Showing 1–11 of 11 results for author: Lotfi, M H

The Interplay of Competition and Cooperation Among Service Providers (Part II)

Authors: Xingran Chen, Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Saswati Sarkar

Abstract: This paper investigates the incentives of mobile network operators (MNOs) for acquiring additional spectrum to offer mobile virtual network operators (MVNOs) and thereby inviting competition for a common pool of end users (EUs). We consider interactions between two service providers, an MNO and an MVNO, when the EUs 1) must choose one of them 2) have the option to defect to an outside option shoul… ▽ More This paper investigates the incentives of mobile network operators (MNOs) for acquiring additional spectrum to offer mobile virtual network operators (MVNOs) and thereby inviting competition for a common pool of end users (EUs). We consider interactions between two service providers, an MNO and an MVNO, when the EUs 1) must choose one of them 2) have the option to defect to an outside option should the SP duo offer unsatisfactory access fees or qualities of service. We formulate a multi-stage hybrid of cooperative bargaining and non-cooperative games in which the two SPs jointly determine their spectrum acquisitions, allocations and mutual money flows through the bargaining game, and subsequently individually determine the access fees for the EUs through the non-cooperative game. We identify when the overall equilibrium solutions exist, when it is unique and characterize the equilibrium solutions when they exist. The characterizations are easy to compute, and are in closed form or involve optimizations in only one decision variable. The hybrid framework allows us to determine whether and by how much the different entities benefit due to the cooperation in spectrum acquisition decision. △ Less

Submitted 10 June, 2020; v1 submitted 3 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

The Interplay of Competition and Cooperation Among Service Providers (Part I)

Authors: Xingran Chen, Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Saswati Sarkar

Abstract: This paper investigates the incentives of mobile network operators (MNOs) for acquiring additional spectrum to offer mobile virtual network operators (MVNOs) and thereby inviting competition for a common pool of end users (EUs). We consider a base case and two generalizations: (i) one MNO and one MVNO, (ii) one MNO, one MVNO and an outside option, and (iii) two MNOs and one MVNO. In each of these… ▽ More This paper investigates the incentives of mobile network operators (MNOs) for acquiring additional spectrum to offer mobile virtual network operators (MVNOs) and thereby inviting competition for a common pool of end users (EUs). We consider a base case and two generalizations: (i) one MNO and one MVNO, (ii) one MNO, one MVNO and an outside option, and (iii) two MNOs and one MVNO. In each of these cases, we model the interactions of the service providers (SPs) using a sequential game, identify when the Subgame Perfect Nash Equilibrium (SPNE) exists, when it is unique and characterize the SPNE when it exists. The characterizations are easy to compute, and are in closed form or involve optimizations in only one decision variable. We identify metrics to quantify the interplay between cooperation and competition, and evaluate those as also the SPNEs to show that cooperation between MNO and MVNO can enhance the payoffs of both, while increased competition due to the presence of additional MNOs is beneficial to EUs but reduces the payoffs of the SPs. △ Less

Submitted 10 June, 2020; v1 submitted 31 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Is Non-Neutrality Profitable for the Stakeholders of the Internet Market? - Part II

Authors: Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Saswati Sarkar, George Kesidis

Abstract: In this part of the paper, we obtain analytical results for the case that transport costs are not small (complement of Part I), and combine them with the results in Part I of the paper to provide general results for all values of transport costs. We show that, in general, if an SPNE exists, it would be one of the five possible strategies each of which we explicitly characterize. We also prove that… ▽ More In this part of the paper, we obtain analytical results for the case that transport costs are not small (complement of Part I), and combine them with the results in Part I of the paper to provide general results for all values of transport costs. We show that, in general, if an SPNE exists, it would be one of the five possible strategies each of which we explicitly characterize. We also prove that when EUs have sufficiently high inertia for at least one of the ISPs, there exists a unique SPNE with a non-neutral outcome in which both of the ISPs are active, and the CP offers her content with free quality on the neutral ISP and with premium quality on the non-neutral ISP. Moreover, we show that an SPNE does not always exist. We also analyze a benchmark case in which both ISPs are neutral, and prove that there exists a unique SPNE in which the CP offers her content with free quality on both ISPs, and both ISPs are active. We also provide extensive numerical results and discussions for all ranges of transport costs. Simulation results suggest that if the SPNE exists, it would be unique. In addition, results reveal that the neutral ISP receives a lower payoff and the non-neutral ISP receives a higher payoff (most of the time) in a non-neutral scenario. However, we also identify scenarios in which the non-neutral ISP loses payoff by adopting non-neutrality. In addition, we show that a non-neutral regime yields a higher welfare for EUs than a neutral one if the market power of the non-neutral ISP is small, the sensitivity of EUs (respectively, the CP) to the quality is low (respectively, high), or a combinations of these factors. △ Less

Submitted 24 November, 2017; originally announced November 2017.

Comments: Submitted to IEEE Transaction on Networking, previously contents of this paper were contained in arXiv:1611.10191 which was split during the reviewing process

The Interplay of Competition and Cooperation Among Service Providers

Authors: Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Xingran Chen, Saswati Sarkar

Abstract: We consider the economics of the interaction between Mobile Virtual Network Operators (MVNOs) and Mobile Network Operators (MNOs). We investigate the incentives of an MNO for offering some of her resources to an MVNO instead of using the resources for her own End-Users (EUs). We consider a market with one MNO and one MVNO, and a continuum of undecided EUs. Two cases for EUs are considered: (i) whe… ▽ More We consider the economics of the interaction between Mobile Virtual Network Operators (MVNOs) and Mobile Network Operators (MNOs). We investigate the incentives of an MNO for offering some of her resources to an MVNO instead of using the resources for her own End-Users (EUs). We consider a market with one MNO and one MVNO, and a continuum of undecided EUs. Two cases for EUs are considered: (i) when EUs need to choose either the MNO or the MVNO, and (ii) when EUs have an outside option. In each of these cases, we consider a non-cooperative framework of sequential game and a cooperative framework of bargaining game. We characterize the Subgame Perfect Nash Equilibria (SPNE) and Nash Bargaining Solution (NBS) of the sequential and bargaining games, respectively. We show that in the non-cooperative framework, SPNE assumes two forms: (i) the MNO invests minimally on her infrastructure and the MVNO leases all the newly invested resources and (ii) the MNO invests more on her infrastructure, the MVNO leases only part of these resources to the MVNO, and the MNO uses the rest herself to attract EUs. Thus, in both, the MNO generates revenue indirectly through the MVNO. In addition to that, in (ii), the MNO generates revenue directly from the EUs. We also prove that in the bargaining framework, the MVNO either reserves all the resources or no resources from the MNO, and the MNO's investments are guided by whether EUs have an outside option. If they don't, then the MNO invests as little as possible on her infrastructure. If they do, then the MNO invests more. △ Less

Submitted 21 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: 14 pages, Submitted to IEEE/ACM Transaction on Networking

The Economics of Competition and Cooperation Between MNOs and MVNOs

Authors: Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Saswati Sarkar

Abstract: In this work, we consider the economics of the interaction between Mobile Virtual Network Operators (MVNOs) and Mobile Network Operators (MNOs). We investigate the incentives of an MNO for offering some of her resources to an MVNO instead of using the resources for her own. We formulate the problem as a sequential game. We consider a market with one MNO and one MVNO, and a continuum of undecided e… ▽ More In this work, we consider the economics of the interaction between Mobile Virtual Network Operators (MVNOs) and Mobile Network Operators (MNOs). We investigate the incentives of an MNO for offering some of her resources to an MVNO instead of using the resources for her own. We formulate the problem as a sequential game. We consider a market with one MNO and one MVNO, and a continuum of undecided end-users. We assume that EUs have different preferences for the MNO and the MVNO. These preferences can be because of the differences in the service they are offering or the reluctance of an EU to buy her plan from one of them. We assume that the preferences also depend on the investment level the MNO and the MVNO. We show that there exists a unique interior SPNE, i.e. the SPNE by which both SPs receive a positive mass of EUs, and characterize it. We also consider a benchmark case in which the MNO and the MVNO do not cooperate, characterize the unique SPNE of this case, and compare the results of our model to the benchmark case to assess the incentive of the MNO to invest in her infrastructure and to offer it to the MVNO. △ Less

Submitted 21 January, 2017; originally announced January 2017.

Comments: 8 Pages, Tech report for CISS2017 submission

Is Non-Neutrality Profitable for the Stakeholders of the Internet Market?

Authors: Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Saswati Sarkar, George Kesidis

Abstract: Net neutrality on the Internet is perceived as the policy that mandates Internet Service Providers (ISPs) to treat all data equally, regardless of the source, destination, or type of transmitted data. In this work, we consider a scheme in which the decision makers of the market are two ISPs, one "big" Content Provider (CP), and a continuum of end-users. One of the ISPs is neutral and the other is… ▽ More Net neutrality on the Internet is perceived as the policy that mandates Internet Service Providers (ISPs) to treat all data equally, regardless of the source, destination, or type of transmitted data. In this work, we consider a scheme in which the decision makers of the market are two ISPs, one "big" Content Provider (CP), and a continuum of end-users. One of the ISPs is neutral and the other is non-neutral, i.e. she offers a premium quality to a CP in exchange for a side-payment. In addition, we assume that the CP can differentiate between ISPs by controlling the quality of the content she is offering on each one. In this part of the paper, we consider a scenario in which end-users are not locked in with the ISPs and can switch between ISPs easily. We formulate a sequential game, and show that there exists a unique Sub-game Perfect Nash Equilibrium (SPNE) for the game, where the CP pays the side-payment to the non-neutral ISP and offers her content with the premium quality. In addition, the CP does not offer her content on the neutral ISP. Thus, driving this ISP out of the market. △ Less

Submitted 25 June, 2019; v1 submitted 30 November, 2016; originally announced November 2016.

Comments: Submitted to IEEE Transaction on Networking

The Economics of Quality Sponsored Data in Non-Neutral Networks

Authors: Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Saswati Sarkar, Karthikeyan Sundaresan, Mohammad Ali Khojastepour

Abstract: The growing demand for data has driven the Service Providers (SPs) to provide differential treatment of traffic to generate additional revenue streams from Content Providers (CPs). While SPs currently only provide best-effort services to their CPs, it is plausible to envision a model in near future, where CPs are willing to sponsor quality of service for their content in exchange of sharing a port… ▽ More The growing demand for data has driven the Service Providers (SPs) to provide differential treatment of traffic to generate additional revenue streams from Content Providers (CPs). While SPs currently only provide best-effort services to their CPs, it is plausible to envision a model in near future, where CPs are willing to sponsor quality of service for their content in exchange of sharing a portion of their profit with SPs. This quality sponsoring becomes invaluable especially when the available resources are scarce such as in wireless networks, and can be accommodated in a non-neutral network. In this paper, we consider the problem of Quality-Sponsored Data (QSD) in a non-neutral network. In our model, SPs allow CPs to sponsor a portion of their resources, and price it appropriately to maximize their payoff. The payoff of the SP depends on the monetary revenue and the satisfaction of end-users both for the non-sponsored and sponsored content, while CPs generate revenue through advertisement. We analyze the market dynamics and equilibria in two different frameworks, i.e. sequential and bargaining game frameworks, and provide strategies for (i) SPs: to determine if and how to price resources, and (ii) CPs: to determine if and what quality to sponsor. The frameworks characterize different sets of equilibrium strategies and market outcomes depending on the parameters of the market. △ Less

Submitted 17 October, 2016; v1 submitted 12 January, 2015; originally announced January 2015.

Comments: Submitted to IEEE/ACM Transaction on Networking

Network Non-Neutrality on the Internet: Content Provision Under a Subscription Revenue Model

Authors: Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, George Kesidis, Saswati Sarkar

Abstract: The goal of this paper is to provide an insight into the equilibrium of the Internet market, when the current balance of the market is disrupted, and one of the ISPs switches to a non-neutral regime. We consider a content provider with a subscription revenue model and a continuum of end-users. The CP is also non-neutral, in the sense that she can charge users of different ISPs different subscripti… ▽ More The goal of this paper is to provide an insight into the equilibrium of the Internet market, when the current balance of the market is disrupted, and one of the ISPs switches to a non-neutral regime. We consider a content provider with a subscription revenue model and a continuum of end-users. The CP is also non-neutral, in the sense that she can charge users of different ISPs different subscription fees, and use this "leverage" to control the equilibrium outcome. Results reveal that the CP is able to control the non-neutral ISP to some extend. However, switching to a non-neutral regime by an ISP tips the balance of the market in favor of this ISP. △ Less

Submitted 8 April, 2014; v1 submitted 7 April, 2014; originally announced April 2014.

Comments: 6 pages, 2 figures

Uncertain Price Competition in a Duopoly with Heterogeneous Availability

Authors: Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Saswati Sarkar

Abstract: We study the price competition in a duopoly with an arbitrary number of buyers. Each seller can offer multiple units of a commodity depending on the availability of the commodity which is random and may be different for different sellers. Sellers seek to select a price that will be attractive to the buyers and also fetch adequate profits. The selection will in general depend on the number of units… ▽ More We study the price competition in a duopoly with an arbitrary number of buyers. Each seller can offer multiple units of a commodity depending on the availability of the commodity which is random and may be different for different sellers. Sellers seek to select a price that will be attractive to the buyers and also fetch adequate profits. The selection will in general depend on the number of units available with the seller and also that of its competitor - the seller may only know the statistics of the latter. The setting captures a secondary spectrum access network, a non-neutral Internet, or a microgrid network in which unused spectrum bands, resources of ISPs, and excess power units constitute the respective commodities of sale. We analyze this price competition as a game, and identify a set of necessary and sufficient properties for the Nash Equilibrium (NE). The properties reveal that sellers randomize their price using probability distributions whose support sets are mutually disjoint and in decreasing order of the number of availability. We prove the uniqueness of a symmetric NE in a symmetric market, and explicitly compute the price distribution in the symmetric NE. △ Less

Submitted 16 June, 2015; v1 submitted 29 March, 2014; originally announced March 2014.

Comments: 45 pages, Accepted for publication in IEEE Transaction on Automatic Control

Market-Based Power Allocation for a Differentially Priced FDMA System

Authors: Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, George Kesidis, Saswati Sarkar

Abstract: In this paper, we study the problem of differential pricing and QoS assignment by a broadband data provider. In our model, the broadband data provider decides on the power allocated to an end-user not only based on parameters of the transmission medium, but also based on the price the user is willing to pay. In addition, end-users bid the price that they are willing to pay to the BTS based on thei… ▽ More In this paper, we study the problem of differential pricing and QoS assignment by a broadband data provider. In our model, the broadband data provider decides on the power allocated to an end-user not only based on parameters of the transmission medium, but also based on the price the user is willing to pay. In addition, end-users bid the price that they are willing to pay to the BTS based on their channel condition, the throughput they require, and their belief about other users' parameters. We will characterize the optimum power allocation by the BTS which turns out to be a modification of the solution to the well-known water-filling problem. We also characterize the optimum bidding strategy of end-users using the belief of each user about the cell condition. △ Less

Submitted 30 September, 2014; v1 submitted 13 February, 2014; originally announced February 2014.

Comments: 5 Pages, 2 Figures, Conference Publication

LORD: Leader-based framework for Resource Discovery in Mobile Device Clouds

Authors: Seyed Mohammad Asghari, Yi-Hsuan Kao, Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Mohammad Noormohammadpour, Bhaskar Krishnamachari, Babak Hossein Khalaj, Marcos Katz

Abstract: We provide a novel solution for Resource Discovery (RD) in mobile device clouds consisting of selfish nodes. Mobile device clouds (MDCs) refer to cooperative arrangement of communication-capable devices formed with resource-sharing goal in mind. Our work is motivated by the observation that with ever-growing applications of MDCs, it is essential to quickly locate resources offered in such clouds,… ▽ More We provide a novel solution for Resource Discovery (RD) in mobile device clouds consisting of selfish nodes. Mobile device clouds (MDCs) refer to cooperative arrangement of communication-capable devices formed with resource-sharing goal in mind. Our work is motivated by the observation that with ever-growing applications of MDCs, it is essential to quickly locate resources offered in such clouds, where the resources could be content, computing resources, or communication resources. The current approaches for RD can be categorized into two models: decentralized model, where RD is handled by each node individually; and centralized model, where RD is assisted by centralized entities like cellular network. However, we propose LORD, a Leader-based framewOrk for RD in MDCs which is not only self-organized and not prone to having a single point of failure like the centralized model, but also is able to balance the energy consumption among MDC participants better than the decentralized model. Moreover, we provide a credit-based incentive to motivate participation of selfish nodes in the leader selection process, and present the first energy-aware leader selection mechanism for credit-based models. The simulation results demonstrate that LORD balances energy consumption among nodes and prolongs overall network lifetime compared to decentralized model. △ Less

Submitted 16 April, 2017; v1 submitted 5 August, 2013; originally announced August 2013.