waveforms for Eccentric Gravitational Wave Bursts
Authors:
Nicholas Loutrel
Abstract:
We here present the first analytic effective fly-by (EFB) waveforms designed to accurately capture the burst of gravitational radiation from the closest approach of highly eccentric compact binaries. The waveforms are constructed by performing a re-summation procedure on the well-known Fourier series representation of the two-body problem at leading post-Newtonian order. This procedure results in…
▽ More
We here present the first analytic effective fly-by (EFB) waveforms designed to accurately capture the burst of gravitational radiation from the closest approach of highly eccentric compact binaries. The waveforms are constructed by performing a re-summation procedure on the well-known Fourier series representation of the two-body problem at leading post-Newtonian order. This procedure results in two models: one in the time-domain, and one in the Fourier domain, which makes use of the stationary phase approximation. We discuss the computational efficiency of these models, and find that the time-domain model is roughly twice as fast as a numerical quadrupole waveform. We compare the time-domain model to both numerical, leading post-Newtonian order, quadrupole waveforms and numerical relativity fly-by waveforms using the match statistic. While the match is typically $>0.97$ when compared to the quadrupole waveforms, it is much lower when comparing to the numerical relativity fly-by waveforms, due to neglecting relativistic effects within the model. We further show how to use these individual waveforms to detect a repeated burst source.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2020; v1 submitted 4 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
The Eccentric Behavior of Inspiraling Compact Binaries
Authors:
Nicholas Loutrel,
Samuel Liebersbach,
Nicolas Yunes,
Neil Cornish
Abstract:
Eccentricity of binary systems is not a gauge invariant quantity, but has an important impact on the observed gravitational wave signal of such systems, generating power in all possible harmonics of the orbital period. We here clarify the possible discrepancies between different eccentricity parameters used to describe the orbital dynamics of binary systems across different approximations, specifi…
▽ More
Eccentricity of binary systems is not a gauge invariant quantity, but has an important impact on the observed gravitational wave signal of such systems, generating power in all possible harmonics of the orbital period. We here clarify the possible discrepancies between different eccentricity parameters used to describe the orbital dynamics of binary systems across different approximations, specifically the post-Newtonian approximation, the self-force approximation, and numerical relativity. To this end, we highlight disparities between the typically used orbit averaged method of evolving binary systems under radiation reaction, and more direct techniques of solving the two-body problem in post-Newtonian theory. We show, both numerically and analytically, that the orbit averaged method breaks down in the late inspiral, failing to capture a strong secular growth in the Keplerian eccentricity parameter and producing a orbital de-phasing relative to direct integration of the two-body equations of motion. We show that the secular growth and de-phasing affect the observed gravitational wave signal, which could bias how accurately we may recover parameters for systems with signal-to-noise ratios $\gtrsim 100$. We further develop a frequency domain post-adiabatic waveform model to capture these effects, and study the precision to which we may estimate parameters with this model through a Fisher information matrix analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2019; v1 submitted 8 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
A Fourier Domain Waveform for Non-Spinning Binaries with Arbitrary Eccentricity
Authors:
Blake Moore,
Travis Robson,
Nicholas Loutrel,
Nicolas Yunes
Abstract:
Although the gravitational waves observed by advanced LIGO and Virgo are consistent with compact binaries in a quasi-circular inspiral prior to coalescence, eccentric inspirals are also expected to occur in Nature. Due to their complexity, we currently lack ready-to-use, analytic waveforms in the Fourier domain valid for sufficiently high eccentricity, and such models are crucial to coherently ext…
▽ More
Although the gravitational waves observed by advanced LIGO and Virgo are consistent with compact binaries in a quasi-circular inspiral prior to coalescence, eccentric inspirals are also expected to occur in Nature. Due to their complexity, we currently lack ready-to-use, analytic waveforms in the Fourier domain valid for sufficiently high eccentricity, and such models are crucial to coherently extract weak signals from the noise. We here take the first steps to derive and properly validate an analytic waveform model in the Fourier domain that is valid for inspirals of arbitrary orbital eccentricity. As a proof-of-concept, we build this model to leading post-Newtonian order by combining the stationary phase approximation, a truncated sum of harmonics, and an analytic representation of hypergeometric functions. Through comparisons with numerical post-Newtonian waveforms, we determine how many harmonics are required for a faithful (matches above 99%) representation of the signal up to orbital eccentricities as large as 0.9. As a first byproduct of this analysis, we present a novel technique to maximize the match of eccentric signals over time of coalescence and phase at coalescence. As a second byproduct, we determine which of the different approximations we employ leads to the largest loss in match, which could be used to systematically improve the model because of our analytic control. The future extension of this model to higher post-Newtonian order will allow for an accurate and fast phenomenological hybrid that can account for arbitrary eccentricity inspirals and mergers.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Spin-Precessing Black Hole Binaries in Dynamical Chern-Simons Gravity
Authors:
Nicholas Loutrel,
Takahiro Tanaka,
Nicolas Yunes
Abstract:
Gravitational waves from spin-precessing binaries exhibit amplitude oscillations that provide an invaluable method to extract the spins of the inspiraling compact objects. The spin-spin and spin-orbit interactions that cause this effect are sensitive to the fundamental nature of gravity, which will allow us to constrain modified theories of gravity using gravitational wave observations of precessi…
▽ More
Gravitational waves from spin-precessing binaries exhibit amplitude oscillations that provide an invaluable method to extract the spins of the inspiraling compact objects. The spin-spin and spin-orbit interactions that cause this effect are sensitive to the fundamental nature of gravity, which will allow us to constrain modified theories of gravity using gravitational wave observations of precessing binaries. We here consider precessing black hole binaries in dynamical Chern-Simons gravity, an effective theory of gravity that enhances parity violating interactions. We model the black holes as modified point particles using effective field theory, and derive the spin-precession equations for a binary system by working within the post-Newtonian formalism. We find that the spin-spin and quadrupole-monopole interactions of General Relativity are modified due to an interaction between the scalar dipoles of the two black holes and the modified black hole quadrupole as a result of the violation of the no hair theorems. These modifications enter the precession equations at leading post-Newtonian order. We further show that these precession equations admit seven constants of motion when neglecting radiation reaction, with only the mass-weighted effective spin being modified from General Relativity. We discuss how these may be used to reduce the precession equations to quadrature and the possibility of constructing analytic Fourier domain waveforms for generic spin-precessing binaries in dCS gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2018; v1 submitted 19 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Scalar Tops and Perturbed Quadrupoles: Probing Fundamental Physics with Spin-Precessing Binaries
Authors:
Nicholas Loutrel,
Takahiro Tanaka,
Nicolas Yunes
Abstract:
Parity violation in the gravitational interaction has an important impact on fundamental observables and the evolution of the universe. We here investigate for the first time our ability to probe the parity violating nature of the gravitational interaction using gravitational waves from spin-precessing binaries. Focusing on dynamical Chern-Simons gravity, we derive the spin-precession equations, c…
▽ More
Parity violation in the gravitational interaction has an important impact on fundamental observables and the evolution of the universe. We here investigate for the first time our ability to probe the parity violating nature of the gravitational interaction using gravitational waves from spin-precessing binaries. Focusing on dynamical Chern-Simons gravity, we derive the spin-precession equations, calculate the gravitational waves emitted by spin-precessing, quasi-circular black hole binaries and estimate the level to which the theory could be constrained with future gravitational wave observations.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Nature Abhors a Circle
Authors:
Nicholas Loutrel,
Samuel Liebersbach,
Nicolas Yunes,
Neil Cornish
Abstract:
The loss of orbital energy and angular momentum to gravitational waves produced in a binary inspiral forces the orbital eccentricity to adiabatically evolve and oscillate. For comparable-mass binaries, the osculating eccentricity is thought to decrease monotonically in the inspiral. Contrary to this, we here show that, once the osculating eccentricity is small enough, radiation reaction forces it…
▽ More
The loss of orbital energy and angular momentum to gravitational waves produced in a binary inspiral forces the orbital eccentricity to adiabatically evolve and oscillate. For comparable-mass binaries, the osculating eccentricity is thought to decrease monotonically in the inspiral. Contrary to this, we here show that, once the osculating eccentricity is small enough, radiation reaction forces it to grow secularly before the binary reaches the last stable orbit. We explore this behavior, its physical interpretation and consequences, and its potential impact on future gravitational wave observations.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2019; v1 submitted 26 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Eccentric Gravitational Wave Bursts in the Post-Newtonian Formalism
Authors:
Nicolas Loutrel,
Nicolas Yunes
Abstract:
The detection of GW150914 by ground based gravitational wave observatories has brought about a new era in astrophysics. At optimal sensitivity, these observatories are expected to detect several events each year, with one or two of these occurring with non-negligible eccentricity. Such eccentric binaries will emit bursts of gravitational radiation during every pericenter passage, where orbital vel…
▽ More
The detection of GW150914 by ground based gravitational wave observatories has brought about a new era in astrophysics. At optimal sensitivity, these observatories are expected to detect several events each year, with one or two of these occurring with non-negligible eccentricity. Such eccentric binaries will emit bursts of gravitational radiation during every pericenter passage, where orbital velocities can reach greater than ten percent the speed of light. As a result, such binaries may prove to be powerful probes of extreme gravitational physics and astrophysics. A promising method of achieving detection of such binaries is through power stacking, where the power in each burst is added up in time-frequency space. This detection strategy requires a theoretical prior of where the bursts will occur in time and frequency so that one knows where to search for successive bursts. We here present a generic post-Newtonian formalism for constructing such time-frequency model priors at generic post-Newtonian order. We apply our formalism to generate a burst model at third post-Newtonian order, making it potentially the most accurate, fully analytic model to date.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2017; v1 submitted 6 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
A Survey for New Members of the Taurus Star-Forming Region with the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
Authors:
K. L. Luhman,
E. E. Mamajek,
S. J. Shukla,
N. P. Loutrel
Abstract:
Previous studies have found that ~1 deg2 fields surrounding the stellar aggregates in the Taurus star-forming region exhibit a surplus of solar-mass stars relative to denser clusters like IC~348 and the Orion Nebula Cluster. To test whether this difference reflects mass segregation in Taurus or a variation in the IMF, we have performed a survey for members of Taurus across a large field (~40 deg2)…
▽ More
Previous studies have found that ~1 deg2 fields surrounding the stellar aggregates in the Taurus star-forming region exhibit a surplus of solar-mass stars relative to denser clusters like IC~348 and the Orion Nebula Cluster. To test whether this difference reflects mass segregation in Taurus or a variation in the IMF, we have performed a survey for members of Taurus across a large field (~40 deg2) that was imaged by the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS). We obtained optical and near-infrared spectra of candidate members identified with those images and the Two Micron All Sky Survey, as well as miscellaneous candidates that were selected with several other diagnostics of membership. We have classified 22 of the candidates as new members of Taurus, which includes one of the coolest known members (M9.75). Our updated census of members within the SDSS field shows a surplus of solar-mass stars relative to clusters, although it is less pronounced than in the smaller fields towards the stellar aggregates that were surveyed for previously measured mass functions in Taurus. In addition to spectra of our new members, we include in our study near-IR spectra of roughly half of the known members of Taurus, which are used to refine their spectral types and extinctions. We also present an updated set of near-IR standard spectra for classifying young stars and brown dwarfs at M and L types.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2016; v1 submitted 28 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Hereditary Effects in Eccentric Compact Binary Inspirals to Third Post-Newtonian Order
Authors:
Nicholas Loutrel,
Nicolas Yunes
Abstract:
While there has been much success in understanding the orbital dynamics and gravitational wave emission of eccentric compact binaries in the post-Newtonian formalism, some problems still remain. The largest of these concerns hereditary effects: non-linear phenomena related to the scattering off of the background curved spacetime (tails) and to the generation of gravitational waves by gravitational…
▽ More
While there has been much success in understanding the orbital dynamics and gravitational wave emission of eccentric compact binaries in the post-Newtonian formalism, some problems still remain. The largest of these concerns hereditary effects: non-linear phenomena related to the scattering off of the background curved spacetime (tails) and to the generation of gravitational waves by gravitational waves (memory). Currently, these hereditary effects are only known numerically for arbitrary eccentricity through infinite sums of Bessel functions, with closed-form, analytic results only available in the small eccentricity limit. We here calculate, for the first time, closed-form, analytic expressions for all hereditary effects to third post-Newtonian order in binaries with arbitrary eccentricity. For the tails, we first asymptotically expand all Bessel functions in high eccentricity and find a superasymptotic series for each enhancement factor, accurate to better than $10^{-3}$ relative to post-Newtonian numerical calculations at all eccentricities. We further improve the small-eccentricity behavior of the superasymptotic series by generating hyperasymptotic expressions for each enhancement factor, typically accurate to better than $10^{-8}$ at all eccentricities. For the memory, we discuss its computation within the context of an osculating approximation of the binary's orbit and the difficulties that arise. Our closed-form analytic expressions for the hereditary fluxes allow us to numerically compute orbital phases that are identical to those found using an infinite sum of Bessel functions to double numerical precision.
△ Less
Submitted 16 July, 2019; v1 submitted 19 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
A Census of Young Stars and Brown Dwarfs in IC 348 and NGC 1333
Authors:
K. L. Luhman,
T. L. Esplin,
N. P. Loutrel
Abstract:
We have obtained optical and near-infrared spectra of candidate members of the star-forming clusters IC 348 and NGC 1333. We classify 100 and 42 candidates as new members of the clusters, respectively, which brings the total numbers of known members to 478 and 203. We also have performed spectroscopy on a large majority of the previously known members of NGC 1333 in order to provide spectral class…
▽ More
We have obtained optical and near-infrared spectra of candidate members of the star-forming clusters IC 348 and NGC 1333. We classify 100 and 42 candidates as new members of the clusters, respectively, which brings the total numbers of known members to 478 and 203. We also have performed spectroscopy on a large majority of the previously known members of NGC 1333 in order to provide spectral classifications that are measured with the same scheme that has been applied to IC 348 in previous studies. The new census of members is nearly complete for Ks<16.8 at Aj<1.5 in IC 348 and for Ks<16.2 at Aj<3 in NGC 1333, which correspond to masses of <=0.01 Msun for ages of 3 Myr according to theoretical evolutionary models. The faintest known members extend below these completeness limits and appear to have masses of ~0.005 Msun. In extinction-limited samples of cluster members, NGC 1333 exhibits a higher abundance of objects at lower masses than IC 348. It would be surprising if the initial mass functions of these clusters differ significantly given their similar stellar densities and formation environments. Instead, it is possible that average extinctions are lower for less massive members of star-forming clusters, in which case extinction-limited samples could be biased in favor of low-mass objects in the more heavily embedded clusters like NGC 1333. In the H-R diagram, the median sequences of IC 348 and NGC 1333 coincide with each other for the adopted distances of 300 and 235 pc, which would suggest that they have similar ages. However, NGC 1333 is widely believed to be younger than IC 348 based on its higher abundance of disks and protostars and its greater obscuration. Errors in the adopted distances may be responsible for this discrepancy.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
A Parametrized post-Einsteinian Framework for Gravitational Wave Bursts
Authors:
Nicholas Loutrel,
Nicolas Yunes,
Frans Pretorius
Abstract:
The population of stellar-mass, compact object binaries that merge with non-negligible eccentricity may be large enough to motivate searches with ground-based gravitational wave detectors. Such events could be exceptional laboratories to test General Relativity in the dynamical, strong-field regime, as a larger fraction of the energy is emitted at high-velocities, compared to quasi-circular inspir…
▽ More
The population of stellar-mass, compact object binaries that merge with non-negligible eccentricity may be large enough to motivate searches with ground-based gravitational wave detectors. Such events could be exceptional laboratories to test General Relativity in the dynamical, strong-field regime, as a larger fraction of the energy is emitted at high-velocities, compared to quasi-circular inspirals. A serious obstacle here, however, is the challenge of computing theoretical waveforms for eccentric systems with the requisite accuracy for use in a matched-filter search. The corresponding waveforms are more a sequence of concentrated bursts of energy emitted near periapse than a continuous waveform. Based on this, an alternative approach, stacking excess power over the set of time-frequency tiles coincident with the bursts, was recently suggested as a more practical (though sub-optimal) detection strategy. The leading-order "observable" that would be inferred from such a detection would be a sequence of discrete numbers characterizing the position and size of each time-frequency tile. In General Relativity, this (possibly large) sequence of numbers is uniquely determined by the small set of parameters describing the binary at formation. In this work, following the spirit of the parameterized post-Einsteinian framework developed for quasi-circular inspiral, we propose a simple, parameterized deformation of the baseline general relativistic burst algorithm for eccentric inspiral events that would allow for model-independent tests of Einstein's theory in this high-velocity, strong-field regime.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2017; v1 submitted 31 March, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
New M, L, and T Dwarf Companions to Nearby Stars from the Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer
Authors:
Kevin L. Luhman,
Nicholas P. Loutrel,
Nicholas S. McCurdy,
Gregory N. Mace,
Nicole D. Melso,
Kimberly M. Star,
Michael D. Young,
Ryan C. Terrien,
Ian S. McLean,
J. Davy Kirkpatrick,
Katherine L. Rhode
Abstract:
We present 11 candidate late-type companions to nearby stars identified with data from the Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE) and the Two Micron All-Sky Survey (2MASS). Eight of the candidates are likely to be companions based on their common proper motions with the primaries. The remaining three objects are rejected as companions, one of which is a free-floating T7 dwarf. Spectral types a…
▽ More
We present 11 candidate late-type companions to nearby stars identified with data from the Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE) and the Two Micron All-Sky Survey (2MASS). Eight of the candidates are likely to be companions based on their common proper motions with the primaries. The remaining three objects are rejected as companions, one of which is a free-floating T7 dwarf. Spectral types are available for five of the companions, which consist of M2V, M8.5V, L5, T8, and T8. Based on their photometry, the unclassified companions are probably two mid-M dwarfs and one late-M/early-L dwarf. One of the T8 companions, WISE J142320.84+011638.0, has already been reported by Pinfield and coworkers. The other T8 companion, ULAS J095047.28+011734.3, was discovered by Burningham and coworkers through the United Kingdom Infrared Telescope Infrared Deep Sky Survey, but its companionship has not been previously recognized in the literature. The L5 companion, 2MASS J17430860+8526594, is a new member of a class of L dwarfs that exhibit unusually blue near-IR colors. Among the possible mechanisms that have been previously proposed for the peculiar colors of these L dwarfs, low metallicity does not appear to be a viable explanation for 2MASS J17430860+8526594 since our spectrum of the primary suggests that its metallicity is not significantly subsolar.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Discovery of a Companion at the L/T Transition with the Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer
Authors:
N. P. Loutrel,
K. L. Luhman,
P. J. Lowrance,
J. J. Bochanski
Abstract:
We report the discovery of a substellar companion to the nearby solar-type star HD 46588 (F7V, 17.9 pc, ~3 Gyr). HD 46588 B was found through a survey for common proper motion companions to nearby stars using data from the Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer and the Two-Micron All-Sky Survey. It has an angular separation of 79.2" from its primary, which corresponds to a projected physical separati…
▽ More
We report the discovery of a substellar companion to the nearby solar-type star HD 46588 (F7V, 17.9 pc, ~3 Gyr). HD 46588 B was found through a survey for common proper motion companions to nearby stars using data from the Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer and the Two-Micron All-Sky Survey. It has an angular separation of 79.2" from its primary, which corresponds to a projected physical separation of 1420 AU. We have measured a spectral type of L9 for this object based on near-infrared spectroscopy performed with TripleSpec at Palomar Observatory. We estimate a mass of 0.064+0.008/-0.019 Msun from a comparison of its luminosity to the values predicted by theoretical evolutionary models for the age of the primary. Because of its companionship to a well-studied star, HD 46588 B is one of the few known brown dwarfs at the L/T transition for which both age and distance estimates are available. Thus, it offers new constraints on the properties of brown dwarfs during this brief evolutionary phase. The discovery of HD 46588 B also illustrates the value of the Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer for identifying brown dwarfs in the solar neighborhood via their proper motions.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2011;
originally announced July 2011.
