Showing 1–36 of 36 results for author: Loebbert, F

Geometry from Integrability: Multi-Leg Fishnet Integrals in Two Dimensions

Authors: Claude Duhr, Albrecht Klemm, Florian Loebbert, Christoph Nega, Franziska Porkert

Abstract: We generalise the geometric analysis of square fishnet integrals in two dimensions to the case of hexagonal fishnets with three-point vertices. Our results support the conjecture that fishnet Feynman integrals in two dimensions, together with their associated geometry, are completely fixed by their Yangian and permutation symmetries. As a new feature for the hexagonal fishnets, the star-triangle i… ▽ More We generalise the geometric analysis of square fishnet integrals in two dimensions to the case of hexagonal fishnets with three-point vertices. Our results support the conjecture that fishnet Feynman integrals in two dimensions, together with their associated geometry, are completely fixed by their Yangian and permutation symmetries. As a new feature for the hexagonal fishnets, the star-triangle identity introduces an ambiguity in the graph representation of a given Feynman integral. This translates into a map between different geometric interpretations attached to a graph. We demonstrate explicitly how these fishnet integrals can be understood as Calabi-Yau varieties, whose Picard-Fuchs ideals are generated by the Yangian over the conformal algebra. In analogy to elliptic curves, which represent the simplest examples of fishnet integrals with four-point vertices, we find that the simplest examples of three-point fishnets correspond to Picard curves with natural generalisations at higher loop orders. △ Less

Submitted 27 June, 2024; v1 submitted 29 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: 51 pages, v2: section 3.5 improved, typos corrected

Report number: BONN-TH-2024-04, TUM-HEP-1498/24

The Basso-Dixon Formula and Calabi-Yau Geometry

Authors: Claude Duhr, Albrecht Klemm, Florian Loebbert, Christoph Nega, Franziska Porkert

Abstract: We analyse the family of Calabi-Yau varieties attached to four-point fishnet integrals in two dimensions. We find that the Picard-Fuchs operators for fishnet integrals are exterior powers of the Picard-Fuchs operators for ladder integrals. This implies that the periods of the Calabi-Yau varieties for fishnet integrals can be written as determinants of periods for ladder integrals. The representati… ▽ More We analyse the family of Calabi-Yau varieties attached to four-point fishnet integrals in two dimensions. We find that the Picard-Fuchs operators for fishnet integrals are exterior powers of the Picard-Fuchs operators for ladder integrals. This implies that the periods of the Calabi-Yau varieties for fishnet integrals can be written as determinants of periods for ladder integrals. The representation theory of the geometric monodromy group plays an important role in this context. We then show how the determinant form of the periods immediately leads to the well-known Basso-Dixon formula for four-point fishnet integrals in two dimensions. Notably, the relation to Calabi-Yau geometry implies that the volume is also expressible via a determinant formula of Basso-Dixon type. Finally, we show how the fishnet integrals can be written in terms of iterated integrals naturally attached to the Calabi-Yau varieties. △ Less

Submitted 25 March, 2024; v1 submitted 12 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 42 pages, v2: typos corrected, references updated

Report number: BONN-TH-2023-08, TUM-HEP-1470-23

Integrability for Feynman Integrals

Authors: Florian Loebbert

Abstract: We give a brief overview of the Yangian symmetry of Feynman integrals. After a short introduction to the Yangian and integrability, we motivate the emergence of integrable structures for Feynman integrals via the fishnet limit of AdS/CFT. We discuss the resulting Yangian differential equations for massless fishnets in four dimensions as well as generalizations to massive propagators and generic di… ▽ More We give a brief overview of the Yangian symmetry of Feynman integrals. After a short introduction to the Yangian and integrability, we motivate the emergence of integrable structures for Feynman integrals via the fishnet limit of AdS/CFT. We discuss the resulting Yangian differential equations for massless fishnets in four dimensions as well as generalizations to massive propagators and generic dimensions. We also comment on the relation to momentum space conformal symmetry and on examples in dimensional regularization. Finally we sketch the recent application to fishnet integrals in two spacetime dimensions and the curious identification of Yangian invariants with period integrals of Calabi-Yau geometries. △ Less

Submitted 2 February, 2023; v1 submitted 19 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Comments: 15 pages, Plenary talk at GROUP34 - The 34th International Colloquium on Group Theoretical Methods in Physics, 18-22 July 2022, Strasbourg, France. Submitted to Scipost Proceedings. v2: references added

Report number: BONN-TH-2022-25

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. Proc. 14, 008 (2023)

Yangian-invariant fishnet integrals in 2 dimensions as volumes of Calabi-Yau varieties

Authors: Claude Duhr, Albrecht Klemm, Florian Loebbert, Christoph Nega, Franziska Porkert

Abstract: We argue that $\ell$-loop Yangian-invariant fishnet integrals in 2 dimensions are connected to a family of Calabi-Yau $\ell$-folds. The value of the integral can be computed from the periods of the Calabi-Yau, while the Yangian generators provide its Picard-Fuchs differential ideal. Using mirror symmetry, we can identify the value of the integral as the quantum volume of the mirror Calabi-Yau. We… ▽ More We argue that $\ell$-loop Yangian-invariant fishnet integrals in 2 dimensions are connected to a family of Calabi-Yau $\ell$-folds. The value of the integral can be computed from the periods of the Calabi-Yau, while the Yangian generators provide its Picard-Fuchs differential ideal. Using mirror symmetry, we can identify the value of the integral as the quantum volume of the mirror Calabi-Yau. We find that, similar to what happens in string theory, for $\ell=1$ and 2 the value of the integral agrees with the classical volume of the mirror, but starting from $\ell=3$, the classical volume gets corrected by instanton contributions. We illustrate these claims on several examples, and we use them to provide for the first time results for 2- and 3-loop Yangian-invariant traintrack integrals in 2 dimensions for arbitrary external kinematics. △ Less

Submitted 12 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: 6 pages, 2 figures

Report number: BONN-TH-2022-19

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.Lett. 130 (2023) 4, 041602

Yangian Ward Identities for Fishnet Four-Point Integrals

Authors: Luke Corcoran, Florian Loebbert, Julian Miczajka

Abstract: We derive and study Yangian Ward identities for the infinite class of four-point ladder integrals and their Basso-Dixon generalisations. These symmetry equations follow from interpreting the respective Feynman integrals as correlation functions in the bi-scalar fishnet theory. Alternatively, the presented identities can be understood as anomaly equations for a momentum space conformal symmetry. Th… ▽ More We derive and study Yangian Ward identities for the infinite class of four-point ladder integrals and their Basso-Dixon generalisations. These symmetry equations follow from interpreting the respective Feynman integrals as correlation functions in the bi-scalar fishnet theory. Alternatively, the presented identities can be understood as anomaly equations for a momentum space conformal symmetry. The Ward identities take the form of inhomogeneous extensions of the partial differential equations defining the Appell hypergeometric functions. We employ a manifestly conformal tensor reduction in order to express these inhomogeneities in compact form, which are given by linear combinations of Basso-Dixon integrals with shifted dimensions and propagator powers. The Ward identities naturally generalise to a one-parameter family of D-dimensional integrals representing correlators in the generalised fishnet theory of Kazakov and Olivucci. When specified to two spacetime dimensions, the Yangian Ward identities decouple. Using separation of variables, we explicitly bootstrap the solution for the conformal 2D box integral. The result is a linear combination of Yangian invariant products of Legendre functions, which reduce to elliptic K integrals for an isotropic choice of propagator powers. We comment on differences in the transcendentality patterns in two and four dimensions and their relations to discontinuities. △ Less

Submitted 21 April, 2022; v1 submitted 13 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: 50 pages, many figures, v2: minor improvements and corrections

Report number: HU-EP-21/54, SAGEX-21-38-E

Journal ref: JHEP 04 (2022) 131

Irrelevant Deformations with Boundaries and Defects

Authors: Yunfeng Jiang, Florian Loebbert, De-liang Zhong

Abstract: We initiate the study of $T\bar T$-like irrelevant solvable deformations in quantum field theory with boundaries and defects. For this purpose, we employ a general formalism developed in the context of spin chains, which allows us to derive both, the deformed bulk and boundary/defect scattering matrices of integrable models. Using the deformed scattering matrices, we derive the flow equation for t… ▽ More We initiate the study of $T\bar T$-like irrelevant solvable deformations in quantum field theory with boundaries and defects. For this purpose, we employ a general formalism developed in the context of spin chains, which allows us to derive both, the deformed bulk and boundary/defect scattering matrices of integrable models. Using the deformed scattering matrices, we derive the flow equation for the deformed finite volume spectrum, as well as the cylinder partition function and the exact $g$-function. △ Less

Submitted 27 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: 61 pages, 6 figures

Report number: HU-EP-21/37

Massive Integrability: From Fishnet Theories to Feynman Graphs and Back

Authors: Florian Loebbert, Julian Miczajka

Abstract: An overview of the massive generalization of Yangian symmetry for Feynman integrals is given. We illustrate the relation to a massive fishnet theory defined as a double-scaling limit of Coulomb-branch N=4 SYM theory. An overview of the massive generalization of Yangian symmetry for Feynman integrals is given. We illustrate the relation to a massive fishnet theory defined as a double-scaling limit of Coulomb-branch N=4 SYM theory. △ Less

Submitted 24 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: 6 Pages, Contribution to the Proceedings of the European Physical Society Conference on High Energy Physics (EPS-HEP2021), 26-30 July 2021

Report number: HU-EP-21/36

Three-Body Effective Potential in General Relativity at Second Post-Minkowskian Order and Resulting Post-Newtonian Contributions

Authors: Florian Loebbert, Jan Plefka, Canxin Shi, Tianheng Wang

Abstract: We study the Post-Minkowskian (PM) and Post-Newtonian (PN) expansions of the gravitational three-body effective potential. At order 2PM a formal result is given in terms of a differential operator acting on the maximal generalized cut of the one-loop triangle integral. We compute the integral in all kinematic regions and show that the leading terms in the PN expansion are reproduced. We then perfo… ▽ More We study the Post-Minkowskian (PM) and Post-Newtonian (PN) expansions of the gravitational three-body effective potential. At order 2PM a formal result is given in terms of a differential operator acting on the maximal generalized cut of the one-loop triangle integral. We compute the integral in all kinematic regions and show that the leading terms in the PN expansion are reproduced. We then perform the PN expansion unambiguously at the level of the integrand. Finding agreement with the 2PN three-body potential after integration, we explicitly present new $G^2v^4$-contributions at order 3PN and outline the generalization to $G^2v^{2n}$. The integrals that represent the essential input for these results are obtained by applying the recent Yangian bootstrap directly to their $ε$-expansion around three dimensions. The coordinate space Yangian generator that we employ to obtain these integrals can be understood as a special conformal symmetry in a dual momentum space. △ Less

Submitted 9 March, 2021; v1 submitted 28 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: 15 pages, 5 figures, 1 ancillary machine-readable file, v2: minor improvements and additions, title adapted to journal title

Report number: HU-EP-20/44, SAGEX-20-30-E

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 103, 064010 (2021)

Minkowski Box from Yangian Bootstrap

Authors: Luke Corcoran, Florian Loebbert, Julian Miczajka, Matthias Staudacher

Abstract: We extend the recently developed Yangian bootstrap for Feynman integrals to Minkowski space, focusing on the case of the one-loop box integral. The space of Yangian invariants is spanned by the Bloch-Wigner function and its discontinuities. Using only input from symmetries, we constrain the functional form of the box integral in all 64 kinematic regions up to twelve (out of a priori 256) undetermi… ▽ More We extend the recently developed Yangian bootstrap for Feynman integrals to Minkowski space, focusing on the case of the one-loop box integral. The space of Yangian invariants is spanned by the Bloch-Wigner function and its discontinuities. Using only input from symmetries, we constrain the functional form of the box integral in all 64 kinematic regions up to twelve (out of a priori 256) undetermined constants. These need to be fixed by other means. We do this explicitly, employing two alternative methods. This results in a novel compact formula for the box integral valid in all kinematic regions of Minkowski space. △ Less

Submitted 14 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: 21 pages

Report number: HU-Mathematik-2020-07, HU-EP-20/38, SAGEX-20-27-E

Yangian Bootstrap for Massive Feynman Integrals

Authors: Florian Loebbert, Julian Miczajka, Dennis Müller, Hagen Münkler

Abstract: We extend the study of the recently discovered Yangian symmetry of massive Feynman integrals and its relation to massive momentum space conformal symmetry. After proving the symmetry statements in detail at one and two loop orders, we employ the conformal and Yangian constraints to bootstrap various one-loop examples of massive Feynman integrals. In particular, we explore the interplay between Yan… ▽ More We extend the study of the recently discovered Yangian symmetry of massive Feynman integrals and its relation to massive momentum space conformal symmetry. After proving the symmetry statements in detail at one and two loop orders, we employ the conformal and Yangian constraints to bootstrap various one-loop examples of massive Feynman integrals. In particular, we explore the interplay between Yangian symmetry and hypergeometric expressions of the considered integrals. Based on these examples we conjecture single series representations for all dual conformal one-loop integrals in D spacetime dimensions with generic massive propagators. △ Less

Submitted 16 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

Comments: 61 pages

Report number: HU-EP-20/27

Journal ref: SciPost Phys. 11, 010 (2021)

Massive Fishnets

Authors: Florian Loebbert, Julian Miczajka

Abstract: Recently, infinite families of massive Feynman integrals were found to feature an unexpected Yangian symmetry. In the massless case, similar integrability properties are understood via the interpretation of individual Feynman integrals as correlators in the massless fishnet theory introduced by Gürdoğan and Kazakov. Here we seek for an analogous interpretation of the integrability of massive Feynm… ▽ More Recently, infinite families of massive Feynman integrals were found to feature an unexpected Yangian symmetry. In the massless case, similar integrability properties are understood via the interpretation of individual Feynman integrals as correlators in the massless fishnet theory introduced by Gürdoğan and Kazakov. Here we seek for an analogous interpretation of the integrability of massive Feynman integrals. We contrast two approaches to define simple massive quantum field theories in four dimensions. First, we discuss spontaneous symmetry breaking in the massless bi-scalar fishnet theory. We then propose an alternative route to a massive fishnet theory by taking a double-scaling limit of N=4 SYM theory on the Coulomb branch. Both approaches lead to a massive extension of the massless fishnet theory, differing in how masses enter into the propagators. In the latter theory, planar off-shell amplitudes are in one-to-one correspondence with precisely those massive Feynman integrals that were shown to be invariant under the Yangian. This suggests a re-investigation of Coulomb branch N=4 SYM theory with regard to integrability. Finally, we demonstrate that in the case of spontaneous symmetry breaking, the original conformal symmetry leads to soft theorems for scattering amplitudes in the broken phase. △ Less

Submitted 13 January, 2021; v1 submitted 26 August, 2020; originally announced August 2020.

Comments: 32 pages, v2: figure 1 and sign in eq (3.3) corrected, v3: minor improvements, signs in (3.6),(3.19) and (C.1) corrected

Report number: HU-EP-20/21

Journal ref: JHEP 12 (2020) 197

Massive Conformal Symmetry and Integrability for Feynman Integrals

Authors: Florian Loebbert, Julian Miczajka, Dennis Müller, Hagen Münkler

Abstract: In the context of planar holography, integrability plays an important role for solving certain massless quantum field theories such as N=4 SYM theory. In this letter we show that integrability also features in the building blocks of massive quantum field theories. At one-loop order we prove that all massive n-gon Feynman integrals in generic spacetime dimensions are invariant under a massive Yangi… ▽ More In the context of planar holography, integrability plays an important role for solving certain massless quantum field theories such as N=4 SYM theory. In this letter we show that integrability also features in the building blocks of massive quantum field theories. At one-loop order we prove that all massive n-gon Feynman integrals in generic spacetime dimensions are invariant under a massive Yangian symmetry. At two loops similar statements can be proven for graphs built from two n-gons. At generic loop order we conjecture that all graphs cut from regular tilings of the plane with massive propagators on the boundary are invariant. We support this conjecture by a number of numerical tests for higher loops and legs. The observed Yangian extends the bosonic part of the massive dual conformal symmetry that was found a decade ago on the Coulomb branch of N=4 SYM theory. By translating the Yangian level-one generators from dual to original momentum space, we introduce a massive generalization of momentum space conformal symmetry. Even for non-dual conformal integrals this novel symmetry persists. The Yangian can thus be understood as the closure of massive dual conformal symmetry and this new massive momentum space conformal symmetry, which suggests an interpretation via AdS/CFT. As an application of our findings, we bootstrap the hypergeometric building blocks for examples of massive Feynman integrals. △ Less

Submitted 20 October, 2020; v1 submitted 4 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Comments: 6 pages, v2: typos corrected, clarifications added, v3: minor improvements/corrections, title adapted to journal title, v4: signs in (11) and (23) and prefactors in (22) and footnote [20] corrected

Report number: HU-EP-20/11

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 091602 (2020)

Yangian Bootstrap for Conformal Feynman Integrals

Authors: Florian Loebbert, Dennis Müller, Hagen Münkler

Abstract: We explore the idea to bootstrap Feynman integrals using integrability. In particular, we put the recently discovered Yangian symmetry of conformal Feynman integrals to work. As a prototypical example we demonstrate that the D-dimensional box integral with generic propagator powers is completely fixed by its symmetries to be a particular linear combination of Appell hypergeometric functions. In th… ▽ More We explore the idea to bootstrap Feynman integrals using integrability. In particular, we put the recently discovered Yangian symmetry of conformal Feynman integrals to work. As a prototypical example we demonstrate that the D-dimensional box integral with generic propagator powers is completely fixed by its symmetries to be a particular linear combination of Appell hypergeometric functions. In this context the Bloch-Wigner function arises as a special Yangian invariant in 4D. The bootstrap procedure for the box integral is naturally structured in algorithmic form. We then discuss the Yangian constraints for the six-point double box integral as well as for the related hexagon. For the latter we argue that the constraints are solved by a set of generalized Lauricella functions and we comment on complications in identifying the integral as a certain linear combination of these. Finally, we elaborate on the close relation to the Mellin-Barnes technique and argue that it generates Yangian invariants as sums of residues. △ Less

Submitted 19 January, 2021; v1 submitted 11 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Comments: 20 pages, v2: minor improvements

Report number: HU-EP-19/39

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 101, 066006 (2020)

Nonlocal Symmetries and Factorized Scattering

Authors: Florian Loebbert, Anne Spiering

Abstract: Conventionally, factorized scattering in two dimensions is argued to be a consequence of the conservation of local higher charges. However, integrability may well be realized via nonlocal charges, while higher local charges are not known. Here we address the question of whether a nonlocal Yangian symmetry implies factorized scattering of the S-matrix. We explicitly study the constraints on three-p… ▽ More Conventionally, factorized scattering in two dimensions is argued to be a consequence of the conservation of local higher charges. However, integrability may well be realized via nonlocal charges, while higher local charges are not known. Here we address the question of whether a nonlocal Yangian symmetry implies factorized scattering of the S-matrix. We explicitly study the constraints on three-particle scattering processes of particles transforming in the fundamental representations of su(N), u(1|1), and the centrally extended su(2|2) underlying the dynamic scattering and hexagon form factors in AdS/CFT. These considerations shed light on the role of the Yangian as an axiomatic input for the bootstrap program for integrable theories. △ Less

Submitted 14 August, 2018; v1 submitted 30 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Comments: 33 pages, v2: incorrect argument on conservation of rapidities removed, table 2 updated, some discussions improved

Report number: TCDMATH 18-07, HU-EP-18/17

Journal ref: J. Phys. A51 (2018) 485202

Consistent Conformal Extensions of the Standard Model

Authors: Florian Loebbert, Julian Miczajka, Jan Plefka

Abstract: The question of whether classically conformal modifications of the standard model are consistent with experimental obervations has recently been subject to renewed interest. The method of Gildener and Weinberg provides a natural framework for the study of the effective potential of the resulting multi-scalar standard model extensions. This approach relies on the assumption of the ordinary loop hie… ▽ More The question of whether classically conformal modifications of the standard model are consistent with experimental obervations has recently been subject to renewed interest. The method of Gildener and Weinberg provides a natural framework for the study of the effective potential of the resulting multi-scalar standard model extensions. This approach relies on the assumption of the ordinary loop hierarchy $λ_\text{s} \sim g^2_\text{g}$ of scalar and gauge couplings. On the other hand, Andreassen, Frost and Schwartz recently argued that in the (single-scalar) standard model, gauge invariant results require the consistent scaling $λ_\text{s} \sim g^4_\text{g}$. In the present paper we contrast these two hierarchy assumptions and illustrate the differences in the phenomenological predictions of minimal conformal extensions of the standard model. △ Less

Submitted 6 June, 2018; v1 submitted 24 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Comments: 20 pages, 19 figures. v2: Typo in (3.3) corrected, references added

Report number: HU-EP-18/16, CERN-TH-2018-125

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 99, 015026 (2019)

Hidden Conformal Symmetry in Tree-Level Graviton Scattering

Authors: Florian Loebbert, Matin Mojaza, Jan Plefka

Abstract: We argue that the scattering of gravitons in ordinary Einstein gravity possesses a hidden conformal symmetry at tree level in any number of dimensions. The presence of this conformal symmetry is indicated by the dilaton soft theorem in string theory, and it is reminiscent of the conformal invariance of gluon tree-level amplitudes in four dimensions. To motivate the underlying prescription, we demo… ▽ More We argue that the scattering of gravitons in ordinary Einstein gravity possesses a hidden conformal symmetry at tree level in any number of dimensions. The presence of this conformal symmetry is indicated by the dilaton soft theorem in string theory, and it is reminiscent of the conformal invariance of gluon tree-level amplitudes in four dimensions. To motivate the underlying prescription, we demonstrate that formulating the conformal symmetry of gluon amplitudes in terms of momenta and polarization vectors requires manifest reversal and cyclic symmetry. Similarly, our formulation of the conformal symmetry of graviton amplitudes relies on a manifestly permutation symmetric form of the amplitude function. △ Less

Submitted 16 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Comments: 35 pages, 3 figures

Report number: HU-EP-18/03

Yangian Symmetry for Fishnet Feynman Graphs

Authors: Dmitry Chicherin, Vladimir Kazakov, Florian Loebbert, Dennis Müller, De-liang Zhong

Abstract: Various classes of fishnet Feynman graphs are shown to feature a Yangian symmetry over the conformal algebra. We explicitly discuss scalar graphs in three, four and six spacetime dimensions as well as the inclusion of fermions in four dimensions. The Yangian symmetry results in novel differential equations for these families of largely unsolved Feynman integrals. Notably, the considered fishnet gr… ▽ More Various classes of fishnet Feynman graphs are shown to feature a Yangian symmetry over the conformal algebra. We explicitly discuss scalar graphs in three, four and six spacetime dimensions as well as the inclusion of fermions in four dimensions. The Yangian symmetry results in novel differential equations for these families of largely unsolved Feynman integrals. Notably, the considered fishnet graphs in three and four dimensions dominate the correlation functions and scattering amplitudes in specific double scaling limits of planar, gamma-twisted N=4 super Yang-Mills or ABJM theory. Consequently, the study of fishnet graphs allows us to get deep insights into the integrability of the planar AdS/CFT correspondence. △ Less

Submitted 31 July, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Comments: 6 pages, 5 figures

Report number: MITP/17-049, HU-EP-17/20, LPTENS/17/32

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 96, 121901 (2017)

Yangian Symmetry for Bi-Scalar Loop Amplitudes

Authors: Dmitry Chicherin, Vladimir Kazakov, Florian Loebbert, Dennis Müller, De-liang Zhong

Abstract: We establish an all-loop conformal Yangian symmetry for the full set of planar amplitudes in the recently proposed integrable bi-scalar field theory in four dimensions. This chiral theory is a particular double scaling limit of gamma-twisted weakly coupled N=4 SYM theory. Each amplitude with a certain order of scalar particles is given by a single fishnet Feynman graph of disc topology cut out of… ▽ More We establish an all-loop conformal Yangian symmetry for the full set of planar amplitudes in the recently proposed integrable bi-scalar field theory in four dimensions. This chiral theory is a particular double scaling limit of gamma-twisted weakly coupled N=4 SYM theory. Each amplitude with a certain order of scalar particles is given by a single fishnet Feynman graph of disc topology cut out of a regular square lattice. The Yangian can be realized by the action of a product of Lax operators with a specific sequence of inhomogeneity parameters on the boundary of the disc. Based on this observation, the Yangian generators of level one for generic bi-scalar amplitudes are explicitly constructed. Finally, we comment on the relation to the dual conformal symmetry of these scattering amplitudes. △ Less

Submitted 6 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Comments: 40 pages, 20 figures

Report number: HU-EP-17/09, LPTENS/17/07, MITP/17-022

Journal ref: JHEP05(2018)003

Two-Loop SL(2) Form Factors and Maximal Transcendentality

Authors: Florian Loebbert, Christoph Sieg, Matthias Wilhelm, Gang Yang

Abstract: Form factors of composite operators in the SL(2) sector of N=4 SYM theory are studied up to two loops via the on-shell unitarity method. The non-compactness of this subsector implies the novel feature and technical challenge of an unlimited number of loop momenta in the integrand's numerator. At one loop, we derive the full minimal form factor to all orders in the dimensional regularisation parame… ▽ More Form factors of composite operators in the SL(2) sector of N=4 SYM theory are studied up to two loops via the on-shell unitarity method. The non-compactness of this subsector implies the novel feature and technical challenge of an unlimited number of loop momenta in the integrand's numerator. At one loop, we derive the full minimal form factor to all orders in the dimensional regularisation parameter. At two loops, we construct the complete integrand for composite operators with an arbitrary number of covariant derivatives, and we obtain the remainder functions as well as the dilatation operator for composite operators with up to three covariant derivatives. The remainder functions reveal curious patterns suggesting a hidden maximal uniform transcendentality for the full form factor. Finally, we speculate about an extension of these patterns to QCD. △ Less

Submitted 4 January, 2017; v1 submitted 20 October, 2016; originally announced October 2016.

Comments: 23+13 pages, v2: minor changes, published version

Report number: HU-MATH-2016-17, HU-EP-16/31

Journal ref: JHEP 1612 (2016) 090

Nonlocal Symmetries, Spectral Parameter and Minimal Surfaces in AdS/CFT

Authors: Thomas Klose, Florian Loebbert, Hagen Münkler

Abstract: We give a general account of nonlocal symmetries in symmetric space models and their relation to the AdS/CFT correspondence. In particular, we study a master symmetry which generates the spectral parameter and acts as a level-raising operator on the classical Yangian generators. The master symmetry extends to an infinite tower of symmetries with nonlocal Casimir elements as associated conserved ch… ▽ More We give a general account of nonlocal symmetries in symmetric space models and their relation to the AdS/CFT correspondence. In particular, we study a master symmetry which generates the spectral parameter and acts as a level-raising operator on the classical Yangian generators. The master symmetry extends to an infinite tower of symmetries with nonlocal Casimir elements as associated conserved charges. We discuss the algebraic properties of these symmetries and establish their role in explaining the recently observed one-parameter deformation of holographic Wilson loops. Finally, we provide a numerical framework, in which discretized minimal surfaces and their master symmetry deformation can be calculated. △ Less

Submitted 5 May, 2018; v1 submitted 4 October, 2016; originally announced October 2016.

Comments: 50 pages, 8 figures, v2: minor changes, published version, v3: signs in (B.16) and (5.8) and coefficients in (5.12) corrected, footnote 4 added

Report number: HU-EP-16/30

Journal ref: Nucl.Phys. B916 (2017) 320-372

Master Symmetry for Holographic Wilson Loops

Authors: Thomas Klose, Florian Loebbert, Hagen Munkler

Abstract: We identify the symmetry underlying the recently observed spectral-parameter transformations of holographic Wilson loops alias minimal surfaces in AdS/CFT. The generator of this nonlocal symmetry is shown to furnish a raising operator on the classical Yangian-type charges of symmetric coset models. We explicitly demonstrate how this master symmetry acts on strong-coupling Wilson loops and indicate… ▽ More We identify the symmetry underlying the recently observed spectral-parameter transformations of holographic Wilson loops alias minimal surfaces in AdS/CFT. The generator of this nonlocal symmetry is shown to furnish a raising operator on the classical Yangian-type charges of symmetric coset models. We explicitly demonstrate how this master symmetry acts on strong-coupling Wilson loops and indicate a possible extension to arbitrary coupling. △ Less

Submitted 5 May, 2018; v1 submitted 13 June, 2016; originally announced June 2016.

Comments: 5 pages, 1 table, 1 figure, v2: plots added, slight rewriting v3: definition of deltahat below (28) corrected

Report number: HU-EP-16/17

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 94, 066006 (2016)

Lectures on Yangian Symmetry

Authors: Florian Loebbert

Abstract: In these introductory lectures we discuss the topic of Yangian symmetry from various perspectives. Forming the classical counterpart of the Yangian and an extension of ordinary Noether symmetries, first the concept of nonlocal charges in classical, two-dimensional field theory is reviewed. We then define the Yangian algebra following Drinfeld's original motivation to construct solutions to the qua… ▽ More In these introductory lectures we discuss the topic of Yangian symmetry from various perspectives. Forming the classical counterpart of the Yangian and an extension of ordinary Noether symmetries, first the concept of nonlocal charges in classical, two-dimensional field theory is reviewed. We then define the Yangian algebra following Drinfeld's original motivation to construct solutions to the quantum Yang-Baxter equation. Different realizations of the Yangian and its mathematical role as a Hopf algebra and quantum group are discussed. We demonstrate how the Yangian algebra is implemented in quantum, two-dimensional field theories and how its generators are renormalized. Implications of Yangian symmetry on the two-dimensional scattering matrix are investigated. We furthermore consider the important case of discrete Yangian symmetry realized on integrable spin chains. Finally we give a brief introduction to Yangian symmetry in planar, four-dimensional super Yang-Mills theory and indicate its impact on the dilatation operator and tree-level scattering amplitudes. These lectures are illustrated by several examples, in particular the two-dimensional chiral Gross-Neveu model, the Heisenberg spin chain and N=4 superconformal Yang-Mills theory in four dimensions. This review arose from lectures given at the Young Researchers Integrability School at Durham University (UK). △ Less

Submitted 26 July, 2016; v1 submitted 9 June, 2016; originally announced June 2016.

Comments: 75 pages, v2: references added, typos corrected

Report number: HU-EP-16/12

Journal ref: J.Phys. A49 (2016) no.32, 323002

An Integrability Primer for the Gauge-Gravity Correspondence: an Introduction

Authors: Diego Bombardelli, Alessandra Cagnazzo, Rouven Frassek, Fedor Levkovich-Maslyuk, Florian Loebbert, Stefano Negro, Istvan M. Szécsényi, Alessandro Sfondrini, Stijn J. van Tongeren, Alessandro Torrielli

Abstract: We introduce a series of articles reviewing various aspects of integrable models relevant to the AdS/CFT correspondence. Topics covered in these reviews are: classical integrability, Yangian symmetry, factorized scattering, the Bethe ansatz, the thermodynamic Bethe ansatz, and integrable structures in (conformal) quantum field theory. In the present article we highlight how these concepts have fou… ▽ More We introduce a series of articles reviewing various aspects of integrable models relevant to the AdS/CFT correspondence. Topics covered in these reviews are: classical integrability, Yangian symmetry, factorized scattering, the Bethe ansatz, the thermodynamic Bethe ansatz, and integrable structures in (conformal) quantum field theory. In the present article we highlight how these concepts have found application in AdS/CFT, and provide a brief overview of the material contained in this series. △ Less

Submitted 24 July, 2016; v1 submitted 9 June, 2016; originally announced June 2016.

Comments: v2, published version

Report number: CNRS-16/03, DCPT-16/19, DESY 16-083, DMUS-MP-16/09, HU-EP-16/13, HU-MATH-16/08, NORDITA-2016-33

Journal ref: J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 49 (2016) 320301

On-Shell Methods for the Two-Loop Dilatation Operator and Finite Remainders

Authors: Florian Loebbert, Dhritiman Nandan, Christoph Sieg, Matthias Wilhelm, Gang Yang

Abstract: We compute the two-loop minimal form factors of all operators in the SU(2) sector of planar N=4 SYM theory via on-shell unitarity methods. From the UV divergence of this result, we obtain the two-loop dilatation operator in this sector. Furthermore, we calculate the corresponding finite remainder functions. Since the operators break the supersymmetry, the remainder functions do not have the proper… ▽ More We compute the two-loop minimal form factors of all operators in the SU(2) sector of planar N=4 SYM theory via on-shell unitarity methods. From the UV divergence of this result, we obtain the two-loop dilatation operator in this sector. Furthermore, we calculate the corresponding finite remainder functions. Since the operators break the supersymmetry, the remainder functions do not have the property of uniform transcendentality. However, the leading transcendentality part turns out to be universal and is identical to the corresponding BPS expressions. The remainder functions are shown to satisfy linear relations which can be explained by Ward identities of form factors following from R-symmetry. △ Less

Submitted 5 October, 2015; v1 submitted 23 April, 2015; originally announced April 2015.

Comments: 24 pages; v2: typos corrected, some formulations clarified, matches published version

Report number: HU-MATH-2015-04, HU-EP-15/19

Journal ref: JHEP 1510 (2015) 012

Quantum Gravitational Contributions to the Standard Model Effective Potential and Vacuum Stability

Authors: Florian Loebbert, Jan Plefka

Abstract: We compute the quantum gravitational contributions to the standard model effective potential and analyze their effects on the Higgs vacuum stability in the framework of effective field theory. Non-renormalizability of Einstein gravity induces higher dimension $φ^{6}$ and $φ^{8}$ operators at the one-loop level with novel couplings $η_{1/2}$. The beta functions of these couplings are established an… ▽ More We compute the quantum gravitational contributions to the standard model effective potential and analyze their effects on the Higgs vacuum stability in the framework of effective field theory. Non-renormalizability of Einstein gravity induces higher dimension $φ^{6}$ and $φ^{8}$ operators at the one-loop level with novel couplings $η_{1/2}$. The beta functions of these couplings are established and the impact of the gravity induced contributions on electroweak vacuum stability is studied. We find that the true minimum of the standard model effective potential now lies below the Planck scale for almost the entire parameter space ($η_{1/2}(m_\text{t})> 0.01$). In addition quantum gravity is shown to contribute to the minimal value of the standard model NLO effective potential at the percent level. The quantum gravity induced contributions yield a metastable vacuum for a large fraction of the parameter space in the flowing couplings $η_{1/2}$. △ Less

Submitted 30 September, 2015; v1 submitted 10 February, 2015; originally announced February 2015.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures, v2: published version

Journal ref: Mod. Phys. Lett. A 30, 1550189 (2015)

Integrable Amplitude Deformations for N=4 Super Yang-Mills and ABJM Theory

Authors: Till Bargheer, Yu-tin Huang, Florian Loebbert, Masahito Yamazaki

Abstract: We study Yangian-invariant deformations of scattering amplitudes in 4d N=4 supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory and 3d N=6 Aharony-Bergman-Jafferis-Maldacena (ABJM) theory. In particular, we obtain the deformed Grassmannian integral for 4d N=4 super Yang-Mills theory, both in momentum and momentum-twistor space. For 3d ABJM theory, we initiate the study of deformed scattering amplitudes. We investigat… ▽ More We study Yangian-invariant deformations of scattering amplitudes in 4d N=4 supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory and 3d N=6 Aharony-Bergman-Jafferis-Maldacena (ABJM) theory. In particular, we obtain the deformed Grassmannian integral for 4d N=4 super Yang-Mills theory, both in momentum and momentum-twistor space. For 3d ABJM theory, we initiate the study of deformed scattering amplitudes. We investigate general deformations of on-shell diagrams, and find the deformed Grassmannian integral for this theory. We furthermore introduce the algebraic R-matrix construction of deformed Yangian invariants for ABJM theory. △ Less

Submitted 12 January, 2015; v1 submitted 16 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Comments: 39 pages, 9 figures; v2: references added, typos fixed, section 3.4 improved, published version

Report number: DESY 14-128, IPMU-14-0157, HU-EP-14/29

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 91, 026004 (2015)

Fixing the Quantum Three-Point Function

Authors: Yunfeng Jiang, Ivan Kostov, Florian Loebbert, Didina Serban

Abstract: We propose a new method for the computation of quantum three-point functions for operators in su(2) sectors of N=4 super Yang-Mills theory. The method is based on the existence of a unitary transformation relating inhomogeneous and long-range spin chains. This transformation can be traced back to a combination of boost operators and an inhomogeneous version of Baxter's corner transfer matrix. We r… ▽ More We propose a new method for the computation of quantum three-point functions for operators in su(2) sectors of N=4 super Yang-Mills theory. The method is based on the existence of a unitary transformation relating inhomogeneous and long-range spin chains. This transformation can be traced back to a combination of boost operators and an inhomogeneous version of Baxter's corner transfer matrix. We reproduce the existing results for the one-loop structure constants in a simplified form and indicate how to use the method at higher loop orders. Then we evaluate the one-loop structure constants in the quasiclassical limit and compare them with the recent strong coupling computation. △ Less

Submitted 30 January, 2014; v1 submitted 2 January, 2014; originally announced January 2014.

Comments: 53 pages, 3 figures, v2: typos corrected, v3: section 3.1 improved, small corrections, references added

MSC Class: 81T13; 70S15

Journal ref: JHEP 1404:019, 2014

Integrable Deformations of the XXZ Spin Chain

Authors: Niklas Beisert, Lucas Fievet, Marius de Leeuw, Florian Loebbert

Abstract: We consider integrable deformations of the XXZ spin chain for periodic and open boundary conditions. In particular, we classify all long-range deformations and study their impact on the spectrum. As compared to the XXX case, we have the z-spin at our disposal, which induces two additional deformations: the short-range magnetic twist and a new long-range momentum-dependent twist. We consider integrable deformations of the XXZ spin chain for periodic and open boundary conditions. In particular, we classify all long-range deformations and study their impact on the spectrum. As compared to the XXX case, we have the z-spin at our disposal, which induces two additional deformations: the short-range magnetic twist and a new long-range momentum-dependent twist. △ Less

Submitted 2 October, 2013; v1 submitted 7 August, 2013; originally announced August 2013.

Comments: 24 pages, v2: minor changes

Journal ref: J.Stat.Mech.1309:P09028,2013

Conformal Anomaly for Amplitudes in N=6 Superconformal Chern-Simons Theory

Authors: Till Bargheer, Niklas Beisert, Florian Loebbert, Tristan McLoughlin

Abstract: Scattering amplitudes in three-dimensional N=6 Chern-Simons theory are shown to be non-invariant with respect to the free representation of the osp(6|4) symmetry generators. At tree and one-loop level these "anomalous" terms occur only for non-generic, singular configurations of the external momenta and can be used to determine the form of the amplitudes. In particular we show that the symmetries… ▽ More Scattering amplitudes in three-dimensional N=6 Chern-Simons theory are shown to be non-invariant with respect to the free representation of the osp(6|4) symmetry generators. At tree and one-loop level these "anomalous" terms occur only for non-generic, singular configurations of the external momenta and can be used to determine the form of the amplitudes. In particular we show that the symmetries predict that the one-loop six-point amplitude is non-vanishing and confirm this by means of an explicit calculation using generalized unitarity methods. We comment on the implications of this finding for any putative Wilson loop/amplitude duality in N=6 Chern-Simons theory. △ Less

Submitted 5 November, 2012; v1 submitted 19 April, 2012; originally announced April 2012.

Comments: 29 pages, 9 figures, 1 table; v2: made section 4 more rigorous, minor improvements, references added; v3: added comment and reference on normalization, published in J.Phys.A

Report number: NSF-KITP-12-012; LPT-ENS-12-16; UUITP-10/12; AEI-2012-037

Journal ref: J. Phys. A45, 475402 (2012)

Recursion Relations for Long-Range Integrable Spin Chains with Open Boundary Conditions

Authors: Florian Loebbert

Abstract: It is well known that integrable charges for short-range (e.g. nearest-neighbor) spin chains with periodic boundary conditions can be recursively generated by a so-called boost operator. In the past, this iterative construction has been generalized to periodic long-range spin chains as they appear in the context of the gauge/gravity correspondence. Here we introduce recursion relations for open lo… ▽ More It is well known that integrable charges for short-range (e.g. nearest-neighbor) spin chains with periodic boundary conditions can be recursively generated by a so-called boost operator. In the past, this iterative construction has been generalized to periodic long-range spin chains as they appear in the context of the gauge/gravity correspondence. Here we introduce recursion relations for open long-range spin chain charges converting a short-range into a long-range integrable model. △ Less

Submitted 26 April, 2012; v1 submitted 4 January, 2012; originally announced January 2012.

Comments: 5 pages, 2 figures, v2: comments added

Report number: LPT-ENS-12-01; AEI-2012-000

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D85:086008,2012

Exact Superconformal and Yangian Symmetry of Scattering Amplitudes

Authors: Till Bargheer, Niklas Beisert, Florian Loebbert

Abstract: We review recent progress in the understanding of symmetries for scattering amplitudes in N=4 superconformal Yang-Mills theory. It is summarized how the superficial breaking of superconformal symmetry by collinear anomalies and the renormalization process can be cured at tree and loop level. This is achieved by correcting the representation of the superconformal group on amplitudes. Moreover, we c… ▽ More We review recent progress in the understanding of symmetries for scattering amplitudes in N=4 superconformal Yang-Mills theory. It is summarized how the superficial breaking of superconformal symmetry by collinear anomalies and the renormalization process can be cured at tree and loop level. This is achieved by correcting the representation of the superconformal group on amplitudes. Moreover, we comment on the Yangian symmetry of scattering amplitudes and how it inherits these correction terms from the ordinary Lie algebra symmetry. Invariants under this algebra and their relation to the Grassmannian generating function for scattering amplitudes are discussed. Finally, parallel developments in N=6 superconformal Chern-Simons theory are summarized. This article is an invited review for a special issue of Journal of Physics A devoted to Scattering Amplitudes in Gauge Theories. △ Less

Submitted 18 April, 2011; v1 submitted 4 April, 2011; originally announced April 2011.

Comments: 28 Pages, 6 Figures. Invited review for a special issue of Journal of Physics A devoted to "Scattering Amplitudes in Gauge Theories", v2: references added

Report number: AEI-2011-016; LPT ENS-11/12; UUITP-11/11

Journal ref: J. Phys. A44, 454012 (2011)

Symmetries of Tree-level Scattering Amplitudes in N=6 Superconformal Chern-Simons Theory

Authors: Till Bargheer, Florian Loebbert, Carlo Meneghelli

Abstract: Constraints of the osp(6|4) symmetry on tree-level scattering amplitudes in N=6 superconformal Chern-Simons theory are derived. Supplemented by Feynman diagram calculations, solutions to these constraints, namely the four- and six-point superamplitudes, are presented and shown to be invariant under Yangian symmetry. This introduces integrability into the amplitude sector of the theory. Constraints of the osp(6|4) symmetry on tree-level scattering amplitudes in N=6 superconformal Chern-Simons theory are derived. Supplemented by Feynman diagram calculations, solutions to these constraints, namely the four- and six-point superamplitudes, are presented and shown to be invariant under Yangian symmetry. This introduces integrability into the amplitude sector of the theory. △ Less

Submitted 6 July, 2010; v1 submitted 31 March, 2010; originally announced March 2010.

Comments: 50 pages. v2, v3: References added, minor corrections

Report number: AEI-2010-049

Journal ref: Phys.Rev.D82:045016,2010

Exacting N=4 Superconformal Symmetry

Authors: Till Bargheer, Niklas Beisert, Wellington Galleas, Florian Loebbert, Tristan McLoughlin

Abstract: Tree level scattering amplitudes in N=4 super Yang-Mills theory are almost, but not exactly invariant under the free action of the N=4 superconformal algebra. What causes the non-invariance is the holomorphic anomaly at poles where external particles become collinear. In this paper we propose a deformation of the free superconformal representation by contributions which change the number of exte… ▽ More Tree level scattering amplitudes in N=4 super Yang-Mills theory are almost, but not exactly invariant under the free action of the N=4 superconformal algebra. What causes the non-invariance is the holomorphic anomaly at poles where external particles become collinear. In this paper we propose a deformation of the free superconformal representation by contributions which change the number of external legs. This modified classical representation not only makes tree amplitudes fully invariant, but it also leads to additional constraints from symmetry alone mediating between hitherto unrelated amplitudes. Moreover, in a constructive approach it appears to fully constrain all tree amplitudes when combined with dual superconformal alias Yangian symmetry. △ Less

Submitted 2 November, 2009; v1 submitted 22 May, 2009; originally announced May 2009.

Comments: 47 pages. v2: minor corrections, clarifications and additions; algebraic derivation of {S,Sbar}=K, v3: section 4.4 restored (it was dropped by mistake in v2), minor corrections, to appear in JHEP

Report number: AEI-2009-048

Journal ref: JHEP 0911:056,2009

Long-Range Deformations for Integrable Spin Chains

Authors: Till Bargheer, Niklas Beisert, Florian Loebbert

Abstract: We present a recursion relation for the explicit construction of integrable spin chain Hamiltonians with long-range interactions. Based on arbitrary short-range (e.g. nearest-neighbor) integrable spin chains, it allows to construct an infinite set of conserved long-range charges. We explain the moduli space of deformation parameters by different classes of generating operators. The rapidity map an… ▽ More We present a recursion relation for the explicit construction of integrable spin chain Hamiltonians with long-range interactions. Based on arbitrary short-range (e.g. nearest-neighbor) integrable spin chains, it allows to construct an infinite set of conserved long-range charges. We explain the moduli space of deformation parameters by different classes of generating operators. The rapidity map and dressing phase in the long-range Bethe equations are a result of these deformations. The closed chain asymptotic Bethe equations for long-range spin chains transforming under a generic symmetry algebra are derived. Notably, our construction applies to generalizations of standard nearest-neighbor chains such as alternating spin chains. We also discuss relevant properties for its application to planar D=4, N=4 and D=3, N=6 supersymmetric gauge theories. Finally, we present a map between long-range and inhomogeneous spin chains delivering more insight into the structures of these models as well as their limitations at wrap** order. △ Less

Submitted 5 March, 2013; v1 submitted 5 February, 2009; originally announced February 2009.

Comments: 63 pages, v2: references added, v3: typos corrected in eqs (8.20) and (8.24)

Report number: AEI-2009-009

Journal ref: J.Phys.A42:285205,2009

Boosting Nearest-Neighbour to Long-Range Integrable Spin Chains

Authors: Till Bargheer, Niklas Beisert, Florian Loebbert

Abstract: We present an integrability-preserving recursion relation for the explicit construction of long-range spin chain Hamiltonians. These chains are generalizations of the Haldane-Shastry and Inozemtsev models and they play an important role in recent advances in string/gauge duality. The method is based on arbitrary nearest-neighbour integrable spin chains and it sheds light on the moduli space of def… ▽ More We present an integrability-preserving recursion relation for the explicit construction of long-range spin chain Hamiltonians. These chains are generalizations of the Haldane-Shastry and Inozemtsev models and they play an important role in recent advances in string/gauge duality. The method is based on arbitrary nearest-neighbour integrable spin chains and it sheds light on the moduli space of deformation parameters. We also derive the closed chain asymptotic Bethe equations. △ Less

Submitted 27 August, 2012; v1 submitted 31 July, 2008; originally announced July 2008.

Comments: 10 pages, v2: reference added, minor changes, v3: published version with added/updated references

Report number: AEI-2008-052

Journal ref: J.Stat.Mech.0811:L11001,2008

Open Perturbatively Long-Range Integrable gl(N) Spin Chains

Authors: N. Beisert, F. Loebbert

Abstract: We construct the most general perturbatively long-range integrable spin chain with spins transforming in the fundamental representation of gl(N) and open boundary conditions. In addition to the previously determined bulk moduli we find a new set of parameters determining the reflection phase shift. We also consider finite-size contributions and comment on their determination. We construct the most general perturbatively long-range integrable spin chain with spins transforming in the fundamental representation of gl(N) and open boundary conditions. In addition to the previously determined bulk moduli we find a new set of parameters determining the reflection phase shift. We also consider finite-size contributions and comment on their determination. △ Less

Submitted 21 May, 2008; originally announced May 2008.

Comments: 21 pages

Report number: AEI-2008-032

Journal ref: Adv.Sci.Lett.2:261-269,2009